Dealing with uncertainties: ethics of prenatal diagnosis and preimplantation genetic diagnosis to prevent mitochondrial disorders

This paper aims to address the ethical issues regarding prenatal diagnosis and preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) of mitochondrial disorders. Owing to the absence of effective treatment, the prevention of the transmission of mitochondrial disorders is considered to be of key importance. The characteristics of mtDNA, such as heteroplasmy and the genetic bottleneck, make it difficult to estimate recurrence risks correctly and to provide an accurate prognosis for many mtDNA mutations. A limited number of mtDNA mutations allow reliable predictions, though results in the 'grey zone' are problematic. Both prenatal diagnosis and PGD for mtDNA disorders are complicated by the interpretation of the test results. As a consequence, these applications confront both clinical practice and society at large with several ethical questions and issues for further debate, among which the acceptability of suboptimal genetic testing, the value and research use of embryos, the evaluation of late abortion, the ethics of PGD for disorders with an incomplete penetrance and variable expression, the possible transfer of embryos with residual health risks, the acceptability of risks and drawbacks of genetic reproductive technology in general, and the scope and limits of reproductive autonomy and professional responsibility.     

Clinical differences in patients with mitochondriocytopathies due to nuclear versus mitochondrial DNA mutations

Defects in oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) are genetically unique because the different components involved in this process, respiratory chain enzyme complexes (I, III, and IV) and complex V, are encoded by nuclear and mitochondrial genome. The objective of the study was to assess whether there are clinical differences in patients suffering from OXPHOS defects caused by nuclear or mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations. We studied 16 families with > or = two siblings with a genetically established OXPHOS deficiency, four due to a nuclear gene mutation and 12 due to a mtDNA mutation. Siblings with a nuclear gene mutation showed very similar clinical pictures that became manifest in the first years (ranging from first months to early childhood). There was a severe progressive course. Seven of the eight children died in their first decade. Conversely, siblings with a mtDNA mutation had clinical pictures that varied from almost alike to very distinct. They became symptomatic at an older age (ranging from childhood to adulthood), with the exception of defects associated with Leigh or Leigh-like phenotype. The clinical course was more gradual and relatively less severe; four of the 26 patients died, one in his second year, another in her second decade and two in their sixth decade. There are differences in age at onset, severity of clinical course, outcome, and intrafamilial variability in patients affected of an OXPHOS defect due to nuclear or mtDNA mutations. Patients with nuclear mutations become symptomatic at a young age, and have a severe clinical course. Patients with mtDNA mutations show a wider clinical spectrum of age at onset and severity. These differences may be of importance regarding the choice of which genome to study in affected patients as well as with respect to genetic counseling.     

Transmission of mitochondrial DNA following assisted reproduction and nuclear transfer

Mitochondria are the organelles responsible for producing the majority of a cell's ATP and also play an essential role in gamete maturation and embryo development. ATP production within the mitochondria is dependent on proteins encoded by both the nuclear and the mitochondrial genomes, therefore co-ordination between the two genomes is vital for cell survival. To assist with this co-ordination, cells normally contain only one type of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) termed homoplasmy. Occasionally, however, two or more types of mtDNA are present termed heteroplasmy. This can result from a combination of mutant and wild-type mtDNA molecules or from a combination of wild-type mtDNA variants. As heteroplasmy can result in mitochondrial disease, various mechanisms exist in the natural fertilization process to ensure the maternal-only transmission of mtDNA and the maintenance of homoplasmy in future generations. However, there is now an increasing use of invasive oocyte reconstruction protocols, which tend to bypass mechanisms for the maintenance of homoplasmy, potentially resulting in the transmission of either form of mtDNA heteroplasmy. Indeed, heteroplasmy caused by combinations of wild-type variants has been reported following cytoplasmic transfer (CT) in the human and following nuclear transfer (NT) in various animal species. Other techniques, such as germinal vesicle transfer and pronuclei transfer, have been proposed as methods of preventing transmission of mitochondrial diseases to future generations. However, resulting embryos and offspring may contain mtDNA heteroplasmy, which itself could result in mitochondrial disease. It is therefore essential that uniparental transmission of mtDNA is ensured before these techniques are used therapeutically.     

