Medial prefrontal cortex lesions and spatial delayed alternation in the developing rat: recovery or sparing?

In Experiment 1, Long-Evans rat pups received medial prefrontal cortex (PFC) aspirations or sham surgery on Postnatal Day 10 (PND10) and were then trained on PND23 to perform one of two T-maze tasks: discrete-trials delayed alternation (DA) or simple position discrimination. Early PFC damage produced a selective failure to learn the DA task. In Experiment 2, pups given the same lesion or sham surgery were trained on DA on PND19, PND27, or PND33. In relation to sham-operated controls, pups with PFC damage were impaired on PND19, somewhat impaired on PND27, and entirely unimpaired when tested on PND33. In Experiment 3, pups given larger lesions of the frontal cortex on PND10 were impaired on DA when tested on PND23 but not when tested on PND33. These findings indicate that early PFC lesions result in a memory deficit around the time of weaning, which then recovers over the next 10-14 days of development. Moreover, the early deficit is selective for a late developing cognitive process (or processes) that is involved in acquisition of DA.     

Prefrontal D1 and ventral hippocampal N-methyl-D-aspartate regulation of startle gating in rats

BACKGROUND: Sensorimotor gating, as measured by prepulse inhibition of the startle reflex, is deficient in schizophrenia patients, and in rats after specific manipulations of limbic cortico-striato-pallido-thalamic circuitry. For example, prepulse inhibition in rats is disrupted after D1 blockade in the medial prefrontal cortex, and after N-methyl-D-aspartate infusion into the ventral hippocampus. In the present study, we examined whether these two substrates form part of an integrated circuit regulating sensorimotor gating, which might contribute to the loss of prepulse inhibition in patient populations. METHODS: Prepulse inhibition was assessed in male Sprague-Dawley rats after systemic or intra-medial prefrontal cortex administration of the D1 antagonist, SCH 23390. Separate rats received intra-medial prefrontal cortex infusion of the retrograde transported label Fluoro-Gold. In rats with sham or electrolytic lesions of the medial prefrontal cortex, prepulse inhibition was tested after infusion of N-methyl-D-aspartate or vehicle into ventral hippocampus regions that were determined to send projections to the medial prefrontal cortex. RESULTS: Prepulse inhibition was disrupted after systemic SCH 23390 treatment and after infusion of SCH 23390 into medial prefrontal cortex sites within the prelimbic and cingulate cortices. Fluoro-Gold infusion into these medial prefrontal cortex sites labeled cells in the ventral hippocampus complex, including regions CA1 and entorhinal cortex. N-methyl-D-aspartate infusions into these ventral hippocampus regions disrupted prepulse inhibition in rats after sham but not electrolytic lesions of the medial prefrontal cortex. CONCLUSIONS: Prepulse inhibition appears to be regulated by interacting substrates within the ventral hippocampus and MPFC. Specifically, NMDA activation of the ventral hippocampus appears to disrupt prepulse inhibition in a manner that is dependent on the integrity of infralimbic or cingulate cortical regions that also support a D1-mediated regulation of prepulse inhibition. Conceivably, dysfunction within these hippocampal-frontal circuits may contribute to sensorimotor gating deficits in schizophrenia.     

Definitive disruption of spatial delayed alternation in rats after lesions in the ventral mesencephalic tegmentum

Prefrontal system dysfunction are revealed in rats in delayed response tasks. In view of the anatomical projections existing from the ventral mesencephalic tegmentum to the prefrontal system we have done this research in order to determine whether cognitive processes are impaired after mesencephalic lesions. Rats learned spatial delayed alternation in a T-maze. After acquisition they were randomly divided in two groups; the experimental group received lesions in the ventral mesencephalic tegmentum at the level of the A10 cell bodies. These lesions induced definitive disruption of the retention of the delayed alternation and the rats were unable to relearn the task. However, these animals were able to perform normally in an operant conditioning with food reinforcement indicating the specificity of the deficit observed with respect to the delayed alteration task. The possible modulating role of dopaminergic A10 neurones is hypothetized.     

