Evaluating progress of labor in nulliparas and multiparas using the modified WHO partograph

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the progress of labor in nulliparas and multiparas using the modified World Health Organization (WHO) partograph. METHOD: In a prospective study 259 nulliparas and 204 multiparas were compared for rates of normal labor progression in the active phase; of cervical dilatation plots crossing the alert line of the partograph; and of plots reaching or crossing the action line. Outcome measures were total duration of labor, mode of delivery, incidence of labor augmentation, and number of vaginal examinations. RESULTS: Labor duration was similar in the 2 groups and cervical dilatation remained normal for most women. In both groups, the incidence of spontaneous vaginal delivery was highest among women with normal labor progress and the incidence of both labor augmentation and operative intervention increased when labor progress was delayed. CONCLUSION: Labor progress and duration were found similar for nulliparas and multiparas when monitored with the modified WHO partograph. Delay in labor progress increased the need for operative intervention and adversely affected fetal outcome.     

Membrane sweeping in conjunction with labor induction

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether cervical membrane sweeping (stripping) during induction of labor is beneficial.METHODS: We compared outcomes of labor after induction in pregnant women at term in a randomized trial. Women were assigned to having their membranes swept or not during induction. Outcome measures included duration of labor, maximum dose of oxytocin used, induction-labor interval, and mode of delivery.RESULTS: We recruited 130 nulliparas (64 sweep, 66 nonsweep) and 118 multiparas (60 sweep, 58 nonsweep). Among nulliparas who received intravaginal prostaglandin (PG) E(2) and oxytocin, those who had simultaneous sweeping had significantly shorter mean (+/- standard error of mean) induction-labor interval (13.6 +/- 1.4 versus 17.3 +/- 1.2 hours, P =.048), lower mean maximum dose of oxytocin (6.8 +/- 0.8 versus 10.35 +/- 1.1 mU/minute, P =.01), and increased normal delivery rates (vaginal delivery 83. 3% versus 58.2%, P =.01). Sweeping also had a favorable effect on nulliparas who received oxytocin alone (mean induction-labor interval 5.8 +/- 3.1 versus 11.2 +/- 3.6 hours, P =.04; mean maximum dose 8.8 +/- 1.3 versus 16.3 +/- 1.9 mU/min, P =.01). Those differences were limited to women with unfavorable cervices. There were no differences in any outcome measures in multiparous women. CONCLUSION: Sweeping of the membranes during induction of labor had a beneficial effect on labor and delivery, which appeared to be limited to nulliparas with unfavorable cervices who needed cervical priming with PGE(2).     

Cervical assessment in women with threatened preterm labor.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of the study was to examine the clinical value of cervical assessment by transvaginal ultrasonography in women with symptoms of preterm labor. METHODS: We prospectively evaluated 172 women with singleton pregnancies and symptoms of preterm labor. Seventy of them were nulliparas, while 102 were multiparas. Gestational age ranged between 24 and 34 wks. All women underwent cervical assessment with transvaginal ultrasonography and were given intravenous tocolytics. The only parameter evaluated was cervical length. Women with multiple pregnancies, gestational age <24 wks or >34 wks, cervical dilatation >2 cm, placenta praevia, premature rupture of membranes, or cervical cerclage were excluded from the study. The outcome measure was delivery before 34 wks gestation. RESULTS: The preterm delivery rate before 34 wks was 37%. The sensitivity and the specificity of a cervical length of less than 20 mm was 60 and 53.8% and 97.7 and 95.2% for nulliparas and multiparas, respectively. A cervical length <20 mm was also 93.7% predictive of preterm delivery in nulliparas and 87.5% in multiparas, while the corresponding numbers for its negative predictive value (NPV) were 81.4 and 76.9%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Cervical assessment in women with symptoms of preterm labor can distinguish those at high risk for preterm delivery. Cervical sonography can be a valuable adjunct to the clinical evaluation of these patients.     

Cervical assessment in women with threatened preterm labor

Objective.?The aim of the study was to examine the clinical value of cervical assessment by transvaginal ultrasonography in women with symptoms of preterm labor.

