Arthroscopic rotator cuff repair using a single-row of triple-loaded suture anchors with a modified suture configuration

Achieving an adequate restoration of the muscle–tendon–bone unit and the anatomical footprint is essential for a successful outcome in open and arthroscopic rotator cuff repair. The described suture grasping technique using triple-loaded suture anchors might combine high initial fixation strength with good footprint coverage. It describes two mattress’ stitches medial at the articular margin of the tendon. Additionally, a third mattress stitch is performed laterally to increase footprint contact and avoid dog-ear deformity. The triple-mattress repair is easy to perform and might be a good alternative in either arthroscopic or open rotator cuff repair.     

A Novel Transosseous Button Technique for Rotator Cuff Repair

In an attempt to maximize stability by improving the lateral footprint compression of our repair in rotator cuff tears, we have been using a rotator cuff button (Arthrex, Naples, FL) passed through a transosseous tunnel as an anchor for our transosseous sutures. Our new innovation is to pass a rotator cuff button fully loaded with 4 strands around the central post, with 2 leading strands and 2 trailing strands on either end, through our transosseous tunnel. In this way, we can use the 4 central strands through our tunnel to obtain 2 good mattress sutures as a primary repair and the peripheral 4 strands passed around the lateral humerus as over sew mattress sutures to obtain good compression of the lateral tendon and so improve the footprint area. A double row equivalent is achieved. This technique has a good primary hold in the form of a device with proven history and avoids multiple anchors in the lateral humerus. Because it uses only a single fixation device, it is also significantly more economical. Theoretical risks to the axillary nerve or with osteoporosis have not been seen in practice. Tensioning the repair with suture passage through transosseous tunnels is readily achieved.     

The effect of arthroscopic suture passing instruments on rotator cuff damage and repair strength

There are a variety of arthroscopic devices used to pass sutures through the rotator cuff for its repair. Because they vary in size and shape, it is possible that they could damage the cuff and affect the integrity of the repair. We chose four devices for assessment--SutureLasso (Arthrex, Naples, FL), straight BirdBeak (Arthrex, Naples, FL), Viper (Arthrex, Naples, FL), and a #7 tapered Mayo needle--and performed cuff reattachments in four paired shoulders using suture anchors. These repairs were cycled and tested to failure. The SutureLasso and Mayo needle repairs failed at approximately 285 N whereas the BirdBeak and Viper failed during cycling at 150 N. It appears that the devices, which made the bigger holes in the cuff, can compromise the integrity of the repair.     

Arthroscopic Fixation of Bursal-Sided Rotator Cuff Tears

Subacromial decompression and debridement of partial-thickness bursal-sided rotator cuff tears are often reported with a high rate of unsatisfactory outcomes. We describe an arthroscopic procedure to repair partial-thickness bursal-sided rotator cuff tears without converting to a full-thickness tear in patients with a normal articular-sided rotator cuff and an A0B2 or A0B3 pattern of tear (minimum thickness of 25% to 75%). The articular side of the rotator cuff experiences greater tension than the bursal side of the cuff. As such, by leaving the articular footprint intact, we accomplish 3 goals: the intact articular fibers act as an internal splint to protect the bursal-sided repair, a wide and anatomic footprint is recreated, and we are able to minimize any length-tension mismatch because the tissue is not excessively lateralized with repair. After bursectomy and acromioplasty, the frayed edges of the bursal flap are gently debrided and the tuberosity is excoriated to bleeding bone. One or two bioabsorbable anchors are placed, and both sutures are placed through the full thickness of the rotator cuff (one anterior and one posterior) by use of a percutaneous suture lasso in this manner: (1) the lasso is passed through the full thickness of the cuff, and the nitinol wire is shuttled out of a single cannula along with the more medial of the suture limbs; (2) the nitinol wire is then pulled back out of the percutaneous portal along with the suture limb, with the suture being passed through the full thickness of the cuff; and (3) the procedure is repeated for the posterior limb of the suture after a lasso is again passed through the full thickness of the rotator cuff in a more posterior position. This subset of patients is treated with an aggressive rehabilitation protocol because the intact articular rotator cuff fibers act as an internal splint to protect the bursal repair.     

