Critical clinical appraisal of the role of ultrasound guided fine needle aspiration cytology in the management of parotid tumours

OBJECTIVE: Fine needle aspiration cytology is a well established tool for investigating many head and neck conditions. Its application in parotid tumours is, however, controversial. This article is aimed at defining the role of ultrasound guided fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) in the diagnostic work up of parotid tumours. The accuracy and utility of FNAC of parotid tumours was also assessed. DESIGN: Retrospective case note review. SETTING: District general hospital. PARTICIPANTS: Review of 69 patient records who had parotid surgery under one surgeon's care (JS). Clinical opinion, FNAC results and final pathology findings were examined. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The results of the FNAC were compared to the histopathological diagnosis obtained from the surgical specimen. RESULTS: Histological evaluation revealed 13 malignant tumours and 56 benign lesions. The overall sensitivity of FNAC was 84.6 per cent and specificity was 96.4 per cent. We noted 11 true positive, 54 true negative, two false negative and two false positive results. Positive predictive value for diagnosing malignancy was 84.6 per cent and negative predictive value for malignancy was 96.4 per cent. The overall accuracy of FNAC of parotids in this study was 94.2 per cent. CONCLUSIONS: FNAC results provide useful preoperative information. FNAC enables more reliable patient counselling and reduces pathological surprises. Pre-operative recognition of malignant tumours may help prepare both the surgeon and patient for an appropriate surgical procedure. Its enhancement of the pre-operative recognition of malignant parotid tumours may alert more stringent attention to the operative margin and hence better tumour clearance. Ultrasound guided FNAC was found to be highly specific for malignancy and its sensitivity for malignancy was good.     

A study of salivary gland aspiration cytology reporting: guideline validity

We retrospectively reviewed 44 cases of major salivary gland lesions surgically resected following preoperative fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC). Our objective was to determine the validity of the salivary gland FNAC reporting proposed in 2004 by the Japanese Society of Clinical Cytology. Of the 44 lesions, 33 were in the parotid gland and 11 in the submandibular gland. Of these, 8 lesions were malignant. Two from benign lesions could not be satisfactorily evaluated, and 4 from benign lesions and 1 from a malignant lesion were indeterminate. Results were 3 true positive, 30 true negative, and 4 false negative, with no false positive results. Calculated sensitivity was 42.9% (4/7), specificity 100% (30/ 30), and accuracy 89.2% (34/37). We concluded that using the new reporting decreases ambiguity in clinicians' interpretation of cytology reports, thus benefitting subjects.     

Peroral fine needle aspiration cytology of parapharyngeal tumors: a study of 67 cases

Peroral fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) was carried out to diagnose parapharyngeal tumors in 67 patients from January 2000 to January 2008. The inflammatory lesions were excluded in the present study. The age of patients ranged from 6 years to 72 years. Analysis of results showed 35 benign tumors and 32 malignant neoplasms. Correlation with histopathology showed a diagnostic accuracy of 92.5% with no false positive report. No complication was encountered in the present study. FNAC can replace incisional biopsy which may be hazardous in this area. Immediate treatment can be planned based on the FNAC report. Such a large series of parapharyngeal tumors diagnosed by FNAC has hardly been reported in India.     

The value of fine-needle aspiration cytology in the evaluation of pediatric head and neck tumors

Objective

To study the efficacy of fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) of head and neck masses in pediatric patients.

Study design

Of the 128 cases studied, FNAC was performed in 74 patients and their cyto-histological correlation done. Sensitivity and specificity of cytological diagnosis was then computed.

Results

Benign lesions were found to be more common than the malignant variety, the commonest being soft tissue tumors (46.87%). Lymphomas were the commonest tumors (22.6%) in the malignant category. Cytology was done in 74 patients of whom smears from 21 patients were unsatisfactory for diagnosis. There was one false positive and two false negative cases resulting in the specificity and sensitivity of FNAC in pediatric head and neck tumors to be 95.65% and 93.3% respectively.