Respiratory chain complex I deficiency caused by mitochondrial DNA mutations

Defects of the mitochondrial respiratory chain are associated with a diverse spectrum of clinical phenotypes, and may be caused by mutations in either the nuclear or the mitochondrial genome (mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)). Isolated complex I deficiency is the most common enzyme defect in mitochondrial disorders, particularly in children in whom family history is often consistent with sporadic or autosomal recessive inheritance, implicating a nuclear genetic cause. In contrast, although a number of recurrent, pathogenic mtDNA mutations have been described, historically, these have been perceived as rare causes of paediatric complex I deficiency. We reviewed the clinical and genetic findings in a large cohort of 109 paediatric patients with isolated complex I deficiency from 101 families. Pathogenic mtDNA mutations were found in 29 of 101 probands (29%), 21 in MTND subunit genes and 8 in mtDNA tRNA genes. Nuclear gene defects were inferred in 38 of 101 (38%) probands based on cell hybrid studies, mtDNA sequencing or mutation analysis (nuclear gene mutations were identified in 22 probands). Leigh or Leigh-like disease was the most common clinical presentation in both mtDNA and nuclear genetic defects. The median age at onset was higher in mtDNA patients (12 months) than in patients with a nuclear gene defect (3 months). However, considerable overlap existed, with onset varying from 0 to >60 months in both groups. Our findings confirm that pathogenic mtDNA mutations are a significant cause of complex I deficiency in children. In the absence of parental consanguinity, we recommend whole mitochondrial genome sequencing as a key approach to elucidate the underlying molecular genetic abnormality.     

Mitochondrial disorders: genetics, counseling, prenatal diagnosis and reproductive options

Most patients with mitochondrial disorders are diagnosed by finding a respiratory chain enzyme defect or a mutation in the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA). The provision of accurate genetic counseling and reproductive options to these families is complicated by the unique genetic features of mtDNA that distinguish it from Mendelian genetics. These include maternal inheritance, heteroplasmy, the threshold effect, the mitochondrial bottleneck, tissue variation, and selection. Although we still have much to learn about mtDNA genetics, it is now possible to provide useful guidance to families with an mtDNA mutation or a respiratory chain enzyme defect. We describe a range of current reproductive options that may be considered for prevention of transmission of mtDNA mutations, including the use of donor oocytes, prenatal diagnosis (by chorionic villus sampling or amniocentesis), and preimplantation genetic diagnosis, plus possible future options such as nuclear transfer and cytoplasmic transfer. For common mtDNA mutations associated with mitochondrial cytopathies (such as NARP, Leigh Disease, MELAS, MERRF, Leber's Hereditary Optic Neuropathy, CPEO, Kearns-Sayre syndrome, and Pearson syndrome), we summarize the available data on recurrence risk and discuss the relative advantages and disadvantages of reproductive options.     

Mitochondrial medicine--molecular pathology of defective oxidative phosphorylation

Different tissues display distinct sensitivities to defective mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS). Tissues highly dependent on oxygen such as the cardiac muscle, skeletal and smooth muscle, the central and peripheral nervous system, the kidney, and the insulin-producing pancreatic beta-cell are especially susceptible to defective OXPHOS. There is evidence that defective OXPHOS plays an important role in atherogenesis, in the pathogenesis of Alzheimer's disease, Parkinson's disease, diabetes, and aging. Defective OXPHOS may be caused by abnormal mitochondrial biosynthesis due to inherited or acquired mutations in the nuclear (n) or mitochondrial (mt) deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA). For instance, the presence of a mutation of the mtDNA in the pancreatic beta-cell impairs adenosine triphosphate (ATP) generation and insulin synthesis. The nuclear genome controls mitochondrial biosynthesis, but mtDNA has a much higher mutation rate than nDNA because it lacks histones and is exposed to the radical oxygen species (ROS) generated by the electron transport chain, and the mtDNA repair system is limited. Defective OXPHOS may be caused by insufficient fuel supply, by defective electron transport chain enzymes (Complexes I - IV), lack of the electron carrier coenzyme Q10, lack of oxygen due to ischemia or anemia, or excessive membrane leakage, resulting in insufficient mitochondrial inner membrane potential for ATP synthesis by the F0F1-ATPase. Human tissues can counteract OXPHOS defects by stimulating mitochondrial biosynthesis; however, above a certain threshold the lack of ATP causes cell death. Many agents affect OXPHOS. Several nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) inhibit or uncouple OXPHOS and induce the 'topical' phase of gastrointestinal ulcer formation. Uncoupled mitochondria reduce cell viability. The Helicobacter pylori induces uncoupling. The uncoupling that opens the membrane pores can activate apoptosis. Cholic acid in experimental atherogenic diets inhibits Complex IV, cocaine inhibits Complex I, the poliovirus inhibits Complex II, ceramide inhibits Complex III, azide, cyanide, chloroform, and methamphetamine inhibit Complex IV. Ethanol abuse and antiviral nucleoside analogue therapy inhibit mtDNA replication. By contrast, melatonin stimulates Complexes I and IV and Gingko biloba stimulates Complexes I and III. Oral Q10 supplementation is effective in treating cardiomyopathies and in restoring plasma levels reduced by the statin type of cholesterol-lowering drugs.     

