Dynamic cervical plates: biomechanical evaluation of load sharing and stiffness.

STUDY DESIGN: An in vitro biomechanical study using a simulated cervical corpectomy model to compare the load-sharing properties and stiffnesses of two static and two dynamic cervical plates. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the load-sharing properties of the instrumentation with a full-length graft and with 10% graft subsidence and to measure the stiffness of the instrumentation systems about the axes of flexion-extension, lateral bending, and axial torsion under these same conditions. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: No published reports comparing conventional and dynamic cervical plates exist. METHODS: Six specimens of each of the four plate types were mounted on ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene-simulated vertebral bodies. A custom four-axis spine simulator applied pure flexion-extension, lateral bending, and axial torsion moments under a constant 50 N axial compressive load. Load sharing was calculated through a range of applied axial loads up to 120 N. The stiffness of each construct was calculated in response to +/-2.5 Nm moments about each axis of rotation with a full-length graft, a 10% shortened graft, and no graft. ANOVA and Fisher's post hoc test were used to determine statistical significance (alpha < or = 0.05). RESULTS: The two locked cervical plates (CSLP and Orion) and the ABC dynamic plate were similar in flexion-extension, lateral bending, and torsional stiffness. The DOC dynamic plate was consistently less stiff. The Orion plate load shared significantly less than the other three plates with a full graft. Both the ABC and the DOC plates were able to load share with a shortened graft, whereas the conventional plates were not. CONCLUSIONS: All plates tested effectively load share with a full-length graft, whereas the two dynamic cervical plates tested load share more effectively than the locked plates with simulated graft subsidence. The effect of dynamization on stiffness is dependent on plate design.     

A comparison of fusion rates between single-level cervical corpectomy and two-level discectomy and fusion

A single corpectomy and strut grafting has been proposed as an alternative to performing two-level adjacent discectomies with multiple grafts to produce superior fusion rates. The purpose of this study was to compare the clinical and radiographic success of two-level discectomy and fusion with anterior cervical plate fixation compared with a single-level corpectomy. Fifty-two patients were treated with either a two-level adjacent anterior cervical discectomy and fusion with cervical plating, or by a single-level corpectomy and plate. Thirty-two patients had two-level discectomies, whereas 20 had a single corpectomy and a strut graft (average follow-up was 3.6 years). One patient had a pseudarthrosis from a single-level corpectomy and required subsequent surgery to obtain an osseous union. The fusion rates between the two groups was not statistically significant (p = 0.385). The clinical results of the surgeries were similar between the groups based on Odom's criteria. The addition of cervical plates to either two-level discectomies or single-level corpectomies yielded similar fusion and complication rates.     

相邻两节段脊髓型颈椎病前路不同术式的比较

[目的]比较前路颈椎体次全切除植骨融合术(anterior cervical corpectomy with fusion,ACCF)和前路颈椎间盘切除植骨融合术(anterior cervical discectomy with fusion,ACDF)两种术式在相邻两节段脊髓型颈椎病手术治疗中的应用.[方法]对2006年6月～ 2010年3月相邻两节段脊髓型颈椎病手术治疗患者的临床资料和影像学资料进行回顾性研究,共67例符合研究要求,其中ACCF 36例,ACDF 31例.评估、比较两组的围手术期指标(住院日、出血量、手术时间、取骨处并发症以及颈部并发症)、临床疗效指标(脊髓神经功能JOA评分、颈部及上肢疼痛VAS评分)及影像学指标(颈椎矢状曲度情况、颈椎前凸角度、颈椎活动度、融合节段活动度、融合节段前后缘高度及融合率).[结果]平均随访时间ACCF (28.96±13.21)个月,ACDF (26.81±11.02)个月.两组间比较时,手术时间及术中出血量ACCF比ACDF多,并发症发生率更高,有显著性差异,而术后随访时颈椎前凸角度以及融合节段高度ACCF比ACDF低,有显著性差异,其他参数无显著性差异.但组内比较时,术后即刻与术前、术后6周时与术后即刻有显著性差异,末次随访时与术后6周时ACCF融合节段后缘高度相比有显著性差异,其余指标及ACDF组内无显著性差异.[结论] ACCF、ACDF均是治疗相邻两节段脊髓型颈椎病的有效术式,但ACDF在手术时间、出血量、并发症发生率以及一些影像学指标上有显著性优势,具体的手术方式选择应根据脊髓受压迫需要减压的部位而定.     

