多巴反应性肌张力失常

目的提高对多巴反应性肌张力失常的认识与重视。方法描述近3年诊治的7例多巴反应性肌张力失常患者的临床表现、辅助检查与治疗结果并进行文献复习。结果7例患者均无家族史,发病年龄为6～29岁,平均(13.43±7.93)岁;其中4例患者诊断前的平均病程为1.5年,余3例患者病程较长,分别为47、25和16年。7例患者均为缓慢起病,表现为四肢发僵,活动困难或伴有肢体震颤、足趾屈曲及足内翻,临床症状晨轻暮重。体格检查发现,四肢肌张力呈强直性或齿轮样增高,双下肢腱反射活跃甚至亢进,4例病理征阳性。血清学、脑脊液、头部CT、MR以及神经电生理等各项辅助检查均于正常范围之内。小剂量多巴制剂对所有患者均有明显疗效,平均服用剂量为105.17mg/d,应用最长者达14年,且无须增加剂量。结论多巴反应性肌张力失常为罕见的遗传性运动障碍疾病,临床表现典型者诊断不难。小剂量多巴制剂有显著且持久的疗效;早期应用安坦、金刚烷胺等药物治疗也有效。应注意与帕金森病鉴别。     

Dopa-responsive dystonia: clinical, genetic, and biochemical studies]

Dopa-responsive dystonia (DRD) is a clinical syndrome characterized by childhood-onset dystonia and a dramatic and sustained response to low doses of levodopa. There are at least three causative genes for DRD: (1) the GCH1 gene on chromosome 14q22.1-q22.2, which encodes GTP cyclohydrolase I (GTPCH), the first enzyme in the biosynthetic pathway for tetrahydrobiopterin (BH4; the essential cofactor for tyrosine hydroxylase [THI]), (2) the TH gene on 11 p15.5, coding for the enzyme TH that catalyzes the rate-limiting step in the catecholamine biosynthesis, and (3) an as yet undefined gene on 14q13 (DYT14). In reports on DRD, in which conventional genomic DNA sequencing of GCH1 was conducted in a relatively large number of pedigrees, mutations in the coding region (including the splice sites) of this gene were found in approximately 60% (range: 49-79%) of DRD families. In our series, after conducting additional GCH1 testing (Southern blotting, cDNA sequencing, etc.) and TH analysis, 86% of families with DRD or dystonia with motor delay (an intermediate phenotype between GTPCH-deficient DRD [mild] and GTPCH-deficient hyperphenylalaninemia [severe]) had identifiable GCH1 or (rarely) TH mutations. Up to the present, only one pedigree with autosomal dominant DRD linked to the DYT14 locus has been reported. Neuropathological findings (no Lewy bodies and a normal population of cells with reduced melanin in the substantia nigra) in DRD patients with GTPCH dysfunction were similar to those in a patient with DYT14 dystonia. There have been no reports of autopsied patients with TH-deficient DRD. Neurochemical data suggest that striatal dopamine reduction in GTPCH-deficient DRD is caused not only by decreased TH activity resulting from a low cofactor (BH4) level but also by actual loss of TH protein without nerve terminal loss. This TH protein reduction in the striatum, especially in the putamen, may be due to a diminished regulatory effect of BH4 on stability (rather than expression) of TH molecules or to a dysfunction of TH protein transport from the substantia nigra to the striatum. The extent of striatal TH protein loss may be critical in determining DRD symptomatology and could contribute to gender-related incomplete penetrance of GCH1 mutations in GTPCH-deficient DRD families. Notwithstanding the discovery of the three causative loci for DRD, a therapeutic trial with low doses of levodopa is still the most practical approach to the diagnosis of this treatable disorder. The trial should be considered in all children with dystonic and/or parkinsonian symptoms or with unexplained gait disorders. Analyses of total biopterin and neopterin as well as neurotransmitter metabolites in CSF appear to be useful for the diagnosis of GTPCH-deficient DRD (the major form of DRD) and of TH-deficient DRD (the mild form of TH deficiency). Findings of the precise mechanism of striatal TH protein loss in GTPCH-deficient DRD, the actual status of dopaminergic systems in TH-deficient DRD, and the novel causative gene on the DYT14 locus will better define the pathogenesis of DRD.     

