Histological comparison of healing extraction sockets implanted with bioactive glass or demineralized freeze-dried bone allograft: a pilot study

BACKGROUND: Various materials have been used immediately following tooth extraction to fill and/or cover the socket in an attempt to limit or prevent ridge resorption. The purpose of the present pilot study was to establish a reliable model to investigate the effect of various bone graft and bone replacement materials on extraction socket healing. This study also compared healing extraction sockets 6 to 8 months postimplantation of a bioactive glass (BG) or demineralized freeze-dried bone allograft (DFDBA) to an unfilled socket control (C). METHODS: Following tooth extraction, a total of 30 sockets in 19 patients were randomly divided into 3 treatment groups: 10 sockets received BG, 10 sockets DFDBA, and 10 sockets served as unfilled controls. Primary coverage was achieved by flap advancement over each socket. Six to 8 months postextraction at time of implant placement, histological cores of the treatment sites were obtained. These cores were processed, undecalcified sections prepared and stained with Stevenel blue/van Gieson's picric fuchsin, and histomorphometrically analyzed. Vital bone, connective tissue and marrow, and residual graft particles were reported as a percentage of the total core. RESULTS: A model system was described in humans and used to evaluate the healing response in the 3 treatment groups. Results concluded that mean vital bone present was 59.5% for BG-, 34.7% for DFDBA-, and 32.4% for C-treated sites. These differences were not statistically significant. However, the residual implant material was significantly higher in DFDBA-treated (13.5%) versus BG-treated sockets (5.5%). CONCLUSIONS: Although the differences in percent vital bone were not statistically significant among the 3 treatment groups in this pilot study, BG material was observed to act as an osteoconductive material which had a positive effect on socket healing at 6 to 8 months postextraction. Further research following implant placement in treated and control sockets is warranted to determine if bone implant contact is improved in BG-filled versus unfilled sockets.     

Hyaluronic Acid Improves Bone Formation in Extraction Sockets With Chronic Pathology: A Pilot Study in Dogs

Background: Previous studies on ridge preservation focusing on fresh extraction sockets using graft materials for ridge preservation procedures have reported a delay in the tissue modeling and remodeling phases. The objective of this study is to evaluate the effect of hyaluronic acid (HA) on healing of infected sockets. Methods: Six beagle dogs were used in this study. Both mandibular third premolars were hemisected, and the distal roots were extracted. Subsequently, periodontal and endodontic lesions were induced at the remaining mesial root. After communication of the periodontal lesion, an endodontic periapical lesion was observed at 4 months, and the mesial roots of both the right and left sides were extracted. HA was applied into the socket of the test group, and no treatment was administered to the other group (control group). Three months after extraction of the mesial roots, the dogs were sacrificed, and histologic evaluations were performed. Results: The sockets were filled by mineralized bone (47.80% ± 6.60%) and bone marrow (50.47% ± 6.38%) in the control group, whereas corresponding values were 63.29% ± 9.78% and 34.73% ± 8.97% for the test group, respectively. There was a statistically significant difference between the groups. Reversal lines and a copious lineup of osteoblasts were observed in the middle and apical parts of the sockets in the test group. Conclusion: An infected socket shows delayed healing of the socket wound, and HA, because of its osteoinductive, bacteriostatic, and anti‐inflammatory properties, may improve bone formation and accelerate wound healing in infected sockets.     

Autogenous masticatory mucosal grafts in extraction socket seal procedures: a comparison between sockets grafted with demineralized freeze‐dried bone and deproteinized bovine bone mineral

