Repair of locked bucket-handle meniscal tears in knees with chronic anterior cruciate ligament deficiency

BACKGROUND: Large bucket-handle meniscal tears in knees with chronic anterior cruciate ligament deficiency have been considered avascular and, thus, irreparable. HYPOTHESIS: The rate of meniscal healing is higher than previously reported. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective cohort study. METHODS: Fifty-nine patients underwent staged surgical procedures of meniscal repair followed at an average of 77 +/- 58 days by ligament reconstruction once full range of motion was obtained. RESULTS: Fifty-two patients with 55 meniscal repairs were available for follow-up. At reconstruction, 30 menisci (55%) appeared healed; 19 (34%), partially healed; and 6 (11%) showed no healing (only 4 were removed). Of 43 tears in the white-on-white zone, 21 appeared healed; 17, partially healed; and 5 showed no healing. Of 11 in the red-on-white zone, 8 appeared healed; 2, partially healed; and 1 showed no healing. One meniscal tear in the red-on-red zone appeared healed. At an average follow-up of 4.3 +/- 3.1 years, 36 of the 43 (83.7%) white-on-white meniscal repairs remained asymptomatic; all repairs in the other zones remained asymptomatic. CONCLUSION: Locked bucket-handle meniscal tears heal at a high rate when repaired as an isolated procedure, even when full weightbearing and activity before reconstruction is allowed and when the tear is in the white-on-white zone.     

Healing potential of meniscal tears without repair in knees with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

BACKGROUND: Few previous studies have documented the healing potential of meniscal tears that are left to heal without repair. PURPOSE: To determine the healing rates of meniscal tears left without repair in knees with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective cohort study. METHODS: One hundred and ninety-two knees were evaluated at the time of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction and repeat arthroscopy. The healing rates of 41 medial and 42 lateral torn menisci without repair were evaluated by the same 2 surgeons in an identical fashion. RESULTS: Of 41 medial torn menisci left without repair, 22 (56%) were considered completely healed, 3 (7%) were incompletely healed, 11 (24%) were unhealed, and 5 (10%) had expanded unhealed lesions. Of 42 lateral torn menisci, 31 (74%) were considered completely healed, 2 (5%) were incompletely healed, 6 (14%) were unhealed, and 3 (7%) had expanded unhealed lesions. The healing rate of a medial meniscal tear was length dependent and not related to reconstructed ligament stability. CONCLUSIONS: Stable meniscal tears at the time of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction possibly could be left in situ. However, longer medial meniscal tears are thought to require additional stabilizing procedures.     

All-inside meniscal repair using a new flexible, tensionable device

BACKGROUND: A new generation of flexible all-inside meniscal repair devices is available, but clinical studies with these devices are lacking. HYPOTHESIS: The RapidLoc has an intermediate-term meniscal healing rate that is equivalent to literature reports of inside-out suture technique in patients undergoing concurrent anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. STUDY DESIGN: Case series; Level of evidence, 4. METHODS: Retrospective analysis was performed for 75 meniscal tears in 66 consecutive patients undergoing anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction who underwent meniscal repair with the RapidLoc. Patients with at least 2 years' follow-up were evaluated for symptoms suggestive of a meniscal tear and were assessed with the International Knee Documentation Committee form and the Knee Disorders Subjective History visual analog scale. Subjects were asked to return for a clinical examination to include evaluation for an effusion and joint line tenderness as well as McMurray test and KT-1000 arthrometry readings. Patients with symptoms consistent with meniscal repair failure underwent magnetic resonance arthrography and repeat arthroscopy. RESULTS: Twenty patients with 21 meniscal tears were excluded, resulting in 54 meniscal tears in 46 patients. At a mean follow-up of 34.8 months, the clinical success rate for meniscal repair was 90.7% (49/54), with 5 failures requiring meniscectomy. Univariate analysis revealed predictive variables for failure: bucket-handle configuration, multiplanar tears, tear length greater than 2 cm, and chronicity longer than 3 months. Non-predictive variables included compartment, zone, ligament graft choice, gender, age, follow-up, and visual analog scale score. Analysis of healed patients revealed a negative correlation between chronicity of tear and International Knee Documentation Committee score. CONCLUSIONS: The RapidLoc has an acceptable intermediate-term clinical healing rate in patients undergoing concurrent anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Predictive variables for failure should be considered during operative decision making.     

