Effectiveness of basic clinical skills training programmes: a cross-sectional comparison of four medical schools

OBJECTIVE: Training in physical diagnostic skills is an important part of undergraduate medical education. The objective of this study was to study the outcome of skills training at four medical schools. CONTEXT: At the time of the study, three schools had a traditional lecture-based curriculum and one school had a problem-based learning curriculum with a longitudinal skills training programme. All schools offer extended exposure to clerkships. METHOD: A cross-sectional study in four medical schools was performed, using a written test of skills that has good correlation with actual student performance. The scores attained from four student groups were compared within and between the four medical schools. A total of 859 volunteer students from the later four years at each medical school participated in the study. RESULTS: The mean scores in the traditional medical schools increased with the start of skill training and the hands-on experience offered during the clerkships. Students from the school with the longitudinal skills training programme and the problem-based learning approach had significantly higher mean scores at the start of the clerkships, and maintained their lead in the subsequent clinical years. CONCLUSIONS: Longitudinal skills training seems to offer the students a superior preparation for clerkships as well as influencing the students' learning abilities during the clerkships. The effect of the problem-based learning approach, also related to the innovative philosophy of the curriculum, could not be accounted for.     

UK consensus statement on the content of communication curricula in undergraduate medical education

Context The teaching and assessment of clinical communication have become central components of undergraduate medical education in the UK. This paper recommends the key content for an undergraduate communication curriculum. Designed by UK educationalists with UK schools in mind, the recommendations are equally applicable to communication curricula throughout the world. Objectives This paper is intended to assist curriculum planners in the design, implementation and review of medical communication curricula. The document will also be useful in the education of other health care professionals. Designed for undergraduate education, the consensus statement also provides a baseline for further professional development. Methods The consensus statement, based on strong theoretical and research evidence, was developed by an iterative process of discussion between communication skills leads from all 33 UK medical schools conducted under the auspices of the UK Council of Clinical Communication Skills Teaching in Undergraduate Medical Education. Discussion How this framework is used will inevitably be at the discretion of each medical school and its implementation will be determined by different course designs. Although we believe students should be exposed to all the areas described, it would be impractical to set inflexible competency levels as these may be attained at different stages which are highly school‐dependent. However, the framework will enable all schools to consider where different elements are addressed, where gaps exist and how to generate novel combinations of domains within the communication curriculum. It is hoped that this consensus statement will support the development and integration of teaching, learning and assessment of clinical communication.     

Can general internal medicine be taught in general practice? An evaluation of the University College London model

There is national and international interest in increasing the community-based component of undergraduate medical education, but more research is needed on its potential, practicability and effectiveness. The objective of the study was to examine the feasibility and efficacy of general practitioners teaching basic clinical skills to first year clinical medical students in the community. The structure and methods of evaluation of the programme are described. Evaluation tools included semi-structured interviews of general practitioner tutors; student questionnaires; assessment of student performance; and costs of the programme. The great majority of the students found the programme enjoyable (81 out of 81, 100%) and educational (79 out of 81, 97%). Students' perfomance in the end of rotation Objective Structured Clinical Examination suggested that clinical skills are acquired at least as well in the community as in hospital. Tutors identified the personal benefits of this teaching as development of their own clinical skills and the stimulation of teaching. The programme has been successfully expanded from 24 students to 230 students annually and has demonstrated that community-based teaching can usefully contribute to undergraduate medical education in the area of clinical skills teaching. Key practical issues for schools contemplating similar initiatives are presented.     

Assessing the development of communication skills in undergraduate medical students

CONTEXT: The teaching of clinical communication skills' teaching has become an important part of medical school curricula. Many undergraduate medical courses include communication skills training at various points in their curriculum. Very few reports have been published on the development of communication skills over the duration of a medical undergraduate training. AIMS: To determine the change in communication skills between early and mid-stages of the students' 5-year curriculum, and to investigate the predictive and theoretical significance of knowledge and understanding of communication skills in relation to observed performance. PARTICIPANTS: Students entering as the first cohort to the new medical curriculum at Liverpool Medical School (n=207). Nine students withdrew leaving 198 students who completed two summative assessments in June 1997 (level 1) and November 1998 (level 2). STATISTICAL ANALYSIS: Repeated measures multivariate ANOVAS were applied to the main study data to detect any change in performance between levels 1 and 2. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: An improvement in communication skills was found in medical students over 17 months of their undergraduate teaching: that is from the level 1 to the level 2 assessment. Knowledge and understanding of communication skills at initial assessment did not show the predicted association with performance at level 2.     

