Long-term follow-up study of radioiodine treatment of hyperthyroidism

OBJECTIVE: To determine the cumulative incidence of hypothyroidism during long-term follow-up in patients treated for hyperthyroidism by radioactive iodine (131)I (RAI) therapy, the significance of clinical factors in predicting the development of hypothyroidism, and the outcome after a fixed 7 mCi (259 MBq) dose of RAI. DESIGN: Prospective cohort study of patients treated for hyperthyroidism by RAI. PATIENTS AND MEASUREMENTS: Since 1965, details on 2043 patients treated by RAI therapy in Tampere University Hospital were entered into a computerized register. Following RAI treatment, thyroid status was monitored every 1-3 months during the first year, and subsequently at 1-3-year intervals until June 2002 or until the patient died or moved out of the Tampere University Hospital district. results The cumulative incidence of hypothyroidism in patients with Graves' disease and toxic multinodular goitre at 1, 10 and 25 years was 24%vs. 4%, 59%vs. 15% and 82%vs. 32%, respectively. In a Cox regression model, previous partial thyroidectomy [risk ratio (RR) = 1.63 in patients with Graves' disease and RR = 1.59 in those with toxic multinodular goitre] and age at the first RAI treatment (RR = 0.998 and RR = 0.996 per year) were statistically significantly associated with the development of hypothyroidism both in patients with Graves' disease and in those with toxic multinodular goitre. Antithyroid medication preceding RAI therapy (RR = 0.47) decreased and female gender (RR = 1.53) increased the risk of hypothyroidism only in patients with Graves' disease. Administration of a single dose of RAI resulted in the control of hyperthyroidism in 75% of patients, while two to six RAI treatments were needed in 25% of patients to achieve either a hypothyroid or a euthyroid state in both groups. None of the clinical factors studied was associated with the remission rate either in patients with Graves' disease or in those with toxic multinodular goitre. The remission rate did not differ between the patients who received a dose of RAI calculated according to the uptake of RAI and thyroid size and those who received an empirical dose of RAI. The fixed 7 mCi (259 MBq) dose of RAI cured 80% of patients. CONCLUSION: RAI treatment is effective in treating hyperthyroidism in patients with Graves' disease, but hypothyroidism will develop in 82% of patients in 25 years. Because the development of hypothyroidism seems to be inevitable and unpredictable by any clinical factors, the objective of RAI treatment should be to minimize the persistence of hyperthyroidism with the simplest possible form of treatment. We recommend a fixed 7 mCi dose of RAI to be used as the first empirical dose in the treatment of hyperthyroidism, at least in Graves' disease.     

High dose of (131)I therapy for the treatment of hyperthyroidism caused by Graves' disease

Radioactive iodine ((131)I) has become the most widely used therapy for patients with hyperthyroidism caused by Graves' disease in the United States. There remains, however, significant variability among (131)I dosing regimens, and it is clear that most patients ultimately develop hypothyroidism after therapy. To avoid persistent hyperthyroidism, we adopted a high dose (131)I therapy protocol based on measurement of 24-h thyroid (123)I uptake designed to deliver 8 mCi (296 MBq) to the thyroid gland 24 h after (131)I administration. To evaluate the efficacy of this protocol, we reviewed our clinical experience over a 7-yr period. We treated 261 patients (219 women and 42 men) with hyperthyroidism caused by Graves' disease with (131)I [mean dose, 14.6 mCi (540 MBq)] between 1993 and 1999. Before treatment, 207 (79%) had received an antithyroid drug (109 propylthiouracil and 98 methimazole). We determined their thyroid status 1 yr after treatment in relation to age, pretreatment with an antithyroid drug, pretreatment thyroid size, and dose of (131)I retained in the thyroid 24 h after treatment. Among the 261 patients, 225 (86%) were euthyroid or hypothyroid 1 yr after treatment, and 36 patients (14%) had persistent hyperthyroidism and required a second treatment. The patients who had persistent hyperthyroidism were younger (P < 0.01), had larger thyroid glands (P < 0.01), higher pretreatment thyroid (123)I uptake values (P < 0.01), and higher serum T(4) concentrations (P < 0.01) and were more likely to have taken antithyroid medication before administration of (131)I (P = 0.01). Five of these patients developed transient hypothyroidism, followed by thyrotoxicosis. There was an asymptotic, inverse relationship between the retained dose of (131)I at 24 h and persistent hyperthyroidism, revealing a 5-10% failure rate despite delivery of up to 400 microCi (14.8 MBq)/g. A dose of (131)I that results in accumulation of 8 mCi (296 MBq) in the thyroid gland 24 h after administration is an effective treatment for the majority of patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism. Young patients with larger thyroid glands, higher serum T(4) concentrations, and higher 24-h thyroid (123)I uptake values, and those pretreated with antithyroid medication for greater than 4 months are at higher risk for treatment failure. A higher dose of (131)I may be advisable in such patients.     

