Common RNA replication signals exist among group 2 coronaviruses: evidence for in vivo recombination between animal and human coronavirus molecules

5' and 3' UTR sequences on the coronavirus genome are known to carry cis-acting elements for DI RNA replication and presumably also virus genome replication. 5' UTR-adjacent coding sequences are also thought to harbor cis-acting elements. Here we have determined the 5' UTR and adjacent 289-nt sequences, and 3' UTR sequences, for six group 2 coronaviruses and have compared them to each other and to three previously reported group 2 members. Extensive regions of highly similar UTR sequences were found but small regions of divergence were also found indicating group 2 coronaviruses could be subdivided into those that are bovine coronavirus (BCoV)-like (BCoV, human respiratory coronavirus-OC43, human enteric coronavirus, porcine hemagglutinating encephalomyelitis virus, and equine coronavirus) and those that are murine hepatitis virus (MHV)-like (A59, 2, and JHM strains of MHV, puffinosis virus, and rat sialodacryoadenitis virus). The 3' UTRs of BCoV and MHV have been previously shown to be interchangeable. Here, a reporter-containing BCoV DI RNA was shown to be replicated by all five BCoV-like helper viruses and by MHV-H2 (a human cell-adapted MHV strain), a representative of the MHV-like subgroup, demonstrating group 2 common 5' and 3' replication signaling elements. BCoV DI RNA, furthermore, acquired the leader of HCoV-OC43 by leader switching, demonstrating for the first time in vivo recombination between animal and human coronavirus molecules. These results indicate that common replication signaling elements exist among group 2 coronaviruses despite a two-cluster pattern within the group and imply there could exist a high potential for recombination among group members.     

A clustering of RNA recombination sites adjacent to a hypervariable region of the peplomer gene of murine coronavirus

Coronaviruses undergo RNA recombination at a very high frequency. To understand the mechanism of recombination in murine coronavirus, we have performed RNA sequencing of viral genomic RNA to determine the precise sites of recombination in a series of recombinants which have crossovers within the gene encoding the peplomer protein. We found that all of the recombination sites are clustered within a region of 278 nucleotides in the 5'-half of the gene. This region in which all of the crossovers occurred represents a small fraction of the distance between the two selection markers used for the isolation of these recombinant viruses. This result suggests that this region may be a preferred site for RNA recombination. The crossover sites are located within and immediately adjacent to a hypervariable area of the gene. This area has undergone deletions of varying sizes in several virus strains which have been passaged either in vivo or in vitro. These results suggest that a similar RNA structure may be involved in the occurrence of both recombination and deletion events.     

The kinetics of adenovirus recombination in homotypic and heterotypic genetic crosses

The kinetics of recombination between temperature-sensitive mutants has been studied in both homotypic (Ad5 x Ad5) and heterotypic (Ad5 x Ad2+NDI) crosses. There is a significant increase in the recombination frequency during the rise period of viral replication in a single-step replication cycle. This observation suggests that adenovirus DNA molecules can undergo progressive rounds of recombination before assembly into virions. To examine this possibility further, advantage was taken of the serotype-specific restriction endonuclease sites and polypeptide sizes of Ad5 and Ad2+ND1 to enumerate and to localize the sites of crossing over in ts+ recombinants isolated early and late in a heterotypic infection. The late recombinants exhibited, on average, more crossovers per genome than did the early recombinants. This finding is predicted if multiple rounds of recombination take place in some genomes. Using blot hybridization with specific probes, the production of recombinant molecules in the intracellular DNA replicating pool has been followed. Recombinants were found before the rise in infectious virus and increased in frequency relative to the parental molecules throughout the exponential period. These data confirm and extend the genetic observations, which were made on a selected set of infectious virus.     

Polarity in adenovirus recombination

The distributions of the crossovers necessary to generate ts+ genomes have been examined in a collection of clonally unrelated ts+ recombinants from a set of ts X ts adenovirus crosses. In a cross between two parents that are grossly heterologous between map units 80.2 and 91.5, the distribution of crossovers was significantly skewed toward the left-hand end of the genome, with a declining frequency proceeding rightward. This gradient of recombination was modified by the removal of the right-hand heterology and by the presence of another region of heterology between map units 3.67 and 10.11. In a cross where the ts markers were flanked by both heterologies, no gradient was observed and ts+ recombinants were characterized by a higher rate of supernumerary crossovers. In a cross designed so that one ts marker was internal to two heterologies, crossovers were found disproportionately between the second ts marker and the nearby heterology. In addition, ts+ recombinants formed by crossing over internal to the heterologies again were accompanied by a high frequency of supernumerary crossovers. Finally, ts+ recombinant frequencies in crosses identical except for the presence of either one or two flanking heterologies were markedly lower in the latter case. These data, taken together, suggest that a major pathway of adenovirus recombination initiates at, or near, the molecular termini and is perhaps driven by the displaced single strands produced during DNA replication. Internal initiation, on the other hand, may employ these single strands to form genetic "patches."     