Dissociable onset of cognitive and motivational dysfunctions following neonatal lesions of the ventral hippocampus in rats

This research examined cognitive and motivational processes at different developmental stages in rats with neonatal ventral hippocampus (VH) lesions, an approach used to model schizophrenia. In Experiment 1, performance in a T-maze alternation task was assessed on postnatal days (PNDs) 22 and 23. VH-lesioned rats displayed a severe deficit relative to controls. In Experiment 2, behaviorally naive rats were tested for spontaneous alternation at PND 29. Alternation was intact in VH-lesioned rats only when successive alternations were separated by >5 s. In Experiment 3, motivation was tested in a cost-benefit T-maze task and in a saccharine-water preference test. Between PNDs 22-37, behaviorally naive rats with neonatal VH lesions displayed weaker saccharine preference than controls, but the 2 groups did not differ on the cost-benefit task. At adulthood, between PNDs 56-72, the difference on saccharine preference persisted and an impairment on the cost-benefit task emerged. Overall, these results suggest that working memory deficits observed at the weaning stage were not secondary to spontaneous alternation or motivation dysfunctions.     

Differential changes in glutamate concentration in the primate prefrontal cortex during spatial delayed alternation and sensory-guided tasks

Glutamate is a major neurotransmitter in the mammalian brain and glutamatergic neurotransmission in the frontal cortex is indicated to play important roles in cognitive operations. We previously examined changes in extracellular dopamine in the primate frontal cortex in cognitive tasks, and in this paper we extend this to glutamate. We employed, as cognitive tasks, a delayed alternation task where the animal must retain information in working memory, and a sensory-guided task in which there is no working memory requirement but there may be more sensory processing requirements. Using the in vivo microdialysis method, we examined changes in extracellular glutamate concentration in the dorsolateral, arcuate, orbitofrontal, and premotor areas of the primate frontal cortex. Compared to basal rest levels, we observed significant increases in glutamate concentration in dorsolateral and arcuate areas of the prefrontal cortex during the sensory-guided task, but did not find significant changes in any of the frontal areas examined during the delayed alternation task. When glutamate concentration was compared between the delayed alternation and sensory-guided tasks, difference was observed only in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, especially in the ventral lip area of the principal sulcus. The results indicate the importance of glutamate in processing sensory information but not in retaining information in working memory in the primate dorsolateral and arcuate prefrontal cortex. We also compared the concentration of glutamate and dopamine in the tasks. We found a double dissociation in the concentration of glutamate and dopamine in the dorsolateral area: there was an increase in glutamate but no change in dopamine during the sensory-guided task, whereas there was an increase in dopamine but no change in glutamate during the delayed alternation task. It is thus suggested that in the primate dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, increased glutamate tone without dopamine increase facilitates sensory-guided task performance, while increased dopamine tone without glutamate increase is beneficial for working memory task performance.     

Prefrontal cortical mechanisms underlying delayed alternation in mice

The prefrontal cortex (PFC) has been implicated in the maintenance of task-relevant information during goal-directed behavior. Using a combination of lesions, local inactivation, and optogenetics, we investigated the functional role of the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) in mice with a novel operant delayed alternation task. Task difficulty was manipulated by changing the duration of the delay between two sequential actions. In experiment 1, we showed that excitotoxic lesions of the mPFC impaired acquisition of delayed alternation with long delays (16 s), whereas lesions of the dorsal hippocampus and ventral striatum, areas connected with the PFC, did not produce any deficits. Lesions of dorsal hippocampus, however, significantly impaired reversal learning when the rule was changed from alternation to repetition. In experiment 2, we showed that local infusions of muscimol (an agonist of the GABA(A) receptor) into mPFC impaired performance even when the animal was well trained, suggesting that the mPFC is critical not only for acquisition but also for successful performance. In experiment 3, to examine the mechanisms underlying the role of GABAergic inhibition, we used Cre-inducible Channelrhodopsin-2 to activate parvalbumin (PV)-expressing GABAergic interneurons in the mPFC of PV-Cre transgenic mice as they performed the task. Using whole cell patch-clamp recording, we demonstrated that activation of PV-expressing interneurons in vitro with blue light in brain slices reliably produced spiking and inhibited nearby pyramidal projection neurons. With similar stimulation parameters, in vivo stimulation significantly impaired delayed alternation performance. Together these results demonstrate a critical role for the mPFC in the acquisition and performance of the delayed alternation task.     

