"Atypical" Spitz's nevus, "malignant" Spitz's nevus, and "metastasizing" Spitz's nevus: a critique in historical perspective of three concepts flawed fatally

Our purpose in undertaking this Arbeit was to review all articles published about "atypical" Spitz's nevus, "malignant" Spitz's nevus, and "metastasizing" Spitz's nevus, to criticize them in a fashion that illuminates, and to come to conclusions compellingly about those subjects. We found that an overwhelming majority of neoplasms that claimed to be "atypical Spitz's nevus," "metastasizing Spitz's nevus," and "malignant Spitz's nevus" were, in fact, melanomas ( Table 1). Moreover, in our estimation, those designations, and variants of them, like "atypical Spitz's lesion," "atypical dermal melanocytic lesion with features of Spitz's nevus," "atypical Spitzoid melanocytic neoplasm," and "problematic Spitzoid melanocytic lesion," are mere evasions from a diagnosis, straightforwardly, of either Spitz's nevus or melanoma. Diagnoses in pathology equally bogus are "minimal deviation melanoma," "borderline melanoma," "nevoid melanoma," "potentially low-grade melanocytic neoplasm," and "melanocytic lesion of uncertain biologic potential." Rather than admit uncertainty forthrightly, those who employ circumlocutions like those just mentioned resort to linguistic maneuvers that, at first blush, seem to be "academic" and constructed in such a way as to appear to convey confidence, rather than tentativeness, on the part of a histopathologist. On further scrutiny, however, each of those cliches is revealed to be devoid of content. For example, "malignant" Spitz's nevus and "metastasizing" Spitz's nevus not only are contradictions in terms, but they are outrageous violations of fundamental principles of classic Virchowian pathology, and "atypical" Spitz's nevus not only is a redundancy because the neoplasm was so atypical to Spitz, herself, she insisted (from the time she spawned the idea in 194 through 1951 it was a "malignant melanoma," but is abject intellectually, those who invoke it never setting forth, in clear-cut fashion, criteria for what constitutes a "typical" Spitz's nevus in contradistinction to an "atypical" one.     

Nevus of large spindle and/or epithelioid cells (Spitz's nevus).

By now it is well recognized that there is a benign melanocytic nevus, common in the young and common enough in adults, that has histological features that are confusable with those of malignant melanoma. The anomaly is usually referred to as benign juvenile melanoma, sometimes as Spitz's nevus, and, by some histopathologists, as spindle and epithelioid cell nevus. All the histological subtleties and variations of the condition are still not fully appreciated and some of them are still being misinterpreted as those of malignant melanoma. We herewith present a study designed to clarify the issue and offer firm criteria for histological differentiation of the nevus in point from malignant melanoma. We also suggest a new name for it and supporting arguments therefor.     

A Current Dilemma in Histopathology: Atypical Spitz Tumor or Spitzoid Melanoma?

Both clinically and histopathologically, melanoma of childhood is a rarely encountered lesion. In addition, it has particular histopathologic diagnostic problems. Differential diagnosis of this lesion and Spitz nevus is at times very problematic, in that distant metastases and death of the patient may be the only diagnostic criteria for some cases. We present a 4-year-old girl with an atypical melanocytic neoplasm with Spitzoid features on the left subscapular region.     

Eosinophilic globules in pigmented spindle cell nevus.

Reed's pigmented spindle cell nevus is often misdiagnosed as malignant melanoma despite reliable clinical and histopathologic diagnostic features. In the present report, 10 cases of pigmented spindle cell nevus were studied with step sections to identify Kamino's eosinophilic globules. Eighty percent of the cases disclosed numerous eosinophilic globules, supporting the hypothesis that this nevus is a variant of Spitz's nevus. Kamino's eosinophilic globules could be considered another important sign for the differential diagnosis between pigmented spindle cell nevus and malignant melanoma.     

Epithelioid blue nevus: neoplasm Sui generis or variation on a theme?

