Outcome analysis, including patient and parental satisfaction, regarding nonvascularized free toe phalanx transfer in congenital hand deformities

The therapy for congenital hand malformations, especially in symbrachydactyly and constriction ring syndromes, is challenging. Between 1975 and 1995, 20 children with congenital hand deformities underwent reconstruction by 56 nonvascularized free toe phalanx transfers. The average age at initial surgery was 4.8 (range, 0.5 to 22) years. Retrospectively, the children were examined after an average of 3.5 (range, 1.5 to 17.6) years for function of the hand, transplanted phalanx growth, assessment for the epiphyseal plate, and assessment for psychologic performance with their parents. Donor-site morbidity was determined according to measured growth deficit, observing the child's gait, and toe function. In the younger patients (up to 1.5 years), the grafts were well tolerated and showed good growth and only few resorptions. In the age group from 1.5 to 4 years, the grafts showed no growth. In the age group older than 4 years, the grafts were mostly resorbed. The clinical reexamination revealed in most cases only passive motion in the joints, but the function of the hand was improved, with only few problems of the donor site. Most patients and their parents reported a positive effect of the phalanx transfer.     

Classification and treatment of symbrachydactyly. A series of 117 cases

In the present study, a modification has been proposed of the Blauth and Gekeler classification, aimed at a more accurate definition of appropriate surgical treatment. An analysis was made of a series of 120 cases of symbrachydactyly (117 patients); however, surgery was only performed in 86 cases (51 toe transfers in 49 patients; mean age at surgery 12 months). Type I included the separation of short and sometimes stiff fingers; type II, the 'pseudo-cleft', could be subdivided into three groups. Type IIA included those hands with more than two long and frequently hypoplastic digits, regarding which a decision had to be made between removal of rudimentary fingers or their stabilization. In type IIB, hand function was good and surgery was rarely needed. Type III (monodactylous) could also be subdivided into two categories, i.e., normal thumb in type IIIA and hypoplasia in IIIB. Finally, in type IVA, toe transfer surgery was performed on condition that wrist mobility was sufficient to compensate for the insufficient mobility of the artificial thumb on the anterior aspect of the radius. In all cases, a weak but useful pincer movement was obtained, with poor cosmetic results. In the case of toe transfers, surgery was advocated before the age of one year; and although mobility was disappointing (35 degrees active motion), good growth and excellent discrimination (5 mm on average) was observed. Symbrachydactyly is a fairly frequent congenital malformation; its diverse clinical features require a precise classification to better determine adequate treatment management.     

Double second toe transfer in congenital hand anomalies.

A series of 14 patients with congenital hand anomalies who received staged double second toe transfers to the same hand for restoration of function or form were reviewed retrospectively. There were three children with constriction ring syndrome, two with symbrachydactyly and nine with transverse absence (failure of formation). There were different indications, technical difficulties and results with the various anomalies. All transferred toes were mobile and sensate, and were reported to be of benefit in both function and appearance. However, secondary surgical procedures were required in all patients.     

Toe-to-hand transfer in symbrachydactyly.

Symbrachydactyly, or central atypical cleft, is classified as a failure of formation. For the adactylous or monodactylous forms, free toe transfer is the treatment of choice. We present 18 free toe transfers in 13 patients for symbrachydactyly. Despite abnormal anatomy, the functional building blocks have always been available and transfer technically possible. The result has been improved function and high levels of parental satisfaction.     

Non-vascularized free toe phalanx transplantation in the treatment of symbrachydactyly and constriction ring syndrome

Forty-eight patients underwent a total number of 113 non-vascularized free toe phalanx transplantations for congenital short digits between 1975 and 2003, a mean number of 2.3 transplanted phalanges per patient. The mean age at the time of initial surgery was 3.6 years (range 6 months to 21 years). The follow-up time ranged from 4 months to 14 years with a mean of 6 years. Sixty-four phalanges showed radiographically measured growth, 22 phalanges showed signs of resorption, while 27 phalanges showed neither growth nor resorption. Resorption increased with patient age. Three patients developed donor site problems. The optimum timing for initial surgery is as early as possible because of the safer and greater growth potential and less resorption of the transplanted phalanges. Non-vascularized free toe phalanx transplantations offer a simple and safe method of lengthening with a significant improvement of hand function.     