Dopa-responsive dystonia: [18F]dopa positron emission tomography.

The syndrome of dopa-responsive dystonia comprises a minority of patients with dystonia, yet it is of considerable diagnostic importance because patients respond dramatically to L-dopa therapy. Benefits from this treatment are lasting, and the problems associated with long-term L-dopa therapy in patients with Parkinson's disease are generally absent. It has been suggested that this condition is due to a defect in the dopamine synthetic pathway, which is bypassed when patients are treated with L-dopa. We have studied [18F]dopa uptake in 6 patients with classic dopa-responsive dystonia (5 familial patients and 1 sporadic patient), aged 18 to 66 years. Data have been analyzed according to a graphic approach, calculating an influx constant for each region studied. We have also studied a seventh, clinically atypical, patient with juvenile dystonia-parkinsonism. Similar data have been calculated for a group of 10 healthy control subjects and 10 patients with Parkinson's disease. The 6 patients with typical dopa-responsive dystonia had a modest but significant reduction in the uptake of tracer into both caudate and putamen, which indicates a defect in the decarboxylation, vesicular uptake, and storage of [18F]dopa. This argues against the proposition that dopa-responsive dystonia is due to an inherited defect of tyrosine hydroxylase alone. In the atypical patient, however, we found a greater reduction of [18F]dopa uptake into both caudate and putamen, comparable with that in patients with Parkinson's disease.     

Dopa-responsive dystonia -- the story so far

Dopa-responsive dystonia (DRD) is an eminently treatable condition and its recognition is therefore of crucial importance. In classical cases, the disease manifests in early childhood with walking problems due to dystonia of the lower limbs. The dystonia is frequently accompanied by "parkinsonian" features such as reduced facial expression or slowing of fine finger movements. Biochemically, the disorder is typically characterized by low levels of the neurotransmitter metabolite homovanillic acid and reduced levels of neopterin and tetrahydrobiopterin (BH4) in the cerebrospinal fluid. This is due to heterozygote mutations of the GTP cyclohydrolase I gene, which is the rate-limiting enzyme in the synthesis of BH4. BH4 is an essential co-factor for tyrosine hydroxylase (TH), the rate-limiting enzyme in the synthesis of dopamine. Reduced levels of BH4 lead to the dopamine-deficit syndrome DRD because of reduced TH activity. Other genes implicated in the pathogenesis of this disorder are the TH gene itself and the parkin gene. This article summarizes all relevant aspects of DRD including recent advances in the genetics of this disorder and the widening phenotype. Particular emphasis is given to clinically relevant aspects such as diagnostic difficulties and atypical presentations in infancy and early childhood.     

Dopa-responsive dystonia presenting as delayed and awkward gait

Dopa-responsive dystonia is a hereditary disease characterized by inadequate dopamine production. Autosomal-dominant cases result from mutations in the GCH1 gene, encoding guanosine triphosphate (GTP)-cyclohydrolase 1. The most common presenting manifestation is dystonia of a lower extremity, often worsening late in the day. The onset and clinical severity are variable, sometimes even within a single family. Gender effects on allele penetrance have been reported. We present a male toddler with dopa-responsive dystonia caused by an autosomal-dominant GCH1 mutation. Three other family members were also found to carry the mutation, with widely different functional consequences.     

