Single and multiple exposure tolerance study of cellulose sulfate gel: a Phase I safety and colposcopy study

Vaginally applied gels offer a promising approach for preventing unwanted pregnancies and sexually transmitted infections. Cellulose sulfate (CS) is a non-cytotoxic antifertility agent that also exhibits in vitro antimicrobial activity against sexually transmitted pathogens, including HIV. This was a randomized, double-blinded, Phase I study of 2.5 mL and 5.0 mL doses of 6% CS gel. A single vaginal application of the gel followed by five consecutive daily doses was assessed for genital irritation, safety, vaginal leakage, and product acceptability compared to two controls, Conceptrol, which is a marketed contraceptive gel containing nonoxynol-9, and K-Y jelly. The results suggest that the safety of 6% CS was comparable to that of Conceptrol and K-Y jelly, and it may be associated with less genital irritation. The 2.5 mL dose of CS may be preferable according to the participants’ reports of leakage. All the products had similar acceptability profiles.     

Safety and acceptability of 6% cellulose sulfate vaginal gel applied four times per day for 14 days

BACKGROUND: Six percent cellulose sulfate (CS) is a vaginal gel that has been in development as a microbicide. STUDY DESIGN: This was a single-center, multi-dose, Phase I, placebo-controlled, randomized, fully masked study conducted in Yaoundé, Cameroon, and involving sexually active women at low risk for sexually transmitted infections (STIs). METHODS: The study assessed the effect of CS and K-Y Jelly applied vaginally four times per day, for 14 consecutive days, on genital epithelial disruption, candidiasis and bacterial vaginosis (BV). Acceptability of the products was also assessed. Twenty-seven women were enrolled in each treatment group. RESULTS: Two (7.4%) of the women in each group developed genital epithelial disruption. One (3.7%) of the women in each group developed candidiasis, and one (3.7%) of the K-Y users developed BV. One (3.7%) of the CS users said she would not buy her product for pregnancy prevention but would for STI prevention. All the remaining women indicated they would buy their product for both indications. CONCLUSION: The results suggest that the safety and acceptability of 6% CS gel are comparable to that of K-Y Jelly.     

Cellulose sulfate: tolerance and acceptability of penile application

Sodium cellulose sulfate (CS) is under development as a vaginal microbicide and spermicide. This was a Phase I, randomized, double-blind study of men to assess acceptability, safety, and degree of penile irritation of seven consecutive daily doses of CS compared to an active control containing nonoxynol-9 (Conceptrol). The data suggest that CS gel is not more irritating to the male genitalia than Conceptrol. This, along with the minimal irritation seen in a Phase I safety study in women following 6 consecutive days of vaginal administration, suggests that CS could be used in future studies, without undue risk, where couples engage in vaginal intercourse. Male volunteers in future studies should be informed that 1 out of 24 participants in the CS group in this study experienced tingling and slight stinging for a brief time after exposure compared with 3 out of 12 in the Conceptrol group who reported similar symptoms.     

Fourteen-day safety and acceptability study of the universal placebo gel

OBJECTIVE: This study evaluated the effect of the so-called universal placebo compared to the polystyrene sulfonate (PSS) placebo on genital irritation. DESIGN: A single-center, Phase I, randomized, closed-label study was performed to evaluate the genital irritation of microbicide placebo gels. Thirty healthy, sexually abstinent women were randomly assigned to apply 3.5 mL of either the universal placebo or the PSS placebo gel intravaginally twice daily for 14 days. METHODS: Genital irritation was assessed by signs as seen on pelvic examination and colposcopy and reports of symptoms. Vaginal health was assessed by wet mounts, Gram stains for Nugent score and polymorphonuclear leukocytes, and semiquantitative vaginal cultures. Acceptability was assessed as reported on the follow-up questionnaire. RESULTS: The universal placebo was less irritating than the PSS placebo with a lower proportion of women experiencing signs and/or symptoms of genital irritation throughout follow-up (36% compared to 80%, p=.0253). The universal placebo was associated with few and mild genital symptoms, few and minor colposcopic findings and good vaginal health with no clinically significant changes in genital flora. Most participants found the feel of the universal placebo gel neutral or pleasant, and all participants found it odorless. CONCLUSIONS: The universal placebo appeared safe and acceptable when used twice daily for 14 days. The strategy of creating a de novo inert universal placebo is a successful approach. The universal placebo is appropriate for use as a placebo gel in HIV prevention trials with microbicide candidates.     

