Prospective use of subtraction ictal SPECT coregistered to MRI (SISCOM) in presurgical evaluation of epilepsy

Purpose: In patients with drug‐refractory focal epilepsy, nonlesional magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) or discordant data of presurgical standard investigations leads to failure generating a sufficient hypothesis for electrode implantation or epilepsy surgery. The seizure‐onset zone can be further investigated by subtraction ictal single‐photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) coregistered to MRI (SISCOM). This is an observational study of a large consecutive cohort of patients undergoing prospective SISCOM to generate hypothesis for electrode implantation or site of epilepsy surgery. Methods: One hundred seventy‐five consecutive patients undergoing presurgical evaluation with either nonlesional MRI or discordant data of standard investigations preventing the generation of hypothesis for seizure onset were evaluated with SISCOM. Results were compared to gold standard for seizure onset detection, either electrocorticography (ECoG) and/or postoperative outcome. Key Findings: One hundred thirty patients had successful SPECT injection. Hypothesis for electrode implantation/site of surgery was generated in 74 patients. Forty patients had gold standard comparison. Twenty‐eight patients underwent resective surgery. SISCOM was concordant to site of surgery in 82%. An additional 12 patients underwent invasive EEG monitoring but were not suitable for surgery. SISCOM was concordant multifocal in 75%. Two years postsurgical follow‐up of 26 patients showed favorable outcome in 22 (Engel class I and class II). Significance: SISCOM is a highly valuable diagnostic tool to localize the seizure‐onset zone in nonlesional and extratemporal epilepsies. Outcome in this patient group was unexpectedly good, even in patients with nonlesional MRI. The high correlation with ECoG and site of successful surgery is a strong indicator that outcome prediction in this patient group should be adapted accordingly, which may encourage more patients to undergo electrode implantation and subsequent successful surgery. Statistical analysis showed that SISCOM with shorter duration of seizures, focal seizures, and lesional MRI was more likely to generate implantation hypothesis.     

Postictal aphasia and paresis: a clinical and intracerebral EEG study

BACKGROUND: We examined the lateralizing value of postictal language and motor deficits and studied their underlying mechanisms. PATIENTS AND METHODS: The total sample consisted of 35 patients (26 temporals, 8 frontals, 1 parietal) with a good postsurgical outcome (Engel's class I and II). Postictal examination was blindly reviewed on videotapes. In 15 cases (29 seizures), postictal language manifestations were analyzed in relation with the diffusion of the epileptic discharge recorded by intracerebral EEG. Language dominance was determined by the intracarotid amobarbital test. RESULTS: Postictal aphasia was observed only when (1) seizure originated in the dominant hemisphere and (2) ictal activity spread to language areas (Wernicke and/or Broca areas). When the epileptic focus was in the nondominant hemisphere, no postictal aphasia was observed even if there was secondary generalization of ictal activity affecting the language areas of the dominant hemisphere. Postictal motor deficits also had a strong lateralizing value even when seizures were secondarily generalized. CONCLUSION: Postictal aphasia in temporal epilepsies and postical motor deficits in temporal and extra temporal epilepsies provided excellent lateralizing information. Postictal deficits appear to be the result of inhibitory mechanisms induced by previous ictal activity of the structures related to these functions.     

On the prognostic value of ictal EEG patterns in temporal lobe epilepsy surgery: A cohort study

PurposeTo investigate the prognostic value of ictal scalp EEG patterns in drug-resistant temporal lobe epilepsy associated with hippocampal sclerosis (MTLE-HS) prior to undergoing temporal lobectomy.MethodsScalp EEGs of the first seizure recorded during presurgical long-term video-EEG monitoring of 284 patients were reviewed. Patients were divided according to seizure laterality as either unilateral, when the EEG was restricted to one cerebral hemisphere for the entire seizure, or bilateral, when there was involvement of both hemispheres during the seizure. In patients with unilateral hippocampal sclerosis (HS), seizures were subdivided according to the side of initial ictal activity in relation to the side of the HS, as concordant, non-lateralising or contralateral. Postsurgical seizure outcome, according to Engel's classification, was verified at 1, 2, and 5 years after surgery.ResultsThere was no significant association between ictal EEG characteristics and postsurgical seizure outcome. An Engel I seizure outcome was observed in 87.1% of the patients with unilateral ictal EEGs and in 79.6% of those with bilateral ictal EEGs (p = 0.092).ConclusionAnalysis of the localisation, morphology, and lateralisation of ictal EEG patterns did not provide prognostic information regarding seizure-free status in patients with MTLE-HS undergoing temporal lobectomy.     