Conclusion

FNAC is a useful and reliable tool in the diagnosis of head and neck masses with no contraindications and minimal complications even in children.     

Value of of fine-needle aspiration cytology and MRI in parotid gland masses

INTRODUCTION: The objective of our study was to discuss the valve of fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in the diagnosis and treatment of parotid gland masses. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Forty patients were included in the prospective study. They had undergone clinical examination, FNAC and MRI before parotidectomy. The results of these examinations were compared with the corresponding histopathological diagnosis. RESULTS: When it is positive, FNAC is a good examination of malignant tumours (sensitivity 67%, specificity 79%, positive predictive value 86%, negative predictive value 100%). The MRI allows a good assessment of the tumoural mass and its anatomical relationships (sensitivity 55%, specificity 86%, positive predictive value 89%, negative predictive value 75%). If the T2 sequence shows reduced density (p < 0.05) or in case of bad limitation (p = 0.004), a malignant character is strongly suspected. CONCLUSION: In cases of parotid gland mass, where surgical intervention is necessary, there is no need of special investigations: however FNAC and MRI allow us to anticipate what operation will be required.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology for parotid neoplasms: risk of malignancy through inconclusive results and lower grade tumors

European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology - Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is a commonly performed procedure for parotid masses, although its accuracy in detecting malignancies widely...     

The role of fine-needle aspiration cytology and magnetic resonance imaging in the management of parotid mass lesions

Conclusion. Fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is the diagnostic modality of first choice for characterization of parotid mass lesions, while magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) should not be requested routinely. MRI can be reserved until FNAC shows the indication for surgical intervention. Objectives. Although both FNAC and MRI are useful preoperative diagnostic modalities for parotid mass lesions, it is not well established which modality is more effective. In the present study we sought to address the relative value of FNAC and MRI in relation to the differential diagnosis of benign and malignant parotid mass lesions. Subjects and methods. Eighty-one patients with parotid mass lesions (60 benign and 21 malignant) who had preoperatively undergone FNAC and MRI were reviewed retrospectively. Results. Unsharp margin and infiltration into adjacent tissues on MRI significantly correlated with a malignant histology. The sensitivity/specificity/accuracy of FNAC and MRI were 90%/95%/94% and 81%/92%/89%, respectively. Either FNAC or MRI served equally to predict the malignant nature of parotid mass lesions. Furthermore, the combination of FNAC and MRI yielded no diagnostic advantage over either modality alone. Accurate histological typing rates by FNAC were 80% and 62% for benign and malignant lesions, respectively.     

Is fine needle aspiration biopsy reliable in the diagnosis of parotid tumors? Comparison of preoperative and postoperative results and the factors affecting accuracy

IntroductionFine needle aspiration biopsy is a valuable tool in preoperative evaluation of head and neck tumors. However, its accuracy in management of salivary gland tumors is debatable.ObjectiveWe aimed to investigate the efficacy and the accuracy of fine needle aspiration biopsy in parotid gland tumors.MethodsPatients who underwent parotidectomy between January 2008 and June 2017 due to parotid gland tumor were examined retrospectively. Patients with both preoperative fine needle aspiration biopsy and postoperative surgical pathologies were included. Preoperative fine needle aspiration biopsy was categorized as benign, malignant or suspicious for malignancy. Surgical pathology was grouped as benign or malignant. Surgical pathology was compared with fine needle aspiration biopsy, and sensitivity, specificity, accuracy and agreement between both tests were investigated.Results217 cases were evaluated and 23 cases were excluded because the fine needle aspiration biopsy diagnosis was non-diagnostic or unavailable. 194 cases were included. The mean age of the patients was 47.5 ± 15.88 (7–82). There were 157 benign, 37 malignant cases in fine needle aspiration biopsy, 165 benign and 29 malignant cases in surgical pathology. The most common benign tumor was pleomorphic adenoma (43.3%), and malignant tumor was mucoepidermoid carcinoma (4.13%). The diagnostic accuracy for fine needle aspiration biopsy when detecting malignancy was 86.52%. Sensitivity and specificity were 68.96% and 89.63% respectively. Positive predictive value was 54.05% and negative predictive value was 94.23%. There was moderate agreement between fine needle aspiration biopsy and surgical pathology (κ = 0.52). The sensitivity was 54.54% in tumors less than 2 cm while 77.77% in larger tumors. In tumors extending to the deep lobe, sensitivity was 80%.ConclusionFine needle aspiration biopsy is an important diagnostic tool for evaluating parotid gland tumors. It is more accurate in detecting benign tumors. In tumors greater than 2 cm and extending to the deep lobe, the sensitivity of fine needle aspiration biopsy is high. The use of fine needle aspiration biopsy in conjunction with clinical and radiological evaluation may help to reduce false positive and false negative results.     