Consequences of serial cortical, hippocampal, and thalamic lesions and of different lengths of overtraining on the acquisition and retention of learning tasks

The ability of the rat brain to acquire or to retain specific learning tasks was tested under conditions of multiple lesions and widely different amounts of practice. Lesion targets were (a) the medial prefrontal and cingulate cortex, (b) the anterior and mediodorsal thalamus, and (c) the dorsal and ventral hippocampus. Rats were divided into seven groups. The first group received lesions of all three structural complexes prior to training in a delayed alternation and an active avoidance task. Groups 2-4 received lesions in different combinations of two of the three structural complexes prior to task acquisition. Group 5 first learned both tasks and then received the medial cortical lesion; thereafter it was retrained to criterion. Then, the thalamic lesion was made, and relearning was tested a second time. Finally, the hippocampal region was damaged, and a last relearning test was given. Groups 6 and 7 also first acquired both tasks; however, after that, they received 240 (Group 6) or 1,280 (Group 7) trials of overtraining. Following this, all three structural complexes were given lesions serially before relearning of the two tasks was tested. Nine of the ten animals of Group 1 failed to acquire the alternation task, but all learned the avoidance task. In Groups 2-4, all rats acquired both tasks. Postoperatively, rats of Group 5 were inferior to those of Group 6 in both tasks, and rats of Group 7 were the most successful animals of the last three groups. These results question the assumption that serial lesions with intermittent training between lesions have beneficial effects, and they also stress the importance of task practice, that is, of behavioral experience. It is argued that prolonged training will lead to a widely distributed storage of information within the brain. The process of wide diffusion of information will, however, be disturbed (or at least retarded) by lesions made shortly after task acquisition or task reacquisition (as was the case for animals of Group 5).     

The functional neuroanatomy of classic delayed response tasks in humans and the limitations of cross-method convergence in prefrontal function

Three classic delay tasks: spatial delayed response, delayed spatial alternation and delayed object-alternation are prototypical experimental paradigms for mapping the functional neuroanatomy of prefrontal cortex in animals. These tasks have been applied in human lesion studies, yet there have been very few studies investigating their functional neuroanatomy in healthy human subjects. We used functional magnetic resonance imaging to investigate the functional neuroanatomy of these classic paradigms (and a fourth: object delayed response) in a single sample of healthy human participants. Consistent with previous animal, human lesion, and functional neuroimaging studies, activity was observed in prefrontal and posterior parietal cortices across all three delay tasks. Task-specific activations, however, were not entirely consistent with predictions drawn from animal lesion studies. For example, delayed object-alternation activated dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, a region not generally implicated in animal lesion reports. Spatial delayed response, classically associated with the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, did not activate this region; it rather activated posterior premotor cortices involved in response preparation, as did spatial alternation. All three tasks activated the frontopolar cortex, a region not considered crucial in animal research but associated with manipulation of internally generated information in recent human research. While cross-method convergence may be attained for lower level perceptual or motor tasks, the results of this study caution against the assumption that lesion-specific effects in animals generalize to human prefrontal cortex function.     

Effects of rat medial prefrontal cortex lesions on olfactory serial reversal and delayed alternation tasks

When reward reinforcement in a two-choice discrimination task is regularly changed from one stimulus to another immediately after one learning acquisition session, the learning efficiency of a rat increases as if the rat has come to recognize this regularity of reversal. To investigate how the rat medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) is involved in such improvement, we examined the performance of mPFC-lesioned rats in a serial reversal task of olfactory discrimination. The performance of other mPFC-lesioned rats in a delayed alternation task was also analyzed using the same apparatus to evaluate the contribution of the mPFC to working memory. The mPFC-lesioned rats demonstrated selective difficulty in the second reversal session in the serial reversal task and also showed performance impairment in the delayed alternation task. These results suggest that the rat mPFC mediating working memory is involved in early progress in learning efficiency during experiences of multiple reversals, which may be relevant to cognitive operations in reversal learning beyond a one-time reversal of stimulus response associations.     