Arthroscopic Placement of a Modified Mason-Allen Stitch

Recent studies have shown all-arthroscopic rotator cuff repairs to have comparable clinical results to mini-open or open repairs. Previous drawbacks to arthroscopic repair have included not being able to place a modified Mason-Allen stitch with a suture anchor technique. We present a technique using the Arthrex Scorpion device (Arthrex, Naples, FL) to place a modified Mason-Allen stitch arthroscopically via a double-loaded FiberWire metal suture anchor (Arthrex). The Scorpion suture passer places a stitch from inferior to superior through the torn rotator cuff. The suture is grabbed and reloaded into the Scorpion device. The device is then turned upside down, and a horizontal stitch is placed from superior to inferior. The stitch is retrieved again and reloaded a third time. The last pass is placed so that the final stitch passes anterior to the inferior suture but beyond the previously placed horizontal mattress stitch. This effectively reproduces the described biomechanically superior modified Mason-Allen stitch.     

Part I: Footprint contact characteristics for a transosseous-equivalent rotator cuff repair technique compared with a double-row repair technique

Rotator cuff repair via transosseous tunnels can improve footprint contact area and pressure when compared with suture anchor techniques. A double-row technique has been used clinically to improve footprint coverage by a repaired tendon. We hypothesized that a transosseous-equivalent rotator cuff repair via tendon suture bridges would demonstrate improved pressurized contact between the tendon and tuberosity when compared with a double-row technique. In 6 fresh-frozen human shoulders, a transosseous-equivalent rotator cuff repair was performed: a suture limb from each of 2 medial anchors was bridged over the tendon and fixed laterally with an interference screw (4 suture bridges). In 6 of the contralateral specimens, two types of repair were performed randomly in each specimen: (1) a double-row repair and (2) a transosseous-equivalent repair with a single screw (2 suture bridges). For all repairs, pressure-sensitive film was placed at the tendon-footprint interface, and software was used to obtain measurements. The mean pressurized contact area between the tendon and insertion was significantly greater for the 4-suture bridge technique (124.2 +/- 16.3 mm2, 77.6% footprint) compared with both the double-row (63.3 +/- 28.5 mm2, 39.6% footprint) and 2-suture bridge (99.7 +/- 22.0 mm2, 62.3% footprint) techniques (P < .05). The mean interface pressure exerted over the footprint by the tendon was greater for the 4-suture bridge technique (0.27 +/- 0.04 MPa) than for the double-row technique (0.19 +/- 0.01 MPa) (P = .002). The transosseous-equivalent rotator cuff repair technique can improve pressurized contact area and mean pressure between the tendon and footprint when compared with a double-row technique. A transosseous-equivalent technique, using suture bridges, may help optimize the healing biology at a repaired rotator cuff insertion.     

Editorial Commentary: Delaminated Rotator Cuff Tears—Does the Suture Pattern Matter?

The configuration of the suture placed in the rotator cuff tendon in the presence of a delaminated tear may be an important determinant of outcome. Delaminated rotator cuff tears are difficult to repair and probably occur more frequently than appreciated. The goal of anatomic reduction of the tendon to the footprint, attaching the deep tendon layer to the medial aspect of the footprint while approximating the superior tendon layer to the more lateral aspect of the footprint, may best result in complete healing.     

Modified Mason-Allen Suture Bridge Technique: A New Suture Bridge Technique with Improved Tissue Holding by the Modified Mason-Allen Stitch

We present a new method of suture bridge technique for medial row fixation using a modified Mason-Allen stitch instead of a horizontal mattress. Medial row configuration of the technique is composed of the simple stitch limb and the modified Mason-Allen stitch limb. The limbs are passed through the tendon by a shuttle relay. The simple stitch limb passes the cuff once and the modified Mason-Allen stitch limb passes three times which creates a rip stop that prevents tendon pull-out. In addition, the Mason-Allen suture bridge configuration is basically a knotless technique which has an advantage of reducing a possibility of strangulation of the rotator cuff tendon, impingement or irritation that may be caused by knot.     