Combining ictal surface-electroencephalography and seizure semiology improves patient lateralization in temporal lobe epilepsy

PURPOSE: The study goal was to assess the concordance of ictal surface-EEG and seizure semiology data in lateralizing intractable temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) and to examine the benefits of the combined use of these two methods. METHODS: We independently analyzed the ictal recordings and clinical symptoms associated with 262 seizures recorded in 59 TLE patients. Each seizure was lateralized on the basis of (i) its associated ictal surface-EEG pattern according to a predefined lateralization protocol and (ii) its associated ictal and postictal seizure semiology according to strictly defined clinical criteria. Individual patients were also lateralized based on these data. RESULTS: Ictal surface-EEG findings lateralized 62.6% of seizures and 64.4% of patients. Seizure semiology findings lateralized 46.2% of seizures and 78.0% of patients. There was a high degree of concordance between lateralizations based on these two methods, for both individual seizures and individual patients. Combination of the information from the two methods allowed for lateralization in a greater proportion of both seizures (79.8%) and patients (94.9%). Combined EEG-seizure lateralization was concordant with the side of operation in 33 of 34 patients who underwent successful surgery (Engel's surgical outcome class I/II). CONCLUSIONS: In TLE, there is a high agreement between the lateralization of individual seizures and patients, which is based on ictal surface-EEG findings and seizure semiology. Furthermore, combination of these two methods improves the lateralization of individual seizures and patients. Thus, standardized combined EEG-seizure analysis is a valuable noninvasive tool in the presurgical evaluation of TLE.     

Lateralising value of ictal features in partial seizures: effect on postsurgical outcome.

We reviewed the videotapes of 49 consecutive patients with a history of medically refractory temporal lobe epilepsy for the presence and laterality of unilateral hand posturing (UHP), unilateral hand automatism (UHA), non-forced head turning (HT), and post-ictal dysphasia (PID). All of these patients underwent temporal resections with follow-up for more than 2 years after the surgery. We examined the correlation of consistency, frequency, and laterality of each of these signs on the postsurgical outcomes. The distribution of these signs was not significantly different between patients with Engel class 1 versus Engel class 2-4. The consistency and laterality of these signs do not correlate with postsurgical outcomes.     

Influence on ictal seizure semiology of rapid withdrawal of carbamazepine and valproate in monotherapy

PURPOSE: To quantify changes in ictal seizure semiology during rapid withdrawal of carbamazepine (CBZ) and valproate (VPA) from a monoregimen in presurgical evaluation. METHODS: Therapeutic intensive seizure analysis (TISA) with video-EEG monitoring was used in 33 patients with pharmacoresistant partial epilepsy undergoing complete withdrawal of CBZ (20 patients) or VPA (13 patients) from a monoregimen. Monitoring phases included a 3-day baseline phase, a 3-day rapid antiepileptic drug (AED) withdrawal phase, and another 3-day AED-free phase with AEDs in subtherapeutic levels. Seizure variables as complete processes and their various elements (ictal signs) were analyzed, including duration (seconds), intensity (on a scale of 0 to 3), frequency (number per 3 days), and total duration of seizures and ictal signs in 3 days (seconds). The localization of seizure patterns on ictal EEG recording (EEG seizure onset) and the first appearing clinical ictal phenomena (initial ictal signs) were recorded. RESULTS: A total of 188 seizures in the CBZ group and 57 seizures in the VPA group were investigated. Compared with the baseline phase, the CBZ group showed increases in duration, frequency of seizures, various ictal signs, and secondarily generalized tonic and clonic signs during the following two phases. Significantly increased values of the VPA group were observed in seizure duration and frequency of hypermotoric phenomena during the AED-free phase. More patients in the CBZ group had secondarily generalized clonic signs during the AED-free phase. EEG seizure onset and initial ictal signs showed no obvious changes between study phases. CONCLUSIONS: Withdrawal of CBZ is followed more quickly by an increase of seizure frequency and severity than is the case for VPA withdrawal. Both CBZ and VPA withdrawal influences seizure propagation rather than the seizure-onset characteristics, which speaks in favor of its use in presurgical evaluation.     