Neonatal hippocampal lesions in rhesus macaques alter the monitoring, but not maintenance, of information in working memory

Neonatal hippocampal damage in rodents impairs medial prefrontal working memory functions. To examine whether similar impairment will follow the same damage in primates, adult monkeys with neonatal hippocampal lesions and sham-operated controls were trained on two working memory tasks. The session-unique delayed nonmatch-to-sample (SU-DNMS) task measures maintenance of information in working memory mediated by the ventral lateral prefrontal cortex. The object self-ordered (Obj-SO) task measures monitoring of information in working memory mediated by the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. Adult monkeys with neonatal hippocampal lesions performed as well as sham-operated controls on the SU-DNMS task at either the 5- or 30-s delays but were severely impaired on the Obj-SO task. These results extend the earlier findings in rodents by demonstrating that early lesions of the hippocampus in monkeys impair working memory processes known to require the integrity of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex while sparing lower order working memory processes such as recency. Although the present results suggest that the lack of functional hippocampal inputs may have altered the maturation of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, future studies will be needed to determine whether the nature of the observed working memory deficit is due to an absence of the hippocampus, a maldevelopment of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, or both.     

Frontal lobe activation during object alternation acquisition

Object alternation (OA) tasks are increasingly used as probes of ventral prefrontal functioning in humans. In the most common variant of the OA task, subjects must deduce the task rule through trial-and-error learning. To examine the neural correlates of OA acquisition, the authors measured regional cerebral blood flow with positron emission tomography while subjects acquired an OA task, performed a sensorimotor control condition, or performed already learned and practiced OA. As expected, activations emerged in the ventral prefrontal cortex. However, activation of the presupplemental motor area was more closely associated with successful task performance. The authors suggest that areas beyond the ventral prefrontal cortex are critically involved in OA acquisition.     

Glutamatergic and dopaminergic afferents to the prefrontal cortex regulate spatial working memory in rats

The integrity of the prefrontal cortex is critical for the expression of working memory. The prefrontal cortex is innervated by dopaminergic afferents from the ventral tegmental area and glutamatergic afferents from the mediodorsal thalamus. To determine the role of dopaminergic and glutamatergic afferents in the regulation of working memory, rats were trained to perform a spatial delayed alternation task in a T-maze. The microinjection of the ionotropic glutamate antagonists 6-cyano-7-nitroquinoxaline-2,3-dione or 3-(R)-2-carboxypiperazin-4-propyl-1-phosphonic acid into the prefrontal cortex impaired working memory. Consistent with a role for glutamate receptor activation, microinjecting the GABA_B agonist baclofen into the mediodorsal thalamus produced a dose-dependent disruption of working memory. In contrast, inhibition of the mesocortical dopamine projection was without effect on working memory. The blockade of D₁ and/or D₂ dopamine receptors with SCH-23390 and sulpiride was without effect on working memory. Likewise, the microinjection of baclofen into the ventral tegmental area did not impair working memory. However, stimulating mu-opioid receptors in the ventral tegmental area with [d-Ala²,N-Me-Phe⁴,Gly-ol⁵]enkephalin produced a dose-dependent impairment of working memory that was reversed by blocking D₁ dopamine receptors with SCH-23390 in the prefrontal cortex.These data demonstrate that increased dopamine tone or reduced glutamate tone in the prefrontal cortex disrupts working memory in a spatial delayed alternation task.     

Combined lesions of septum,amygdala, hippocampus,anterior thalamus,mamillary bodies and cingulate and subicular cortex fail to impair the acquisition of complex learning tasks

Summary Previous investigations (Irle and Markowitsch 1982a, 1983, 1984) demonstrated that triple or fourfold lesions within the cat's limbic system fail to produce learning impairments, as opposed to lesions of single or double loci, when tasks of visual reversal, delayed alternation, and active two-way avoidance were used. On the basis of these results, limbic regions of the cat's brain might be considered unessential for intact learning and mnemonic functions. Therefore, in order to obtain indisputable information on the importance of the limbic system for learning and memory, lesions of nearly all limbic core regions of the cat were performed. Ten cats received lesions of seven limbic core regions: the septum, amygdala, anterior thalamus, mamillary bodies, cingulate cortex, subicular cortex, and the hippocampus proper. Nine of these animals were tested postoperatively in the acquisition of a visual reversal task, a spatial alternation and delayed alternation task, and an active two-way avoidance task, and were then compared to the performance levels of ten control animals. The experimental animals turned out to be unimpaired in all tasks tested; the performance scores in the visual reversal and delayed alternation task and — for some experimental animals in the active two-way avoidance task even indicate a slight, though statistically insignificant, facilitation in the learning behavior of these animals. It is assumed that the learning functions underlying the tasks used were taken over by other brain regions, which, prior to massive limbic lesions, may be suppressed or otherwise inhibited. Alternatively, utilization of spared tissue in the damaged limbic regions must be considered as the possible explanation.     