Long term follow-up of composite non-vascularized toe phalanx transfers for aphalangia

The results of 21 non-vascularized toe phalanx transfers in 13 patients were reviewed radiologically with respect to function, physeal patency, growth and donor site morbidity at a mean follow-up of 7.4 (range 2.9-13.6) years. Physeal patency was maintained in 4 of 18 surviving transfers. The length of the transferred phalanx averaged 75% of the contralateral comparable toe phalanx and 44% of the contralateral digit proximal phalanx. Most patients had good or simple use of the hand with active joint motion. There was universal shortening of the donor toe with hypoplasia of the middle and distal phalanges. This review suggests that transfer of a non-vascularized toe phalanx provides a reliable but limited means for increasing length of a digit, stabilizing soft tissue "nubbins" and improving function. Longer follow-up has shown more modest gains in growth than in some previous reports.     

Technique of nonvascularized toe phalangeal transfer and distraction lengthening in the treatment of multiple digit symbrachydactyly

A combination of nonvascularized multiple toe phalangeal transfers, web space deepening, and distraction lengthening may provide excellent function in the child born with the oligodactylous type of symbrachydactyly. These techniques may reconstruct multiple digits, maintaining a wide and stable grip span with good prehension to the thumb.We detail the techniques of each of these 3 stages in reconstruction and describe appropriate patient selection. Potential complications are discussed. However, with strict attention to technical details, these complications can be minimized.     

Symbrachydactylie

Symbrachydactyly is literally defined as a combination of short fingers with syndactyly. Blauth and Gekeler described four types of symbrachydactyly, ranging from simple shortness of middle phalanges to complete absence of digital rays. In type I (short finger) function is quite normal and syndactyly release is usually the only procedure needed. In type II (cleft hand), presence of a thumb and at least one ulnar finger allows pinch function. Surgical treatment, when needed, consists in separation of webbed fingers, resection of nonfunctional digital stumps, or finger translocation. In type III (monodactyly) all long fingers are absent. Pinch function can be created between the thumb and a toe transfer in ulnar location. Bone lengthening is an alternative procedure to create a pincer. Surgery is not always indicated in type IV (peromely) as function can only be restored if active motion is already present at wrist or carpometacarpal levels.     

Symbrachydactyly

Symbrachydactyly is literally defined as a combination of short fingers with syndactyly. Blauth and Gekeler described four types of symbrachydactyly, ranging from simple shortness of middle phalanges to complete absence of digital rays. In type I (short finger) function is quite normal and syndactyly release is usually the only procedure needed. In type II (cleft hand), presence of a thumb and at least one ulnar finger allows pinch function. Surgical treatment, when needed, consists in separation of webbed fingers, resection of nonfunctional digital stumps, or finger translocation. In type III (monodactyly) all long fingers are absent. Pinch function can be created between the thumb and a toe transfer in ulnar location. Bone lengthening is an alternative procedure to create a pincer. Surgery is not always indicated in type IV (peromely) as function can only be restored if active motion is already present at wrist or carpometacarpal levels.     

Non vascularized toe phalangeal transfers for symbrachydactyly. Active range of motion without joint reconstruction

Symbrachydactyly is a rare congenital malformation of the hand and its treatment is controversial. Non vascularized toe phalangeal transfers have been used for management of short digits for three children. Six phalanges have been harvested complete with their periosteum. No joint reconstruction has been performed and all children have undergone surgery at a young age. Four of six digits involved have an active range of motion (range 30 to 105 degrees ). All authors who have reported active range of motion of toe phalangeal transfers have performed joint reconstruction. Here, we report obtaining active range of motion of phalangeal transfers without necessity of joint reconstruction.     

Temporary arteriovenous loop between the saphenous vein and the first plantar metatarsal artery in toe-to-hand transfers

We describe a technique for creating a temporary arteriovenous loop by anastomosing the saphenous vein to the first plantar metatarsal artery to facilitate harvesting and subsequent anastomosis of a great or second toe transfer. This technique has been used in 9 patients: 6 pediatric toe-to-hand transfers for congenital hand differences and 3 adult toe transfers for a thumb amputation. All 9 toe transfers survived. The advantages of this technique are that it allows precise determination of the exact length of the loop to reach the recipient artery, it facilitates palmar positioning of the arterial pedicle, and, if necessary, the saphenous vein can be anastomosed directly to the lateral digital artery of a great toe transfer or the medial digital artery of a second toe transfer rather than the first plantar metatarsal artery itself, thereby minimizing more proximal dissection of the first plantar metatarsal artery, which is more difficult and time consuming.     