Teaching sexual history taking to medical students and examining it: experience in one medical school and a national survey

OBJECTIVES: To assess the feasibility and acceptability of training and examining medical students in taking a sexual history and to compare practice with other medical schools in the UK. DESIGN: A training programme involving group work, role play and clinical attachments was developed and applied to 131 students at the University of Bristol Medical School. They then underwent an objective structured clinical assessment using simulated patients. The practice of other medical schools was surveyed by postal questionnaire. RESULT: The students felt that the examination was a good test of their knowledge and skills. One student failed. Sexual history taking is taught in 17 of 22 medical schools but examined in only six. CONCLUSION: Both teaching and examining of sexual history taking skills are possible and are likely to occur increasingly in UK medical schools.     

Teaching patient wellness to first-year medical students: the impact on future ability to perform the history of present illness

OBJECTIVES: Curriculum innovations to improve clinical skills have been implemented at many American medical schools. A current curricular change at the University of Connecticut School of Medicine involves teaching wellness to students in the first year rather than the more traditional focus on disease processes. It is unknown, however, if focusing on wellness detracts from students' future ability to perform the history of present illness (HPI) which requires students to focus on disease processes. DESIGN: The current study examined this issue by comparing two cohorts' clinical skills (n=156), with one class participating in a traditional curriculum during their first year and the other in a revised curriculum teaching wellness during the first year. Each class was evaluated at the beginning of their second year to determine their level of clinical competence. SETTING: University of Connecticut School of Medicine SUBJECTS: Second-year medical students. RESULTS: Analyses suggested that teaching wellness did not detract from future ability to perform an HPI, and in fact students taught wellness had significantly higher history-taking scores. CONCLUSIONS: Curricular innovations which stress wellness and prevention early in medical education do not detract from and may enhance students' ability to perform the history of present illness later during medical training.     

Humanizing medicine: a special study module

As medical schools begin to implement their new curricula under the guidance of Tomorrow's Doctors, the authors wish to raise some discussion on the form and content of the special study module (SSM) component. In order to do this they put forward in this paper proposals for an SSM in Medicine and Literature. This course has been designed jointly and will be run concurrently in three Scottish medical schools: Glasgow, Aberdeen and Dundee. Arguments for the course's acceptability to faculties of medicine and to students are discussed and its inclusion in the curriculum in terms of its educational impact, skills training, effect on personal development and broadening of the student's perspective are justified. The course structure, content and assessment procedures are described and a reading list proposed. The General Medical Council points out that SSMs should be seen as opportunities for innovation and this course demands a different educational approach from the standard objectives-led approach of most medical education. A process-led model is more appropriate as it stresses the way that students develop while taking the course rather than the end point reached at its finish.     

Clinical skills assessment with standardized patients

Previous projects (Combell I & II) to assess clinical skills were conducted in medical schools in Catalonia, in order to introduce a model of such an assessment using standardized patients (SP). The aim of this study (Combell III) was to measure selected characteristics of our model. Seventy-three medical students in the final year at the Bellvitge teaching unit of the University of Barcelona participated in a clinical skills assessment (CSA) project that used 10 SP cases. The mean group scores for the four components of clinical skills for each day of testing were studied, and ratings for each student in the 10 sequential encounters were checked. The study also compared the clinical skills scores with their academic grades. The total case mean score (mean score of history-taking, physical examination and patient notes scores) was 51.9%, and the mean score for communication skills was 63.6%. The clinical skills scores over the 8 testing days showed no day-to-day differences. The study did not find differences among the sequential encounters for each student (training effect). There was a lack of correlation between clinical skill scores and academic grades. The project demonstrated the feasibility of the method for assessing clinical skills, confirmed its reliability, and showed that there is no correlation between scores with this method and academic examinations that mainly reflect knowledge.     

