A computer-aided diagnosis system to screen for osteoporosis using dental panoramic radiographs

OBJECTIVES: An eroded inferior cortex of the mandible detected on dental panoramic radiographs is useful for identifying post-menopausal women with low skeletal bone mineral density (BMD) or osteoporosis. The purposes of this study were to develop a computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) system that automatically determines cortical erosion of the mandible on dental panoramic radiographs and to assess the validation of this CAD system. METHODS: A CAD system was developed based on mathematical morphology for identifying post-menopausal women with low skeletal BMD or osteoporosis, based on World Health Organization criteria, by identifying whether the endosteal margin of mandibular cortical bone was eroded. The sensitivity, specificity, predictive value, accuracy and likelihood for a positive risk result were calculated using dichotomous 2 x 2 tables using 100 panoramic radiographs. RESULTS: For identifying women with low skeletal BMD, the sensitivity and specificity were 76.8% and 61.1%, respectively, the positive and negative predictive values were 90.0% and 36.7%, accuracy was 74.0% and the likelihood for positive risk was 1.96. The respective values for identifying women with osteoporosis were 94.4% and 43.8%, the positive and negative predictive values were 48.6% and 93.3%, respectively, the accuracy was 62.0% and the likelihood for positive risk was 1.68. CONCLUSION: Our results suggest that a CAD system applied to dental panoramic radiographs may be useful for identifying post-menopausal women with low skeletal BMD or osteoporosis.     

The clinical utility of prostate-specific antigen and bone scintigraphy in prostate cancer follow-up.

To assess the value of serum prostate-specific antigen (PSA) in prostate cancer follow-up, we prospectively studied 107 consecutive patients with: (1) pathologically confirmed prostate cancer; (2) definitive prostatectomy and/or radiation therapy greater than or equal to 3 mo prior to bone scanning; and (3) one bone scan and serum PSA sampling within 3 mo of each other. The mean and range of patient follow-up since definitive therapy was 1.6 and 0.5-8 yr, respectively. Abnormal bone scans were correlated with pertinent radiographs. Of 107 bone scans, 16 demonstrated metastatic bone disease. A PSA value of less than or equal to 8 ng/ml excluded bone metastases with a predictive value of a negative test of 98.5%. Without radiographic correlation, abnormal bone scans rarely represented metastases if the PSA value was less than or equal to 8 ng/ml. In summary, serum PSA concentration determines the need for follow-up bone scanning and assists in scan interpretation in patients status post definitive therapy for prostate cancer.     

Osteomyelitis of the foot in diabetic patients: evaluation with plain film, 99mTc-MDP bone scintigraphy, and MR imaging

Diagnosis of osteomyelitis of the foot in diabetic patients may be difficult because of the coexistence of chronic cellulitis, vascular insufficiency, and peripheral neuropathy. This study compared the diagnostic accuracies of plain films, bone scans, and MR imaging studies in diabetic patients with suspicion of osteomyelitis of the foot. Twenty-nine plain radiographs, 20 bone scans, and 30 MR studies were obtained in 24 patients. Twenty-nine bones from 14 patients were pathologically proved either positive (25 bones) or negative (four bones) for osteomyelitis. Another 15 bones (10 patients) studied with MR had no pathologic proof, but the bones healed with only local wound care and/or a short course of oral antibiotics. These patients had trauma, cellulitis, or unhealed ulcers. The sensitivity and specificity of plain films were both 75%. Bone scans had a very low specificity (100% false-positive rate). A negative bone scan should strongly exclude the probability of osteomyelitis. Unlike the findings in previous reports, MR had much higher sensitivity and specificity than bone scans in detecting osteomyelitis in diabetic patients. When the 10 patients without pathologic proof (those who presumably had neuroarthropathy, vascular insufficiency, and/or cellulitis) were included, the sensitivity and specificity of all three techniques decreased. Our experience with this small group of patients suggests that MR is a useful imaging technique for diagnosing osteomyelitis of the foot in diabetic patients.     