The epithelioid blue nevus has recently been associated with the Carney complex, which is characterized by myxomas, spotty skin pigmentation, endocrine overactivity, and schwannomas. Using the general criteria proposed by Carney and Ferreiro, similar lesions were identified in 33 patients with no evidence of the Carney complex. Those lesions presented on the face, trunk and extremities of 15 males and 18 females. The mean age was 35 years, much older than those in the Carney complex (mean 16.3 years). Clinical diagnoses included malignant blue nevus, atypical nevus, melanoma, congenital nevus, and dermatofibroma. The lesions were symmetric, predominantly dermal melanocytic proliferations arranged as short fascicles, small nests, and single cells. Large polygonal and epithelioid melanocytes with moderate pleomorphism, and occasional nuclear pseudoinclusions were admixed with heavily pigmented dendritic and spindled melanocytes and melanophages. Rare mitotic figures were seen in some cases. The neoplasms showed a morphologic spectrum that encompassed a group of combined blue nevi with epithelioid melanocytes and other Spitz's nevus characteristics. These epithelioid combined nevi (ECN) fell into three phenotypes with morphologies that most closely paralleled those pictured by Carney and Ferreiro in the Carney complex: the classic or Carney complex pattern (ECN-CC), those that showed overlap with deep penetrating nevus (ECN-DPN), and those that have many dermal Spitz's nevus features, [BLue + SpITZ's nevus; (ECN-BLITZ)I. In six cases, there was such an admixture of features that it was difficult to ascribe them to one of the groups. Nine lesions had associated banal congenital nevus. Follow-up that averaged over 2.5 years (31 months) (range 6-162 months) showed no evidence of malignancy or recurrent disease after excision. Epithelioid combined nevus is a type of combined nevus with blue nevus and Spitz's nevus features, which may or may not be associated with the Carney complex. It shows morphologic overlap with the epithelioid blue nevus described by Carney (ECN-CC), deep penetrating nevus (ECN-DPN), and blue nevus with intradermal Spitz's (desmoplastic) nevus (ECN-BLITZ). Epithelioid combined nevus is thought to be a fitting nosologic designation for all of these lesions.     

"Atypical" blue nevus, "malignant" blue nevus, and "metastasizing" blue nevus: a critique in historical perspective of three concepts flawed fatally

The same errors that spawned, sustained, and continue to spur the notions of "atypical" Spitz's nevus, "malignant" Spitz's nevus, and "metastasizing" Spitz's nevus are animating of 3 other concepts flawed equally, namely, those of "atypical blue nevus," "malignant blue nevus," and "metastasizing blue nevus." Our intention here is to compel to the conclusion, by way of critique in historical perspective, that all neoplasms claimed to be "malignant blue nevus" and "metastasizing blue nevus;" in fact, are melanomas, that all "atypical blue nevi" are either a nevus or a melanoma, and that the trio of curious designations that serve as title of this work are mere evasions transparently from a diagnosis, straightforwardly, of 1 of only 3 possibilities, to wit, "blue nevus," melanoma, or melanoma in association with a "blue nevus." Rather than admit uncertainty forthrightly, those who employ circumlocutions that we deplore, such as those under scrutiny here, resort to linguistic maneuvers that, at first blush, seem to have the cachet of scholarship (the jargon used being in keeping with a slew of other well-accepted, but equally bogus diagnoses in [dermato]pathology, among those being "minimal deviation melanoma," "borderline melanoma," "nevoid melanoma," "potentially low-grade melanocytic neoplasm," and "melanocytic proliferation of uncertain biologic potential"). All those terms and phrases are constructed in a manner designed to make them appear to convey unbridled confidence on the part of a histopathologist, rather than what they are in actuality, that is, a cover abjectly for tentativeness. Scrutiny of the lingo, in very abbreviated form, just catalogued reveals it to be devoid of content utterly. For example, "malignant blue nevus" and "metastasizing blue nevus" not only are contradictions in terms, but they are outrageous violations of principles fundamental to classic Virchowian pathology. We seek here to debunk that claptrap in the same manner we did "atypical Spitz's nevus," "malignant Spitz's nevus," and "metastasizing Spitz's nevus." It is our hope that readers will consider our arguments worthy because they are logical, will find them convincing because they are irrefutable, and will incorporate the lessons communicated through them so that their own professional life, pathology as a discipline, and, ultimately, patients, are the beneficiaries.     

