Analysis of the IgV(H) somatic mutations in splenic marginal zone lymphoma defines a group of unmutated cases with frequent 7q deletion and adverse clinical course

This study aimed to correlate the frequency of somatic mutations in the IgV(H) gene and the use of specific segments in the V(H) repertoire with the clinical and characteristic features of a series of 35 cases of splenic marginal zone lymphoma (SMZL). The cases were studied by seminested polymerase chain reaction by using primers from the FR1 and J(H) region. The results showed unexpected molecular heterogeneity in this entity, with 49% unmutated cases (less than 2% somatic mutations). The 7q31 deletions and a shorter overall survival were more frequent in this group. Additionally a high percentage (18 of 40 sequences) of SMZL cases showed usage of the V(H)1-2 segment, thereby emphasizing the singularity of this neoplasia, suggesting that this tumor derives from a highly selected B-cell population and encouraging the search for specific antigens that are pathogenically relevant in the genesis or progression of this tumor.     

Analysis of IgV gene mutations in B cell chronic lymphocytic leukaemia according to antigen-driven selection identifies subgroups with different prognosis and usage of the canonical somatic hypermutation machinery

Cases of B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (B-CLL) with mutated (M) IgV(H) genes have a better prognosis than unmutated (UM) cases. We analysed the IgV(H) mutational status of B-CLL according to the features of a canonical somatic hypermutation (SHM) process, correlating this data with survival. In a series of 141 B-CLLs, 124 cases were examined for IgV(H) gene per cent mutations and skewing of replacement/silent mutations in the framework/complementarity-determining regions as evidence of antigen-driven selection; this identified three B-CLL subsets: significantly mutated (sM), with evidence of antigen-driven selection, not significantly mutated (nsM) and UM, without such evidence and IgV(H) gene per cent mutations above or below the 2% cut-off. sM B-CLL patients had longer survival within the good prognosis subgroup that had more than 2% mutations of IgV(H) genes. sM, nsM and UM B-CLL were also characterized for the biased usage of IgV(H) families, intraclonal IgV(H) gene diversification, preference of mutations to target-specific nucleotides or hotspots, and for the expression of enzymes involved in SHM (translesion DNA polymerase zeta and eta and activation-induced cytidine deaminase). These findings indicate the activation of a canonical SHM process in nsM and sM B-CLLs and underscore the role of the antigen in defining the specific clinical and biological features of B-CLL.     

Immunoglobulin heavy chain genes somatic hypermutations and chromosome 11q22-23 deletion in classic mantle cell lymphoma: a study of the Swiss Group for Clinical Cancer Research

Mantle cell lymphoma (MCL) shares immunophenotypic and karyotypic features with chronic lymphocytic leukaemia. The latter comprises two distinct entities with prognosis dependent upon immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) gene mutational status and the presence of 11q deletion. We evaluated the relevance of IgH gene mutational status, IgV gene family usage and presence of 11q deletion in a series of 42 histologically reviewed classical MCL cases to determine the prognostic impact. VH3 was the most common VH family, with VH3-21 being the most frequent individual VH gene. Approximately 30% of the cases had a IgH somatic mutation rate higher than 2%, but was only higher than 4% in <10% of cases. Half of the cases had deletion of chromosome 11q21-telomere (11q21->ter), with two minimal deleted regions, at 11q22.2 and 11q23.2. There was no association between 11q loss and IgH gene somatic mutation rate; the use of VH3-21 gene could be associated with a better prognosis.     

Immunoglobulin gene segment usage, location and immunogenicity in mutated and unmutated chronic lymphocytic leukaemia

The mutational status of the variable region of the immunoglobulin heavy chain gene (IgV(H)) is an important prognostic marker in B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (B-CLL), with mutated patients having improved outcome. To examine the impact of mutational status on V(H), D(H), and J(H) gene segment location and immunogenicity, we analysed 375 IgH sequences from 356 patients with B-CLL. Although V(H) and D(H) gene usage was different in mutated compared to unmutated patients, there was no impact of gene location on frequency of use or clinical outcome. Surprisingly, somatic mutations did not increase the immunogenicity of the Ig, as assessed by predicted binding affinity of Ig-derived peptides to major histocompatibility Class I and Class II molecules. Even excluding patients using V(H)1-69, cases using the V(H)1 gene family had a poor outcome. Both mutated and unmutated CLL patients demonstrated evidence of antigen selection. The worst outcome was seen in the subset of 14 unmutated patients with similar HCDR3 amino acid sequence using V(H)1-69, D(H)3-3 and J(H)6, suggesting an antigen-driven process modulating the clinical course.     