Prediction of cure and risk of hypothyroidism in patients receiving 131I for hyperthyroidism

Context There is little consensus regarding the most appropriate dose of radioiodine (¹³¹I) to be administered to patients with hyperthyroidism. Objective To compare the efficacy of fixed dose regimens of ¹³¹I in curing hyperthyroidism and to define simple clinical and biochemical factors that predict outcome in individual patients. Design Consecutive series of hyperthyroid subjects treated with ¹³¹I. Setting Single Secondary/Tertiary Care Hospital Clinic. Participants A total of 1278 patients (1013 females and 262 males, mean age 49·7 years) presenting with hyperthyroidism between 1984 and 2006. Intervention Treatment with ¹³¹I using a fixed dose regimen. Main outcome measures Probability of cure and risk of development of hypothyroidism following a single dose of ¹³¹I. Results Patients given a single dose of ¹³¹I of 600 MBq (n = 485) had a higher cure rate (84·1%) compared with those receiving either 370 MBq (74·9%, P < 0·001) or those given 185 Bq (63%, P < 0·001). An increased incidence of hypothyroidism by 1 year was evident with higher doses (600 MBq: 60·4%; 370 MBq: 49·2%, P = 0·001; 185 Bq: 38·1%, P < 0·001). Binary logistic regression analysis identified a 600 Bq dose of ¹³¹I [adjusted odds ratio, AOR 3·33 (2·28–4·85), P < 0·001], female gender [AOR 1·75 (1·23–2·47), P = 0·002], lower presenting serum free T4 concentration [AOR 1·01 (1·01–1·02), P < 0·001] and absence of a palpable goitre [AOR 3·33 (2·00–5·56), P < 0·001] to be independent predictors of cure. Similarly, a 600 MBq dose [AOR 3·79 (2·66–5·38), P < 0·001], female gender [AOR 1·46 (1·05–2·02), P = 0·02], younger age [AOR 1·03 (1·02–1·04), P < 0·001], absence of a palpable goitre [AOR 3·85 (2·38–5·88), P < 0·001] and presence of ophthalmopathy [AOR 1·57 (1·06–2·31), P = 0·02] were identified as independent factors predicting the probability of development of hypothyroidism at one year. Based on these findings, formulae to indicate probability of cure and risk of hypothyroidism for application to individual patients were derived. Conclusions Simple clinical/biochemical criteria can be used to predict outcome after ¹³¹I treatment. These factors determine that males, those with severe biochemical hyperthyroidism, and those with a palpable goitre require larger doses (600 MBq) in order to achieve cure.     

Standardized radioiodine therapy in Graves' disease: the persistent effect of thyroid weight and radioiodine uptake on outcome

Abstract. Objective. To assess the incidence of hypothyroidism, euthyroidism, and recurrent hyperthyroidism following a standard dose of Na¹³¹I (3.7 MBq or 100 μCi) per g thyroid tissue, adjusted for radioiodine tracer uptake. Design. A single-centre prospective follow-up study from January 1990 to December 1992. Setting. Academic Hospital in Utrecht, the Netherlands. Subjects. Newly diagnosed patients with Graves' disease (n = 148). Interventions. Radioiodine treatment at a standard dose of 3.7 MBq or 100 μCi per g thyroid tissue. Main outcome measures. Confidence interval testing of resulting thyroid status, defined by biochemical criteria. Results. The overall cure rate was 70% (103 of 148 subjects), confidence interval (CI) 62–77%. A 90% incidence of hypothyroidism was found in patients with a small thyroid (less than 20 g). Recurrent hyperthyroidism was found significantly more often in subjects with a thyroid weight exceeding 60 g compared to those who had a thyroid of 9–59 g. More recurrences were found in subjects in the highest tertile of a 24-h radioiodine uptake test (> 80% uptake) compared to those in the lowest tertile (< 60% uptake). Conclusions. No uniform treatment results expressed per thyroid weight category were obtained, in spite of standardizing the treatment Na¹³¹I dose (3.7 MBq per g thyroid). Graves' patients with a thyroid smaller than 20 g and those with less than 60% 24-h radioiodine uptake have a 50–90% chance of hypothyroidism at the 12-month follow-up.     

125I therapy in Graves' disease. Long-term results in 355 patients.