Meeting the challenge of prescribing and administering medicines safely: structured teaching and assessment for final year medical students

OBJECTIVES: To promote safe prescribing and administration of medicines in the pre-registration house officer (PRHO) year through a programme of structured teaching and assessment for final year medical students. DESIGN: Forty final year medical students from two medical schools were randomly allocated either to participate in a pharmacist facilitated teaching session or to receive no additional teaching. Teaching comprised five practical exercises covering seven skills through which students rotated in small groups. One month later, a random sample of 16 taught and 16 non-taught students participated in a nine-station objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) to assess the impact of the teaching. SETTING: Manchester School of Medicine (MSM), and Kings College School of Medicine and Dentistry (KCSMD). PARTICIPANTS: Final year medical student volunteers. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The need for teaching as indicated by student prior experience; questionnaire rating of student acceptability of teaching and assessment; self-rating of student confidence post-assessment, and student performance assessed by OSCE. RESULTS: The study demonstrated that the taught group achieved higher scores in eight OSCE stations. Four of these were statistically significant (P < or= 0.005). Taught students felt more confident performing the skills on five stations. From 0 to 47.5% students had prior experience of the skills taught. The post-teaching questionnaire evaluated exercises positively on several criteria, including provision of new information and relevance to future work. CONCLUSIONS: Structured teaching provided an effective and acceptable method of teaching the medicines management skills needed in the PRHO year. The structured approach complemented variable precourse clinical experience.     

Day surgery: teaching the next generation

The advent of day surgery presents new opportunities and challenges for medical education. The opportunity to see patients pre-operatively and follow them through surgery to discharge on the same day is unique to day surgery. However, with rare exceptions, the development of educational programmes in ambulatory surgical settings is still largely at a rudimentary level. An undergraduate pilot programme was conducted at the University of Adelaide to explore the practicalities, acceptance and educational value of a day surgery programme for final-year medical students. The programme had three components: day surgery patient follow through, practical procedure tutorials and problem-based learning tutorials. It incorporated assessment of practical skills and theoretical knowledge with the use of log books and clinical and practical simulations as important elements in the assessment process. The pilot programme was accepted by all stakeholders and students' perceived significant gains in knowledge and skills. This programme may provide a teaching model that could be adapted for use in other medical schools.     

Clinical electives: setting up an overseas programme in a new medical school

Summary. This paper describes the methods used to establish an overseas elective programme in a new medical school, the objectives and the perceived results. The aims and objectives of the programme are listed. The students who participated in the programme were from the charter class and had completed the second year of a 3-year clinical programme. The methods used to establish the programme are described. Destinations were organized through academic staff contacts. Systematic preparation of students was an important feature of the programme. Comparative costs and methods of financing the programme are described in detail. The results of the programme are analysed together with the form of assessment used and feedback from both the host institution and the student. The importance of monitoring progress while students are abroad is described. The discussion focuses on the benefits derived from an overseas elective programme for both students and teachers. The advantages and disadvantages of different destinations are compared. Further refinements to the programme are discussed including alternative methods of obtaining funding. The importance of developing reciprocal arrangements with other medical schools and institutions throughout the world is emphasized.     

The teaching of medicine at the University Centre for Health Sciences Yaounde,Cameroon: its concordance with the Edinburgh Declaration on Medical Education

Summary. The University Centre for Health Sciences (UCHS) or as it is referred to in French ‘Centre Universitaire des Sciences de la Santé’ (CUSS), became functional in 1969 with the enrolment of the first group of students. The objective of this training programme was to produce a scientifically sound, multipurpose doctor who would be fully operational in a rural setting with minimal equipment and supplies ( Monekosso 1970, 1972 ). The graduate had to be able to adapt readily to new situations and improvise whenever possible, calling for a high degree of competence and initiative. The training strategies adopted by UCHS in 1969 which met this requirement were later found to be in close concordance with the tenets of the World Conference on Medical Education held in Edinburgh in 1988, the Edinburgh Declaration. While some of the terminology may not have been worked out at the time, the programme developed embraced some new concepts hitherto untried or undeveloped:

• — the problem-solving approach in the first to the sixth year;
• — an integrated teaching approach during the first to sixth year of medical training;
• — an integrated medicine internship in district hospitals in the sixth year;
• — a community-based training approach throughout the training;
• — team training of three different health professionals;
• — competency-based training;
• — health services linked research;
• — health services linked training ( Monekosso & Quenum 1978 ).