Evaluation of infectious diabetic foot complications with indium-111-labeled human nonspecific immunoglobulin G.

Osteomyelitis of the foot is a well-known complication of diabetes mellitus. In this study, the validity of 111In-labeled human nonspecific immunoglobulin G (IgG) scintigraphy was studied in 16 diabetic patients with foot ulcers, gangrene or painful Charcot joints. In all patients, plain radiographs, conventional bone scan images and 111In-IgG images were recorded. The results were verified by histologic examination of surgical specimens in patients who did not respond to antibiotic treatment within 2-3 wk (10 lesions) or long-term clinical follow-up of at least 6-mo (16 lesions). On the bone scans, all seven osteomyelitic foci were detected. However, 19 additional foci not due to osteomyelitis were seen. The absence of true-negative bone scans in this study resulted in a specificity of 0%. On the plain radiographs, four of seven osteomyelitis foci were detected; for 111In-IgG scintigraphy, six of seven (sensitivity 57% and 86%, respectively). Plain radiographs correctly ruled out osteomyelitis in 15 of 19 lesions, 111In-IgG scintigraphy in 16 of 19 (specificity 79% and 84%, respectively). All imaging procedures gave false-positive results in penetrating ulcers over the calcaneus in two patients and in one patient with a Charcot joint, most likely due to recent fractures. A false-negative 111In-IgG study was observed in a patient with severe arterial angiopathy. Accurate estimation of probable osteomyelitis was not possible from the results of soft-tissue cultures, since in only 6 of 12 positive cultures, osteomyelitic foci could be proven. Indium-111-IgG scintigraphy can contribute to adequate evaluation of osteomyelitis in diabetic foot complications because it improves specificity when compared to bone scan and radiographic findings and improves sensitivity in comparison to plain radiographs.     

Pulmonary lymphangiomyomatosis: correlation of CT with radiographic and functional findings

In 14 patients with biopsy-proved lymphangiomyomatosis, disease extent at computed tomography (CT) was correlated with findings at chest radiography and pulmonary-function testing. The CT scans and chest radiographs were read independently by two chest radiologists. Disease extent was assessed on CT scans by using a visual score (0%-100% involvement of the lung parenchyma) and on radiographs by using an adaptation of the International Labour Office classification of the pneumoconioses. There was good concordance between the two observers for CT and radiographic scores (Kendall tau greater than or equal to .86, P less than .01). A significant but relatively low correlation was present between CT findings and radiographic severity of disease (r = .59, P less than .05). Impairment in gas exchange as assessed with the diffusing capacity correlated better with disease extent seen on CT scans (r = .69) than with chest radiographic findings (r = .59). Three patients had evidence of parenchymal disease on the CT scans but not on the radiographs. In one patient CT findings were negative despite a positive finding on chest radiographs. The authors conclude that CT is superior to chest radiography in the assessment of patients with lymphangiomyomatosis.     

Initial results in the assessment of multiple myeloma using 18F-FDG PET

This prospective study was undertaken to investigate the appearance of multiple myeloma on fluorine-18 fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography (FDG-PET). Furthermore, the accuracy of FDG-PET in detecting myeloma lesions and its influence on patient management were evaluated. Forty-three patients with known multiple myeloma (n=28) or solitary plasmacytoma (n=15) underwent FDG-PET. The results of routinely performed radiographs and of scans obtained using all available imaging modalities (MRI, CT), as well as the clinical course, were used for verification of detected lesions. Focally increased tracer uptake was observed in 38 of 41 known osteolytic bone lesions (sensitivity 92.7%) in 23 patients. In addition, 71 further bone lesions which were negative on radiographs were detected in 14 patients. Twenty-six (36.6%) of these lesions could be confirmed in ten patients. As a result of FDG-PET imaging, clinical management was influenced in five (14.0%) patients. The positive predictive value for active disease was 100% in patients with focal or mixed focal/diffuse skeletal FDG uptake and 75% in patients with diffuse bone marrow uptake. Depending on the interpretation of the PET scans in patients with diffuse bone marrow uptake, the sensitivity ranged from 83.8% to 91.9% and the specificity from 83.3% to 100%. FDG-PET thus proved highly accurate in detecting multiple myeloma, and revealed a greater extent of disease than routine radiographs in 14 of 23 (60.9%) patients who had osteolytic bone lesions. FDG-PET might contribute to the initial staging of solitary plasmacytoma.     

