Validation of a semi-automated human hepatocyte assay for the determination and prediction of intrinsic clearance in discovery

An automated high throughput human hepatocyte assay has been established with a 96-well format using a Tecan Genesistrade mark Workstation. Validation of this assay was performed with nine commercially available compounds and an additional 10 Pfizer compounds with varying hepatic extraction ratios (E(H)) ranging from 0.02 to approximately 1. The incubation conditions in the automated assay are readily and precisely controlled and cell viability of over 80% was achieved in the automated assay further confirming its utility for absorption, distribution, metabolism, and excretion (toxicity) (ADME (T)) screening. The results of the nine commercial compounds correlate with both manually executed (R(2)=0.97) and literature reported experimental results (R(2)=0.93). Overall, measured E(H)s were within two-fold of the literature values for approximately 90% of the 19 compounds tested. Additionally, good inter- and intra-day reproducibility was observed for all the 19 compounds. In conclusion, an automated and robust assay suitable for simultaneously testing up to 48 compounds with multiple time points has been validated. Throughput of 192 compounds per run can be achieved using 384-well plates to meet increasing needs in drug discovery. Currently, this automated assay is used to support early discovery profiling towards lead optimization of various discovery targets/programs.     

In vitro preclinical lead optimisation technologies (PLOTs) in pharmaceutical development

The explosion of genuine high throughput technologies has allowed large compound libraries to be screened with ever increasing biological specificity, exacerbating the problem of lead candidate selection for subsequent drug development. To avoid creating a bottleneck, compounds identified from the high throughput screens undergo lead optimisation, a medium-throughput screen which allows ranking in terms of their basic absorption, distribution, metabolism, excretion (ADME) and toxicological properties. The historical role of the preclinical scientist in the drug discovery/development continuum has been to perform ADME and toxicology studies, simply to support the regulatory submission of lead candidates. This situation is, however, changing with the development of preclinical lead optimisation technologies (Approaches to High Throughput Toxicity Screening, London, Atterwill et al., 1999) facilitating the selection of leading candidates, thereby bridging the gap between high throughput efficacy screens and traditional safety assessment programmes.     

HTS Technologies--IBC Informa Conference

In 1997, approximately US $6 billion were spent on worldwide screening technologies. The estimate for the total global market for high-throughput screening (HTS) products and services was about US $1.5 billion (source: Medical and Healthcare Marketplace Guide, 15th Edition, 1999-2000). Genomics and combinatorial chemistry demand a technological shift away from present-day laboratory to fully automated HTS and ultra HTS (uHTS), with over 100,000 compounds screened per day. The potential of new technology in miniaturization and automation will ensure faster and cheaper solutions to discovery. The conference explored the rapidly advancing field of HTS and examined numerous areas of HTS application. Identification and prioritization of viable targets, and the development of 'information rich' screens without reducing screening capacity, are important topics. Furthermore, the essential integration of all these screening, analytical and parallel synthesis systems in one coherent process is considered to be of significant interest. Focused sessions addressed the rapidly advancing areas of ADME (absorption, distribution, metabolism, elimination), toxicity and formulation screening, including virtual 'in silico' screening.     

Equilibrium drug solubility measurements in 96-well plates reveal similar drug solubilities in phosphate buffer pH 6.8 and human intestinal fluid

This study was conducted to develop a high throughput screening (HTS) method for the assessment of equilibrium solubility of drugs. Solid-state compounds were precipitated from methanol in 96-well plates, in order to eliminate the effect of co-solvent. Solubility of twenty model drugs was analyzed in water and aqueous solutions (pH 1.2 and 6.8) in 96-well plates and in shake-flasks (UV detection). The results obtained with the 96-well plate method correlated well (R(2)=0.93) between the shake-flask and 96-well plates over the wide concentration scale of 0.002-169.2mg/ml. Thereafter, the solubility tests in 96-well plates were performed using fasted state human intestinal fluid (HIF) from duodenum of healthy volunteers. The values of solubility were similar in phosphate buffer solution (pH 6.8) and HIF over the solubility range of 10(2)-10(5)μg/ml. The new 96-well plate method is useful for the screening of equilibrium drug solubility during the drug discovery process and it also allows the use of human intestinal fluid in solubility screening.     

