Variability of Stickler syndrome

Stickler syndrome is a dominantly inherited disorder characterized by ocular and nonocular manifestations. The phenotype of the affected patients is known to be variable. Our study of 3 families and a review of the literature show that the variability is mostly interfamilial while in each family less variability is present. In one family all the patients had high myopia and most developed a retinal detachment at a young age. In the second family the major symptoms were cleft palate and characteristic facial changes in presence of mild ocular changes. In the third family, all patients had a marfanoid habitus, high myopia, and mental retardation. Interfamilial variability coupled with intrafamilial similarities in clinical manifestation may indicate that the so-called Stickler syndrome represents in fact a phenotype and not a single genetic entity.     

Mosaicism in Stickler syndrome

Stickler syndrome is a heterogeneous condition due to mutations in COL2A1, COL11A1, COL11A2, and COL9A1. To our knowledge, neither non-penetrance nor mosaicism for COL2A1 mutations has been reported for Stickler syndrome. We report on a family with two clinically affected sibs with Stickler syndrome who have clinically unaffected parents. Both sibs have a novel heterozygous mutation in exon 26 of COL2A1 (c.1525delT); this results in a premature termination codon downstream of the mutation site. One parent was found to have low level mosaicism in DNA extracted from whole blood. This scenario encourages consideration of molecular testing in seemingly unaffected parents for recurrence risks and potential screening for mild age-related manifestations.     

Marshall/Stickler syndrome

A family originally reported as a variant of Marshall syndrome is re-examined. The clinical picture now encompasses both the Marshall and Stickler syndromes and it is suggested that the distinction between the two should be abandoned.     

Genetic and clinical heterogeneity of Stickler syndrome.

We have studied 6 multigeneration Stickler syndrome families. Manifestations of the syndrome in the families included myopia, deafness, arthritis, characteristic facial changes with "flat" midface and cleft palate, although not all these were present in all families. COL2A1 has been implicated as a gene which can give rise to Stickler syndrome based on evidence from 2 large families which each showed significant linkage between the disease locus and restriction fragment length polymorphisms for the gene (Francomano CA, Lieberfarb RM, Hirose T, Maumenee IH, Streeten EA, Meyers DA, Pyeritz RE (1987): Genomics 1:293-296; Knowlton RG, Weaver EJ, Struyk AF, Knobloch WH, King RA, Norris K, Shamban A, Uitoo J, Jimenez SA, Prockop DJ (1989): Am J Hum Genet 45:681-688). We have found crossovers between the disease locus and COL2A1 in 2 families with Stickler syndrome. This could be explained by either genetic heterogeneity or the actual mutation being in a closely linked, currently unrecognized gene. We found a weakly positive overall lod score (z = 0.96 at theta = 0.10) suggesting that genetic heterogeneity is a more likely explanation. In one family, with typical findings, a translocation t5;17 (q15:q23) was found to segregate with the disease in 4 affected relatives. In view of the possible heterogeneity, although no crossovers with COL2A1 were seen in this family, either of these breakpoints could be the position of a further disease causing gene.     

Clinical and molecular genetics of Stickler syndrome

Stickler syndrome is an autosomal dominant disorder with characteristic ophthalmological and orofacial features, deafness, and arthritis. Abnormalities of vitreous gel architecture are a pathognomonic feature, usually associated with high myopia which is congenital and non-progressive. There is a substantial risk of retinal detachment. Less common ophthalmological features include paravascular pigmented lattice degeneration and cataracts. Non-ocular features show great variation in expression. Children with Stickler syndrome typically have a flat midface with depressed nasal bridge, short nose, anteverted nares, and micrognathia. These features can become less pronounced with age. Midline clefting, if present, ranges in severity from a cleft of the soft palate to Pierre-Robin sequence. There is joint hypermobility which declines with age. Osteoarthritis develops typically in the third or fourth decade. Mild spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia is often apparent radiologically. Sensorineural deafness with high tone loss may be asymptomatic or mild. Occasional findings include slender extremities and long fingers. Stature and intellect are usually normal. Mitral valve prolapse was reported to be a common finding in one series but not in our experience. The majority of families with Stickler syndrome have mutations in the COL2A1 gene and show the characteristic type 1 vitreous phenotype. The remainder with the type 2 vitreous phenotype have mutations in COL11A1 or other loci yet to be identified. Mutations in COL111A2 can give rise to a syndrome with the systemic features of Stickler syndrome but no ophthalmological abnormality.     

