Cationic lipids containing cyclen and ammonium moieties as gene delivery vectors

In this study, two novel cationic lipids containing protonated cyclen and quaternary ammonium moieties were designed and synthesized as non-viral gene delivery vectors. The structures of the two lipids differ in their hydrophobic region (cholesterol or diosgenin). Cationic liposomes were easily prepared from the lipids individually or from the mixtures of each cationic lipid and dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine. Several studies including DLS, gel retardation assay, and ethidium bromide intercalation assay suggest that these amphiphilic molecules are able to bind and compact DNA into nanometer particles which can be used as non-viral gene delivery agents. Our results from in vitro transfection show that in association with dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine, two cationic lipids can induce effective gene transfection in human embryonic kidney 293 cells, although the gene transfection efficiencies of two cationic lipids were found to be lower than that of lipofectamine 2000(TM) . Besides, different cytotoxicity was found for two lipoplexes. This study demonstrates that the title cationic lipids have large potential to be efficient non-viral gene vectors.     

Current status of non-viral gene therapy for CNS disorders

ABSTRACT

Introduction: Viral and non-viral vectors have been used as methods of delivery in gene therapy for many CNS diseases. Currently, viral vectors such as adeno-associated viruses (AAV), retroviruses, lentiviruses, adenoviruses and herpes simplex viruses (HHV) are being used as successful vectors in gene therapy at clinical trial levels. However, many disadvantages have risen from their usage. Non-viral vectors like cationic polymers, cationic lipids, engineered polymers, nanoparticles, and naked DNA offer a much safer option and can therefore be explored for therapeutic purposes.

Areas covered: This review discusses different types of viral and non-viral vectors for gene therapy and explores clinical trials for CNS diseases that have used these types of vectors for gene delivery. Highlights include non-viral gene delivery and its challenges, possible strategies to improve transfection, regulatory issues concerning vector usage, and future prospects for clinical applications.

Expert opinion: Transfection efficiency of cationic lipids and polymers can be improved through manipulation of molecules used. Efficacy of cationic lipids is dependent on cationic charge, saturation levels, and stability of linkers. Factors determining efficacy of cationic polymers are total charge density, molecular weights, and complexity of molecule. All of the above mentioned parameters must be taken care for efficient gene delivery.     

Cationic transfection lipids in gene therapy: successes,set-backs,challenges and promises

The clinical success of gene therapy is critically dependent on the development of efficient and safe gene delivery reagents, popularly known as "Transfection Vectors". The transfection vectors commonly used in gene therapy are mainly of two types: viral and non-viral. The efficiencies of viral transfection vectors are, in general, superior to their non-viral counterparts. However, the myriads of potentially adverse immunogenic aftermaths associated with the use of viral vectors are increasingly making the non-viral gene delivery reagents as the vectors of choice. Among the existing arsenal of non-viral gene delivery reagents, the distinct advantages associated with the use of cationic transfection lipids include their: (a) robust manufacture; (b) ease in handling & preparation techniques; (c) ability to inject large lipid:DNA complexes and (d) low immunogenic response. The present review will highlight the successes, set-backs, challenges and future promises of cationic transfection lipids in non-viral gene therapy.     

Cationic lipid vectors for plasmid DNA delivery

Successful gene therapy depends on efficient gene transfer vectors. Viral vectors and non-viral vectors have been investigated extensively. Cationic lipids are non-viral vectors, which resemble traditional pharmaceuticals, display little immunogenicity, and have no potential for viral infection. However, toxicity and low transfection efficiency are two barriers limiting the clinical applications of cationic lipids. Over the last decade, hundreds of cationic lipids have been synthesized to address these problems. In this brief review, we summarized recent research results concerning the structures of DNA/liposomes complexes, some important strategies used to design different classes of cationic lipids, and use of disulfide cationic lipids in plasmid DNA delivery.     

