Electromyographic study of human jaw-closing muscle endurance, fatigue and recovery at various isometric force levels

The effect of a sustained isometric clenching, at various force levels or maximum voluntary bite-force levels, was evaluated on normal jaw-function subjects. Surface electromyographic (EMG) recordings of the masseter and temporalis were taken and bite force was measured using an intra-oral force transducer placed unilaterally in the 2nd premolar-1st molar region. Subjects sustained isometric force at the 25, 50, 75 and 100 per cent force level. Maximal bite force and EMG contraction levels were measured before, during and after these sustained isometric tasks. Subjects showed no change in their brief maximal contraction or force levels during or after various fatigue-inducing isometric tasks. The findings suggested a lack of contractile failure in the jaw-closing muscles. Pain intolerance rather than neuromuscular fatigue is the limiting factor of a sustained submaximal or even maximal clenching effort.     

Masseter muscle relaxation rate in volunteers with a myogenous craniomandibular disorder

SUMMARY Twelve volunteers were investigated to determine their masseter muscle relaxation rate following voluntary contractions. Four of these volunteers were patients diagnosed as having a myogenous craniomandibular disorder. Electromyograms were recorded from the left and right masseter muscles and maximum bite force was recorded in the midline between the incisor teeth. A sustained contraction was maintained at 50% maximum voluntary bite force for 90s, during which there was a brief relaxation every 10s. Recordings were continued for a 3 min recovery period. This sequence was then repeated at 25% of maximum bite force. Median power frequencies were calculated from the power spectra for the first and last 3s of the sustained contractions. Relaxation rates were measured for each brief relaxation during the sustained contraction and for the relaxation from each brief clench during the recovery period. It was found that maximum bite force values were very similar for volunteers in both the patient and control groups. Relaxation rates slowed more and percentage changes in median frequency were greater in the controls than in the patients during the sustained contractions. However, relaxation rates returned to initial levels more quickly in the controls than in the patients.     

The effect of sustained submaximal clenching on maximum bite force in myofascial pain dysfunction patients

The effect of a sustained (30% maximum) isometric clenching task on the maximum voluntary bite force level was evaluated on normal jaw function subjects as well as on abnormal jaw function subjects (MPD patients). The results indicate that the MPD subjects had a lower maximum voluntary bite force level and a shorter endurance time when compared to normal subjects. Neither the control subjects nor the MPD subjects demonstrated a change in their brief MVBF after a ‘fatigue inducing’ task. These results suggest a lack of contractile element failure in the jaw closing muscles following sustained submaximal isometric clenching on a force transducer.     

Reproducibility of estimation of blood flow in the human masseter muscle from measurements of 133Xe clearance

The reproducibility of estimations of the masseter intramuscular blood flow (IMBF) was assessed bilaterally within and between clinical sessions. The 133Xe clearance in nine normal individuals was measured before, during, immediately after, and after endurance of isometric contraction at an attempted level of 50% of maximum voluntary clenching contraction. An overall low reproducibility of the estimations was found. This result was probably caused by uncertainties about the exact site of intramuscular 133Xe deposition, errors in assessment of the plots of clearance, and variabilities in the relative contraction levels sustained and, especially, in the overall muscle effort. In agreement with previous reports concerning other skeletal muscles, the 133Xe clearance method provided inconsistent estimates of absolute values of IMBF also in this clinical setting. Although there was a high intra-individual variation in the relative level of isometric contraction sustained, the endurance test induced distinct changes in IMBF, among which the estimate of post-endurance hyperemia was the most consistent for each individual. Therefore, measurements of 133Xe clearance seem to be useful to detect intra-individual changes in masseter IMBF resulting from isometric work.     

Relation between integrated electromyographic activity and biting force during voluntary isometric contraction in human masticatory muscles.

