Inferior results after revision ACL reconstructions: a comparison with primary ACL reconstructions

Purpose

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) ruptures are common, especially among young athletes, and such injuries may have considerable impact on both sport careers and everyday life. ACL reconstructions are successful for most patients, but some suffer from persistent giving-way symptoms and/or re-ruptures requiring revision surgery. The aim of this study was to evaluate the results after revision ACL reconstructions and compare them with the results in a control group consisting of primary ACL reconstructions.

Methods

This retrospective study included 56 patients undergoing revision ACL reconstruction and 52 patients receiving primary ACL reconstructions. The follow-up evaluation included clinical examination, instrumented laxity testing, testing of muscle strength, Tegner activity score, Lysholm score, Knee injury and osteoarthritis outcome score (KOOS) and radiological grading of osteoarthritis.

Results

The median time from the last ACL reconstruction to follow-up was 90 months in the revision ACL reconstruction group and 96 months in the primary ACL reconstruction group. The revision group had significantly inferior KOOS and Lysholm scores compared with the primary group. Patients in the revision group also showed greater laxity measured with the pivot shift test, a larger reduction in the Tegner activity score, reduced muscle strength in the injured knee, and more severe radiological osteoarthritis; however, no difference in anterior-posterior translation was found.

Conclusion

Inferior results were found on several of the testing parameters in the revision group compared with the primary group. Patients should receive this information prior to revision ACL reconstructions.

Level of evidence

III.     

A medium to long-term follow-up of ACL reconstruction using double gracilis and semitendinosus grafts

This paper reports the results of our approach to ACL tears and knee laxity, based on 30 years of experience in ACL reconstruction with hamstrings and founded on the following cornerstones: the use of doubled semitendinosus and gracilis as a free graft; the use of an out-in technique for femoral drilling and of very strong and stiff fixation devices; the careful examination and repair or reconstruction of the lateral compartment in selected patients; and the use of unaggressive rehabilitation. We prospectively evaluated a series of 100 consecutive patients who underwent ACL reconstruction between 2001 and 2002. A clinical and radiological follow-up was performed at a minimum of 6 years. After 6 years, the International Knee Documentation Committee score demonstrated good-to-excellent results (A and B) in 98% of patients. However, arthrometric results using the KT-1000 demonstrated that 6/80 patients (7.5%) had >5 mm manual maximum side-to-side difference. The median Tegner activity score was 5 (range 1–9); the median Lysholm score was 96 (range 81–100); and the median subjective IKDC score was 94 (range 66–100). We reported 6/80 failures as revealed by a 2+ or 3+ pivot-shift test result and/or KT-1000 side-to-side difference of more than 5 mm. The IKDC score revealed excellent results in all women who underwent extra-articular tenodesis. Radiographic evaluation demonstrated early signs of osteoarthritis in 9% of patients.     

Over-the-top double-bundle revision ACL reconstruction

Revision ACL presents many technical issues that are not seen in the primary ACL reconstruction. A variety of surgical techniques for revising ACL reconstruction have been described in the literature to address these concerns. The purpose of this article is to present a novel technique consisting in a non-anatomic double-bundle ACL revision reconstruction, using a fresh-frozen Achilles tendon allograft with soft tissue fixation. This technique is a valid treatment option when faced with a complex scenario such as ACL revision surgery.     

Causes for failure of ACL reconstruction and influence of meniscectomies after revision

The purpose of this multicenter retrospective study was to analyze the causes for failure of ACL reconstruction and the influence of meniscectomies after revision. This study was conducted over a 12-year period, from 1994 to 2005 with ten French orthopaedic centers participating. Assessment included the objective International Knee Documenting Committee (IKDC) 2000 scoring system evaluation. Two hundred and ninety-three patients were available for statistics. Untreated laxity, femoral and tibial tunnel malposition, impingement, failure of fixation were assessed, new traumatism and infection were recorded. Meniscus surgery was evaluated before, during or after primary ACL reconstruction, and then during or after revision ACL surgery. The main cause for failure of ACL reconstruction was femoral tunnel malposition in 36% of the cases. Forty-four percent of the patients with an anterior femoral tunnel as a cause for failure of the primary surgery were IKDC A after revision versus 24% if the cause of failure was not the femoral tunnel (P?=?0.05). A 70% meniscectomy rate was found in revision ACL reconstruction. Comparison between patients with a total meniscectomy (n?=?56) and patients with preserved menisci (n?=?65) revealed a better functional result and knee stability in the non-meniscectomized group (P?=?0.04). This study shows that the anterior femoral tunnel malposition is the main cause for failure in ACL reconstruction. This reason for failure should be considered as a predictive factor of good result of revision ACL reconstruction. Total meniscectomy jeopardizes functional result and knee stability at follow-up.     