Single and multiple exposure tolerance study of polystyrene sulfonate gel: a phase I safety and colposcopy study

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate symptoms and signs of genital irritation, vaginal leakage and acceptability of polystyrene sulfonate (PSS), which is being studied as a vaginal contraceptive and microbicide. METHODS: Forty-nine women applied 2.5 mL of either 5% PSS, 10% PSS, PSS vehicle, or Conceptrol (a marketed spermicidal product containing 4% nonoxynol-9) for 6 consecutive days. RESULTS: All women completed the study except one in the Conceptrol group who experienced vaginal symptoms after her first use and was discontinued. After both the first use and after all uses, irritation was seen among more women in the Conceptrol group than in the PSS groups, reaching statistical significance with regard to any evidence of irritation, signs of irritation and product-related irritation. There were no adverse events that were serious, unexpected and related to product use in any group. The 5% concentration of PSS may be preferable in terms of leakage and acceptability. CONCLUSION: The results suggest that PSS has a safety profile comparable to that of the marketed nonoxynol-9 product, Conceptrol, and appears to be associated with less genital irritation.     

A Phase I study of the functional performance, safety and acceptability of the BufferGel Duet

BACKGROUND: The purpose of this study was to assess the functional performance of the BufferGel Duet, a buffering microbicide and spermicide gel applied to the cervix and vagina by a novel applicator that also serves as a mechanical barrier. STUDY DESIGN: This was a noncomparative Phase I safety trial in 30 healthy couples, aged 20-50 years, at low risk for sexually transmitted infections, who agreed to use the gel-device combination twice in 1 week and respond to detailed questionnaires about their experience. The female participants were examined with colposcopy before and 6-18 h after using the second device. RESULTS: Based on written instructions alone, 25 women successfully placed and 28 women successfully removed the device. Three women reported feeling the device dislodge around the time of intercourse. The product was equally acceptable to both men and women. Most users concluded that intercourse was the same or better with the device than with no product. About 73% would choose Duet over male condoms, and no one preferred the standard diaphragm. Colposcopic findings were noted in 79% of women with external genital findings (9) or cervicovaginal peeling (18) predominating. Only one finding breached the epithelium. Most product-related adverse events were mild (10/11) and confined to the genitourinary tract. CONCLUSIONS: The successful placements and acceptability suggest that further product development is warranted and could target over-the-counter use. During increased duration of use or more frequent dosing, cervicovaginal monitoring is advised based on the extent of peeling and external colposcopic findings in this short-term study.     

A randomized Phase I vaginal safety study of three concentrations of C31G vs. Extra Strength Gynol II

BACKGROUND: C31G is an antimicrobial and spermicidal agent that contains two surface-active compounds, cetyl betaine and myristamine oxide. It is being developed as a vaginal microbicide and contraceptive. METHOD: Three C31G concentrations (0.5%, 1.0% and 1.7%) were tested and compared with Extra Strength Gynol II(R), a marketed spermicide containing 3% nonoxynol-9 (N-9), in a randomized, double-blinded, Phase I, dose-escalation study to assess genital irritation (by subject report, visual examination at pelvic examination and colposcopy), plasma and vaginal lavage levels of C31G, product leakage, systemic safety and acceptability. Women were randomized to use 3.5 mL of one of the three C31G products or the N-9 gel at night for 7 days then twice daily for another 7 days. Pelvic and colposcopic evaluations were performed after 7 and 14 days of product use. RESULTS: The percent of women experiencing irritation in the 0.5% and 1.0% C31G groups in the study were similar to each other and were lower than the percent experiencing irritation in the 1.7% and N-9 groups, which were also similar to each other. Differences were statistically significant between 1.0% C31G vs. N-9 at 7 days and between 0.5% C31G and 1.0% C31G vs. N-9 at 14 days. There was no significant difference between groups in leakage or acceptability. No C31G was detected in the plasma of any volunteer. CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest that 0.5% and 1.0% C31G are less irritating to the female genital tract than 1.7% C31G or Extra Strength Gynol II.     

