Current Approaches for Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

With advancement in biomechanical and biological research on idiopathic carpal tunnel syndrome, the insight on the pathophysiology of carpal tunnel syndrome has gained much clinical relevance. Open carpal tunnel release is still a gold standard procedure for carpal tunnel syndrome, which has evolved into mini-open procedure with development of new devices. Endoscopic carpal tunnel release has become popular in recent practice of hand surgery with an advantage of early recovery of hand function with minimal morbidity. However, endoscopic carpal tunnel release has its own limitation such as long learning curve with obvious surgical risk reported in the literature. In this review article, various treatment protocols for idiopathic carpal tunnel syndrome are presented with special highlight on endoscopic carpal tunnel release, which is gaining popularity in current practice.     

Carpal tunnel syndrome: Unusual contraindications to endoscopic release

Endoscopic carpal tunnel release has become an increasingly popular method of surgical treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome. Consequently, the contraindications to this technically challenging procedure continue to evolve. We describe two patients with carpal tunnel syndrome and unusual anomalies and pathology of the hook of the hamate that we believe represent relative or absolute contraindications to endoscopic carpal tunnel release.     

Multistate Comparison of Cost,Trends, and Complications in Open Versus Endoscopic Carpal Tunnel Release

Background: Surgical carpal tunnel release is performed by either open carpal tunnel release (OCTR) or endoscopic carpal tunnel release (ECTR). The purpose of this study was to assess differences in intraoperative and postoperative complications, trends, and costs between OCTR and ECTR. Methods: State Ambulatory Surgery and Services Databases (SASD) files for California, Florida, and New Jersey were queried for patients who underwent OCTR and ECTR between 2000 and 2014. Patient demographics, comorbidities, intraoperative and postoperative complications, and cost were compared between OCTR and ECTR. The frequency of each procedure was used to formulate trends in OCTR and ECTR. Results: A total of 571 403 patients were included in this study. Sex was significantly different by a small percentage (OCTR = 64.8% female, ECTR = 65.4% female). A higher proportion of Hispanic patients underwent ECTR (P < .001). The patients who underwent OCTR had a greater comorbidity burden in terms of diabetes and rheumatoid arthritis (P < .001). None of the aforementioned complication rates were statistically significant between the 2 procedures. Endoscopic carpal tunnel release was significantly more costly by almost $2000. Open carpal tunnel release has remained stable over the years studied, whereas ECTR increased 3-fold. Conclusions: Our findings demonstrate no significant differences between OCTR and ECTR regarding intraoperative and postoperative complications and patient outcomes. Endoscopic carpal tunnel release was found to be significantly more costly.     

Endoscopic Carpal Tunnel Release

On the basis of clinical outcome measures, endoscopic carpal tunnel release is an effective operation for treating idiopathic carpal tunnel syndrome. Patients who have undergone bilateral carpal tunnel operations have routinely preferred endoscopic release over the open release. An endoscopic release allows many patients to return to work sooner. However, the benefits of more rapid functional recovery and return to work are tempered by the increased cost and higher complication rate of the procedure. Endoscopic carpal tunnel release is a technically demanding procedure with low tolerances for error. Despite its widespread use, its role is not yet clearly defined.     

Carpal tunnel release via limited palmar incision

The limited incision carpal tunnel release provides an effective, reliable, and safe method for decompression of the median nerve at the wrist. The technique described above minimizes risk of complication through the design of the instruments and conceptual approach to the anatomy and surgical exposure. This method combines the reduced postoperative pain and quicker recovery of the ECTR technique with the safety and lower operative expense of the conventional open technique.     

痛风石致腕管综合征的手术治疗

目的 探讨痛风石导致腕管综合征的临床特点及手术治疗效果.方法 回顾性分析2017年10月至2019年12月于复旦大学附属华山医院手外科接受手术治疗的16例(17侧)痛风石致腕管综合征病人的临床资料,痛风病程(7.68±5.48)年,腕管综合征病程(5.22±2.24)个月.术中7侧可见正中神经局部压痕,9侧痛风石广泛包...     

Carpal tunnel release using the Paine retinaculotome inserted through a palmar incision

Background

Carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) is the most commonly diagnosed and treated entrapment neuropathy. There is no consensus regarding the optimal technique for carpal tunnel release. The objective of this study is to demonstrate the surgical treatment of CTS by a small palmar incision and utilization of Paine retinaculotome to divide the transverse carpal ligament.