非病毒载体在肿瘤基因治疗领域的研究进展

随着肿瘤基因治疗领域的研究进展，临床应用逐渐增多。载体是癌症基因治疗的主要难题。当前广泛使用的病毒载体存在的安全问题越来越受到人们的重视，已经有多种非病毒载体用于肿瘤基因治疔，如：裸DNA直接注射、阳离子脂质、阳离子聚合物。研究非病毒载体的目标是：它能像靶向的合成病毒载体那样对肿瘤组织表现出高度特异性；具有很高的转染效率；潜在的安全性问题能够被控制。     

Optimization of Lipid Composition in Cationic Emulsion as In Vitro and In Vivo Transfection Agents

Purpose. To enhance in vitro and in vivo transfection activity by optimizing lipid composition of cationic lipid emulsions.Methods. Various emulsion formulations having different cationic lipids as emulsifiers, and additional helper lipids as co-emulsifiers, were prepared. The stability of the emulsion and its complex with DNA was investigated by measuring the particle size change in phosphate buffer saline (PBS) over a period of 20 days. The activity of the emulsions in transfecting pCMV-beta into COS-1 cells in the presence or absence of 80% serum was evaluated. We also evaluated in vivo transfection activity using intravenously administered pCMV-Luc+ as a reporter gene.Results. Among the cationic emulsifiers, 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-trimethylammonium-propane (DOTAP) formed the most stable and efficient emulsion gene carrier. Addition of 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (DOPE) increased in vitro transfection activity, but slightly compromised the stability of the emulsion. The loss was compensated for by including small amounts of Tween 80 in the emulsion. The in vitro and in vivo transfection activities were also increased by adding Tween 80. Even though in vitro transfection activity of liposomes was high in the absence of serum, the transfection activity of emulsions was far greater than that of liposomes in the presence of serum and for in vivo applications.Conclusions. By including DOPE as an endosomolytic agent and Tween 80 as a stabilization agent, the cationic emulsion becomes a more potent gene carrier for in vitro and in vivo applications, especially in the presence of serum.     

Design, synthesis, and transfection biology of novel cationic glycolipids for use in liposomal gene delivery.

The molecular structure of the cationic lipids used in gene transfection strongly influences their transfection efficiency. High transfection efficiencies of non-glycerol-based simple monocationic transfection lipids with hydroxyethyl headgroups recently reported by us (Banerjee et al. J. Med. Chem. 1999, 42, 4292-4299) are consistent with the earlier observations that the presence of hydroxyl functionalities in the headgroup region of a cationic lipid contributes favorably in liposomal gene delivery. Using simple sugar molecules as the source of multiple hydroxyl functionalities in the headgroup region of the transfection lipids, we have synthesized four novel simple monocationic transfection lipids, namely, 1-deoxy-1-[dihexadecyl(methyl)ammonio]-D-xylitol (1), 1-deoxy-1-[methyl(ditetradecyl)ammonio]-D-arabinitol (2), 1-deoxy-1-[dihexadecyl(methyl)ammonio]-D-arabinitol (3) and 1-deoxy-1-[methyl(dioctadecyl)ammonio]-D-arabinitol (4), containing hydrophobic aliphatic tails and the hydrophilic arabinosyl or xylose sugar groups linked directly to the positively charged nitrogen atom. Syntheses, chemical characterizations, and the transfection biology of these novel transfection lipids 1-4 are described in this paper. Lipid 1, the xylosyl derivative, showed maximum transfection on COS-1 cells. All the lipids showed transfection with cholesterol as colipid and not with dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine (DOPE). Radioactive quantitation of free and complexed DNA combined with ethidium bromide exclusion measurements suggest that though nearly 70% of the DNA exists as complexed DNA, the DNA may not have condensed as was observed with other cationic lipids. Presence of additional (more than two) hydroxyl functionalities in the headgroup of the cationic lipids appears to have improved the transfection efficiency and made these lipids less cytotoxic compared to two-hydroxyl derivatives.     

