From ‘Hard’ Neuro-Tools to ‘Soft’ Neuro-Toys? Refocussing the Neuro-Enhancement Debate

Since the 1990’s, the debate concerning the ethical, legal and societal aspects of ‘neuro-enhancement’ has evolved into a massive discourse, both in the public realm and in the academic arena. This ethical debate, however, tends to repeat the same sets of arguments over and over again. Normative disagreements between transhumanists and bioconservatives on invasive or radical brain stimulators, and uncertainties regarding the use and effectivity of nootropic pharmaceuticals dominate the field. Building on the results of an extensive European project on responsible research and innovation in neuro-enhancement (NERRI), we observe and encourage that the debate is now entering a new and, as we will argue, more realistic and societally relevant stage. This new stage concerns those technologies that enter the market as ostensibly harmless contrivances that consumers may use for self-care or entertainment. We use the examples and arguments of participants in NERRI debates to describe three case studies of such purportedly innocent ‘toys’. Based upon this empirical material, we argue that these ‘soft’ enhancement gadgets are situated somewhere in the boundary zone between the internal and the external, between the intimate and the intrusive, between the familiar and the unfamiliar, between the friendly and the scary and, in Foucauldian terms, between technologies of the self and technologies of control. Therefore, we describe their physiognomy with the help of a term borrowed from Jacques Lacan, namely as “extimate” technologies.     

Editorial ‘Supplement DIZZYNET 2017’

Classical teaching in epileptology localizes the origins of focal seizures solely in the cerebral cortex, with only inhibitory effects attributed to subcortical structures. However, electrophysiological and neuroimaging studies over the last decades now provide evidence for an initiation of epileptic seizures within subcortical structures. Intrinsic epileptogenicity of hypothalamic hamartoma has already been established in recognition of subcortical epilepsy, whereas a seizure-generating impact of dysplastic cerebellar lesions remains to be clarified. Herein, we examine the supportive evidence and clinical presentation of cerebellar seizures and review therapy options.     

Does ‘Yuck’ mean ‘Eek’? Fear responses in children after a disgust manipulation

Background and objectivesDisgust is a basic emotion that is thought to play a role in the development of animal phobias. This study was conducted to test whether experimentally induced disgust also results in higher levels of fear and interpretation bias.MethodsChildren aged 9–13 years (N = 94) were asked to inspect a set of specimen characteristic of a novel animal and requested to form themselves an impression of it based on those characteristics. Half of the children were given a set of disgust-eliciting products in relation to the animal, whereas the other half received a set of neutral materials.ResultsThe main results indicated that children in the disgust specimen group exhibited an increase in fear towards the novel animal and a stronger inclination to interpret ambiguous situations involving this animal in a more negative way as compared to children in the neutral specimen group.ConclusionThese findings confirm that disgust has a fear-promoting effect.     

Magnetization transfer imaging in ‘premanifest’ Huntington’s disease

To investigate whether magnetization transfer imaging (MTI) is a useful detector of diffuse brain abnormalities in ‘premanifest’ carriers of the Huntington’s disease (HD) gene mutation. Furthermore we examined the relations between MTI, clinical measures and CAG repeat length. Sixteen premanifest carriers of the HD gene without motor manifestation and 14 non-carriers underwent a clinical evaluation and a MRI scan. MTI analysis of whole brain, grey matter and white matter was performed producing magnetization transfer ratio (MTR) histograms. A lower peak height of the grey matter MTR histogram in carriers was significantly associated with more UHDRS motor abnormalities. Furthermore, a lower peak height of the whole brain, grey and white matter was strongly associated with a longer CAG repeat length. MTI measures themselves did not differ significantly between carriers and non-carriers. In premanifest HD mutation carriers, a lower MTR peak height, reflecting worse histological brain composition, was related to subtle motor abnormalities and higher CAG repeat length. Although we could not detect altered MTI characteristics in carriers of the HD gene mutation without clinical manifestations, we did provide evidence that the MTR peak height might reflect genetic and subclinical disease burden and may be of value in monitoring further disease progression and provide insight in clinical heterogeneity.     