Methods.?We prospectively evaluated 172 women with singleton pregnancies and symptoms of preterm labor. Seventy of them were nulliparas, while 102 were multiparas. Gestational age ranged between 24 and 34 wks. All women underwent cervical assessment with transvaginal ultrasonography and were given intravenous tocolytics. The only parameter evaluated was cervical length. Women with multiple pregnancies, gestational age <?24 wks or >?34 wks, cervical dilatation >?2?cm, placenta praevia, premature rupture of membranes, or cervical cerclage were excluded from the study. The outcome measure was delivery before 34 wks gestation.

Results.?The preterm delivery rate before 34 wks was 37%. The sensitivity and the specificity of a cervical length of less than 20?mm was 60 and 53.8% and 97.7 and 95.2% for nulliparas and multiparas, respectively. A cervical length <?20?mm was also 93.7% predictive of preterm delivery in nulliparas and 87.5% in multiparas, while the corresponding numbers for its negative predictive value (NPV) were 81.4 and 76.9%, respectively.

Conclusions.?Cervical assessment in women with symptoms of preterm labor can distinguish those at high risk for preterm delivery. Cervical sonography can be a valuable adjunct to the clinical evaluation of these patients.     

Three-dimensional ultrasound power Doppler assessment of the cervix: comparison between nulliparas and multiparas

AIM: To assess the sonographic cervical characteristics between nulliparous and multiparous women. SUBJECT AND METHODS: Transvaginal three-dimensional ultrasound and power Doppler using the virtual organ computer-aided analysis (VOCAL) program were performed on 71 nulliparas and 59 multiparas at a mean gestational age of 25.3+/-7.9 weeks. We compared the cervical volume and power Doppler vascularization index (VI), flow index (FI), and vascularization-flow index (VFI) between nulliparas and multiparas. RESULTS: The mean cervical volume and mean VI, VFI, FI measurements were not significantly different between multiparas and nulliparas. CONCLUSION: Our observations suggest that the morphological changes in the cervix of parous women are merely configurational without a change in cervical mass and vascularization. These configurational changes might result from the inevitable cervical stretching during labor and represent a healing process that does not involve a subsequent change in mass or vascularity.     

Characteristics of second labor occurring 10 or more years after the first.

Labor characteristics in 89 women undergoing a second vaginal delivery 10-18 years after the first were compared retrospectively with those of 136 women with an interval of 1-4 years between their first and second vaginal deliveries and with those of 128 nulliparous women. The pelvic findings on admission, average length of stages 1 and 2 of labor, average cervical dilation per hour and rates of surgical intervention in relation to arrest disorders were similar in the two multiparous groups and significantly different from these parameters in the nulliparous group. Women with long intervals between their first and second vaginal deliveries should be managed in the same way as are other multiparas and not like nulliparas with respect to such issues as indications for oxytocin treatment, surgical intervention and use of conduction anesthesia.     

Comparison of labor progression between induced and noninduced multiparous women

OBJECTIVE: The incidence of labor induction is rising rapidly in the United States. Among multiparas, labor is often followed with traditional labor curves derived from noninduced pregnancies. We sought to determine how labor progression of multiparous women who presented in spontaneous labor differed from those who were electively induced with and from those induced without preinduction cervical ripening. METHODS: We analyzed data on all low-risk multiparous women with an elective induction or spontaneous onset of labor between 37(+0) and 40(+6) weeks of gestation from January 2002 to March 2004 at a single institution. The median duration of labor by each centimeter of cervical dilatation and the risk of cesarean delivery were computed for 61 women with preinduction cervical ripening and oxytocin induction, 735 women with oxytocin induction, and 1,885 women with a spontaneous onset of labor. An intracervical Foley catheter was used to ripen the cervix. RESULTS: Those women who experienced electively induced labor without cervical ripening had a shorter active phase of labor than did those admitted in spontaneous labor (99 minutes in induced labor versus 161 minutes in spontaneous labor, P < .001). However, the cesarean delivery rate was elevated in the induction group (3.9% versus 2.3%, P < .05). Women who underwent preinduction cervical ripening also had a shorter active phase than those admitted in spontaneous labor (109 minutes versus 161 minutes, P = .01). CONCLUSION: The pattern of labor progression differs for women with an electively induced labor without cervical ripening compared with those who present with spontaneous onset of labor.     