A randomized controlled safety trial of the diaphragm and cellulose sulfate microbicide gel in sexually active women in Zimbabwe

BACKGROUND: Cellulose sulfate (CS) is an antimicrobial and contraceptive agent. We assessed its safety when used alone or with the diaphragm in Harare, Zimbabwe. STUDY DESIGN: This was a randomized controlled safety trial with three arms: diaphragm with 6% CS gel vs. diaphragm with KY gel vs. CS gel alone. Participants were instructed to use their study products before every sex act for a period of 6 months. Safety end points were assessed monthly by questionnaires and urinanalysis and bimonthly by clinical examinations, colposcopy, wet mounts and gram stains. RESULTS: One hundred nineteen monogamous women were enrolled (28% HIV+) and 105 (88%) completed the study. No urinary tract infections were diagnosed during the study; 81.4% women had symptoms and/or signs of genital irritation considered at least possibly related to the gel or device, and 41.5% had changes in vaginal flora. There were no statistically significant differences between treatment groups in safety end points. All six women with deep epithelial disruption were diaphragm users, and all such findings were on the external genitalia. Of those, 4 had herpetic ulcers which were unrelated to products use. CONCLUSIONS: Cellulose sulfate appeared safe when used for 6 months alone or with a diaphragm.     

Contraception by Ushercell (cellulose sulfate) in formulation: duration of effect and dose effectiveness

This study evaluated contraception by formulated Ushercell, a uniquely high-molecular-weight form of cellulose sulfate, in the rabbit. Variables included (1) dose effectiveness, (2) duration of effectiveness, and (3) formulation excipients. Vaginally applied carboxymethyl-cellulose-based Ushercell gel is contraceptive. A 6% gel is active for at least 18 h; partial activity is observed for at least 24 h. With an application-insemination interval of 0.5 h, Ushercell as low as 0.1% is contraceptive. Contraception is incomplete with 2% Ushercell and an application-insemination interval of 24 h. Ushercell formulations containing a relatively high concentration of Carbopol are ineffective contraceptives, whether the gel is applied before insemination or is premixed with spermatozoa before insemination. Contraceptive activity is restored in Ushercell formulations with lower Carbopol content. This study shows that formulated Ushercell is an effective, long-lasting contraceptive and, hence, is bioavailable when vaginally applied. Activity is dependent on the type and relative concentration of formulation excipients. These data support a projected successful outcome of further clinical trials.     

Vaginal distribution of two volumes of the novel microbicide gel cellulose sulfate (2.5 and 3.5 mL)

This was a blinded crossover study to determine the in vivo distribution of 2.5 and 3.5 mL of 6% cellulose sulfate gel. This potential vaginal microbicide was mixed with dilute gadolinium chelate and inserted into the vagina. Magnetic resonance imaging was performed at baseline and repeated after 5, 20, 35 and 50 min with subjects either resting or ambulating between data acquisitions. Use of 2.5 mL with no ambulation gave low linear spread (53.1% of vaginal length) and surface contact (61.7%) at 50 min. Using 3.5 mL of gel with ambulation improved linear spread (84.5%) and surface contact (85.9%) of the gel in the same time interval without significant leakage. Most linear spreading took place in the first 5 min after insertion, although lateral spreading continued to increase with time especially when ambulation took place. Leakage and gel was not a significant problem at either volume.     

Desired qualities and hypothetical contextual use of vaginal microbicides in a diverse sample of US women

Background

Vaginal microbicides represent an important emerging class of antiinfectives. To guide research and development, we conducted a survey to determine interest in desired qualities of and intended use of microbicides within the current milieu of contraceptive options.

Study Design

Women completed an anonymous survey while waiting for health care clinic appointments in Portland, OR, and Atlanta, GA, and in one public area (Atlanta).

Results

Four hundred one women completed the survey. Subjects had a mean age of 25.6 (SD=7.4), parity of 1.5 (SD=1.6) and 47.7% were non-Caucasian. Respondents showed moderate interest in noncontraceptive anti-HIV gel-based microbicides (mean, 53.8; SD, 39.6; n=362) and significantly stronger interest in contraceptive anti-HIV microbicides (mean, 89.4 mm; SD, 20.7; n=363; p<.001). The qualities of HIV, pregnancy and sexually transmitted infection (STI) prevention were the highest priorities of the largest percentage (40%) of respondents. Half (49.6%) of respondents reported they would use another form of protection in conjunction with a contraceptive anti-HIV microbicide.