Successful preservation of the edentulous ridge after extractions may eliminate or reduce the need for ridge augmentation procedures. It has been claimed that grafting fresh extraction sockets and sealing them with autogenous soft tissue grafts promote ridge preservation after tooth extraction. In this study, the survival of free autogenous connective tissue grafts sealing extraction sites was evaluated. In 24 healthy patients, 42 maxillary anterior teeth were extracted. After socket debridement, soft tissue margins of the socket orifice were carefully cut to remove epithelial debris, Sockets were filled with either demineralized freeze-dried bone allografts (DFDBA) or deproteinized natural bovine bone mineral xenograft (DBBMX) to the level of the alveolar bone crest. Circular connective tissue grafts, slightly larger in diameter than the soft tissue socket orifice, were obtained and placed on top of the filler graft material sealing the sockets. Grafts were stabilized and secured by sutures and inspected weekly for the first month. The grafts were classified into 3 groups according to clinical parameters: vital, partially vital and non-vital. After 1 week, 18 grafts were vital, 13 partially vital and 11 non-vital. When only 1 sample unit (1 site per patient) was compared between DFDBA and DBBMX grafted sockets, no significant difference in graft vitality was shown (P = 0.34 for vital; P = 0.67 for vital plus partially vital). After 1 month, all socket orifices were sealed with mucosa. Based on the present observations, it seems that connective tissue grafts sealing fresh extraction sites are mainly dependent on underlying tissue vascularization and that sealing grafted fresh extraction sockets filled with bone substitute allograft or xenograft materials may be beneficial but an unpredictable procedure.     

Medical grade calcium sulfate hemihydrate in healing of human extraction sockets: clinical and histological observations at 3 months

BACKGROUND: Following tooth extraction, remodeling and resorption of the alveolar bone at the extraction site characterize wound healing. This produces a reduction in ridge volume and difficulties in delayed placement of implants in an ideal position. Medical grade calcium sulfate hemihydrate (MGCSH) has been proposed as a graft material in extraction sockets to minimize the reduction in ridge volume. The aim of the present study was to investigate the influence of MGCSH on the histopathologic pattern of intrasocket regenerated bone and to evaluate histologically the healed MGCSH grafted extraction socket site 3 months postextraction METHODS: MGCSH was grafted in 10 fresh human extraction sockets in 10 patients. Five post-extraction sockets were used as controls. At 3 months a cylindrical tissue specimen, 2.5 mm in diameter, was trephined from the previously grafted site followed by implant placement. Non-decalcified specimens were sectioned at a cross-horizontal plane and stained with fast green, toluidine blue, and Van Kossa stains for histological and histomorphometrical examination. RESULTS: Histologically, MGCSH was not observed in most of the specimens. Newly formed bone with lamellar arrangements was identified in all the horizontal sections with no difference between apical, medium, and coronal areas. The mean trabecular area in the coronal sections was 58.6% +/- 9.2%; in the medium sections, 58.1% +/- 6.2%; and in the apical sections, 58.3% +/- 7.8%. The differences were not statistically significant. CONCLUSION: MGCSH seems to be an ideal graft material in extraction socket bone regeneration because it is almost completely resorbable, and it allows a new trabecular bone arrangement at 3 months.     

Medial-grade calcium sulfate hemihydrate (surgiplaster) in healing of a human extraction socket--histologic observation at 3 months: a case report

PURPOSE: Following tooth extraction, wound healing is characterized by remodeling and resorption of the alveolar bone at the extraction site. This produces reduction in ridge volume. Medical-grade calcium sulfate hemihydrate (MGCSH) has been proposed as a graft material for extraction sockets to minimize the reduction in ridge volume. The aim of this study was to investigate the influence of MGCSH on the histopathologic pattern of intrasocket regenerated bone and to evaluate histologically the healed MGCSH-grafted extraction socket site at 3 months postextraction. MATERIALS AND METHODS: MGCSH was grafted in a fresh human extraction socket, and at 3 months a cylindric tissue specimen, 2.5 mm in diameter, was trephined from the previously grafted site and an implant was placed. Non-decalcified specimens were sectioned at a horizontal plane and stained for histologic and histomorphometric evaluation. RESULTS: The mean trabecular area was 58.6% +/- 9.2% in the coronal sections, 58.1% +/- 6.2% in the middle sections, and 58.3% +/- 7.8% in the apical sections. The differences in mean trabecular area between sections were not statistically significant. DISCUSSION: It is significant that the MGCSH underwent complete resorption and replacement by newly formed bone because the most important negative attribute of other graft materials is the resorption time. Moreover, calcium sulfate shows great potential for guided bone regeneration in surgical sites. CONCLUSION: MGCSH seems to be an acceptable graft material for extraction socket bone regeneration because it is completely resorbable and allows new trabecular bone arrangement in a limited 3-month period.     

Mandibular Third Molar Extraction Wound Healing With and Without Platelet Rich Plasma: A Comparative Prospective Study

Aims

To evaluate the efficacy of autologous platelet rich plasma (PRP) in regeneration of bone and to assess clinical compatibility of the material in mandibular third molar extraction socket.