Lateral cavity wall thickening as an early radiographic sign of mycetoma formation

The sensitivity of chest radiography for the early detection of mycetoma formation within fibrotic cavities is poor. The purpose of this study was to determine the predictive value of the secondary sign of lateral cavity wall thickening for the detection of a radiographically occult mycetoma. The chest radiographs and CT scans of 70 patients who had a total of 109 fibrotic cavities on CT were reviewed by two observers. Dimensions of the cavity, mycetoma, and cavity wall thickness on chest radiography and CT scans were recorded. Mycetomas were visible in 41 of 99 cavities on chest radiographs and in 61 of 109 cavities on CT. Using CT as the gold standard for detecting the presence of mycetomas, the sensitivity of chest radiography for the presence of a mycetoma was 62 % and the specificity 94 %, and the positive and negative predictive values were 93 and 66 %, respectively. On logistic regression analysis, lateral wall thickness on chest radiography was predictive of the presence of a mycetoma (p < 0.0005) independent of other radiographic features. In patients with chronic fibrocavitary disease on chest radiography, the presence of lateral wall thickening is highly suggestive of an underlying mycetoma. Received: 28 May 1999; Revised: 2 August 1999; Accepted: 5 August 1999     

Acute osteomyelitis: advantage of white cell scans in early detection

Acute osteomyelitis was induced in 18 rabbits after direct injection of a solution of Staphylococcus aureus culture into a proximal tibial metaphysis. Serial plain radiographs and radionuclide studies with indium-111 oxide labeled while blood cells and technetium-99m methylene diphosphonate were performed over the next 4 weeks. Visual and quantitative analysis by measuring the isotope activity of 111In and 99mTc over the infected tibias as compared with the opposite bones revealed that the white blood cell scans were positive in 15 (83%) of the 18 rabbits during the first week after injection of the microorganism. During the same period, the 99mTc bone scans were positive in only 22% of the animals (p less than 0.005). In the animals that survived, both white blood cell and bone scans were positive during the second week, and thereafter, the bone scans revealed consistently higher activity than was observed with white blood cell scans. Computed tomography performed in six rabbits revealed an increased attenuation coefficient of the medullary cavities in the infected bones of four animals during the first week and of one more during the second week. Plain radiographs became positive after the 12th day. Results indicate that in patients with suspected acute osteomyelitis, white blood cell scans and probably computed tomography can detect the disease earlier than 99mTc bone scans and plain radiographs.     

Hyperdense middle cerebral artery sign on CT: efficacy in detecting middle cerebral artery thrombosis

The hyperdense middle cerebral artery sign is a CT predictor of the development of a large cerebral infarct. The limits of detectability were tested in a blinded, then unblinded analysis of CT scans from 25 acute stroke patients. In the initial blinded analysis, sign detection exhibited the following mean values: sensitivity, 78.5%; specificity, 93.4%; positive predictive value, 66%; negative predictive value, 96.4%; accuracy, 91.3%. Kappa statistics analysis indicated poor interobserver agreement (k = .38). Results of unblinded analysis were as follows: sensitivity, 69%; specificity, 94.4%; positive predictive value, 82.8%; negative predictive value, 88.7%; accuracy, 87.3%. There was fair unblinded interobserver agreement (k = .53). Unblinded analysis had a lower false-positive frequency and did not increase the number of true-positive determinations. We conclude that detection of the hyperdense middle cerebral artery sign on CT scans by multiple observers is a sensitive, accurate, and predictive indicator of middle cerebral artery thromboembolism.     