The role of rat dorsomedial prefrontal cortex in spatial working memory

We used an operant delayed spatial alternation task to examine the role of rat dorsomedial prefrontal cortex (dmPFC) in spatial working memory. The task was designed to restrict movements during the delay period to minimize use of motor-mediating strategies. Inactivation of dmPFC (muscimol) resulted in increased errors and increased the temporal variability of responding. Animals did not show perseveration after errors (i.e., responding again at the erroneous location). Under control conditions, the time between spatial responses was greater and more variable before errors as compared to correct responses. These effects were eliminated when muscimol was infused into dmPFC. Trial outcome also affected movement and delay times in the next trial. This effect was diminished with muscimol in dmPFC. By contrast, when muscimol was infused in dorsal agranular insular cortex (AId)—a region that is strongly interconnected with dorsomedial prefrontal regions—there was no effect on delayed spatial alternation performance. These experiments confirm that dmPFC is necessary for successful delayed spatial alternation and establish that there is a relationship between response time variability and trial outcome that depends on dorsomedial prefrontal function.     

Differential effects of prefrontal lesions and combined prefrontal and limbic lesions on subsequent learning performance in the cat

On the basis of a previous experiment (Irle & Markowitsch, 1983) in which triple limbic lesions as opposed to double limbic lesions in the cat failed to impair the learning behavior of these animals, the effects of a lesion in a fourth brain structure, in addition to the original ones, were examined. Two groups of cats were given lesions in either the prefrontal cortex alone or in the prefrontal cortex, the anterior thalamus, the mamillary bodies, and the subiculum and subsequently tested in the acquisition of a visual reversal, a delayed alternation, and an active two-way avoidance task. Compared with control cats, cats with prefrontal lesions were strongly impaired in the acquisition of the visual reversal task and the delayed alternation task but only slightly impaired in the acquisition of the active two-way avoidance task. In contrast, animals with combined prefrontal cortical, anterior thalamic, mamillary, and subicular lesions were unimpaired in the acquisition of the visual reversal task, slightly facilitated in the acquisition of the active two-way avoidance task, but impaired in the acquisition of the delayed alternation task similarly to the animals with prefrontal lesions. The superior performance rates of the animals with fourfold lesions are considered to be due to a lesion-induced functional shift acting on intact brain structures which, prior to massive limbic lesions, remain inhibited or otherwise suppressed. The failure of the animals with fourfold lesions in the delayed alternation task indicates that the functions underlying this type of behavior cannot be compensated for or, alternatively, that a prefrontal lesion is not sufficient to disinhibit other structures involved in the same behavior.     

Activation of dopaminergic neurotransmission in the medial prefrontal cortex by N-methyl-d-aspartate stimulation of the ventral hippocampus in rats