Objective of the Study

To compare the healing of mandibular third molar extraction wounds with and without PRP.

Materials and Methods

Group A consists of the 30 patients where PRP will be placed in the extraction socket before closure of the socket. Group B consists of 30 patients who will be the control group where the extraction sockets will be closed without any intra socket medicaments. The patients would be allocated to the groups randomly.

Results

Soft tissue healing was better in study site compared to control site. The result of the study shows rapid bone regeneration in the extraction socket treated with PRP when compared with the socket without PRP. Evaluation for bone blending and trabecular bone formation started earlier in PRP site compared to control, non PRP site. Also there was less postoperative discomfort on the PRP treated side.

Conclusion

Autologous PRP is biocompatible and has significant improved soft tissue healing, bone regeneration and increase in bone density in extraction sockets.     

A model to evaluate bone substitutes for immediate implant placement

A calcified alloplast was evaluated as a gap-filling material around implants placed immediately into fresh extraction sockets. Periodontal measurements and computed tomography scans were obtained to evaluate the clinical effectiveness of the alloplast when compared with demineralized freeze-dried bone. To determine whether this alloplast would be a suitable grafting material, 14 patients were selected to evaluate the extraction socket as a model for routine histologic confirmation of the efficacy and biocompatibility of bone substitutes. The results of this study showed the following: (1) human extraction sockets can be models for the study of bone/implant interaction; (2) the alloplast was well tolerated and demonstrated no inflammation through histologic evaluation of core biopsies; (3) the alloplast was a suitable material when used as a gap-filling graft in sockets around immediately placed implants; and (4) dental computed tomography scans and periodontal measurements around grafted implants 6 months after the procedure provide valuable clinical information about graft healing and osteointegration.     

Alveolar bone preservation in extraction sockets using non-resorbable dPTFE membranes: a retrospective non-randomized study

BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to investigate the clinical regeneration of extraction sockets using high-density polytetrafluoroethylene (dPTFE) membranes without the use of a graft material. METHODS: A total of 276 extraction sockets were evaluated in 276 subjects (151 males and 125 females; mean age, 50.2 years; age range: 24 to 73 years). After extraction, flaps were elevated and a dPTFE membrane was placed over the extraction site. The flaps were repositioned and sutured into place. Primary closure was not obtained over the membranes. The cemento-enamel junctions of the adjacent teeth were used as reference points. Measurements were taken postextraction and 12 months after surgery in the same areas with the help of a stent and were defined as the distance from the reference points to the bone level. Hard tissue biopsies were taken from 10 representative cases during implant placement 12 months after socket preservation. The bone core samples were submitted for histologic evaluation. A stringent plaque-control regimen was enforced in all subjects during the 12-month observation period. RESULTS: A significant regeneration of the volume of sockets could be noted by histologic evaluation, indicating that the newly formed tissue in extraction sites was mainly bone. No influence of gender, smoking, age, or clinical bone level before treatment was found on the percentage of bone gain. CONCLUSION: The use of dPTFE membranes predictably led to the preservation of soft and hard tissue in extraction sites.     

Extraction socket preservation graft before implant placement with calcium sulfate hemihydrate and platelet-rich plasma: a clinical and histomorphometric study in humans

Background: The aim of this investigation is to evaluate clinical and histologic outcome of using medical‐grade calcium sulfate hemihydrate (MGCSH) mixed with platelet‐rich plasma (PRP) for extraction socket preservation graft before implant placement. Methods: This study is a single‐site, randomized and controlled investigation. Sixteen patients with a non‐restorable tooth requiring extraction followed by implant placement were enrolled in this study. After extraction of a tooth, eight selected patients randomly received MGCSH mixed with PRP in the extraction sockets (test group), and eight selected patients randomly received collagen resorbable plug dressing material (control group). At the time of extraction and 3 months later (at implant placement surgery), vertical and horizontal socket dimensions were measured. Bone core samples were retrieved from the center of the healed socket before implant placement for histomorphometric analysis. Results: There was a statistically significant difference between the two groups based on histomorphometric analysis (P <0.05). New vital bone percentage regenerated after 3 months of healing was 66.5% ± 10.4% in sockets grafted with MGCSH mixed with PRP compared to 38.3% ± 9.3% collagen resorbable plug. There was no statistically significant difference in the amount of vertical and horizontal bone resorption (P >0.05) between groups. In all cases but two in the control group, implants were placed with primary stability. Conclusion: MGCSH mixed with PRP showed greater vital bone volume at 3 months with rapid enhancement of bone healing compared to PRP‐free collagen resorbable graft.     