Automatisms with preserved responsiveness and ictal aphasia: contradictory lateralising signs during a dominant temporal lobe seizure.

The 25-year-old right-handed woman suffering from temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) was referred to our centre for presurgical evaluation. MRI showed a right-sided hippocampal sclerosis. During video-EEG-recorded seizures, abdominal aura was followed by oral automatisms, during which she was completely reactive to external stimuli, although she was unable to speak. Ictal EEG showed right temporal seizure pattern, without contralateral propagation. She had abnormal speech postictally. Speech-activated functional transcranial Doppler sonography revealed right-sided speech dominance. She has become seizure free after a right-sided amygdalo-hippocampectomy. In our patient, contradictory clinical ictal lateralising signs (automatisms with preserved responsiveness vs. ictal and postictal dysphasia) occurred during right-, speech-dominant-sided seizures. This is the first report when automatisms with preserved consciousness occurred during a seizure originating and involving the speech-dominant hemisphere.     

Potentially misleading extratemporal lobe lesions in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy

From a series of 217 consecutive temporal resections for intractable epilepsy between 1993 and 2000, we identified all patients with large non-neoplastic extratemporal lesions. Only patients with known postsurgical outcomes with follow up for more than two years were included. Fifteen patients were identified. All patients had a history of medically refractory epilepsy with clinical and ictal evidence of mesial temporal seizure onset. Eleven patients had extratemporal lesions ipsilateral to the seizure focus, whereas four patients had the lesions contralateral to the seizure focus. Nine of the 15 patients had evidence of hippocampal atrophy on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Following temporal resection, nine of these patients (60%) became seizure free (Engel class 1A), two patients were free of disabling seizures only (Engel class 1B), and two patients had a few early seizures but then became seizure free for at least two years (Engel class 1C). Two patients had significant improvement (Engel class 2). Thus, the finding of large extratemporal lesions on MRI was potentially misleading. When clinical semiology and ictal EEG recordings provide evidence of temporal onset seizures, anterior temporal resection should be considered in patients with extratemporal lesions.     

Ictal speech, postictal language dysfunction, and seizure lateralization

In 84 patients with complex partial seizures evaluated by EEG and video telemetry, who went on to have seizure surgery, complex intraictal vocalizations and postictal language dysfunction were found to have strong lateralizing significance. Thirteen patients had ictal speech, and 12 of these had right-sided seizure foci. Twenty-eight had intact postictal language, and 21 of these had right-sided foci. Of the 32 with impaired postictal language, 21 had left-sided foci.     

Lateralizing signs during seizures in focal epilepsy

This article reviews lateralizing semiological signs during epileptic seizures with respect to prediction of the side of the epileptogenic zone and, therefore, presurgical diagnostic value. The lateralizing significance of semiological signs and symptoms can frequently be concluded from knowledge of the cortical representation. Visual, auditory, painful, and autonomic auras, as well as ictal motor manifestations, e.g., version, clonic and tonic activity, unilateral epileptic spasms, dystonic posturing and unilateral automatisms, automatisms with preserved responsiveness, ictal spitting and vomiting, emotional facial asymmetry, unilateral eye blinking, ictal nystagmus, and akinesia, have been shown to have lateralizing value. Furthermore, ictal language manifestations and postictal features, such as Todd's palsy, postictal aphasia, postictal nosewiping, postictal memory dysfunction, as well as peri-ictal water drinking, peri-ictal headache, and ipsilateral tongue biting, are reviewed. Knowledge and recognition of semiological lateralizing signs during seizures is an important component of the presurgical evaluation of epilepsy surgery candidates and adds further information to video/EEG monitoring, neuroimaging, functional mapping, and neuropsychological evaluation.     