In vitro comparison of bioresorbable and titanium anterior cervical plates in the immediate postoperative condition

Bioresorbable plates have recently been used with anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF). Compared with metallic plates, bioresorbable plates provide segmental stabilization with minimal imaging artifact, eventual resorption, and increased load sharing. The objectives of the present study were to determine whether a bioresorbable plate can withstand simulated physiologic static and cyclic loading, to compare the reduction in flexibility provided by bioresorbable and titanium plates, and to quantify load sharing between the plate and spine with graft. Sixteen human cervical motion segments were tested to +/-2.5 Nm in flexion-extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation. Range of motion (ROM) was measured (1) in the intact state, (2) with ACDF without plating, (3) after addition of either a bioresorbable or titanium plate, and (4) after 500 cycles of combined flexion-extension and axial torsion. Load sharing was evaluated by applying the same fixed rotation both without and with the plate, and was calculated as the moment resisted by the uninstrumented ACDF expressed as a percentage of the plated ACDF state. No plate failures or graft migration occurred during testing. Compared with the uninstrumented ACDF, bioresorbable plates reduced mean ROM by 49% in flexion-extension and 25% in lateral bending, with very little change in torsion. Titanium plates reduced uninstrumented ACDF ROM by 69% in flexion-extension, 45% in lateral bending, and 27% in torsion. Differences between bioresorbable and titanium plates were significant in flexion-extension and lateral bending. Cyclic loading did not significantly change ROM for either plate. More moment was shared in lateral bending by the spine/graft with bioresorbable plates (78%) compared with titanium plating (63%). Bioresorbable plates contained an intervertebral graft, provided some stabilization, remained intact throughout the simulated immediate postoperative loading, and shared more load with the graft and osteoligamentous spine than titanium plates.     

In vitro diagnosis of susceptibility to malignant hyperthermia: comparison between dynamic and static halothane and caffeine tests

In vitro tests for the diagnosis of malignant hyperthermia susceptibility were performed in 105 patients and 20 normal controls according to the protocol of the European MH Group. Results of dynamic halothane and caffeine tests (in which muscle bundle length is cyclically changed) were compared to those of static tests (constant muscle bundle length). Overall, no significant differences between dynamic and static tests were found in threshold concentrations eliciting contractures. Identical diagnostic results with dynamic and static tests were obtained in 94.3% with halothane and in 88.9% with caffeine. The magnitude of contractures was, however, significantly greater in the dynamic than in the static halothane test for halothane concentrations less than 3%, but this did not influence diagnosis. The results indicate that dynamic tests are not superior to static tests, but several tests should be performed to enhance diagnostic safety.     

Anterior cervical fixation: analysis of load-sharing and stability with use of static and dynamic plates

BACKGROUND: Anterior plates provide stability following decompression and fusion of the cervical spine. Various plate designs have emerged, and they include static plates with fixed-angle screws, rotationally dynamic plates that allow the screws to toggle in the plate, and translationally dynamic plates that allow the screws to both toggle and translate vertically. The goal of this study was to document the effects of plate design following a single-level corpectomy and placement of a full-length strut graft and the effects following 10% subsidence of the graft. METHODS: A total of twenty-one cadaveric cervical spines (C2-T1) were randomized into three treatment groups and were tested for initial range of motion. A C5 corpectomy was performed, reconstruction was done with a full-length interbody spacer containing a load-cell, and an anterior cervical plate was applied. Load-sharing data were recorded with incremental axial loads. The range of motion was measured with +/- 2.5 Nm of torque in flexion-extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation. Then, the total length of the interbody spacer was reduced by 10% to simulate subsidence, and load-sharing and the range of motion were retested. RESULTS: With the full-length interbody spacer, there were no significant differences in the abilities of the constructs to share load or limit motion. Following shortening of the interbody spacer, the static plate construct lost nearly 70% of its load-sharing capability, while neither of the dynamic plate constructs lost load-sharing capabilities. Also, the static plate construct allowed significantly more motion in flexion-extension following simulated subsidence than did either of the dynamic plate constructs (p < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Although all of the tested anterior cervical plating systems provide similar load-sharing and stiffness following initial placement of the interbody spacer, the static plate system lost its ability to share load and limit motion following simulated subsidence of the interbody spacer. Both dynamic plate systems maintained load-sharing and stiffness despite simulated subsidence. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: This study provides an improved understanding of the immediate performance of anterior cervical fusion surgery with plate fixation.     