Genetic and clinical heterogeneity of Stickler syndrome

We have studied 6 multigeneration Stickler syndrome families. Manifestations of the syndrome in the families included myopia, deafness, arthritis, characteristic facial changes with “flat” midface and cleft palate, although not all these were present in all families. COL2A1 has been implicated as a gene which can give rise to Stickler syndrome based on evidence from 2 large families which each showed significant linkage between the disease locus and restriction fragment length polymorphisms for the gene (Francomano CA, Lieberfarb RM, Hirose T, Maumenee IH, Streeten EA, Meyers DA, Pyeritz RE (1987): Genomics 1:293–296; Knowlton RG, Weaver EJ, Struyk AF, Knobloch WH, King RA, Norris K, Shamban A, Uitoo J, Jimenez SA, Prockop DJ (1989): Am J Hum Genet 45:681–688). We have found crossovers between the disease locus and COL2A1 in 2 families with Stickler syndrome. This could be explained by either genetic heterogeneity or the actual mutation being in a closely linked, currently unrecognized gene. We found a weakly positive overall lod score (z = 0.96 at θ = 0.10) suggesting that genetic heterogeneity is a more likely explanation. In one family, with typical findings, a translocation t5;17 (q15:q23) was found to segregate with the disease in 4 affected relatives. In view of the possible heterogeneity, although no crossovers with COL2A1 were seen in this family, either of these breakpoints could be the position of a further disease causing gene.     

The Stickler syndrome (Hereditary arthro-ophthalmopathy)

Three patients with Stickler syndrome are reported. Two of the patients were found among the 26 children attending a special pre-school for the visually impaired. One of the patients had bilateral choanal atresia which may represent an extreme example of the mid-facial hypoplasia commonly seen in these patients. It appears that Stickler syndrome may not be as rare as previously thought.     

Prevalence of mitral valve prolapse in Stickler syndrome

A single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) in chromosome Y has been associated with blood pressure. In men, the risk of suffering from cardiovascular diseases, including coronary artery disease, could be influenced by one or more loci on chromosome Y. We genotyped 208 men who had suffered an early episode of myocardial infarction (MI) (< or =55 years) and 178 healthy control men for two Y-polymorphisms (a HindIII polymorphism in an alphoid satellite in the centromeric non-recombining region and the -2627 T/C in the SRY gene). Frequencies were compared through a chi(2)-test. Frequencies for the two polymorphisms did not differ between patients and controls. The alphoid-HindIII polymorphism was not related to blood pressures in our population (HindIII+: diastolic, 80 +/- 2; systolic, 129 +/- 5. HindIII-: diastolic, 80 +/- 2; systolic, 128 +/- 3). Seventy-six patients (37%) were hypertensives and had a significantly higher frequency of the HindIII+ allele compared to the normotensive patients (46 and 26%, respectively; P = 0.028). According to our data, the alphoid-HindIII polymorphism in chromosome Y was not associated with differences in blood pressure in men from Asturias (Northern Spain). However, the HindIII+ allele increased the risk of suffering an early episode of MI among hypertensives.     

Prevalence of mitral-valve prolapse in the Stickler syndrome

An increased prevalence of mitral-valve prolapse occurs in several connective tissue dysplasias, including Marfan syndrome, Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, and pseudoxanthoma elasticum. We evaluated 57 patients diagnosed as having the Stickler syndrome for mitral-valve prolapse by auscultation and two-dimensional echocardiography. The diagnosis was made on the basis of craniofacial and musculoskeletal abnormalities, sensorineural hearing loss, eye defects, and a family history of Stickler syndrome. Twenty-six patients (45.6%) had mitral-valve prolapse, including 11 of 22 females (50.0%) and 15 of 35 males (42.9%). The age range of our study population was 4 to 60 years. Prevalence of mitral-valve prolapse did not increase with age. Nine patients (34.6% of those with mitral-valve prolapse) had the click-murmur syndrome; only one of them was symptomatic. Because of the growing list of complications associated with mitral-valve prolapse, all patients with Stickler syndrome should be evaluated by auscultation, electrocardiogram, and echocardiography. Those with mitral-valve prolapse should be advised to have periodic follow-up and to instruct physicians caring for them of their need for antibiotic prophylaxis with certain surgical procedures.     

Stickler syndrome: clinical characteristics and diagnostic criteria

The purpose of this study was to establish diagnostic criteria for Stickler syndrome. Ninety patients from 38 families had complete evaluations for possible Stickler syndrome. Molecular confirmation of COL2A1 mutation status (type I Stickler syndrome) was available on 25 patients from six families. In the remaining 65 patients, 47 from 25 families were affected with Stickler syndrome and 18 from seven families were unaffected with Stickler syndrome. A diagnostic nosology based on type I Stickler patients with known COL2A1 mutations was applied to clinically affected and unaffected patients. A diagnostic scale of 9 points evaluated molecular data or family history data and characteristic ocular, orofacial, auditory, and musculoskeletal findings. A score of > or =5 was diagnostic of Stickler syndrome. These criteria demonstrate 100% sensitivity when applied to type I Stickler syndrome patients with known COL2A1 mutations, 98% sensitivity when applied to clinically affected Stickler patients, and 86% specificity when applied to patients unaffected based on clinical and/or molecular analysis. We conclude that diagnostic criteria based on type I Stickler patients with molecularly confirmed COL2A1 mutations appear to be sensitive and specific for the diagnosis of this syndrome and should be helpful to clinicians when making the diagnosis.     