Spitz样肿瘤320例临床及组织病理分析

【摘要】 目的 总结Spitz样肿瘤的临床及组织病理特征。方法 回顾2005年1月至2020年1月西京皮肤医院确诊的320例Spitz样肿瘤患者的临床及病理资料。结果 320例患者中,男141例,女179例,年龄0 ~ 65（12.5 ± 11.7）岁,病程1个月至30年;其中,Spitz痣307例,不典型Spitz肿瘤（AST）8例,Spitz痣样黑素瘤（SM）5例。皮损多为单发,可见于头面部、躯干和四肢,边界均清楚。307例Spitz痣皮损以黑色（132例,43.0%）和红色（108例,35.1%）为主,多数色素均匀（262例,85.3%）且表面平滑（272例,88.6%）。Spitz痣存在特殊临床亚型,11例 （3.6%）发生在斑痣上,11例 （3.6%）呈簇发性,6例（2.0%）播散性,7例（2.3%）结节性,1例（0.3%）为瘢痕疙瘩样。Spitz痣特征性病理表现包括表皮内痣细胞呈Paget样扩散（123例,40.1%）,真表皮交界处出现Kamino小体（74例,24.1%）,痣细胞呈水平带状（177例,57.8%）及楔形分布（118例,38.4%）,痣细胞巢周围出现裂隙（177例,57.8%）,可见生理性核分裂象（117例,38.1%）,核染色质均细腻。根据特殊组织病理表现,Spitz痣又分为色素性上皮样Spitz痣（9例,2.9%）、结缔组织增生性Spitz痣（13例,4.2%）、血管瘤样Spitz痣（8例,2.6%）、疣状Spitz痣（12例,3.9%）、黏液样Spitz痣（10例,3.3%）、晕痣样Spitz痣（4例,1.3%） 等。4例AST皮损为黑色,7例色素均匀,3例皮损表面粗糙;特征病理表现包括细胞均有轻度至中度的异型性,均可见核分裂象（7例为2 ~ 6个/mm2）,5例核染色质粗糙。3例SM皮损呈红色,4例色素不均匀,3例表面粗糙;特征病理表现包括黑素细胞呈Paget样扩散（3例）,瘤细胞呈无极性浸润性生长且均未见成熟现象,均有明显异型性,并可见病理性核分裂象（3例, > 6个/mm2）,核染色质均粗糙且核膜明显着色。结论 Spitz样肿瘤的临床及组织病理表现具有特征性,Spitz痣的临床及病理亚型繁多,AST同时具有Spitz痣和黑素瘤的临床及组织学特征。     

Spitz nevus and atypical spitzoid neoplasm

Spitz nevus (SN) and Spitzoid malignant melanoma (SMM) represent benign and malignant counterparts at both ends of the spectrum of Spitzoid lesions. Atypical Spitzoid neoplasm (ASN) is a poorly defined and characterized category of melanocytic tumors with histologic features of both benign Spitz nevi and malignant melanomas. The group of ASN represents a mixture of Spitz nevi with atypical features and Spitzoid melanomas. However, at the current moment in time, histopathologists are not capable of differentiating between the 2 in some cases and are forced to place them in this ambiguous category, where the behavior of these lesions cannot be predicted with certainty. Because this group encompasses both benign and malignant lesions, and perhaps also a separate category of melanocytic tumors that behave better than conventional melanomas, some of these neoplasms can metastasize and kill patients, whereas others have no metastatic potential, and yet others might only metastasize to regional lymph nodes. Although diagnostic accuracy has improved over the years, many of these lesions remain controversial, and there is still poor interobserver agreement in classifying problematic Spitzoid lesions among experienced dermatopathologists. The objective of this review article is to summarize the most relevant information about SN and ASNs. At this time histologic examination remains the golden standard for diagnosing these melanocytic neoplasms. We therefore concentrate on the histopathologic, clinical, and dermoscopic aspects of these lesions. We also review the most recent advances in immunohistochemical and molecular diagnostics as well as discuss the controversies and dilemma regarding whether to consider sentinel lymph node biopsy for diagnostically ambiguous melanocytic neoplasms.     

