Cycloid psychosis: An examination of the validity of the concept

The diagnosis of cycloid psychosis has a long tradition in European psychiatry. However, it has been poorly assimilated within the DSM IV and ICD-10 diagnostic systems. Leonhard set the basis for the current conceptualization of the disorder, and Perris and Brockington developed the first operational diagnostic criteria. However, the two conceptualizations of the disorder are not the same and differ across a number of meaningful variables. Cycloid psychosis is a useful concept in that it possesses both clinical and predictive validity. Despite the high prevalence of mood symptoms and syndromes, cycloid psychosis does not equal schizoaffective disorder. Although a substantial body of evidence suggests that cycloid psychosis differs meaningfully from typical schizophrenia, it is less clear whether it differs from major mood disorders or represents an independent nosological entity. The existence of putative subtypes is also likely, and the differentiation between affective and nonaffective subtypes has received some support.     

Incidence of cycloid psychosis

Summary The concept of cycloid psychosis has gained increasing acceptance during recent decades. Using the diagnostic criteria of Perris and Brockington, an intelligible delineation of a group of patients has been obtained. Few epidemiological data on cycloid psychosis have been reported so far. The objective of the present study was to describe the one-year incidence of cycloid psychosis in a clinical sample. The diagnostic registers of all patients hospitalized for a functional or an organic psychosis and discharged in the year 1983, in Lund, Sweden were investigated. 514 patients were identified of whom 83 were admitted to hospital for the first time. 29 of these patients had a functional psychosis and were below the age of 50. In this age group 7 cases (4 women, 3 men) fulfilled the diagnostic criteria of cycloid psychosis and thus constituted almost one fourth of all first admissions of functional psychoses that year. The one-year incidence for first admission in cycloid psychosis was 5.0 per 100000 inhabitants in women and 3.6 per 100000 inhabitants in men within the age group 15–50 years in the catchment area of 163 175 persons. We conclude that cycloid psychosis consitutes a considerable proportion of functional psychoses in both sexes.     

Cycloid psychoses revisited: case reports, literature review, and commentary

Emil Kraepelin proposed to separate psychiatric disorders with psychotic features into two major categories, dementia praecox (later schizophrenia) and manic-depressive insanity (later bipolar disorder and major depression). Over the past century, there have been many efforts to categorize conditions that do not fit readily in either group. These conditions include many cases of acute psychotic illnesses of limited duration, with recovery between recurrences. For some of these conditions, Karl Kleist proposed the term cycloid psychosis: acute features were psychotic, as in schizophrenia, but the course was episodic, as in manic-depression. His concept was later elaborated by Karl Leonhard and Carlo Perris, and validated by modern studies. Leonhard described three overlapping cycloid subtypes (anxiety-beatific, excited-inhibited confusional, and hyperkinetic-akinetic motility dysfunction forms); Perris proposed a more unitary syndrome with operational diagnostic criteria; and recent investigators have considered relatively affective versus thought-disordered subtypes. The cycloid concept is not explicitly included in standard international diagnostic schemes, but both DSM-IV and ICD-10 have broad categories for acute, recurrent psychotic disorders, whose validity remains insecure. We present two cases of probable cycloid psychosis, review the history of the concept, and propose that it be reconsidered as a clinically useful category whose validity and utility for prognosis and treatment can be further tested.     

Cycloid psychosis

This article reviews the concept, nosological status, diagnostic features, associated clinical characteristics, and the etiopathological variables involved in cycloid psychosis. The concept of cycloid psychosis is based on sound psychopathological and course underpinnings, and despite the inclusion of some cycloid features in the current diagnostic systems such as ICD-10 and DSM-IV, these systems do not capture well the diagnostic construct of this disorder. Cycloid psychosis is a valid clinical constructs that can be easily differentiated from the boundary disorders on clinical grounds. It seems to be heterogeneous from the etiopathological point of view, in that a variety of factors seems to be involved to a different degree in most of the patients. Future studies should examine putative subtypes of the disorder in relation to etiological, pathophysiological and clinical variables.     