Arthroscopic rotator interval repair and anterior portal closure: An alternative technique

The rotator interval capsule has been implicated as an important restraint to shoulder subluxation, and plays an important role in shoulder stability. Anterior portal placement during arthroscopic shoulder instability repair violates the interval capsule and compromises the biomechanical integrity of the rotator interval. The following is a technique for interval capsule repair. Using an 18-gauge needle via the anterior portal, a monofilament suture is passed through the capsule just above the subscapularis. A Penetrator suture retriever (Arthrex, Naples, FL) is passed high into the capsule just anterior to the biceps. The intra-articular end of the suture is then removed from the superior aspect of the interval capsule. The suture limbs are then tied into the portal onto the anterior capsule. The technique is advantageous because it may be repeated as needed until appropriate interval plication has been achieved. Furthermore, it does not require an interval portal through which to pass the suture. It appears to be a safe, effective, and reproducible technique for arthroscopic rotator interval closure.Arthroscopy: The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery, Vol 18, No 4 (April), 2002: pp 436–439     

“Transosseous-Equivalent” Rotator Cuff Repair Technique

In order to optimize healing biology at a repaired rotator cuff footprint, we have developed a “transosseous-equivalent” rotator cuff repair that can be performed arthroscopically. What the arthroscopically repaired tendon experiences is “equivalent” to what is experienced with a traditional open suture-bridge technique. This repair maximizes the utility of a single-row repair technique by preserving the suture limbs of the medial single-row and bridging these sutures over the footprint insertion with distal-lateral interference screw suture fixation; the medial row uses a mattress suture configuration. The geometry of the construct compresses the tendon, optimizing tendon-to-tuberosity contact dimensions, while providing strength sufficient to withstand immediate postoperative rehabilitation.     

Proper Insertion Angle Is Essential to Prevent Intra-Articular Protrusion of a Knotless Suture Anchor in Shoulder Rotator Cuff Repair

The advent of new arthroscopic devices has led to the development of novel techniques of arthroscopic rotator cuff repair. However, failure to recognize specific technical aspects and improper application of these devices can lead to complications. We report a case of intra-articular protrusion of knotless anchors (PEEK PushLock SP, 4.5 × 18.5 mm; Arthrex, Naples, FL), used in the lateral row of a suture-bridging technique for arthroscopic rotator cuff repair. This case draws attention to the increased length of such devices when compared with traditional suture anchors, the technical aspects of proper device use, the possible patient-related factors such as implant-patient size mismatch, and the importance of additional imaging for the investigation of failure to progress postoperatively.     

Arthroscopically assisted coracoclavicular ligament reconstruction for chronic acromioclavicular joint instability

The treatment of symptomatic chronic acromioclavicular joint dislocations can be challenging. Different surgical procedures have been described in the literature. We present an arthroscopically assisted stabilization using a gracilis tendon transclavicular-transcoracoid loop technique augmented with a Tight-Rope (Arthrex, Naples, FL, USA). In contrast to the classic Weaver–Dunn procedures this technique is designed to stabilize the acromioclavicular joint by recreating the anatomy of the coracoclavicular ligaments via a minimal invasive approach.     

The Double-Pulley Technique for Double-Row Rotator Cuff Repair

In an effort to maximize the area of footprint coverage, we developed the “double-pulley technique” for double-row rotator cuff repairs. Two suture anchors are inserted at the articular margin of the greater tuberosity (one anterior and one posterior). All 4 suture strands from each anchor are passed through a single medial point on the torn cuff. In this way, the 4 suture strands from the anteromedial anchor pass through 1 point in the cuff and the 4 strands from the posteromedial anchor pass through a different point in the cuff. A suture strand from 1 anchor is tied extracorporeally to a suture strand of the same color from the other anchor. The other ends of those 2 strands are then pulled, thereby delivering this extracorporeal knot into the joint and over the medial footprint. These 2 free suture strands are then tied together as a static knot. The procedure is repeated with the other sutures. This technique creates a double mattress suture medially, which compresses the intervening tendon bridge against its bone bed. We call this procedure the double-pulley technique because it uses the anchor eyelets as pulleys to deliver the extracorporeal knot into the shoulder. After the lateral row repair is performed, the rotator cuff footprint will be completely reconstituted.     

Knotless anatomic double-layer double-row rotator cuff repair: a novel technique re-establishing footprint and shape of full-thickness tears

The standard technique for restoring footprint after full-thickness tears of the rotator cuff includes double-row or transosseous-equivalent techniques. However, the anatomically typical bird’s beak shape and profile of tendon insertion may not be originally restored and biomechanics may be altered. In this report, the authors describe a technique that involves creating two intratendinous stitches at different levels of the torn tendon. The first passes through the bursal-side layer, the second stitch through the joint-side layer. Both stitches may be performed in mattress suture configuration. The anchorage is performed by knotless anchors in order to avoid knots lying within the insertion area. The footprint is restored first medially then laterally by the use of double-row principles. The joint-side suture is anchored within the medially placed anchor. The bursal-side suture is anchored by a laterally placed anchor. The anatomic insertion and restoration of the shape and profile may be enabled by the described double-layer suture technique. Using a double-layer double-row repair may potentially improve functional results of rotator cuff repair constructs.     

