Speech, velopharyngeal function, and hearing before and after orthognathic surgery

Articulation, voice, resonance, hearing sensitivity, and middle ear function were examined in 34 patients before and 3, 6, 9, and 12 months after orthognathic surgery. Thirty of the 34 patients had articulation errors before surgery. Errors on the sibilants /s/ and /z/ occurred most frequently, followed by those on /j,zh,ch/ and /sh/. Errors were predominantly distortions with both visual and acoustic components. After surgery, articulation improved spontaneously in the absence of intervention. Most of the preoperative articulation errors were eliminated by 3 months postoperative, but, thereafter, a gradual decline was noted so that by 12 months, errors occurred on /s/ and /z/. Voice, resonance, velopharyngeal port area, and hearing sensitivity were not altered by surgery. This study suggests that severe skeletal malocclusions requiring surgical correction have deleterious effects on the patients' articulation of consonants and that surgical alteration leads to the correction of most of these errors.     

Evaluation of unilateral cleft lip and palate treatment: long term results

Fifty-seven consecutive complete unilateral cleft lip and palate patients were followed longitudinally from birth to 21 years of age. All patients were operated with the same primary surgical procedures. Reevaluation at age 21 with respect to speech, dental condition, need for secondary surgery, and skeletal and soft tissue facial growth was completed. Speech results indicated that 13 patients (23 percent) had required a pharyngeal flap, and that at age 21 only one patient still had unacceptable speech. The majority of patients had slight speech disturbances related to articulation and voice quality. Fifty-one patients had acceptable occlusion following orthodontic treatment, twenty-two patients (39 percent) without need for prosthodontic treatment of the cleft area. Secondary surgery for correction of nasal deformities was required for fifty-two patients. Growth analysis demonstrated deficiency in growth; however, normal and acceptable profiles were obtained in 50/57 of the patients.     

A cross-sectional study of speech in 10-year-old children with cleft palate: results and issues of rater reliability.

OBJECTIVES: To describe speech based on perceptual evaluation in a group of 10-year-old children with cleft palate. A secondary aim was to investigate the reliability of speech-language pathologists' perceptual assessment of cleft palate speech. DESIGN: Retrospective cross-sectional study in children with cleft palate. External raters made assessments from randomized speech recordings. SUBJECTS: Thirty-eight children with unilateral cleft lip and palate (UCLP) or cleft palate only (CPO) and 10 children in a comparison group. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Ratings of hypernasality, hyponasality, audible nasal air leakage, weak pressure consonants, and articulation. Exact agreement and weighted kappa values were used for reliability. RESULTS: Hypernasality was found in 25% of children with a cleft of the soft palate (CSP), 33% of children with a cleft of the hard and soft palate (CHSP), and 67% of children with a UCLP. Similar results were found for audible nasal air leakage. Articulation errors were found in 6% of the CHSP group and 25% of the UCLP group, whereas no child in the CSP group had articulation errors. The reliability was moderate to good for different variables, with lowest values for hypernasality. CONCLUSIONS: Speech results in this series seem less satisfactory than those reported in other published international studies, but it is difficult to draw any certain conclusions about speech results because of large methodological differences. Further developments to ensure high reliability of perceptual ratings of speech are called for.     

Pharyngeal flap surgery in adults

The elimination of hypernasal speech in patients with cleft palate following pharyngeal flap surgery in childhood is well established. However, pharyngeal flaps in adults have been considered to yield more modest results. This study reports on 20 adult patients with cleft palate-related hypernasality who underwent pharyngeal flap surgery. Normal nasal resonance was achieved in 15 cases, hyponasality occurred in 3 cases, and hypernasality persisted in 2 cases. However, speech intelligibility was not always dramatically improved. Indications and outcome were found to be highly dependent on preoperative articulation.     

Speech outcome after closure of oronasal fistulas with bone grafts.