Methods

In this technical note, we describe the use of a retinaculotome described by Paine in 1955, through a palmar approach.

Discussion

Open, minimally invasive and endoscopic surgical techniques have all been described as treatment options for CTS, and short-term success with these methods is well established. During the last decade, less invasive techniques have been developed in order to reduce the incidence of pillar pain and tender scars. We have used a mini-palmar incision and the Paine retinaculotome for carpal tunnel release since 1994. The goals of surgery are to create a small incision that permits a patient to have early motion and return to activity.

Conclusion

After many years, no permanent nerve or vascular damage has been reported. This method has demonstrated itself to be efficient and safe in the treatment of the carpal tunnel syndrome.     

腕管综合征在内窥镜视下手术与常规手术的疗效比较

目的 对腕管综合征在内窥镜视下手术与常规手术的疗效进行比较。方法 内窥镜组４０例４４腕,常规手术组４０例４４腕。术前按滨田分类方法分为３类。两组分别在术后１个月、３个月、１２个月进行随访。根据Ｋｅｌｌｙ功能评定标准对各型进行功能评价。结果内窥镜组各型患者术后１个月时,功能恢复速度稍慢于常规手术组,３个月两后两组功能则完全相同。结论 两组的手术入路不同,但术后３个月时的疗效却相同。但内窥镜组具有皮     

Morphologic Analysis of the Carpal Tunnel and Median Nerve Following Open and Endoscopic Carpal Tunnel Release

Background: Endoscopic carpal tunnel release (ECTR) has purported advantages over open release such as reduced intraoperative dissection and trauma and more rapid recovery. Endoscopic carpal tunnel release has been shown to have comparable outcomes to open release, but open release is considered easier and safer to perform. Previous studies have demonstrated an increase in carpal tunnel volume, regardless of the technique used. However, the mechanism by which this volumetric increase occurs has been debated. Our study will determine through magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) analysis the morphologic changes that occur in both open carpal tunnel release (OCTR) and ECTR, thereby clarifying any morphologic differences that occur as a result of the 2 operative techniques. We hypothesize that there will be no morphologic differences between the 2 techniques. Methods: This was a prospective study to compare the postoperative anatomy of both techniques with MRI. Nineteen patients with clinical and nerve conduction study–confirmed carpal tunnel syndrome underwent either open or endoscopic release. Magnetic resonance imaging was performed preoperatively and 6 months postoperatively in all patients to examine the volume of the carpal tunnel, transverse distance, anteroposterior (AP) distance, divergence of tendons, and Guyon’s canal transverse and AP distance. Results: There was no significant difference in the postoperative morphology of the carpal tunnel and median nerve between OCTR and ECTR at 6-month follow-up on MRI. Conclusion: We conclude that there are no morphologic differences in OCTR and ECTR. It is an increase in the AP dimension that appears to be responsible for the increase in the volume of the carpal tunnel.     

小切口治疗腕管综合征14例报告

Objective　To introduce the technique of carpal tunnel release by small incision,and evaluate its outcome in the treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome.Methods　This method was applied in the operations of 14 cases of carpal tunnel syndrome.An incision 1.5 cm in length was made at the level of the proximal transverse wrist crease ulnar to the palmaris longus tendon.The proximal margin of the transverse carpal ligament was visualized and the ligament was cut subcutaneously under direct vision.The flexor digitorum tendons were retracted and the edematous synovium excised.Results　Follow - up of the patients 2 weeks postoperatively showed that the symptoms of numbess and pain disappeared in all 14 cases.Normal 2 - PD in the pulp of the thumb,index finger and long finger was ＜ 4 mm.One year after the operation,muscle atrophy in 5 patients who sustained preoperative thenar muscle atrophy was greatly improved with recovery of normal opponens function of the thumb.No pillar pain and injury of the ulnar nerve and superficial palmar arch was found.Conclusion　Carpal tunnel release under direct vision through a small incision is a new and effective surgical procedure.     