The role of the disulfide group in disulfide-based polymeric gene carriers

Background: An essential prerequisite for successful gene therapy is the development of safe and efficient gene delivery carriers. For this purpose, cationic polymers have been widely studied as non-viral carriers, but they generally suffer from low transfection efficiency and/or high cytotoxicity. To address these problems, disulfide-based cationic polymers have been designed as intelligent gene carriers that are capable of inducing highly efficient gene transfection with low cytotoxicity. Objective: The present review discusses the effects of the disulfide linker on the gene delivery properties of cationic polymers in relation to various gene delivery barriers. Methods: The literature regarding the gene delivery barriers encountered by polymeric gene delivery is reviewed and discussed in relation to the presence of the disulfide moiety in these gene carriers. Conclusions: The presence of disulfide linkages in cationic polymers can in many aspects favorably influence the gene delivery properties, such as increasing DNA binding ability, enabling de-shielding of ‘stealth’ (PEG) groups, fine-tuning of the buffer capacity for enhanced endosomal escape, improving carrier-unpacking and decreasing cytotoxicity. Therefore, disulfide-based cationic polymers are promising candidates for the next generation of non-viral carriers.     

Cationic liposome (DC-Chol/DOPE=1:2) and a modified ethanol injection method to prepare liposomes, increased gene expression

Cationic liposomes composed of 3beta-[N-(N',N'-dimethylaminoethane)-carbamoyl] cholesterol (DC-Chol) and dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine (DOPE) (DC-Chol/DOPE liposome, molar ratio, 1:1 or 3:2) prepared by the dry-film method have been often used as non-viral gene delivery vectors. The formulation and preparation of DC-Chol/DOPE liposomes, as well as the formation of their lipoplexes were investigated in an attempt to improve transfection efficiency in vitro. A more efficient transfection in medium with serum was achieved using DC-Chol/DOPE liposomes (molar ratio, 1:2) than those (3:2), and preparation method by a modified ethanol injection than the dry-film. The most efficient DC-Chol/DOPE liposome for gene transfer was molar ratio (1:2) and prepared by a modified ethanol injection method. The enhanced transfection might be related to an increase in the release of DNA in the cytoplasm by the large lipoplex during incubation in optiMEM, not to an increased cellular association with the lipoplex. The use of a modified ethanol injection method might enhance the role of DOPE that is aid in destabilization of the plasma membrane and/or endosome. These findings suggested that cationic liposomes rich in DOPE prepared by a modified ethanol injection method will help to improve the efficacy of liposome vector systems for gene delivery.     

Structure-activity relationship in cationic lipid mediated gene transfection

Non-viral synthetic vectors for gene delivery represent a safer alternative to viral vectors. Their main drawback is the low transfection efficiency, especially in vivo. Among the non-viral vectors currently in use, the cationic liposomes composed of cationic lipids are the most common. This review discusses the physicochemical properties of cationic lipids, the formation, macrostructure and specific parameters of the corresponding formulated liposomes, and the effect of all these parameters on transfection efficiency. The optimisation of liposomal vectors requires both the understanding of the biological variables involved in the transfection process, and the effect of the structural elements of the cationic lipids on these biological variables. The biological barriers relevant for in vitro and in vivo transfection are identified, and solutions to overcome them based on rational design of the cationic lipids are discussed. The review focuses on the relationship between the structure of the cationic lipid and the transfection activity. The structure is analysed in a modular manner. The hydrophobic domain, the cationic head group, the backbone that acts as a scaffold for the other domains, the linkers between backbone, hydrophobic domain and cationic head group, the polyethyleneglycol chains and the targeting moiety are identified as distinct elements of the cationic lipids used in gene therapy. The main chemical functionalities used to built these domains, as well as overall molecular features such as architecture and geometry, are presented. Studies of structure-activity relationships of each cationic lipid domain, including the authors', and the trends identified by these studies, help furthering the understanding of the mechanism governing the formation and behaviour of cationic liposomes in gene delivery, and therefore the rational design of new improved cationic lipids vectors capable of achieving clinical significance.     