The relation between integrated electromyographic activity and computed biting force during voluntary isometric contraction was evaluated in the masticatory muscles of healthy subjects. The slopes of the curves relating integrated electromyographic activity to computed biting force in masseter muscles were steeper on the non-preferred chewing side than on the preferred chewing side, and they progressively became steeper during the course of continuous isometric contraction of a given biting force.     

Analysis of electromyographic signals in human jaw closing muscles at various isometric force levels

The effect of sustained isometric contraction on surface electromyograph (EMG) and force signals derived from these muscles was examined. Premolar-molar region force was measured with a small unilaterally positioned force transducer. Subjects produced and sustained 25, 50, 75 and 100 per cent isometric force levels, and measurements were made at the beginning and end of these efforts. There was no significant change in the resulting EMG/force ratio at any of the force levels. The EMG signal did exhibit a significant shift in its frequency both as the force level increased and during the sustained effort. Neuromuscular fatigue, when defined as a change in the EMG/force ratio, was not demonstrated even though there was a consistent change in the frequency of the EMG signal.     

Electromyographic power spectrum of jaw muscles during clenching in unilateral temporomandibular joint osteoarthritis patients

The relationship between temporomandibular joints (TMJ) osteoarthritis and masticatory muscle disorders is poorly understood. The data are sparse, the results are conflicting, and electromyographic (EMG) power spectrum analysis has not been used. The aims of this study were to compare the differences in EMG power spectrum during, and pressure pain thresholds (PPTs) before and after, sustained clenching in patients with unilateral TMJ osteoarthritis and healthy control subjects. Nineteen patients with unilateral TMJ osteoarthritis without masticatory muscle pain and 20 control subjects were evaluated. We measured EMG amplitudes at maximum voluntary contraction, median frequency from the EMG power spectrum during sustained clenching at 70% and PPTs before and after the clenching in both temporalis and masseter muscles. There were no significant differences in PPT decrease between muscles or between groups during sustained clenching. There were no significant differences in maximum voluntary contraction EMG activity ratios of affected to unaffected sides between groups, or of masseter to temporalis muscles between affected and unaffected side of patients with TMJ osteoarthritis. Median frequencies decreased from the beginning to the end of the sustained clench, and the interaction between group and clench was significant: the median frequency decrease was larger in the osteoarthritis group. Our results suggested that masticatory muscles of patients with unilateral TMJ osteoarthritis are more easily fatigued during sustained clenching than normal subjects.     

Fatigue-related changes in discharge patterns of motor units in the inferior head of the lateral pterygoid muscle in humans

OBJECTIVE: To investigate single motor unit (SMU) firing patterns of the inferior head of the human lateral pterygoid muscle (IHLP) during sustained isometric contractions, and to examine IHLP fatigability. DESIGN: In 5 subjects, EMG was recorded from the right IHLP during generation of horizontal isometric mandibular force towards left side. Subjects tracked a target on an oscilloscope, slowly increasing the force to 25% of maximum voluntary contraction, and then maintained that force for 120 s (endurance task). Subjects rested for 30 s after each test, and three 10s recovery tests were performed every 30 s (recovery task). Fatigue data were obtained from 23 SMUs. RESULTS: Twelve of 23 SMUs (52.2%) continued to fire throughout the 120 s, and each subject had at least one of these units. These units were classified as tonic pattern (T-unit). The firing rate of 6 of the 12 T-units (50.0%) decreased gradually with time. Comparison of the mean firing rate and coefficient of variance (CV) of interspike interval (ISI) of the 12 T-units between pre-fatigue, post-fatigue and the three recovery tasks showed that the mean firing rate decreased and CV of ISI increased after fatigue. Mean firing rate and CV of ISI recovered after 30 s of rest after the endurance task. CONCLUSIONS: The firing patterns of IHLP units changed with the passing of time during sustained isometric contractions leading to fatigue.     