PURPOSE: The purpose of this prospective study was to evaluate the outcome of speech after complete closure of oronasal fistulas with bone grafts and to determine the possible relationship between outcome of speech and the size and location of the oronasal fistulas. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Ten unilateral cleft lip and palate patients with postoperative oronasal fistulas, ranging in age from 7 to 14 years, underwent secondary alveolar cleft repair and closure of the oronasal fistulas with an iliac bone graft. All patients underwent videofluoroscopic evaluation of the velopharyngeal valve, audiologic assessment, and speech evaluation (resonance, nasal emission, articulation, intelligibility, and nasalance) preoperatively. The examinations were repeated 3 months postoperatively. RESULTS: Six patients had preoperative velopharyngeal competency (60%). Of the 4 patients with slight to mild velopharyngeal incompetency preoperatively, 2 developed velopharyngeal competency postoperatively. All patients had satisfactory audiologic function preoperatively. Every patient also was intelligible before and after surgery. Eight patients (80%) showed nasal emission before surgery and 7 of these patients improved postoperatively (P <.01). Nine patients had articulation errors before surgery, with no significant improvement postoperatively. Nasalance was significantly improved in selected sequences. All patients had variable levels of nasality preoperatively; 8 showed a significant decrease of nasality postoperatively (P <.002). The results were not related to location or size of the oronasal fistulas. CONCLUSION: A significant improvement in speech is noticeable after closure of oronasal fistulas. Early oronasal fistula closure might prevent permanent speech distortions acquired by the cleft palate patients at an early age.     

渗出性中耳炎听力损失对腭裂患者术后语音的影响

目的分析腭裂患者中耳及听力状况与术后语音效果的关系.方法记录18例腭裂患者术前中耳及听力状况以及术后各自的言语清晰度,将不同言语清晰度组间渗出性中耳炎(+)及渗出性中耳炎(-)病例数进行比较,将患者术前平均语频气导听阈值与术后相应言语清晰度进行线形相关分析.结果腭裂患者平均语频气导听阈值与术后言语清晰度呈负相关关系(r=-0.504,t=-2.349,P=0.032<0.05),而不同言语清晰度组间以声阻抗检查诊断渗出性中耳炎(+)及渗出性中耳炎(-)病例数的差异无显著性.结论腭裂患者的听力状况与腭裂术后语音状况关系密切,是选择腭裂患者伴发渗出性中耳炎合理治疗方案的重要依据.     

Audiologic and tympanometric findings in children with cleft lip and palate.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the otologic and audiologic status of 50 children with repaired cleft lip, cleft palate, or both in Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey. DESIGN: Audiometric and tympanometric evaluation of 100 ears in 50 children were performed. Hearing levels < or = 15 dB and middle ear pressures between -50 to +50 decaPascals were considered to be normal. Results were examined according to cleft type and laterality. The least and most affected frequencies were calculated. A simple evaluation of speech characteristics including nasal resonance, nasal air escape, and errors of articulation was also performed. RESULTS: Sixty-three of the 100 ears had normal hearing status, whereas 40 had normal middle ear pressures. No evidence was found to suggest that individual cleft type and laterality of the ear had any effect on hearing loss or middle ear disease. Two-thirds of the patients had normal or acceptable degree of language skills. CONCLUSION: The final hearing status of patients with cleft palate is a result of a combination of surgical correction, developmental factors, and treatment of middle ear disease. Early and aggressive ventilation tube placement is the standard of cleft care in many countries. Our long-term hearing outcome is relatively good in a population not treated with routine insertion of ventilation tubes. The majority of patients also have satisfactory speech. Patients with cleft palate should have close follow-up for middle ear disease, but further research is warranted to determine the aggressive usage of ventilation tubes.     

Comparison of resonance outcomes after pharyngeal flap and furlow double-opposing z-plasty for surgical management of velopharyngeal incompetence.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to test the hypothesis that no significant difference exists in the speech outcomes between patients with severe velopharyngeal incompetence (VPI) who receive a pharyngeal flap and patients with less severe VPI who receive a Z-plasty for management of VPI. DESIGN: This retrospective study from 1993 to 2002 included a review of pre- and postoperative perceptual speech and resonance assessments of patients with marginal VPI who received a Furlow double-opposing Z-plasty and patients with VPI who received a pharyngeal flap. SETTING: All patients had surgical management of VPI at the Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Clinic at University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics. RESULTS: Both groups benefited from surgery with significant reduction in perceived hypernasality (p < .001). Comparison of postoperative assessments indicated no difference between the groups in hypernasality or hyponasality ratings. Neither group had a significant increase in hyponasality. CONCLUSION: Both pharyngeal flap and double-opposing Z-plasty proved equally effective at reducing hypernasality when the selection of the surgical procedures was based on preoperative ratings of perceived hypernasality and evaluation of velopharyngeal physiology. Severity of the VPI is an important factor when considering surgical management of VPI. Thorough preoperative evaluations of patients with VPI are essential in appropriate treatment planning.     