The features and shortcomings for gene delivery of current non-viral carriers

Since the viral vector for gene therapy has serious problems, including oncogenesity and other adverse effects, non-viral carriers have attracted a great deal of attention. Non-viral carriers are expected to achieve gene therapy without serious side effects. However, the most critical issue of gene delivery by non-viral carriers is the low-expression efficiencies of the desired gene. In order to apply non-viral carriers for gene therapy in practical clinical usage, further understanding of the cellular barriers against gene delivery is a prerequisite. Moreover, additional intelligent concepts for gene delivery are also needed. We will summarize the features and shortcomings of currently developed non-viral delivery systems. Especially, we will address the current progress of cationic lipids (lipoplex) and cationic polymers (polyplex) in terms of transfection efficiency. Furthermore, our group has developed a system that responds to the particular intracellular signals of target disease cells. We have named this gene delivery system a drug delivery system based on responses cellular signal (D-RECS). We will introduce this new concept of intelligent non-viral delivery system that our group recently developed.     

Galactosylated DNA lipid nanocapsules for efficient hepatocyte targeting

The main objective of gene therapy via a systemic pathway is the development of a stable and non-toxic gene vector that can encapsulate and deliver foreign genetic materials into specific cell types with the transfection efficiency of viral vectors. With this objective, DNA complexed with cationic lipids of DOTAP/DOPE was encapsulated into lipid nanocapsules (LNCs) forming nanocarriers (DNA LNCs) with a size suitable for systemic injection (109 ± 6 nm). With the goal of increasing systemic delivery, LNCs were stabilised with long chains of poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG), either from a PEG lipid derivative (DSPE-mPEG₂₀₀₀) or from an amphiphilic block copolymer (F108). In order to overcome internalisation difficulties encountered with PEG shield, a specific ligand (galactose) was covalently added at the distal end of the PEG chains, in order to provide active targeting of the asialoglycoprotein-receptor present on hepatocytes. This study showed that DNA LNCs were as efficient as positively charged DOTAP/DOPE lipoplexes for transfection. In primary hepatocytes, when non-galactosylated, the two polymers significantly decreased the transfection, probably by creating a barrier around the DNA LNCs. Interestingly, galactosylated F108 coated DNA LNCs led to a 18-fold increase in luciferase expression compared to non-galactosylated ones.     

阳离子脂质在基因传递中构效关系的研究进展

阳离子脂质是非病毒载体中应用最为广泛的一种基因传递载体,其结构中的4个部分各自发挥着重要作用。构效关系研究表明,阳离子脂质的疏水基团、骨架链、连接键以及阳离子头基等结构的微小变化均会不同程度的影响阳离子脂质的细胞毒性、基因结合能力以及转染效率。本文综述了近几年有关阳离子脂质的文献,介绍了阳离子脂质各部分结构组成,归纳了阳离子脂质构效关系研究中的各种作用规律,希望为未来新型阳离子脂质的合成开发及应用提供参考。     

Modifications in the head group and in the spacer of cholesterol-based cationic lipids promote transfection in melanoma B16-F10 cells and tumours