Many behavioral functions-including sensorimotor, attentional, memory, and emotional processes-have been associated with hippocampal processes and with dopamine transmission in the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC). This suggests a functional interaction between hippocampus and prefrontal dopamine. The anatomical substrate for such an interaction is the intimate interconnection between the ventral hippocampus and the dopamine innervation of the mPFC. The present study yielded direct neurochemical evidence for an interaction between ventral hippocampus and prefrontal dopamine transmission in rats by demonstrating that subconvulsive stimulation of the ventral hippocampus with N-methyl-d-aspartate (NMDA; 0.5 mug/side) activates dopamine transmission in the mPFC. Postmortem measurements revealed that bilateral NMDA stimulation of the ventral hippocampus, resulting in locomotor hyperactivity, increased the homovanillic acid/dopamine ratio, an index of dopamine transmission, in the mPFC; indices of dopamine transmission in any of five additionally examined forebrain regions (amygdala, nucleus accumbens shell/core, lateral prefrontal cortex, caudate putamen) were unaltered. In vivo microdialysis measurements in freely moving rats corroborated the suggested activation of prefrontal dopamine transmission by demonstrating that unilateral NMDA stimulation of the ventral hippocampus increased extracellular dopamine in the ipsilateral mPFC. The suggested influence of the ventral hippocampus on prefrontal dopamine may be an important mechanism for hippocampo-prefrontal interactions in normal behavioral processes. Moreover, it indicates that aberrant hippocampal activity, as found in neuropsychiatric diseases, such as schizophrenia and mood disorders, may contribute to disruption of certain cognitive and emotional functions which are extremely sensitive to imbalanced prefrontal dopamine transmission.     

Delayed alternation in adolescent and adult male and female rats

The prefrontal cortex continues to develop throughout adolescence in several species, and our laboratory has demonstrated that during adolescence there is a decrease in neurons in the rat medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC). A PFC-dependent task, the delayed alternation task, was used in the present study to examine the function of the mPFC while it is still maturing in rats of both sexes. A deficit was found in adolescents when compared to adults during 15- and 60-s delays but not at other delays (5, 10, 30, and 90 s). Furthermore, adolescents committed more perseverative errors. No significant sex differences occurred at any delay for either age group; however, in the no delay training sessions, adolescent males reached criterion faster than females. These results indicate that performance on a mPFC-dependent task improves between adolescence and adulthood.     

Ocular motor delayed-response task performance among patients with schizophrenia and their biological relatives

Schizophrenia patients and their relatives have saccadic abnormalities characterized by problems inhibiting a response. The dorsolateral prefrontal cortex and its associated circuitry ostensibly mediate inhibition and support correct delayed response performance. In this context, two components of delayed response task performance are of interest: memory saccade metrics and error saccades made during the delay. To evaluate these variables, an ocular motor delayed response task was presented to 23 schizophrenia patients, 25 of their first-degree biological relatives, and 19 normal subjects. The measure that best differentiated groups was an increased frequency of error saccades generated during the delay by schizophrenia subjects and relatives. Decreased memory saccade gain also characterized patients and relatives. The similar pattern of results demonstrated by the patients with schizophrenia and their relatives suggests that performance on ocular motor delayed response tasks, either alone or in combination with other saccadic variables, may provide useful information about neural substrates associated with a liability for developing schizophrenia.     

Delayed alternation behavior following ablations of the medial or dorsal prefrontal cortex in dogs

Medial, but nor dorsal, prefrontal ablations interfered with retention in a spatial delayed alternation task. In this problem, normal dogs showed systematic bodily orientations during the delays. It has been found previously that dorsal, but not medial, lesions produced deficits in other delayed response type tasks in which positional mediations were not used. Occurrence of impairment after a given lesion appeared to be related to whether or not the animal adopted a positional strategy for solving the task. It was suggested that the medial prefrontal cortex subserves responding to kinesthetic cues, while the dorsal cortex may have a function in behavior based on retained spatial stimuli. Comparisons were made between properties of prefrontal cortices in dog and monkey.     

Influence of the mesocortical dopaminergic system on activity, food hoarding, social-agonistic behavior, and spatial delayed alternation in male rats

In order to assess the behavioral role of the dopaminergic mesocortical input to the prefrontal cortex, bilateral lesions were made in the ventral tegmental area (VTA). The possibility of a functional recovery by the administration of a dopamine agonist was examined. General activity, food hoarding, social-agonistic behavior, and spatial delayed alternation performance were recorded in rats with VTA lesions and in sham-operated animals. In the open field animals with VTA lesions were more active but showed less anxiety. Food hoarding was impaired. In dyadic interactions with sham-operated opponents, VTA rats were socially more active, whereas sham operates performed more keeping down and aggressive grooming. This behavioral deficit was partially recovered when apomorphine was administered prior to testing. VTA animals were impaired in the performance of a spatial delayed alternation task with an intertrial interval of 15 s, whereas no impairment was found with a 0-s intertrial interval. The theoretical implications of these findings are discussed.