Middle Phalangectomy for the Correction of Toe Clinodactyly With Longitudinal Epiphyseal Bracket in Young Children

Toe clinodactyly is often owed to the presence of a longitudinal epiphyseal bracket. We developed middle phalangectomy as a simple surgical solution for correction of toe clinodactyly because of longitudinal epiphyseal bracket in childhood. Ten children (ages 1–5 years) were operated on by the same surgeon between October 2007 and May 2012 (n = 15 feet). The same surgical technique was used in all the cases. A clinical evaluation included the appearance of the foot, the parents’ level of satisfaction, and the presence or absence of bothersome symptoms (such as pain and discomfort when wearing footwear). A radiological evaluation under weight-bearing conditions enabled us to 1) rate the achievement of a natural-looking toe parabola and 2) detect the recurrence of clinodactyly (defined as an angle of >40° between 2 adjacent phalanges). The mean follow-up period was 5.4 (range 3.3 to 8.1) years. Nine sets of parents (90%) were satisfied with the results of the procedure. None had difficulties wearing boots, and only 1 child (10%) had residual pain during sports activities. Clinodactyly recurred in 3 feet in 3 patients (20% of feet, 30% of patients). Two (20%) of the latter patients underwent repeat surgery and achieved a lasting, satisfactory outcome. Middle phalangectomy is an appropriate procedure for the treatment of toe clinodactyly because of longitudinal epiphyseal bracket in young children. However, the patients’ long-term outcomes (notably once bone growth has ended) must be assessed.     

The role of nonvascularized toe phalanx transplantation

Stabilization of boneless finger stumps or lengthening of partially aplastic digits in congenital malformations is difficult, because the bone graft, placed on top of the existing bone, will undergo resorption. Only the periosteum-covered proximal toe phalanx will withstand resorption and show a complete take. With the toe phalanx, including the plantar plate and the collateral ligaments of the metatarsophalangeal joint as a half-joint, it is possible to construct a new joint with the cartilage-covered distal end of the recipient bone (metacarpal or proximal phalanx) as the proximal half-joint. Flexor and extensor tendons exist in almost all cases. Between 1976 and 1990, 97 toe phalanx transplantations were performed in 57 children. The indications were boneless digital stumps with partial absence of digits and large bone defects in fingers in symbrachydactyly and ring-constriction syndrome. Follow-up examinations of 44 patients with 69 transplanted toe phalanges (95% of the patients operated on by March 1989) have shown a 100% take of the bone graft, provided it had been unsplit and the periosteal cover undamaged. The earlier in life the operation was performed, the more postoperative growth was recorded. The shortening of the donor toe was less because a tendon interposition was used. A joint construction was attempted in 64 digits with variable results. The range of active motion varied between 0 (fusion) and 90 degrees.     

Long-term follow-up of free vascularized joint transfers to the hand in children

Toe-to-hand vascularized joint transfers in four children were reviewed 6 to 8 years after operation (average, 6.6 years). Two children had vascularized metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joints. Both children have near normal active range of motion. The transferred epiphyses have provided a major contribution to digital growth. The other two children had second toe proximal interphalangeal (PIP) joints transferred to damaged hand joints. Active PIP joint extension has been disappointing, and the overall growth contribution of the transferred epiphysis has been small. We conclude that MTP to metacarpophalangeal vascularized joint transfer can provide painless, functional, stable motion, with near normal growth potential, and the usefulness of toe PIP to hand PIP joint transfer is limited by the inability to achieve good active extension and limited growth potential.     

Thiemann's finger or toe disease. Follow-up of seven cases

Thiemann's disease is a non-inflammatory disorder of unknown etiology, affecting the epiphyses of the phalanges of the fingers and the first toe in children. We have re-examined seven patients after up to 18 years. Two patients had had pain in the affected digits for several years. In four patients radiographs after closure of the growth plates showed normal phalangeal dimensions without arthrosis. We conclude that different degrees of severity of epiphyseal disturbance consistent with the type described by Thiemann may be encountered. It is possible that trauma may worsen the prognosis by deformation of a susceptible epiphysis.     