The concordance of this programme to the Edinburgh Declaration is of great interest in realizing the World Federation for Medical Education programme and implementing the Edinburgh Declaration. The involvement of the three innovative medical schools in the planning stage of the curriculum explains this concordance.     

The essential role of the student in curriculum planning

Medical school curricula are planned, written and organized by academic and clinical staff within medical schools. While these medical educators may well be experts in their given field, they lack first-hand experience of what it is to be a medical student in 1995. For a medical curriculum to be an effective means of learning for today's students, it must be written with a knowledge of their priorities, needs and abilities. The way in which this can be best achieved is by the inclusion of current students in all stages of designing a new curriculum.
In my second year of medicine at Flinders University, I became involved in planning for the new Graduate Entry curriculum. In the role of student advocate, I have found I am able to offer teaching staff a unique perspective, the student perspective , on various issues.
Students, through experience from their own education, are able to give advice on student resources and facilities and are in a favourable position to judge other aspects of curricula, such as the balance and relevance of course content and assessment. Students need to realize the valuable insight they have to offer their faculties and the way in which this can benefit future students. It is by actively seeking student involvement and using their input, that faculties will be able to create a consumer-friendly curriculum.     

Consistency of teaching in parallel surgical firms: an audit of student experience at one medical school

BACKGROUND: Traditional clinical clerkships have been based on the apprenticeship model of learning, with opportunistic teaching by doctors on presenting patients. Students at King's College School of Medicine, London had expressed concern that they were receiving inequitable experiences in different clerkships. This had become more apparent since the introduction of a school-wide end-of-year skills assessment. We decided to assess the consistency of delivery of the surgical syllabus. METHOD: A multistage questionnaire survey was undertaken with third-year (first clinical year) undergraduate medical students on surgical clerkships. The questionnaire required students to record topics about which they had been taught, and practical skills on which they had been supervised, from the surgical syllabus pertaining at the time. RESULTS: 194 (46.4%) questionnaires were returned. A low level of consistency was reported in the teaching of theoretical topics and practical skills across surgical clerkships in eight different locations. There were substantial differences, both in overall coverage of the syllabus and in the priority given to different topics. There were no overall differences between teaching hospital- and district general hospital-based clerkships. DISCUSSION: Students in so called 'parallel' clerkships did not receive comparable teaching. The traditional opportunistic nature of clinical teaching led, in effect, to individual curricula within each clerkship. The General Medical Council has called for a core curriculum to be delivered across different clinical sites within each medical school. To achieve this, medical schools may need to introduce guidelines to direct teaching in the same way that clinical protocols have been developed to achieve greater standardization in clinical practice.     

The students' view of an innovative undergraduate medical course: the first year at the University of Newcastle,N.S.W.†

An innovative medical course commenced in 1978 in a new medical school at the University of Newcastle. An evaluation of the student response to the first year of this course was carried out. This evaluation aimed to assess how far the students had progressed towards the attainment of the long-term Faculty objectives on which the Newcastle curriculum is based. Students' perceptions of educational innovations were obtained and compared with the Faculty's stated aims. Students felt that they could approach a problem scientifically, in a manner consistent with the Faculty's specified methods. In the area of team work, students had accepted the need for training in team skills as preparation for work after graduation. Students have adapted to the use of objectives, to assessment for competence, and to the marking of one another's papers. These methods had been introduced to facilitate the development of skills necessary for independent and continuing self-education. Patient contact was designated as the greatest strength of the first year. Students expressed concern for patient well-being and the influence of student activities on patients. This indicated that students had progressed some way towards the attainment of the Faculty objective that they should develop an humanitarian approach to patients.     

One year's experience with a clinical skills resource centre

OBJECTIVES: To describe our experience of teaching clinical skills to first-year medical students in a new problem-based curriculum. DESIGN: Prospective evaluation of clinical skills acquisition using objective measures. SETTING: Students were taught in a purpose-designed clinical skills resource centre in weekly structured sessions. SUBJECTS: All 210 first year medical undergraduates in the first year of a new problem-based and clinically oriented course. RESULTS: Student performance in structured objective examinations improved over 1 year. In all but one of nine matched stations, involving history, examination and procedural skills, improvements were significant. Ninety-three per cent thought that the appropriateness of the skills training course to other course elements was 'good' or 'very good'. CONCLUSIONS: First-year medical students can learn a wide range of clinical skills. Integrated teaching of clinical skills improves satisfaction with undergraduate studies.     