Arthroscopic meniscal repair using T-fix

We evaluated the arthroscopic meniscal repair using T-fix and present our preliminary results. The series included 47 consecutive patients who underwent meniscal repair using T-fix. Mean follow-up was 26 months (range 12-42 months). The overall number of T-fixes used in the repairs was 163, with a mean of three (range two to five) per patient. Patients were evaluated according to the modified Marshall scoring system. Results were rated as excellent in 32, good in 10, fair in 2, and poor in 3 patients. Second-look arthroscopy was performed in 18 patients as the part of our protocol. In 15 patients meniscal tears were considered to be healed, according to Henning's criteria. Six of those who underwent anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction healed completely. There were no neurovascular complications. Repair of the menisci using T-fix proved successful and reliable. In view of satisfactory functional results and the observation of healing of tears on second-look arthroscopy, we believe that preservation and repair of menisci should be attempted in appropriate cases.     

Deteriorating outcomes after meniscal repair using the Meniscus Arrow in knees undergoing concurrent anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: increased failure rate with long-term follow-up

BACKGROUND: An increased awareness of the degenerative changes that occur in the knee after meniscectomy has led to efforts to salvage the injured meniscus. Numerous devices have been developed in an effort to provide the dual benefits of a durable meniscal repair and minimal invasiveness. HYPOTHESIS: The Meniscus Arrow is comparable to conventional inside-out suture repair in accomplishing long-term healing of meniscal tears. STUDY DESIGN: Case series; Level of evidence, 4. METHODS: This study is an extended follow-up of an original series of 32 patients with outcomes analysis. All patients underwent meniscal repair with exclusive use of the arrow. All repairs were performed in the context of a concomitant anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Follow-up assessment included physical examination, arthrometry, the International Knee Documentation Committee instrument, and the Knee Disorders Subjective History visual analog scale. Intermediate follow-up at a mean of 2.3 years yielded a success rate of 90.6%. The mean follow-up in the present study has been extended to 6.6 years. RESULTS: The extended follow-up analysis revealed a substantial attrition in the success rate of this series of patients undergoing meniscal repair with the arrow. A 90.6% success rate at a mean follow-up of 2.3 years deteriorated to 71.4% at 6.6 years. CONCLUSION: This study provides the longest follow-up in the literature of any of the all-inside meniscal repair implants. The Meniscus Arrow demonstrated long-term meniscal healing rates inferior to those found in the literature for inside-out suture repair techniques.     

Arthroscopic repair of meniscal tears extending into the avascular zone in patients younger than twenty years of age

BACKGROUND: Limited data are available regarding repair results of meniscal tears extending into the central avascular region. HYPOTHESIS: Meniscal tears extending into the avascular region can be successfully repaired in patients less than 20 years old. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective cohort study. METHODS: We examined the results of 71 meniscal repairs (64 knees) for tears extending into the central avascular region in patients 19 years of age or younger; 67 were examined clinically (mean, 51 months after surgery) and 36, by follow-up arthroscopy (mean, 18 months). RESULTS: In 53 of 71 (75%) meniscal repairs patients had no tibiofemoral compartment symptoms and there were no clinical failures. In 18 (25%) meniscal repairs, patients showed tibiofemoral symptoms or a failed repair was detected on follow-up arthroscopy. In the subgroup of 45 knees with meniscal repair and anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction evaluated clinically, 39 (87%) patients rated their knee as normal or very good, 2 (4%) as good, 3 (7%) as fair, and 1 (2%) as poor. CONCLUSIONS: A stable repair of complex meniscal tears that extend into the avascular region can be obtained using a meticulous inside-out vertical divergent suture technique. We recommend repair, particularly in young active patients in whom removal of complex tears would result in major loss of meniscal function and the risk of future arthrosis.     