The course of the patellar tendon after reharvesting its central third for ACL revision surgery: a long-term clinical and radiographic study

The choice of the optimal graft for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) revision surgery is still controversial. Reharvesting the patellar tendon has been suggested as one graft alternative. Our hypothesis was that in the long-term, ACL revision surgery using reharvested patellar tendon autografts would render a good clinical outcome and a normal patellar tendon at the donor site as seen on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Fourteen consecutive patients (five women, nine men), who underwent ACL revision surgery using reharvested ipsilateral patellar tendon grafts, were included in the study. They underwent bilateral MRI evaluations of the patellar tendon and were tested for clinical outcome 26 (20–35) and 115 months (102–127) after the revision procedure. On the second occasion, they also underwent standard weight-bearing X-ray examinations.The serial MRI evaluations revealed that the thickness of the patellar tendon at the donor site was significantly increased compared with the non-harvested, normal contralateral side and that the donor-site gap was still visible after 10 years. No significant differences were seen between the 2- and 10-year MRI evaluations. Standard weight-bearing X-ray examinations revealed signs of mild degenerative changes in all patients. Clinical results in terms of the Lysholm score, IKDC evaluation system, one-leg-hop test, KT-1000 laxity test and the knee-walking test revealed no significant differences between the 2- and 10-year assessments. In overall terms, the clinical results were considered to be poor on both occasions. The patellar tendon at the donor site had not normalised 10 years after the reharvesting procedure, as seen on MRI. Furthermore, the clinical results were poor after ACL revision surgery using reharvested patellar tendon autograft.     

Strategies for revision surgery after primary double-bundle anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction

Purpose

The purpose of this article was to discuss pre- and intra-operative considerations as well as surgical strategies for different femoral and tibial tunnel scenarios in revision surgery following primary double-bundle anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction.

Methods

Based on the current literature of ACL revision surgery and surgical experience, an algorithm for revision surgery after primary double-bundle ACL reconstruction was created.

Results

A guideline and flowchart were created using a case-based approached for revision surgery after primary double-bundle ACL reconstruction.

Conclusion

Revision surgery after primary double-bundle ACL reconstruction can be a challenging procedure that requires flexibility and a repertoire of surgical techniques. The combination of pre-operative planning with 3D-CT reconstruction, in addition to careful intra-operative assessment, and the use of this flowchart can simplify the ACL revision procedure.

Level of evidence

V.     

A CT-based classification of prior ACL femoral tunnel location for planning revision ACL surgery

Purpose

The purposes of this study are to describe an ACL femoral tunnel classification system for use in planning revision ACL reconstruction based on 3-D computed tomography (CT) reconstructions and to evaluate its inter- and intra-rater reliability.

Methods

A femoral tunnel classification system was developed based on the location of the femoral tunnel relative to the lateral intercondylar ridge. The femoral tunnel was classified as Type I if it was located entirely below and posterior to the ridge as viewed from distally, Type II if it was slightly malpositioned (either vertically, anteriorly, or both), and Type III if it was significantly malpositioned. To evaluate the reproducibility of the classification system, CT scans of 27 knees were obtained from patients scheduled for revision ACL reconstruction, and 3-D reconstructions were created. Four views of the 3-D reconstruction of each femur were then obtained, and inter- and intra-observer reliability was determined following classification of the tunnels by eight observers.

Results

Twenty-five tunnels were classified as Type I (5 tunnels), Type II (9 tunnels), or type III (11 tunnels) by at least 5 of 8 observers, while insufficient agreement was noted to classify two tunnels. The interobserver reliability of tunnel classification as type I, II, or III yielded a κ coefficient of 0.57, while intra-observer reliability yielded a κ coefficient of 0.67. Subclassification of type II femoral tunnels into the subgroups anterior, vertical, and both was possible in four of the nine type II patients. The interobserver reliability of the complete classification system yielded a κ coefficient of 0.50, while the intra-observer reliability yielded a κ coefficient of 0.54.

Conclusion

Classification of the location of ACL femoral tunnels utilizing 3-D reconstructions of CT data yields moderate to substantial inter- and intra-observer reliability.

Level of evidence

Diagnostic Level III.     

人工韧带联合自体肌腱在前交叉韧带重建失败后翻修手术中应用

目的探讨在前交叉韧带重建失败后,应用LARS新型中空人工韧带联合自体肌腱行翻修手术的可行性及短期临床效果。方法回顾性分析自2015年6月至2016年7月收治的因前交叉韧带重建失败行翻修手术的11例患者的临床资料。11例患者均在关节镜下行翻修手术,采用LARS新型中空人工韧带联合自体肌腱重建前交叉韧带,采用KT-2000检查术前与末次随访时膝关节屈曲30°平均差值,根据国际膝关节评分委员会评分标准(IKDC)、Lysholm及Tegner评分系统对术前及末次随访时患者情况进行评价,探讨其临床疗效。结果本组患者随访6~18个月,平均12个月。末次随访时,膝关节屈曲30°平均差值较术前明显减小[(2.05±0.28)mm比(6.15±0.85)mm],差异有统计学意义(P<0.01)。末次随访时,IKDC、Tegner及Lysholm评分均较翻修前有显著改善,差异有统计学意义(P<0.01)。结论 LARS中空人工韧带联合自体肌腱在前交叉韧带重建失败翻修术中是一种可行的移植物选择,术后临床效果改善明显,值得推广。     

Quadriceps muscle activation and radiographic osteoarthritis following ACL revision

Purpose  

Quadriceps strength and activation may play an important role in the recovery from ACL revision surgery. The purpose of this study was to describe quadriceps strength and central activation ratio (CAR) and correlate with radiographic findings in patients with ACL revision surgery.     

Intra-articular lateral femoral condyle fracture following an ACL revision reconstruction

Lateral femoral condyle fractures following an ACL reconstruction are rare. To our knowledge, this is the first case report of a lateral femoral condyle fracture following a revision ACL reconstruction. The patient’s fracture was intra-articular, had a significant amount of soft tissue damage, and was further complicated by a large defect involving the bone tunnel from the ACL revision reconstruction. The patient was treated with an open reduction and internal fixation and recovered well.     

The location-specific healing response of damaged articular cartilage after ACL reconstruction: short-term follow-up

Although many different interventions have been proposed for treating cartilage lesions at the time of ACL reconstruction, the normal healing response of these injuries has not been well documented. To address this point, we compared the arthroscopic status of chondral lesions at the time of ACL reconstruction with that obtained at second-look arthroscopy. We hypothesized that there might be a location-specific difference in the healing response of damaged articular cartilage. Between September 1998 and March 2000, 383 patients underwent arthroscopically-assisted hamstring ACL reconstruction without any intervention to the articular cartilage. Among these patients, 84 patients underwent second-look arthroscopy (ranging from 6 to 52 months following initial surgery) and make up the population of the present study. Chondral injuries, left untreated at ACL reconstruction, were arthroscopically evaluated using the Outerbridge classification, and were again evaluated at second-look arthroscopy. At second-look arthroscopy, there was significant recovery of chondral lesions by Outerbridge grading on both the medial and lateral femoral condyles. Among the recovered chondral lesions, 69% of cases of the medial femoral condyle, 88% of cases of the lateral femoral condyle were partial thickness injuries (grade I and II). Conversely, there was no significant recovery of chondral lesions observed at the patello-femoral joint or tibial plateaus. Our study revealed that there was a location-specific difference in the natural healing response of chondral injury. Untreated cartilage lesions on the femoral condlyes had a superior healing response compared to those on the tibial plateaus, and in the patello-femoral joint.     

Long-term follow-up of ACL reconstruction with hamstring autograft

Purpose

To investigate the differences in the incidence and severity of knee osteoarthritis (OA), joint space narrowing, knee laxity, and knee flexion and extension strength between an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL)-reconstructed knee and the contralateral non-reconstructed limb.

Methods

Retrospective case series of patients from a single surgeon that had an ACL reconstruction with a semitendinosus/gracilis autograft more than 12 years ago. Outcome measures included radiographic analysis, International Knee Documentation Committee Subjective Knee Evaluation Form (IKDC), KT-1000, Tegner Activity Level Scale, Lysholm Knee Score, ACL quality of life score (ACL-QOL) and knee flexor/extensor strength.

Results

Seventy-four patients consented and sixty-eight (43 male, 25 female) were included for analysis. Average age (SD) at the time of surgery was 31.2 (±9.1) years. At follow-up of 14.6 (1.9) years, 9 % had re-ruptured their ACL, whereas 5 % ruptured the contralateral ACL. Reconstructed knees had a greater incidence and severity of OA (P < 0.01). Medial meniscus surgery was a strong predictor of OA. Seventy-five per cent scored a normal or nearly normal knee on the IKDC. The mean Lysholm score was 75.8 % and Tegner Activity Level Scale scores decreased (P < 0.001) from the time of surgery. Knee extension strength was greater in the contralateral knee at speeds of 60°/s (P = 0.014) and 150°/s (P = 0.012).

Conclusions

Reconstructed knees have a greater incidence and severity of OA than non-reconstructed knees, which suggests degenerative changes are secondary to ACL rupture. Medial meniscus surgery is a strong predictor of OA. Despite this, 75 % of patients reported good outcomes.     

Time to return to professional soccer matches after ACL reconstruction

Abstract After ACL reconstruction, accelerated rehabilitation allows professional soccer players to return to official matches within 4–6 months of surgery, but in many cases accelerated rehabilitation is impossible. This retrospective study investigated the variables that affect the time to return to competition of professional soccer players after ACL reconstruction. Between October and December 2002, a questionnaire designed for this study was administered to the players competing in the Italian First Division (Series A) who previously reported an ACL reconstruction. Among 479 players surveyed, we identified 38 cases of arthroscopic ACL reconstruction (8%). The mean time to return to competition was 232±135 days from surgery (range, 76–791). In 12 cases (31.6%; group A), there was an isolated ACL rupture and these players returned to competition within 163±44 days after surgery (range, 76–231). Twenty cases were associated with one or more lesions (52.6%; group B), and these players returned to competition within 203±56 days after surgery (range, 146–329). Six cases reported complications after surgery or during rehabilitation (infections, swelling; 15.8%; group C) and returned to competition within 456±203 days after surgery (range, 233–791; p<0.001 compared to groups A and B). In this study, a fast (<4 months) return to competition was achieved only in three cases of isolated ACL rupture (8%). Accelerated rehabilitation (<6 months) seems to be possible only in cases of isolated ACL reconstruction or when only the medial meniscus is involved as an associated lesion. The time to return to competition after ACL reconstruction was independent of the surgical technique used and must be considered the consequence of the complexity of the injury to the knee.     

Quadriceps strength impairment in the mid- to long-term follow-up period after total knee arthroplasty

Purpose

Quadriceps strength impairment after total knee arthroplasty (TKA) continues to be a concern. However, most studies of quadriceps strength have short-term follow-up periods. Whether quadriceps strength impairment occurs in the long-term follow-up period after TKA remains unclear. The purpose of this study was to compare the quadriceps strength between posterior cruciate ligament-retaining (CR) and substituting (PS) design mobile-bearing TKA (1) in the same patients after an average of 10 years and (2) between TKA patients and age-matched controls.

Methods

A prospective, quasi-randomized design was used. Thirty-four patients (68 knees) who underwent bilateral TKA (CR on one side and PS on the other) were followed for a minimum of 5 years, and 35 age-matched controls (70 knees) were evaluated. A handheld dynamometer was used to measure quadriceps isometric strength. For each patient, the maximum value of three trials was used. The ratio of muscle strength to body weight (MS/BW ratio; N/kg) was used to evaluate outcomes.

Results

The median MS/BW ratio was 3.3 (range 1.4–10.5) for CR 3.4 (range 0.9–9.3) for PS, and 4.6 (range 0.4–8.8) for controls. The MS/BW ratio did not differ between prosthesis designs, but was significantly smaller in both CR (p = 0.020) and PS (p = 0.024) than in controls.

Conclusions

Posterior cruciate ligament-retaining TKA does not confer a substantial advantage an average of 10 years postoperatively. In addition, quadriceps strength, as measured using a hand-held dynamometer, was significantly lower in both TKA patient groups than in age-matched controls. Clinically, the results of this study indicate that quadriceps-strengthening exercises should be continued in the long term after TKA.

Level of evidence

II.

     

Changes in the brain during long-term follow-up after liver transplantation

Purpose:

To examine changes in the brain before liver transplantation caused by the accumulation of paramagnetic ion deposits and to investigate recovery after liver transplantation over a long‐term horizon.

Materials and Methods:

Fifteen patients indicated for liver transplantation, 26 patients up to 2 years after, and 40 patients 8–15 years after liver transplantation were subjected to MR relaxometry. T₁ and T₂ relaxation times in the basal ganglia, thalamus, and white matter were evaluated.

Results:

Relaxometry revealed a shortening of the relaxation times due to the deposition of paramagnetic ions in the basal ganglia before liver transplantation (P < 0.05), complete normalization of the relaxation times shortly after transplantation in the globus pallidus and caudate nucleus, and partial recovery of T₂ in the putamen. Relaxation times remained stable even 15 years posttransplantation. Increased relaxation times posttransplantation were found in the white matter and thalamus.

Conclusion:

The shortening of the relaxation times observed in the basal ganglia before liver transplantation was caused by paramagnetic ion deposition. The recovery observable within 2 years after transplantation was permanent, and no recurrence of paramagnetic ion deposition was observed even 15 years posttransplantation. Changes in the white matter and thalamus after transplantation were attributed to damage caused by permanent exposure to immunosuppressants. J. Magn. Reson. Imaging 2012;35:1332–1337. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Histologic long-term follow-up after embolization with polyvinyl alcohol particles.

A large facial vascular malformation was embolized with polyvinyl alcohol particles twice in 8 years. Resected tissue enabled long-term examination of this material, confirming its chemical inertness and revealing minimal tissue reaction to it apart from calcification. No particle migration, fragmentation, or absorption occurred. There was some recanalization of occluded vessels. Most vessels containing polyvinyl alcohol particles, and all of the larger vessels, were incompletely occluded, with particles becoming embedded in their walls.     

Landing adaptations after ACL reconstruction

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to determine whether fully rehabilitated ACL reconstructed (ACLr) recreational athletes utilize adapted lower-extremity joint kinematics and kinetics during a high-demand functional task. METHODS: The kinematic and kinetic performance of 11 healthy and 11 hamstring ACLr recreational athletes were compared during a 60-cm vertical drop landing. RESULTS: At initial ground contact, the ACLr group demonstrated greater hip extension and ankle plantarflexion compared with the healthy group. The peak vertical ground-reaction force was not different between groups, but the ACLr group delayed the time to its occurrence. The knee extensors provided the major energy absorption function for both groups; however, the ACLr group performed 37% more ankle plantarflexor work and 39% less hip extensor work compared with the healthy group. CONCLUSIONS: The hamstring ACLr recreational athletes utilized an adapted landing strategy that employed the hip extensor muscles less and the ankle plantarflexor muscles more. The harvesting of the medial hamstring muscles for ACL reconstruction may contribute to the utilization of this protective landing strategy.     

Maximizing quadriceps strength after ACL reconstruction

The primary objectives of ACL surgery and rehabilitation are to restore knee function to preinjury levels and promote long-term joint health. Often these goals are not achieved, however. The quadriceps is critical to dynamic joint stability, and weakness of this muscle group is related to poor functional outcomes. Because of this, identifying strategies to minimize quadriceps weakness following ACL injury and reconstruction is of great clinical interest. This article reviews the current literature and critically discusses current rehabilitation approaches to restore quadriceps muscle function after ACL reconstruction.