To Play ‘B’ But Not to Say ‘B’: Selective Loss of Letter Names

This paper is the first report of an aphasic patient (GT) who shows a selective impairment in naming musical notes and letters in the context of preserved instrumental reading of notes. The ability to orally name notes (which are given the letter names A-G in English) and to play notes from a spoken note name was severely impaired. By contrast, instrumental sightreading and matching of written letters and single notes were both well preserved. This complex pattern of impairments can be explained in terms of a selective deficit in the letter name system.     

Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder dimensionality: the reliable ‘g’ and the elusive ‘s’ dimensions

The best structural model for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) symptoms remains a matter of debate. The objective of this study is to test the fit and factor reliability of competing models of the dimensional structure of ADHD symptoms in a sample of randomly selected and high-risk children and pre-adolescents from Brazil. Our sample comprised 2512 children aged 6–12 years from 57 schools in Brazil. The ADHD symptoms were assessed using parent report on the development and well-being assessment (DAWBA). Fit indexes from confirmatory factor analysis were used to test unidimensional, correlated, and bifactor models of ADHD, the latter including “g” ADHD and “s” symptom domain factors. Reliability of all models was measured with omega coefficients. A bifactor model with one general factor and three specific factors (inattention, hyperactivity, impulsivity) exhibited the best fit to the data, according to fit indices, as well as the most consistent factor loadings. However, based on omega reliability statistics, the specific inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity dimensions provided very little reliable information after accounting for the reliable general ADHD factor. Our study presents some psychometric evidence that ADHD specific (“s”) factors might be unreliable after taking common (“g” factor) variance into account. These results are in accordance with the lack of longitudinal stability among subtypes, the absence of dimension-specific molecular genetic findings and non-specific effects of treatment strategies. Therefore, researchers and clinicians might most effectively rely on the “g” ADHD to characterize ADHD dimensional phenotype, based on currently available symptom items.     

How does the ‘environment’ come to the person? The ‘ecology of the person’ and addiction

Currently, psychiatry lacks a field that can be called “theoretical psychiatry”, which uses theoretical concepts and explanatory models: The main stream of research is to collect data of all kinds in the hope that the computational Big Data approach will shed a bright light on the black box of mental disorders. Accordingly, the biology-based Research Domain Criteria of the National Institute of Mental Health have been established. However, as philosophical analyses of concepts and methods have shown, several epistemological gaps stand in the way of a consistent multilevel understanding of mental disorders. Also, the implicit ontological problems in the biological reduction of the psychosocial level and in the integration of so-called hard and soft disciplines are mostly left out. As a consequence, a non-reductive psychological theory of mental disorders is sought that also integrates correlating biological and sociological issues. In this context, one example of promising nonreductive psychiatric research is the option of systems/network psychopathology. The possibilities for integrating different psychological perspectives are highlighted for the field of addiction research and treatment, where pragmatic behaviorist approaches dominate over the theory-based practice of psychoanalysis. In comparing the theoretical constructs of these two approaches, the relevance of the concept of “(social) environment” as the wealth of influential sociocultural factors is discussed at levels superior to the interpersonal micro-level, namely the organizational meso- and societal macro level, which is not sufficiently considered in current biopsychiatry. On this basis of argumentation, the usefulness of grounding and framing psychiatry through the field of ecological sciences, especially human ecology, is demonstrated. Finally, to this end, an outline of an ecological model of mental health and illness is presented.     