Anterior cruciate-deficient knees: a review of the literature

Injury to the anterior cruciate ligament may lead to functional instability, meniscal injury, and premature degenerative changes of the knee or, if treatment and rehabilitation are carried out carefully, to a functionally stable knee with no premature degenerative changes. Unfortunately, the complex anatomy of the three fiber bundles, consisting of multiple collagenous strands, which constitutes the anterior cruciate ligament combined with variation of injuries to the ligament, with or without injury to other structures of the knee, makes any standardization of surgical treatment difficult. In this paper, we review the biomechanics of the knee, the anatomy and vascularization of the anterior cruciate ligament, the healing characteristics of ligamentous material, and the types of surgical repair that have appeared in recent articles. Those repairs can be divided into direct repair, extraarticular substitution and intraarticular augmentation, freeze-dried fascia lata allografts, and temporary supportive prosthesis such as carbon fiber. Essential to the success of any surgical repair of the anterior cruciate-deficient knee is a prolonged, carefully organized rehabilitation program that allows adequate healing and strengthening of the ligament before it is used normally again. The patient's clear understanding of the importance of a prolonged rehabilitation is best established before the surgical procedure is done.     

The effect of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction on the risk of knee reinjury

BACKGROUND: Although there is evidence that very active, young patients are better served with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, there is a lack of objective data demonstrating that future knee injury is prevented by these procedures. HYPOTHESIS: Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction protects against reinjury of the knee that would require reoperation. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective cohort study. METHODS: A cohort of 6576 active-duty army personnel who had been hospitalized for anterior cruciate ligament injury from 1990 to 1996 were identified. Using the Total Army Injury and Health Outcomes Database, the authors followed these individuals for up to 9 years and collected clinical, demographic, and occupational data. These data were evaluated with bivariate and multivariable analyses to determine the effect of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction on the rate of knee reinjury that required operation. RESULTS: Of the 6576 study subjects, 3795 subjects (58%) underwent anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction and 2781 (42%) did not. The rate of reoperation was significantly lower among the anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction group (4.90/100 person-years) compared with those treated conservatively (13.86/100 person-years; P < .0001). Proportional hazard regression analyses adjusted for age, race, sex, marital status, education, and physical activity level confirmed that anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction was protective against meniscal and cartilage reinjury (P < .0001). Secondary medial meniscal injury was more common than secondary lateral meniscal injury (P < .003). Younger age was the strongest predictor of failure of conservative management leading to late anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (P < .0001). CONCLUSIONS: Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction protected against reoperation in this young, active population; younger subjects were more likely to require late anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Strong consideration should be given to anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction after anterior cruciate ligament injury in young, active individuals.     

Evaluation and treatment of chronic medial collateral ligament injuries of the knee

Injuries to the medial collateral ligament (MCL) can occur as isolated injuries or in conjunction with injuries to other structures about the knee. Most grade I and II MCL injuries without meniscal avulsion, alone or in combination with anterior or posterior cruciate ligament injuries, can be treated nonoperatively. Grade III or complete tears also can be treated nonoperatively, but only after careful exclusion of any associated injuries that may require surgical treatment. Treatment recommendations also have been based on the location of the MCL tear and the associated injuries. Surgical treatment may include reconstruction of the anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments with primary repair of the MCL. Chronic medial knee injuries often are associated with concomitant ligament injuries, which also must be treated. Treatment options include nonoperative (bracing, activity modification, and rehabilitation) and operative reconstruction.     

Fixed posterior subluxation in posterior cruciate ligament-deficient knees: diagnosis and treatment of a new clinical sign.