An evaluation of temporomandibular joints and jaw muscles after orthodontic treatment involving premolar extractions

Experimental subjects (n = 29) were patients who had undergone orthodontic treatment in combination with extraction of maxillary or mandibular premolar teeth, or both. Control subjects (n = 29) were healthy dental students with no orthodontic or extraction experience. Sagittal (corrected axis) tomograms of the TMJs were used to determine the narrowest linear distances between the anterior and posterior outlines of the TMJ condyle and the TMJ fossa, expressed as the joint space ratio. There were no significant (p greater than 0.05) differences between the control and experimental ratios. Bipolar surface electromyograms of the masseter and anterior temporalis muscles were used to determine the isometric contraction velocities of these muscles until 50% and 100% voluntary isometric contraction effort (teeth clenching) was achieved. There were no significant (p greater than 0.05) differences between the control and experimental subjects. Electromyograms were also used to determine the relative contribution of the masseter and anterior temporalis muscles to the bite force developed during brief maximum voluntary tooth clenching, expressed as the activity index. There were no significant (p greater than 0.05) differences between the control and experimental subjects.     

Haemodynamic changes in human masseter and temporalis muscles induced by different levels of isometric contraction.

This study evaluated the influence of low contraction forces on intramuscular haemodynamics in human masseter and temporalis using near-infrared tissue spectroscopy. This method allowed the intramuscular haemoglobin (Hb) to be assessed dynamically before, during and after a 5, 15, 25 and 100% maximum voluntary contraction (MVC). Twenty volunteers, 10 males and 10 females, without pain or dysfunction in the masticatory system were included in this study. Data were recorded for 30 s before, 30 s during and 5 min after the four sustained contraction tasks. The results showed that all four levels of voluntary contraction produced a clear haemodynamic response (during and after contraction) in both muscles. For analytical purposes, the maximum Hb achieved after 100% MVC was set equal to 1.00. In the masseter the mean peak Hb during the 5, 15, 25 and 100% MVC was 0.49, 0.92, 1.30 and 1.73 while after the contractions it was 0.50, 0.65, 0.78 and 1.00, respectively. In the temporalis the peak Hb during the contractions was 0.23, 0.36, 0.48 and 0.66 and after the contractions 0.32, 0.45, 0.56 and 1.00, respectively. Repeated-measures analysis of variance revealed a significant main effect for the different contraction levels both in the masseter (during contraction, p = 0.001; after contraction, p<0.001) and the temporalis (during contraction, p = 0.002; after contraction, p<0.001). These data suggest that low levels of contraction induce a clear haemodynamic response, even at 5% effort. When compared, the masseter and anterior temporalis showed clearly different patterns for the Hb signal during the contraction (p<0.001) as well as after it (p = 0.007). Specifically, the Hb during the contractions in the masseter appeared more stable than in the temporalis, which showed a strong return to baseline. Obviously the contracting masseter had a stronger and more sustained venous occlusion than the contracting temporalis. It is speculated that variation in architecture between the two muscles contributes to these differences in blood flow.     

Anterior and posterior neck muscle activation during a variety of biting tasks

Bruxism may be involved in the aetiology of myofascial neck pain. The objective of this study was to test the hypothesis that anterior and posterior neck muscles co-contract during jaw clenching. Ten test subjects developed different feedback-controlled submaximum bite forces in a variety of bite-force directions by means of bite-force transducers. The electromyographic activity of the sternocleidomastoid and supra/infrahyoidal muscles, and of the semispinalis capitis, semispinalis cervicis, and multifidi muscles was recorded by use of surface electrodes and intramuscular wire electrodes, respectively. For normalization of electromyography data, maximum voluntary contraction tasks of the neck muscles were conducted in eight different loading directions. The results confirmed co-contraction of the neck muscles in the range of 2-14% of the maximum voluntary contraction at a bite force ranging from 50 to 300 N. Significant activity differences were observed as a result of the different force levels and force directions exerted by the jaw muscles. Long-lasting tonic activation of specific neck muscles triggered by the jaw-clenching tasks was also detected. These findings support the assumption of a relationship between jaw clenching and the activity of the neck muscles investigated. The low level of co-contraction activity, however, requires further study to elucidate possible pathophysiological interactions at the level of single motor units.     