Primary structure and translation of a defective interfering RNA of murine coronavirus

An intracellular defective-interfering (DI) RNA, DIssE, of mouse hepatitis virus (MHV) obtained after serial high multiplicity passage of the virus was cloned and sequenced. DIssE RNA is composed of three noncontiguous genomic regions, representing the first 864 nucleotides of the 5' end, an internal 748 nucleotides of the polymerase gene, and 601 nucleotides from the 3' end of the parental MHV genome. The DIssE sequence contains one large continuous open reading frame. Two protein products from this open reading frame were identified both by in vitro translation and in DI-infected cells. Sequence comparison of DIssE and the corresponding parts of the parental virus genome revealed that DIssE had three base substitutions within the leader sequence and also a deletion of nine nucleotides located at the junction of the leader and the remaining genomic sequence. The 5' end of DIssE RNA was heterogeneous with respect to the number of UCUAA repeats within the leader sequence. The parental MHV genomic RNA appears to have extensive and stable secondary structures at the regions where DI RNA rearrangements occurred. These data suggest that MHV DI RNA may have been generated as a result of the discontinuous and nonprocessive manner of MHV RNA synthesis.     

Concordance of the RNA termini of recombinants from crosses between avian retroviruses with different termini.

In previous work we have analyzed the RNA of recombinants issuing from crosses between avian retroviruses with distinguishable oligonucletoide maps and have the origins of the different segments of the recombinant RNA. Several recombinants appeared to contain the 5′-proximal part of one parent and the 3′-proximal part of the other parent, however, the terminal regions themselves were not analyzed. We have now examined the 5′- and 3′-terminal RNase T₁-resistant oligonucleotides of the parents and the progeny of two crosses and found that in all cases the 5′- and 3′-terminal regions were derived from only one of the parents. Inasmuch as the parental RNAs are subterminally redundant, as in the ase of Pr RSV-C and AMV RNA, the progeny RNA have the same property. It is remarkable that the crossovers appear to take place with a high frequency close to the termini of the viral RNA.     

Identification of a preferred region for recombination and mutation in HIV-1 gag

We designed a cell culture-based system to test the hypothesis that recombination events during HIV-1 replication would be more frequent near the dimerization initiation sequence (DIS). A 459-bp region spanning the DIS through the 5'-end of gag was sequenced and analyzed to determine the frequency and distribution of crossover sites. We found a strong preference for recombination events occurring within a 112-nt-long region encompassing the gag AUG (64% of crossovers occurred in this region, compared to 10-14% in surrounding regions with similar lengths). Surprisingly, the region immediately surrounding the DIS was not a preferred site of recombination. Analysis of recombination events using RNA templates transcribed in vitro revealed a preference for crossover sites at the start of the gag coding region, similar to that observed in cell culture. This recombinogenic region was unusually G-rich and promoted extensive pausing by RT in vitro. Template features that induce RT pausing very likely contribute to the observed template switching events in gag during minus-strand synthesis. The region in gag that was a preferred site for recombination also had an approximately 2-fold higher mutation frequency compared to the rest of the region sequenced, but mutations were no more common in recombinant compared to non-recombinant clones, suggesting that recombination events were not mutagenic.     

Multiple sites of recombination within the RNA genome of foot-and-mouth disease virus

Recombinant foot-and-mouth disease viruses were isolated from cells infected with a mixture of temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants belonging to different subtype strains. In order to select for recombination events in many different regions of the genome, crosses were performed between various pairs of mutants, with ts mutations in different regions of the genome. ts+ progeny were analysed by electrofocusing virus-induced proteins and RNase T1 fingerprinting of their RNA. All but 5 out of 43 independent isolates, from nine crosses, proved to have recombinant RNA genomes. Maps of these genomes, based on a knowledge of the locations of the unique oligonucleotides, were constructed. Most could be interpreted as being the products of single genetic cross-overs, although three recombinants were formed by two cross-overs each. Cross-overs in at least twelve distinct regions of the genome were identified. This evidence of a large number of recombination sites suggests that RNA recombination in picornaviruses is a general, as opposed to a site-specific, phenomenon.     

Recombination in adenovirus: DNA sequence analysis of crossover sites in intertypic recombinants

The nucleotide sequence of the adenovirus type 5 genome has been determined for a 620-bp region that spans the C terminus of the pVI gene and the N terminus of the hexon gene, and compared to the adenovirus type 2 DNA sequence: 25 base changes have been identified, most of which do not lead to alterations in the amino acid sequence and regulatory signals in the region. Crossover sites in three intertypic recombinants have been previously located in this region of the genome by fine restriction mapping. A sequence determination for the three recombinants, and the four ts mutants used in generating the ts+ recombinants, was carried out. The crossovers were in each case located in a small region of complete sequence homology (from 45 to 156 nucleotides long) flanked on either side by sequences derived from each parent. These structures are compatible with a reciprocal crossing over model of generalised recombination, where a recombinant joint has resolved in a region of high DNA homology. For the recombinants considered here, this region abutts onto a neighbouring region of much lower sequence homology, and it is possible that the position of the crossover is determined at least in part by the termination of branch migration at a heterologous boundary.     