Because of the physical and radiobiologic differences between 125I and 131I, a trial using 125I to treat hyperthyroidism was undertaken in the hope of controlling hyperthyroidism without causing subsequent hypothyroidism. Three hundred fifty-five patients with diffuse toxic goitres were treated and have been under review for an average of 49.4 months: 63.4% are euthyroid, 33.5% are hypothyroid, and 3.1% remain hyperthyroid. Different groups of patients received a wide range of doses of 125I (4.0 to 56.0 mCi), and the lowest incidence of hypothyroidism (23%) was in the group that received between 6.0 and 10.5 mCi. Sixty-three percent of the patients whose initial dose was greater than 20.0 mCi are hypothyroid. Persistent hyperthyroidism was common in patients who received small doses. Because of the high incidence of posttreatment hypothyroidism in this series and because 131I has stood the test of time, we believe that 131I is the radionuclide of choice for the routine treatment of hyperthyroidism.     

The efficacy of long term thyrostatic treatment in elderly patients with toxic nodular goitre compared to radioiodine therapy with different doses.

The objective of the study was to investigate the efficacy of long term thyrostatic versus radioiodine treatment of hyperthyroidism in old age. Our study is a retrospective analysis of the therapeutical outcome in 66 patients over 60 years of age with toxic nodular goitre. The patients were divided in two groups: Group A: 28 patients on methimazole treatment: starting dose 5-30, median (M) 10 mg, maintenance dose 2.5-15 (M = 5) mg, follow up 6 to 240 months (M = 23.5 months). Group B: 38 patients treated by either 100-300 MBq (N = 14, subgroup B1) or 325-1000 MBq (N = 24, subgroup B2) 131I, follow up: 18 to 156 months (M = 48 months). The efficacy of the different therapeutical approaches were compared by calculating the occurrence rate of persisting and relapsing thyroid dysfunctions and associated side effects. The 28 patients on methimazole treatment became euthyroid after 1-16 (M = 5) months but numerous relapses occurred in the follow up: hyperthyroidism, clinical: 5, subclinical 13, (relapse duration: M = 8 months; associated symptoms: hypertension in 4, cardiac arrhythmia in 3, cerebral embolism in 1, angina pectoris in 2, weight loss in 2 cases). Poor patient's compliance (9/28) or dose reduction by the physician (5/28) were the main causes of the relapses. Transient clinical (3 cases) or subclinical (6 cases) hypothyroidism also occurred (duration: 1-3 M = 2 months, no clinical symptoms). In 7 out of 14 (50%) patients receiving 100-300 MBq 131I (Group B1) hyperthyroidism persisted (versus 4/24 -16.7%- in Group B2 following 325-1000 MBq 131I; chi2(1) = 4.78 P = 0.028), methimazole treatment had to be continued in 9/14 patients (64.3%) (versus 5/24 -20.8%)- in Group B2., chi2(1) = 7.18 P = 0.0074) and in 5/14 (35.7%) the radiotherapy had to be repeated (versus 5/24 -020.8%- in Group B2, not sign.). Our conclusions are: 1) long term thyrostatic treatment is not safe in elderly patients with toxic nodular hyperthyroidism, mainly because of poor compliance or dose reduction by the physician; 2) radioiodine treatment as the first choice should be recommended for these patients and higher doses should be preferred.     

STANDARD DOSE 131I THERAPY FOR HYPERTHYROIDISM CAUSED BY AUTONOMOUSLY FUNCTIONING THYROID NODULES

Thirty-one patients with hyperthyroidism shown on scintigram to have autonomously functioning thyroid nodules were treated with a standard dose of 15 milliocuries (mCi) of 131I. Of thirty patients who have been followed up for a least 6 months to over 3 years, all but one patient were euthyroid after a single dose. Repeat scintigram and Thyrotropin Releasing Hormone (TRH) test after therapy confirmed that twenty-five patients were cured of the disease. Only one patient developed hypothyroidism. This simplified standard dose regimen of radioiodine is effective in the treatment of hyperthyroidism caused by autonomously functioning nodules and is not complicated by the high incidence of hypothyroidism that is observed following radioiodine therapy of Graves' disease.     