Cold pressor stimulation effect on hemodynamic changes following sustained isometric contraction in human jaw-closure muscles

It is postulated that an altered adrenergic response pattern may be associated with chronic muscle pain states. To evaluate this hypothesis, one must fully understand the effect of an adrenergic activation on masticatory muscle blood flow under various conditions. This study evaluated the effect of a 12 degrees C cold pressor stimulation (a mild adrenergic activator), applied to the hand-forearm area, on intramuscular hemodynamics in the human masseter and temporalis muscles following a sustained isometric contraction. We assessed hemodynamics by measuring intramuscular hemoglobin concentration repeatedly, using a non-invasive near-infrared spectroscopy device. Measurements were taken before, during, and after a 30-second sustained 50% maximum voluntary contraction task. Fourteen healthy subjects, seven males and seven females, with no history of muscle pain in the masticatory system participated in this study. This protocol was repeated three times, but in the second trial, the cold pressor stimulation was applied to the subject during and for 5 min after the sustained contraction task. Repeated-measure analysis of variance performed on these data revealed that the peak hemoglobin concentration levels in the post-contraction recovery period were significantly reduced (between 13 and 14%) with cold pressor stimulation, both in the masseter (p < 0.001) and in the temporalis (p < 0.001) muscles. The results suggest that cold pressor stimulation produced a reduced intramuscular vasodilative response in these muscles during the immediate post-contraction period. One explanation for these results is that altering the local chemical environment of the muscle affects the adrenergic response pattern typically induced by a cold pressor stimulation.     

Activity index and isometric contraction velocity of human jaw muscles

To determine the relative contribution of the masseter and anterior temporalis muscles to global isometric bite force, activity indices were constructed on the basis of the peak mean voltage (microV) and the integrated voltage (microV.s) of bipolar surface electromyograms obtained during brief maximum voluntary teeth clenching (MVC). The index that was based on integrated myoelectrical activity showed that the masseter muscle contributed the major part of the isometric MVC force. The index that was based on instantaneous peak myoelectrical activity also showed that activity in the masseter muscle predominated over that in the anterior temporalis muscle. In addition, the latter index showed a negative linear association with the initial (0-50% MVC) isometric contraction velocities of the masseter and anterior temporalis muscles. Both indices appear to be promising clinical diagnostic tools.     

Electromyographic activity during awake tooth grinding tasks at different jaw posture in the sagittal plane

Abstract

Objective. The goal of this study was to evaluate the electromyographic (EMG) activity of the anterior temporalis, suprahyoid, infrahyoid and trapezius muscles during tooth grinding at different jaw posture tasks. Materials and methods. Participants were 30 healthy subjects with natural dentition, bilateral molar support and incisive protrusive guidance. Bipolar surface electrodes were located on the right side of the subject. EMG recordings were performed in the following tasks: (A) Eccentric grinding from intercuspal position to protrusive edge-to-edge contact position; (B) concentric grinding from protrusive edge-to-edge contact position to intercuspal position; (C) eccentric grinding from intercuspal position to the maximum voluntary retrusive position; and (D) concentric grinding from the maximum voluntary retrusive position to intercuspal position. The results were analyzed statistically by Friedman test and Wilcoxon signed rank-sum test. Results. EMG activity in the anterior temporalis and infrahyoid muscles was significantly higher during task C than the other tasks. EMG activity in the suprahyoid muscles was significantly higher during task C than task D. EMG activity in the trapezius muscle was significantly higher during task C than tasks A and B. Conclusions. The higher EMG activity recorded in task C could become important when its frequency, duration and magnitude are enough to exceed the adaptation capability of the individual.     

