Multidirectional depiction of internal carotid arterial stenosis: three-dimensional time-of-flight MR angiography versus rotational and conventional digital subtraction angiography

PURPOSE: To evaluate whether and to what extent greater number of projection images obtained at three-dimensional (3D) time-of-flight (TOF) magnetic resonance (MR) angiography versus conventional digital subtraction angiography (DSA) causes overestimation of internal carotid arterial (ICA) stenosis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: DSA (two or three projections), rotational angiography (16 or 32 projections), and 3D TOF MR angiography (12 projections) were performed in 47 stenotic ICAs of 38 symptomatic patients. Two observers independently measured maximum stenosis, and the mean differences among MR angiography, DSA, and rotational angiography were compared. RESULTS: Three rotational and five MR angiograms were nondiagnostic. Seven MR angiograms of ICA stenoses showed a signal void and were excluded from analysis. On the remaining 32 angiograms, mean differences in maximum stenosis for observers 1 and 2, respectively, were 7% (95% CI: 3%, 12%) and 8% (95% CI: 3%, 13%) at MR angiography versus DSA and 2% (95% CI: -2%, 7%) and -1% (95% CI: -5%, 3%) at MR angiography versus rotational angiography. ICA stenosis was graded significantly higher at MR angiography versus DSA, whereas, it was not overestimated at MR angiography versus rotational angiography. The difference in maximum stenosis at MR angiography versus DSA was significantly different from that of MR angiography versus rotational angiography. CONCLUSION: Apparent overestimation of ICA stenosis at 3D TOF MR angiography versus conventional DSA may be partly explained by the greater number of projection images available at 3D TOF MR angiography.     

Diagnosis of carotid artery stenosis: comparison of 2DFT time-of-flight MR angiography with contrast angiography in 50 patients

Fifty patients underwent 2DFT time-of-flight MR angiography and intraarterial contrast angiography for evaluation of possible carotid atherosclerotic disease. The MR angiography technique employed contiguous axial flow-sensitive (short TR/TE) slices that were reformatted and postprocessed by using a maximum-intensity projection algorithm to provide 16 angiographic views of the carotid arteries. Both studies were independently reviewed by two observers in a blinded manner. Carotid arteries were categorized as normal, mildly stenotic, moderately stenotic, severely stenotic, or occluded. For the 94 carotid arteries available for review, one observer reported a 70% agreement between the two techniques and the second observer reported a 56% agreement (p = .0001). The best correlation was in the severely stenotic category and the worst was in the occluded category. Agreement between observers was 67% for MR angiography and 72% for contrast angiography, which was similar to that between the two techniques. Although not all carotid atherosclerotic disease was visualized equally well, 2DFT time-of-flight MR angiography had a good overall correlation with the "gold standard" of intraarterial contrast angiography, supporting its use as a screening technique. While further improvements are needed, use of MR angiography as the primary diagnostic tool for many patients with suspected carotid stenosis should continue to increase.     

Contrast-enhanced MR angiography in patients with carotid artery stenosis: comparison of two different techniques with an unenhanced 2D time-of-flight sequence

Conventional time-of-flight (TOF) MR angiography (MRA) in carotid artery stenosis relies on flow-related enhancement to produce signal from vascular structures. Intravoxel phase dispersion, due to vortices, causes loss of signal and is the reason for the tendency to overestimate the degree of stenosis. In contrast-enhanced MRA, intravascular signal is mainly dependent on T1 shortening of the blood. We compared first-pass contrast-enhanced MRA (contrast-enhanced 3D gradient echo, ce3D GRE) and contrast-enhanced 2D TOF (ce2D TOF) sequences with an unenhanced 2D TOF in 13 patients with carotid artery stenosis, assessing delineation of the carotid bifurcation, enhancement of veins and grade of stenosis. The contrast-enhanced techniques produced more morphological detail, the ce3D GRE being superior to the ce2D TOF. Four carotid arteries were reclassified into lesser stenosis categories using the ce3D GRE technique. However, seven carotid arteries (27 %) were rated as nondiagnostic on the ce3D GRE, mainly due to masking of the carotid bifurcation by veins. The latter can be avoided by decreasing the acquisition time; on our 1.5-T system we could achieve a minimum time of 23 s per 3D GRE. Further reduction of acquisition time would be necessary to incorporate this method into clinical routine, requiring higher-performance gradients, which are not available in many UK hospitals. Received: 25 February 1999 Accepted: 29 July 1999     

Three-dimensional magnetization-prepared time-of-flight MR angiography of the carotid and vertebral arteries