Sweeping of the membranes versus uterine stimulation by oxytocin in nulliparous women. A randomized controlled trial

The aim of this study was to evaluate whether sweeping of the membranes at term could shorten the length of pregnancy and reduce the incidence of postterm pregnancies. We randomly selected 104 nulliparas with uncomplicated pregnancy and gestational age between 281 and 287 days. Our patients were divided into three groups. Group A consisted of 34 women who were subjected to sweeping of the membranes. Uterine stimulation with oxytocin was applied in 35 women (group B), and 35 women (group C) were used as a control group. We had no significant reduction of the time interval from sweeping of the membranes until delivery (1.9 +/- 1.2 days), compared to that of group B (2.1 +/- 0.8 days) as well as that of the control group (2.5 +/- 0.9 days). The incidence of spontaneous labor in patients after sweeping of the membranes was greater (67.6%) when compared with oxytocin-stimulated patients and the control group (p < 0.05). Furthermore, a better Bishop score was noted in patients of group A. No statistically significant difference was noted in the mode of delivery between the groups, but sweeping of the membranes significantly decreased the incidence of postterm pregnancies (p < 0. 05). We concluded that sweeping of the membranes is an effective method for initiating labor in women with a gestational age between 40 and 41 weeks, thus reducing the need for induction.     

Sonographic cervical length measurement before labor induction in term nulliparous women

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of the study was to determine if transvaginal sonographic measurement of the cervical length is a useful method to predict successful labor induction in nulliparas. METHODS: 137 women who were scheduled for medically indicated induction of labor had a transvaginal sonographic measurement of the cervical length before labor induction. Inclusion criteria were: (1) singleton pregnancy; (2) gestational age between 37-42 weeks; (3) live fetus in cephalic presentation; (4) intact membranes; (5) no vaginal bleeding; (6) no previous history of uterine surgery; (7) nulliparous women, and (8) no allergy or asthma in response to prostaglandins. Induction of labor was performed within 6 h of the ultrasonographic examination, by inserting 2 mg of dinoprostone in the posterior vaginal fornix, repeated if needed every 6 h for up to three doses. When the cervix became favorable and no regular contractions were observed, amniotomy and oxytocin augmentation, starting at 1 mIU/min and increasing 1 mIU every 30 min as necessary, was performed. RESULTS: All women were Caucasians and the mean age was 24.3 years (range 19-37 years). The mean cervical length was 28 mm (range 11-39 mm). The Bishop score was < or =5 in 101 women and >5 in the 36 others. Vaginal delivery occurred in 92 women (67.1%), and the vast majority of them (89 women; 96.7%) gave birth within 24 h of induction. Forty-five women (32.8%) had a cesarean section. The Bishop score was not predictive of the mode of delivery. Thirty-six of 101 women (35.6%) with a Bishop score < or =5 delivered by cesarean section, compared to 9 of 36 women with a Bishop score >5 (25%) (p = NS). Women with a cervical length <27 mm were more likely to deliver vaginally. Using this cutoff value the sensitivity of a successful labor induction was 76% and the specificity was 75.5%. CONCLUSIONS: Transvaginal sonographic measurement of cervical length is a good predictor of a successful labor induction at term in nulliparas.     

Duration of labor. An analysis of influencing factors

9703 labors at Akershus Central Hospital during the period January 1979 to January 1984 were analysed to see which factors influenced the duration of labor. Median duration was 8.2 h for nulliparas, 5.3 h for multiparas. Parity greater than one had no influence on duration. Induced labors were 1.9 h (nulliparas) and 1.4 h (multiparas) shorter than those with spontaneous onset. Stepwise linear regression showed that duration of labor was positively correlated with the weight of the infant, duration of pregnancy, weight gain and prepregnant weight. It was negatively correlated with mother's height. Mother's age did not influence duration of labor. Occiput posterior presentation and extensions of the head prolonged labor in nulliparas, but not in multiparas, while breech presentation had no influence.     