The Stickler syndrome presenting as a dominantly inherited cleft palate and blindness.

The Stickler syndrome is a newly recognized, but probably relatively frequent inherited generalized connective tissue disorder involving skeleton, eye, and oro-facial structures. A family with three affected generations is discussed. Severe myopia leading to blindness, cleft palate, or subnucous cleft, Pierre Robin anomaly, premature degenerative arthritis, or a family history of any of these indicates further evaluation.     

PCR assay confirms diagnosis in syndrome with variably expressed phenotype: mutation detection in Stickler syndrome.

Stickler syndrome is an autosomal dominant disease with ocular (severe myopia, vitreal degeneration, and retinal detachment) and other systemic manifestations (hearing loss, cleft palate, epiphyseal dysplasia, and premature osteoarthritis). As with other dominantly inherited conditions, the clinical phenotype of Stickler syndrome varies considerably. To date, all mutations have been located in the type II procollagen (COL2A1) gene. Analysis of a C-->T mutation we had identified previously, in COL2A1 gene in exon 40, in a three generation pedigree showed the loss of a cleavage site for the TaqI restriction enzyme. We designed a rapid PCR based restriction enzyme assay to detect this mutation and used it to establish the diagnosis in a neonate from the same pedigree, presenting with the first occurrence of the Pierre-Robin sequence in the family and minimal ocular findings. These results underline the potential diagnostic value of many as yet undetected DNA mutations in families affected with Stickler syndrome, since the variability of the phenotype can impede accurate diagnosis, appropriate genetic counselling, and effective intervention and prophylactic treatment for affected people.     

Correlation of linkage data with phenotype in eight families with Stickler syndrome

The clinical findings of eight families with Stickler syndrome were analyzed and compared with the results of linkage studies using a marker for the type II collagen gene (COL2A1). In six families, there was linkage of the phenotype to COL2A1. The manifestations of the affected individuals were similar to those of the original Stickler syndrome family [Stickler et al., Mayo. Clin. Proc. 40:433–455, 1965] and resembled the phenotype of the previously reported individuals or families with Stickler syndrome in which a dominant mutation in the COL2A1 gene has been identified. Linkage to COL2A1 was excluded in the two remaining families. The most striking difference between these two types of families was the absence of severe myopia and retinal detachment in the two unliked families. In the COL2A1 unlinked families, linkage of the phenotype to genes (COL11A1 and COL11A2) that encode proα chains of type XI collagen, a minor cartilage-specific collagen, was also excluded. Since Stickler syndrome can be produced by mutations in COL2A1, COL11A1, and COL11A2, our data suggest that there is at least a fourth locus for Stickler syndrome. Am. J. Med. Genet. 80:121–127, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

LOXL3 novel mutation causing a rare form of autosomal recessive Stickler syndrome

Stickler syndrome is a collagenopathy that is typically inherited as autosomal dominant disease caused by monoallelic mutations in COL2A1, COL11A2, and COL11A1. Rarely, biallelic mutations in COL9A1, COL9A2, and COL9A3 cause an autosomal recessive Stickler syndrome. One previous report described two siblings with Stickler syndrome and a homozygous mutation in LOXL3, suggesting that biallelic mutations in LOXL3 can also cause autosomal recessive Stickler syndrome. LOXL3 is a member of the lysyl oxidase family of genes which encode enzymes oxidizing the side chain of peptidyl lysine permitting the covalent crosslinking of collagen and elastin chains. Therefore, LOXL3 deficiency is expected to result in collagen defect. Furthermore, Loxl3 deficient mouse model demonstrated features overlapping with Stickler syndrome. In this report, we describe a child and his father who had clinical features consistent with Stickler syndrome and found to have a homozygous novel mutation c.1036C>T (p.Arg346Trp) in LOXL3. This report not only supports that biallelic LOXL3 mutations cause autosomal recessive Stickler syndrome, but also further delineates the phenotype associated with LOXL3 mutations. In addition, the family described here shows an interesting example for pseudodominance, which can be observed in recessive diseases when one parent is affected and the other is heterozygous carrier.     

A mild form of Stickler syndrome type II caused by mosaicism of COL11A1

Stickler syndrome, a clinically as well as molecularly heterogeneous connective tissue disorder, is predominantly inherited in an autosomal dominant manner and is considered complete penetrant. Previously, mosaicism in Stickler syndrome has been reported in only a few cases. We describe a child with Stickler syndrome due to a novel splice site mutation in COL11A1. Initially, Sanger sequencing of both parents showed normal test results for the mutation. Due to mild phenotypic traits, the father was tested again using a more sensitive method (NGS), and was found to have low-grade mosaicism in various tissue samples (range 7–22% of the DNA). Therefore, we recommend using sensitive genetic testing when mosaicism is suspected. Furthermore, we support previous suggestions of parental testing even when the parents of an affected patient do not have obvious phenotypic signs of Stickler syndrome.