Cellular HTS assays for pharmacological characterization of Na(V)1.7 modulators

Ion channels are challenging targets in the early phases of the drug discovery process, especially because of the lack of technologies available to screen large numbers of compounds in functionally relevant assays. The electrophysiological patch-clamp technique, which is the gold standard for studying ion channels, has low throughput and is not amenable to screening large numbers of compounds. However, for random high-throughput screening (HTS) of compounds against ion channel targets, a number of functional cellular assays have become available during the last few years. Here we use the sodium channel NaV1.7 stably expressed in human embryonic kidney 293 cells and compare three HTS assays-a Li flux atomic absorption spectroscopy (AAS) assay, a fluorescent imaging plate reader (FLIP, Molecular Devices, Sunnyvale, CA) membrane potential assay, and a fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET)-based membrane potential assay-to an automated electrophysiological assay (the Ionworks HT [Molecular Devices] platform) and characterize 11 known NaV inhibitors. Our results show that all three HTS assays are suitable for identification of NaV1.7 inhibitors, but as an HTS assay the Li-AAS assay is more robust with higher Z' values than the FLIPR and FRET-based membrane potential assays. Furthermore, there was a better correlation between the Ionworks assay and the Li-AAS assay regarding the potency of the NaV inhibitors investigated. This paper describes the first comparison between all the HTS assays available today to study voltage-gated NaVs, and the results suggest that the Li-AAS assay is more suited as a first HTS assay when starting an NaV drug discovery campaign.     

IBC's Drug Discovery Technology - Europe 2001. 23-26 April 2001, Stuttgart, Germany

Specific sectors within the pharmaceutical industry are rapidly changing in response to technological advances. Genomics, high-throughput automated chemistry, high-throughput screening (HTS), ADME/Tox screening and informatics, provide new opportunities, but also create new bottlenecks. In addition, the selection and validation of biological targets, the proper design of compound libraries, data and knowledge management, and as the last and crucial step, the proof of therapeutic relevance by clinical trials, generates an enormous financial load on biotechnology and pharmaceutical companies. In the future, drug development costs might be reduced due to an ongoing pressure for shorter development cycles of new drugs. IBC's Drug Discovery Technology Europe 2001 conference addressed many aspects relevant to drug discovery technologies, and, along with its US partner conference, provides an annual meeting place for researchers and company executives to interact and exchange ideas.     

Development of a high throughput equilibrium dialysis method

The identification of large numbers of biologically active chemical entities during high throughput screening (HTS) necessitates the incorporation of new strategies to identify compounds with drug-like properties early during the lead prioritization and development processes. One of the major steps in lead prioritization is an assessment of compound binding to plasma proteins, because it affects both the pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics of the compound in vivo. Equilibrium dialysis is the preferred method to determine the free drug fraction, because it is less susceptible to experimental artifacts. However, even low-volume standard equilibrium dialysis is currently not amenable to the HTS format. Those considerations dictate the development of a high throughput equilibrium dialysis device, without compromising the analytical quality of the data. The present paper demonstrates successful development of a 96-well format equilibrium dialysis plate. Plasma protein binding of three drugs, propranolol, paroxetine, and losartan, with low, intermediate, and high binding properties, respectively, were chosen for assay validation. The data indicate that the apparent free fraction obtained by this method correlates with the published values determined by the traditional equilibrium dialysis techniques.     

A novel HIV-1 antiviral high throughput screening approach for the discovery of HIV-1 inhibitors

Antiviral high throughput screens remain a viable option for identifying novel target inhibitors. However, few antiviral screens have been reduced to practice on an industrial scale. In this study, we describe an HIV-1 dual reporter assay that allows for the simultaneous evaluation of the potential antiviral activities and cytotoxicities of compounds in a high throughput screen (HTS) format. We validate the assay with known HIV-1 inhibitors and show that the antiviral and cytotoxic activities of compounds are reproducibly measured under screening conditions. In addition, we show that the assay exhibits parameters (e.g., signal-to-background ratios and Z' coefficients) suitable for high throughout screening. In a pilot screen, we demonstrate that non-specific or cytotoxic compounds represent a significant fraction of the hits identified in an antiviral screen and that these false positives are identified and deprioritized by the HIV-1 dual reporter assay at the primary screening step. We propose that the HIV-1 dual reporter assay represents a novel approach to HIV-1 antiviral screening that allows for the effective execution of industrial scale HTS campaigns with significantly greater returns on resource investment when compared to previous methods.     