Conclusions

A diverse sample of women reported substantial interest in vaginal microbicides capable of preventing HIV and pregnancy, and a smaller high-risk subgroup was interested in noncontraceptive anti-HIV microbicides. Most women would prefer a product capable of preventing HIV, pregnancy and STIs. Almost half of respondents would use vaginal microbicides as part of a dual method.     

A phase I comparative postcoital testing study of three concentrations of C31G

BACKGROUND: C31G is a broad-spectrum antibacterial agent that shows contraceptive properties in vitro. This postcoital testing study evaluated the ability of three C31G concentrations, 0.5%, 1.0% and 1.7%, administered as a 3.5-mL dose of a vaginal gel to prevent sperm from entering mid-cycle cervical mucus. Irritation of the genitalia and acceptability were also assessed. METHOD: At baseline, a mid-cycle cervical mucus test and a postcoital test were performed within 24 h of each other without use of any study products to establish normal mid-cycle cervical mucus and sperm penetration. Subjects then completed up to three test cycles using one of the three concentrations of study product during intercourse. RESULTS: Twenty-two of the 61 women enrolled completed a baseline cycle and at least one test cycle. An average of 14.6 progressively motile sperm per high power field was seen at baseline. This was reduced to 0.3 after use of 0.5% C31G, 0.5 after use of 1.0% C31G, and 0.4 after use of 1.7% C31G. There was no significant difference between test products (p >/= 1.000) but each test product was significantly different from baseline (p < 0.002). Very little genital irritation was observed. There were more reports of leakage and messiness with increasing C31G concentration. CONCLUSION: This study suggests that all three concentrations of C31G are likely to give reasonable results in a contraceptive effectiveness trial. Based on the results of this and other trials, the 1.0% concentration has been selected for further development, including Phase III trials of contraceptive effectiveness.     

Good intentions: risk factors for unintended pregnancies in the US cohort of a microbicide trial

Background

The study was conducted to assess socio-behavioral and biological factors associated with unplanned pregnancy in the US cohort of a microbicide trial.

Study Design

We conducted a mixed-method, nested case-control study of risk factors for pregnancy within the US cohort of the microbicide trial HPTN 035. We developed an instrument to assess attitudes and beliefs about fertility control/contraceptive utilization among 122 women. Cases were HPTN 035 participants who became pregnant while enrolled, matched by time on study 1:4 with controls. Univariable and multivariable analysis were performed with pregnancy as the outcome of interest.

Results

Contraceptive method change during the trial was associated with unplanned pregnancy (OR=1.76). Participant desire/partners' desire for future children (OR=4.95) and young age (OR=0.88 annually above age 19 years) were independently associated with unintended pregnancy.

Conclusion

Within a trial that enrolls heterosexually active women, there may be ways to identify those at highest risk of becoming pregnant a priori.     

Reddy female condom: functional performance of a 90-mm shaft length in two clinical studies

Background

We report on the functional performance, safety and acceptability of the 90-mm Reddy female condom in two clinical trials, one in Los Angeles, CA, and one in Pune, Maharashtra, India.

Study Design

Both studies used a Phase I, crossover design involving 25 couples. Each couple used three condoms of each of two shaft lengths: in Los Angeles, shaft lengths of 150 and 90 mm were used; in Pune, shaft lengths of 120 and 90 mm were used. This paper focuses on the 90-mm condom since it is commercially available. The primary endpoint of each study was invagination, defined as the outer frame of the condom being pushed into the vagina during intercourse. Secondary functionality endpoints included nonclinical breakage, clinical breakage, penile misdirection and complete slippage.

Results

Invagination occurred in 26.9% of uses in Los Angeles vs. 6.8% of uses in Pune. Penile misdirection and complete slippage were reported only in Pune during 4.0% and 9.5% of uses, respectively. There were two clinical breaks in Pune and none in Los Angeles. Total clinical failure was 26.9% in Los Angeles and 23.0% in Pune.