The role of fine-needle aspiration cytology and magnetic resonance imaging in the management of parotid mass lesions

Conclusion. Fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is the diagnostic modality of first choice for characterization of parotid mass lesions, while magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) should not be requested routinely. MRI can be reserved until FNAC shows the indication for surgical intervention. Objectives. Although both FNAC and MRI are useful preoperative diagnostic modalities for parotid mass lesions, it is not well established which modality is more effective. In the present study we sought to address the relative value of FNAC and MRI in relation to the differential diagnosis of benign and malignant parotid mass lesions. Subjects and methods. Eighty-one patients with parotid mass lesions (60 benign and 21 malignant) who had preoperatively undergone FNAC and MRI were reviewed retrospectively. Results. Unsharp margin and infiltration into adjacent tissues on MRI significantly correlated with a malignant histology. The sensitivity/specificity/accuracy of FNAC and MRI were 90%/95%/94% and 81%/92%/89%, respectively. Either FNAC or MRI served equally to predict the malignant nature of parotid mass lesions. Furthermore, the combination of FNAC and MRI yielded no diagnostic advantage over either modality alone. Accurate histological typing rates by FNAC were 80% and 62% for benign and malignant lesions, respectively.     

Diagnostic value of needle biopsy and frozen section histological examination in the surgery of primary parotid tumors

The necessity of fine-needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB) in the diagnosis and treatment of parotid gland lesions is still controversial. We examined the accuracy of cytology and histology in a review of 128 parotid gland tumors who underwent surgery with FNAB, n = 102 and/or frozen section examination (FS), n = 94. The diagnostic sensibility and specificity for malignant or benign lesions was respectively 81.5% and 97.5% for FNAB and 75% and 100% for FS as compared with definite histology (110 tumors were benign and 18 malignant). Insufficient material for FNAB evaluation was found in 12 patients mainly with small tumors (p = 0.043) or with tumors located in the deep process of the parotid gland (p = 0.029). Surgery was inappropriate (superficial lobe resection for malignant tumor) because of 4 false negative FS diagnoses. FNAB offers valuable information in the diagnosis of nonsurgical lesions and permits to avoid FS if FNAB identify a benign lesion. FS remains mandatory if FNAB evaluation is not possible or suggests a neoplastic tumor.     

Precisión diagnóstica de la citología por punción aspiración con aguja fina en tumores de la glándula parótida

Introduction and objectivesFine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is a globally accepted technique in the preoperative evaluations of head and neck tumours; however, the effectiveness in the interpretation of salivary glands neoplastic lesions is still controversial. The objective of this study consisted of assessing the efficacy of FNAC in preoperative diagnosis of parotid tumours.MethodsThis retrospective study was conducted using 93 patient samples with parotid gland tumoral pathology, treated at the Otorhinolaryngology Department in our institution during the 2007-2011 period. Preoperative FNAC was employed and the patients subsequently submitted to surgical excision with histopathological diagnosis of the specimen. Cytology results were classified as negative for malignancy, positive for malignancy or insufficient sample, and later compared with the definitive histological diagnosis.ResultsThe mean age of the studied sample was 52.9 years (range: 11 to 88 years); 55.9% were men. The FNAC showed significant sensitivity of 57.1%, with a specificity of 95.1%, for detecting malignancy in parotid gland tumours. The positive and negative predictive values for malignancy were 50 and 96.3%, respectively.ConclusionsFNAC is considered a simple test but of limited use for diagnostic guidance in tumour pathology of the parotid gland in our environment, mainly because of its low sensitivity. However, the high specificity and high negative predictive value of FNAC makes it a more accurate test in benign or negative result cases.     