Somatically mutated Ig V(H)3-21 genes characterize a new subset of chronic lymphocytic leukemia

Recent studies on the immunoglobulin variable heavy chain (IgV(H)) genes have revealed that B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia (B-CLL) consists of at least 2 clinical entities with either somatically mutated or unmutated V(H) genes. We have analyzed the V(H) gene mutation status and V(H) gene usage in 119 B-CLL cases and correlated them to overall survival. A novel finding was the preferential use of the V(H)3-21 gene in mutated cases, whereas biased V(H)1-69 gene usage was found in unmutated cases as previously reported. Interestingly, the subset of mutated cases using the V(H)3-21 gene displayed distinctive genotypic/phenotypic characteristics with shorter average length of the complementarity determining region 3 and clonal expression of lambda light chains. In addition, this mutated subset showed significantly shorter survival than other mutated cases and a similar clinical course to unmutated cases. We therefore suggest that B-CLL cases with mutated V(H)3-21 genes may constitute an additional entity of B-CLL.     

Is there a role for antigen selection in mantle cell lymphoma? Immunogenetic support from a series of 807 cases

We examined 807 productive IGHV-IGHD-IGHJ gene rearrangements from mantle cell lymphoma (MCL) cases, by far the largest series to date. The IGHV gene repertoire was remarkably biased, with IGHV3-21, IGHV4-34, IGHV1-8, and IGHV3-23 accounting for 46.3% of the cohort. Eighty-four of 807 (10.4%) cases, mainly using the IGHV3-21 and IGHV4-34 genes, were found to bear stereotyped heavy complementarity-determining region 3 (VH CDR3) sequences and were placed in 38 clusters. Notably, the MCL stereotypes were distinct from those reported for chronic lymphocytic leukemia. Based on somatic hypermutation (SHM) status, 238/807 sequences (29.5%) carried IGHV genes with 100% germ line identity; the remainder (569/807; 70.5%) exhibited different SHM impact, ranging from minimal (in most cases) to pronounced. Shared replacement mutations across the IGHV gene were identified for certain subgroups, especially those using IGHV3-21, IGHV1-8, and IGHV3-23. Comparison with other entities, in particular CLL, revealed that several of these mutations were "MCL-biased." In conclusion, MCL is characterized by a highly restricted immunoglobulin gene repertoire with stereotyped VH CDR3s and very precise SHM targeting, strongly implying a role for antigen-driven selection of the clonogenic progenitors. Hence, an antigen-driven origin of MCL could be envisaged, at least for subsets of cases.     

VH mutation status and VDJ rearrangement structure in mantle cell lymphoma: correlation with genomic aberrations,clinical characteristics,and outcome

Immunoglobulin variable heavy chain gene (VH) mutation status and VDJ rearrangement structure were analyzed in 141 patients with mantle cell lymphoma (MCL) and correlated with biologic and clinical characteristics; 29% of the MCLs displayed mutated VH using a 98% germline homology cutoff. Striking differences occurred in the VH mutation subgroups with respect to the use of specific V genes. Rearrangements involving V4-34 and V3-21 were almost exclusively unmutated, whereas rearrangements using V4-59 and V3-23 were typically mutated. Significant association occurred between mutated VH with shorter CDR3 lengths and the use of JH4b. V3-21 and V4-59 were involved in highly characteristic rearrangements, implying that antigen specificity might have been involved in MCL development. There was no evidence for isotype switch recombination or Bcl-6 expression in any MCL. ZAP70 expression was not different in VH-mutated or -unmutated MCL. Although the deletions 11q- and 17p- showed a balanced distribution, an overrepresentation was observed for trisomies +3q, +8q, and tetraploidy in the VH-unmutated subgroup and +12q in the VH-mutated subgroup. Clinically, mutated VH was associated with a higher rate of complete remission, but there was no correlation between VH mutation status and other clinical characteristics or overall survival.     

