Two ankle joint laxity testers: reliability and validity

Two test devices were manufactured to objectively measure ankle joint laxity: the dynamic anterior ankle tester (DAAT) and the quasi-static anterior ankle tester (QAAT). The primary aim was to analyse the reliability of both testers; The secondary aim was to assess validity in correlation with TELOS stress test and manual anterior drawer test. Twenty-four normal subjects and 14 patients 1 year after acute lateral ankle ligament injury were included. Both ankles were tested with the DAAT and QAAT by two different observers; one experienced orthopaedic surgeon performed the manual test; the TELOS stress X-rays were evaluated by one observer. Intra observer reliability for the DAAT varied between 0.81 and 0.94; for the QAAT between 0.71 and 0.94. Inter observer reliability for the DAAT varied between 0.84 and 0.94; for the QAAT between 0.76 and 0.82. Concurrent validity showed fair correlation between DAAT and QAAT for the first couple observers (0.71); however, a poor correlation was observed for the second couple (0.42). No significant correlations were found between neither DAAT and the TELOS and the manual test, nor QAAT and the TELOS and the manual test. In conclusion, reliability of both testers is high. Validity of the testers needs further investigation.     

Increased inversion angle replication error in functional ankle instability

The inversion-angle replication error of the ankle joint was measured in subjects with a functionally stable or unstable ankle. Testing was performed as a passive set–active replication design. The absolute replication error on the unstable side of 23 unilaterally, functionally, and mechanically unstable subjects was found to be significantly greater (2.5°) than the error on the healthy contralateral side (2.0°; P < 0.05) and the error in a group of 40 ankle healthy controls (1.7°; P < 0.01). In 10 ankle-healthy high-level cross-country runners the replication error was reduced by 38% after warming up (P = 0.04). Received: 12 July 1999 Accepted: 20 March 2000     

The ankle meter: an instrument for evaluation of anterior talar drawer in ankle sprain

The aim of this study was to work out a clinical test which is possible to measure the anterior talar drawer (ATD) in patients after ankle sprain. The instrument for evaluation was called ankle meter. The instrument consists of two plastic scales (heal scale and tibia scale). The instrument allows quantifying the results of the anterior drawing test. A total of 38 persons (16 men, 22 women) were available as control group. The persons were 28.8±10.1 years old. No proband had any ankle problems in his history. A total of 45 patients (25 males, 20 females) suffering from ankle sprain were included in the study. In these patients stress radiography (147.1 N) was performed to measure the ATD. In control group the clinical measured ATD was 1.7±1.3 mm. Measurement for detect the interobserver validity did not detect significant differences. The ATD of the joint after ankle sprain was significantly higher (8.9±4.3 mm). The difference between healthy and injured ankle in case of an ankle sprain was 7.4±4.2 mm. There was a significant correlation between clinical and radiological measured ATD (R=0.91). The results suggest that it is possible to measure the ATD exactly. The values of the clinical ATD measurement showed a good correlation with the results of stress radiography. Diligent clinical examination in combination with this special test are after this experiences sufficient to classify the severity of injury after ankle sprain.     

Anatomical reconstruction versus tenodesis for the treatment of chronic anterolateral instability of the ankle joint: a 2- to 10-year follow-up, multicenter study

The clinical outcome of anatomical reconstruction or tenodesis in the treatment of chronic anterolateral ankle instability was assessed in a retrospective multicenter study. The anatomical reconstruction group (group A) consisted of 106 patients (mean age at operation 24 ± 8.4 years) and the tenodesis group (group B) of 110 patients (mean age at operation 26 ± 11.4 years). Patients were evaluated at a mean follow-up of 5.5 ± 2.8 years in group A and 5.2 ± 2.9 years in group B. The review protocol included patient characteristics, physical examination, two ankle scoring scales to evaluate the functional results, and standard anteroposterior and lateral radiographs to evaluate degenerative changes. Mechanical stability was evaluated using standardized stress radiographs. A larger number of reoperations was performed in group B (P = 0.008). At physical examination, more patients in group B had a smaller range of ankle motion than those in group A (P = 0.009). ¶A larger proportion of patients in group B had medially located osteophytes, as seen on standard radiographs (P = 0.04). On stress radiographic examination, the mean talar tilt (P = 0.001) and mean anterior talar translation (P < 0.001) were seen to be significantly greater in group B than in group A. There were no differences in mean Karlsson score between the groups, but more patients in group A had an excellent result on the Good score (P = 0.011). Unlike anatomical reconstructions, tenodeses do not restore the normal anatomy of the lateral ankle ligaments. This results in restricted range of ankle motion, reduced long-term stability, an increased risk of medially located degenerative changes, a larger number of reoperations, and less satisfactory overall results.     