Gutartige Tumoren der Glandula parotidea

Background

Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) is a widely used diagnostic tool to evaluate neoplastic or inflammatory tumorous lesions of the salivary glands. This method influences the selection of the modality of surgical treatment. In cases of benign tumors of the parotid gland, a (partial) superficial parotidectomy is usually recommended. However, for tumors other than pleomorphic adenomas (such as cystadenolymphomas, other adenomas, or benign tumor-like lesions) this operation is considered an overtreatment because extracapsular satellites are rare and recurrences in case of a capsular lesion are not likely. In such cases, a less extended surgery (enucleation) with lower morbidity is sufficient and can be carried out provided that pleomorphic adenomas and non-pleomorphic benign lesions are reliably differentiated prior to surgery. The aim of this study was to evaluate the reliability of the FNAC in differentiating benign tumors of the parotid gland.

Methods

A retrospective evaluation of 160 cases of benign parotid gland tumors was performed and the cytological diagnoses compared with the histomorphological results. A collection of 26 cases with false-negative and false-positive results was reevaluated.

Results

FNAC showed a sensitivity of 74.2% and a specificity of 89.8% for differentiation between pleomorphic adenomas and non-pleomorphic benign lesions. The predictive value for pleomorphic adenomas was 82.1%, and for non-pleomorphic benign lesions 84.6%. Reevaluation showed higher sensitivity (96.2%), specificity (98.9%), and negative/positive predictive values (97.9% and 98.1%, respectively).

Discussion/conclusion

Poor quality and hypocellularity of the cytological smears seem to negatively effect the outcome of the cytological diagnosis. It is concluded that only an accurate diagnosis of non-pleomorphic adenoma or a benign tumor-like lesion, based on an adequate FNAC specimen and assessed by an experienced cytopathologist, can justify tumor enucleation because the risk of pleomorphic adenoma is only 2% under these circumstances.     

Synchronous benign and malignant tumors in the ipsilateral parotid gland

Synchronous benign and malignant tumors in the ipsilateral salivary glands are extremely rare. We report a unique case of synchronous unilateral parotid tumors in a 71-year-old man. The main parotid lesion was preoperatively suggested to be adenocarcinoma by fine needle aspiration cytology. A coexisting Warthin's tumor was also diagnosed on microscopic examination of total parotidectomy specimens. We describe this case of rare synchronous salivary gland tumors exhibiting both benign and malignant components with a review of the literature.     

Prudent Management of the Mid‐Cheek Mass: Revisiting the Accessory Parotid Gland Tumor

Objectives/Hypothesis The head and neck surgeon's fascination with parotid surgery arises from the gland's spectrum of histopathological presentations, as well as the diversity of its morphological features. A mass arising in the mid‐cheek region may often be overlooked as a rare accessory lobe parotid neoplasm. This report serves to revisit the topic of accessory parotid gland neoplasms to emphasize proper management, particularly the surgical aspects, so that consequences of salivary fistula, facial nerve paralysis, and recurrence are avoided. Study Design This is a retrospective review of our experience with four accessory parotid gland neoplasms and five other masses mimicking this lesion. Methods A literature review and retrospective chart review. Results Over a 6‐year period, we have encountered four true accessory lobe tumors, all pleomorphic adenomas. These presented very similarly to four other more commonly encountered masses not of salivary origin and one normal but hyperplastic accessory parotid gland. All were removed through a wide parotidectomy‐style approach modified by extending incisions anterosuperiorly and inferoanteriorly. The only complication was a minor salivary fistula in one patient. There were no permanent facial paralyses. Conclusions Accessory parotid gland neoplasms are rare and may present as innocuous extraparotid mid‐cheek masses. A high index of suspicion, prudent diagnostic skills (including fine‐needle aspiration [FNA] biopsy followed by computed tomography [CT] imaging), and meticulous surgical approach (extended parotidectomy‐style incision and limited peripheral nerve dissection when possible) are the keys to successful management of these lesions.     

