A comparison of 35 mm cine film and digital radiographic image recording: implications for quantitative coronary arteriography. Film vs. digital coronary quantification

To assess potential differences in the intrinsic properties of image recording media and their impact on quantitative coronary arteriography, we used an automatic quantitative arteriography computer program to analyze cine film and digital radiographic images of a radiographic arterial phantom. The phantom consisted of a lucite plate with precision-drilled lumena ranging from 0.5 to 5.0 mm in diameter. Film images were digitized at 2048 X 2048 pixel resolution, and digital radiographic images were acquired at 512 X 512 and 1024 X 1024 resolution. Arterial geometric diameter, percent diameter stenosis, densitometric relative cross-sectional area, and densitometric percent area stenosis were measured. All three techniques were equivalent in measuring diameters with a high degree of overall accuracy (R greater than .992). All methods overestimated diameters below 1.0 mm. Both 512 X 512 and 1024 X 1024 digital images were superior to film for densitometric measurement of relative area (R = .995 vs. R = .940, P = .0032). We conclude that automated analysis of digital radiographic images yields results that are similar in geometric precision but greater in densitometric precision than film analysis.     

Absolute cross-sectional area measurements in quantitative coronary arteriography by dual-energy DSA

Recent studies have emphasized the limitations of conventional coronary angiography. These limitations include the lack of correlation between the severity of coronary stenosis as estimated from coronary angiograms and the actual severity of stenotic lesions measured in postmortem hearts. As a result, attempts have been made to quantitate luminal dimension more precisely. The application of quantitative digital subtraction angiography (DSA) in the assessment of coronary artery lesion dimension has been limited by cardiac and respiratory motion artifacts. We have reported previously on a motion-immune dual-energy (DE) cardiac mode in which kVp and filtration are switched at 30 Hz. To assess the potential advantages of a videodensitometric technique for quantification of absolute vessel cross-sectional area (CSA), three different quantitative coronary arteriography (QCA) algorithms were compared. The three algorithms under comparison were a videodensitometric (V) algorithm, which does not require any geometric assumption for absolute vessel CSA measurement, and videodensitometric (VC) and edge detection (ED) algorithms, which do require the assumption of circular cross-section for CSA measurements. A cylindrical vessel phantom (0.5-4.75 mm in diameter) and a crescentic vessel phantom, producing 25% to 90% area stenosis, were imaged over the chest of a humanoid phantom. The low- and high-energy images were corrected for scatter and veiling glare before energy subtraction. For CSA measurements in crescentic vessel phantoms, the V algorithm produced significantly improved results (slope = 0.87, intercept = 0.51 mm2, r = .95) when compared to the VC (slope = 1.05, intercept = 4.19 mm2, r = .75) and the ED (slope = 1.57, intercept = 5.21 mm2, r = .60) algorithms.     

Effect of sharpening filter on vessel diameter measured by quantitative coronary arteriography

At cardiac catheterization, analog images obtained using cinefilm are translated into digital images, and images appearing on the CRT are filtered by a sharpen filter. We investigated the effect of the sharpening filter on vessel diameter as measured by quantitative coronary arteriography. We acquired images of a vessel phantom filled with contrast material using an X-ray image intensifier. Vessel diameters measured by quantitative coronary arteriography were 1 mm, 1.5 mm, 2 mm, 3 mm, 4 mm, and 6 mm. Results showed that vessel diameters were decreased when the sharpening filter was used and that more intense filtering decreased the measured diameter further. When the diameter of the vessel phantom was less than 4 mm, the diameter was smaller and the ratio of decrease was larger. Vessel diameters of 2 mm, 3 mm, 4 mm, and 6 mm measured a maximum of 2.9 smaller, while those of 1 mm and 1.5 mm measured a maximum of 9.2 smaller.     

Complications of selective percutaneous transfemoral coronary arteriography.

A total of 1,250 selective coronary arteriographic procedures were performed by the percutaneous transfemoral technique. There were no deaths. Local complications included delayed hemorrhage in 14 patients, peripheral emboli in 2, and thrombosis in 1. Cerebral complications included fibrin or air emboli in 3 and dislodgement of a mural thrombus by the catheter in 1. Cardiac complications included ventricular fibrillation in 11, myocardial infarction in 3, and profound hypotension in 1. With routine use of a transparent manifold and removal of the guide wire distal to the arch vessels, no cerebral emboli or myocardial infarctions have occurred in the last 500 examinations.     

Complications of coronary arteriography: A follow-up report

A nationwide survey of complications due to coronary arteriography during 1973–74 yielded responses from 176 hospitals (89,079 coronary arteriograms). The overall mortality rate three times as high for non-heparinized as for heparinized patients. In institutions performing fewer than 100 examinations per year, the combined incidence of death, myocardial infarction, and cerebral embolism was five times higher than in institutions performing more than 400 examinations per year. Left main coronary artery or three-vessel disease was present in most patients who died of the procedure. Compared to a previous survey of 1970–71, there was a profound decrease in significant complications (including death, myocardial infarction, and cerebral embolism) and entry site complications such as thrombosis. A reduction in mortality with the femoral technique since 1971 was not accounted for by heparinization and may reflect increasing experience with the method and shorter angiographic times. Supported in part by USPHS grants HL20895, HL05832, and GM18674     

Improved coronary disease detection with quantitative attenuation-corrected Tl-201 images