Ankle muscle activation during the limits of stability test in subjects with chronic ankle instability

ObjectiveTo study postural control and muscle activity during the limit of stability test (LOS) in subjects with chronic ankle instability.DesignObservational study.SettingUniversity laboratory.Participants10 healthy subjects were included in the control group and 10 subjects in the CAI group (age between 18 and 30 years, with history of the multiple ankle “giving way” episodes in the last six months and score ≤24 in the Cumberland Ankle Instability Tool).Main outcome measuresA computerized dynamic posturography equipment was used for assessing the LOS. The electromyography activity of tibialis anterior (TA), soleus (SOL), medial gastrocnemius (MG) and peroneus longus (PL) was registered.ResultsSubjects with CAI had a greater activation in TA to forward (p < .01), forward affected (p = .001), backward affected (p = .007) and backward directions (p < .01); in PL to forward affected (p < .01) and affected directions (p = .001); in MG to forward (p = .023) and affected directions (p < .01) and in SOL to the affected direction (p = .009). We observed restricted excursions and less directional control in subjects with CAI.ConclusionsSubjects with CAI exhibited poorer ability to move their center of gravity within stability limits. In addition, they have an altered ankle muscle activity during LOS test toward the affected ankle joint.     

Ankle laxity affects ankle kinematics during a side-cutting task in male collegiate soccer athletes without perceived ankle instability

ObjectivesTo investigate whether ankle joint laxity alone influences lower limb kinematics during a side-cutting task.DesignA cross-sectional study.SettingSports medicine research laboratory.ParticipantsIn total, 66 male collegiate soccer players with history of ankle sprains with no perceived ankle instability were categorised into three groups: no-laxity copers (n = 26), laxity copers (n = 23), and severe-laxity copers (n = 17).Main outcome measuresThe hip, knee, ankle, rearfoot, midfoot, and forefoot kinematic data during the stance phase (0%–100% indicated initial contact to take-off) of a 45° side-cutting task were analysed using one-dimensional statistical parametric mapping.ResultsThe horizontal plane kinematics of the rearfoot differed significantly among the three groups during 30%–91% of the stance phase (P < .05). Severe-laxity copers exhibited a greater external rotation angle than no-laxity copers during 6%–14% and 32%–92% of the stance phase (P < .05).ConclusionOur data suggest that severe ankle joint laxity affects rearfoot horizontal plane kinematics in individuals without perceived ankle instability performing a 45° side-cutting task. These findings could be used by clinicians in developing rehabilitation programs to prevent further ankle sprains in patients with severe ankle joint laxity.     

Knee joint simulator: an anatomical reconstruction of the joint surfaces and of the ligamentous structures of the knee joint for teaching purposes

A knee joint simulator with anatomical reconstruction of the joint surfaces and of the ligamentous structures was built for teaching purposes. With this simulator it is possible to demonstrate the anatomy, physiology and kinematics of knee ligaments, to teach and learn how to conduct ligamentous instability tests and to demonstrate the effect of knee ligament reconstructive surgery. Received: 11 March 1998 Accepted: 12 May 1998     

Arthrography of the ankle joint in chronic instability

Papers on arthrography of injuries of the lateral ligaments of the ankle relate mainly to recent distortion of the joint. Arthrography performed at a later stage after injury generally is considered useless. In fact, changes in chronic instability are observed; they are subtle and consist either of small recesses adjacent to the lateral malleolus or communication of the joint with the peroneal tendon sheaths. Arthrography was assessed in 61 cases of recurrent lateral sprains of the ankle more than 2 weeks after acute injury; 38 were considered as positive. Twenty-five patients had operative evaluation, with four false negative and one false positive results. Small recesses adjacent to the lateral malleolus or opacification of the peroneal tendon sheaths are sequelae of an acute sprain with tear of the anterior talofibular and/or the calcaneofibular ligaments. Although false negative results occur, arthrography is useful in the preoperative assessment of chronic ankle instability.     