The value of fine-needle aspiration cytology in salivary gland lesions, 1994-2004

OBJECTIVE: Fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) of the salivary gland is a commonly accepted, sensitive and specific technique in the diagnosis of both neoplastic and nonneoplastic lesions of the salivary gland. The aim of this study was to investigate the efficacy of FNAC of salivary gland lesions and to decide whether the radiologist could perform it or not. METHODS: We aspirated 162 salivary gland lesions of 56 patients undergoing biopsy and excision. A cytopathologist and a surgical pathologist made histopathological and cytological examinations in a blinded fashion. RESULTS: In the present study, among the FNAC performed in 162 patients with salivary gland masses, 15 (9%) were inadequate, and the remaining 147 were diagnostic. Of the 162 cases, 56 (35%) were also checked histologically. With FNAC there were 89 (55%) nonneoplastic and 58 (36%) neoplastic lesions. With FNAC 45 of the neoplastic lesions were benign and 13 malignant tumors. When cytohistopathological correlation was performed, the overall accuracy in diagnosing benign and malignant lesions was 91 and 78%, respectively, except for 2 malignant lymphoma cases. The sensitivity and specificity for benign and malignant lesions were 72 and 100%, respectively. The diagnostic sensitivity for all neoplastic and nonneoplastic lesions was 84% and the specificity 92%. There was 1 false-positive result, in which a nonneoplastic lesion was misdiagnosed as a Warthin's tumor. Fifteen (26%) cases were false-negative, 12 of which were undefined. CONCLUSION: FNAC is a useful and reliable tool in the diagnosis of salivary gland masses when performed by a radiologist or a clinician. There are no contraindications, and complications are minimal.     

Parotid tumours: correlation between fine needle aspiration biopsy and histological findings

ObjectivesTo evaluate the role of the fine needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB) in the study of parotid masses.MethodsRetrospective review of FNAB results compared with final histological diagnosis in 148 patients with a parotid mass from 1993 to 2003.ResultsFNAB was performed in 93.92% of parotid masses. Eleven of these were not conclusive. The FNAB diagnosis of malignant o suspicious lesion had 81.25% of sensibility, 96.87% of specificity and positive and negative predictive values of 89.65% and 93.94%, respectively. The FNAB specific histopathologic diagnosis in the benign parotid masses were 92%, and 57.69% in the malign masses.ConclusionsFNAB is a diagnostic tool with a high negative predictive value, very usotul in the study of suspicious malignant parotid masses and whenever surgery is not possible.     

Comparative analysis of benign and malignant parotid gland tumors: A retrospective study of 992 patients

ObjectiveWe analyzed and compared the clinical characteristics of benign and malignant parotid gland tumors.Patients and methodsA total of 992 patients who underwent surgical treatment for parotid gland tumors from January 2010 to December 2020 were included in this study. This study population was subdivided into benign (n = 812, 81.9 %) and malignant parotid gland tumors (n = 180, 18.1 %).ResultsPleomorphic adenoma is the most common benign tumor and mucoepidermoid carcinoma is the most common malignant tumor. The patients with malignant parotid gland tumors were older than the patients with benign lesions. The duration of symptoms was longer in patients with benign parotid gland tumors compared to those with malignant lesions. The size of the malignant tumors was larger than that of the benign lesions. Preoperative fine-needle aspiration cytology had a diagnostic sensitivity of 50.3 %, diagnostic specificity of 98.7 %, a positive predictive value of 89.5 %, a negative predictive value of 89.9 %, and accuracy of 89.9 % for diagnosing malignant parotid gland tumors. For benign parotid gland tumors, superficial parotidectomy was most frequently performed, and for malignant parotid gland tumors, total parotidectomy was most frequently performed. Facial palsy was observed in 19.4 % of the patients with malignant parotid gland tumors compared to 5.4 % of those with benign tumors.ConclusionThe clinical features of benign and malignant parotid gland tumors showed differences in age, symptoms, duration of symptoms, size and site of the parotid tumors, surgical procedures, and postoperative facial nerve palsy.     