Lateralized Postictal EEG Delta Predicts the Side of Seizure Surgery in Temporal Lobe Epilepsy

PURPOSE: The concordance of lateralized EEG postictal polymorphic delta activity (PPDA) to the side of seizure origin in temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) has received limited study. Our objective was to study the lateralizing value of PPDA in patients with documented TLE. METHODS: A cohort of consecutive adults with TLE, detailed presurgical evaluation before temporal lobectomy, and minimal follow-up of 2 years were included. One author masked the ictal rhythm of presurgical EEGs and randomly presented 20 s of preictal and the postictal EEG to two electroencephalographers who were blind to all clinical data. They independently assigned PPDA to one of three categories: not present, bilateral, or lateralized (defined as newly appearing or an amplitude >50% of the preictal record). RESULTS: Eighty seizures from 29 patients were studied. Fifteen patients had a left, and 14 had a right temporal lobectomy. Twenty-three patients were seizure free or substantially improved (defined as simple partial or nocturnal seizures only). Lateralized PPDA was present in 64% of all EEGs and at least one record from 22 (76%) patients. Lateralized PPDA, when present, was concordant with the side of surgery in 96% of the EEGs. CONCLUSIONS: Lateralized PPDA is highly predictive of the side of ultimate temporal lobectomy, and by inference the side of seizure origin.     

Lateralized ictal immobility of the upper limb in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy

The primary aim of this study was to establish the incidence and the lateralizing value of 'lateralized ictal immobility of the upper limb' (LIL) in patients suffering from temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE), and to describe the connection between LIL and other clinical ictal signs. We retrospectively reviewed video records of 87 patients with TLE. We reviewed a total of 276 focal epileptic seizures with or without secondary generalization. We studied the incidence of LIL, its lateralizing value, and its relationship to other ictal clinical signs. Of the 87 patients, 49 had undergone a successful resective surgery at least 1 year prior to the study. LIL is a late sign in the course of partial seizure. It occurred in 25 of our 87 patients (28.7%), and in 47 of 276 seizures (17.1%). In all of the evaluated seizures, LIL occurred contralateral to the side of seizure onset (P < 0.001). LIL was always associated with ipsilateral upper limb automatisms, and in 63.1% of the occurrences, it was immediately followed by ictal dystonia. LIL is a more accurate term to describe what has previously been called 'ictal paresis' in the literature. Due to the inability to execute proper testing during a partial seizure, it is better to use the term LIL when making a visual analysis of a seizure. LIL is a more suitable term to describe the studied ictal sign. It is a relatively frequent sign in patients with TLE. LIL has an excellent lateralizing value for the contralateral hemisphere. It is a negative motor sign, and its genesis is probably associated with the epileptic involvement of the contralateral frontal lobe.     

Dynamic changes of ictal high-frequency oscillations in neocortical epilepsy: using multiple band frequency analysis

PURPOSE: To characterize the spatial and temporal course of ictal high-frequency oscillations (HFOs) recorded by subdural EEG in children with intractable neocortical epilepsy. METHODS: We retrospectively studied nine children (four girls, five boys; 4-17 yr) who presented with intractable extrahippocampal localization-related epilepsy and who underwent extraoperative video subdural EEG (1000 Hz sampling rate) and cortical resection. We performed multiple band frequency analysis (MBFA) to evaluate the frequency, time course, and distribution of ictal HFOs. We compared ictal HFO changes before and after clinical onset and postsurgical seizure outcomes. RESULTS: Seventy-eight of 79 seizures showed HFOs. We observed wide-band HFOs ( approximately 250 Hz, approximately 120 electrodes) in six patients either with partial seizures alone (three patients) or with epileptic spasms (three patients). Three patients with partial seizures that secondarily generalized had wide-band HFOs ( approximately 170 Hz) before clinical onset and sustained narrow-band HFOs (60-164 Hz) with electrodecremental events after clinical onset ( approximately 28 electrodes). In four postoperatively seizure-free patients, more electrodes recorded higher-frequency HFOs inside the resection area than outside before and after clinical seizure onset. In five patients with residual seizures, electrodes recorded more HFOs that were of higher or equal frequency outside the surgical area than inside after clinical onset. CONCLUSION: For partial seizures alone and epileptic spasms, more electrodes recorded only wide-band HFOs; for partial seizures that secondarily generalized, fewer electrodes recorded wide-band HFOs, but in these seizures electrodes also recorded subsequent sustained narrow-band ictal HFOs. Resection of those brain regions having electrodes with ictal, higher HFOs resulted in postsurgical seizure-free outcomes.     