CD38 expression and immunoglobulin variable region mutations are independent prognostic variables in chronic lymphocytic leukemia, but CD38 expression may vary during the course of the disease.

Although the presence or absence of somatic mutations in the immunoglobulin variable region (IgV(H)) genes in chronic lymphocytic leukemia (B-CLL) identifies subtypes with very different prognoses, the assay is technically complex and unavailable to most laboratories. CD38 expression has been suggested as a surrogate marker for the 2 subtypes. IgV(H) mutations and CD38 expression in 145 patients with B-CLL with a long follow-up were compared. The 2 assays gave discordant results in 41 patients (28.3%). Multivariate analysis demonstrated that Binet stage, IgV(H) mutations and CD38 were independent prognostic indicators. Median survival time in patients whose cells had unmutated IgV(H) genes and expressed CD38 was 8 years; in those with mutated IgV(H) genes not expressing CD38, it was 26 years. For those with discordant results, median survival time was 15 years. Thus, although CD38 expression does not identify the same 2 subsets as IgV(H) mutations in CLL, it is an independent risk factor that can be used with IgV(H) mutations and clinical stage to select patients with B-CLL with the worst prognoses. Using cryopreserved cells taken at intervals during the course of the disease, however, changes of CD38 expression over time were demonstrated in 10 of 41 patients. Causes of the variation of CD38 expression require further study. Additional prospective studies are required for comparing CD38 expression with other prognostic factors and for taking sequential measurements during the course of the disease.     

Analysis of immunoglobulin V genes suggests cutaneous marginal zone B-cell lymphomas recognise similar antigens

Extranodal marginal zone B-cell lymphomas (EMZL) are thought to develop from reactive infiltrates that represent immune responses to external or auto-antigens. Except for gastric EMZL, the antigenic triggers of EMZL development are mostly unknown, although a subset of cutaneous EMZL have been associated with Borrelia burgdorferi infections. To further evaluate whether a common antigen may be promoting the development of cutaneous EMZL, the immunoglobulin heavy chain variable (V(H)) genes from eight USA cases were sequenced and analysed. All used V(H)3 family gene segments, with 2/8 using the same V3-30 segment, 2/8 using the closely related V3-30.3 or V3-33 segments, 6/8 containing mutations and 2/7 showing evidence of ongoing mutation. Many of the complimentarity-determining region 3s (CDR3s) also showed similarities in length and displayed conserved amino acid motifs in the non-templated areas between the diversity and joining segments. The use of similar V(H) gene segments and conserved CDR3 amino acid motifs suggests that some of these cutaneous EMZL may bind the same or similar antigen via their surface immunoglobulin receptor. Analysis of the somatic mutations present in many of the V(H) genes was also consistent with antigen directly stimulating the growth of cutaneous EMZL.     

IgV gene intraclonal diversification and clonal evolution in B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukaemia

Intraclonal diversification of immunoglobulin (Ig) variable (V) genes was evaluated in leukaemic cells from a B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (B-CLL) case over a 2-year period at four time points. Intraclonal heterogeneity was analysed by sequencing 305 molecular clones derived from polymerase chain reaction amplification of B-CLL cell IgV heavy (H) and light (C) chain gene rearrangements. Sequences were compared with evaluating intraclonal variation and the nature of somatic mutations. Although IgV intraclonal variation was detected at all time points, its level decreased with time and a parallel emergence of two more represented V(H)DJ(H) clones was observed. They differed by nine nucleotide substitutions one of which only caused a conservative replacement aminoacid change. In addition, one V(L)J(L) rearrangement became more represented over time. Analyses of somatic mutations suggest antigen selection and impairment of negative selection of neoplastic cells. In addition, a genealogical tree representing a model of clonal evolution of the neoplastic cells was created. It is of note that, during the period of study, the patient showed clinical progression of disease. We conclude that antigen stimulation and somatic hypermutation may participate in disease progression through the selection and expansion of neoplastic subclone(s).     