Options for correction of post-traumatic length discrepancies in forearm bones in children (case reports)

Correction of radius length after a premature complete or partial closure of the distal epiphyseal plate is important for both the correction of radial deviation of the hand and the restoration of normal function of the radiocarpal articulation. This study comprised four patients. Two children with complete closure of the epiphyseal plate of the distal radius underwent callotaxis. One patient was treated for atrophic pseudoarthrosis of the distal radial metaphysis by external fixation and subsequent spongioplasty. One patient with partial closure of the epiphyseal plate was treated by physeal distraction. In each patient an Ilizarov's external fixator was applied. The full correction of radius length was achieved in all cases. No complications were recorded with the exception of tissue irritation around Kirchner's wires, which occurred mainly on the volar side. In the therapy of injuries suffered during adolescent growth acceleration, it is necessary to perform a certain overdistraction of the radius. An alternative method includes epiphyseodesis of the distal ulna. Key words: post-traumatic closure of the epiphyseal plate, callotaxis, physeal distraction, chondrodiatasis.     

Pedicle scapular apophysis transplantation in congenital limb malformations.

Congenital segmental amputations are difficult to correct. Free interposition bone grafts with growth centers were tried experimentally by many investigators even at the beginning of this century. Attempts at clinical application of this principle, however, were mostly failures. More recently, with the advent of microsurgical techniques, new hope has arisen. In particular, toe transfers in children have confirmed the survival of such growth centers, as these transfers could be found to grow normally [1]. The transfer of vascularized epiphysis with its growth plate has been shown in animal limbs to achieve a rate of growth comparable with the normal site. Originally, two donor sites were used with acceptable results in children. These were the superior epiphysis of the fibula and the iliac crest. So far, in most clinical applications, they have been used as appositional transfers. However, a growth problem occurring at the donor site has proved to be quite crippling.     

Lengthening of long bones by the method of slow lysis of the epiphyses. Preliminary report

The authors have presented a preliminary report on the results of elongation of the lower extremities by the bloodless method of slow disruption of the long bones epiphyses based on the observation of 6 cases. The treatment was applied in the children just before bone growth has been finished. Bone rebuilding at the site of elongation was obtained at 4 to 6 months after the start of distraction. In that period, union of the epiphyseal cartilage was present in 5 from 6 treated patients. The authors believe that the presented method of elongation of the lower extremities can be recommended.     

Slipped capital femoral epiphysis in skeletally immature patients

Fixation by a single screw is considered the current treatment of choice for a slipped capital femoral epiphysis. This approach promotes premature physeal closure. The use of a modified, standard, single, cannulated screw designed to maintain epiphyseal fixation without causing premature closure of the physis was reviewed in ten patients. The nine boys and one girl aged between 10.6 and 12.6 years with unilateral slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE), were markedly skeletally immature (Tanner stage I, bone age 10 to 12.6 years). Clinical and radiological review at a mean follow-up of 44.3 months (36 to 76) showed no difference in the time to physeal closure between the involved and uninvolved side. Measurement of epiphyseal and physeal development showed continued growth and remodelling in all patients. Use of this device provided epiphyseal stability and maintained the capacity for physeal recovery and growth following treatment for both unstable and stable slipped capital femoral epiphysis.     

Bone-lengthening for symbrachydactyly of the hand with the technique of callus distraction

BACKGROUND: Bone-lengthening in the hand and foot is a relatively new application for distraction osteogenesis. We present the operative treatment and postoperative outcome for four patients with M ller type-D symbrachydactyly of the hand who underwent metacarpal lengthening with use of a distraction device to establish pinch function. METHODS: Four patients who underwent distraction osteogenesis for the treatment of congenital symbrachydactyly of the hand were evaluated over a thirteen-year period. The nondominant right hand was treated in two patients, and the nondominant left hand was treated in the other two. The patients included three boys and one girl; all patients had the operation between the ages of five and eleven years. Distraction osteogenesis was performed on the fifth metacarpal in one patient and on the fourth and fifth metacarpals in the remaining three, in whom both bones were lengthened simultaneously with use of a single device. Postoperative bone elongation was analyzed with radiographs made at the time of removal of the distractor. The sensory function of the treated fingers and any growth disturbance of the distracted bones were evaluated. RESULTS: The mean duration of distraction was 37.3 days (range, thirty-two to forty-nine days), and the distractor was removed at a mean of eighty-four days after surgery. The bones were lengthened by a mean of 22.3 mm (81.6% of their original length) at a rate of 0.6 mm/day. Pinch function was improved in all patients. CONCLUSIONS: On the basis of our limited experience, we found that distraction osteogenesis of the metacarpals was an effective technique for the establishment of pinch function. We also found that an intramedullary Kirschner wire could maintain the alignment of the osteotomized bone. Although distraction requires a longer treatment period, it is apparently more effective than bone-grafting in terms of achieving adequate bone length. Simultaneous lengthening of two metacarpals also was found to be an effective technique.