BACKGROUND: The normal distribution of myocardial tracer activity is different in attenuation-corrected images compared with uncorrected images. We therefore postulated that quantitation of attenuation-corrected thallium 201 images with direct comparison to a database of healthy subjects could improve detection of coronary artery stenoses. METHODS AND RESULTS: In 49 patients with angiographic evidence of coronary artery disease and 69 patients with a less than 5% likelihood of coronary artery disease, tomographic Tl-201 myocardial imaging was performed by means of a triple-headed camera with fan-beam collimators and the images were processed with attenuation correction, with attenuation and Compton scatter correction, and without correction. Images were subjectively interpreted in a blinded manner. From the group of 69 patients with a low likelihood of coronary disease, scintigraphic data from the first 20 men and the first 20 women were used to generate normal reference ranges for each of the 3 image-processing methods. Data from the 49 patients with angiographic coronary disease and from the remaining 29 patients with a low likelihood of coronary disease were then analyzed quantitatively in comparison to the gender-matched normal databases. With visual interpretation, attenuation-corrected images yielded an improved detection rate compared with uncorrected images (79% vs 46%, P =.008) for 70% or greater left anterior descending coronary artery stenoses. Attenuation-corrected images also provided an improved normalcy rate for the right coronary artery territory (91% vs 75%, P =.006) and an improved normalcy rate when the images were analyzed overall by patient (88% vs 74%, P =.009). With quantitative analysis, attenuation correction yielded an improved detection rate for patients with a significant coronary artery stenosis compared with uncorrected images (90% vs 71%, P =.016). Defect extent was also increased by attenuation correction. Compared with attenuation correction alone, the addition of scatter correction yielded no incremental improvement in detection rate or normalcy rate. Attenuation-scatter correction did produce a nonsignificant trend toward detection of more of the total number of stenotic arteries compared with uncorrected images (60 vs 48 of 79 arteries). CONCLUSIONS: With the use of a triple-headed camera with fan-beam collimation, visual analysis of attenuation-corrected Tl-201 images improved detection of left anterior descending coronary artery disease without loss of detection in other coronary territories. Furthermore, quantitative analysis of attenuation-corrected Tl-201 images improved the overall detection rate for coronary artery disease in patients without compromise of the normalcy rate.     

A comparison of hexabrix and Renografin 60 in peripheral arteriography

Fifty-one patients were analyzed after a randomized double-blind study comparing Hexabrix and Renografin 60 in peripheral arteriography. The arteriographic studies and the volumes of contrast material used in both groups were similar. Hexabrix caused significantly less pain and discomfort than Renografin 60, and the diagnostic quality of the radiographs was comparable. A slightly higher incidence of minor side effects was noted in the Hexabrix group, mostly nausea and vomiting and urinary retention.     

Myocardial scintigraphy with technetium 99m methoxyisobutylisonitrile. A comparison with coronary arteriography in patients with suspected ischemic cardiopathy]

Technetium-99m methoxy-isobutyl-isonitrile (MIBI) myocardial scintigraphy has been proposed as an alternative to Thallium 201 myocardial imaging in the evaluation of patients with coronary artery diseases. We studied 39 patients (37 men, mean age 56 +/- 9 years) with suspected coronary artery disease. All patients underwent 99mTc MIBI myocardial scintigraphy after stress and at rest. Coronary arteriography, performed within 1 month, showed significant (greater than or equal to 50%) stenosis of at least 1 epicardial coronary artery in 36 subjects. 99mTc MIBI myocardial scintigraphy exhibited 94% sensitivity (34/36 patients) and 100% specificity (3/3 subjects with normal coronary arteries). Sensitivity for individual vessel stenosis was 81% (96% for the left anterior descending artery, 65% for the circumflex artery and 79% for the right artery). Our data show that 99mTc MIBI myocardial scintigraphy is capable of evaluating patients with coronary artery diseases.     

Single injection thallium-201 stress and redistribution myocardial perfusion imaging: comparison with stress electrocardiography and coronary arteriography.

The efficacy of single injection thallium-201 exercise stress and rest redistribution imaging in the evaluation of myocardiacl ischemia was compared with stress electrocardiography and coronary arteriography. Thallium-201 imaging was interpreted at two levels of sensitivity in order to define the circumstances under which it best serves as a screening modality for coronary arteriography. With the prevalence of coronary disease usually found in patients referred for coronary arteriography (75%), unprocessed thallium-201 imaging is as good as stress electrocardiography in identifying patients apt to show coronary artery abnormalities, but not much better than stress electrocardiography in delineating those patients unlikely to show coronary artery disease. In contrast, processed lesion enhanced images showing normal results virtually eliminate the possibility of significant arteriographic findings. With this screening technique, many patients may be spared unnecessary coronary arteriography.     

Transfemoral cerebral arteriography versus direct precutaneous carotid and brachial arteriography: a comparison of complication rates.

Cerebral arteriograms in 1,141 consecutive patients, which were done either as direct percutaneous carotid or brachial studies or as transfemoro-cerebral catheter studies, were reviewed. While the overall complication rate for the direct percutaneous studies was higher, the incidence of neurologic complications, both transient and permanent, was higher in the transfemoral group. This higher incidence of neurologic complications may be related to the frequent irrigation of the catheter, which increases the probability of embolism. The incidence of serious complications was lower than in previous studies, perhaps because gravely ill patients are more likely to undergo computed tomographic scanning.