Analysis of expressed immunoglobulin heavy chain genes in familial B-CLL

In this study, we wished to determine whether familial chronic lymphocytic leukemia of B-cell phenotype (CLL) shares with sporadic B-CLL the same immunoglobulin (Ig) heavy chain variable region (VH) gene usage and occurrence of somatic mutation, to gain insight into the pathogenetic relatedness of these epidemiologically distinct forms of CLL. We therefore analyzed the expressed Ig heavy chain genes in 23 cases (11 families) of familial CLL, and compared these results with data previously reported for sporadic CLL. In addition, we assessed the relationship of the occurrence of somatic mutation to several clinical and phenotypic features. The distribution of V genes among these cases was similar to that observed in sporadic CLL: VH3 > VH1 > VH4. Thirteen of the 23 cases (57%) showed germ line VH gene sequences, whereas somatic mutations were detected in 10 cases (43%). The average mutation frequency of these latter 10 cases of was 6.7% (ranging from 1.7% to 8.8%), and evidence of antigen selection was noted in 6. Intraclonal variation, followed by clonal evolution and the appearance of a second clone over a 20-year period was observed in 1 case, suggesting that mutations can continue to accumulate after neoplastic transformation. The presence of somatic mutations correlated with age at presentation, low white blood cell (WBC) count, and low fluorescence intensity of surface CD5, and the potential significance of these relationships is discussed. Our data indicate that familial and sporadic B-CLL display a similar pattern of immunoglobulin gene usage and frequency of somatic mutation, and are consistent with a common ontogeny and immunogenetic origin for these 2 epidemiologically distinct forms of CLL. (Blood. 2000;95:1413-1419)     

Variable heavy chain gene analysis of follicular lymphomas: correlation between heavy chain isotype expression and somatic mutation load

The expansion of follicular lymphomas (FLs) resembles, both morphologically and functionally, normal germinal center B-cell growth. The tumor cells proliferate in networks of follicular dendritic cells and are believed to be capable of somatic hypermutation and isotype switching. To investigate the relation between somatic mutation and heavy chain isotype expression, we analyzed the variable heavy (V(H)) chain genes of 30 FL samples of different isotypes. The V(H) genes of the FLs were heavily mutated (29.3 mutations on average). In addition, isotype-switched lymphomas contained more somatic mutations than immunoglobulin M-positive lymphomas (33.8 mutations per V(H) gene versus 23.0, respectively). In all but one of the FLs, the ratios of replacement versus silent mutations in the framework regions were low, independent of the absolute number of somatic mutations and the level of intraclonal variation. Analysis of relapse samples of 4 FLs showed no obvious increase in somatic mutation load in most FLs and a decrease in intraclonal variation in time. In 3 of 4 cases, we obtained evidence for selection of certain subclones, rather than clonal evolution. Our findings question if intraclonal variation is always a reflection of ongoing somatic hypermutation. This may have implications for the concept of antigen-driven lymphomagenesis. (Blood. 2000;95:2922-2929)     

Nodal marginal zone B-cell lymphomas may arise from different subsets of marginal zone B lymphocytes

Nodal marginal zone B-cell lymphoma (MZL) is a rare and not extensively studied entity that accounts for approximately 2% of all non-Hodgkin lymphomas. Complementarity-determining regions 2 and 3 (CDR2, CDR3) of the immunoglobulin heavy-chain variable region (V(H)) genes were amplified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR), cloned, and sequenced in 8 patients with nodal MZL. All showed a potentially functional V(H) rearrangement. The use of V(H) gene families was unbiased and without overrepresentation of any particular V(H) gene or gene family. The presence of somatic V(H) mutations was detected, with a deviation from the closest germ line sequence ranging from 4% to 17% in 6 of 8 patients. In 3 mutations, the replacement-to-silent mutation ratio suggested the presence of an antigen-selected process. Sequencing different subclones of the same cloned PCR products allowed the detection of intraclonal variability in 4 analyzed patients. The observed pattern of V(H) mutations suggested that nodal MZL, formerly deemed a malignancy of memory B cells, may arise from different subsets of marginal zone B cells-the naive B cells that express unmutated V(H) genes-from memory B cells showing somatic mutations without intraclonal variation, and from germinal center B cells defined by their capacity to undergo the somatic hypermutation process. (Blood. 2001;98:781-786)     