Correlation of fine needle aspiration biopsy and CT scanning of parotid masses

Preoperative evaluation of parotid tumors still poses difficult problems for the head and neck surgeon. The complex anatomy of the parotid space leads to difficulty in localizing these tumors. In addition, physical examination will rarely determine whether a parotid lesion is benign or malignant. High resolution CT scanning with contrast and fine needle aspiration can provide enough preoperative information to enable the surgeon to counsel his patient concerning possible risks and the extent of surgery that may be indicated. We are able to determine tumor location, multiple or bilateral masses, associated adenopathy, and often specific tumor histology. Forty-two parotid aspirates and 26 CT scans were reviewed and correlated with their postoperative pathology specimen. Parotid aspiration cytology was found to be a highly accurate and safe procedure for preoperative determination of parotid pathology. However, the CT scan was specific only in defining the anatomic localization and extent of a parotid mass.     

Large cell neuroendocrine carcinoma of the parotid gland: case report and literature review

A 74-year-old male presented with a large polinodular mass in the neck. Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) showed an undifferentiated large cell carcinoma. Computed tomography (CT) showed a large parotid mass with multiple satelite nodules. The remaining radiological studies were normal. Radical parotidectomy was performed. The tumor was a large cell carcinoma with neuroendocrine features and positive immunostain for neuroendocrine markers. The patient received postoperative radiotherapy and was free of tumor eight months later. Only four cases of large cell neuroendocrine carcinoma (LCNEC) of the salivary gland have been communicated. All of them have involved the parotid gland. This tumor presents in elderly patients as a large infiltrating parotid mass. Fine needle aspiration cytology serves to recognize the carcinoma, but it fails in recognizing the neuroendocrine features of the tumor. The histopathological features of this tumor are the same as in other organs. Chromogranin and synaptophysin are useful immunohistochemical markers. A primary location of the tumor in another organ, specially the lung, should be ruled out. Surgery is the main treatment modality and can be complemented with postoperative radiotherapy. The prognosis seems to be poor. More studies are needed to better define the therapeutical alternatives and prognostic factors of these rare tumors.     

The role of fine needle aspiration in the evaluation of parotid masses

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Fine needle aspiration is a safe diagnostic technique that is widely employed for lesions of the head and neck. Among head and neck sites, the parotid gland stands apart for the number, diversity and peculiarity of pathologic processes to target this structure. This matchless complexity has prompted a thoughtful discussion regarding the application of the fine needle aspiration to parotid masses--a discussion that has primarily focused on the reliability of the fine needle aspiration as a diagnostic tool, and on its utility in guiding patient management. RECENT FINDINGS: Recent studies have confirmed a high overall accuracy rate for fine needle aspiration evaluation of parotid masses, ranging from 90 to 95%. At the same time, these soaring accuracy rates cannot be uniformly anticipated across all diagnostic scenarios. Fine needle aspiration is notoriously unreliable in recognizing the malignant nature of the parotid carcinoma, providing its precise classification, and establishing its grade. A few malignant neoplasms are particularly prone to diagnostic error. Acinic cell carcinoma is frequently interpreted as benign or even nonneoplastic; and low-grade lymphomas are often discounted as inflammatory processes. SUMMARY: Parotid gland masses are not particularly conducive to diagnostic accuracy and precision by fine needle aspiration. Accordingly, indiscriminant reliance on the fine needle aspiration findings at the expense of the clinical, radiographic, and intraoperative findings is unwarranted. Whether one uses the fine needle aspiration routinely or selectively in patients with parotid masses, the fine needle aspiration findings should contribute to, not displace, the overall diagnostic impression.