Active-phase labor arrest: oxytocin augmentation for at least 4 hours

OBJECTIVE: To assess a labor-management protocol that mandated at least 4 hours of oxytocin augmentation before cesarean delivery for active-phase labor arrest. METHODS: We prospectively evaluated term gravidas in spontaneous labor with active-phase labor arrest (cervix at least 4 cm dilated and 1 cm or less of cervical progress in 2 hours). Exclusion criteria included nonvertex presentation, previous cesarean, multiple gestation, and a nonreassuring fetal heart rate tracing or chorioamnionitis at the time of labor arrest. After the diagnosis of active-phase arrest, oxytocin was initiated with an intent to achieve a sustained uterine contraction pattern of greater than 200 Montevideo units. Cesarean delivery was not performed for labor arrest until at least 4 hours of a sustained uterine contraction pattern of greater than 200 Montevideo units, or a minimum of 6 hours of oxytocin augmentation if this contraction pattern could not be achieved. RESULTS: Five hundred forty-two women were managed by the protocol, and 92% delivered vaginally. The subsequent vaginal delivery rate for parous women who had not progressed (1 cm of cervical dilation or less) despite 2 hours of oxytocin augmentation was 91%, and it was 74% for nulliparas. With no labor progress after 4 hours of oxytocin augmentation, the subsequent vaginal delivery rates were 88% for parous women and 56% for nulliparas. There were no severe maternal complications. One neonate had persistent fetal circulation and one had a positive blood culture, but both did well. CONCLUSION: Extending the minimum period of oxytocin augmentation for active-phase labor arrest from 2 to at least 4 hours was effective and safe.     

Foley catheter with simultaneous oxytocin on labor induction: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

Objective: It is unclear that whether Foley catheter with simultaneous oxytocin could improve the efficacy of induction outcome.

Method: To conduct a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trial (RCT) studies to evaluate the effect of Foley catheter with simultaneous oxytocin on labor induction. PubMed, Embase, and other databases were searched from their inception to July 2017. We included all RCTs comparing Foley catheter with simultaneous oxytocin (i.e. intervention group) with Foley catheter followed by oxytocin (i.e. control group) in the three kinds of women (nulliparas and multiparas/only nulliparas/only multiparas). We estimate summarized relative risk (RR) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) for dichotomous outcomes, standard mean difference for continuous outcomes. Fixed- and random-effects models were used, depending on heterogeneity.

Results: After application of our inclusion and exclusion criteria, six RCTs with a total of 1133 participants were identified. We found that only nulliparas had significant RR of delivery within 24?h (RR?=?1.32, 95% CI: 1.12, 1.55, I²?=?46.5%). Meanwhile, there was no statistically significant difference between intervention and control groups in vaginal delivery in 24?h, cesarean delivery, time to delivery, and Apgar score at 5?min less than 7. Foley catheter with simultaneous oxytocin did not increase the risk of side effects, included chorioamnionitis, postpartum hemorrhage, uterine hyperstimulation, and neonatal intensive care unit admission.

Conclusion: The results seem to support the use of oxytocin to a Foley catheter at the initiation of labor induction, as it might lead to increases the rate of delivery within 24?h in nulliparas.     