A series of four cationic lipids derived from cholesterol was synthesised and their efficiencies to vectorise nucleic acids were compared. The investigation concerns the effects of systematic chemical modifications in the polar head and in the spacer. The cationic lipid molecules used are in the same family of 3beta[N-(N',N',N'-trimethylaminoethane)-carbamoyl] cholesterol iodide (TMAEC-Chol), presenting a spacer of two or three carbons and a quaternary ammonium polar head ramified with methyl or ethyl groups. These lipids formed stable liposomes sizing from 100 to 200 nm when prepared with the colipid dioleoyl phosphatidylethanolamine (DOPE). The goal of this work was to investigate the effect of the chemical structure of these cationic lipids on lipofection. Their ability to form complexes with DNA, their cytotoxicity and their transfection efficiency in vitro and in vivo were studied. Results were compared with those obtained from the well known cholesterol-based cationic lipid DC-Chol. In a melanoma cell line (B16-F10), results showed that either the polar head or the spacer affected the cytotoxicity. Cationic lipids with three ethyl groups in the head are more toxic than those with three methyl groups while cationic lipids with three carbons in the spacer are less toxic than those with two carbons in the spacer. The best transfection level was obtained in vitro and in vivo with cationic lipids having 3C in the spacer. Data indicated that among these lipids, in vivo gene transfer is advantaged by the methylated polar head while in vitro the best level was obtained with the ethylated one. Finally, it was observed that the chemical structure influences the transfection in the presence of serum while the complex charge and the DOPE ratios in liposomes preferentially affect the interaction with erythrocytes. Argumentations are proposed to explain the discrepancies between in vitro and in vivo transfection results concerning the optimal charge ratio and the chemical nature of the cationic lipid head group.     

Tris(2-aminoethyl)amine-based α-branched fatty acid amides – Synthesis of lipids and comparative study of transfection efficiency of their lipid formulations

The synthesis of a new class of cationic lipids, tris(2-aminoethyl)amine-based α-branched fatty acid amides, is described resulting in a series of lipids with specific variations in the lipophilic as well as the hydrophilic part of the lipids. In-vitro structure/transfection relationships were established by application of complexes of these lipids with plasmid DNA (pDNA) to different cell lines. The α-branched fatty acid amide bearing two tetradecyl chains and two lysine molecules (T14diLys) in mixture with the co-lipid 1,2-di-[(9Z)-octadec-9-enoyl]-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (DOPE) (1/2, n/n) exhibits effective pDNA transfer in three different cell lines, namely Hep-G2, A549, and COS-7. The presence of 10% serum during lipoplex incubation of the cells did not affect the transfection efficiency. Based on that, detailed investigations of the complexation of pDNA with the lipid formulation T14diLys/DOPE 1/2 (n/n) were carried out with respect to particle size and charge using dynamic light scattering (DLS), ζ-potential measurements, and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Additionally, the lipoplex uptake was investigated by confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM). Overall, lipoplexes prepared from T14diLys/DOPE 1/2 (n/n) offer large potential as lipid-based polynucleotide carriers and further justify advanced examinations.     

Asymmetric 1-alkyl-2-acyl phosphatidylcholine: a helper lipid for enhanced non-viral gene delivery

Rationally designed asymmetrical alkylacyl phosphatidylcholines (APC) have been synthesized and evaluated as helper lipids for non-viral gene delivery. A long aliphatic chain (C22-C24) was introduced at the 1-position of glycerol backbone, a branched lipid chain (C18) at the 2-position, and a phosphocholine head group at the 3-position. The fusogenicity of APC depends on the length and degree of saturation of the alkyl chain. Cationic lipids were formulated with APC as either lipoplexes or nanolipoparticles, and evaluated for their stability, transfection efficiency, and cytotoxicity. APC mediated high in vitro transfection efficiency, and had low cytotoxicity. Small nanolipoparticles (less than 100 nm) can be obtained with APC by applying as low as 0.1% PEG-lipid. Our study extends the type of helper lipids that are suitable for gene transfer and points the way to improve non-viral nucleic acid delivery system other than the traditional cationic lipids optimization.     