Three-dimensional magnetization-prepared (MP) MR angiography (MRA) was applied to the carotid and vertebral arteries by using ECG triggering, a slab selective RF inversion pulse, centric phase encoding and acquisition during diastole. Both theoretically and experimentally, the MP MRA sequence was shown to perform well in cases where there was substantial blood replenishment during the inversion time Tl (>330 ms). In comparison with standard, ungated, steady-state 3D time-of-flight MRA in 13 consecutive volunteers, the MP MRA images demonstrated better background suppression with less artifact and generally had more uniform vessel depiction. The MP MRA sequence was generally superior for portraying vessels exhibiting high pulsatility such as the carotid siphon. However, in distal vessels with slow flow and incomplete blood replenishment, the MP MRA technique was inferior due to increased loss of vessel signal. The reasons for this increased signal loss are identified and improvements to the MP MRA sequence are suggested.     

Intracranial vascular stenosis and occlusion: comparison of 3D time-of-flight and 3D phase-contrast MR angiography

We compared the value of 3D time-of-flight (TOF) and phase-contrast (PC) MR angiography (MRA) for detection and grading of intracranial vascular steno-occlusive disease. Unenhanced 3D-TOF MRA and 3D-PC MRA (30–60 cm/s velocity encoding) were performed at the level of the circle of Willis in 18 patients, mean age 56 ± 10 years. Postprocessed images using a maximum-intensity projection reconstruction with multiple targetted projections were analysed. A total of 126 vessels was assessed by PC MRA and 143 by TOF MRA, with digital subtraction angiography (DSA) in 15 patients and/or transcranial Doppler sonography (TCD) in 18 as a standard. Two blinded readers reviewed the MRA, DSA and TCD examinations retrospectively. On DSA and/or TCD the two observers found 32 and 28 steno-occlusive lesions. 3D-TOF MRA was more sensitive than 3D-PC MRA (87 % and 86 % vs. 65 % and 60 %) and had a higher negative predictive value (96 % vs. 89 %). Correct grading of stenoses was achieved in 78 % by 3D-TOF and 65 % by 3D-PC MRA. Received: 24 September 1997 Accepted: 27 February 1998     

Pulse sequence strategies for vascular contrast in time-of-flight carotid MR angiography

A systematic evaluation in healthy volunteers of the relative efficacy of various techniques for background suppression to improve two-dimensional (2D) and three-dimensional (3D) time-of-flight magnetic resonance angiography of the cervical carotid arteries was performed. Conventional 2D and 3D FISP (fast imaging with steady-state precession) sequences with flow compensation were compared with modifications of these sequences, including a tracking saturation pulse (2D), prolonged absolute TEs for fat suppression based on T2* decay (2D and 3D), frequency-selective saturation of fat (2D and 3D), in-plane spatial saturation (2D), and magnetization transfer contrast (2D and 3D). The tracking saturation pulse and slight overlap of the excitation sections provided uniform background suppression without impairing depiction of the morphology of the cervical carotid arteries. Frequency-selective fat saturation was the most effective background suppression scheme among the 2D and 3D techniques but was occasionally compromised by local field inhomo-geneities. Magnetization transfer contrast provided little suppression of stationary tissues in the neck because of the intrinsic limitations of the coil. In-plane spatial saturation yielded the highest background suppression but reduced apparent arterial diameters and could not be implemented in a 3D version. The T2* decay method not only reduced the apparent size of the vessels but also their signal intensity.     

三维增强磁共振血管成像和数字减影血管造影在颈部动脉狭窄闭塞性病变中的对比分析

目的 评价三维增强磁共振血管成像(3D-CE-MRA)诊断颈部动脉狭窄闭塞性病变的准确性及应用价值.方法 对43例可疑颈部动脉狭窄或闭塞的患者分别先后进行3D-CE-MRA和数字减影血管造影(DSA)检查,对成像结果进行对比研究.结果 与DSA相比,3D-CE-MRA 对颈部动脉狭窄闭塞性病变诊断的敏感度为83.0%,特异度为94.1%.结论 3D-CE-MRA对颈部动脉狭窄闭塞性病变的显示具有独特的优势,是一种无创、安全、快速、准确性高的检查方法,可以作为首选的检查方法.     