Screw angulation affects bone-screw stresses and bone graft load sharing in anterior cervical corpectomy fusion with a rigid screw-plate construct: a finite element model study

Background contextAnterior corpectomy and reconstruction with bone graft and a rigid screw-plate construct is an established procedure for treatment of cervical neural compression. Despite its reliability in relieving symptoms, there is a high rate of construct failure, especially in multilevel cases.PurposeThere has been no study evaluating the biomechanical effects of screw angulation on construct stability; this study investigates the C4–C7 construct stability and load-sharing properties among varying screw angulations in a rigid plate-screw construct.Study designA finite element model of a two-level cervical corpectomy with static anterior cervical plate.MethodsA three-dimensional finite element (FE) model of an intact C3–T1 segment was developed and validated. From this intact model, a fusion model (two-level [C5, C6] anterior corpectomy) was developed and validated. After corpectomy, allograft interbody fusion with a rigid anterior screw-plate construct was created from C4 to C7. Five additional FE models were developed from the fusion model corresponding to five different combinations of screw angulations within the vertebral bodies (C4, C7): (0°, 0°), (5°, 5°), (10°, 10°), (15°, 15°), and (15°, 0°). The fifth fusion model was termed as a hybrid fusion model.ResultsThe stability of a two-level corpectomy reconstruction is not dependent on the position of the screws. Despite the locked screw-plate interface, some degree of load sharing is transmitted to the graft. The load seen by the graft and the shear stress at the bone-screw junction is dependent on the angle of the screws with respect to the end plate. Higher stresses are seen at more divergent angles, particularly at the lower level of the construct.ConclusionThis study suggests that screw divergence from the end plates not only increases load transmission to the graft but also predisposes the screws to higher shear forces after corpectomy reconstruction. In particular, the inferior screw demonstrated larger stress than the upper-level screws. In the proposed hybrid fusion model, lower stresses on the bone graft, end plates, and bone-screw interface were recorded, inferring lower construct failure (end-plate fractures and screw pullout) potential at the inferior construct end.     

Changes in cervical spine curvature after uninstrumented one- and two-level corpectomy in patients with spondylotic myelopathy

OBJECTIVE: We studied changes in the cervical spine curvature in patients with cervical spondylotic myelopathy who underwent one- or two-level central corpectomy and iliac bone grafting without the use of instrumentation. METHODS: Curvature of the fused segment and of the whole cervical spine was evaluated on preoperative and follow-up x-rays in 93 patients (30 underwent one-level corpectomy, and 63 underwent two-level corpectomy). In 59 patients, the changes in the cervical spine curvature were studied using one follow-up x-ray; in the other 34 patients, the changes were studied on x-rays obtained at two or more follow-up visits. The sagittal alignment of the fused segment was categorized as lordotic (>+5 degrees), straight (+5 to -5 degrees) or kyphotic (>-5 degrees). The whole spine curvature also was recorded as lordotic, straight, or kyphotic. RESULTS: At a mean follow-up of 22.2 months (range, 6-71 mo), there was a mean change of -10.4 degrees in the segmental curvature (P < 0.001). The fused segment sagittal alignment also worsened (lordotic angles becoming straight or kyphotic and straight angles becoming kyphotic) in 44 patients (47%)(P < 0.001). However, serial studies in 34 patients (mean first and last follow-ups, 11.9 and 30.8 mo, respectively) did not demonstrate significant worsening of the kyphotic angle or the sagittal alignment over time (P = 0.9). Whole spine curvature worsened in 33 (35%) of the 93 patients (P < 0.001); serial studies did not reveal a significant change (P = 0.9). Patients improved in their functional status from a preoperative mean Nurick grade of 2.9 (range, 1-5) to a follow-up mean Nurick grade of 1.5 (range, 0-4) (P < 0.001). Patients with a kyphotic change in their whole spine curvature (n = 33) and those without such change (n = 60) had a similar functional outcome (mean change in Nurick grade, 1.5 and 1.4, respectively). CONCLUSION: Cervical spine curvature tended to undergo a kyphotic change at the fused segment in 47% of patients and a kyphotic change of the whole spine curvature in 35% of patients who underwent one- or two-level uninstrumented central corpectomy. This kyphotic change in the cervical spine, which stabilizes within 1 year after surgery, is not progressive, and it does not affect neurological outcome in these patients.     