Perineurial cells filled with collagen in ‘atypical’ Cogan’s syndrome

Cogan’s syndrome is a rare clinical entity characterized by non-infectious interstitial keratitis with vestibuloauditory dysfunction. The clinical course is extremely variable. In the majority of patients, there appears to be an underlying systemic process, often a “vasculitis”. We were able to study for the first time a sural nerve biopsy of a 38-year-old female with clinically suggested Cogan’s syndrome associated with a severe multiplex type of neuropathy. There were unusual cells in or below the perineurium and along perineurial extensions into the endoneurium which were usually associated with blood vessels and which have thus far not been described in association with any type of peripheral neuropathy. The unusual cells were identified as perineurial cells because (1) they were frequently associated with the perineurium and its endoneurial extensions; (2) they were immunoreactive for antibodies against epithelial membrane antigen (EMA) but did not react with antibodies against protein S100, GFAP, and CD 68; and (3) they showed focally accumulated pinocytotic vesicles and hemidesmosomes. Some of these cells were clearly immunoreactive with antibodies against collagen VI. Electron microscopic examination revealed numerous intracellular bundles of collagen fibers which were surrounded by an amorphous basal lamina-like material, indicating that they were located within intracellular projections of the surface membrane. The number of myelinated and unmyelinated nerve fibers was severely reduced corresponding to the clinical manifestation of the neuropathy and to the atrophy, especially of the distal arm and leg muscles. It is concluded that the changes were caused by a special type of autoimmune reaction involving blood vessels and perineurial cells of peripheral nerves.     

‘Everyday Memory’ Impairments in Autism Spectrum Disorders

‘Everyday memory’ is conceptualised as memory within the context of day-to-day life and, despite its functional relevance, has been little studied in individuals with autism spectrum disorders (ASDs). In the first study of its kind, 94 adolescents with an ASD and 55 without an ASD completed measures of everyday memory from the Rivermead Behavioural Memory Test (RBMT) and a standard word recall task (Children’s Auditory Verbal Learning Test-2: CAVLT-2). The ASD group showed significant impairments on the RBMT, including in prospective memory, alongside impaired performance on the CAVLT-2. Social and communication ability was significantly associated with prospective remembering in an everyday memory context but not with the CAVLT-2. The complex nature of everyday memory and its relevance to ASD is discussed.     

‘Cosmetic Neurology’ and the Moral Complicity Argument

Over the past decades, mood enhancement effects of various drugs and neuromodulation technologies have been proclaimed. If one day highly effective methods for significantly altering and elevating one’s mood are available, it is conceivable that the demand for them will be considerable. One urgent concern will then be what role physicians should play in providing such services. The concern can be extended from literature on controversial demands for aesthetic surgery. According to Margaret Little, physicians should be aware that certain aesthetic enhancement requests reflect immoral social norms and ideals. By granting such requests, she argues, doctors render themselves complicit to a collective ‘evil’. In this paper, we wish to question the extent to which physicians, psychiatrists and/or neurosurgeons should play a role as ‘moral gatekeepers’ in dealing with suspect demands and norms underlying potential desires to alter one’s mood or character. We investigate and discuss the nature and limits of physician responsibilities in reference to various hypothetical and intuitively problematic mood enhancement requests.     

Basal ganglia volume and clinical correlates in ‘preclinical’ Huntington’s disease

Abstract Objective   To establish differences in basal ganglia and thalamic volume between preclinical carriers and non-carriers of the Huntington’s disease (HD) gene and to link the volume to motor, cognitive and behavioural characteristics in carriers. Methods   Sixteen HD gene carriers without overt clinical motor signs and 14 non-gene carriers underwent clinical evaluation and a MRI scan. Volumes of the caudate nucleus, putamen, gobus pallidus and thalamus were measured using T1-weighted MR images. Motor, cognitive and behavioural functioning was assessed using the Unified Huntington’s Disease Rating Scale (UHDRS), cognitive testing and the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI-II). Results   Volumes of the caudate nucleus, putamen and globus pallidus were significantly smaller in carriers than in non-carriers while no differences between groups were found on clinical evaluation. In gene carriers smaller globus pallidus volume was associated with more motor abnormalities. A smaller putamen volume correlated significantly with worse psychomotor function on the Symbol Digit Modalities Task and the Trail Making Test B. Conclusions   In line with previous research we demonstrated that basal ganglia abnormalities precede overt disease manifestation of HD. Besides we showed that smaller basal ganglia volumes are related to subtle motor abnormalities and worse psychomotor performance in gene carriers without clinical diagnosis. Motor and psychomotor measures may be suitable clinical markers in future neuroprotective trials when combined with volumetric imaging.     

I’m not alone,’ said the boy. ‘I’ve got a puppy

European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry -