Long-term course and outcome of severe postpartum psychiatric disorders.

Thirty-nine women who had suffered from a severe first-episode postpartum psychiatric illness were re-examined after a period of 6-26 years (averaging 12.5 years). Diagnoses were established according to ICD-10 and Leonhard's classification, revealing a marked predominance of cycloid psychoses (54%) according to Leonhard. There was no evidence of the nosological independence of postpartum psychosis. Only 4 patients (10%) had never recovered fully since the onset of the illness. In contrast, 6 patients had undergone a monophasic course without any further psychopathology. In 20 cases (51%) the illness had run a multiphasic course. The average number of episodes per patient was 2.5 (range 2-6). The course was not determinable in 4 patients (10%). Nineteen women (49%) had 22 further deliveries after the first manifestation of the illness. The frequency of a relapse in connection with further pregnancy or delivery was 50%. Applying the Strauss-Carpenter Outcome Scale, we found a favourable outcome for the total sample with a mean value of 14.1 (SD = 2.6). The vast majority of patients (75%) showed no persistent alterations. Our findings provide further evidence of a favourable prognosis of severe postpartum psychiatric disorder despite the remarkably high rate of puerperal relapses.     

The effect of the menstruation cycle on manifestations of pychiatric diseases

In the present study we investigated whether a correlation exists between menstrual cycle phase on the day of an acute psychiatric admission and diagnostic entities. Therefore we assessed the menstrual cycle phase in 155 women at the time of acute admission for any non-organic psychiatric disorder. A specific diagnosis according to ICD-10-criteria and to Leonhard's nosology was established without knowledge of the menstrual cycle phase. Independent of diagnosis and classification, the majority of patients (57%) was admitted during the pre-menstrual/menstrual period. Comparing the frequencies of admission before (increasing blood-estrogen-level) and after ovulation (decreasing blood-estrogen-level) we found using ICD-10 criteria there were no significant differences between affective psychoses (F3), acute polymorphous psychotic disorder (F23), schizophrenia/schizoaffective psychoses (F20 and F25) and patients suffering from neuroses or personality disorders (F4-F6). Applying Leonhard's criteria we found no significant differences between endogeneous psychoses and personality disorders and no significant differences between cycloid psychoses and affective psychoses or affective psychoses and schizophrenias as well. However, patients with cycloid psychoses were significantly more frequently admitted to hospital during the luteal-/menstrual phase than patients with schizophrenia (chi 2-Test, p = 0.02). These findings do not confirm a specificity of a pre-menstrual exacerbation of psychotic symptoms for schizophrenia. Rather we found cycloid psychoses to be significantly more frequently associated with premenstrual exacerbation of symptoms.     

Successful ECT in a case of Leonhard's cycloid psychosis

In Leonhard's nosological system, acute, episodic psychoses with good short-term and long-term prognoses, characterized by mixed affective and schizophrenic features, confusion, and alternating psychomotor retardation and excitement are called cycloid psychoses. According to clinical lore, patients with cycloid psychoses show an excellent and prompt response to electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). We describe a patient with typical motility psychosis, a subtype of cycloid psychoses, who failed to respond to a combination of antipsychotic and benzodiazepine medication but quickly recovered after the administration of ECT.     

Successful use of ECT as the sole modality of treatment in a case of motility psychosis

Episodic psychoses characterized by predominant abnormalities of movement are called motility psychoses in Leonhard's classification of endogenous psychoses. They have been treated with a variety of methods, including ECT and lithium. Here we describe a case of motility psychosis that was successfully managed with ECT as the only modality of treatment.     

Concordance of acute and transient psychoses and cycloid psychoses

OBJECTIVE: We prospectively investigated a sample of 42 patients with acute and transient psychotic disorder (ATPD) as defined by the 10th revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-10; F23) to determine the clinical and demographic features of this entity and its relationship to cycloid psychoses. METHODS: During a 5-year period, all in-patients with ATPD were identified. We systematically evaluated demographic and clinical features and carried out follow-up investigations on average 2 years after the index episode, using standardised instruments. RESULTS: We found 42 cases of ATPD (4.1%) among 1,036 patients treated for psychotic disorders or a major affective episode. There was a marked female preponderance in ATPD (79%). Fifty-five percent of cases concurrently met the criteria of cycloid psychosis according to Perris and Brockington [in Perris C, Struwe G, Jansson B (eds): Biological Psychiatry. Amsterdam, Elsevier, 1981, pp 447-450]. There was no difference in gender distribution between cycloid and non-cycloid ATPD. As expected, abrupt onset and polymorphic features were significantly more common in cycloid than in non- cycloid ATPD. At follow-up, patients with cycloid ATPD showed less persistent alterations and better social functioning. CONCLUSION: ATPD as defined by ICD-10 is a heterogeneous category. A diagnosis of cycloid psychosis is made in half of the cases of ATPD, and in these cases, the prognosis is more favourable.     

Prognostic validity of the cycloid psychoses. A prospective follow-up study

In a prospective 4-year follow-up study, 26 out of 31 patients initially diagnosed as cycloid psychoses were investigated (anxiety-happiness psychosis n = 15; confusion psychosis n = 8; motility psychosis n = 3). Patients were independently interviewed by two clinical researchers. 61.5% showed one or several 'first-rank symptoms' according to Schneider. In addition, the SADS-LA was applied for RDC and DSM-IIIR diagnoses. According to these classification systems most of the patients were diagnosed as schizophrenic or schizoaffective. Personal interview as well as application of the Strauss-Carpenter Outcome Scale indicated a highly favorable clinical outcome, i.e. lack of affective or behavioral defective states in literally all patients of the study. These results justify the distinction of the cycloid psychoses as a nosological entity in general and--less convincingly--of the three subtypes of cycloid psychoses.     

The genetic heterogeneity of "schizophrenia".

The main reason for the inconsistent findings in schizophrenia research is the lack of diagnostic conformity. This has not changed markedly following the introduction of modern operational diagnostic systems. Taking schizophrenia as a disease entity or assuming schizophrenia spectrum psychoses to represent a continuum of diseases without any clear dividing lines, the results of family and twin studies point to a multifactorial etiology based on a polygenic mode of transmission. Further, then it has to be assumed a familial continuum from schizophrenia to affective psychosis and other spectrum disorders. However, in family and twin studies based on Leonhard's classification, there is clearcut evidence that schizophrenic spectrum psychoses have to be divided into clinical and etiological subgroups with a completely different genetic background. For example, systematic catatonia is, for the most part, a sporadic disease, whereas periodic catatonia aggregates in families in a manner consistent with a major gene effect. Further, the results indicate that schizophrenic spectrum psychoses consist of three main valid categories: cycloid psychoses, unsystematic schizophrenias and systematic schizophrenias. In the case of cycloid psychosis and systematic schizophrenias, genetic loading seem to be very low, while "environmental" factors, for example, birth complications, may play an important etiological role. Unsystematic schizophrenias, however, are predominantly inherited and "environmental" factors are not very prominent.     

Classification of nonschizophrenic psychotic disorders: a historical perspective

The existence of a group of psychoses that are symptomatologically and prognostically different from schizophrenia and affective psychotic disorders is supported by clinical and epidemiologic evidence. Although such "atypical" psychoses account for up to 10% of all psychotic disorders, their aetiology, pathophysiology, and neuropathology remain insufficiently understood. Moreover, they have been described by different schools of psychiatry a variety of ways, including non-process schizophrenia, schizophreniform psychosis, reactive (or psychogenic) psychosis, bouffées délirantes, and cycloid psychoses, but the extent to which these diagnostic categories overlap or differ has not been systematically explored. Neither Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV), nor International Classification of Disease, Tenth Revision (ICD-10), provides adequate diagnostic criteria and classificatory categories for this group of disorders. Special attention to the refinement of the diagnosis and classification of the acute and transient psychotic disorders in future versions of the two classifications will be warranted.     

Incidence and diagnostic stability of ICD-10 acute and transient psychotic disorders

OBJECTIVE: The 10th Revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-10) introduced a new diagnostic category, F23 acute and transient psychotic disorders (ATPD) to embrace clinical concepts such as the French bouffée délirante, Kleist and Leonhard's cycloid psychoses, and the Scandinavian reactive and schizophreniform psychoses. The relative rarity of these disorders and insufficient follow-up studies with adequate numbers of patients makes ATPD classification as uncertain as their validity. The aim of this study was to evaluate incidence and validity of ATPD in terms of diagnostic stability. METHOD: A 6-year analysis of readmission patterns of all subjects listed in the Danish psychiatric central register as having been first-ever admitted to hospital or treated in outpatient services with a diagnosis of ATPD from January 1 to December 31, 1996, was conducted. RESULTS: The incidence of ATPD was 9.6 per 100 000 population, with a higher rate of females than males (9.8 vs 9.4). Incidence rates by age group were higher for males than for females, with a marked reversal of this pattern above 50 years. This contrasted with incidence of schizophrenia that was almost twice as high in males as in females, particularly in the 20-29 year age group. Of 416 cases with a first-admission diagnosis of ATPD, an increasing number tended to change on subsequent admissions, nearly half to another F2 category schizophrenia and related disorders. The overall stability rate reached only 39%. CONCLUSIONS: Although demographic differences from schizophrenia are topics that deserve further research, poor diagnostic stability argues against attempts to separate ATPD from borderland disorders.     

The relationship of reactive psychosis and ICD-10 acute and transient psychotic disorders: evidence from a case register-based comparison

BACKGROUND: ICD-10 introduced a new diagnostic category, F23 'acute and transient psychotic disorders' (ATPD), to embrace clinical concepts such as bouffée délirante, cycloid psychosis, psychogenic (reactive) psychosis and schizophreniform psychosis. The purpose of this study was to examine the relationship between the concept of reactive psychosis (RP), equivalent to the ICD-8 298 category of 'other psychoses', and ATPD. SAMPLING AND METHOD: Since January 1, 1994, ICD-10 has replaced ICD-8 as official classification in Denmark. Patients given an ICD-8 298 diagnosis on their last admission in 1992-1993 were identified from the Danish Psychiatric Central Register, and the ICD-8 diagnoses assigned were compared with their ICD-10 diagnoses when readmitted in 1994-1995. RESULTS: Diagnosis of RP was recorded in 19.2% of patients with functional psychoses in 1992-1993, whereas ATPD overall prevalence accounted for 8.7% of those with non-organic psychotic and affective disorders in 1994-1995. Thirty-eight per cent of patients with an ICD-8 298 diagnosis were readmitted during the years 1994-1995. Schizophrenia and related disorders (F2) and affective disorders (F3) accounted for three quarters of ICD-10 diagnoses. The most frequently used ATPD subcategories were F23.3 'other acute delusional psychotic disorders', F23.0 'acute polymorphic psychotic disorder without symptoms of schizophrenia' and F23.9 'acute and transient psychotic disorder unspecified'. A significant majority were female and associated acute stress was recorded only in 5.3% of cases. CONCLUSIONS: ICD-8 298 register diagnosis of RP showed little empirical continuity to ATPD and conformed more to F23.3 acute delusional disorder among ATPD subtypes.     

Differences in quality of life and course of illness between cycloid and schizophrenic psychoses - a comparative study.

OBJECTIVE: Cycloid psychoses represent a nosological entity not adequately recognised by contemporary psychiatry. They present with full recoveries after each psychotic episode and, thus, have a favourable prognosis. METHOD: To verify this clinical observation course, outcome and quality of life (QoL, measured by the German version of the Lancashire Quality of Life Profile) of 33 patients with cycloid psychosis and 44 schizophrenics were compared after a mean time of 13 years since first hospitalisation. For comparison of objective and subjective QoL measures, 48 healthy controls were included. RESULTS: Concerning the course of their disease, schizophrenics were hospitalised significantly longer and received higher neuroleptic doses than patients with cycloid psychosis. The latter displayed significantly better scores in the CGI, GAF, Strauss-Carpenter-Outcome and PANSS scales. In global QoL measures, cycloid psychotic patients were more satisfied with their QoL than schizophrenic patients, and did not differ significantly from healthy controls. CONCLUSION: Cycloid psychoses seem to exhibit a better prognosis than schizophrenia regarding course, outcome, objective, and subjective aspects of QoL. Thus, they appear to present a useful concept deserving more clinical and scientific attention.     

A prospective study of postpartum psychoses in a high-risk group. 3. Relationship to mental health characteristics during pregnancy

Within a sample of 88 pregnant women with a history of nonorganic psychosis, mental health characteristics during pregnancy, assessed prospectively through interviews and psychiatric records, were studied in relationship to the development of 25 postpartum psychotic episodes (PPPs) occurring during the first 6 months postpartum. Cases with PPP onset within 3 weeks of delivery (mostly affective or cycloid psychoses) evidenced more frequent tension-anxiety and excitement at interviews during pregnancy than did diagnostically comparable cases not developing PPPs. Cases with PPP onset later than 3 weeks postpartum (mostly schizophrenic-like psychoses) were not more frequently disturbed than were diagnostically comparable cases not developing PPPs. An absence of both affective symptoms and common fears represented a sign of increased PPP-risk in these later onset cases. The subsample of actively disturbed cases who were in contact with a psychiatrist during pregnancy were at notably increased risk for a PPP during the total 6-month period.     

Follow-up and family study of postpartum psychoses Part I: Overview

A group of 119 patients suffering from a severe psychiatric postpartum disorder who were admitted for the first time in their life to a psychiatric hospital has been investigated. The onset of illness occurred within 3 months following delivery. The patients represented 92% of the total sample fulfilling the inclusion criteria. A follow-up investigation was performed after a mean of 21 years (range 2–35 years). Of the patients 66% had nonpuerperal psychotic episodes in later life. The diagnosis, taking into account the long-term course, was affective psychosis in 57%, schizoaffective psychosis in 18%, schizophreniform psychosis in 12%, brief reactive psychosis in 4% and schizophrenia in 9%. A bipolar psychosis was found in 31%. The relation of unipolar to bipolar psychoses corresponded to that in a control group of affectively ill women without puerperal onset. The frequency of a manic syndrome in bipolar psychoses at the index episode was the same as in nonpuerperal episodes, which does not suggest a mania-provoking pathoplastic effect of the puerperium. The comparison with female nonpuerperal controls matched for age and diagnosis revealed evidence of a better long-term course in the index patients. The risk of a puerperal relapse for further pregnancies was 35%. The global morbidity risk for functional psychoses in first-degree relatives was 11%, with affective psychoses representing the majority of secondary cases (6.8%). The index patients showed a nonsignificant lower-morbidity risk in relatives than a control group of psychotically ill women without puerperal onset. The major aetiological factor found for postpartum psychoses is the relation of these disorders to functional psychoses. There is strong evidence that the postpartum period tends to provoke affective psychoses and other nonschizophrenic psychoses, but not, or only to a lesser degree, narrowly defined schizophrenias. The liability to puerperal decompensations suggests some common pathophysiological mechanism, the nature of which remains unknown.     

Acute and transient psychotic disorders

Psychotic disorders with acute onset, a dramatic and polymorphous symptomatology and rapid resolution have been described in different countries and by different psychiatric schools. They have been called cycloid psychosis, bouffée délirante, psychogenic psychosis or good prognosis schizophrenia. ICD-10 has given an operational definition under the name "acute and transient psychotic disorders" (F23). Their nosological status is unclear. The Halle-Study of acute and transient psychotic disorders (ATPD) has investigated in a prospective manner clinical, para-clinical features and course of illness in 42 patients with ATPD and matched controls with positive schizophrenia, bipolar schizoaffective disorders as well as mentally healthy patients with acute surgical conditions. First results of our study show that ATPD amount to 4% of psychotic in-patients, prefer female sex, show short prodromi, marked affective disturbances within the episode and much better outcome as schizophrenic psychoses according to psychopathological, social, psychological and biographical criteria. Though ATPD may still be an inhomogeneous group, their clinical delineation from schizophrenia seems justified.     

Cycloid psychoses revisited: case reports, literature review, and commentary

Emil Kraepelin proposed to separate psychiatric disorders with psychotic features into two major categories, dementia praecox (later schizophrenia) and manic-depressive insanity (later bipolar disorder and major depression). Over the past century, there have been many efforts to categorize conditions that do not fit readily in either group. These conditions include many cases of acute psychotic illnesses of limited duration, with recovery between recurrences. For some of these conditions, Karl Kleist proposed the term cycloid psychosis: acute features were psychotic, as in schizophrenia, but the course was episodic, as in manic-depression. His concept was later elaborated by Karl Leonhard and Carlo Perris, and validated by modern studies. Leonhard described three overlapping cycloid subtypes (anxiety-beatific, excited-inhibited confusional, and hyperkinetic-akinetic motility dysfunction forms); Perris proposed a more unitary syndrome with operational diagnostic criteria; and recent investigators have considered relatively affective versus thought-disordered subtypes. The cycloid concept is not explicitly included in standard international diagnostic schemes, but both DSM-IV and ICD-10 have broad categories for acute, recurrent psychotic disorders, whose validity remains insecure. We present two cases of probable cycloid psychosis, review the history of the concept, and propose that it be reconsidered as a clinically useful category whose validity and utility for prognosis and treatment can be further tested.     

On the nosology of severe psychiatric post-partum disorders

Summary A group of 57 women, who had been hospitalised for puerperal psychiatric disorders from 1958 to 1977, were reexamined in 1982. The aim of the study was to determine the proportion of patients who had suffered from nonpuerperal psychotic relapses or other subsequent psychopathology, to define the sample diagnostically, taking into account progress in classification, to characterize the so far relatively neglected later course of illness, and to establish criteria related to relapse and global clinical outcome.Of these patients 65% had at least one nonpuerperal relapse, only 25% remained free of later psychopathology, but the global outcome was favorable or relatively favorable in many cases. Of the patients who had had nonpuerperal relapses 43% were classified as suffering from affective psychosis, as many as 38% from schizoaffective psychosis, and only 19% from schizophrenia. Schizoaffective psychosis seems to be particularly liable to be provoked by childbirth. No major evidence was found that endogenous psychoses with puerperal onset and nonpuerperal relapses have a course of illness different from that of the corresponding diagnostic category in general. Cases with exclusively puerperal decompensations seem to be nosologically independent from the traditionally recognized endogenous psychoses. Characteristics strongly related to nonpuerperal relapses were a family history of psychosis and the occurrence of psychotic episodes before the index episode. Puerperal relapses occurred at a much higher rate in patients who also had nonpuerperal relapses than in patients without.