Among 248 patients seen for posterior cruciate ligament insufficiency, 109 (44%) had fixed posterior subluxation of the tibia, defined as a condition in which posterior sag could not be reduced to a neutral position, as evidenced by posterior tibial displacement of 3 mm or more on anterior stress radiographs at 200 N. The mean fixed posterior displacement was 6.23 mm (range, 3 to 20). The fixed posterior subluxation was divided into three grades: I, 3 to 5 mm (57.8%); II, 6 to 10 mm (33.9%); and III, more than 10 mm (8.3%). Comparison of the 109 study patients with the 139 control patients revealed a history of a failed posterior cruciate ligament operation or of a patellar tendon harvest, male sex, and a long history of posterior cruciate ligament insufficiency as significant risk factors for the development of a fixed posterior subluxation. After patients were treated with a posterior tibial support brace, the fixed posterior subluxation could be reduced to a mean of 2.58 +/- 5.22 mm within an average treatment period of 180 days. Fixed posterior subluxation can be detected in patients with posterior cruciate ligament deficiency by anterior and posterior stress radiographs and should be addressed before posterior cruciate ligament reconstruction to prevent early overloading of the graft.     

Clinical outcome of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with quadrupled hamstring tendon graft and bioabsorbable interference screw fixation

BACKGROUND: To date, there has been no publication of clinical follow-up data on patients who have undergone quadrupled hamstring tendon autograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with bioabsorbable screw fixation. PURPOSE: To report the results of quadrupled hamstring tendon autograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with bioabsorbable interference screw fixation. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective review. METHODS: Sixty-five patients (66 knees) were retrospectively identified by chart review as having undergone quadrupled hamstring tendon autograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with bioabsorbable interference screw fixation with a minimum 2-year follow-up. RESULTS: Data were collected on 48 knees in 47 patients (73%) at an average 30.2 months (range, 24 to 43) after surgery. Thirty-six patients (37 knees) returned for clinical evaluation (56% return) and subjective follow-up only was obtained in 11 patients (17%). The mean Lysolm knee score was 91 (range, 45 to 98), with a mean of 97 for the uninvolved knee. The mean Tegner activity score was 5.7 (range, 3 to 7). The KT-1000 arthrometer mean side-to-side difference for manual maximum displacement was 2.03 mm (range, -1 to 8). The mean International Knee Documentation Committee knee score was 83 (range, 47 to 100). Patients who underwent associated partial meniscectomy or meniscal repair had significantly lower International Knee Documentation Committee scores than patients without associated procedures (P < 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Quadrupled hamstring tendon autograft anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with bioabsorbable interference screw fixation is comparable with other methods of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in terms of patient satisfaction, knee stability, and function.     

Distribution of substance-P nerve fibers in intact and ruptured human anterior cruciate ligament: a semi-quantitative immunohistochemical assessment

Numerous studies have reported qualitative and quantitative analysis of nerve supply in the anterior cruciate ligament; however, as yet relatively little is known about the distribution of substance-P nerve endings in the human anterior cruciate ligament. The objective of this work was to evaluate the distribution of substance-P nerve fibers in intact human anterior cruciate ligament, and determine if rupture of the ligament has any influence on occurrence of these receptors. The intact anterior cruciate ligament group (group 1) of osteoarthritis knee, undergoing total knee arthroplasty, consisted of nine patients (eight females) with a mean age of 65.3 years at surgery. The anterior cruciate ligament rupture group (group 2) consisted of 20 patients (18 males and 2 females) with a mean age of 27.8 years at reconstruction. Healing time of the torn ligament in vivo, determined by the time period between the rupture and reconstruction, lasted from 1 to 40 months and the patients were divided into 3 groups (I, II and III) embracing diverse time periods. All harvested anterior cruciate ligaments were sectioned in thirds so that there was a proximal, middle and distal third for each ligament. The distribution of nociceptive receptors was studied by immunohistochemistry with monoclonal antibody to substance-P, including the semi-quantitative assessment. No significant difference was found between the number of substance-P nerve fibers in the proximal, middle and distal third of the intact anterior cruciate ligament ( p >0.05). During the first 4 months after injury (group I) the mean number of neuropeptide-containing fibers was greater in the proximal than in the distal third ( p =0.048996). The number of SP-positive nerve fibers in the proximal third decreased between 5 and 12 months after rupture, in a statistically significant manner ( p =0.045864). This study showed that distribution of the nociceptive nerve supply, positively stained for substance-P, is equal among the intact anterior cruciate ligament. The substance-P nerve ending density was significantly affected by the injury as well as by the time since rupture. The results of this study provide immunohistochemical evidence suggesting that between 1 to 4 months after rupture the site of the injury undergoes neurogenic inflammation, which could have an influence on the healing course of the torn ligament.     