High throughput drug screening for human immunodeficiency virus type 1 reactivating compounds

The ability of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) to persist in a latent stage in memory T cells in the presence of antiretroviral therapy poses a major obstacle to the development of an HIV-1 therapy with curative intent. As latently infected cells are phenotypically not distinguishable from uninfected cells, therapeutic reactivation of the latent infection, followed by the death of the host cell induced by viral cytopathicity, is considered the only means to eliminate this viral reservoir. To identify compounds with the potential to reactivate latent HIV-1, we have developed a series of latently HIV-1-infected reporter cell lines that allow for high throughput drug screening (HTS) in a 384-well plate-based format. The latent reporter cell lines use enhanced green fluorescence protein (eGFP) as a direct and quantitative marker of HIV-1 expression. To aid identification of specific compounds, the cells are engineered to constitutively express a second, red fluorescent protein that has no spectral overlap with eGFP, which allows for the simultaneous quantification of cell viability (inversely correlated to compound toxicity). Thus, these reporters enable prioritization of compounds most likely to have a favorable therapeutic window. The high dynamic signal range and the excellent reproducibility of the primary screening assay result in a Z' -factor of 0.89, which characterizes the HTS system as very robust. The assay has been implemented for automated drug screening, and we here discuss the advantages and limitations of the HTS system based on the data obtained for 1,600 compounds during a limited proof-of-concept drug screen.     

High throughput pharmacology for drug discovery

High Throughput Screening (HTS) now plays an important role in the discovery of new lead compounds for novel therapeutic targets. The advantage of HTS over the conventional method, now termed as Low Throughput Screening (LTS), is that valuable compounds can be selected rapidly from a large number of samples with minimal human involvement. In spite of the growing awareness of HTS, the importance of the LTS in the drug discovery and development is still not changed. Advances in pharmacogenomics will also provide us many pharmacological targets, and thus increase the number of compounds that should be assayed by HTS and LTS. In this review, we will first describe the outline of HTS. We will next describe new approaches to develop and brush up the LTS: 1) screening method of drugs acting on ion channels by voltage-sensitive fluorescent dye, 2) functional assay method using reconstituted smooth muscle fiber, and 3) organ culture method as a useful model of vascular proliferative disease. These approaches, which work cooperatively with HTS, will contribute greatly to the development of new drugs.     

以微管蛋白为靶的高通量药物筛选方法的建立与应用

目的：以微管蛋白为靶建立高通量筛选（HTS）模型，以便有效地发现抗肿瘤化合物。方法：细胞培养与免疫荧光技术。结果：以常规的免疫组化（玻片）方法为基础优化实验条件，在96孔板上建立了以微管蛋白为靶点的高通量药物筛选模型；抗肿瘤药物紫杉醇和秋水仙碱作用于人肝癌HepG2细胞后，细胞的免疫荧光强度发生了明显的可检测的变化，间接反映药物对细胞徽管蛋白聚合／解聚作用的影响，与理论预测结果一致。结论：基于人肿瘤细胞的以徽管蛋白为靶点的高通量筛选方法可用于抗肿瘤化合物的筛选。     

Automated Parallel Oocyte Electrophysiology Test station (POETs): a screening platform for identification of ligand-gated ion channel modulators

Ligand-gated ion channels (LGICs) play important roles in the regulation of cellular function and signaling and serve as excellent drug targets. However, fast desensitization of most LGICs limits the choice of reliable methods to identify agonists, antagonists, and/or modulators in a high throughput manner. In this study, automated Parallel Oocyte Electrophysiology Test station (POETs) was used to screen a directed compound library against a rapidly desensitizing LGIC and to characterize further the pharmacological properties of the hits. POETs allows up to six two-electrode voltage-clamp experiments to be performed in parallel by automatically loading of the oocytes into flowcells, assessing individual oocyte behavior prior to initiating experiments. Oocytes injected with cRNA were transferred from a chilled 96-well plate into flowcells by the instrument, where they were impaled under software control by two independent electrodes. Expression was tested by measuring current responses to rapid application of agonists. Compounds, prepared in a 96-well format, were tested for effects by coapplication with agonist at a single concentration of 30 microM over 2 s. After compound application, oocytes were washed for a minimum of 30 s, and used repeatedly if the test compounds had no significant effect on the control response. Typical throughput could reach approximately 14 plates/day depending on the protocol. Pilot library screening revealed a hit rate of 0.06%, with active compounds having IC(50) values of 4-40 microM. Hits were also confirmed in native neurons using patch-clamp techniques. We conclude that automated POETs serves as a suitable platform for screening and expedient identification of LGIC modulators.     