FDG-PET as a "metabolic biopsy" tool in thoracic lesions with indeterminate biopsy

A common problem encountered in clinical medicine is the classification of a lung lesion (nodule/opacity) on conventional imaging. Often attempts at biopsy are unsuccessful or are falsely reassuring, and the decision to send the patient for more invasive and potentially morbid procedures can be difficult. Our aim was to investigate the role of fluorine-18 fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography (FDG-PET) in helping to identify more accurately those patients with malignant lesions. Sixty-three patients underwent FDG-PET scans following unsuccessful biopsy of a lung lesion or, in a lesser number of cases, when an attempt at biopsy was considered too dangerous. Follow-up was by histology or, if this was unavailable, by clinical progress to death or a minimum of 18 months post scan. Visual and quantitative analysis was performed. On visual analysis, positive and negative predictive values were 90% and 100%, respectively. On quantitative (SUV>2.5) analysis, positive and negative predictive values were 90% and 85%, respectively. We interpret these results as showing that the use of FDG-PET scans in patients in this circumstance is non-invasive and highly sensitive in diagnosing malignancy. The high positive predictive value suggests that those with a positive scan must undergo further investigation, while the 100% negative predictive value means those with no FDG uptake can safely be spared further invasive investigations     

Painful infection at the site of hip prosthesis: CT imaging

PURPOSE: To prospectively determine the accuracy of computed tomography (CT) in the detection of painful infection at the site of hip prosthesis before surgery. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Helical CT examinations of hip prostheses were prospectively performed before surgery after a standard clinical and radiologic examination of 65 patients. CT scans and conventional radiographs were reviewed for periprosthetic bone abnormalities, and CT scans were reviewed for periprosthetic soft-tissue abnormalities (joint distention, fluid-filled bursae, and fluid collection in muscles and perimuscular fat). Patients subsequently underwent revision arthroplasty within 1 month, and infection was diagnosed in 12 (19%) patients. RESULTS: Infection was detected clinically in 25% of patients. Periprosthetic bone abnormalities did not allow differentiation of infection from complications not related to sepsis, except for periostitis, with 100% specificity but only 16% sensitivity. Soft-tissue findings were accurate for detection of infection, with 100% sensitivity and 87% specificity. Fluid collection in muscles and perimuscular fat had a 100% positive predictive value, and absence of joint distention had a 96% negative predictive value. CONCLUSION: CT is accurate in the diagnosis of painful infection at the site of a hip prosthesis on the basis of soft-tissue findings, whereas periprosthetic bone abnormalities are not useful.     

多层螺旋CT评价脊柱融合模型成骨过程的研究

目的 分析自体骨成骨与硫酸钙成骨的CT表现,结合同期病理学结果,探讨影像改变的病理机制.材料与方法 20只健康家兔建立腰椎融合模型,一侧植入医用硫酸钙,对侧植入自体髂骨.于术后3、6、12周行手术部位多层螺旋CT (MSCT)检查,观察植入物与自体骨融合状况.于术后12周,根据CT表现计算植骨融合率及MSCT评估腰椎融合的敏感度、特异度、阳性预测值(PPV)及阴性预测值(NPV).术后3、6周各随机处死1只家兔,获得同期病理对照,术后12周处死剩余18只家兔,获得最终时间点病理对照.结果 MSCT评估硫酸钙植骨一侧腰椎融合的敏感度、特异度均为100.0％,自体髂骨植骨侧分别为94.1％和100.0％.术后12周,硫酸钙植骨一侧融合率为88.9％ (n=16),PPV为94.1％,NPV为100.0％;自体髂骨植骨一侧融合率为94.4％ (n=17),PPV为100.0％,NPV为50.0％,两侧融合率差异无统计学意义(P＞0.05).结论 MSCT能够有效评价脊柱融合术后骨移植材料的成骨表现.     