Prospective comparison of arthroscopic medial meniscal repair technique: inside-out suture versus entirely arthroscopic arrows

BACKGROUND: Medial meniscal repairs are commonly performed with inside-out sutures and entirely arthroscopic with arrows, but few comparative evaluations on failures have been performed. HYPOTHESIS: No differences in failure rates exist between medial meniscal repairs performed with inside-out suture or entirely arthroscopic at the time of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective cohort study. MATERIALS: A single surgeon performed 47 consecutive inside-out suture repairs from August 1991 to June 1996 and 98 consecutive entirely arthroscopic repairs with arrows from June 1996 to December 1999. All data were derived from a prospective database and rehabilitation was held constant (nonweightbearing 5 weeks). Clinical success was defined as no reoperation for failed medial meniscal repair. Statistical evaluation was by Kaplan-Meier curves and Cox proportional hazards model. RESULTS: The inside-out suture group had 85% follow-up (40 of 47) with a median 68 months and the entirely arthroscopic group had 87% follow-up (85 of 98) with a median 27 months. There were seven failures in each group. Both Kaplan-Meier curves and the Cox proportional hazards model showed no difference in time to reoperation between techniques (P = 0.85). Three-year success rates (proportions with no reoperations) were 88% for sutures versus 89% for arrows. CONCLUSIONS: Repairs of the longitudinal posterior horn of the medial meniscus during an anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with nonweightbearing for 5 weeks can be performed with an equivalent high degree of clinical success for both repair techniques.     

Clinical outcomes after combined meniscal allograft transplantation and anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

BACKGROUND: Concomitant meniscal transplantation performed at the time of ligament surgery may help to protect the anterior cruciate ligament graft. PURPOSE: To determine the objective and subjective clinical outcomes after combined anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction and meniscal allograft transplantation. STUDY DESIGN: Uncontrolled retrospective review. METHODS: Twenty-eight patients who underwent anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction along with meniscal transplantation were retrospectively evaluated postoperatively at an average of 2.8 years (range, 1.8 to 5.6). RESULTS: On the International Knee Documentation Committee overall subjective assessment, 86% had normal or nearly normal scores. The SF-36 physical and mental component summary scores were at higher levels than those of the patients' age- and sex-matched populations. Objectively, nearly 90% had normal or nearly normal Lachman and pivot shift test scores. The KT-1000 arthrometer testing at 30 pounds and maximum manual both demonstrated an average increased anterior translation of 1.5 mm compared with the contralateral knee. Joint space narrowing of the transplanted compartments was not significantly different from that of the contralateral knee. CONCLUSIONS: Meniscal transplantation with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction can be a beneficial procedure in properly selected patients with either chronic anterior cruciate ligament insufficiency or failed anterior cruciate ligament surgery. Restoration of meniscal function may provide protection for the articular cartilage and improve joint stability.     

Future directions in meniscal surgery

Despite the considerable technological advances in arthroscopic surgery in the past decade, it is of concern that meniscal repair is not being done in many cases where the meniscus tear is reparable and the patient, if properly informed, would desire it.There is accumulating evidence that the long-term benefits of meniscal repair significantly outweigh those of partial meniscectomy. But success must be tempered by looking at longer follow-up assessments than we are accustomed to doing.DeHaven found that the average time between surgery and failure was 4 years, in a study averaging 11 years of follow-up. Meniscal repairs in isolated tears of the meniscus are significantly less successful than repairs of meniscal tears associated with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. There is evidence that isolated meniscal tears in ACL-stable knees occur in menisci that are significantly more degenerated compared with menisci having tears associated with ACL disruption. Improved techniques of meniscal repair include the abrasion of both sides of the tear site, the use of increased numbers of vertically oriented nonabsorbable sutures, the insertion of a fibrin clot into the tear site, and the development of completely inside-the-knee suturing techniques. In the future, meniscal repair will become simpler and faster to perform. As a result, more meniscal repairs will be attempted. Over the next decade, we will see increasing research in the role of meniscal allografts and collagen (or other material) substitutes for the meniscus in patients with segmental defects or complete loss of the meniscus.     