Dysplastic changes in different types of melanocytic nevi. A unifying concept

We observed histopathologic changes previously described in dysplastic melanocytic nevi in association with a dermal component characteristic of other types of melanocytic nevi or overlapping with features of other varieties of nevi. In order to determine the frequency of these changes, we studied 2,164 cases of compound melanocytic nevi that fulfilled the histopathologic criteria for the diagnosis of compound dysplastic nevus, including architectural pattern, cytologic features, and mesenchymal changes. Of the 2,164 compound dysplastic melanocytic nevi, 1,895 (87.6%) had the histopathologic characteristics previously described for dysplastic nevus, 179 (8.3%) showed a dermal component with a congenital pattern, 67 (3.1%) demonstrated epidermal and dermal characteristics of Spitz's nevus, 8 (0.3%) had features of a combined blue nevus, 13 (0.6%) had a halo phenomenon and 2 (0.1%) showed dermal neuronevus. By considering these nevi as variants of dysplastic nevi, one may apply a unified conceptual basis for their nomenclature. In order to completely describe the appearance of the nevus, we named them by adding the term "dysplastic", to their main histopathologic subtype. Accordingly, six different varieties of dysplastic nevi were identified: 1) dysplastic nevus (original); 2) dysplastic nevus with a congenital pattern; 3) dysplastic Spitz's nevus; 4) dysplastic combined blue nevus; 5) dysplastic halo nevus; and 6) dysplastic neuronevus. In summary, we conclude that the histopathologic criteria previously reported for the diagnosis of dysplastic nevi may be found in association with a dermal component characteristic of other types of melanocytic nevi or may have overlapping features with other variants of nevi.     

Differential diagnosis of Spitzoid melanocytic neoplasms

Atypical Spitzoid neoplasms represent a controversial and incompletely defined diagnostic category for lesions with intermediate architecture and cytomorphology between Spitz nevus and melanoma. The vast majority of these neoplasms have a good overall prognosis. Only a small proportion of patients will end up developing distant metastases and death. The distinction between Spitz tumours with atypical features and Spitzoid melanoma remains difficult on clinical and histological grounds and the prediction of the biological behaviour of those tumours even with sentinel lymph node biopsy is impossible. Tools such as immunohistochemistry, genetic analysis, mutation analysis and mass spectometry have contributed to the better understanding of those tumours and may be useful in the differential diagnosis of Spitzoid tumours.     

Desmoplastic nevus: An entity distinct from spitz nevus and blue nevus

Desmoplastic (sclerotic) nevus is an infrequently reported poorly characterized benign melanocytic proliferation, with only 4 case series published to date. To better define this nevus, we examined the clinical and histologic features of 25 lesions. Desmoplastic nevus is seen in both children and adults and can be located on the face, trunk, or extremities. There is a female predominance. Clinically, it can resemble intradermal nevus, atypical nevus, melanoma, and pigmented basal cell carcinoma. These are generally small, symmetric, and well-circumscribed lesions, averaging 3.5 mm in diameter. The most distinctive features include predominantly compound growth, a zonal configuration with greater cellularity in the superficial portion of the lesion, and a mixture of melanocytic phenotypes including type A, B, and C nevus cells, ovoid and dendritic melanocytes, and Spitzoid melanocytes. A distinctive eosinophilic stroma which either resembles that of a dermatofibroma or neurofibroma is always present. Variable amounts of melanin pigment are found in both tumor cells and macrophages, but this is not a prominent feature. Mitotic activity is exceedingly rare (1 case), and pleomorphism is minimal. These lesions are distinct from typical compound nevus, Spitz nevus, epithelioid blue nevus, and desmoplastic melanoma, to which they are often compared. Strict application of these histologic features allows definitive diagnosis of desmoplastic nevus as a distinct form of a benign melanocytic nevus.     