Mitochondria and degenerative disorders

In mammalian cells, mitochondria provide energy from aerobic metabolism. They play an important regulatory role in apoptosis, produce and detoxify free radicals, and serve as a cellular calcium buffer. Neurodegenerative disorders involving mitochondria can be divided into those caused by oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) abnormalities either due to mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) abnormalities, e.g., chronic external ophthalmoplegia, or due to nuclear mutations of OXPHOS proteins, e.g., complex I and II associated with Leigh syndrome. There are diseases caused by nuclear genes encoding non-OXPHOS mitochondrial proteins, such as frataxin in Friedreich ataxia (which is likely to play an important role in mitochondrial-cytosolic iron cycling), paraplegin (possibly a mitochondrial ATP-dependent zinc metalloprotease of the AAA-ATPases in hereditary spastic paraparesis), and possibly Wilson disease protein (an abnormal copper transporting ATP-dependent P-type ATPase associated with Wilson disease). Huntingon disease is an example of diseases with OXPHOS defects associated with mutations of nuclear genes encoding non-mitochondrial proteins such as huntingtin. There are also disorders with evidence of mitochondrial involvement that cannot as yet be assigned. These include Parkinson disease (where a complex I defect is described and free radicals are generated from dopamine metabolism), amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, and Alzheimer disease, where there is evidence to suggest mitochondrial involvement perhaps secondary to other abnormalities.     

Mitochondrial Encephalomyopathies: Defects of Nuclear DNA

The term "mitochondrial diseases" encompasses a heterogeneous group of disorders in which a primary mitochondrial dysfunction is suspected or proven by morphologic, genetic, or biochemical criteria. Clinically, these progressive disorders usually affect muscle, either alone (mitochondrial myopathies) or in combination with other systems, most often brain (encephalomyopathies). Mitochondria are unique among intracellular organelles in that mitochondrial proteins are encoded by two genomes, nuclear DNA (nDNA) and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA). The vast majority of mitochondrial proteins are encoded by the nuclear genome, whereas mtDNA (a circular, double stranded 16.5 kb molecule) encodes only 13 polypeptides, all of them subunits of respiratory chain complexes. In addition to structural genes, mtDNA also codes for 22 transfer RNAs and two ribosomal RNAs. Our understanding of mitochondrial diseases has grown at an impressive rate in the past few years, and most of the progress has been in the area of mtDNA genetics, where several mtDNA mutations have been associated with specific diseases (reviewed in this issue by Zeviani et al.). In comparison, our understanding of mitochondrial disorders due to nDNA lesions has lagged behind and, to date, molecular defects of nuclear genes have been documented in only a few patients. We will review which alterations in the nuclear genome can cause mitochondrial disorders and which criteria are useful in identifying such mutations. While several examples will be provided, this is not intended as a complete review of the subject.     