Reperfusion response changes induced by repeated,sustained contractions in normal human masseter muscle

The purpose was to evaluate the intramuscular reperfusion response characteristics associated with repeated isometric contractions in normal human masseter. Intramuscular blood volume was quantified with a near-infrared spectroscopic device that measured the total haemoglobin (Hb) concentration in the muscle. Electromyographic (EMG) activity from the masseter and total bite forces were also recorded. Sixteen healthy volunteers, eight females and eight males, without masticatory muscle pain participated. They were asked first to clench their teeth for as long as possible at 50% of their maximum voluntary contraction (MVC). This was followed by a 60s rest and then immediately by a standard clenching task (50% MVC for 30s) and a 60s recovery period, immediately after which they were asked to repeat exactly the same procedure, with a final 5 min recovery period after the second 30s contraction. Bite force, EMG and Hb concentration were measured continuously and the duration of the two endurance tasks and the amplitudes of all recorded signals were compared (first trial versus second trial). Specifically, the difference between the lowest Hb (trough) seen during the standardised 30s contractions and the highest (peak) seen just after them was assessed. The trough-to-peak difference in Hb concentration of the second standard contraction task was significantly smaller than that of the first standard task (P<0.05, paired t-test). These data show that with sustained effort the post-contraction vasodilatory reperfusion responses of the human masseter are diminished, suggesting a progressive desensitisation of the vasodilatory system.     

The effect of various jaw motor tasks on body sway

Alterations of body sway caused by isometric contractions of the jaw muscles have been reported previously. The objective of this study was to test if motor tasks of the masticatory system with different control demands affect body posture differently during quiet stance. Position and sway displacements of the center of foot pressure (COP) were measured for 20 healthy subjects who either kept the mandible at rest or performed unilateral and bilateral maximum voluntary teeth clenching, feedback-controlled biting tasks at submaximum bite forces, or unilateral chewing. Two weeks later the measurements were repeated. Compared with quiet stance, the COP results revealed significant changes during the feedback-controlled biting tasks. Robust sway reduction and anterior displacement of the COP were observed under these conditions. Body oscillations were not significantly affected by maximum bites or by unilateral chewing. For most of the variables investigated there were no significant differences between unilateral and bilateral biting. Robust sway reduction during feedback-controlled biting tasks in healthy subjects involved a stiffening phenomenon that was attributed to the common physiological repertoire of posture control, and might optimize the stability of posture under these conditions.     

Comparison of 133Xe clearance and laser Doppler flowmetry in assessment of blood flow changes in human masseter muscle induced by isometric contraction

Changes induced by 30 s of isometric contraction at 10% and 50% of the maximum voluntary contraction were assessed in 10 healthy subjects; there was a median increase of 1.8 and 0.3 times in 133Xe clearance and 5.3 and 2.7 times in laser Doppler flowmetry. In the first minute after 10% maximum voluntary contraction, 133Xe clearance increased 12.1 times in relation to the initial resting level, and flowmetry values decreased to become 3.5 times higher than the basal flow; corresponding values after 50% maximum voluntary contraction were 24.3 times and 3.7 times. From the second minute after contraction, there was a rapid decrease in 133Xe clearance and a slow decrease in flowmetry values. Five minutes after biting at 10% maximum voluntary contraction, both methods showed a total net increase of about 15 times; after biting at 50% maximum voluntary contraction the corresponding values were 38 and 23 times. Thus laser Doppler flowmetry can be used to assess changes in blood flow in the masseter; it registers a greater increase in flow during isometric contraction than does 133Xe clearance. The significant difference between methods immediately after either chosen level of contraction disappears when the total net post-contraction hyperaemia is assessed over a period of 2 and 5 min, respectively.     