Comparison of biomaterial implants in the dental socket: histological analysis in dogs

Background: Bone graft procedures have been used commonly in buco-maxillo-facial surgery. For this reason, many researchers have evaluated the bone substitutes.
Purpose: The present study evaluated soft and hard tissue reactions to two different hydroxyapatites HAs (synthetic HA and natural HA) and bioactive glass implanted into the sockets immediately after extraction.
Materials and Methods: First and third upper and lower premolars, on both sides, were extracted from six female dogs. The alveolar sockets were randomly assigned to four groups: Group 1 – control (unfilled), Group 2 – filled with synthetic hydroxyapatite, Group 3 – filled with bovine bone mineral (natural HA), and Group 4 – filled with bioactive glass. The animals were euthanized at 4 weeks ( n  = 2), 8 weeks ( n  = 2), and 28 weeks ( n  = 2) after extraction. The mandible and maxilla of each animal were removed for histological analysis to determine soft tissue reactions, newly formed bone, bone characteristics, and presence or absence of implanted materials.
Results: Most particles of synthetic hydroxyapatite had bone formation on their surface, although some particles showed a layer of fibrous connective tissue. The bovine bone mineral group exhibited particles partially replaced with bone formation. The bioactive glass group showed particles with a thin layer of calcified tissue, but was absent in some specimens, suggesting complete resorption.
Conclusion: All biomaterials had similar behavior. Bovine bone mineral, compared to synthetic hydroxyapatite and bioactive glass, showed a larger number of particles covered with osseous tissue. All biomaterials interfered with the socket repair process.     

Clinical-radiographic and histological evaluation of two hydroxyapatites in human extraction sockets: a pilot study

After tooth extraction the healing process involves bone resorption and soft tissue contraction, events that can compromise the ideal implant placement with functional and aesthetic limitations. Following tooth extraction, a socket preservation technique can limit bone resorption. This study evaluated two different types of hydroxyapatite (HA) grafting materials placed into fresh extraction sockets, 6 months after tooth extraction, histologically, clinically and radiographically. Ten extraction sockets from 10 patients were divided in two groups: 5 sockets received a biomimetic HA and 5 received nanocrystalline HA. After 6 months, before implant placement, samples from the grafted area were harvested and evaluated clinically, radiographically and histologically. The percentages of bone, osteoid areas and residual material in the two groups were not statistically different. All samples showed great variability with extensive bone formation and total material resorption or amounts of osteoid tissue that filled the spaces between the residual material particles. The authors did not find any differences between biomimetic and nanocrystalline HA and assume that, within the limits of this study, both these materials could be applied into fresh extraction sockets to limit bone resorption. A control material and a much larger sample size are needed to confirm these findings.     

羟基磷灰石种植体的动物实验研究

分别在兔子左下切牙远端人工制备牙槽窝,植入羟基磷灰石生物陶瓷种植体,分别于1、3、6个月处死兔子,制成标本在光镜及电镜下观察。种植体与骨组织1个月时为纤维性结合;3个月时大部分为骨性结合,少部分为纤维性结合;6个月时为骨性结合,有较多骨组织长入种植体内。另再拔除兔子上前牙,即刻将种值体植入牙槽窝内,同法观察。1个月时大部分为纤维性结合,根尖为骨性结合;3个月时为骨性结合,有较多骨组织长入种植体(多孔型)内;6个月时为骨性结合。生理性牙槽窝有利于种植体与周围组织的结合与稳固;多孔型比致密型固位快,可能与表面微孔有关;种植体与骨组织的结合是一种正合关系。     