An optimized automated assay for determination of metabolic stability using hepatocytes: assay validation, variance component analysis, and in vivo relevance

Screening of new chemical entities for metabolic stability using hepatocytes is routinely used in drug discovery. To enhance compound throughput, an optimized automated microassay for determination of intrinsic clearance was developed. Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium, Hanks' balanced salt solution, and Leibovitz L-15 medium (L-15) were tested for their ability to maintain cell viability during incubation in 96-well plates. L-15 was found to keep pH within 0.1 units and maintain high viability during several hours of incubation. Moreover, two different thawing protocols for cryopreserved hepatocytes were compared. Protocol 2 resulted in a nearly 100% increase in post-thaw yield, whereas no difference was observed in cell viability. The microassay was validated using human cryopreserved hepatocytes and 19 reference compounds covering the most important phase I and II liver metabolizing enzymes ranging from low to medium and high clearance compounds. The day-to-day variation was determined, revealing an overall good precision of the assay. In vitro-in vivo correlations, for both fresh rat and cryopreserved human hepatocytes, were calculated. For 86% (human) and 77% (rat) of the compounds, calculated hepatic clearance was within twofold observed clearance in vivo. Using the validation data, variance component analysis was applied to determine within and between-experiment variability, enabling estimation of variation and detection limit for any combination of repeated experiments and replicate samples. Based on the precision desired, this provides a tool to select the most optimal and cost-effective assay approach for different compounds considering the actual phase in the drug discovery program.     

High throughput screening assay for UDP-glucuronosyltransferase 1A1 glucuronidation profiling

Development of high throughput screening (HTS) assays for evaluation of a compound's toxicity and potential for drug-drug interactions is a critical step towards production of better drug candidates and cost reduction in the drug development process. HTS assays for drug metabolism mediated by cytochrome P450s are now routinely used in compound library characterization and for computer modeling studies. However, development and application of HTS assays involving UDP-glucuronosyltransferases (UGTs) are lagging behind. Here we describe the development of a fluorescence-based HTS assay for UGT1A1 using recombinant enzyme and fluorescent substrate in the presence of an aqueous solution of PreserveX-QML (QBI Life Sciences, Madison, WI) polymeric micelles, acting as a stabilizer and a blocker of nonspecific interactions. The data include assay characteristics in 384-well plate format obtained with robotic liquid handling equipment and structures of hits (assay modifiers) obtained from the screening of a small molecule library at the University of Wisconsin HTS screening facility. The application of the assay for predicting UGT-related drug-drug interactions and building pharmacophore models, as well as the effects of polymeric micelles on the assay performance and compound promiscuity, is discussed.     

Application of NMR screening in drug discovery

The application of NMR screening in drug discovery has recently attained heightened importance throughout the pharmaceutical industry. NMR screening can be applied at various points in a drug discovery program, ranging from very early in the program, when new targets can be screened long before an HTS enzymatic assay is developed, to later in the program, as in the case where no useful hits have been detected by HTS using biological assays. The binders determined in primary NMR screens are used to guide secondary screens, which can be either completely NMR driven or use NMR in combination with other biophysical techniques. In this review we briefly discuss the methods and techniques used in NMR screening. Then, we describe in detail the NMR screening strategies and their applications to specific targets, including successful examples from actual drug design programs at our own and other pharmaceutical companies.     

A 1536-well cAMP assay for Gs- and Gi-coupled receptors using enzyme fragmentation complementation

Guanosine triphosphate binding protein (G protein)-coupled receptors (GPCRs) are a large class of pharmaceutical drug targets. With the increasing popularity of functional assays for high throughput screening, there arises an increasing need for robust second messenger assays that reflect GPCR activation and are readily amenable for miniaturization. GPCRs that upon agonist stimulation modulate adenylyl cyclase activity, and, consequently, cellular cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) levels, via the G protein Gs or Gi, form a subset of therapeutic targets. While there are several cAMP assays currently available, most are not scalable for miniaturization into the 1536-well format employed for automated high throughput screening of large chemical libraries. Here, we describe a cAMP assay based on the enzyme fragmentation complementation (EFC) of beta-galactosidase. In this assay, recombinant cells expressing Gs- or Gi-coupled receptors exhibit robust and reproducible pharmacology for agonists and antagonists, as measured by cAMP levels. Furthermore, the EFC cAMP assay offers sufficient sensitivity to be used with cells expressing endogenous GPCRs. We demonstrate the miniaturization of this assay into a 1536-well format with comparable sensitivity and plate statistics to those of the 384-well assay for both Gs- and Gi-coupled receptors, and its suitability for miniaturized high throughput screening.     