Diagnosis of orthopedic infection in clinical practice using Tc-99m sulesomab (antigranulocyte monoclonal antibody fragment Fab'2)

OBJECTIVE: The aim of the study was to analyze the use of Tc-99m-labeled antigranulocyte monoclonal antibody fragment Fab'2 (SMab, Leukoscan) in the diagnosis of acute osteomyelitis and articular prosthesis infection. One hundred seventeen patients (118 studies) have been included, 92 women and 25 men. Thirty-seven had a suspicion of osteomyelitis and 81 with suspicion of infection of a hip (35 patients) or a knee (45 patients) prosthesis. The mean age was 64 years. A 3-phase bone scan and a SMab scan were obtained in all patients. Antigranulocyte scans were obtained within 3 and 8 hours postinjection of 20 mCi (740 MBq) of Tc-99m-labeled antibody. Diagnosis of infection was based on bone biopsy in 8 cases and on at least 2 positive cultures in the remaining cases. Infection was ruled out with negative cultures or 1-year patient follow up with negative C-reactive protein and normal erythrocyte sedimentation rate. RESULTS: Sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, and negative predictive value of Tc 99m-SMab scintigraphy were: 75%, 95%, 87%, and 92% for long bone osteomyelitis and 80%, 89%, 87%, and 91% for articular prosthesis infection, respectively. Positive predictive values were 83% and 63%, respectively. CONCLUSION: Tc-99m-antigranulocyte monoclonal antibody fragment Fab'2 scintigraphy seems to be a useful method in the diagnosis of osteoarticular infection.     

Acute knee trauma: role of ultrasound

The purpose of this study was to determine the diagnostic accuracy of high spatial resolution ultrasonography (US) in the detection of lipohemarthrosis of the knee and to evaluate this sign as criteria of intra-articular fracture. Forty-eight patients with clinical suspicion of knee fracture were prospectively examined by conventional radiography, sonography examination and computed tomography (CT) within 48 h after trauma in order to depict direct (fracture line) and indirect (lipohemarthrosis) signs of intra-articular fracture. Lipohemarthrosis was defined as a multi-layered collection in the subquadricipital recess. CT was considered as the gold standard for both direct and indirect fracture criteria. CT imaging showed direct signs of intra-articular fracture in 31 patients (65%). Among these patients, 30 (97%) had a lipohemarthrosis. Conventional radiographs showed intra-articular fracture in 26 patients (54%). Among these, 18 (69%) had a lipohemarthrosis. Sonographic examinations could not depict any direct sign of intra-articular fracture but showed a lipohemarthrosis in 29 (93%) of patients with proven fracture via CT. This allowed the depiction of four out of five occult knee fractures. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value of sonography for the diagnosis of lipohemarthrosis was 97, 100, 100 and 94%, respectively, compared with 55, 100, 100 and 55% with conventional radiographs. Using lipohemarthrosis as criterion of fracture, the sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value and negative predictive value of sonography for early detection of intra-articular knee fractures was 94, 94, 97 and 89%, respectively, compared with 84, 88, 93 and 75% with conventional radiographs. We concluded that, by showing lipohemarthrosis in the subquadricipital recess, high-resolution sonography is a reliable and accurate technique for the evaluation of intra-articular knee fractures.     