Focal Regression‐Like Changes in Dysplastic Back Nevi :A Diagnostic Pitfall for Malignant Melanoma

The spectrum of melanocytic proliferations ranges from banal to overtly malignant. Borderline melanocytic lesions which bridge these two extremes pose a challenge, as their biological nature remains undefined. We set out to evaluate the utility of the sentinel lymph node biopsy in such lesions. Our compendium was defined by 11 cases of borderline melanocytic proliferations whereby sentinel node sampling was conducted. There were three severely atypical dermal‐epidermal melanocytic proliferations manifesting borderline features with nevoid melanoma (calf, shoulder, knee), three arising in association with a deep penetrating nevus (chest, shoulder, and arm), three atypical Spitz's tumors (helix, calf, arm, back), and two atypical pigment‐synthesizing melanocytic tumors, resembling equine melanotic disease in one and cellular blue nevus in another (buttock, calf, arm). The patient population comprised seven males and five females ranging in age from age 9–36 (mean: 25 years). At least one positive sentinel lymph node was uncovered in seven of the cases with a positive sentinel lymph observed in all but one case of deep penetrating nevus and atypical Spitz's tumor. The identification of sentinel lymph node positivity in seven of the twelve cases (58%) validates the role of sentinel lymph node biopsy in the setting of borderline melanocytic proliferations.     

A Case of Spitzoid Melanoma

Spitzoid melanoma is a subtype of melanoma that, clinically and histologically, resembles a Spitz nevus. Clinically, spitzoid melanomas usually evolve from amelanotic nodular lesions, growing to 1 cm or more in diameter. They often remain clinically undiagnosed because of their wide variety of clinical appearances and a lack of pigmentation. Distinguishing a Spitz nevus from a spitzoid melanoma can be extremely difficult. Features that favor the diagnosis of a spitzoid melanoma are asymmetrical shape, diameter greater than 1 cm, a lesion with a deep invasive component, and a high degree of cytologic atypia. There have been only rare reports in the literature of the presence of giant cells in malignant melanoma, and the presence of these cells may result in its misdiagnosis as a histiocytic tumor. We present a case of spitzoid melanoma on the right ankle of a 22-year-old-woman.     

Nevo de Spitz y otros tumores spitzoides en la infancia. Parte 1: aspectos clínicos,histológicos e inmunohistoquímicos

A Spitz nevus is a melanocytic neoplasm of epithelioid and/or spindle cells that usually appears in childhood. These lesions are by nature benign, but their features can sometimes make them difficult to distinguish from melanomas. Spitzoid melanocytic lesions have been grouped into 3 types in recent decades: Spitz nevi, atypical Spitz tumors, and spitzoid melanomas. Atypical Spitz tumors are spitzoid melanocytic proliferations that have atypical histopathologic features that are insufficient to support a diagnosis of melanoma. The malignant potential of these lesions is at present uncertain. This review examines the clinical, dermoscopic, and histopathologic features of this group of lesions.     

Fluorescence in situ hybridization for distinguishing cellular blue nevi from blue nevus-like melanoma

Background: Blue nevus‐like melanomas are melanomas that arise in association with blue nevi or closely simulate the histopathologic appearance of a blue nevus, usually a cellular blue nevus (CBN). Although the majority of CBN can be readily distinguished from blue nevus‐like melanoma by conventional microscopy, there are a subset of cases where this distinction may be exceedingly difficult or impossible. Methods: In this study, we evaluated the ability of a fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) assay targeting 6p25 (RREB1), 6q23 (MYB), 11q13 (CCND1) and the centromere of chromosome 6 (Cep6) to distinguish between CBN and blue nevus‐like melanoma. We identified five cases of blue nevus‐like melanoma and 12 cases of CBN. Results: The FISH assay was performed with 100% sensitivity and 100% specificity. Three of five cases met the 6p25/Cep6 criteria, all five met the 6p25 gain criteria and three of five met the 6q23/Cep6 loss criteria. None of the cases met criteria for gains in 11q13. None of the 12 CBN met any criteria for melanoma. Conclusions: A combined analysis of clinical aspects, histopathologic changes and FISH analysis could potentially contribute significantly to the ability of pathologists to discriminate between blue nevus‐like melanoma and blue nevi in challenging cases. Gammon B, Beilfuss B, Guitart J, Busam KJ, Gerami P. Fluorescence in situ hybridization for distinguishing cellular blue nevi from blue nevus‐like melanoma.     