Current Status of Outcomes Research in Carpal Tunnel Surgery

More than 3,000 publications on carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) have been presented in the literature. Although surgery for treating CTS is commonly performed, the outcomes of these surgical procedures are still relatively unclear. This paper will summarize relevant publications on the surgical treatment of CTS to critically examine outcomes data based on the best available evidence.Presented at: (1) Cumulative Trauma Conference, American Association for Hand Surgery, Chicago, Illinois, May 21, 2004; (2) 2006 Annual Scientific Meeting, American Association for Hand Surgery, Special Topics Day—Challenges in Nerve Compression, Tucson, Arizona, January 11, 2006.     

Carpal tunnel syndrome associated with long-term hemodialysis: case report

Since Warren and Otieno reported carpal tunnel syndrome in patients on intermittent hemodialysis in 1975, a number of related reports have been published. However, there are few reports associated with neurosurgery about carpal tunnel syndrome in patients on long term hemodialysis. We reviewed this disease and reported our case. We treated a patient who complained of bilateral hand numbness and atrophy of the right thenar muscle. He had been suffering from chronic renal failure and had been treated with hemodialysis for ten years. We diagnosed carpal tunnel syndrome based on the findings concerning Tinel's sign, Phalen test, and the conduction velocity of the median nerve. We performed decompression surgery of the median nerve. However, although there was no recovery from thenar muscle atrophy, there was improvement of hand numbness. Histologically, amyloid deposits within the hypertrophic transverse carpal ligament on the right side, could be found but on the left side where the internal shunt had been made amyloid deposits were absent. The reason why patients receiving long term hemodialysis develop carpal tunnel syndrome is controversial, but it seems that beta 2 microglobulin may play an important role in developing carpal tunnel syndrome in hemodialysis patients. This was reported by Gejyo in 1985. There may be uremic and/or diabetic neuropathy in these patients, and these neuropathies may be responsible for the more rapid deterioration and poorer surgical results in carpal tunnel syndrome associated with hemodialysis than in idiopathic cases. It is most important that carpal tunnel syndrome has to be diagnosed early and that surgical decompression is performed while the disease is in its early stage.     

Carpal tunnel syndrome caused by a fibrolipomatous hamartoma of the median nerve treated by endoscopic release of the carpal tunnel

Fibrolipomatous hamartoma has up to now been considered a rare anomaly that most commonly affects the median nerve. Its pathogenesis is controversial. The magnetic resonance (MR) appearance is pathognomonic and precludes the necessity for a diagnostic biopsy. Its reported incidence is likely to increase as a result of the increased use of MRI. There is no definitive treatment, although carpal tunnel syndrome caused by fibrolipomatous hamartoma has been noted to respond to open release of the carpal tunnel. We describe a case of carpal tunnel syndrome caused by fibrolipomatous hamartoma of the median nerve that responded to a two-port endoscopic technique of release. Provided that a safe, distinct surgical plane can be established between the median nerve and the flexor retinaculum, the two-port technique of endoscopic release of the carpal tunnel is both safe and effective.     

Releasing the Tourniquet in Carpal Tunnel Surgery

The purpose of this study was to determine if letting down the tourniquet prior to closure after carpal tunnel release decreases the amount of post-operative ecchymosis and subsequent post-operative pain. We prospectively studied 18 consecutive patients who were undergoing bilateral open carpal tunnel releases. The side done first was randomized and the tourniquet was released to obtain hemostasis prior to closure on this side only. The second side was completed, closed, and dressed prior to letting the tourniquet down. The patients’ pre-operative and post-operative pain scores were recorded, as was an ecchymosis score at the 10-day follow-up visit. The results showed no significant difference between the two groups in either pain or ecchymosis. We conclude that the added surgical time required for letting the tourniquet down and obtaining hemostasis prior to closure in a carpal tunnel is unnecessary.     

