Personal influencing factors associated with pap smear testing and cervical cancer

Pap smear is a screening test that detects abnormal cells before they advance to cancer. Unfortunately, not all women obtain routine screening. The method used was a qualitative study exploring personal influences regarding Pap smears. Face-to-face interviews with 7 low-income African American women who do and do not obtain Pap smears (between 21 and 37 years of age) were conducted at a health department about their social influence, previous health care experience, and cognitive appraisal regarding Pap smears and cervical cancer. Women were found to be socially influenced by their family and their physician. Previous health care experience with the Pap and pelvic was perceived as negative. Cognitively, Pap smears were believed to test for sexually transmitted diseases, including HIV, and the women also felt that if one took good care of oneself it reduced the risk for cervical cancer. It was concluded that exploring beliefs associated with Pap smears and perceptions of vulnerability to cervical cancer and giving correct information and counseling may increase Pap smear screening in women.     

Cervical cancer screening knowledge and practices among Korean-American women.

Cervical cancer is one of the most common cancers of American women. The Papanicolaou (Pap) smear test for cervical screening is a widely used and effective means to reduce the morbidity and mortality rate from cervical cancer through early detection. Despite these benefits, many women have never been screened or are not screened at regular intervals. The purpose of this study was to examine cervical cancer screening knowledge and practices of Korean-American women. The sample consisted of 159 Korean-American women, 40 to 69 years of age. The 1987 Cancer Control Supplement questionnaire was translated into Korean and used to collect data. Twenty-six percent of the respondents never heard of the Pap smear test. Only 34% of respondents reported having had a Pap smear test for screening. The most frequently cited reason for not having had a Pap smear test was absence of disease symptoms. Results indicate that education and usual sources of health care were significant factors related to having heard of or having had a Pap smear test. The findings from this study have important implications for health practitioners and policy makers who serve this ethnic population.     

Screening for cervical cancer among Israeli lesbian women

Background:  The proportion of lesbian women who contract the human papilloma virus may reach 13% or even 21%; however, lesbian women were found to receive Pap smear tests less often or less regularly.
Aim:  To explore factors influencing lesbian women to undergo Pap smear tests and to determine whether the Health Belief Model (HBM) is able to predict whether lesbian women would be willing to undergo the test.
Method:  This is a correlational quantitative study guided by the HBM. A convenience sample of 108 Israeli lesbian women was recruited from local events in the lesbian community in the city of Tel Aviv, Israel. Data were collected using a self-administered questionnaire.
Findings:  Findings indicate that only 22.2% of the women had undergone Pap smear tests in the past, but a slightly higher proportion, 30.8%, intended to be tested during the next year. Older women were found to be more compliant with the test. Model-based factors affecting actual testing were perceived benefits and barriers. Factors affecting women's intention to be tested were perceived susceptibility, perceived benefits and general health motivation.
Conclusions:  Effective strategies for nurses promoting cervical cancer screening among lesbians should address ways to improve familiarity with Pap smear tests, raise physicians' awareness of offering the test to lesbians and emphasize the importance of women-based medical teams.     

Primary care cancer and diabetes complications screening of black women with type 2 diabetes

PURPOSE: To determine the frequency with which Black women with type 2 diabetes receive routine primary health care screening for cancer and diabetes complications. DATA SOURCES: Pilot study data from a convenience sample of 21 Black women (mean age 46.8 years) with type 2 diabetes. CONCLUSIONS: Cancer screening consisted of Pap smear, mammography, and colon cancer screening consistent with current American Cancer Society recommendations. Ninety percent reported having had a Pap smear, 86% mammogram and 33% colon cancer screening. Diabetes complications screening was based on the American Diabetes Association care recommendations. Fifty-five percent received screening eye exams, 40% were screened for renal proteinuria, and 50% received foot examinations and diabetes foot care instruction. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: This sample of mid-life, Black, educated, working women with type 2 diabetes utilize healthcare services and have high rates of primary care cancer screening. Rates of diabetes complications screening are less than optimal. Because Black American women suffer disproportionately high rates of diabetes and related complications, it is imperative that they receive quality diabetes care in an effort to improve health outcomes and decrease premature mortality.     