纳米晶羟基磷灰石复合胶原材料在拔牙创修复中的作用

目的:探讨纳米晶羟基磷灰石复合胶原材料(nHAC)在拔牙创修复中的作用。方法:拔除12只成年狗两侧下颌第二及第三切牙,并去除牙槽间隔,一侧随即植入nHAC,对侧植入致密多晶羟基磷灰石微粒人工骨(HA)作为对照。于植入后4、8、12周分别取材,采用99mTc MDP核素骨显像、组织学观察、图像分析等方法比较两种植入材料在牙槽窝中的骨修复能力。结果:nHAC植入牙槽骨后,材料被逐渐降解吸收,新骨不断生成,12周后植入材料几乎完全被成熟的骨组织取代;图像分析结果显示不同时间nHAC组新骨形成的比值显著高于HA组(P<0.01);4、8、12周nHAC组浓聚程度均高于HA组。结论:nHAC在修复拔牙创缺损时比HA效果更好,是一种较为理想的骨替代材料。     

Extraction environment enhancement: critical evaluation of early socket healing in long-term barrier-protected extraction sockets

Resorption and remodeling of the alveolar bone occurs after periodontal disease, trauma, or tooth extraction. Loss of the functional apparatus can have a deleterious effect on the ability to place endosseous root-form implants into prosthetically ideal locations. As a result, there has been a trend toward socket preservation at the time of extraction. However, there has been limited investigation with histologic verification of results on types of materials used to preserve or augment extraction sockets. Minimizing bone loss after extractions enables an implant to be placed in an ideal orientation surrounded by bone, thereby increasing the longevity of the implant and associated prosthesis. The case reports presented detail clinical and histological results during the 3 to 6 months after a bone maintenance procedure that used a nonexpanded polytetrafluoroethylene barrier placed over an extraction socket with no graft material at the time of tooth extraction.     

Socket grafting with the use of autologous bone: an experimental study in the dog

Background: Studies in humans and animals have shown that following tooth removal (loss), the alveolar ridge becomes markedly reduced. Attempts made to counteract such ridge diminution by installing implants in the fresh extraction sockets were not successful, while socket grafting with anorganic bovine bone mineral prevented ridge contraction. Aim: To examine whether grafting of the alveolar socket with the use of chips of autologous bone may allow ridge preservation following tooth extraction. Methods: In five beagle dogs, the distal roots of the third and fourth mandibular premolars were removed. The sockets in the right or the left jaw quadrant were grafted with either anorganic bovine bone or with chips of autologous bone harvested from the buccal bone plate. After 3 months of healing, biopsies of the experimental sites were sampled, prepared for buccal–lingual ground sections and examined with respect to size and composition. Results: It was observed that the majority of the autologous bone chips during healing had been resorbed and that the graft apparently did not interfere with socket healing or processes that resulted in ridge resorption. Conclusion: Autologous bone chips placed in the fresh extraction socket will (i) neither stimulate nor retard new bone formation and (ii) not prevent ridge resorption that occurs during healing following tooth extraction. To cite this article:
Araújo MG, Lindhe J. Socket grafting with the use of autologous bone: an experimental study in the dog.
Clin. Oral Impl. Res. 22 , 2011; 9–13.
doi: 10.1111/j.1600‐0501.2010.01937.x     

Ridge preservation with the use of Bio-Oss® collagen: A 6-month study in the dog

Background: In previous short-term studies, it was observed that while the placement of biomaterial in alveolar sockets may promote bone formation and ridge preservation, the graft may in fact also delay healing.
Aim: The objective of the present experiment was to evaluate the more long-term effect on hard tissue formation and the amount of ridge augmentation that can occur by the placement of a xenogeneic graft in extraction sockets of dogs.
Material and methods: Five beagle dogs were used. The third mandibular premolars were hemi-sected. The distal roots were carefully removed. A graft consisting of Bio-Oss^® collagen was placed in one socket while the contra-lateral site was left without grafting. After 6 months of healing, the dogs were euthanized and biopsies were sampled. From each experimental site, four ground sections – two from the mesial root and two from the healed socket – were prepared, stained and examined under a microscope.
Results: The placement of Bio-Oss^® collagen in the fresh extraction socket served as a scaffold for tissue modeling but did not enhance new bone formation. In comparison with the non-grafted sites, the dimension of the alveolar process as well as the profile of the ridge was better preserved in Bio-Oss^®-grafted sites.
Conclusion: The placement of a biomaterial in an extraction socket may modify modeling and counteract marginal ridge contraction that occurs following tooth removal.     