Mitochondrial DNA and disease

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) defects are a relatively common cause of inherited disease and have been implicated in both ageing and cancer. MtDNA encodes essential subunits of the mitochondrial respiratory chain and defects result in impaired oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS). Similar OXPHOS defects have been shown to be present in a number of neurodegenerative conditions, including Parkinson's disease, as well as in normal ageing human tissues. Additionally, a number of tumours have been shown to contain mtDNA mutations and an altered metabolic phenotype. In this review we outline the unique characteristics of mitochondrial genetics before detailing important pathological features of mtDNA diseases, focusing on adult neurological disease as well as the role of mtDNA mutations in neurodegenerative diseases, ageing and cancer.     

Mutations in the ND5 subunit of complex I of the mitochondrial DNA are a frequent cause of oxidative phosphorylation disease

Background

Detection of mutations in the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) is usually limited to common mutations and the transfer RNA genes. However, mutations in other mtDNA regions can be an important cause of oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) disease as well.

Objective

To investigate whether regions in the mtDNA are preferentially mutated in patients with OXPHOS disease.

Methods

Screening of the mtDNA for heteroplasmic mutations was performed by denaturing high‐performance liquid chromatography analysis of 116 patients with OXPHOS disease but without the common mtDNA mutations.

Results

An mtDNA sequence variant was detected in 15 patients, 5 of which were present in the ND5 gene. One sequence variant was new and three were known, one of which was found twice. The novel sequence variant m.13511A→T occurred in a patient with a Leigh‐like syndrome. The known mutation m.13513G→A, associated with mitochondrial encephalomyopathy lactic acidosis and stroke‐like syndrome (MELAS) and MELAS/Leigh/Leber hereditary optic neuropathy overlap syndrome, was found in a relatively low percentage in two patients from two different families, one with a MELAS/Leigh phenotype and one with a MELAS/chronic progressive external ophthalmoplegia phenotype. The known mutation m.13042G→A, detected previously in a patient with a MELAS/myoclonic epilepsy, ragged red fibres phenotype and in a family with a prevalent ocular phenotype, was now found in a patient with a Leigh‐like phenotype. The sequence variant m.12622G→A was reported once in a control database as a polymorphism, but is reported in this paper as heteroplasmic in three brothers, all with infantile encephalopathy (Leigh syndrome) fatal within the first 15 days of life. Therefore, a causal relationship between the presence of this sequence variant and the onset of mitochondrial disease cannot be entirely excluded at this moment.

Conclusions

Mutation screening of the ND5 gene is advised for routine diagnostics of patients with OXPHOS disease, especially for those with MELAS‐ and Leigh‐like syndrome with a complex I deficiency.Mitochondria are key for many cellular processes. One of the most important mechanisms is oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) resulting in the production of cellular energy in the form of ATP. The OXPHOS system consists of five multiprotein complexes (I–V) and two mobile electron carriers (coenzyme q and cytochrome c) embedded in the lipid bilayer of the mitochondrial inner membrane.^1,2 The mitochondrial genome encodes 13 essential polypeptides of the OXPHOS system and the necessary RNA machinery (two ribosomal RNAs and 22 transfer RNAs (tRNA)). The remaining structural proteins and proteins involved in import, assembly and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) replication are encoded by the nucleus and specifically targeted to the mitochondria. OXPHOS disease is characterised by a wide variety of clinical symptoms, in which one or more organs can be involved, and by genetic and clinical heterogeneity.^2,3 With an estimated total number of about 1500 nuclear mitochondrial genes of which 600 have been identified so far,⁴ this complicates the process of identification of the underlying genetic defect. Although mutations in the mtDNA tRNA genes have been reported far more often than other mutations in mtDNA protein‐coding genes,² this figure is highly biased by a preferential screening of these genes.In this study, the complete mtDNA was screened for heteroplasmic mutations using denaturing high‐performance liquid chromatography (DHPLC) analysis in a group of 116 unrelated patients suspected for OXPHOS disease but without the common mutations for mitochondrial encephalomyopathy, lactic acidosis and stroke‐like syndrome (MELAS) m.3243A→G, myoclonic epilepsy, ragged red fibres (MERRF) m.8344A→G, Leigh/neuropathy, ataxia and retinitis pigmentosa m.8993T→G/C or large deletions. For this group of patients, we report that the ND5 gene is a commonly mutated gene.     