Effectiveness of radioiodine (131-I) as definitive therapy in patients with autoimmune and non-autoimmune hyperthyroidism

We evaluated the outcome of radioiodine (RAI) therapy in 100 consecutive patients treated in the period 2000-2001 for hyperthyroidism due to Graves' disease (GD), toxic adenoma (TA) and toxic multinodular goiter (TMG). Thyroid function was measured before and after therapy every 3-6 months up to 3 yr. Three years after therapy, 75% of TA patients were euthyroid, 18.7% were hypothyroid and 6.3% hyperthyroid. Of the TMG patients, 62.2% were euthyroid, 18.9% were hypothyroid and 18.9% hyperthyroid. In GD patients euthyroidism was achieved in 12.9% of the patients, hypothyroidism in 74.2% and hyperthyroidism persisted in 12.9%. Definitive hypothyroidism was significantly higher in GD (p<0.0001) than in TA and TMG patients. Overall, positive effect of RAI (definitive hypothyroidism or euthyroidism) was very high: 93.7% in TA, 81.1% in TMG and 87.1% in GD patients. Thyroid volume reduction was observed in all patients, but was higher in GD patients (mean reduction of 76%) and in TA patients (mean nodule reduction of 69%). In TMG, mean reduction was of 32%. The median activity of RAI received by the 86 cured patients was 555 MBq (15 mCi) compared to 407 Mbq (11 mCi) received by the 14 patients who remained hyperthyroid. No influence was found between outcome and clinical parameters at the moment of 131-I therapy. In conclusion, our results indicate that RAI therapy is highly effective and safe for the control of hyperthyroidism.     

Optimized radioiodine therapy of Graves' disease: analysis of the delivered dose and of other possible factors affecting outcome.

The best approach to radioiodine dose selection in the treatment of Graves' hyperthyroidism remains highly controversial. The formula to calculate the individual dose of (131)I to be delivered has been used for half a century and takes into account the thyroid mass, the effective half-life and the maximum uptake of (131)I. The objective of the present study was to evaluate the accuracy of this formula by determining the relationship between the administered dose of (131)I calculated to deliver a target dose of 50Gy to the thyroid and the actual exact organ dose. We further analyzed if therapeutic success, defined by euthyroidism following the individually calculated dose, can be predicted by different pretreatment parameters and particularly by organ dose. One hundred patients with a first episode of Graves' disease and who had received optimal thyroid irradiation after precise dosimetry were retrospectively reviewed. The patients were categorized according to their thyroid function (plasma free thyroxine (T(4)) serum concentration) as eu-, hyper- or hypothyroid during and 1 year after treatment. The relationship between the administered dose and organ dose was assessed by simple regression. We compared free T(4), free tri-iodothyronine, thyroid weight, the number of patients with antithyroperoxidase antibodies and TSH receptor autoantibodies, 24h urinary iodine excretion, (131)I uptake, and the exact dose of (131)I delivered to the thyroid as pretreatment variables. Although we found a correlation between administered dose (mCi) and organ dose (Gy) (r=0.3, P=0.003), the mean coefficient of variation for organ dose was 45%. Individualized radioiodine therapy enabled euthyroidism in 26% of patients and failed in 74% of patients (33% had persistent or recurrent hyperthyroidism and 41% permanent hypothyroidism). (131)I uptake was significantly higher in the hyperthyroidism group in comparison with the euthyroid group. However, organ dose and other pretreatment variables did not differ among the three groups. In conclusion, these results confirm the low performance of individual dosimetry using what are established ratios, since the delivered dose to the gland, although correlated to the intended dose, is highly variable. The finding that other usual pretreatment variables are not different between groups, gives little hope for improving the way of calculating the ideal dose of radioiodine. We suggest to those not yet ready to give a standard or an ablative dose for Graves' hyperthyroidism that they abandon this way to calculate the (131)I dose.     

Is calculation of the dose in radioiodine therapy of hyperthyroidism worth while?