Impact of 3-dimensional anatomical changes secondary to orthognathic surgery on voice resonance and articulatory function: a prospective study

An evaluation was made of the impact of orthognathic surgery (OS) on speech, addressing in particular the effects of skeletal and airway changes on voice resonance characteristics and articulatory function. A prospective study was carried out involving 29 consecutive patients subjected to OS. Preoperative, and short and long-term postoperative evaluations were made of anatomical changes (skeletal and airway measurements), speech evolution (assessed objectively by acoustic analysis: fundamental frequency, local jitter, local shimmer of each vowel, and formants F1 and F2 of vowel /a/), and articulatory function (use of compensatory musculature, point of articulation, and speech intelligibility). These were also assessed subjectively by means of a visual analogue scale. Articulatory function after OS showed immediate improvement and had further progressed at one year of follow up. This improvement significantly correlated with the anatomical changes, and was also notably perceived by the patient. On the other hand, although a slight modification in vocal resonance was reported and seen to correlate with anatomical changes of the tongue, hyoid bone, and airway, it was not subjectively perceived by the patients. In conclusion, the results demonstrated that OS had beneficial effects on articulatory function and imperceptible subjective changes in a patient’s voice. Patients subjected to OS, apart from benefitting from improved articulatory function, should not be afraid that they will not recognise their voice after treatment.     

The impact of mandibular advancement on articulation, resonance and voice characteristics in Flemish speaking adults: a pilot study

Bilateral saggital split osteotomy (BSSO) of the mandible is a frequently performed mandibular orthognathic procedure, used to resolve mandibular disharmonies. Literature review showed contradictory findings regarding the effect of the orthognathic surgery on speech characteristics. The purpose of the present study was to determine a detailed analysis of the articulation, resonance and voice characteristics after BSSO with mandibular advancement for the treatment of Class II malocclusions using objective and subjective assessment techniques (perceptual evaluations, Dysphonia Severity Index, nasalance scores) in eight subjects. The findings of the present study indicate that before and after BSSO with mandibular advancement three types of articulation disorders may predominate in the Flemish language: the incorrect production of the trill sound /r/ and the /s/ sound and devoicing of the /z/. After orthognathic surgery most patients showed an identical articulation pattern (normal or disturbed pattern) as in the presurgical condition. In this study the BSSO with mandibular advancement had no significant impact on the nasality characteristics and the nasalance values probably due to the competent velopharyngeal valving in the presurgical condition. And, as expected the vocal quality revealed no significant difference. The maxillofacial surgeon and the speech language pathologist must be aware of the persistency of these preoperative articulation errors in the postsurgical condition.     

Clinical outcomes of the furlow z-plasty for primary cleft palate repair

Objective: To review the clinical outcomes following the Furlow Z-plasty for primary cleft palate repair. The primary objective was to determine if the presence of an associated sequence or syndrome (i.e., Pierre Robin sequence), age at palate repair, cleft type, or surgeon experience influenced speech outcomes after a Furlow Z-plasty. Design: The outcomes of 140 patients who underwent palate repair were analyzed retrospectively. Speech evaluations were performed to score the severity of hypernasality, nasal escape, articulation errors, and velopharyngeal insufficiency. Results: The mean age at latest evaluation was 4 years 9 months (age range 2 years old to 12 years old and 4 months). Of the 140 patients, 83% had no evidence of hypernasality, 91% had no presence of nasal escape, and 69% had no articulation errors. Overall, 84% of patients had no evidence of velopharyngeal insufficiency. Secondary posterior pharyngeal flap to correct velopharyngeal insufficiency was required in only 2.1% of patients. The formation of an oronasal fistula occurred in only 3.6% of patients. Nonsyndromic patients with Pierre Robin sequence and syndromic patients did just as well as purely nonsyndromic patients in terms of velopharyngeal insufficiency, hypernasality, and nasal escape. Syndromic patients were more likely to make mild-to-moderate articulation errors. In addition, age at palate repair, cleft type, and surgeon experience had no statistically significant effect on speech results. Conclusions: The Furlow Z-plasty yielded excellent speech results in our patient population with minimal and acceptable rates of fistula formation, velopharyngeal insufficiency, and the need for additional corrective surgery.     

Factors affecting articulation skills in children with velocardiofacial syndrome and children with cleft palate or velopharyngeal dysfunction: a preliminary report.