Cycloid psychosis

This article reviews the concept, nosological status, diagnostic features, associated clinical characteristics, and the etiopathological variables involved in cycloid psychosis. The concept of cycloid psychosis is based on sound psychopathological and course underpinnings, and despite the inclusion of some cycloid features in the current diagnostic systems such as ICD-10 and DSM-IV, these systems do not capture well the diagnostic construct of this disorder. Cycloid psychosis is a valid clinical constructs that can be easily differentiated from the boundary disorders on clinical grounds. It seems to be heterogeneous from the etiopathological point of view, in that a variety of factors seems to be involved to a different degree in most of the patients. Future studies should examine putative subtypes of the disorder in relation to etiological, pathophysiological and clinical variables.     

Classification of nonschizophrenic psychotic disorders: a historical perspective

The existence of a group of psychoses that are symptomatologically and prognostically different from schizophrenia and affective psychotic disorders is supported by clinical and epidemiologic evidence. Although such "atypical" psychoses account for up to 10% of all psychotic disorders, their aetiology, pathophysiology, and neuropathology remain insufficiently understood. Moreover, they have been described by different schools of psychiatry a variety of ways, including non-process schizophrenia, schizophreniform psychosis, reactive (or psychogenic) psychosis, bouffées délirantes, and cycloid psychoses, but the extent to which these diagnostic categories overlap or differ has not been systematically explored. Neither Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV), nor International Classification of Disease, Tenth Revision (ICD-10), provides adequate diagnostic criteria and classificatory categories for this group of disorders. Special attention to the refinement of the diagnosis and classification of the acute and transient psychotic disorders in future versions of the two classifications will be warranted.     

Epidemiology of cycloid psychosis

Summary The objective of the present study on cycloid psychosis was to describe the incidence and risk in a defined population sample. We therefore re-evaluated specific diagnostic groups in the 1947 cohort of the Lundby Study. Three female cases were identified as cycloid psychosis according to the diagnostic criteria of Leonhard, Perris and Brockington. No men were found. The incidence rate (per 100 observation years) was found to be 0.016% for women. The cumulative probability i.e. risk, up to 60 years of age was calculated to be 0.7%. Incidence rate and risk for cycloid psychosis in women was thus about half of the corresponding values for schizophrenia as described for the same population in a parallel study. We conclude that cases of cycloid psychosis constitute a substantial proportion of female psychotic patients.The present study was financed by the following grants: Nos. 4803, 06881 from The Swedish Medical Research Council, No. 83/64:1 from The Swedish Ministry of Health and Social Affairs, Delegation for Social Research and Pfannenstillska Stiftelsen     

Neurological deviations in newborns at psychiatric high risk

Neurological deviations on the third to fourth day of life were blindly assessed in 55 offspring of index women with histories of nonorganic psychoses and in 71 offspring of demographically similar control women with no history of psychosis. While the total index group did not differ from the total control group on rates of neurological deviation, the offspring of women with schizophrenia and cycloid psychosis showed more neurological deviations of a diverse nature than did their controls. The offspring of women with affective disorders had rates of deviation that were lower than those of controls and other index diagnostic groups. The differences observed were not sensitive to the narrowness of diagnostic criteria for schizophrenia and affective disorder.     

Distinct neurophysiological mechanisms for manic and cycloid psychoses: evidence from a P300 study on manic patients

Pathologically asymmetrical P300 fields with right lateralized peaks were described in core schizophrenia as an expression of left-temporal functional deficits, while higher than normal amplitudes were found in cycloid psychosis. This latter finding appeared to be specific for cycloid psychosis and was explained by a generalized cerebral hyperarousal. Based on some psychopathological analogies with cycloid psychosis, and on the comparable pharmacological treatment of the acute episodes, a group of 19 manic patients was investigated immediately after remission and clinical stabilization of an episode. Patients with psychotic features were excluded to avoid overlaps with cycloid psychosis. Patients showed normal P300 amplitudes and no pathological asymmetries of the field, but more posterior positive areas compared to age- and sex-matched controls. This indicates that the neurophysiological changes underlying mania are different from both core schizophrenia and cycloid psychosis. Based on previous three-dimensional source location studies, this finding indicates that disinhibition due to reduced frontal lobe activity, and not hyperarousal, is the basic functional mechanism of manic disorders.     