A case study of the effectiveness of nurse-led screening programmes for cervical cancer among Hong Kong Chinese women

Cervical cancer remains a cause of morbidity and mortality among women despite the efficacy of Pap smear screening. Uptake rates for Papanicolaou (Pap) smears among Hong Kong Chinese women remain low and evidence suggests that both intrinsic and extrinsic factors influence women's attendance for Pap smear screening, particularly the practitioner taking the smear. This study examined the experiences and perceptions of Hong Kong Chinese women of having a Pap smear taken by a female doctor or a female nurse using a case study design. A convenience sample of 50 women was selected from the two case study settings. Data collection involved a confidential structured interview, followed by focus group interviews with a sample of women participating in the structured interview. The findings relating to the technical quality and outcome of care provide the focus for this paper. Although women were highly satisfied with the care provided by both practitioners, women were more satisfied with the information given about the procedure by the nurse (P = 0.0130) and had more confidence in the nurse (P = 0.024). One of the five criteria used to assess the quality of smears demonstrated the doctor achieved a statistically significant higher number of smears containing the required percentage of endocervical cells (P = 0. 0180). Nevertheless, none of the smears taken by the nurse required repeating due to an inadequate specimen. These findings suggest, despite the need for audit of Pap smears, that appropriately qualified nurses can make an important contribution to the uptake of Pap smears among this population.     

Preventive health pamphlets in the emergency department

We conducted a prospective clinical trial to determine the effectiveness of an emergency department informational pamphlet in improving patients’ compliance with recommendations that they receive Pap smears, mammograms, and a pneumococcal vaccination. Informational pamphlets were distributed to 1,000 consecutive patients who presented to a university-affiliated emergency department (ED). The pamphlet contained information stating the indications for obtaining routine Pap smears, mammograms, and a pneumococcal vaccination. Target individuals were women 18 years and older and men 65 years and older. Target patients were called approximately 2 months after their ED visits to obtain follow-up data. There were 464 target patients obtained from the 1,000 pamphlets distributed (409 female/55 male), and 68% (316) of the 464 were contacted by telephone for follow-up data. Significantly more women than men had read the pamphlet (62% vs. 8%). Of the women contacted (279), 31.9% (89) were not up to date (UTD) with Pap smears, and 11.2% (10) stated that they had scheduled an appointment for a Pap smear; 14.5% (11) of the women were not UTD with mammograms, and none had scheduled an appointment to receive care. Of the patients over age 65, 67% were not UTD with a pneumococcal vaccination, and no appointments were scheduled to obtain one. We conclude that a significant number of patients who present to this ED are in need of preventive health care. Emergency department informational pamphlets may have a role in improving Pap smear compliance. Women may be more likely then men to read informational pamphlets distributed in the ED.     

Assessing physicians' compliance with guidelines for Papanicolaou testing.

In this study, population-based data were used to examine the appropriateness of Papanicolaou (Pap) testing from the perspective of the women being tested and their physicians. The approach used is unique in its assessment of overtesting and undertesting in the primary care setting. From the data base of the province of Manitoba's universal health insurance plan, 4-year health histories (1981 to 1984) were constructed for each woman from a random sample of the population of women who, in 1982, were between the ages of 25 to 64 years (n = 22,287). At the last visit to a general practitioner, gynecologist, or general surgeon in 1984 (termed the current visit), the authors determined whether a Pap test was given for each woman. Using decision rules from a Canadian task force report on cervical screening and previous health history, the authors evaluated the appropriateness of screening by determining whether a Pap test was given and was needed, or whether a women who had not received a Pap test required one. Overall, 55.7% of women were tested appropriately. Of the 5352 women who received a Pap test at the current visit, 62.8% were overtested. Of the 16,935 women not tested at the current visit, 38.5% required screening (i.e. were undertested). Characteristics of a physician's practice that were significantly related to compliance with the guidelines included having a high proportion of patients visiting for obstetric or gynecologic reasons. Variables that were associated with negative compliance were 1) being a gynecologist; and 2) having a high proportion of patients who lived in inner city or rural areas. Because physicians are paid a fee for every Pap smear taken and the guidelines were well disseminated, these results should be reasonably representative of fee-for-service practice in North America, where preventive care is not subject to user charges. This study supports previous findings that a passive approach to dissemination of guidelines is insufficient to effect practice.     