Knockout mouse models of sperm flagellum anomalies

To date, 21 knockout mouse models are known to bear specific anomalies of the sperm flagellum structures leading to motility disorders. In addition, genes responsible for flagellar defects of two well-known spontaneous mutant mice have recently been identified. These models reveal genetic factors, which are required for the proper assembly of the axoneme, the annulus, the mitochondrial sheath and the fibrous sheath. Many of these genetic factors follow unexpected cellular pathways to act on sperm flagellum morphogenesis. These mouse models may bear anomalies which are restricted to the spermatozoa or display more complex phenotypes that often include neuropathies and/or cilia-related diseases. In human, several structural disorders of the sperm flagellum found in brothers or consanguineous men probably have a genetic origin, but the genes involved have not yet been identified. The mutant mice we present in this review are invaluable models, which can be used to identify potential candidate genes for infertile men with specific sperm flagellum anomalies.     

Organismal effects of mitochondrial dysfunction

Mitochondrial disease can lead to clinical abnormalities in any organ system. Both inherited and spontaneous disorders are known. The spontaneous forms can occur as a mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutation early in embryogenesis or, later in life, as somatic mutations that accumulate with age. The inherited forms may arise from any of >100 characterized mutations in mtDNA or from >200 nuclear gene defects that affect proteins required for mitochondrial function. Most dividing cells survive and interact normally despite their mitochondrial defects. Thus post-mitotic, terminally differentiated cells are preferentially affected in mitochondrial disease. This review emphasizes cellular metabolic co-operation and the structural and biochemical diversity of mitochondria as the framework for understanding the clinical spectrum of mitochondrial disease. The principles of the mitochondrial clinical assessment scale I (MCAS-I) are presented to assist in the development of diagnostic spectra of mitochondrial disease.     

Transmission of the human mitochondrial genome

The segregation and transmission of mitochondrial genomes in humans are complicated processes, but are particularly important for understanding the inheritance and clinical abnormalities of mitochondrial disorders. This review describes three aspects of mitochondrial genetics. First, that the segregation and transmission of mitochondrial (mt)DNA molecules are likely to be determined by their physical association within the organelles and by the dynamics of mitochondrial structure and subcellular organization. Second, that the transmission of heteroplasmic mtDNA sequence changes from one generation to the next often involves rapid shifts in allele frequency. For >20 years, the standard explanation has been that there is a developmental bottleneck in which, at some stage of oogenesis, there is a reduction in the effective number of mitochondrial units of inheritance. The third aspect is that ongoing analyses of the segregation and transmission of pathogenic mtDNA mutations indicate the operation of multiple genetic processes. Thus, the segregation and transmission of mtDNA mutations occurs predominantly, but not exclusively, under conditions of random genetic drift. However, there is also evidence for bias due to incomplete ascertainment of pedigrees and for negative selection of pathogenic mutations in rapidly dividing somatic tissues such as the white blood cell population.     

Mutation in subdomain G' of mitochondrial elongation factor G1 is associated with combined OXPHOS deficiency in fibroblasts but not in muscle

The mitochondrial translation system is responsible for the synthesis of 13 proteins required for oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS), the major energy-generating process of our cells. Mitochondrial translation is controlled by various nuclear encoded proteins. In 27 patients with combined OXPHOS deficiencies, in whom complex II (the only complex that is entirely encoded by the nuclear DNA) showed normal activities, and mutations in the mitochondrial genome as well as polymerase gamma were excluded, we screened all mitochondrial translation factors for mutations. Here, we report a mutation in mitochondrial elongation factor G1 (GFM1) in a patient affected by severe, rapidly progressive mitochondrial encephalopathy. This mutation is predicted to result in an Arg250Trp substitution in subdomain G' of the elongation factor G1 protein and is presumed to hamper ribosome-dependent GTP hydrolysis. Strikingly, the decrease in enzyme activities of complex I, III and IV detected in patient fibroblasts was not found in muscle tissue. The OXPHOS system defects and the impairment in mitochondrial translation in fibroblasts were rescued by overexpressing wild-type GFM1, establishing the GFM1 defect as the cause of the fatal mitochondrial disease. Furthermore, this study evinces the importance of a thorough diagnostic biochemical analysis of both muscle tissue and fibroblasts in patients suspected to suffer from a mitochondrial disorder, as enzyme deficiencies can be selectively expressed.     