Ictal Contralateral Paresis in Complex Partial Seizures

Summary: Certain behaviors that occur during a complex partial seizure (CPS) are useful in lateralizing the side of seizure onset. In 5 (5.3%) of 94 consecutive patients with partial epilepsy, we observed ictal unilateral arm and hand paresis during 27 of 34 CPS. In all these seizures, this behavior occurred contralateral to an epileptogenic temporal lobe, as determined by video-EEG monitoring and surgical outcome. In 5 of the 27 seizures, an observer demonstrated that the paretic arm and hand were flaccid. None of these patients had postictal (Todd's) paralysis. In most of the seizures, the arm ipsilateral to seizure onset had simultaneous purposeful movements or automatisms, sometimes with awkward posturing. Ictal unilateral paresis is distinctly different from ictal dystonia or postictal paralysis and consistently lateralizes seizure onset to the contralateral temporal lobe. Recognition of this particular ictal behavior and comparison to other simultaneous behaviors can aid in the lateralization and possibly localization of the epileptogenic zone.     

Frontal lobe partial seizures and psychogenic seizures: comparison of clinical and ictal characteristics.

Of all partial seizures, those of frontal lobe origin (FLPS) are most bizarre and are often mistaken for psychogenic seizures (PS). The reverse can also be true. To clarify the confusing clinical presentation of these different seizure types, we compared the clinical ictal characteristics of 63 FLPS in 11 patients with 29 PS in 12 patients. Patients with PS had significantly later age at onset and longer ictal duration. There was no statistically significant difference between the two groups with respect to history of psychiatric disorder, ictal pelvic thrusting, rocking of body, side-to-side head movements, or rapid postictal recovery, all of which previously have been reported as characteristic features of PS. Turning to a prone position during the seizure occurred only in FLPS. Nocturnal occurrence, short ictal duration, younger age at onset, stereotyped patterns of movements, and MRI and EEG abnormality suggested FLPS.     

Ictal magnetic source imaging as a localizing tool in partial epilepsy

OBJECTIVE: To determine the feasibility and usefulness of ictal magnetoencephalography (MEG) recordings in the presurgical evaluation of patients with epilepsy. METHODS: Twenty patients with frequent or predictable seizures were studied with the intent to capture seizures using a large array single-probe 37-channel or dual-probe 74-channel biomagnetometer. RESULTS: Successful ictal MEG recordings were made in 6 of 20 patients with neocortical epilepsy. In one other patient, a seizure was captured but movement artifact made MEG recordings impossible. As determined by invasive EEG recording and postsurgical outcome, ictal MEG provided localizing information that was superior to interictal MEG in three of the six patients. Localization of ictal onset by MEG was at least equivalent to invasive EEG in five of the six patients, and was superior in two patients as determined by postsurgical outcome. CONCLUSION: Larger studies are necessary to confirm that ictal MEG recordings in patients with frequent or easily provoked neocortical seizures can contribute localizing information equivalent or superior to invasive EEG recording.     

Spontaneous periictal leaving behavior: A potential lateralizing sign in mesial temporal lobe epilepsy

Purpose:   Seizure-related spontaneous leaving behavior (LB) is an uncommonly reported phenomenon. The aim of this study was to determine its frequency, clinical significance, and especially its lateralizing value.
Methods:   We analyzed retrospectively the spontaneous periictal LB occurring in complex partial seizures (CPS) of 138 patients with medically refractory mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (MTLE) with excellent postoperative seizure outcome and pathologic finding of hippocampal sclerosis. The relation of LB occurring in different phases of CPS to the side of resection was investigated.
Results:   The overall frequency of periictal LB was 8.3% of 517 CPS and 25.2% of 123 patients. Among the 12 patients with ictal LB, 9 patients had epileptogenic focus ipsilateral to language dominant side, whereas the remaining 3 had seizure onset in the nondominant side. Conversely, 8 of 11 patients with postictal LB had foci in the nondominant side, and only three patients' seizures originated in the dominant side. Therefore, it was more likely for patients with left MTLE to show ictal LB and for those with right foci to display postictal LB (p = 0.03).
Conclusions:   LB may represent a potential lateralizing sign. When LB occurs ictally, it may indicate seizure onset in the dominant temporal lobe, and LB occurring postictally indicates nondominant side seizure onset in patients with MTLE.     