Changes in public health nurses' knowledge and perception of counseling and clinical skills for breast and cervical cancer control

This study discusses the findings from two surveys of 459 nurses working in public health about their knowledge and perception of counseling and clinical skills related to breast and cervical cancer control. The first survey was conducted in 1993 before professional education efforts with the Breast and Cervical Cancer Control Program (BCCCP) began in North Carolina. The second survey was carried out in 1996. The results show a significant increase from 1993 to 1996 in recognition of increasing age, nulliparity, late childbearing, and family history as risk factors for breast cancer, and for smoking and early age at first sexual intercourse as risk factors for cervical cancer. Nurses' skills were more likely to be rated as excellent or very good in 1996 as compared with ratings in 1993 for educating women about mammography, performing a clinical breast examination, teaching breast self-examination by demonstration, performing a Papanicolaou (Pap) smear and bimanual examination, and counseling women about abnormal Pap tests. Nurses who took a BCCCP-sponsored adult physical assessment course were more likely to know correct risk factors for breast and cervical cancer, and to show improvement in teaching breast self-examination, performing a Pap smear, and counseling women about abnormal Pap tests.     

Enhancing cervical cancer detection using nucleic acid hybridization and acetic acid tests

Acetowhitening of abnormal cervical epithelium has been suggested as an indicator of increased cervical cancer risk. The presence of human papillomavirus (HPV) types 16, 18, 31, 33 and 35 may also indicate increased cervical cancer risk. Hence, tests that detect these two abnormal conditions may augment that Papanicolaou smear (Pap test) as predictors of cervical cancer risk. The cohort consisted of 145 women aged 14 to 47 (mean 21 years) attending health clinics. Thirty women (20.6 percent) showed acetowhitening of the cervical epithelium following exposure to vinegar of 4-percent acetic acid content. Fourteen (9.6 percent) had a positive Pap test and 13 (9 percent) carried a cervical HPV infection as determined by the commercially available ViraPap and ViraType nucleic acid tests. Statistical analysis of the data showed a positive correlation between Pap, ViraPap and acetic acid tests results. The acetic acid test and the nucleic acid tests were the sole positive tests for 21 (14.5 percent) and nine (6.2 percent) women, respectively. Four women with negative Pap results were infected with HPV types previously shown to have an association with cervical intraepithelial neoplasias, carcinoma in situ and cervical cancer. The authors have concluded that the acetic acid and nucleic acid tests detect women at risk for cervical cancer who would not have been detected by the Pap test alone.     

Understanding cervical cytology

Nurse practitioners and nurse midwives perform Pap smears routinely as a part of well-woman health care. However, the clinician may not understand the terminology used to express the results of the test or the rationale for strict adherence to correct technique. Information on basic histology and cytology is presented with the goal of helping the clinician understand what the cytologist is looking for and what the results from a Pap smear mean. Two sets of nomenclature for results are presented. Risk factors for development of cancerous and precancerous conditions of the cervix and the controversy regarding frequency of Pap smear sampling are discussed, as are guidelines for treatment and referral of women with class II Pap smears.     

A project to improve the screening rate of pap smear for cervical cancer

The incidence of cervical cancer in Taiwan is high and ranks as the seventh highest in the world. However, only 28.4% of the women in Kaohsiung underwent Pap smear screening. Ironically, the screening rate for female patients in our hospital was even lower at 13.2%. As medical staff in a public, community hospital, we have the responsibility to promote the health of our residents. The aim of this project was to increase the Pap smear screening rate to 28.0% in our community. The prior data analysis revealed that the low rate of Pap smear screening was related to inadequate information about the Pap smear, poor health knowledge among the women in this community, long processing time (50.86 +/- 5.88 minutes), inconvenient accessibility, and the lack of good explanation from our medical staff. The situation has significantly improved after we made adjustments including: providing an education program for women in our community, reduction of processing time, and convenient home services. The Pap smear screening rate increased from 13.2% to 28.4. The entire processing time was reduced to 20.48 +/- 2.28 minutes. We encourage women of all ages to take Pap smear tests regularly, which would be helpful for the prevention of cervical cancer.     