Somatic mutation of bcl-6 genes can occur in the absence of V(H) mutations in chronic lymphocytic leukemia

Somatic mutation in immunoglobulin variable (V) region genes occurs largely in the germinal center and, after neoplastic transformation, imprints V genes of B-cell tumors with the mutational history of the cell of origin. Recently, it has been found that chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) consists of 2 subsets, each with a different clinical course, one with unmutated V(H) genes consistent with a naive B cell, and the other with mutated V(H) genes consistent with transit through the germinal center. However, somatic mutation also occurs at another distinct locus, the 5' noncoding region of the bcl-6 gene, in both B-cell tumors and in normal germinal center B cells. To probe the suggestive link between the occurrence of mutations in V(H) and bcl-6 genes, we analyzed the nature of somatic mutation at these distinct loci in the 2 CLL subsets. Unexpectedly, we found no such link in the CLLs defined by unmutated V(H) genes, with 4 of 10 cases clearly showing mutations in bcl-6. In those CLLs defined by somatically mutated V(H) genes, 4 of 9 cases predictively showed bcl-6 mutations. The frequency of bcl-6 mutations was comparable in both subsets, with mutations being biallelic, and in 3 of 8 cases indicative of clonal origins. Surprisingly, intraclonal variation, which is not a feature of V(H) genes in CLL, was found in 6 of 8 cases in both subsets. These data indicate that somatic mutation of the V(H) and bcl-6 loci may not necessarily occur in tandem in CLL, suggesting diverse pathways operating on the 2 genes.     

Somatic hypermutation and V(H) gene usage in mantle cell lymphoma

Abstract: Mantle cell lymphoma (MCL) is considered to derive from naïve, pregerminal center (GC) CD5⁺ B‐cells. However, the cell of origin has been questioned in recent studies that showed somatic hypermutations in the immunoglobulin (Ig) variable heavy chain (V_H) genes in subsets of MCL. To clarify this issue, we analyzed the IgV_H genes for the presence of somatic hypermutations in 51 MCL cases. Twenty percent of the MCL cases displayed somatically mutated V_H genes (defined as >2% mutated), whereas 80% showed unmutated V_H genes. This finding suggests that MCL is a genetically heterogeneous disease, with the majority of cases originating from unmutated pre‐GC B‐cells and a subset deriving from more mature B‐cells which have been exposed to the GC environment and have undergone somatic hypermutation. A biased V_H gene usage has been demonstrated in several B‐cell malignancies; however, this has not yet been investigated in MCL, although V_H4‐34 overusage has been indicated by small studies. Interestingly, we found a restricted usage of three individual V_H genes in our MCL material; V_H4‐34 (22%), V_H3‐21 (16%) and V_H5‐51 (12%). This novel finding of preferential V_H gene usage in half of the MCL cases may suggest an antigen driven process occurring in B‐cells expressing specific V_H genes, thus implicating that Ig specificity could be involved in mantle cell lymphoma development.     