OBJECTIVE: To examine the influence of speech perception, cognition, and implicit phonological learning on articulation skills of children with velocardiofacial syndrome (VCFS) and children with cleft palate or velopharyngeal dysfunction (VPD). DESIGN: Cross-sectional group experimental design. PARTICIPANTS: Eight children with VCFS and five children with nonsyndromic cleft palate or VPD. METHODS AND MEASURES: All children participated in a phonetic inventory task, speech perception task, implicit priming nonword repetition task, conversational sample, nonverbal intelligence test, and hearing screening. Speech tasks were scored for percentage of phonemes correctly produced. Group differences and relations among measures were examined using nonparametric statistics. RESULTS: Children in the VCFS group demonstrated significantly poorer articulation skills and lower standard scores of nonverbal intelligence compared with the children with cleft palate or VPD. There were no significant group differences in speech perception skills. For the implicit priming task, both groups of children were more accurate in producing primed nonwords than unprimed nonwords. Nonverbal intelligence and severity of velopharyngeal inadequacy for speech were correlated with articulation skills. CONCLUSIONS: In this study, children with VCFS had poorer articulation skills compared with children with cleft palate or VPD. Articulation difficulties seen in the children with VCFS did not appear to be associated with speech perception skills or the ability to learn new phonological representations. Future research should continue to examine relationships between articulation, cognition, and velopharyngeal dysfunction in a larger sample of children with cleft palate and VCFS.     

Parent and child ratings of satisfaction with speech and facial appearance in Flemish pre-pubescent boys and girls with unilateral cleft lip and palate

The purpose of this controlled study is to determine satisfaction with speech and facial appearance in Flemish pre-pubescent children with unilateral cleft lip and palate. Forty-three subjects with unilateral cleft lip and palate and 43 age and gender matched controls participated in this study. The Cleft Evaluation Profile was used to assess the perceived satisfaction for individual features related to cleft care. Both the cleft palate subjects and their parents were satisfied with the speech and facial appearance. The Pearson χ(2) test revealed significant difference between the cleft palate and the control group regarding hearing, nasal aesthetics and function, and the appearance of the lip. An in depth analysis of well specified speech characteristics revealed that children with clefts and their parents significantly more often reported the presence of an articulation, voice and resonance disorder and experienced /s/ /r/ /t/ and /d/ as the most difficult consonants. To what extent the incorporation of specific motor oriented oral speech techniques regarding the realisation of specific consonants, attention to vocal and ear care, and the recommendation of secondary velopharyngeal surgery, with the incorporation of primary correction of the cleft nose deformity simultaneously with primary lip closure, will aid these patients are future research subjects.     

替牙期安氏Ⅲ类骨性错畸形与语音功能的相关分析

目的 探讨替牙期安氏Ⅲ类骨性反与患儿语音功能的相关关系。方法 选择38例替牙期安氏Ⅲ类骨性反患儿为试验组，并随机选择40名替牙期正常儿童为对照组。由语音专家对试验组和对照组儿童的语音进行判听，将患儿发音错误数量与其X线头影测量片的牙、颌、面的软硬组织测量结果进行相关分析。结果 替牙期骨性安氏Ⅲ错患儿大多数存在发音异常，错误发音与反覆盖及OBJ（覆与覆盖之和）呈高度相关，与上下切缘间的距离呈高度正相关，与TD-PW（舌背最高点至咽后壁距离）呈正相关。结论 替牙期安氏Ⅲ类骨性反患儿大部分存在语音功能障碍，发音功能障碍与切牙关系及舌位置有关。     

Velopharyngeal closure pattern and speech characteristics of patients congenital velopharyngeal insufficiency

目的 研究先天性腭咽闭合不全（CVPI）患者的腭咽闭合模式、腭咽口各部分收缩情况及语音特点。方法 回顾2009—2017年于四川大学华西口腔医院唇腭裂外科就诊的CVPI患者的病历资料,分析其共鸣状况、辅音构音表现及辅音正确率,采用鼻咽内镜观察患者的腭咽闭合模式以及软腭、咽侧壁和咽后壁的运动情况。结果 共纳入47例CVPI患者,均接受了鼻咽内镜检查,29例（61.7%）为环状闭合,16例（34.0%）为冠状闭合,2例（4.3%）为矢状闭合;25例（53.2%）患者软腭动度中度,占比最高;22例（46.8%）患者咽侧壁动度弱,41例（87.2%）患者咽后壁无动度。所有患者均有不同程度的高鼻音表现,其中23例（48.9%）为中度高鼻音,占比最高。47例患者中5例（10.6%）构音正常,42例（89.4%）存在不同程度构音障碍。不同构音方法正确率的高低排序为：鼻辅音>边音>擦音>塞音>塞擦音。不同构音位置正确率的高低排序为：唇音>舌前音>舌后音>舌面音。结论 环状闭合是CVPI患者最主要的腭咽闭合模式,辅音省略是最常见的构音障碍。     