增强与门控二维时间飞跃法MR血管造影评价颈内动脉狭窄的对比研究

目的：评价对比剂增强MR血管造影（CE MRA）与心电门控二维时间飞跃法（Gated 2D TOF)MRA评价颈内动脉狭窄的准确性。方法：34例怀疑有颈内动脉狭窄的病人（男27例,女7例,年龄45－78岁）均接受了CE MRA、Gated 2D TOF MRA和DSA检查。MRA图像采用最大强度投影法重建后与DSA进行对比。评价两种MRA方法的敏感性、特异性、诊断准确性、高估狭窄和低估狭窄的情况。结果：（1）34例68条颈内动脉中,DSA诊断23条为正常,45条呈不同程度狭窄或闭塞,其中轻度狭窄10条、中度14条、重度17条、闭塞4条。CE MRA与DSA结果一致者66（97％）,2条高估。Gated 2D TOF MRA与DSA诊断一致者为56条（82％）,其中高估9条,低估3条。（2）以正常和狭窄或闭塞为判断点时,CE MRA较Gatde 2D TOF MRA的敏感性、特异性和诊断准确性高,分别为100％、100％、100％与95．6％、78．3％、89．4％。（3）以70％狭窄为判断点时,CE MRA与Gated 2D TOF MRA的敏感性、特异性和诊断准确性分别为100％、97．8％、98．5％与95．2％、93．6％、94．1％。Gated 2D TOF MRA与DSA比较的χ^2=3.000,P=0.083;CE MRA与DSA比较的χ^2=2.000,P=0.157;而Gated 2D TOF MRA与CE MRA比较的χ^2=1.600,P=0.206。结论：与Gated 2D TOF MRA相比,CE MRA评价颈动脉狭窄更可靠。     

Ultra-short echo-time 2D time-of-flight MR angiography using a half-pulse excitation.

Flow-related artifacts remain a significant concern for magnetic resonance (MR) angiography because their appearance in angiograms adversely impacts accuracy in evaluation of arterial stenoses. In this paper, a half-pulse excitation scheme for improved two-dimensional time-of-flight (2D TOF) angiography is described. The proposed method eliminates the need for gradient moment nulling (of all orders), providing significant reductions in spin dephasing and consequent artifactual signal loss. Furthermore, because the post-excitation refocusing and flow compensation gradients are obviated, the achievable echo time is dramatically shortened. The half-pulse excitation is employed in conjunction with a fast radial-line acquisition, allowing ultra-short echo times on the order of 250-300 microsec. Radial-line acquisition methods also provide additional benefits for flow imaging: effective mitigation of pulsatile flow artifacts, full k-space coverage, and decreased scan times. The half-pulse excitation/radial-line sequence demonstrated improved performance in initial clinical evaluations of the carotid bifurcation when compared with a conventional 2D TOF sequence.     

Multiple breathhold 3D time-of-flight MR angiography of the renal arteries

A technique is described for angiographic imaging of the renal arteries with acquisition performed over several periods of suspended respiration. The 3D Fourier transform (FT) gradient-echo angiographic sequence uses magnetization preparation and appropriately chosen delay times for background nulling and time-of-flight enhancement of the vasculature. The sequence was applied to 10 volunteers, each of whom was imaged in three ways: (i) over a series of breathholds in which feedback was provided to enable reproducible breath-holding; (ii) over a series of breathholds with no feedback; and (iii) over continuous respiration. Results were evaluated by measuring the transverse extent of the well-delineated renal vasculature and by noting the distal extent of the vasculature branching (main, segmental, and interlobar branches). The transverse extent of renal vasculature visible with breathhold feedback, breathholding, and free breathing was 6.1 ± 0.9 cm, 5.0 ±1.8 cm, and 4.0 ±1.4 cm, respectively (mean ± SD). Breathhold feedback enabled visualization of segmental renal arteries bilaterally in all 10 volunteers.     

Carotid artery stenosis: clinical efficacy of two-dimensional time-of-flight MR angiography.

To assess the clinical efficacy of two-dimensional time-of-flight magnetic resonance (MR) angiography in the evaluation of carotid artery stenosis, a group of patients was evaluated in which 73 vessels were studied with both MR and conventional angiography. Four experienced neuroradiologists each scored both the MR and conventional angiograms in a blinded manner by using a standardized scoring scheme. Comparison of the scores revealed a high degree of correlation. In particular, MR angiography served to discriminate reliably between mildly narrowed and severely narrowed or occluded vessels. Furthermore, severe stenoses were accurately discriminated from occlusions in all cases. MR angiography is a robust and accurate modality for the characterization of carotid artery stenosis. It is useful in conjunction with routine MR imaging of the brain in the evaluation of the patient with suspected carotid arterial disease.     