Epidural analgesia and fetal head malposition at vaginal delivery

OBJECTIVE: To determine if nulliparas who delivered with on-demand epidural analgesia are more likely to have malpositioning of the fetal vertex at delivery than women delivered during a period of restricted epidural use. METHODS: A retrospective cohort of nulliparous women with spontaneous labor delivered during a 12-month period immediately before the availability of on-demand labor epidural analgesia was compared with a similar group of nulliparas delivered after labor epidural analgesia was available on request. The primary outcome variable was a non-occiput anterior position or malpositioned fetal head at vaginal delivery. RESULTS: The frequency of epidural use increased from 0.9% before epidural analgesia became available on demand to 82.9% afterward. Fetal head malpositioning at vaginal delivery occurred in 26 of 434 (6.0%) women delivered in the before period compared with 29 of 511 (5.7%) in the after period (relative risk 0.95, 95% confidence interval 0.6, 1.6). No statistically significant difference in the incidence of fetal head malpositioning was present after patients were stratified by mode of delivery (Mantel-Haenszel weighted relative risk 0.94, 95% confidence interval 0.6, 1.4). The study sample size provided 85% power to detect a two-fold increase in the incidence of fetal malpositioning from a baseline rate of 6% associated with on-demand epidural use. CONCLUSION: Providing on-request labor epidural analgesia to nulliparas in spontaneous labor did not result in a clinically significant increase in the frequency of fetal head malpositioning at vaginal delivery.     

Uterine Activity in Spontaneous Labour with Breech Presentation

Uterine activity was quantified for patients who had a breech presentation, spontaneous labour and a vaginal delivery. Results were studied according to parity and in relation to cervical dilatation. The multiparas with breech presentation overall had lower uterine activity compared to nulliparas when the whole labour was considered. These values were compared with control patients with vertex presentation who had spontaneous normal labour and vaginal delivery. The median uterine activity values in breech presentation were not significantly different from control nulliparous or multiparous patients. Among the breech deliveries, irrespective of parity, mean Apgar scores at 1 and 5 minutes were over 6 and cord arterial blood pH values were above 7.15, but these results were significantly lower than the control cases with vertex presentation. The uterus performs similar uterine activity in spontaneous normal labour whether the fetus presents as a vertex or breech, when controlled for parity.     

Preterm labor in twin pregnancies: prediction by cervical assessment

Patients attending a twin pregnancy antenatal clinic underwent cervical palpation at each visit to calculate a cervical score by subtracting dilatation from length. Prediction of the onset of labor by cervical assessment was studied in 223 already parous women with twin pregnancies who ultimately labored spontaneously. The lower the score, the shorter was the mean time until delivery, although there existed a subgroup of patients who had ripe cervices for several weeks before the onset of labor. The cervical score itself appeared to give better prediction of labor than did changes in the score. Cervical assessment identified a group of twin pregnancies at especially high risk of preterm labor, in that 76% of patients with a score of -2 or less at or before 34 weeks delivered preterm. There was no evidence that labor was precipitated by vaginal examination, although this requires further study.     

Impact of collaborative management and early admission in labor on method of delivery

OBJECTIVE: This study compared the effects of early admission in labor and perinatal care provider on delivery method. Higher spontaneous vaginal delivery rates for certified nurse midwives as compared with physicians have been reported in observational studies and randomized clinical trials. Certified nurse midwives, with their more expectant approach to labor management, would be expected to admit women later in labor than obstetricians. METHODS: Prospective cohort study of 2,196 low-risk pregnancies, with singleton, vertex infants admitted in spontaneous labor. Independent and joint effects of perinatal care provider and cervical dilation at admission on delivery method were evaluated. Confounding was addressed using restriction and multiple regression. RESULTS: Fewer (23.4%) women in collaborative care were admitted in early labor (< 4 cm cervical dilation) than women managed by obstetricians (95% CI = -27.6 to -19.2). Obstetrician care had 9% to 30% fewer spontaneous vaginal deliveries. Women admitted early in labor also had 6% to 34% fewer spontaneous vaginal deliveries. Evaluation of joint effects suggested that interaction between obstetrician provider and earlier admission increased the risk of operative delivery. CONCLUSION: Later admission in labor (at 4 cm or greater cervical dilation) and management of perinatal care by certified nurse midwives in collaboration with obstetricians increased the rate of spontaneous vaginal delivery in low-risk women.     