Diagnosis of osteomyelitis of the foot in diabetic patients: value of 111In-leukocyte scintigraphy

The noninvasive diagnosis of osteomyelitis of the foot in diabetic patients with currently available radiologic and radionuclide imaging techniques is often difficult. Recently, 111In-labeled leukocyte scintigraphy has been proposed as an attractive alternative. Accordingly, we retrospectively reviewed 51 111In-labeled leukocyte scans, 49 technetium-99m bone scans, and 49 plain radiographs obtained in 51 adults with diabetes in whom osteomyelitis of the foot was suspected. The sensitivity and specificity of these techniques were evaluated in all patients, as well as in a subgroup of 11 patients with neuroarthropathy. Results with 111In-labeled leukocyte scans were also examined in subsets of patients with soft-tissue ulcers (n = 35) and those receiving antibiotics during investigation (n = 20). Confirmation or exclusion of osteomyelitis was made surgically in 28 patients and clinically in 23. Fourteen patients had osteomyelitis. Bone scans were most sensitive (93%) but least specific (43%); plain radiographs were most specific (83%) but least sensitive (43%). 111In-labeled leukocyte scans were both sensitive (79%) and specific (78%), and remained useful in patients with neuroarthropathy, soft-tissue ulcers, and antibiotic treatment. Poor spatial resolution contributed to the false-negative and false-positive 111In-labeled leukocyte scans, suggesting that this technique should not be interpreted independent of other tests. 111In-labeled leukocyte scans are a valuable diagnostic tool for the diagnosis of pedal osteomyelitis in diabetic patients.     

18F-FDG SPECT/CT诊断肺癌骨转移的价值:与全身骨显像比较

目的：探讨^18F—FDG SPECT／CT肿瘤代谢显像在诊断肺癌骨转移方面的应用价值。材料和方法：对32例肺癌患者分别进行^18F—FDGSPECT／CT显像和^99Tc^m-MDP全身骨显像，间隔时间不超过2周。其他影像学和临床随访结果为确诊依据，比较两种方法诊断骨转移的敏感性、特异性、阳性预测值、阴性预测值和准确性。结果：11个病人共48个病灶最终诊断为骨转移。^18F—FDG SPECT／CT诊断11个病人有骨转移^99T^m-MDP全身骨显像诊断10个病人。按病灶分析，FDG和MDP的敏感性、特异性、阳性预测值、阴性预测值、准确性分别为94％、71％、89％、92％、77％和83％、64％、79％、89％、53％。”F—FDGSPECT／CT的敏感性和准确性优于^99Tc^m-MDP全身骨显像（P〈0.05）。结论：^18F—FDG SPECT／CT显像在诊断肺癌骨转移方面的敏感性和准确性高于^99Tc^m—MDP全身骨显像。     

Tc-99m ciprofloxacin scans for detection of tubercular bone infection

Tc-99m MDP and Tc-99m ciprofloxacin scans were performed in 14 patients with suspected tubercular bone disease and in 2 cases of nontubercular bone infection. In 5 patients the findings were true negative. There were no false positives and 1 was false negative. The sensitivity, specificity, and positive predictive value were found to be 93, 71, and 87.5%, respectively, for detection of bone tubercular lesions. However, the test does not distinguish TB osteomyelitis from other types of osteomyelitis. Delayed 24 hour scans were found useful to differentiate between inflammatory and infective lesions. The aim of this study was to evaluate the usefulness of the Tc-99m ciprofloxacin scan as a means to detect tubercular bone disease.     

Comparative value of bone scintigraphy and radiography in monitoring tumor response in systemically treated prostatic carcinoma

Radionuclide bone scans and skeletal radiographs were obtained before and during combination chemotherapy or initial hormonal treatment in 46 patients with disseminated adenocarcinoma of the prostate. The purpose of the study was to determine the usefulness of these two modalities in evaluating tumor response to therapy. Prior to treatment, bone scans were positive in 44 patients (96%). In all but one patient either bone radiographs or bone marrow biopsy revealed evidence of osseous metastases. In 22 patients partial response to therapy was documented by a variety of other staging tests. Eleven of these patients showed concurrent or later improvement on bone scans; one showed improvement on a radiograph. "Flare phenomena" were observed relatively frequently since 23% of the scans and 50% of the radiographs showed worsening at the time of response. Bone scans revealed worsening in 79% of 33 patients with disease progression of extraosseous tumor; radiographs were equally sensitive (82% worsening). It is concluded that bone scans in particular are useful for monitoring tumor status in systemically treated patients with prostate cancer. However, because of the lack of sensitivity for response and paradoxical worsening with tumor regression in some patients, scans are not accurate enough to be employed as the sole test in following these patients.     