Critical review of self-reported functional ankle instability measures: A follow up

ObjectiveDetermine which ankle instability questionnaire predicts subject's ankle instability status based on a minimum accepted criteria for FAI (MC_FAI).DesignCross-sectional study.SettingLarge Midwestern University.ParticipantsCollege aged subjects (n = 1127 19.6 ± 2.1 years) from a university population were recruited for this study. Any volunteer, regardless of ankle injury history was included in the study.Main outcome measuresThe independent variables were the score on three self-report ankle instability questionnaires: Ankle Instability Instrument, Cumberland Ankle Instability Tool, and Identification of Functional Ankle Instability. Subjects completed the questionnaires for their dominant limb during a single testing session. The dependent variable was created based on the previously established MC_FAI. This was established as at least one ankle sprain and at least one episode of giving way. Data were modeled using a chi-square and multinomial logistic regression. 95% confidence intervals were calculated for the resulting odds ratios.ResultsA test of the full model with all three predictors against MC_FAI revealed that only the IdFAI (X² = 457.09, p = .001) had a significant relationship with the outcome variable. The IdFAI had an overall prediction rate of 87.8%.ConclusionsThis analysis illustrates that IdFAI is a good overall option for predicting ankle stability status by self-reported questionnaire.     

Effects of elastic ankle support on running ankle kinematics in individuals with chronic ankle instability and healthy controls

BackgroundIndividuals with chronic ankle instability (CAI) have an increased risk for recurrent injuries. The preventive effects of external ankle supports are not fully understood. This study aimed to examine the effect of elastic ankle support on running ankle kinematics.Methods3D running gait analysis of individuals with and without CAI was conducted at three-minute-running trials at 2.78 m/s with and without elastic ankle support in a randomised order. Ankle kinematics and intra-individual standard deviations (variability) were calculated at each percent of the running gait cycle. Group and ankle support effects were calculated using statistical parameter mapping.ResultsTwenty-seven individuals were analysed (CAI: n = 14, controls: n = 13). When wearing ankle support, CAI individuals showed significantly decreased plantarflexion angles at 43–47 % (p = 0.033) and 49–51 % (p = 0.043) of the running gait cycle compared to normal running. In healthy controls, no differences in ankle angles between both conditions were found. Comparisons between CAI individuals and healthy controls showed statistically significant differences in the plantar-/dorsiflexion angles at 38–41 % (p = 0.044) with ankle support and at 34–46 % (p = 0.004) without ankle support. Significant ankle angle variability differences were found for ankle in-/eversion between CAI individuals and healthy controls (p = 0.041) at 32–33 % of the running gait cycle.ConclusionsElastic ankle support reduces the range of sagittal plane running ankle kinematics of CAI individuals but not of healthy controls. Further research is needed to evaluate the association between ankle support effects and the risk for recurrent ankle sprains.     

The effects of the tension of figure-8 straps of a soft ankle orthosis on the ankle joint kinematics while walking in healthy young adults: A pilot study

BackgroundFigure-8 straps are commonly used in ankle orthoses, which are provided to reduce the risks of primary and recurrent sprain by providing functional support. Functional treatment with ankle orthoses can provide better rehabilitation than immobilization for a mild ankle sprain. However, it is not known how much tension should be applied to the straps while donning the orthosis to optimize its effectiveness.Research questionThe aim of this study was to investigate the effects of figure-8 strap tension of a soft ankle orthosis on ankle joint kinematics in the sagittal, coronal, and transverse planes during gait in healthy young adults.MethodsTen healthy adults (five males and five females) were enrolled in this study. The 3-dimensional motion analysis system was used to evaluate the ankle kinematics of the participants during gait under five conditions: no soft ankle orthosis, soft ankle orthosis with no figure-8 straps tension (lace-up only), 50 N, 80 N, and 110 N tension of the figure-8 straps, respectively. All participants walked in a straight path at a comfortable speed.ResultsPlantarflexion angles were significantly reduced with 110 N of tension in the figure-8 straps when compared to the lace-up only and a moderate correlation with r = 0.34 (p = 0.03) was observed between the tensions of figure-8 straps and maximum plantarflexion angles at pre-swing of a gait cycle. No significant effects on ankle joint angles were demonstrated in the coronal and transverse planes.SignificanceThis study showed that increasing the tension of the figure-8 straps could restrict the ankle joint plantarflexion angle during pre-swing in gait. However, it might not affect inversion/eversion or internal/external rotation angles of the ankle joint in individuals without ankle pathologies.     