Knowledge and beliefs related to cervical cancer and screening among Korean American women

The purpose of this article is to examine knowledge and health beliefs associated with cervical cancer screening among Korean American women. A telephone survey was conducted with 189 Korean American women in the Chicago area. Age, marital status, income, knowledge of early detection method for cervical cancer, and perceived beliefs about benefits of and barriers to receiving Pap tests were all related to outcomes of ever having a Pap test and having had one in the preceding 3 years. Variables uniquely related to ever having a Pap test were education, employment status, fluency in English, and proportion of life spent in the United States. Variables uniquely related to having had the test during the preceding 3 years were having a usual source of care and regular checkups. Different intervention components are suggested for the groups of Korean American women who have never had a Pap smear and for those who have not had one in the preceding 3 years, in addition to common intervention strategies that aim to increase knowledge and perceived benefit and to decrease perceived barriers to receiving Pap tests.     

The roles of citizenship status, acculturation, and health insurance in breast and cervical cancer screening among immigrant women

BACKGROUND: Immigrant women are less likely to undergo cancer screening. However, few national studies have examined the role of citizenship status or acculturation. OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to examine differences in Papanicolaou (Pap) smear and mammography screening among U.S.-born women and immigrants who are naturalized citizens or remained noncitizens. Among Latinas, we also determined if acculturation is related to screening after adjusting for covariates. RESEARCH DESIGN: The authors conducted a cross-sectional analysis of the Adult Section of the 2000 National Health Interview Survey, a nationally representative sample. SUBJECTS: A total of 18,342 women completed the survey, including 1445 who were not citizens. MEASURES: For Pap smears, women age 18-65 were appropriately screened if they reported testing within the past 3 years. For mammograms, women age 50-70 were considered appropriately screened if they reported testing within the past 2 years. We determined acculturation using a modified version of the Marin scale. RESULTS: After adjusting for age, education, family income, and marital status, noncitizens remained significantly less likely to report having a mammogram than U.S.-born women (14 percentage point difference; P < 0.01). However, after adjusting for health insurance coverage and a usual source of care, these disparities were markedly attenuated. For Pap smears, after adjusting for sociodemographics and access to care, disparities persisted (11 percentage points, P < 0.01). Among Latinas, differences in Pap smears between noncitizens and the U.S.-born disappeared after further controlling for acculturation. CONCLUSIONS: Our study suggests that initiatives to diminish disparities in screening should prioritize improving access to care for noncitizens. Our study also lends support to culturally sensitive interventions aimed at improving Pap smear screening among noncitizens.     

Breast and cervical cancer screening among Korean American elderly women

The purpose of this study was to estimate the prevalence and correlates of breast and cervical cancer screening tests among Korean American elderly women. This study examined the effects of individual socio-demographic background, acculturation level (e.g., proportion of life spent in the US, spoken English proficiency), health status and access to health care on uptake of mammography and Pap smear tests in the past 2 years. Subjects were 130 Korean American women aged 60 and older living in the Greater Metropolitan Baltimore Area. A cross-sectional face-to-face interview was conducted. The 2-year prevalence was only 35% for mammography and 29% for Pap smear tests. In multiple logistic regression analysis, educational attainment, government support, multiple chronic conditions, and routine checkups were associated with having mammography. Age, acculturation and insurance were associated with having a Pap test. Taking advantage of the positive influence of identified covariates may increase the effectiveness of cancer control interventions among Korean American elderly women.     

The epidemiology, clinical manifestations and health-maintenance needs of women infected with HIV.