Impact of labor induction,gestational age,and maternal age on cesarean delivery rates

OBJECTIVE: To quantify the impact of labor induction and maternal age on cesarean delivery rates in nulliparous and multiparous women between 36 and 42 weeks' gestation. METHODS: We performed a retrospective cohort study on 14,409 women delivering at two teaching hospitals in metropolitan Boston during 1998 and 1999. Women who had contraindications to labor, including a prior cesarean delivery, were excluded. The risks for cesarean delivery by induction status, gestational age by completed week between 36 and 42 weeks, maternal age <35, 35-39, and >/=40 years, and stratified by parity, were calculated by logistic regression. RESULTS: In nulliparas, labor induction was associated with an increase in cesarean delivery from 13.7% to 24.7% (adjusted odds ratio [OR] 1.70; 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.48, 1.95]). In multiparas, induction was associated with an increase from 2.4% to 4.5% (OR 1.49; 95% CI 1.10, 2.00). Other variables that placed a nulliparous woman at increased risk for cesarean delivery included maternal age of at least 35 years and gestational ages over 40 weeks. For multiparas, only maternal age 40 years or older and gestational age of 41 weeks were associated with an increase in cesarean deliveries. CONCLUSION: Induction of labor, older maternal age, and gestational age over 40 weeks each independently increase the risk for cesarean delivery in both nulliparous and multiparous women. Although the relative risk from induction is similar in nulliparas and multiparas, the absolute magnitude of the increase is much greater in nulliparas (11% versus 2.1%).     

Transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) for adjuvant pain-relief during labor and delivery

Objective: We examined the efficacy of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) in general and the new Freemom TENS device (LifeCare, Israel) in particular, for pain relief during labor and delivery. Methods: The study group consisted of 104 women. Forty-six nulliparas (44.2%) and 58 multiparas (55.8%), all of whom used the TENS device for pain relief during labor. All participants completed a questionnaire on the degree of pain relief afforded them by TENS during the delivery and related questions. The objective evaluation was based on the documented labor and delivery parameters including medical interventions during delivery. Results: The majority of subjects (72% of the nulliparas and 69% of the multiparas) considered TENS effective for the relief of pain during labor. Most of them (67% of the nulliparas and 60% of the multiparas) responded positively to the use of TENS in future deliveries. Sixty-five percent of the multiparas considered TENS at least as effective as the other pain relief methods they had used before. TENS significantly reduced the duration of the first stage of labor P<0.001 for nulliparas, P<0.005 for multiparas and it significantly decreased the amount of analgesics administered to individual patients. No significant difference was found in fetal heart rate tracings, Apgar scores and cord blood pH between the study group and an equal number of matched controls who used other forms of pain management. Conclusions: TENS is an effective non-pharmacological, non-invasive adjuvant pain relief modality for use in labor and delivery. TENS application reduced the duration of the first stage of labor and the amount of analgesic drug administered. There were no adverse effects on mothers or newborns.     

Elective induction of labor: failure to follow guidelines and risk of cesarean delivery

BACKGROUND: Estimate the frequency of failure to follow the French consensus guidelines for elective induction, and assess how failure affects the rate of cesarean delivery. METHODS: We compared cesarean rates according to mode of onset of labor among 5,046 low-risk patients. Violation of the guidelines was defined as induction before 38 weeks or with a Bishop score <5 or with prostaglandins. The cesarean risk was analysed with a bivariable and then a multivariable analysis, which used a multilevel logistic model. RESULTS: Women with electively induced and spontaneous labor had identical cesarean rates (4.1%). The guidelines were not followed in 23.2% of elective inductions. The risk of cesarean was higher after induction with a Bishop score <5, than after spontaneous labor (adjusted OR=4.1, 95% CI [1.3-12.9]), while elective induction with a favourable cervix did not increase the cesarean risk. In nulliparas, failure to follow the guidelines tripled the risk of cesarean (adjusted OR=3.2 [1.0-10.2]). On the other hand, elective induction of labor for women with a favourable cervix did not increase the risk of cesarean over the risk with spontaneous labor. CONCLUSION: Elective induction does not appear to increase the cesarean rate when the guidelines are met. Electively inducing labor with a low Bishop score increased the risk of cesarean, especially in nulliparas.