Diagnostic performance of general dental practitioners after lecture in identifying post-menopausal women with low bone mineral density by panoramic radiographs

OBJECTIVES: Mandibular cortical erosion detected on panoramic radiographs may be useful for identifying post-menopausal women with low skeletal bone mineral density (BMD). The purposes of this study were to calculate the diagnostic performance of general dental practitioners (GDPs) who attended a lecture on identifying post-menopausal women with low BMD from findings on panoramic radiographs and to evaluate the influence of GDPs' age on diagnostic performance. METHODS: After a 1 h lecture, 111 GDPs were asked to classify the mandibular cortex (normal or eroded) on panoramic radiographs obtained from 100 post-menopausal women who have had skeletal BMD assessment. Low BMD was defined as a BMD T score of -1.0 or less. Diagnostic performance was analysed by comparing two groups classified by mandibular cortex (women with normal cortex and women with any eroded cortex) with those classified by BMD (women with normal BMD and women with low BMD). RESULTS: The mean sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value, accuracy and likelihood ratio for a positive risk result were 73.0% (95% confidence interval [CI]; 71.3 to 74.7%), 49.0% (95% CI; 46.4 to 51.5%), 66.9% (95% CI; 66.0 to 67.8%), 57.0% (95% CI; 55.8 to 58.2%), 62.9% (95% CI; 62.1 to 63.7%) and 1.51 (95% CI; 1.44 to 1.58), respectively. GDPs' age did not influence diagnostic performance. CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest that 73.0% of women who had low skeletal BMD can be identified by GDPs after a lecture on the use of panoramic radiographs as an aid in diagnosing low BMD; however, the diagnostic performance may not be influenced by GDPs' age.     

Can exercise renography be an alternative to ACE inhibitor renography in hypertensive patients who are suspicious for renal artery stenosis?

The aim of this study was to evaluate the value of Tc-99m ethylenedicysteine exercise renography in patients with hypertension who were suspicious for renal artery stenosis and compare the results with captopril renography. METHODS: Twenty-nine patients with hypertension who were highly suspect for having renal artery stenosis were included in the study. Basal captopril exercise renograms were performed within 1 week in all patients with Tc-99m EC. Exercise was performed with a bicycle ergometer as described in the literature. Interpretations of renograms were made according to the consensus report on angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitor renography as high, low, or intermediate probability. The sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values were also obtained on both the kidneys and a patient basis. The results were compared with renal angiography in 19 patients. RESULTS: Twenty of 29 patients had concordant results with both captopril and exercise studies. All discordant tests were normal with captopril but positive with exercise renograms. Nineteen patients with 38 kidneys were included for statistical data analysis. Nine kidneys, which were either atrophic or abnormal during the basal study, were excluded from the kidney-based analysis. With contrast angiography, 8 patients had renal artery stenosis. When evaluated on a kidney basis, the sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values for captopril scans were 87%, 100%, 100%, and 95%, and for the exercise scans were 100%, 90%, 80%, and 100% respectively. When calculated on a patient basis with regard to the captopril scans, the sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values were 87%, 81%, 77%, and 88%, and for exercise scans were 100%, 54%, 61%, and 100% respectively. There were 2 false-positive exercise scans that were found to be the result of dilated minor collecting systems and changes in kidney contours as a result of motion during exercise. CONCLUSIONS: These results indicate that exercise renography has a similar sensitivity but lower specificity compared with captopril scintigraphy in the diagnosis of renal artery stenosis. Because of the lower specificity, its use in the screening of renovascular hypertension may be limited. Exercise renography may be more useful as an investigative tool for essential hypertension.