Dopa-responsive dystonia is induced by a dominant-negative mechanism

Dopa-responsive dystonia (DRD) is induced by a deficiency of GTP cyclohydrolase I (GCH) and has a postulated autosomal dominant inheritance with a low penetrance. G201E is a dominant DRD mutation. Recombinant G201E mutant protein possessed very low enzyme activity. When G201E was expressed in eukaryotic cells, only a small amount of GCH protein could be detected. In baby hamster kidney cells, G201E protein was synthesized normally but was degraded rapidly in pulse-chase experiments. More interestingly, G201E dramatically decreased the level of wild-type protein and GCH activity in cotransfection studies. Therefore, G201E exerts a dominant-negative effect on the wild-type protein, probably going through an interaction between them. We also showed that L79P but not R249S (a recessive DRD mutation) had a dominant-negative effect. Through the dominant-negative mechanism, a single mutation could decrease GCH activity to less than 50% of normal. This study not only explains the inheritance of DRD but also increases the understanding of genetic diseases associated with multiple subunit proteins.     

Frequency of GCH1 deletions in Dopa-responsive dystonia

We performed a systematic study on the frequency of point mutations and deletions of the gene GCH1 in dopa-responsive dystonia (DRD). A total of 136 dystonia patients were studied. Fifty of these had a sustained response to oral L-Dopa therapy (group 1: definite diagnosis of DRD), whereas the response to L-Dopa was incomplete or not tested in 86 patients (group 2: possible diagnosis of DRD). We found a GCH1 point mutation in 27 patients of group 1 (54%) and in four patients of group 2 (5%). Of these, nine single and one double mutation have not been described before. GCH1 deletions were detected in four patients of group 1 (8%) and in one patient of group 2 (1%). Among GCH1 point-mutation-negative patients with a definite diagnosis of DRD (group 1), the frequency of GCH1 deletions was 17% (4/23). We conclude that GCH1 deletion analysis should be incorporated into the routine molecular diagnosis of all patients with DRD with a sustained response to L-Dopa.     

Dopa-responsive dystonia: A clinical and molecular genetic study

We have studied the GTP-cyclohydrolase 1 (GCH-1) gene in 30 patients with the diagnosis of clinically definite (n = 20) or possible (n = 10) dopa-responsive dystonia (DRD) as well as in a child with atypical phenylketonuria due to complete GCH-1 deficiency. A large number of new heterozygote mutations (seven point mutations, two splice site mutations and one deletion) as well as a new homozygote mutations in the child with atypical phenylketonuria were detecte. In addition, two previously described mutations wer found in two other cases. We further extended our investigation of GCH-1 to the 5′ and 3′ regulatory regions and report the first detection of point mutations in the 5′ untranslated region. Demethylation of CpG islands does not appear to be an important causative factor for the GCH-1 mutations in DRD. In addition, we have extended the clinical phenotype of genetically proven DRD to focal dystonia, dystonia with relapsing and remitting course, and DRD with onset in the first week of life. None of our DRD patients without a mutation in GCH-1 had the 3-bp deletion recently detected in DYT1, the causative gene for idiopathic torsion dystonia with linkage to 9q34.     

Dopa-responsive dystonia and Tourette syndrome in a large Danish family

BACKGROUND: Guanosine triphosphate cyclohydrolase I (GTPCH) catalyzes the first step in the synthesis of tetrahydrobiopterin (BH4). Autosomal dominantly inherited defects in the GTPCH gene (GCH1) cause a form of dystonia that is responsive to treatment with levodopa (dopa-responsive dystonia [DRD]). OBJECTIVE: To investigate molecular and clinical aspects of DRD in a large Danish family. METHODS: For analysis of the GCH1 gene, a mutation-scanning method based on denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) was used. A novel mutation, X251R, was identified in the GCH1 gene of 2 distantly related Danish patients with DRD, one of whom also had Tourette syndrome (TS). Thirty-five additional family members were investigated for this mutation, and 16 of them underwent clinical neurological examination. RESULTS: A total of 18 patients were heterozygous for the X251R allele, 16 of whom had neurological complaints spanning from very mild parkinsonism to severe invalidism due to dystonia. Of 13 symptomatic heterozygotes who had been neurologically examined, 10 had signs of dystonia or parkinsonism. Sixteen of the heterozygotes were treated with levodopa, and 13 reported a treatment benefit. Three of the symptomatic heterozygotes had signs of TS. CONCLUSIONS: This study confirms the large variability in DRD symptoms and emphasizes the usefulness of molecular analysis for diagnosis and treatment of DRD. The presence of TS is suggested to be coincidental, though the development of TS-like symptoms due to mutations in GCH1 cannot be excluded.     