Diagnostic accuracy of contrast-enhanced MR angiography in severe carotid stenosis: meta-analysis with metaregression of different techniques

Contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance angiography (CE-MRA) has become a well-established noninvasive imaging method for the assessment of severe carotid stenosis (70–99% by NASCET criteria). However, CE-MRA is not a standardised technique, but encompasses different concurrent techniques. This review analyses possible differences. A bivariate random effects meta-analysis of 17 primary diagnostic accuracy studies confirmed a high pooled sensitivity of 94.3% and specificity of 93.0% for carotid CE-MRA in severe carotid stenosis. Sensitivity was fairly uniform among the studies, while specificity showed significant variation (I ² = 73%). Metaregressions found significant differences for specificity with two covariates: specificity was higher when using not only maximum intensity projection (MIP) images, but also three-dimensional (3D) images (P = 0.01). Specificity was also higher with electronic images than with hardcopies (P = 0.02). The timing technique (bolus-timed, fluoroscopically triggered or time-resolved) did not result in any significant differences in diagnostic accuracy. Some nonsignificant trends were found for the percentages of severe carotid disease, acquisition time and voxel size. In conclusion, in CE-MRA of severe carotid stenosis the three major timing techniques yield comparably high diagnostic accuracy, electronic images are more specific than hardcopies, and 3D images should be used in addition to MIP images to increase the specificity.     

Carotid artery stenosis: intraindividual correlations of 3D time-of-flight MR angiography, contrast-enhanced MR angiography, conventional DSA, and rotational angiography for detection and grading

PURPOSE: To compare three-dimensional (3D) time-of-flight (TOF) MR angiography, contrast-enhanced MR angiography, digital subtraction angiography (DSA), and rotational angiography for depiction of stenosis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The study had Ethics Committee approval, and each patient gave written informed consent. Forty-nine patients (18 women, mean age, 67.2 years +/- 9.1 [+/- standard deviation], and 31 men, mean age, 63.1 years +/- 8.0) with symptomatic stenosis of internal carotid artery (ICA) diagnosed at duplex ultrasonography underwent transverse 3D TOF MR angiography with sliding interleaved kY acquisition and coronal contrast-enhanced MR angiography, followed by DSA and rotational angiography within 48 hours. MR angiography was performed at 1.5-T with a cervical coil. Contrast-enhanced MR angiograms were obtained after a bolus injection of 20 mL of gadobenate dimeglumine. Maximum ICA stenosis on maximum intensity projection and source images was quantified according to NASCET criteria. Correlations for 3D TOF MR angiography, contrast-enhanced MR angiography, DSA, and rotational angiography were determined by means of cross tabulation, and accuracy for detection and grading of stenoses were calculated. Data were evaluated with analysis of variance, Wilcoxon signed rank test, and McNemar test, all at significance of P < .05. RESULTS: Ninety-eight ICAs were evaluated at contrast-enhanced MR angiography, DSA, and rotational angiography, and 97 were evaluated at 3D TOF MR angiography. Correlations for contrast-enhanced MR angiography, 3D TOF MR angiography, and DSA relative to rotational angiography were r2 = 0.9332, r2 = 0.9048, and r2 = 0.9255, respectively. Lower correlation (r2 = 0.8593) was noted for contrast-enhanced MR angiography and DSA. Respective sensitivity and specificity for detection of hemodynamically relevant stenosis relative to rotational angiography were 100% and 90% for contrast-enhanced MR angiography, 95.5% and 87.2% for 3D TOF MR angiography, and 88.6% and 100% for DSA. Four of 31 severe stenoses were underestimated at DSA, and three were underestimated at contrast-enhanced MR angiography. Three severe stenoses were underestimated at 3D TOF MR angiography, and one was misclassified as occluded. Of 13 moderate (50%-69%) stenoses, one was overestimated at contrast-enhanced MR angiography, two were underestimated and three overestimated at 3D TOF MR angiography, and two were underestimated at DSA. CONCLUSION: DSA results in an underestimation of ICA stenosis compared with rotational angiography. Contrast-enhanced MR angiography correlates best with rotational angiography.     