Densitometric analysis of the autogenous demineralized dentin matrix on the dental socket wound healing process in humans

The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of the autogenous demineralized dentin matrix (ADDM) on the third molar socket wound healing process in humans, using the guided bone regeneration technique and a polytetrafluoroethylene barrier (PTFE). Twenty-seven dental sockets were divided into three groups: dental socket (Control), dental socket with PTFE barrier (PTFE), and dental socket with ADDM slices associated to PTFE barrier (ADDM + PTFE). The dental sockets were submitted to radiographic bone densitometry analysis and statistical analysis on the 15th, 30th, 60th and 90th days using analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Tukey's test (p < or = 0.05). The radiographic analysis of the ADDM + PTFE group showed greater homogeneity of bone radiopacity than the Control group and the PTFE group, during all the observation times. The dentin matrix gradually disappeared from the dental socket during the course of the repair process, suggesting its resorption during the bone remodeling process. It was concluded that the radiographic bone density of the dental sockets treated with ADDM was similar to that of the surrounding normal bone on the 90th day. The ADDM was biocompatible with the bone tissue of the surgical wounds of human dental sockets. The radiographic analysis revealed that the repair process was discreetly faster in the ADDM + PTFE group than in the Control and PTFE groups, although the difference was not statistically significant. In addition, the radiographic image of the ADDM + PTFE group suggested that its bone architecture was better than that of the Control and PFTE groups.     

Effect of a xenograft on early bone formation in extraction sockets: an experimental study in dog

Aim: The aim of this study was to study the effect on early bone formation resulting from the placement of a xenograft in the fresh extraction socket in dogs.
Material and methods: Five beagle dogs were used. The distal roots of the third and fourth mandibular premolars were removed. In one quadrant, a graft consisting of Bio-Oss^® Collagen was placed in the fresh extraction wound, while the corresponding premolar sites in the contra-lateral jaw quadrant were left non-grafted. After 2 weeks of healing, the dogs were perfused with a fixative, the mandibles removed, the experimental sites dissected, demineralized, sectioned in the mesio-distal plane and stained in hematoxyline–eosine.
Results: The central portion of the non-grafted sockets was occupied by a provisional matrix comprised of densely packed connective tissue fibers and mesenchymal cells. Apical and lateral to the provisional matrix, newly formed woven bone was found to occupy most of the sockets. In the apical part of the grafted sockets , no particles of the xenograft could be observed but newly formed bone was present in this portion of the experimental site. In addition, limited numbers of woven bone trabeculae occurred along the lateral socket walls. The central and marginal segments of the grafted sockets, however, were occupied by a non-mineralized connective tissue that enclosed Bio-Oss^® particles that frequently were coated by multinucleated cells.
Conclusions: The placement of Bio-Oss^® Collagen in the fresh extraction wound obviously delayed socket healing. Thus, after 2 weeks of tissue repair, only minute amounts of newly formed bone occurred in the apical and lateral borders of the grafted sockets, while large amounts of woven bone had formed in most parts of the non-grafted sites.     

Effect of Diode Laser on Healing of Tooth Extraction Socket: An Experimental Study in Rabbits

Objectives

To evaluate the effect of low-level laser therapy on healing of extracted tooth socket of healthy rabbits.

Design

The sample of this study was 20 male rabbits of 2–2.5 kg weight with age range of 8–12 months. Right and left lower first premolar teeth were extracted. The extraction sockets of lower right first premolar were irradiated with 0.9 W gallium-aluminum-arsenide (GaAlAs) diode laser for 5 min, immediately after extraction and then every 72 h for the next 12 days. The extraction socket of left side were not exposed to laser and served as a control. The animals were sacrificed after 7, 14, 30 and 45 days and the experimental and control sockets were removed from the harvested mandibles and prepared for haematoxylin and eosin staining and Masson’s stain. The prepared slides were examined under light microscope for histological and histomorphometric examination.

Results

The histological examination showed that diode laser-treated sockets demonstrated early formed new bone with faster maturation of primary bone to secondary bone as compared to non-treated control sockets. Histomorphometric analysis revealed a statistically significant increase in the density and volume of trabecular bone in laser-treated sockets than control sockets.

Conclusion

Diode laser application to tooth extraction socket has a positive effect on bone formation.