A one-day, dispense-only IP-One HTRF assay for high-throughput screening of Galphaq protein-coupled receptors: towards cells as reagents

Abstract: Compared to biochemical high-throughput screening (HTS) assays, cell-based functional assays are generally thought to be more time consuming and complex because of additional efforts for running continuous cell cultures as well as the numerous assay steps when transferring media and compounds. A common strategy to compensate the anticipated reduction in overall throughput is to implement highly automated cell culture and screening systems. However, such systems require substantial investments in sophisticated hardware and highly specialized personnel. In trying to set up alternatives to increasing throughput in functional cell-based screening, we combined several approaches. By using (1) cryopreserved cell aliquots instead of continuous cell culture, (2) cells in suspension instead of adherent cells, and (3) "ready-to-screen" assay plates with nanoliter aliquots of test compounds, an assay procedure was developed that very much resembles a standard biochemical, enzymatic assay comprising only a few dispense steps. Chinese hamster ovary cells stably overexpressing a Galphaq-coupled receptor were used as a model system to measure receptor activation by detection of intracellular D-myo-inositol 1-phosphate with the help of homogeneous time-resolved fluorescence (HTRF, CISbio International, Bagnols-sur-Cèze, France). Initially established in 384-well adherent cell format, the assay was successfully transferred to 1,536-well format. The assay quality was sufficient to run HTS campaigns in both formats with good Z'-factors and excellent reproducibility of antagonists. Subsequently, the assay procedure was optimized for usage of suspension cells. The influences of cell culture media, plate type, cell number, and incubation time were assessed. Finally, the suspension cell assay was applied to pharmacological characterization of a small molecule antagonist by Schild plot analysis. Our data demonstrate not only the application of the IP-One HTRF assay (CISbio International) for HTS in a high-density format, but furthermore the successful use of cryopreserved and suspension cells in a one-day functional cell-based assay.     

Advances in computationally modeling human oral bioavailability

Although significant progress has been made in experimental high throughput screening (HTS) of ADME (absorption, distribution, metabolism, excretion) and pharmacokinetic properties, the ADME and Toxicity (ADME–Tox) in silico modeling is still indispensable in drug discovery as it can guide us to wisely select drug candidates prior to expensive ADME screenings and clinical trials. Compared to other ADME–Tox properties, human oral bioavailability (HOBA) is particularly important but extremely difficult to predict. In this paper, the advances in human oral bioavailability modeling will be reviewed. Moreover, our deep insight on how to construct more accurate and reliable HOBA QSAR and classification models will also discussed.     

Configuration of a scintillation proximity assay for the activity assessment of recombinant human adenine phosphoribosyltransferase

Adenine phosphoribosyltransferase plays a role in purine salvage by catalyzing the direct conversion of adenine to adenosine monophosphate. The involvement of the purine salvage pathway in tumor proliferation and angiogenesis makes adenine phosphoribosyltransferase a potential target for oncology drug discovery. We have expressed and characterized recombinant, N-terminally His-tagged human adenine phosphoribosyltransferase. Two assay formats were assessed for use in a high throughput screen: a spectrophotometric-based enzyme-coupled assay system and a radiometric ionic capture scintillation proximity bead assay format. Ultimately, the scintillation proximity assay format was chosen because of automated screening compatibility limitations of the coupled assay. We describe here the biochemical characterization of adenine phosphoribosyltransferase and the development of a robust, homogeneous, 384-well assay suitable for high throughput screening.     

Drug-like properties and the causes of poor solubility and poor permeability

There are currently about 10000 drug-like compounds. These are sparsely, rather than uniformly, distributed through chemistry space. True diversity does not exist in experimental combinatorial chemistry screening libraries. Absorption, distribution, metabolism, and excretion (ADME) and chemical reactivity-related toxicity is low, while biological receptor activity is higher dimensional in chemistry space, and this is partly explainable by evolutionary pressures on ADME to deal with endobiotics and exobiotics. ADME is hard to predict for large data sets because current ADME experimental screens are multi-mechanisms, and predictions get worse as more data accumulates. Currently, screening for biological receptor activity precedes or is concurrent with screening for properties related to "drugability." In the future, "drugability" screening may precede biological receptor activity screening. The level of permeability or solubility needed for oral absorption is related to potency. The relative importance of poor solubility and poor permeability towards the problem of poor oral absorption depends on the research approach used for lead generation. A "rational drug design" approach as exemplified by Merck advanced clinical candidates leads to time-dependent higher molecular weight, higher H-bonding properties, unchanged lipophilicity, and, hence, poorer permeability. A high throughput screening (HTS)-based approach as exemplified by unpublished data on Pfizer (Groton, CT) early candidates leads to higher molecular weight, unchanged H-bonding properties, higher lipophilicity, and, hence, poorer aqueous solubility.