OBJECTIVE The persistent controversy as to the best approach to radioiodine dose selection in the treatment of hyperthyroldism led us to perform a study in order to compare a fixed dose regime comprising doses of 185, 370 or 555 MBq based on gland size assessment by palpation only, with a calculated ¹³¹I dose based on type of thyroid gland (diffuse, multinodular, solitary adenoma), an accurate thyroid volume measurement, and a 24-hour ¹³¹I uptake determination. DESIGN Prospective randomized study. PATIENTS Two hundred and twenty-one consecutive hyperthyroid patients referred for ¹³¹I treatment. Four patlents who dled for reasons unrelated to hyperthyroidism, 7 lost to follow-up and 47 who did not receive antithyroid drugs after treatment, were excluded. The remalnlng 163 patlents (143 women) were studied, dlvlded into subgroups accordlng to the type of gland. They all recelved antithyroid drugs prior to ¹³¹I treatment and this was resumed 7 days after treatment for a period of 3 weeks. MEASUREMENTS Thyroid function variables were determined approximately 2 weeks before ¹³¹I treatment, and again 1, 2, 3, 6, 9 and 12 months after treatment. Prior to ¹³¹I therapy the size of the thyroid gland was determined by ultrasound and a 24-hour uptake of ¹³¹I was carried out. Thyroid in 78 of the 163 patients. Twelve months after the initial ¹³¹I dose patients could be classified as euthyroid, hyperthyrold or hypothyroid. RESULT Neither in the group of 163 patients nor within the three subgroups of hyperthyroidism could any significant difference in outcome between the two treatment regimes be demonstrated. Thirty-two of 78 patients (41%) in the calculated dose group and 30 of 85 patients (35%, NS) in the fixed group were classified as hyperthroid. Seven of 78(9%) in the calculated dose group were classified as permanently hypothyroid. Finally, 39 of 78(50%) In the calculated dose group and 49 of 85(58%, NS) in the fixed group were enthyroid at 12 months after ¹³¹I treatment. One year after ¹³¹I therapy thyroid volume was deduced from 59.3 ± 9.2 (mean ± SEM) to 36.2 ± 6.6 ml (average reduction 39%) In the calculated dose group (P < 0.001). This reduction did not differ significantly from the fixed dose group where thyroid volume declined from 61.6 ± 6.1 to 41.17 ± 4.7 ml (average reduction 32%) (P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS A semiquantitative approach is probably as good as the more elaborately calculated radiolodine dose for treatment of hyperthyroidism. It is clearly more cost effective and allows the use of predetermined standard doses.     

Appearance of thyroid stimulating antibody and Graves' disease after radioiodine therapy for toxic nodular goitre

A patient with toxic nodular goitre is described in whom radioiodine (¹³¹I) therapy paradoxically induced typical Graves' disease. This patient had a goitre with two autonomously functioning nodules suppressing uptake by the remainder of the gland. Circulating thyroid peroxidase antibody indicated the coexistence of focal lymphocytic thyroiditis. Radioiodine therapy was followed by the development of severe and persistent Graves' hyperthyroidism associated with diffuse ¹³¹I uptake by the gland. A second administration of ¹³¹I produced a further worsening of hyperthyroidism, and the appearance of ophthalmopathy. TSH-receptor antibody and thyroid stimulating antibody were undetectable before ¹³¹I, appeared after the first administration of radioiodine, and showed a further increase after the second dose of ¹³¹I. We suggest that, in a patient genetically susceptible to thyroid autoimmunity, the release of TSH-receptor antigenic components from follicular cells damaged by radioiodine therapy triggered an autoimmune response to the TSH-receptor, thus turning a toxic nodular goitre into Graves' disease.     

Influence of compensated radioiodine therapy on thyroid volume and incidence of hypothyroidism in Graves' disease

Abstract. Objectives . To investigate the long-term effect of radioactive iodine (¹³¹I) on thyroid function and size in patients with Graves' disease. Setting . Out-patient clinic in Herlev Hospital. Subjects . One hundred and seventeen consecutive patients (104 women) with Graves' disease selected for ¹³¹I treatment and followed for a minimum of 12 months (range 1–10 years, median 5 years). Interventions . ¹³¹I dose was calculated based on thyroid volume and 24-h ¹³¹I uptake. Main outcome measures . Standard thyroid function variables and ultrasonically determined thyroid volume before treatment as well as 0.75, 1.5, 3, 6 and 12 months after treatment, and then once a year were investigated. Results . Seventy-eight patients were cured by one ¹³¹I dose and 30 by two doses, while the remaining nine patients received additional doses (range one to five doses, median one dose). Within one year, 25% developed hypothyroidism, and hereafter, hypothyroidism developed at a constant rate of 3% per year independent of antithyroid pretreatment. The cumulative 10-year risk of hypothyroidism was 60%. Initial median thyroid volume was 33 mL (range 9–106 mL). At 12 months after the last ¹³¹I dose, median thyroid volume was reduced to 14 mL (range 6–36 mL) (P < 0.00001). The median reduction being 58% (range 0–80%,), hereafter no further reduction occurred. A significant reduction in thyroid volume was also noted in patients needing subsequent ¹³¹I doses and in those developing hypothyroidism within the first year. Conclusions . ¹³¹I normalizes thyroid volume in patients with Graves' disease. Hypothyroidism seems an inevitable end result of this treatment. The present study suggests that it will be impossible to modify ¹³¹I therapy in a way to achieve both early control of hyperthyroidism and a low incidence of hypothyroidism.     