A new technique of arthroscopic capsular shift in anterior shoulder instability

We describe a new arthroscopic technique to reinforce the torn inferior glenohumeral ligament (IGHL) and the elongated capsule to the glenoid rim. The arthroscope is inserted over the superior portal and, after the insertion of a suture anchor, both limbs are pulled out over the posterior portal. The IGHL is grasped and pulled upward onto the glenoid rim using a suture retriever clamp inserted over the posterior portal. A 45° curved blunt clamp (Sidewinder; Arthrex, Naples, FL) coming from the anterior penetrates the IGHL, and 1 end of the suture limb is given into the branches of the clamp and pulled out anteriorly. After a second perforation of the capsule, a horizontal suture creating a neolabrum can be placed. This technique allows a suitable reinforcement of the capsule without intraoperative complications. In cases of capsular elongation, especially a torn IGHL, the capsular instability can be addressed by the described Sidewinder technique. More sophisticated arthroscopic techniques such as this will increase the indication for arthroscopic shoulder stabilization.Arthroscopy: The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery, Vol 17, No 4 (April), 2001: pp 426–429     

Arthroscopic Rotator Cuff Repair Using a Triple-Loaded Suture Anchor and a Modified Mason-Allen Technique (Alex Stitch)

Surgical repair of the rotator cuff must have good resistance and should restore the tendon footprint. To attain this goal, a stitch with a strong biomechanical profile that avoids tissue strangulation should be used. We describe an arthroscopic suture technique undertaken to repair rotator cuff tears with a single triple-loaded suture anchor. The technique consists of a combination of a horizontal mattress and 2 vertical simple sutures that are positioned medial to the mattress suture. The suture anchor used is the 5-mm self-tapping ThRevo (Linvatec). This anchor is loaded with 3 sutures: 2 No. 2 nonabsorbable braided polyester sutures of different colors and a central high-strength No. 2 polyethylene suture. The shape of the anchor eyelet permits all 3 sutures to glide freely. A modified Mason-Allen technique (Alex stitch) that combines a horizontal side-to-side suture and 2 simples sutures as vertical loops is used. With use of the Spectrum suture passing device and shuttle relay system (Linvatec), both limbs of the centrally located polyethylene suture are passed through the cuff from bottom to top, approximately 1 cm from the tendon edge. This suture is not immediately tied. Next, with use of the same system, the other 2 sutures are placed medially and over the previous horizontal suture. Simple sutures are placed at an approximately 30° angle from the center of the anchor; 1 is placed anterior and the other posterior. The sutures are tied through the lateral portal. The mattress horizontal central stitch is always tied first, followed by the 2 vertical sutures. The horizontal mattress suture serves as a “rip stop stitch” and theoretically reduces the possibility of cutting out of the simple sutures.     

Biceps tenodesis associated with arthroscopic repair of rotator cuff tears

Associated lesions of the biceps tendon are commonly found during arthroscopic repair of rotator cuff tears. These lesions are treated with tenodesis, classically performed through an open approach. However, it seems reasonable to seek a single approach to correct both lesions; therefore, we have proposed a new arthroscopic technique that allows an exclusive arthroscopic tenodesis by including the biceps tendon in the rotator cuff suture, a surgical technique with a single suture of the rotator cuff that includes the biceps tendon. We treated 97 shoulders in 96 patients arthroscopically for complete rotator cuff tears. Of these shoulders, 15 required tenodesis for treatment of biceps tendon lesions. Through an arthroscopic approach, a subacromial decompression followed by a rotator cuff repair was carried out in association with a biceps tenodesis. In this technique, one limb of the suture was passed through the biceps tendon, and the other was passed through the rotator cuff tear, bringing both tissues together in the final suture. Of the patients, 9 were men and 5 were women. Their mean age was 71 years (range, 41-80 years). The dominant arm was affected in all patients. Postoperative evaluation, by use of the UCLA score, after a mean follow-up period of 32.4 months showed satisfactory results in 93.4% of patients: 11 had excellent results, 3 had good results, and only 1 had an unsatisfactory result. In this case a postoperative magnetic resonance imaging scan showed an intact rotator cuff and biceps tenodesis. The suture involving the rotator cuff and the biceps tendon proved effective to correct both lesions, with the main advantage being that an additional approach was not required.     