Conclusions

Two clinical studies of the 90-mm Reddy female condom suggest that its functional performance is inferior to other female condoms.     

Reproductive health counseling at pregnancy testing: a pilot study

OBJECTIVES: To pilot brief reproductive health counseling for women obtaining pregnancy testing in a managed-care setting who did not desire pregnancy. METHODS: Women received counseling, access to contraception and a booster call at 2 weeks. Changes in contraceptive behavior were evaluated. RESULTS: Of 85 women who completed counseling, 58 (68%) completed follow-up. Participants reported that counseling was useful at baseline (94%) and follow-up (83%). The staff found the intervention important (100%) and implementation feasible (100%). Forty-one percent of participants improved their use of contraception (from no use or from less effective use to more effective use). Twenty-nine percent continued highly effective use and 9% recessed from highly effective use. Of 22 participants with risk of sexually transmitted disease, 3 (14%) began using condoms consistently, while 1 (5%) continued using condoms consistently. CONCLUSIONS: Counseling at pregnancy testing was well accepted by the staff and participants. Observed behavioral changes suggest that this intervention may be effective in increasing effective use of contraception.     

A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled safety and acceptability study of two Invisible Condom® formulations in women from Cameroon

Background

The objectives of this clinical trial were to evaluate the safety, tolerance and acceptability of two gel formulations of the Invisible Condom®: (i) the polymer alone and (ii) the polymer-containing sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS) compared to placebo when applied intravaginally with our unique applicator in sexually abstinent and active woman volunteers.

Study Design

A randomized, doubled-blind, placebo-controlled study in healthy women from Yaoundé, Cameroon. Two hundred sixty women were randomized into three gel arms: (a) gel alone, (b) gel plus SLS and (c) placebo gel. Thirty-seven sexually abstinent women applied gel intravaginally once a day for 14 days, while 75, 74 and 74 sexually active women applied gel intravaginally once, twice or three times daily for 14 days, respectively.

Results

Retention rate was high at 85% and 221 women applied the two products and the placebo for a total of 6005 times. Nugent score, H₂O₂-producing lactobacilli and vaginal pH were stable throughout the study and were not affected by the study products. Colposcopy showed neither genital ulceration nor mucosal lesions. No study product-related serious adverse events were reported. The majority of reported adverse events were mild or moderate and largely similar in all 3 arms. Satisfaction questionnaire showed that the gel formulations and applicator were generally comfortable and acceptable.

Conclusion

The Invisible Condom® formulations and applicator were found to be comfortable, well tolerated and acceptable when applied intravaginally once, twice or thrice daily for 14 days. Thus, expanded safety evaluation is warranted.     

Postcoital testing after the use of a bio-adhesive acid buffering gel (ACIDFORM) and a 2% nonoxynol-9 product

ACIDFORM is a gel already shown to be safe in vaginal use during six consecutive days through colposcopic observation. A randomized, blinded, crossover study was carried out to compare the spermicidal effect of ACIDFORM to that of a commercial 2% nonoxynol-9 (N-9) product. Twenty sexually active, sterilized women, aged 19–45 years, with regular cycles, normal gynecological exam, no previous sexually transmitted infection (STI) and stable partner willing to undergo four postcoital tests (PCTs) at midcycle during four different menstrual cycles, were enrolled in the study. Known allergy to N-9 or ACIDFORM, oligospermic partner, chronic diseases, use of hormones, previous treatment for STI or presence of STI at screening tests were criteria for exclusion. ACIDFORM or N-9 product administered 0–30 min precoitus or ACIDFORM given 8–10 h precoitus significantly reduced the mean number of progressively motile sperm compared to control cycles (0.19, 0.07, 0.75 vs. 17.94, respectively, p<.05, Wilcoxon test). All treated cycles had five or fewer progressively motile sperm in midcycle cervical mucus, confirming in vivo the spermicidal effect of ACIDFORM previously observed in vitro and in animal models.     