Effect of iopanoic acid on radioiodine therapy of hyperthyroidism: long-term outcome of a randomized controlled trial

CONTEXT: Telepaque [iopanoic acid (IA)] is believed to rapidly ameliorate hyperthyroidism; however, it may preclude subsequent 131I therapy, possibly delaying it for several months. OBJECTIVE: Our objective was to see how early patients, made euthyroid with Telepaque, can be treated with 131I and to compare their short- and long-term outcome with patients treated with 131I, after making them euthyroid with carbimazole and beta-blockers. DESIGN: We conducted a randomized controlled trial. SETTING AND PATIENTS: We studied 200 hyperthyroid patients at a tertiary care teaching institute. INTERVENTIONS: The IA group received Telepaque, 500 mg/d orally, for 7 d and then no medication for 1 wk followed by 131I therapy if radioiodine neck uptake had recovered. The control group received 30-40 mg oral carbimazole daily until patients became euthyroid followed by 131I. MAIN OUTCOME: After 1 wk of Telepaque therapy and 6 wk of carbimazole, almost all patients became clinically and biochemically euthyroid, and 86 and 94% of patients were ready for 131I therapy after 1 and 2 wk off Telepaque, respectively. The cure rate, defined as euthyroid plus hypothyroid, after the first dose of 131I in controls and the IA group was 80 and 76.2%, respectively (P = 0.54). Thirty-two percent among controls and 25% in the IA group became hypothyroid within 1 yr (P = 0.33); thereafter, the annual rate of hypothyroidism was about 2% in both groups. After a mean follow-up duration of 11 yr, 58% of patients in the control group and 51% in the IA group were hypothyroid. CONCLUSIONS: Telepaque rapidly ameliorates hyperthyroidism without jeopardizing the subsequent radioiodine therapy, and the outcome of radioiodine therapy in this subset of patients is in no way different compared with those prepared by carbimazole.     

A randomized comparison of radioiodine doses in Graves' hyperthyroidism

The optimal method for determining iodine-131 treatment doses for Graves' hyperthyroidism is unknown, and techniques have varied from a fixed dose to more elaborate calculations based upon gland size, iodine uptake, and iodine turnover. Patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism (n = 88) who had not been previously treated with radioactive iodine were randomized to one of four dose calculation methods: low-fixed, 235 MBq; high-fixed, 350 MBq; low-adjusted, 2.96 MBq (80 micro Ci)/g thyroid adjusted for 24 h radioiodine uptake; and high-adjusted, 4.44 MBq (120 micro Ci)/g thyroid adjusted for 24 h radioiodine uptake. Subjects were followed for mean of 63 months (range, 10-94 months) for the following clinical outcomes: euthyroid without medication, hyperthyroid requiring further radioiodine, and hypothyroid requiring life-long L-T(4). Mean treatment doses were similar in the different outcome groups. We could not demonstrate any advantage to using an adjusted dose method. Survival analysis did not demonstrate any difference in the time to outcome between the fixed and adjusted dose methods. The use of a fixed dose method simplifies the approach to treatment with potential cost savings.     

Evaluation of radioiodine therapy with fixed doses of 10 and 15 mCi in patients with Graves' disease

The treatment options for the hyperthyroidism of Graves disease are antithyroid drugs, surgery and radioiodine, none of which is considered ideal, as they do not act directly on the etiopathogenesis of the disease. Radioiodine has been increasingly used as the treatment of choice because it is a safe and definitive therapy whose administration is very easy. Some authors prefer to administer higher doses in order to deliberately induce hypothyroidism, while others recommend lower doses that result in a lower incidence of hypothyroidism and a greater incidence of euthyroidism. There is no consensus for the optimal regimen of fixed doses to be used and this is the main focus of the present study, where doses of 10 and 15 mCi of (131)I were compared. Among the 164 patients analyzed, 61 (37.2%) were submitted to 10 mCi and 103 (62.8%) to 15 mCi. In the longitudinal analysis it was observed that remission of the hyperthyroidism was statistically different in the sixth month (p < 0.001), being higher in the group that used the dose of 15 mCi, but similar in both groups at 12 and 24 months. It may be concluded that the administration of fixed doses of 10 and 15 mCi of (131)I brought about a similar remission of the hyperthyroidism after 12 months of treatment. Moreover, the remission rate of the hyperthyroidism had no association with age, sex or previous therapy with antithyroid drugs.     