A Modified Suture-Bridge Technique for a Marginal Dog-Ear Deformity Caused During Rotator Cuff Repair

Recently, the suture-bridge technique was found to maximize the utility of a single-row construct by using the suture limbs from the medial mattress sutures to bridge and compress the repaired tendon. However, the formation of marginal dog-ear deformities at a repaired rotator cuff is not uncommon with the suture-bridge technique. If a dog-ear deformity is observed at the margin after completion of the rotator cuff repair, the detached marginal cuff is pierced via a suture hook. One strand of the uncut suture in the lateral row is transported through the deformed cuff. A nonsliding knot is seated on top of the detached cuff and presses this area of soft tissue firmly onto the bone. If necessary, these steps are repeated for the other side of the detached rotator cuff. After completion of the rotator cuff repair, a “zigzag” pattern of compression of the cuff against the bone footprint without detachment of the rotator cuff is observed. After repair of the rotator cuff tear via the suture-bridge technique, the benefit of our simple technique for treating a marginal detached cuff is that the footprint contact area of the rotator cuff is restored completely, without the need for additional suture anchors.     

Performance of antegrade suture passers according to tendon thickness

Purpose:

To determine the effect of tendon thickness on the needle penetration ability of four different designs of antegrade suture passers.

Materials and Methods:

Four antegrade suture passers were tested: (a) ExpresSew II (Depuy Mitek Inc., Raynham, MA), (b) Arthrex Scorpion (Arthrex, Naples, FL), (c) Concept (Linvatec Corp, Largo, FL), and (d) ElitePass (Smith and Nephew Endoscopy, Andover, MA). Bovine tendons were divided into five thickness groups: 3, 5, 7, 9 and 11 mm. At each tendon thickness, we performed 15 trials with the suture loaded and 15 unloaded per device. Successful needle penetration was recorded, and in case of success, the exit point of the needle was noted in relation to the superior arm of the grasping component.

Results:

All tested suture passing devices successfully penetrated tendon thicknesses of 3 and 5 mm. With the suture loaded, one device (Concept) only successfully penetrated 7 mm group tendons in 3/15 (20%) trials. Success rates at 9 mm with the suture loaded were 40% in ExpresSew II, 53% in Arthrex Scorpion, 0% in Concept and 53% in ElitePass. Among successful passages with a loaded suture in the 7 and 9 mm-groups, about 20-50% of passages were oblique, and the needle came out distal to the superior arm of grasping the component. No trial with any device succeeded with 11 mm tendons in the suture loading condition.

Conclusion:

Using an antegrade suture passer during arthroscopic rotator cuff repair should be carefully considered when the torn end of the tendon is thicker than about 7-9 mm due to potential failure of needle penetration and/or too oblique a suture passage.

Level of Evidence:

Controlled laboratory study.     

Anatomic Reduction and Next-Generation Fixation Constructs for Arthroscopic Repair of Crescent,L-Shaped,and U-Shaped Rotator Cuff Tears

Emerging techniques and instrumentation have allowed orthopaedic surgeons to achieve rotator cuff repair through an all-arthroscopic technique. The most critical steps in rotator cuff repair consist of proper identification of the cuff tear pattern and anatomic restoration of the torn tendon footprint. With anatomic reduction of the rotator cuff tendons, a sound fixation construct can help restore rotator cuff contact pressure and kinematics, allowing for decreased repair tension and optimal healing potential. We provide surgical methods to recognize tear patterns and present a repair construct that will restore the anatomic footprint of the torn rotator cuff tendon. The key, initial maneuver to restore the anatomic footprint of the cuff includes placement of a suture anchor at the anterolateral corner for L-shaped tears and at the posterolateral corner for reverse L–shaped and U-shaped tears. After insertion of the medial-row anchors, the tendon stitches should be planned by use of a grasper to hold the tendon in a reduced position and guide location of the stitch. The lateral row with suture bridge can be visualized, and the final repair construct should produce an anatomic restoration of the rotator cuff footprint.