High resolution analysis of haplotype diversity and meiotic crossover in the human TAP2 recombination hotspot

Little is known about the nature of recombination hotspots in the human genome and the relationship between crossover activity and patterns of linkage disequilibrium. We have therefore used both haplotype analysis and direct detection of crossovers in sperm to characterize a putative recombination hotspot in the TAP2 gene within the class II region of the MHC. Haplotype diversity provided evidence for a localized hotspot within intron 2 of this gene. Sperm DNA typing using allele-specific PCR primers to selectively amplify recombinant TAP2 molecules revealed a highly localized meiotic crossover hotspot approximately 1.2 kb long, unusually abundant in sequence polymorphisms and flanked by DNA much less active in recombination. Sperm crossover appeared to be fully reciprocal, and almost all crossover products were simple, involving a single exchange between adjacent heterozygous markers. This hotspot appears to be much more active in female than male meiosis. No primary sequence similarities could be found between any of the very few well defined crossover hotspots in the human genome, all of which show recombinationally active domains 1-2 kb long. Direct comparison of recombination frequency and haplotype diversity in TAP2 showed that linkage disequilibrium measures were a poor predictor of crossover frequency in this region, with non-recombining markers sometimes in free association and with examples of pairs of markers spanning the recombination hotspot showing substantial or even absolute linkage disequilibrium.     

Strong correlation between meiotic crossovers and haplotype structure in a 2.5-Mb region on the long arm of chromosome 21

Although the haplotype structure of the human genome has been studied in great detail, very little is known about the mechanisms underlying its formation. To investigate the role of meiotic recombination on haplotype block formation, single nucleotide polymorphisms were selected at a high density from a 2.5-Mb region of human chromosome 21. Direct analysis of meiotic recombination by high-throughput multiplex genotyping of 662 single sperm identifies 41 recombinants. The crossovers were nonrandomly distributed within 16 small areas. All, except one, of these crossovers fall in areas where the haplotype structure exhibits breakdown, displaying a strong statistically positive association between crossovers and haplotype block breaks. The data also indicate a particular clustered distribution of recombination hotspots within the region. This finding supports the hypothesis that meiotic recombination makes a primary contribution to haplotype block formation in the human genome.     

Crossover regions in foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) recombinants correspond to regions of high local secondary structure

Summary The RNA genome of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) was analysed for the degree of inverted complementarity and thus potential secondary structure using the procedure of Pustell and Kafatos [Nucleic Acids Res (1982) 10: 4765–4782]. Regions of crossover in 42 FMDV recombinants [King et al. (1985) Virus Res 3: 373–384; Saunders et al. (1985) J Virol 56: 921–929] and regions lacking crossovers were assigned an average secondary structure score against which the number of observed recombinants was plotted. In general it was found that the mean value of potential secondary structure is significantly higher in crossover zones than in recombination-free zones. Recombination increased much more steeply with increasing secondary structure in the part of the genome coding for non-structural proteins than in the 5 third of the genome coding for structural proteins.Member of the MRC Virology Unit.     

Studies on the recombination between RNA genomes of poliovirus: the primary structure and nonrandom distribution of crossover regions in the genomes of intertypic poliovirus recombinants

A series of intertypic (type 3/type 1) poliovirus recombinants was obtained whose crossover sites were expected to be located in the middle of the viral genome, between the loci encoding type-specific antigenic properties, on the 5' side, and an altered sensitivity to guanidine, on the 3' side. The primary structures of the crossover regions in the genomes of these recombinants were determined by the primer extension method. The length of the crossover sites (the uninterrupted sequences shared by the recombinant and both parental genomes that are flanked, in the recombinant RNAs, by two heterotypic segments) varied between 2 and 32 nucleotides, but the majority of the sites were 5 nucleotides long or shorter. The crossover sites were nonrandomly distributed over the presumably available genome region: only a single such site was found within the gene for polypeptide 2A, whereas an apparent clustering of the crossover sites was encountered in other genomic segments. When the crossover sites were superimposed on a model of the secondary structure of the relevant region of the viral RNA molecule, a pattern consistent with the previously proposed mechanism of poliovirus recombination (L.I. Romanova, V.M. Blinov, E.A. Tolskaya, E.G. Viktorova, M.S. Kolesnikova, E.I. Guseva, and V.I. Agol (1986) Virology 155, 202-213) was observed. It is suggested that the nonrandom distribution of the crossover sites in the genomes of intertypic poliovirus recombinants was due to two factors: the existence of preferred sites for recombination, and selection against recombinants with a lowered level of viability.