Radioiodine treatment of hyperthyroidism-prognostic factors for outcome

There is little consensus regarding the most appropriate dose regimen for radioiodine (131I) in the treatment of hyperthyroidism. We audited 813 consecutive hyperthyroid patients treated with radioiodine to compare the efficacy of 2 fixed-dose regimens used within our center (185 megabequerels, 370 megabequerels) and to explore factors that may predict outcome. Patients were categorized into 3 diagnostic groups: Graves' disease, toxic nodular goiter, and hyperthyroidism of indeterminate etiology. Cure after a single dose of 131I was investigated and defined as euthyroid off all treatment for 6 months or T4 replacement for biochemical hypothyroidism in all groups. As expected, patients given a single dose of 370 megabequerels had a higher cure rate than those given 185 megabequerels, (84.6% vs. 66.6%, P < 0.0001) but an increase in hypothyroidism incidence at 1 yr (60.8% vs. 41.3%, P < 0.0001). There was no difference in cure rate between the groups with Graves' disease and those with toxic nodular goiter (69.5% vs. 71.4%; P, not significant), but Graves' patients had a higher incidence of hypothyroidism (54.5% vs. 31.7%, P < 0.0001). Males had a lower cure rate than females (67.6% vs. 76.7%, P = 0.02), whereas younger patients (<40 yr) had a lower cure rate than patients over 40 yr old (68.9% vs. 79.3%, P < 0.001). Patients with more severe hyperthyroidism (P < 0.0001) and with goiters of medium or large size (P < 0.0001) were less likely to be cured after a single dose of 131I. The use of antithyroid drugs, during a period 2 wk before or after 131I, resulted in a significant reduction in cure rate in patients given 185 megabequerels 131I (P < 0.01) but not 370 megabequerels. Logistic regression analysis showed dose, gender, goiters of medium or large size, and severity of hyperthyroidism to be significant independent prognostic factors for cure after a single dose of 131I. We have demonstrated that a single fixed dose of 370 megabequerels 131I is highly effective in curing toxic nodular hyperthyroidism as well as Graves' hyperthyroidism. Because male patients and those with more severe hyperthyroidism and medium or large-sized goiters are less likely to respond to a single dose of radioiodine, we suggest that the value of higher fixed initial doses of radioiodine should be evaluated in these patient categories with lower cure rates.     

A reappraisal of the role of methimazole and other factors on the efficacy and outcome of radioiodine therapy of Graves' hyperthyroidism

The outcome of radioiodine therapy of Graves' hyperthyroidism was retrospectively evaluated in 274 consecutive patients treated from 1975 to 1984. At 1-yr follow-up, permanent hypothyroidism occurred in 36.9% of patients and the cumulative incidence of hypothyroidism progressively increased up to 79.3% after 7-10 yr. At the end of the follow-up period, 148 patients (54%) were hypothyroid, 115 (42%) euthyroid and 11 (4%) still hyperthyroid. The prevalence of hypothyroidism was significantly higher in patients with small goiters (less than or equal to 50 g) than in those with large goiters (greater than 90 g). Moreover, hypothyroidism was more frequent in patients with high thyroglobulin antibodies titers (greater than or equal to 1:25,600) than in those with low titers or negative tests, and occurred earlier in the former group than in the latter ones Correction of thyrotoxicosis was obtained after the administration of a single dose of 131I in 187 patients (63.6%); 69 patients required two doses and 11 three or more doses. Seven patients refused further treatment with 131I after the first dose. In an effort to identify possible factors affecting the efficacy of 131I therapy, we evaluated the results obtained after the administration of the first dose of radioiodine. We found that large goiters, rapid iodide turnover and adjunctive therapy with methimazole shortly after radioiodine were associated with a higher rate of persistence of thyrotoxicosis, whereas an increased prevalence of hypothyroidism was observed in patients with small goiters and in those not treated with methimazole up to one week after 131I.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

PRODUCTION OF NON-STIMULATORY IMMUNOGLOBULINS THAT INHIBIT TSH BINDING IN Graves'' DISEASE AFTER RADIOIODINE ADMINISTRATION

The effect of a single dose of ¹³¹I upon thyroid stimulating immunoglobulins has been studied in twenty-two patients with Graves' disease. The thyroid stimulating immunoglobulins were assessed by parallel measurements of thyrotrophin receptor binding inhibitory immunoglobulins (TBII) and of thyroid adenylate cyclase stimulating immunoglobulins (TACSI) in serum by radioreceptor assay and stimulation of adenylate cyclase respectively. Prior to ¹³¹I therapy TBII were present in fourteen and TACSI in sixteen patients; seventeen were positive in one of the assays and thirteen in both assays. After radioiodine the level of both TACSI and TBII increased in most patients, but in six patients ¹³¹I therapy appeared to lead to a dissociation between the TBII and TACSI. After 12 months, nine patients were still positive in both assays, and twenty-one in one of the assays. In total, five patients developed hypothyroidism within 1 year after radioiodine. The TBII levels were significantly higher both before and 3 months after therapy in these patients than in those who remained euthyroid. Two of the hypothyroid patients developed non-stimulatory TSH binding inhibitory antibodies. The present study thus confirms that radioiodine therapy is followed by an increase of TBII and TACSI in most patients with Graves' disease. The level of TBII can probably provide a marker for development of hypothyroidism following ¹³¹I therapy and might be involved in its pathogenesis.     