Cationic lipids as gene transfer agents: a patent review

Background: Cationic lipids have been among the more efficient synthetic gene delivery reagents in vitro. They condense nucleic acids into cationic particles when the components are mixed together. Since the first studies were conducted, hundreds of cationic lipids have been synthesized as candidates for non-viral gene delivery and a few entered clinical trials. Objective: This paper reviews the lipid structure of cationic lipids, their structure–activity relationship, toxicity and transfection efficacy. A revision of the more recent patents is also included. Methods: Bibliographic research was carried out using the PubMed database. Patent literature was searched using the Derwent Innovations Index^SM. Results/conclusions: There is a wide range of scientific literature and patents about new cationic lipids and at present many research groups focus their investigation on the development of new molecules. Advances in the development of new technologies to better understand the in vitro and in vivo behavior of the lipoplexes will help to redesign new cationic lipids. The results obtained in clinical trials confirm gene therapy as a very promising therapeutic tool in the future.     

Gene transfer efficacies of serum-resistant amino acids-based cationic lipids: dependence on headgroup, lipoplex stability and cellular uptake

Serum is a major obstacle to efficient cationic liposome-mediated gene transfection. In this paper, three alkaline amino acids based cationic lipids including lysinylated cholesterol (lipid 1), histidinylated cholesterol (lipid 2) and argininylated cholesterol (lipid 3) were used as non-viral gene vectors. The physicochemical properties such as size, Zeta potential, stability and cellular uptake of the lipoplexes formed from lipids 1-3 as well as the transfection efficacies with or without serum were investigated. The results demonstrated that lipid 1 and lipid 3 showed good properties in lipoplex stability and cellular uptake. Interestingly, lipid 3-based liposome showed serum-enhanced effect on the gene transfection. The transfection efficiency of lipid 1 and lipid 3 was remarkably higher than that of lipid 2. Moreover, they exhibited 10-20-fold more efficaciously than the control, 1,2-dioleoyloxy-3-(trimethylammonio)-propane (DOTAP) liposome in serum-containing media. The data suggested the strong effect of the type of the headgroup on gene transfection. The lysine/arginine derivative cationic lipids could be promising nonviral vectors for gene delivery in vivo.     

Evaluation of improved PAMAM-G5 conjugates for gene delivery targeted to the transferrin receptor

The transfection activity of non-viral vectors is highly dependent on the delivery capacity of the carriers. Therefore, the aim of this work was to evaluate the activity of a new PAMAM dendrimer-Transferrin conjugate (P-Tf) with improved gene delivery activity to cancer cells. The formulations containing the novel P-Tf were able to bind pDNA and protect it from the activity of DNAse I enzyme. Moreover, it formed nanoparticles with positive surface charge, although the presence of Tf led to a decrease of the zeta potential to almost electroneutral values. This new vector, formulated at N/P 6, exhibited excellent transfection efficacy in HeLa, HepG2 and CT26 cell lines, whereas in Neuro2A no improvement was achieved. Compared to control complexes with branched polyethylenimine (bPEI), targeted dendriplexes (complexes formed by cationic polymeric dendrimers and DNA) were more efficient in HepG2 and HeLa cells. Cellular viability was always kept over 80% in these cell lines with higher values than bPEI control polyplexes. The uptake via receptor-mediated endocytosis was ensured by a competition assay, by adding an excess of free Tf, which led to a decrease in the transfection activity of targeted dendriplexes.     

阳离子脂质体用做基因传递载体的研究进展

 基因治疗的难题之一在于研制安全有效的基因传递载体。常用的基因传递载体分为病毒载体和非病毒载体两类,其中,非病毒载体中的阳离子脂质体因具有低毒性与免疫原性、生物相容性好、易于制备等优点而受到广泛关注,具有良好的应用前景。近年来对阳离子脂质体载体的研究主要集中在对其传递基因机制的考察、各种影响其转基因效率的因素的探求、应用各种方法研制安全性和转染活性更佳的新型阳离子脂质体等方面。文中从转基因特点、传递机制、常用的制备材料、影响转基因效率的因素、近年来出现的新型阳离子脂质体等方面综述了此类基因传递载体的研究进展。