Subsets with restricted immunoglobulin gene rearrangement features indicate a role for antigen selection in the development of chronic lymphocytic leukemia

We recently identified a chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) subgroup using the immunoglobulin variable heavy-chain (V(H)) gene V(H)3-21 with almost identical heavy-chain complementarity determining region 3s (HCDR3s) and preferential variable light-chain (V(L)) gene usage, suggesting recognition of a common antigen epitope in this subset. To further explore the B-cell receptors (BCRs) in CLL, we characterized 407 V(H) rearrangements amplified from 346 CLLs regarding V(H), diversity (D), and joining (J(H)) gene usage and performed multiple alignment of the HCDR3 sequences. These analyses revealed 3 small subsets (2 V(H)1-69 groups, 7 cases; and 1 V(H)1-2 group, 5 cases) with highly restricted HCDR3 features including identical V(H)/D/J(H) usage, HCDR3 lengths, and shared N-sequences, in addition to the V(H)3-21 group (22 cases). Furthermore, another 3 groups (9 V(H)1-3(+) cases, 3 V(H)1-18(+) cases, and 5 V(H)4-39(+) cases) had essentially identical V(H)/D/J(H) use and similar HCDR3 lengths but less conserved N-regions. Analysis in all 6 of these subgroups showed restriction in V(L) gene use, whereas no association between V(H) and V(L) usage was found in cases without HCDR3 similarities. Altogether, structurally similar HCDR3s associated with preferential V(L) gene usage implies selection of BCRs, especially in subsets showing high HCDR3 similarities, thus pointing to restricted antigen recognition sites and possibly involvement of specific antigens in CLL development.     

VH gene usage by family members affected with chronic lymphocytic leukaemia

The excess risk of chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (CLL) in the first-degree relatives of affected patients suggests that familial CLL might constitute a useful model to study the pathogenesis of this disease, as has been demonstrated in numerous other neoplastic disorders. Previous studies have shown non-random utilization of immunoglobulin genes in CLL, some germline in sequence and others containing numerous somatic mutations. To investigate whether familial cases of CLL exhibit similarities in the composition of the B-cell receptor repertoire to the pattern expressed by CLL patients as a whole, we have studied 25 CLL patients belonging to 12 different families (four French and eight Italian), each of which contained at least two affected members. Among familial cases, VH gene segment utilization proved non-random and diverged from the frequencies previously reported among unrelated patients with CLL. Specifically, although the 4-34 and 5-51 gene segments were found repeatedly, the 1-69 and 4-39 gene segments were used sparingly and the 3-23 gene segment presented with increased frequency. Following the pattern detected in studies of unrelated patients, the single 1-69 expressing CLL contained an unmutated H chain sequence and included a long HCDR3 interval. In contrast, 3-23 containing H chains all used JH4, retained at most 93% homology with germline sequence, and included only short HCDR3 intervals. The vast majority of the CLL variable domains contained a high degree of somatic mutation and exhibited an excess of replacement mutations in the CDR intervals. These findings suggest that familial CLL cases may preferentially derive from B-cell progenitors that have responded to antigen.     

Mutated VH genes and preferential VH3-21 use define new subsets of mantle cell lymphoma

Mantle cell lymphoma (MCL) is believed to originate from a naive B cell. However, we recently demonstrated that a subset of MCL displayed mutated V(H) genes. We also reported restricted use of certain V(H) genes. To assess the prognostic impact of these new findings, we performed V(H) gene analysis of 110 patients, revealing that 18 (16%) patients had mutated and 92 (84%) patients had unmutated V(H) genes. Because the mutation rate was low in the mutated group (2.2%-6.7%), further investigation of the germline V(H) gene in T cells from 5 patients with mutated V(H) genes was carried out; results showed that the unrearranged V(H) gene was identical to the published sequence. These data confirm that the base pair substitutions within the rearranged V(H) genes represent hypermutations, and indicate germinal center exposure. However, V(H) gene mutation status did not correlate with prognosis because there was no difference in clinical outcome between the unmutated and mutated groups. The most frequently used V(H) genes were V(H)3-21 (21 patients) and V(H)4-34 (19 patients). A novel finding was that V(H)3-21(+) MCL almost exclusively expressed lambda light chains and displayed highly restricted use of the V(lambda)3-19 gene. V(H)3-21(+) patients had longer median survival than the remaining patients (53 vs 34 months; P =.03), but they tended to be younger at diagnosis. The combined use of V(H)3-21/V(lambda)3-19 suggests a possible role for antigen(s) in the pathogenesis of these tumors and indicates that V(H)3-21(+) patients constitute a new MCL entity.