Fibular taping does not influence ankle dorsiflexion range of motion or balance measures in individuals with chronic ankle instability

ObjectivesTo determine the effects of fibular taping on ankle dorsiflexion range of motion (ROM) and dynamic balance in individuals with chronic ankle instability (CAI).DesignSingle-blind, randomized crossover.MethodsTwenty-three individuals (age = 23.4 ± 2.5 years, height = 171.6 ± 12.4 cm, mass = 71.5 ± 13.1 kg) with CAI were allocated to either a fibular taping intervention or sham taping intervention (tape applied without tension) over the course of two visits. Weight-bearing ankle dorsiflexion ROM and components of the Star Excursion Balance Test (SEBT) were measured before and after intervention.ResultsThere was not a significant change in ankle dorsiflexion ROM when comparing the taping interventions (F_1,43 = 1.03, P = .32), but both interventions resulted in a small increase (F_1,43 = 8.07, P = .007) in dorsiflexion ROM (pre = 36.7° ± 6.9°, post = 37.7° ± 6.2°). This increase in ROM did not exceed the established minimal detectable change for dorsiflexion ROM. Fibular taping with tension produced an increase (F_1,41 = 5.84, P = .02) (pre = 69.0 ± 9.1%, post = 70.6 ± 8.6%) in posterolateral reach distance when compared to taping without tension (pre = 72.7 ± 11.0%, post = 71.4 ± 9.6%), but this increase did not exceed the established minimal detectable change. There was not a significant change in dynamic balance between groups for the anterior (F_1,41 = 2.33, P = .14) and posteromedial (F_1,41 = .41, P = .53) reach directions.ConclusionsAlthough small changes in ankle dorsiflexion ROM and posterolateral reach distances were observed, these changes did not exceed established minimal detectable change values for these measures. These results suggest that the benefits of fibular taping are not related to an increase in ankle dorsiflexion ROM or dynamic balance.     

低场磁共振成像在踝关节周围骨挫伤的应用价值

目的探讨低场磁共振成像(MRI)在踝关节骨挫伤中的应用价值。方法对32例踝关节损伤的患者行MRI检查,MRI技术使用快速自旋回波(FSE)T1WI、T2WI及脂肪抑制短时间反转恢复序列(STIR)。结果在踝关节的骨挫伤中,STIR对骨挫伤病变显示率为100%,表现为骨髓水肿信号。结论在踝关节的骨挫伤中,MRI具有明显的优越性,STIR技术是最为敏感和准确的序列。     

Knee joint kinematics of the pendulum test in children with and without Down syndrome

BackgroundThe Wartenberg pendulum test is a common clinical test that is used to measure stiffness about the knee in persons with and without disabilities such as cerebral palsy and Down syndrome (DS). Adults and adolescents with DS show fewer number of swing cycles and a lower relaxation index than healthy controls. However, it is not clear if children with DS show a similar trend compared to typically developing (TD) children.Research questionWas the knee joint kinematics different between children with and without DS during the pendulum test?MethodsThirteen children with DS and 13 TD children participated in this study. There were two load conditions: no load (NL) and with ankle load (AL) equal to 2 % of the subject’s body weight. Five trials of a pendulum test were collected for each condition.ResultsThe DS group showed a smaller first flexion excursion, a lower relaxation index, lower mean and peak velocities and accelerations during the first and second flexion and extension, and greater variability of acceleration during the first flexion than the TD group across both load conditions. This suggests that the DS group may have greater stiffness of the knee than the TD group to compensate for joint instability.SignificanceThe pendulum test appears to be a valid test to evaluate the passive stiffness of the knee in children with DS. The lower relaxation index in children with DS suggests that larger bursts of quadriceps may be activated during a pendulum test, particularly in the first flexion excursion, to assure the knee joint stability.     

Stabilizing effects of ankle bracing under a combination of inversion and axial compression loading

The combined effects of bracing, axial compression and inversion rotation on the ankle-subtalar complexes were evaluated. Ex vivo tests under the load-controlled condition were performed on six cadaver ankle specimens using a six degree-of-freedom fixture. Inversion rotation was measured while subjecting the ankle-subtalar complex to a 2.5 N-m inversion moment and a combination of the testing variables (brace type, no brace, 178 N axial compression load, no compression load, 0° and 20° of plantar flexion) for a total of 16 tests per specimen. Three commercially available braces (two semirigid types and one lace up type) were evaluated. An axial compression load significantly decreased ankle-subtalar motion in unbraced ankles for the tested inversion moment. The contribution of bracing to stabilization of the ankle was smaller in the axial loading condition than in the no axial loading condition. The semirigid braces had greater stabilizing effects in response to the inversion moment than the lace up brace. Stabilizing effects of bracing were significantly greater in 20° of plantar flexion than in 0° of plantar flexion. The most common mechanism for an ankle sprain injury is inversion rotation on a weight-bearing ankle. Therefore, we should not overestimate stabilizing effects of bracing from evaluations of bracing without axial compression loading.     