Maternally inherited mitochondrial DNA disease in consanguineous families

Mitochondrial respiratory chain disease represents one of the most common inborn errors of metabolism and is genetically heterogeneous, with biochemical defects arising from mutations in the mitochondrial genome (mtDNA) or the nuclear genome. As such, inheritance of mitochondrial respiratory chain disease can either follow dominant or recessive autosomal (Mendelian) inheritance patterns, the strictly matrilineal inheritance observed with mtDNA point mutations or X-linked inheritance. Parental consanguinity in respiratory chain disease is often assumed to infer an autosomal recessive inheritance pattern, and the analysis of mtDNA may be overlooked in the pursuit of a presumed nuclear genetic defect. We report the histochemical, biochemical and molecular genetic investigations of two patients with suspected mitochondrial disease who, despite being born to consanguineous first-cousin parents, were found to harbour well-characterised pathogenic mtDNA mutations, both of which were maternally transmitted. Our findings highlight that any diagnostic algorithm for the investigation of mitochondrial respiratory chain disease must include a full and complete analysis of the entire coding sequence of the mitochondrial genome in a clinically relevant tissue. An autosomal basis for respiratory chain disease should not be assumed in consanguineous families and that 'maternally inherited consanguineous' mitochondrial disease may thus be going undiagnosed.     

Mitochondria: potential roles in embryogenesis and nucleocytoplasmic transfer

This review examines current understanding of mammalian mitochondria and mitochondrial DNA in the light of new reproductive technologies. Mitochondria are central to ageing, apoptosis, metabolism and many diseases. They are controlled by a dual genome system, with cooperation between endogenous mitochondrial genes and mitochondrial genes translocated to the nucleus over the course of evolution. This translocation has been accompanied by extreme compression of the mitochondrial genome, with little tolerance for mutations or heteroplasmy (multiple genomes). The highly compact mitochondrial genome appears to be maintained by a stringent numerical bottleneck in embryogenesis and oogenesis, followed by clonal expansion from a highly selected subset of precursor molecules. The dual nature of control between nucleus and cytoplasm sets up potential conflicts, which are normally resolved by natural selection. Such potentially opposing interests and mechanisms are probably partly to blame for the poor rates of success in cloning animals by nuclear transfer. The ability to construct cell systems and animal embryos with novel combinations and permutations of nuclear and cytoplasmic genes will provide powerful tools for examining these fundamental biological questions. Clinically, attempts to 'rescue' abnormal human oocytes or embryos by cytoplasmic transfer risk complex and unpredictable outcomes emerging from disharmonious nuclear-cytoplasmic interactions.     

A novel NDUFA1 mutation leads to a progressive mitochondrial complex I-specific neurodegenerative disease

Mitochondrial diseases have been shown to result from mutations in mitochondrial genes located in either the nuclear DNA (nDNA) or mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA). Mitochondrial OXPHOS complex I has 45 subunits encoded by 38 nuclear and 7 mitochondrial genes. Two male patients in a putative X-linked pedigree exhibiting a progressive neurodegenerative disorder and a severe muscle complex I enzyme defect were analyzed for mutations in the 38 nDNA and seven mtDNA encoded complex I subunits. The nDNA X-linked NDUFA1 gene (MWFE polypeptide) was discovered to harbor a novel missense mutation which changed a highly conserved glycine at position 32 to an arginine, shown to segregate with the disease. When this mutation was introduced into a NDUFA1 null hamster cell line, a substantial decrease in the complex I assembly and activity was observed. When the mtDNA of the patient was analyzed, potentially relevant missense mutations were observed in the complex I genes. Transmitochondrial cybrids containing the patient’s mtDNA resulted in a mild complex I deficiency. Interestingly enough, the nDNA encoded MWFE polypeptide has been shown to interact with various mtDNA encoded complex I subunits. Therefore, we hypothesize that the novel G32R mutation in NDUFA1 is causing complex I deficiency either by itself or in synergy with additional mtDNA variants.