Improving the interpretation of ictal scalp EEG: BSS-CCA algorithm for muscle artifact removal

PURPOSE: To investigate the potential clinical relevance of a new algorithm to remove muscle artifacts in ictal scalp EEG. METHODS: Thirty-seven patients with refractory partial epilepsy with a well-defined seizure onset zone based on full presurgical evaluation, including SISCOM but excluding ictal EEG findings, were included. One ictal EEG of each patient was presented to a clinical neurophysiologist who was blinded to all other data. Ictal EEGs were first rated after band-pass filtering, then after elimination of muscle artifacts using a blind source separation-canonical correlation analysis technique (BSS-CCA). Degree of muscle artifact contamination, lateralization, localization, time and pattern of ictal EEG onset were compared between the two readings and validated against the other localizing information. RESULTS: Muscle artifacts contaminated 97% of ictal EEGs, and interfered with the interpretation in 76%, more often in extratemporal than temporal lobe seizures. BSS-CCA significantly improved the sensitivity to localize the seizure onset from 62% to 81%, and performed best in ictal EEGs with moderate to severe muscle artifact contamination. In a significant number of the contaminated EEGs, BSS-CCA also led to an earlier identification of ictal EEG changes, and recognition of ictal EEG patterns that were hidden by muscle artifact. CONCLUSIONS: Muscle artifacts interfered with the interpretation in a majority of ictal EEGs. BSS-CCA reliably removed these muscle artifacts in a user-friendly manner. BSS-CCA may have an important place in the interpretation of ictal EEGs during presurgical evaluation of patients with refractory partial epilepsy.     

Epilepsy-induced behavioral changes during the ictal phase

In epilepsy, experiential phenomena and behavioral manifestations may pose a number of problems in terms of differential diagnosis. From a clinical point of view, ictal psychiatric symptoms represent partial seizures, mainly partial ones. In the majority of cases, they are very brief (lasting from a few seconds to a few minutes), stereotyped, out of context, and frequently associated with subtle or overt automatisms and postictal confusion of variable duration. In some cases, such symptoms are followed by alteration of consciousness as the ictus evolves to a complex partial seizure or a generalized tonic–clonic seizure. This paper reviews clinically relevant behavioral patterns during seizures discussing clinical phenomenology and relevance in terms of lateralizing value.This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Epilepsy and Consciousness.     

The localizing and lateralizing value of ictal/postictal coughing in patients with focal epilepsies.

Postictal coughing has so far been reported to indicate a temporal origin of focal epilepsy. A trend towards non-dominant hemisphere lateralization and mesial temporal localization has been suggested. However, postictal coughing has also been reported in a few patients with extratemporal epilepsies. We have retrospectively evaluated the localizing and lateralizing value of ictal/postictal coughing in 197 patients with temporal and extratemporal epilepsy who received presurgical video-EEG long-term recordings from 1999 to 2001. There was no statistical significant difference in percentage of coughing patients in both groups. However, only patients belonging to the temporal group presented with coughing as a regular element of seizure semiology (simple partial and complex partial seizures) whereas in the extratemporal group coughing occurred more sporadically. Within the temporal group a statistically significant tendency to left-sided seizure onset and a statistically not significant preponderance of mesial seizure onset was observed. Additional vegetative signs were observed only in about half of the patients. These results suggest that coughing occurs in both temporal and extratemporal lobe epilepsy and may only be indicative of temporal lobe seizure onset if representing a regular semiologic element. Coughing may be due to two different mechanisms, one dependent and the other independent from additional vegetative symptoms.