MR angiography in carotid stenosis: A comparison of three techniques

Purpose: To compare the accuracy of three different magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) techniques for studying steno-occlusive disease of carotid arteries. Methods: 64 patients were evaluated with three MRA techniques- three-dimensional (3D) time-of-flight (TOF), two-dimensional (2D) TOF, and 3D Phase-Contrast (PC); the acquisition was in the axial plane, the volume included the carotid bifurcation. Digital subtraction angiography (DSA) was considered the `gold standard'. The MRA images were reprojected with a maximum intensity pixel ray-tracing (MIP) algorithm. The three MRA techniques were blindly graded as normal, mildly stenotic (0–29%), moderately stenotic (30–49%), severely stenotic (70–99%), or occluded. Results: DSA provided 128 diagnostic judgments: 92 were negatives and 36 positives. 2D TOF was in agreement with angiography in 116 of 128 cases (90%), but overestimated the results in seven cases and underestimated in five cases. 3D TOF agreed with angiography in 125 of 128 cases (97%), with one overestimation and two under estimations. 3D PC was concordant in 116 of 128 cases (90%), overestimating in six cases, underestimating in six cases. The sensitivity, specificity and diagnostic accuracy for 2D TOF was, respectively 84%, 94%, and 92%, while for 3D TOF was 94%, 100%, and 98%, and for 3D PC 86%, 98%, and 95%. The comparison of the three different MRA techniques provided no statistically significant difference (Friedman test P<0.05). Conclusion: The high degree of diagnostic accuracy of MRA found in the study of the steno-occlusive disease of the carotid arteries confirms the high degree of reliability of this methodology carried out with the 3D TOF technique, compared to 2D TOF and 3D PC.     

MR angiography of internal carotid arteries: breath-hold Gd-enhanced 3D fast imaging with steady-state precession versus unenhanced 2D and 3D time-of-flight techniques

PURPOSE: The purpose of this work was to compare Gd-enhanced breath-hold fast imaging with steady-state precession (Gd-FISP) with unenhanced time-of-flight (TOF) sequences in evaluating internal carotid arteries (ICAs). METHOD: Thirty patients underwent three unenhanced TOF sequences [2D traveling saturation (Travelsat); 3D tilted optimized nonsaturated excitation (TONE); TOF 3D Multislab] and two breath-hold 3D Gd-FISP sequences with automated intravenous contrast agent injection (axial and coronal). ICAs were classified as normal (no stenosis); with mild (<30%), moderate (30-70%), or severe stenosis; or occluded (100%). Digital subtraction angiography (DSA) with aortic arch injection was used as a reference technique. RESULTS: DSA revealed 20 normal ICAs; 11 mild, 9 moderate, and 14 severe stenoses; and 2 occlusions. DSA and all MR angiography (MRA) sequences diagnosed the occlusion of four common carotid arteries. The TOF 2D overestimated 10 stenoses, TOF 3D TONE 9, and TOF 3D Multislab 5; Gd-FISP 3D overestimated only 2 of them, reaching the highest sensitivity and specificity for severe stenoses. Significant differences were found between the overestimation of Gd-FISP and each of the three unenhanced sequences (0.0020 < p < 0.0313, Wilcoxon and McNemar tests). Severe artifacts were observed with TOF techniques only. CONCLUSION: Gd-FISP is an interesting, largely artifact-free improvement for MRA of ICAs.     

Acute subarachnoid Haemorrhage: 3D time-of-flight MR angiography versus intra-arterial digital angiography

To evaluate the efficacy and reliability of 3D time-of-flight MR angiography (TOF MRA) as a noninvasive procedure, 27 patients with acute subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH) were studied with MRA immediately before or after intra-arterial digital subtraction angiography (DSA). 3DTOF MRA was performed with an axial slab of 60 mm centred on the circle of Willis and isotropic voxels. DSA showed 22 aneurysms and 1 dural arteriovenous fistula in 21 patients; the aneurysms ranged in size from 2 to 8 mm. MRA failed to show 2 small aneurysms, at the origin of the posterior and anterior communicating arteries. The 3D display of the intracranial vessels obtained with maximum intensity projection (MIP) or targetted MIP sometimes rendered the aneurysms better than DSA. However, due to its high spatial resolution, DSA more clearly defined the overall anatomy of the walls of the normal and abnormal vessels.1992 Scientific Award of the ESNR     

Intracranial vascular stenosis and occlusion: evaluation with three-dimensional time-of-flight MR angiography.

To assess the usefulness of magnetic resonance (MR) angiography in the characterization of intracranial arterial stenosis and occlusion, a three-dimensional time-of-flight method was compared with conventional angiography in 214 vessels in 29 patients. Studies were independently interpreted by two neuroradiologists who scored each vessel as normal, narrowed, or occluded. Overall, 97% of normal vessels and 100% of occlusions were correctly graded. Sixty-one percent of stenoses were graded correctly; the remainder were graded as normal. The portions of the intracranial vessels near the skull base and especially the paracavernous and supraclinoid segments of the internal carotid arteries were areas of frequent over- and underestimation of stenosis due to the presence of dephasing artifacts. In patients with stenosis or occlusion, MR angiography also provided information regarding the presence of collateral flow in the circle of Willis. When used in conjunction with MR imaging of the brain and MR angiography of the extracranial carotid arteries, intracranial MR angiography allows a more complete evaluation of the patient with symptoms of cerebral ischemia or infarction.