Short-term outcomes and long-term impact of a programme in medical education for medical students

Objectives  There is growing appreciation of the value of early preparation of future medical educators. Staff development programmes, conferences and workshops pertaining to the training of educators may be crucial to the pursuit of a school's larger educational mission to educate students, doctors and scholars and to provide comprehensive knowledge, research, patient care and service. This study examined the efficacy of a 1-week educational intervention aimed at preparing medical students to become effective doctor educators by building skills early in their careers. The study asked whether participation in a 5-day teacher training programme led to increased knowledge of instructional methods, more favourable attitudes towards teaching, and the integration of structured instructional design methods in a student-developed teaching project.
Methods  A mixed methods research design was employed with quantitative data captured through pre- and post-test inventories, qualitative components captured through written comments, and a 2-year post-intervention survey. Quantitative analyses included pre-/post-intervention repeated measures with calculated effect sizes. Qualitative analysis was conducted using constant comparative methods.
Results  Subjects demonstrated improved content knowledge and more positive attitudes towards motivation, teaching confidence, teacher roles, varied pedagogy, and use of assessment, instructional planning, and evaluation. Subjects were able to incorporate the programme's teaching theory and methods into their teaching projects and assessment of peers' and others' teaching in their own institutions 2 years post-training.
Conclusions  This study demonstrates that a well-designed programme for teacher preparation can be pedagogically effective for training medical students to become better educators and that this learning can be incorporated into long-term practice.     

Integration of the surgical specialties into an innovative undergraduate curriculum

Summary. A dilemma exists concerning the most effective way to incorporate surgical specialty teaching into an innovative undergraduate curriculum. Should the specialties form part of the core curriculum or should they be available as electives? The aim of this study is to describe an educationally sound and time-effective way to give all students an exposure to the surgical specialties while maintaining the philosophy of an innovative curriculum. The SCORPIO method was used, on a trial basis, in 1992 to teach cardiothoracic surgery, neurosurgery, plastic surgery and urology to fourth-year medical students at a university teaching hospital. The teaching was evaluated by comparing group pretest performance with a posttest assessment given one month after each of the teaching sessions. Student perceptions were assessed by a questionnaire and a time analysis was carried out comparing SCORPIO with the traditional ward tutorial system. Students completed the sequence pretest, teaching and posttest on 169 occasions. Group performance increased from a pretest mean 28% (SD16) to a posttest mean 44% (SD13) P<0.0001 . Student acceptance was favourable, with high ratings given to the structured, problem-based style of teaching. The time to run the programme was one-eighth that to teach by the ward tutorial system. This teaching model is a practical way to incorporate the surgical specialties into the core curriculum of a school moving towards a student centred, problem-based, integrated curriculum.     

Basic sciences in problem-based learning and conventional curricula: students' attitudes

The purpose of this study was to compare the attitudes toward basic sciences of students in a preclinical problem-based curriculum and a conventional lecture-based curriculum at the end of their second year of medical school. The results showed that the PBL class had more positive attitudes toward basic sciences than students in the conventional class. These results may reflect a learning environment where students meet many scientist role models as teachers and where basic science is learnt in the context of clinical problems.     

An evaluation of the undergraduate teaching programme in ophthalmology in Sri Lanka and Malaysia

The knowledge and clinical and minor surgical skills acquired by 257 medical students in three universities in Sri Lanka and Malaysia were assessed by a questionnaire after they had completed their training period in ophthalmology. This study showed that many medical students graduating from these universities lacked the basic clinical and minor surgical skills essential for a doctor practising in a community in south-east Asia. The responses also indicated that teaching by consultants in all three universities was inadequate and due to these inadequacies the students requested that the duration of their training period be doubled. Ophthalmology is an important component of clinical practice and proper education in this subject is important. An urgent revision of the aims and objectives of the curriculum in ophthalmology is essential to place greater emphasis on this important and much neglected subject, for which very little curricular time is allotted.