Melanoma within naevus spilus: 5 cases

BACKGROUND: Nevus spilus is defined as café-au-lait macules with dark maculopapular speckles. Histologically, it has the aspect of lentigo associated with nevocellular nevus. There are 3 types of nevus spilus: small or medium-sized (<20 cm), giant and zosteriform. Malignant transformation of nevus spilus is rare. PATIENTS AND METHODS: We analyzed the cases of 5 patients presenting melanoma within nevus spilus as well as 20 published cases. The evaluation criteria were: for nevus spilus: size, type, topography, age of onset and presence of dysplastic nevi within the nevus spilus; for melanoma: clinical aspect, histological type, thickness, level and age at diagnosis. The presence of other risk factors for melanoma was noted. RESULTS: The 14 women and 11 men had a mean age of 49 years at melanoma diagnosis. Type of nevus spilus was: small or medium-sized (15 cases), zosteriform (6 cases) and giant (4 cases). Only 3 nevi spili were<4 cm in diameter. Nevus spilus was present since birth (11 cases), childhood (7 cases), after the age of 20 years (3 cases) and was unspecified in 4 cases. Three of our five patients had other risk factors for melanoma. Two patients were presenting 2 melanomas within nevus spilus. The histological type of melanoma was not specified in 8 cases but SSM was the most common type (13 cases). Median Breslow thickness was 1.25 mm (0.27 to 8 mm) for the 19 cases in which it was specified. CONCLUSION: The following criteria appeared to be associated with risk of developing melanoma in nevus spilus patients: nevus spilus present since birth, nevus spilus over 4 cm in diameter, and giant or zosteriform nevus spilus. Development of melanoma within nevus spilus is a rare event. Consequently, guidelines for follow-up of nevus spilus cannot be defined. However, follow-up is recommended, and in particular, self-examination.     

Melanomas in prepubescent children: review comprehensively,critique historically,criteria diagnostically,and course biologically

Our series was comprised of 11 children age 10 years or younger (6 were younger than age 5) with primary cutaneous melanoma. All of the melanomas occurred de novo and all metastasized; one child died. In no instance was melanoma a clinical consideration, and in none did the histopathologist who first "signed out" the case make a diagnosis of melanoma. Despite the inability of clinicians and pathologists to diagnose correctly, with repeatability, melanomas that develop in children yet to be pubescent, those neoplasms, nonetheless, are melanomas and, therefore, criteria employed currently for diagnosis of melanoma, especially clinically, must be refined in order that they be applicable equally to melanomas in pre- and postpubescents. The vaunted ABCDs (Asymmetry, Border irregular, Color variability, Diameter >6.0mm) surely do not work for melanomas that appear in children who are prepubescent. Additionally, melanomas that occur in these children have distinctly different architectural and cytopathological features from those that arise in postpubescents, often being confused as they are by conventional microscopy with a Spitz's nevus. As a rule, melanomas in prepubescent children grow much more rapidly then those in adults but, like them, have the capability to disseminate widely and cause death.     

Unusual form of melanocytic nevus associated with Turner's syndrome

An 11-year-old girl with Turner's syndrome developed a combined nevus on the back. The examination of the excised specimen revealed the combination of common compound nevus and a component of Spitz's nevus. Numerous melanocytic nevi are a feature of Turner's syndrome, but this appears to be the first case of a combined nevus with Spitz's component.