Ultrasound Evaluation for Incomplete Carpal Tunnel Release

Background: Ultrasound can provide evaluation of the anatomy of the carpal tunnel in a convenient, noninvasive office setting. This study is intended to determine the accuracy and diagnostic performance of ultrasound, used by surgeons, for the evaluation of completeness of carpal tunnel release (CTR). Methods: Ten cadaver arms underwent randomized sectioning of 0%, 25%, 50%, 75%, or 100% of the transverse carpal ligament. Following a brief training session, a blinded observer used ultrasound to evaluate the percentage of the transverse carpal ligament release. The release amount was then confirmed with an open exposure of the transverse carpal ligament. Results: Cronbach α and Pearson correlation coefficients were 0.92 and 0.87, demonstrating excellent reliability and validity of the technique. Diagnostic performance including sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value was 100%, 75%, 86%, and 100%, respectively, for the diagnosis of incomplete release of the transverse carpal ligament by a novice sonographer orthopedic surgeon. Conclusions: The ultrasound is a highly accurate tool for the diagnosis of incomplete transverse carpal ligament release and requires a minimal amount of training to use for this purpose. It provides a rapid means of diagnosing incomplete release of the transverse carpal ligament following CTR.     

Evaluation of Dynamic Carpal Arch Stability following Carpal Tunnel Release Using Four-Dimensional Computed Tomography

Introduction  This study aimed to assess the carpal arch dynamics during active finger and wrist motion following carpal tunnel release using four-dimensional computed tomography (4D-CT). Materials and Methods  Four patients who diagnosed with bilateral carpal tunnel syndrome and underwent unilateral carpal tunnel release were prospectively included. 4D-CT of the bilateral wrists during active finger and wrist motion was performed for 10 seconds at five frames per second. The distances between the tip of tuberosity of the scaphoid and the volar ridge of the pisiform (S–P distance) and volar ridge of trapezium and the tip of hook of hamate (T–H distance) were measured at each position and the values of S–P and T–H distances were compared between the postoperative and contralateral wrists. Results  During finger motion, the S–P and T–H distances were not different at any position between the postoperative side and contralateral side. Conversely, S–P and T–H distances gradually increased in the postoperative wrists. The differences between the sides of S–P distance were significant, with >0 degrees of wrist extension, and differences of T–H distance were significant with >15 degrees of wrist extension. Conclusion  This study demonstrated the carpal arch dynamics using 4D-CT and revealed that the carpal arch was widened with the wrist in extension after carpal tunnel release. This study suggests that the transverse carpal ligament plays an important role in maintaining carpal arch stability.     

Carpal tunnel syndrome]

The carpal tunnel syndrome is very frequent. The authors insist on some points of surgical technique. The results of a Swiss study on the problem of the recurrent carpal tunnel syndrome are described (96 cases); the etiology of the recurrency, the surgical technique and the results after operative revision are analysed.     

Carpal tunnel syndrome: reconciling "demand management" with clinical need

Purchasers of surgical services are seeking justification for operative interventions with increasing frequency. This paper seeks to identify all relevant data currently available for carpal tunnel decompression; one of the commonest operative interventions in hand surgery. Such data, as is available, would suggest carpal tunnel decompression rates in the United Kingdom are relatively low, with fairly prolonged preoperative duration of symptoms.     

Carpal tunnel syndrome grading system in rheumatoid arthritis

The grading system of Hashizume and Hirooka for carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) was modified to refine the system for surgical treatment selection for specific subsets of CTS in patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA). The grading system uses clinical signs and symptoms of CTS, including pain indications, to identify surgical subsets of patients to facilitate treatment selection. Retrospective analysis of the system included radiographic and electromyographic findings. Twenty-nine hands of 21 adult patients with CTS in RA were graded in the current study. Eight hands with mild synovitis received conservative treatment only. Endoscopic carpal tunnel release (ECTR), using Okutsu's universal subcutaneous endoscopic system with a clear cannula, was performed in 11 hands with moderate synovitis. Open carpal tunnel release (OCTR) combined with flexor tenosynovectomy was performed in 9 hands with severe synovitis. One more hand required OCTR after ECTR when malignant RA was diagnosed. Clinical results, evaluated using Kelly's criteria, were: excellent in 19 hands, good in 5, fair in 4, and poor in the 1 patient with malignant RA. Clinical symptoms of CTS improved in all but the latter patient. Although the sample size in the current study is small, the results appear to warrant further study to determine the clinical utility of the grading system. Received: April 2, 2001 / Accepted: November 1, 2001     

Carpal tunnel syndrome in the adolescent

Three cases of carpal tunnel syndrome in the adolescent age group are described. All were associated with an increase in the patient's athletic activities. After a trial of conservative treatment, all symptoms were successfully relieved by surgical release.