The effects of time course after anterior cruciate ligament injury in correlation with meniscal and cartilage loss

In this study, 130 consecutive patients with anterior cruciate ligament insufficiency who were undergoing ligament reconstruction underwent arthroscopic examination at the time of reconstruction, and any loss of meniscal or chondral integrity was documented in a systematic fashion. In these patients, a greater proportion of the medial meniscus was lost compared with the lateral meniscus (16% versus 5%). On average, 6 cm2 of the articular cartilage was damaged (5.2 cm2) or lost (0.8 cm2), with the area of damage and loss greatest on the medial femoral condyle. Patients whose injuries had occurred more than 2 years before the examination had more than sixfold greater cartilage loss and damage compared with those whose injuries had occurred within the past 2 months. Meniscal loss was associated with a threefold increase in cartilage damage or loss. The group of patients with meniscal loss whose initial anterior cruciate ligament injury occurred more than 2 years before examination exhibited 18 times the amount of cartilage loss or damage as did the group that had no meniscal loss and whose injury occurred less than 1 month before examination.     

Effects of local administration of vascular endothelial growth factor on properties of the in situ frozen-thawed anterior cruciate ligament in rabbits

BACKGROUND: In the autogenous tendon for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, intrinsic fibroblasts are necrotized immediately after surgery, and repopulation and revascularization occur. Vascular endothelial growth factor is considered to be a potent mediator of angiogenesis. HYPOTHESIS: An application of vascular endothelial growth factor significantly enhances angiogenesis in the in situ frozen anterior cruciate ligament, and the application significantly affects mechanical properties of the in situ frozen anterior cruciate ligament. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Right anterior cruciate ligaments from 66 rabbits underwent the freeze-thaw treatment, and animals were then divided into 3 groups. Group I served as a freeze-thaw but otherwise untreated control. In group II, 0.2 mL phosphate-buffered saline alone was applied. In group III, 30 mug vascular endothelial growth factor was applied. The groups were compared on the basis of histologic revascularization examinations using the Chalkley score, an indicator of the microvessel density, and mechanical evaluations, which included the anterior-posterior translation of the tibia relative to the femur during +/- 10 N of anterior-posterior load and the mechanical properties of the anteromedial bundle of the anterior cruciate ligament. RESULTS: Group III's Chalkley score was significantly greater than that of groups I and II. The tensile strength and the tangent modulus of anterior cruciate ligaments in groups I, II, and III were significantly lower than those of a normal anterior cruciate ligament, although there were no significant differences among groups I, II, and III. CONCLUSION: Vascular endothelial growth factor, as administered in this study, significantly promoted angiogenesis in the devitalized anterior cruciate ligament with in situ freeze-thaw treatment, but it did not affect the mechanical properties of the in situ frozen-thawed anterior cruciate ligament in the rabbit model. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: An application of the recombinant anterior cruciate ligament is a potential future strategy to enhance revascularization of the autograft in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction.     