Bite force, endurance and masseter muscle fatigue in healthy edentulous subjects and those with TMD

It is well known that bite force and EMG activity are considerably reduced in edentulous patients, but the susceptibility of their jaw-closing muscles to localized fatigue is less certain. This information is even less clear for edentulous subjects who have TMD. Eleven healthy edentulous subjects and 10 edentulous subjects with TMD participated in this study. Maximum bite force was measured first, with the transducer placed on the canine-first premolar region bilaterally, and then two rapid relaxations were made from a brief voluntary clench to 50% of maximum. A sustained voluntary clench of 50% of maximum was then maintained and endurance time was noted. EMG was recorded from both masseter muscles and the median frequency of the power spectrum of the EMG from 2 s at the beginning of the sustained clench and 2 s at the end was subsequently calculated. Two more rapid relaxations from brief clenches were performed immediately after the sustained clench. The mean maximum bite force in the healthy group was 115 N (SD +/-41) and in the TMD group was 75 N (SD +/-22), this difference being significant (P = 0.0013). The mean endurance time in the healthy group was 86 s (SD +/-51) and in the TMD group was 63 s (SD +/-20). The percentage change in the median frequency in the healthy group as a result of the sustained contraction was 6% (left) and 8.6% (right) and in the TMD group was 13.9% (left) and 12.8% (right). The percentage change in the mean relaxation half time for the healthy group was 28.5% and for the TMD group was 72%, a significant difference (P = 0.0046). It was apparent that the maximum bite force was low in edentulous subjects and was further reduced in edentulous TMD subjects; endurance time was reduced in TMD subjects; fatigue resistance of the masseter muscles was reduced in TMD subjects.     

Observations on the motor control of brief teeth clenching in man

Without artificial feedback control, maximum voluntary isometric contractions were performed for about 1 s by six subjects. Randomly selected surface electromyograms of the anterior temporalis and masseter muscles suggested that, in some cases, the motor control of the entire isometric contraction might have been preprogrammed through the phenomenon of anticipation. In the majority of cases, the control of the initial contraction phase might have been preprogrammed, followed by a phase of servo-controlled motor activity. As a functional basis for the servo-control of isometric force generation, it was suggested that compartmentalized 'extrafusal and intrafusal motor units' were recruited and decruited in an orderly manner, and periods of alpha-motor inhibition were interpreted as signs of switching from one control scheme to another, possibly via a transcortical loop.     

Fatigue and pain in human jaw muscles during a sustained, low-intensity clenching task

Fatigue, pain and changes in the electromyographic (EMG) activity of the jaw-closing muscles are well documented during short, high-intensity tooth-clenching tasks but less so during sustained, low-intensity tasks. In this study, 11 healthy men clenched on a bite-force meter for 60 min at 10% of the maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) and scored the intensity of fatigue and pain on separate 10 cm visual analogue scales (VAS). Surface EMG activity from the masseter and anterior temporalis muscles was recorded in 10 s epochs every 5 min throughout the task. Pressure-pain thresholds (PPTs) in the jaw-closing muscles, unassisted maximum jaw opening and MVC were determined before and after the task. All participants reported an increasing sensation of fatigue in the jaw-closing muscles during the task (mean+/-SD: peak VAS=7.5+/-2.0 cm) but all were able to maintain the required force. Most (7/11) also reported a painful sensation (peak VAS=2.7+/-2.8 cm). The jaw-opening capacity (59.5+/-7.4 vs. 58.3+/-6.5 mm, P=0.031) and the MVC (777+/-73 vs. 652+/-115 N,P=0.002) were slightly, but significantly, decreased immediately after the task whereas the PPTs remained unchanged (ANOVA: P=0.612). The mean frequency of the EMG activity decreased in all muscles during the task (95.7 vs. 46.6 Hz;P<0.001), and the root mean squares increased (53.2 vs. 154 microV, P<0.001). The changes in EMG activity were more strongly correlated with the sensation of fatigue than pain. These findings demonstrate that a sustained, low-intensity clenching task can induce subjective and electrophysiological indications of fatigue.