Differences in P300 amplitudes and topography between cycloid psychosis and schizophrenia in Leonhard's classification

In a polydiagnostic approach, we investigated the parameters of auditory P300 in a group of 18 remitted schizophrenics and in 18 age- and sex-matched controls. All patients fulfilled the criteria of schizophrenic disorder according to DSM-III-R. Applying Leonhard's classification, patients were to be subdivided into 7 cycloid psychosis and 11 Leonhard's schizophrenics. Patients with cycloid psychosis fulfilled the operational criteria of Brockington et al. We found significantly lower P300 amplitudes in the group of Leonhard's schizophrenics than in controls and in cycloid psychosis, whereas no difference could be shown between patients with cycloid psychosis and controls. Both the maxima and the minima of the P300 field map were dislocated significantly to the right in the group of Leonhard's schizophrenics but not in cycloid psychosis.     

Relationship between cycloid psychosis and typical affective psychosis

This article describes the clinical features and outcome of a series of 73 inpatients who fulfilled Perris' criteria for cycloid psychosis. It is argued that although the cases differ from either schizophrenia or affective psychosis in some ways, the condition of cycloid psychosis is best regarded as an atypical variety of affective psychosis.     

Categorical and dimensional diagnostic approach to acute psychosis in view of operational diagnostic criteria

"Acute psychosis" is the tentative diagnosis made for the patients presenting acute onset of delusion, hallucination, confusion and emotional instability. "Acute psychosis" was focused in view of operational diagnostic criteria, ie, DSM-IV-TR and ICD-10. The diagnostic categories in the DSM-IV-TR corresponding to "acute psychosis" were brief psychotic disorder, schizophreniform disorder, schizo-affective disorder and mood disorder with psychotic features. Although brief psychotic disorder is representative of "acute psychosis" in the DSM-TR, it lacks in clinical usefulness, because its diagnostic criteria, based on no historical background, lack clinical validity in terms of symptom definition and duration (1 month>). On the other hand, in the ICD-10, a diagnostic category of acute transient psychotic disorder was based on the traditional "acute psychosis" concept that has been bred in the European Psychiatry. Among the acute transient psychotic disorders, acute polymorphic psychotic disorder is the diagnostic category made according to traditional concept of "bouffées délirantes" and cycloid psychosis. It is a clinically useful diagnostic category, because it could predict favorable episode outcome, if a person with fairly good premorbid social adaptation presents acute onset of polymorphic psychotic symptoms. One of the most prominent points of the revision of DSM-IV-TR to DSM-5 is the adoption of dimensional approach evaluation (diagnosis) in a disorder-crossing fashion. In addition to insomnia, depressive mood and anxiety, symptomatic domain such as acute onset, bipolarity, polymorphism of psychotic symptoms, and furthermore such domain as premorbid social adaptation, life event and episode outcome should be evaluated in the course of treatment, contributing to the clinical practice of the patients with acute psychosis.     

Schizoaffective mania reconsidered

Schizoaffective mania refers to a heterogeneous group of disorders characterized by mixtures of schizophrenic and manic (or bipolar) symptoms. Of the proposed diagnostic criteria, the Research Diagnostic Criteria (RDC) most clearly distinguish relevant subgroups. Family, clinical, and treatment studies suggest that the RDC's mainly affective subtype of schizoaffective mania is a variant of psychotic bipolar disorder. Limited available data suggest that the mainly schizophrenic subtype has a poorer prognosis and includes cases more closely related to schizophrenia. Schizoaffective mania also overlaps with proposed categories such as reactive and cycloid psychosis. It is premature to assume that all schizoaffective manic disorder represents a bipolar variant. Further studies that differentiate patients according to subtype, drug response, and course are needed.     