Meniscal repair compared with meniscectomy for bucket-handle medial meniscal tears in anterior cruciate ligament-reconstructed knees

BACKGROUND: Repair of meniscal tears is generally preferred over meniscectomy. HYPOTHESIS: Repair of unstable bucket-handle tears of the medial meniscus leads to better outcomes than partial meniscectomy. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective review of prospectively collected data. METHODS: We reviewed the records of 155 patients who had isolated bucket-handle medial meniscal tears and anterior cruciate ligament tears. Fifty-six menisci were repaired; 99 that were degenerative and crushed beyond repair were removed. Patients were evaluated at a mean follow-up of 6 to 8 years after surgery with the International Knee Documentation Committee examination and a modified Noyes questionnaire. RESULTS: The mean subjective scores were similar for patients in both the repair (N = 51) and meniscectomy (N = 87) groups. However, in the repair group, the mean subjective score of 93.9 for nondegenerative menisci was significantly better than the 87.1 for degenerative menisci. Objective grades for 25 patients in the repair group were normal or nearly normal in 22 patients (88%) and for 51 of 56 patients (91%) in the removal group. Radiographic subscores for the repair group were normal or nearly normal in 23 patients in the repair group and 49 in the removal group. CONCLUSION: Outcomes from meniscal repair were not superior to those from partial removal. Patients with repaired degenerative tears had significantly lower subjective scores than those with nondegenerative tears.     

Subacute versus delayed reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament in the competitive athlete

The objective of this study was to compare the function and activity level in patients with anterior cruciate ligament injuries, who participated in competitive sports (Tegner activity level ≥ 7) and underwent a reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament, either subacute (2–12 weeks, group I) or late (12–24 months, group II) after the injury. The patients in group I (n = 97) were comparable with those in group II (n = 103) in terms of gender, age, pre-injury activity level, and the reconstruction technique. At the final follow-up (2–5.5 years after the operation), the Lysholm score, the IKDC evaluation system and the one-leg-hop test revealed no differences between the groups. There were also no differences between the groups in terms of the patients’ subjective evaluation or expectations. The Tegner activity level at follow-up was 8 (range 2–10) in group I and 6 (range 2–9) in group II (P = 0.0001). The same thing was found in terms of the desired Tegner activity level, which was 9 (range 4–9) in group I and 7 (range 3–10) in group II (P = 0.0002). The KT-1000 laxity meter revealed a total side-to-side difference of 1.5 mm (–3.5–8.5) in group I and 1.5 mm (–3.5–7) in group II (NS). Associated meniscal surgery between the index injury and the reconstruction, or during the reconstruction, was performed in 37/97 (38%) of the patients in group I and 59/103 (57%) of the patients in group II (P < 0.01). This study revealed that competitive athletes who underwent reconstruction at a subacute stage after the anterior cruciate ligament injury had a higher activity level 2–5.5 years after the index operation, as well as a higher desired level of activity compared to athletes who had the reconstruction delayed by 12–24 months. Furthermore, meniscal injuries were significantly more frequent if the reconstruction was delayed. Received: 10 May 1998 Accepted: 30 November 1998     

Treatment of acute isolated and combined ruptures of the anterior cruciate ligament. A long-term follow-up study.

From a total of 293 patients who had an acute, complete anterior cruciate ligament rupture, we selected all patients (N = 55) who had an anterior cruciate ligament rupture without associated meniscal or ligamentous injuries, and all patients (N = 52) who had an anterior cruciate ligament rupture combined with a rupture, and subsequent primary repair, of the medial collateral ligament. Initially, all patients were assigned to one of two groups: conservative treatment of the anterior cruciate ligament or augmented anterior cruciate ligament repair with the iliotibial band. In the 52 patients who had an anterior cruciate ligament rupture combined with a medial collateral ligament rupture, the associated injuries to the medial collateral ligament and sometimes the posterior oblique ligament, meniscus, and arcuate ligament complex were treated in a similar fashion, without regard to the treatment of the anterior cruciate ligament. Ninety-nine patients (93%) were reexamined 35 to 74 months after the injury, and knee function was evaluated with subjective and objective criteria, including functional tests. Patients who had been treated with augmented anterior cruciate ligament repair had superior stability with better subjective results and returned to strenuous activities more frequently than patients who had undergone conservative treatment. In those patients who had augmented repair, the prognosis did not differ between those who had isolated lesions and those who had combined lesions. Conservative treatment of the anterior cruciate ligament with repair of the medial collateral ligament and other associated injuries, when present, resulted in an almost equally unfavorable outcome for patients with combined and isolated anterior cruciate ligament lesions.