Effects of an ankle brace on the in vivo kinematics of patients with chronic ankle instability during walking on an inversion platform

BackgroundAs in vivo tibiotalar and subtalar joint kinematics are not currently known following the application of an ankle brace, an investigation of these kinematics may provide insight into the mechanisms of ankle braces.Research questionThis study aimed to determine the effect of an ankle brace on in vivo kinematics of patients with chronic ankle instability.MethodsEleven patients with chronic ankle instability were recruited in this study. A dual fluoroscopic imaging system and a solid modeling software were utilized to calculate the joint positions of the participants as they walked barefooted on a level platform, walked barefooted on a 15° inversion platform, and walked with an ankle brace on a 15° inversion platform. The joint positions during the three walking conditions were compared.ResultsTibiotalar joints were more inverted (pose 2, p = .004), and subtalar joints were more anteriorly translated (pose 2–6, p = .003), more plantarflexed (pose 2, p = .008; pose 3, p = .013; pose 5, p = .008; pose 6, p = .016) and more inverted (pose 1–5, p = .003; pose 6, p = .013) during barefooted walking on the inversion platform than during walking on the level platform. The inversion of subtalar joints was decreased after the brace application (pose 2–4, p = .003; pose 5, p = .004; pose 7, p = .016).SignificanceBrace application reduced the increased subtalar inversion induced by the inversion platform. Nevertheless, increased subtalar anterior translation and plantarflexion persisted after brace application. The ankle brace might be beneficial for clinical populations with increased subtalar inversion.     

Center of pressure during stance and gait in subjects with or without persistent complaints after a lateral ankle sprain

Study aimTo investigate differences in the center of pressure (COP) during gait and single leg stance between subjects with persistent complaints (PC) and without persistent complaints (NPC) after a lateral ankle sprain.Methods44 patients who consulted the general practitioner, 6–12 months prior to inclusion, with a lateral ankle sprain were included for the current study purpose. Using a 7-point Likert scale patients were divided into the PC or NPC group. All subjects filled out an online questionnaire, walked along a walkway and performed a single leg stance, both on the RSscan. Primary outcomes included the COP displacement, range and percentage used in mediolateral and anterioposterior direction.ResultsThere was a trend (p < 0.05) towards a more medially COP trajectory during walking at 34–46% and 83–96% and more anteriorly at 21–31% and 91–100% of the stance phase in the PC group compared to NPC group. Additionally, the COP was more laterally located in the sprained leg compared to the non-sprained leg in the PC group in the loading response phase (p < 0.05). An interaction was found for the percentage of anterior–posterior range used in single leg stance without vision.ConclusionThe COP trajectory discriminates between patients with PC and NPC. This indicates that roll off during gait might play an important role in the recovery of patients after a lateral ankle sprain and could be used to monitor treatment.     

Arthroscopic assessment of the chronic unstable ankle joint

The purpose of this study was to evaluate prospectively the findings during arthroscopy in patients with chronic instability of the ankle joint. One hundred and ten consecutive patients who had suffered at least two ankle sprains and were symptomatic for at least 6 months were included in this study. A complete rupture of the anterior talofibular ligament was found in 64%, of the calcancofibular ligament in 41% and of the deltoid ligament in 6%. Cartilage lesions of the talus were seen in 54% of the joints, more of them medial (56%) than lateral (15%) or ventral (20%). Other frequently observed findings were synovialitis (38%), rupture of the syndesmosis (7%), and ventral scarring (6%). While cartilage damage was found independently of the lateral ligament injuries, all complete tears of the deltoid ligament were associated with cartilage injury of the talus. Medial instability was assessed in five ankles clinically and found arthroscopically in 23 ankle joints. Our arthroscopic findings show that chronic instability of the ankle joint is associated with various pathological conditions of ligaments, capsule and cartilage. It can therefore give essential information about the status of the chronic unstable joint with regard to the choice of operative or conservative treatment.