Long-term speech outcome in patients with Robin sequence after cleft palate repair and tongue-lip adhesion: A 21-year retrospective analysis

The purpose of this study was to assess the effect of tongue−lip adhesion (TLA) on the long-term speech and articulation outcomes of patients with Robin sequence (RS) after cleft palate repair. Outcomes were compared to those in patients with RS who required positioning alone and to patients with isolated cleft palate (ICP).All consecutive patients with RS (with or without TLA) versus isolated cleft palate (ICP) who underwent cleft palate repair were retrospectively reviewed. Speech and articulation included all assessments between the age of 3–6 years. Secondary speech operations, velopharyngeal insufficiency (VPI), hypernasality, and articulation errors by cleft-type characteristics (CTC), including 4 categories (passive), non-oral, anterior-oral, and posterior-oral. A total of 41 RS patients and 61 ICP patients underwent repair with sufficient follow-up. Of them, 23 patients underwent a TLA at median age of 12 days. Rates of hypernasality (p = 0.004), secondary speech operations (p = 0.004), and posterior oral CTC (p = 0.042) were higher in RS compared to ICP. Isolated RS had speech outcomes similar to those of ICP; however, syndromic RS patients needed more secondary speech operations compared to isolated RS (p = 0.043). TLA-RS patients did not demonstrate differences in speech outcomes or any CTCs (all p > 0.05) compared to non−TLA-RS patients, except for the anterior oral CTC (74% TLA-RS vs 28% non−TLA-RS, p = 0.005).Within the limitations of the study, it seem that TLA does not affect long-term velopharyngeal function in patients with RS. However, TLA-RS patients demonstrated higher rates of anterior-oral CTC, which might be related to a different positioning of the tongue after TLA. Every effort should be taken to treat patients with RS conservatively instead of with TLA because of this demonstrated a negative effect on one type of articulation error. However, if conservative therapy fails, a TLA is still a valuable adjunct in the treatment of RS, and cleft speech pathologists who treat such patients should be more aware of this phenomenon in order to improve long-term articulation outcomes.     

The intrajudge reliability of the perceptual rating of cleft palate speech before and after pharyngeal flap surgery: the effect of judges and speech samples.

OBJECTIVE: In this pilot study, the reliabilities of the perceptual ratings of four types of speech samples by six judges, with and without expertise in evaluating cleft palate speech, were studied. DESIGN: Pre- and postoperative tape recordings of 15 patients with cleft lip and palate who had undergone a superiorly based pharyngeal flap operation were selected. Five speech-language pathologists and one oral and maxillofacial surgeon perceptually rated the following variables on separate 100-mm visual analog scales: hypernasality, audible nasal emission, intelligibility, misarticulations associated with velopharyngeal insufficiency, voice quality, and the presence or absence of hyponasality. These six variables were rated in four types of speech samples: reading of three sentences, repeating after the speech pathologist of three sentences, 10 sentences containing the aforementioned material, and the same 10 sentences in paired comparison. All speech samples were rerated after 3 months by the same judges. RESULTS: Judges differed largely in the range they used in their rating. Intrajudge reliability of .56 to .78 was found for ratings of hypernasality. No significant differences in intrajudge reliability were found for the ratings with the different types of speech samples. The intrajudge reliability of a judge with expertise was not necessarily higher than of a judge without this expertise. CONCLUSIONS: The improvement in speech is most reliably assessed with speech samples in paired comparison. A speech-language pathologist with expertise in evaluating cleft palate speech does not guarantee a high intrajudge reliability of the rating.     

Phonetic and phonologic skills of two-year-olds with cleft palate.

This article examines the phonetic and phonologic skills of 2-year-olds with cleft palate. Fifteen children, 10 children with cleft palate and five noncleft children, participated in the study. The children with cleft palate all received palatal surgery after 12 months of age and after the onset of meaningful speech. All subjects were video and audiotaped while interacting with their mothers during unstructured play. At least one hundred different spontaneous word productions were phonetically transcribed and analyzed for (1) percent consonants correct, (2) phonologic processes, and (3) "compensatory" articulation patterns. A comparison between the groups indicated that although the children with cleft palate exhibited more errors overall, they were similar to their noncleft peers in their phonologic process usage with two exceptions. Additionally, few "compensatory" articulation errors were noted in the speech of these children.