Influence of diagnostic classification on gender ratio in schizophrenia

BACKGROUND: The research literature on hospital admissions for psychoses in youths was reviewed in order to test whether there was a gender ratio discrepancy in diagnostic subgroups; the effect of the diagnostic criteria classification on this measure was also investigated. METHOD: A meta-analysis was conducted on 12 primary studies by assessing the male/female odds ratio (OR) in the schizophrenia and mood disorders with psychosis subgroups as well as the amount of variability between studies. Study inclusion criteria were: patients between the ages of 8 and 19, at least 15 patients with psychosis and a standardized diagnostic criteria classification system such as DSM, ICD or RDC. RESULTS: The male/female OR measured in this meta-analysis implies that a male subject with psychosis is 1.7 times as likely to obtain a diagnosis of schizophrenia; conversely, a female subject with psychosis is 2.1 times as likely to be assigned in the mood disorders with psychosis subgroup. Disparity in diagnostic criteria nomenclature (ICD-9 vs. DSM) could account for a statistically significant difference in male/female OR for the schizophrenia subgroup in a subset of 11 studies. CONCLUSIONS: Under the narrower definition of schizophrenia in studies using DSM diagnostic criteria classification, the shift towards a greater proportion of patients diagnosed with mood disorders with psychosis could be explained by the time criteria; the simultaneous emergence of the gender ratio difference is discussed. This study shows that subtle changes in diagnostic criteria in psychiatric illnesses can greatly influence observational data pertaining to youths.     

Concordance of acute and transient psychoses and cycloid psychoses

OBJECTIVE: We prospectively investigated a sample of 42 patients with acute and transient psychotic disorder (ATPD) as defined by the 10th revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-10; F23) to determine the clinical and demographic features of this entity and its relationship to cycloid psychoses. METHODS: During a 5-year period, all in-patients with ATPD were identified. We systematically evaluated demographic and clinical features and carried out follow-up investigations on average 2 years after the index episode, using standardised instruments. RESULTS: We found 42 cases of ATPD (4.1%) among 1,036 patients treated for psychotic disorders or a major affective episode. There was a marked female preponderance in ATPD (79%). Fifty-five percent of cases concurrently met the criteria of cycloid psychosis according to Perris and Brockington [in Perris C, Struwe G, Jansson B (eds): Biological Psychiatry. Amsterdam, Elsevier, 1981, pp 447-450]. There was no difference in gender distribution between cycloid and non-cycloid ATPD. As expected, abrupt onset and polymorphic features were significantly more common in cycloid than in non- cycloid ATPD. At follow-up, patients with cycloid ATPD showed less persistent alterations and better social functioning. CONCLUSION: ATPD as defined by ICD-10 is a heterogeneous category. A diagnosis of cycloid psychosis is made in half of the cases of ATPD, and in these cases, the prognosis is more favourable.     

Epidemiology of cycloid psychosis

The incidence and risk of cycloid psychosis were investigated in the 1947 cohort of the Lundby Study. No male cases were found. For women the incidence rate (per 100 observation years) was 0.016%. The cumulative probability, i.e. risk up to 60 years of age, was 0.7%. These figures are about half of those for schizophrenia in women in the same population. It is concluded that cycloid psychosis constitutes a substantial part of psychotic disorders among women.     