Dopa-responsive dystonia: Pathological and biochemical observations in a case

We report the first neuropathological and neurochemical study of a patient with dopa-responsive dystonia. She had onset of foot dystonia at age 5 years and by age 8 years it was generalized with prominent right leg and arm involvement. On levodopa 750 mg daily she had complete symptomatic improvement that was sustained for 11 years until death. Pathological studies revealed normal numbers of hypopigmented substantia nigra neurons, normal tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) immunoreactivity and TH protein in the SN, no inclusion bodies or gliosis, and no evidence of a degenerative process in the striatum. Biochemical studies revealed reduced dopamine in the substantia nigra and striatum (8% in the putamen and 18% of control in the caudate) with a similar but not identical subregional distribution as in idiopathic Parkinson's disease. In the striatum, TH protein and TH activity was reduced, with the loss more pronounced in the putamen than the caudate. The GBR 12935 binding to DA transporter was normal in the caudate and at the lower end of the range of control values in the putamen. We conclude that disturbed dopamine synthetic capacity or a reduced arborization of striatal dopamine terminals may be the major disturbance in dopa-responsive dystonia.     

Dopa-responsive dystonia: recent advances and remaining issues to be addressed.

It is evident from this review that there is much that we know and much that we still do not know about DRD. In terms of diagnosis and clinical management, there is general agreement that patients with childhood-onset dystonic symptoms of unknown etiology should be treated initially with levodopa with the later addition, if necessary, of other medications (for example, BH4, 5-hydroxytryptophan). Although the results of molecular genetic and CSF studies are, at this time, unlikely to significantly alter clinical management of the patient, these analyses could be useful in providing information on prognosis (that is, DRD versus progressive neurodegenerative disorders or more severe metabolic disorders). It is also clear that notwithstanding the discovery of GCH1 and hTH mutations responsible for DRD, there remain many important unresolved issues regarding this disorder, including questions of female predominance, phenotypic heterogeneity, and presence of childhood-onset dystonia versus the expected parkinsonism resulting from a striatal DA deficit. We are confident that answers to these interesting questions on DRD will, in addition to providing clarification of the mechanisms of this disorder, provide exciting information relating to the pathogenesis of other types of dystonia as well as PD and to long-standing issues regarding a role of DA and serotonin in normal human brain development.     

Dopa-responsive dystonia due to a large deletion in the GTP cyclohydrolase I gene

Although it is assumed that most patients with autosomal dominant dopa-responsive dystonia (DRD) have a GTP cyclohydrolase I dysfunction, conventional genomic DNA sequencing of the gene (GCH1) coding for this enzyme fails to reveal any mutations in about 40% of DRD patients, which makes molecular genetic diagnosis difficult. We found a large heterozygous GCH1 deletion, which cannot be detected by the usual genomic DNA sequence analysis, in a three-generation DRD family and conclude that a large genomic deletion in GCH1 may account for some "mutation-negative" patients with dominantly inherited DRD.     

Dopa-responsive dystonia: the spectrum of clinical manifestations in a large North American family

We examined 106 members of a family affected with dopa-responsive dystonia (DRD), a subset of idiopathic dystonia. Ten members had unequivocal dystonia; 8 of these had generalized dystonia and the other 2 had focal dystonias (writer's cramp and spastic dysphonia). Twenty members had lesser dystonic signs and symptoms suggestive of a diagnosis of dystonia. Five members, including 1 with dystonia, had prominent parkinsonism that became symptomatic in late adulthood. All members affected with dystonia or parkinsonism had increased muscle tone (rigidity), which may represent the minimal clinical expression of DRD. Gene penetrance in families with DRD may be greater than previously suspected.     