Determinants of longterm outcome of radioiodine therapy of sporadic non-toxic goitre

OBJECTIVE: Radioiodine treatment is effective in reducing the size of sporadic nontoxic goitre, albeit at the expense of a high incidence of postradiation hypothyroidism. The decrease in goitre size, however, is not observed in all subjects, and little is known about recurrent goitre growth after 131I therapy. The aim of the present study was to evaluate which factors determine the longterm outcome of 131I treatment in patients with sporadic nontoxic nodular goitre, in terms of changes in both thyroid size and thyroid function. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective follow-up study. PATIENTS: Fifty patients with sporadic nontoxic nodular goitre were evaluated who had been treated in our institution with 131I (mean dose 4.4 MBq/g thyroid) in the period 1988-95. Nine patients received a second dose of 131I and one a third. Median follow-up time was 41 months (range 24-115). MEASUREMENTS: Thyroid function was assesed by TSH and FT4 index, and thyroid volume by ultrasound in 46 patients, by scintiscan using the Himanka formula in three and by CT-scan in one. The response to treatment was defined as a decrease in thyroid volume of greater than 13% (i.e. the mean + 2SD of the coefficient of variation of volume measurements), and recurrent goitre as an increase in thyroid volume greater than 13% after an initial response. RESULTS: Goitre size decreased from a median value of 82 ml (range 17-325) to 37 ml (range 6-204) two years after 131I treatment, a median reduction of 49%. The decrease in goitre size was directly related to the dose of 131I (r = 0.50, P = 0.0003) and indirectly to baseline goitre size (r = - 0.35, P = 0.006). Seven patients (14%) were nonresponders, and four (8%) experienced recurrent goitre growth after 3-5 years. These 11 patients (22%) when compared to the remaining 39 responders (78%) had larger goitres with more often a dominant nodule, and had received a lower 131I dose. The efficacy of a second dose of 131I (median reduction in goitre size 37%) was comparable to the first dose. Hypothyroidism occurred in 24 patients (48%), mostly in the first two years after treatment; 11 had overt and 13 subclinical hypothyroidism. Kaplan Meier statistics indicated a probability of 58% for developing hypothyroidism after 8 years. Hypothyroid patients had a smaller initial goitre size and a higher prevalence of TPO antibodies and a family history of thyroid disease than the patients who remained euthyroid; the 131I dose did not differ between the two groups. CONCLUSIONS: The size of sporadic nontoxic goitres is reduced on average by 50% after a single dose of 4.77 MBq 131I/g thyroid. Independent determinants of the relative decrease in thyroid volume are administered 131I dose and initial goitre size. Nonresponders (14%) and those with late recurrence of goitre growth (8%) have larger goitres and more often dominant nodules than responders. Determinants of postradioiodine hypothyroidism (cumulative risk 58% after 8 years) are the presence of TPO antibodies, a family history of thyroid disease and a relatively small goitre.The implications of these findings are that the efficacy of a given 131I dose can be enhanced when administered at an earlier stage when the goitre is still smaller, albeit at the expense of an increased risk for developing hypothyroidism.     

Successful treatment of solitary toxic thyroid nodules with relatively low-dose iodine-131, with low prevalence of hypothyroidism

Forty-five patients with solitary toxic thyroid adenomas received 131I (mean dose, 10.3 mCi) for treatment of hyperthyroidism and were followed for 4.9 +/- 3.2 years (range, 0.5 to 13.5). Seventy-seven percent were euthyroid by 2 months, 91% by 6 months, and 93% by 1 year. Only 3 patients did not respond to a single dose of 131I, but all responded to multiple doses. Late recurrent hyperthyroidism occurred in 3 patients at 4.5, 6, and 10 years after treatment with a single dose of 131I. No patient developed clinical hypothyroidism, and none had a low serum thyroxine level associated with an elevated serum thyrotrophin level. Three patients developed minimal elevations in serum thyrotrophin levels: 1, 4, and 7.5 years after 131I treatment, their thyrotrophin levels were 8.4, 6.2, and 9.6 microU/mL, respectively. All 3 had normal serum thyroxine levels and were clinically euthyroid. Mean serum thyroxine concentrations of all patients were unchanged between 1 and more than 9 years of follow-up. These data suggest that solitary toxic adenomas may be treated with relatively low doses of 131I (5 to 15 mCi), and that post-treatment hypothyroidism is very unusual.