The nosology of psychotic disorders: a comparison among competing classification systems

This study examined the concordance and predictive validity of two empirical and two operational classification systems of psychotic disorders. Latent class analysis (LCA) was applied to 16 index episode and to their corresponding 16 lifetime symptom ratings of 660 psychotic inpatients, who were also diagnosed according to DSM-IV and ICD-10 criteria. The resulting classes or diagnoses were validated against clinical (premorbid adjustment, treatment response, and course) and etiologic (morbidity risk of schizophrenia and major mood disorders) variables. LCA of index episode and lifetime ratings showed that five classes of psychotic disorders provided the best fit to the data: schizophrenia, psychosis, schizomania/schizobipolar, schizodepression, and mixed psychosis (cycloid psychosis for index episode ratings and atypical schizophrenia for lifetime ratings). The concordance between the empirical and operational classification systems was poor. Irrespective of the classification method used, the most powerful validators were the clinical ones, whereas the etiologic validators played a negligible role in validating the classes or diagnoses. Overall, DSM-IV and ICD-10 classifications had more clinical validity than empirical classifications, mainly because of circularity in operational definitions regarding treatment response and course of the disorders. With the exception of the category of schizophrenia, which showed some nosological stability across the four classification systems, the number and type of categories of psychosis were highly dependent upon the set of classification procedures. These results make clear the problems inherent in drawing well-defined boundaries between psychotic disorders.     

Nonschizophrenic psychotic disorders: the case of cycloid psychoses

BACKGROUND: Cycloid psychosis is a psychiatric disorder known for about 100 years. This disorder is at present partly and simplified represented in the ICD-10. SAMPLING AND METHODS: Over a period of 15 months, 139 consecutively acutely admitted psychotic patients were assessed, by means of different diagnostic instruments, in order to investigate the prevalence and the symptom profile of cycloid psychoses. In addition, the concordance between the diagnoses cycloid psychosis, brief psychotic disorder, and acute polymorphic psychotic disorder with or without symptoms of schizophrenia was calculated. RESULTS: Cycloid psychoses were present in 13% of the patients. There was a significant but small overlap with the DSM brief psychotic disorder and the ICD acute polymorphic psychotic disorder. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates that cycloid psychoses can be identified with the proper diagnostic instruments in a proportion that is also found in other studies. Since this type of psychosis entails a distinct prognosis and may require a specific treatment, its identification is of clinical importance. Limitations are the nature of the psychiatric facility with an inherent bias in the selection of patients and the lack of a long-term evaluation.     

Problems of schizo-affective disorders

The inclusion of schizo-affective type under schizophrenia in ICD-9 (9th revision of the international classification of diseases) and under psychotic disorders not elsewhere classified in DSM-3 (3rd edition of diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders), the absence of this term in the French classification, and its parallelism among Scandinavian writers with cycloid psychosis - all the above data reflect the present perplexity of schizo-affective disorders. Recent studies showed the presence of depressive symptoms in a large number of acute and chronic schizophrenias as an integral part of the schizophrenic process. The difficulty of differential diagnosis between mania and schizophrenia has added to our present dilemma. A review and discussion of the present status of the term 'schizo-affective disorders' are presented. A plea is made to abandon the dichotomy of functional psychosis with delineating 'psychosis of unknown etiology' into three or four categories (as this is no more functional).     

Effectiveness of lithium prophylaxis in schizoaffective psychoses: application of a polydiagnostic approach

The effectiveness of lithium prophylaxis has been tested in a group of patients fulfilling the relatively broad ICD-9 definition of schizophrenic psychosis, schizoaffective type, and in each of the subgroups resulting from the application to the same patients of four different sets of diagnostic criteria for schizoaffective or cycloid psychoses. Moreover, a comparison has been made, within the whole patient population, between responders and non-responders to treatment, with respect to some clinical and biological variables. The mean number of morbid episodes and the mean total morbidity have been found significantly reduced during the treatment period, as compared with a control period of the same length, in the whole patient population as well as in subjects meeting RDC and Kendell's criteria for schizoaffective disorder (with special regard to schizomanics) and Perris's criteria for cycloid psychoses. No significant difference between the two periods has been observed in patients diagnosed as schizoaffectives according to Welner et al. Clinical/historical variables (with special regard to those concerning the course of the illness and the family history of major psychoses) have been found the most reliable predictors of response, whereas biological variables did not discriminate between responders and nonresponders to prophylaxis.