Dopa-responsive dystonia with depigmentation of the substantia nigra and formation of Lewy bodies.

The patient, who died at 23 years of age, was first diagnosed when she was 12 year old as having a dopa-responsive dystonia with decreased concentrations of monoamine metabolites in the cerebrospinal fluid. Also the concentrations of other neurotransmitters including somatostatin, substance P and metenkefalin were lowered indicating a more widespread damage of the cerebral neurotransmitter systems. At autopsy the brain was essentially intact except for pronounced gliosis and extreme loss of melanotic nerve cells in the substantia nigra. Several remaining nerve cells showed the presence of Lewy bodies.     

Dopa-responsive dystonia simulating spastic paraplegia due to tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) gene mutations

Spastic paraplegia is not widely recognized to occur in dopa-responsive dystonia (DRD). The authors found a compound heterozygote for novel mutations of the human tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) gene (TH). The patient was initially diagnosed as having spastic paraplegia, but responded completely to levodopa therapy. Exercise-induced stiffness in the patient's father, who had a TH deletion, also responded to levodopa. The data expand the clinical spectrum of TH deficiency and suggest that TH mutations may account for some patients with DRD simulating spastic paraplegia.     

Dopa-responsive childhood dystonia: a forme fruste with writer's cramp; triggered by exercise

An 11-year-old girl was evaluated for walking difficulties and fatigue at the end of the day in the last 2 years. Handwriting was also difficult with 'cramps' after a short time of writing. Neurological examination was normal most of the time but in the evening and after exercise, an abnormal walking posture and rare dystonic movements of the foot could sometimes be seen. The mother was found to have mild parkinsonism and is asymptomatic on L-dopa. In the daughter, all symptoms and signs disappeared on L-dopa, but returned when the drug was withdrawn. The changes on- and off-treatment were documented with videofilms and computerized analysis of writing samples. The situation has been stable during a 5-year follow-up. We draw attention to this 'forme fruste' of dopa-sensitive childhood dystonia which becomes manifest with exercise and which can easily go unrecognized. We also discuss and illustrate the methods used for the analysis of writing.     

Dopa-sensitive dystonia]

Dopa-sensitive dystonia has been recognised for twenty years. It may occur in the first years of life. It first affects the lower limbs, then generalized becomes, as in torsion dystonia. Eight clinical cases are presented in five boys and three girls. The absence of the disorder in the parents, but its presence in siblings in three cases suggests that it might be recessively inherited. The symptoms are severe enough to cause major functional disability. In some cases, the intensity of the motor disorder varies during the days being, less pronounced in the morning or after a nap and more marked in the evening. Nonetheless, this feature is not constant and thus cannot be considered as an essential diagnostic criterion. Treatment with levodopa gives remarkable and durable results, but it must be continued indefinitely. Abnormal movements accompany an overdose but regress when the dosage is decreased. Unlike Parkinson's disease, it is not necessary to increase or fragment doses to avoid fluctuations in the efficacy of treatment during the day. On the contrary, after several years of the illness a decrease in daily dosage sometimes to a single dose is possible. Discontinuing treatment leads to reappearance of dystonia after two or three days. There are no established biological criteria to aid diagnosis. However, a decrease in urine levels of homovanillic acid was observed in two cases. Dopa-sensitive dystonia should be regarded as distinct from juvenile Parkinson's disease, firstly because of its symptomatology and secondly, and more importantly, because of its particular course, since fluctuations in therapeutic efficacy are never observed. It is the only known example of dopaminergic insufficiency that is chronically almost completely controlled by a modest exogenous supply of levodopa.