Phase I safety study of Praneem polyherbal vaginal tablet use among HIV-uninfected women in Pune, India

Praneem polyherbal formulations containing purified extracts of Azadirachta indica (neem tree) have shown activity against HIV and sexually transmitted disease pathogens in studies in vitro. The product also has contraceptive properties. This has prompted its development as a possible microbicide. We evaluated the safety of Praneem polyherbal tablet use among HIV-uninfected women. Twenty eligible women were enrolled in a Phase I open-label study requiring 14 days of consecutive intravaginal use of Praneem polyherbal tablets. Nine (45%) participants experienced 17 episodes of genital irritation. Transient genital itching was reported by eight (40%) participants, burning micturation by two (10%) and lower abdominal pain, genital burning and intermenstrual spotting by one (5%) each. On colposcopy, petechial haemorrhage was observed in two participants, one on day 7 and the other on day 14, and both were resolved without any treatment. There were no serious adverse events. Praneem polyherbal tablets were found to be safe for once daily intravaginal use for 14 consecutive days in sexually active HIV-uninfected women and a Phase II study may be taken up as a priority.     

Evaluation of safety and immunogenicity of HNVAC,an MDCK-based H1N1 pandemic influenza vaccine,in Phase I single centre and Phase II/III multi-centre,double-blind,randomized, placebo-controlled,parallel assignment studies

The clinical evaluation of the MDCK-based H1N1 pandemic influenza vaccine HNVAC in adults aged 18–65 years is reported. In the Phase I randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, single-centre study, 160 subjects were parallelly assigned 3:1 to vaccine:placebo groups (n = 60:20) with both the aluminium hydroxide adjuvanted and non-adjuvanted vaccine formulations. A single dose of both the formulations containing 15 μg of haemagglutinin protein showed minimal adverse reactions, the most common of which were pain at injection site (11.67%) and fever (10.00%). Both formulations produced 74–81% seroprotection (SRP: titre of ≥40), 67–70% seroconversion (SRC: four-fold increase in titres between days 0 and 21), and a four-fold increase in geometric mean titres (GMT). Aluminium hydroxide did not have a significant effect either on immunogenicity or on reactogenicity. Nevertheless, based on its recognized positive effects on the stability and immunogenicity of many vaccines, and its marginal benefit in both pre-clinical and Phase I studies of HNVAC, alum adjuvanted HNVAC was further tested in a staggered Phase II/III randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, multi-centre study of 200 and 195 subjects, respectively, parallelly assigned 4:1 to adjuvanted vaccine and placebo groups. In these studies, the most common adverse reactions were pain at injection site (6.88% and 5.77% in Stage 1 and Stage 2, respectively) and fever (7.50% and 7.05%, respectively), and a single dose resulted in 87–90% SRP, 85–86% SRC, and a nearly six-fold increase in GMT, meeting or exceeding licensing criteria. It is concluded that HNVAC is safe and immunogenic to adults of 18–65 years.     

Vaginal safety after use of a bioadhesive, acid-buffering, microbicidal contraceptive gel (ACIDFORM) and a 2% nonoxynol-9 product

BACKGROUND: ACIDFORM is a microbicidal and contraceptive candidate with strong buffering capacity. METHODS: This was a Phase I blinded, randomized and crossover clinical study on two products, ACIDFORM and a commercial nonoxynol-9 (N-9) product (2%), evaluating their vaginal safety in 20 couples aged between 19 and 45 years. The women had regular menses, underwent previous tubal ligation, were not breast-feeding, had no vaginal sign and symptom and were in a stable partnership; both partners had no previous STI. Colposcopy, vaginal microbiology, inflammation markers and subject complaints were studied after coitus. Women were randomly assigned sequentially to receive ACIDFORM 0-30 min (0-30 min before intercourse), ACIDFORM 8-10 h (8-10 h before intercourse) or N-9 0-30 min after a control cycle. RESULTS: Mild/moderate vulvar irritation was observed in five postcoital test colposcopies, burning and pruritus were reported in six treated cycles and non-irritation-related symptoms were found in five cycles with different treatments. No difference in vaginal pH, Nugent scores, H2O2-producing lactobacillus or leukocytes and interleukin 6 in the cervicovaginal lavage was found between the treatment and control cycles. CONCLUSIONS: ACIDFORM appears to be safe for clinical use once a day. There is a potential spermicidal-microbicidal role for ACIDFORM as a vaginal flora helper or as a vehicle for products, except N-9.