The growing epidemic of HIV infection poses a serious threat to women's health in the United States and abroad. In the United States, HIV disproportionately affects African-American and Hispanic-American woman. Primary care providers will be faced with an increasing need to provide counseling and clinical services to these women. It is not yet clear whether gender affects the natural history of HIV infection; differences in survival rates may reflect lack of access to care rather than true biologic differences. Opportunistic infections among women with HIV infection are similar to those found among men with AIDS who use injection drugs. Unique expressions of HIV disease associated with women's reproductive tracts include persistent vaginal candidiasis, human papillomavirus infections and cervical dysplasia. Women with HIV infection should receive thorough gynecologic screening, including Pap smears, every six months. Women who know they are HIV positive may choose to become pregnant; these clients require extensive prenatal care and state-of-the-art HIV management.     

Does diabetes care compete with the provision of women's preventive care services?

OBJECTIVE: Care for chronic diseases may compete with preventive health care. To test this hypothesis, we examined the association between diabetes-related processes of care and preventive care in women. RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS: Using data from a prospective cohort study of diabetes care in managed care settings, we reviewed the care 540 diabetic women received from 355 primary care providers within 14 provider groups from one health plan. Of the 540 women, 278 were eligible to receive mammograms and 314 were eligible to receive Pap smears. Mammography performance was measured as at least one mammogram over a 2-year period and Pap performance was measured as at least one Pap smear over a 3-year period. To assess the association between diabetes-related processes of care and preventive services, we used hierarchical logistic regression models, accounted for clustering within provider groups, and adjusted for patient age, race, income and education level, diabetes treatment and duration, and health status, as well as physician age, sex, years of practice, and specialty. Diabetes-related processes of care were defined as dilated retinal examinations, urine microalbumin/protein testing, foot examinations, lipid and HbA(1c) testing, recommendations to take aspirin, and influenza vaccinations received over a 1-year period. RESULTS: In this cohort, 73% of eligible women received mammograms and 56% received Pap smears. After adjustment of models, better diabetes-related processes of care, better health status, and non-Medicaid insurance were associated with mammography performance. Better diabetes-related processes of care, younger patient age, and any visit to a gynecologist were associated with Pap performance. CONCLUSIONS: Better processes of diabetes care were associated with better women's preventive health care. Diabetes management did not compete with sex-specific screening.     

PS1-25: Cervical Cancer Testing and Follow-up in Four Managed Care Plans, 1998-2007

Background/Aims Cervical cancer screening is performed to detect pre-cancerous cervical intraepithelial neoplasia or invasive cancerous cervical lesions prior to the onset of symptoms so they can be removed before the cancer has developed or spread. With the addition of high-risk human papillomavirus (HPV) testing to the long-established Papanicolaou (Pap) smear, national and health plan screening guidelines have been regularly updated in recent years. Guidelines on screening frequency and follow-up protocols have also changed over time and will likely continue to do so as HPV vaccination becomes more widespread. Here we describe patterns and results of cervical cancer testing and follow-up over a 10-year period within four geographically-dispersed U.S. managed care organizations. Methods Using data collected by the SEARCH: Screening Effectiveness And Research in Community-Based Healthcare project, we analyzed electronic medical record data on all women aged 20-65 during the period 1998-2007 across four HMORN sites. We created standardized files for Pap smear dates and results; cervical histology dates, types, and results; and HPV test dates and results. We also collected Virtual Data Warehouse data on HPV vaccinations, and selected diagnosis and procedure codes. We calculated rates of Pap testing, HPV testing, colposcopy, and cervical histology (biopsy and treatment). We also calculated rates for Pap testing we classified as "screening." Among women who had Pap tests in 2002 and 2007 and no abnormal test directly preceding the index test, we examined patterns of screening frequency. We also examined frequencies and trends in the results of "screening" Pap testing and cervical histology. Results Overall, annual Pap testing rates decreased and HPV testing rates dramatically increased over the 10 years, while rates of colposcopy, cervical histology, and cervical treatment did not display obvious patterns. Trends varied by age group and health plan. Pap screening frequency differed by health plan; overall, in 2007 a higher proportion of subjects had longer screening intervals (2 years or greater) than in 2002. Information on patterns of Pap and histology results will be presented. Discussion Evaluating trends in cervical cancer testing and follow-up may highlight opportunities to optimize cervical cancer screening delivery in community-based settings.