Cervical spine loading characteristics in a cadaveric C5 corpectomy model using a static and dynamic plate

Anterior plates are used to increase the initial stability of anterior cervical spine fusions; however, plating has been suggested to cause graft stress shielding, leading to reduced fusion rates. The objectives of this study were to quantify the effects of graft size and plating (static versus dynamic) and the role of the posterior elements on load transmission in anterior cervical fusion. A C5 corpectomy was performed on six human cervical spines (C3-C7). An instrumented height-adjustable graft and dynamic cervical plate were used to measure axial load transmission. Each specimen underwent axial compressive testing with dynamic and static plate configurations, optimal and undersized graft heights, and posterior elements intact and removed. Dynamic plating allowed significantly more load transmission by the graft, particularly in the undersized graft configuration. The posterior elements play a significant role in load transmission.     

The inverse effects of load transfer and load sharing on axial compressive stiffness.

BACKGROUND CONTEXT: The goal of spinal instrumentation is to stabilize involved motion segments while fusion occurs. Although some degree of load sharing is necessary for fusion, the ability of the instrumentation system to transfer the load may vary. PURPOSE: The purpose of this study is to formulate a mathematical relationship between load sharing and load transfer of specific spinal instrumentation systems using a well-accepted mechanical model. STUDY DESIGN/SETTING: Forty-eight American Society for Testing Materials standard ultra high molecular weight polyethylene cylinders were used as per designation F 1717-96, standard test methods for static and fatigue for spinal implant constructs in a corpectomy model. METHODS: Twenty-four spinal assemblies consisting of anterior plates, anterior rod, and posterior rods were subjected to compression bending tests using a MTS Bionix servo-hydraulic material testing apparatus. Each implant was tested in compression bending with and without the addition of a titanium load-sharing cage. The force applied was the independent variable, and the displacement was the dependent variable. The stiffness was determined for each setup with and without the addition of an anterior load-sharing cage. RESULTS: The average axial compressive stiffness of a system increased by a factor of 8.5 with the addition of the load-sharing cage. An inverse relationship existed between the compressive stiffness of the construct and its relative increase achieved with the addition of the load-sharing cage. The compressive stiffness of the system with the addition of the load-sharing cage approached that of the anterior device itself as the system flexibility increased. The ability of instrumentation systems to load share or load transfer and their respective stiffness was determined. CONCLUSIONS: The 5-mm rod screw posterior system was compared with the 7-mm Ti posterior system with the addition of one and two devices for transverse traction (DTTs). The rods with the increased diameter had a stiffness of 1723 n/mm with one DTT and 1815 n/mm with two DTTs. The addition of an anterior cage had little effect on the stiffness of these systems. Anterior plate and screw/rod systems were analyzed and showed similar mechanical behavior to the 5-mm posterior rod/screw systems. A significant increase in stiffness was realized with the addition of an anterior cage. A means to determine the load sharing/transferring properties of a spinal instrumentation system is presented. This technique will allow the amount of load transferred from the fusion mass to the instrumentation to be predicted.     

A comparison of anterior cervical discectomy and corpectomy in patients with multilevel cervical spondylotic myelopathy

Background  

The optimal surgical approach for multilevel cervical spondylotic myelopathy (CSM) has not been defined, and the relative merits of multilevel anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) and anterior cervical corpectomy (2-level or skip 1-level corpectomy) and fusion (ACCF) remain controversial. However, few comparative studies have been conducted on these two surgical approaches.     

Central corpectomy for cervical spondylotic myelopathy: a consecutive series with long-term follow-up evaluation

Since 1984, a consecutive series of patients with cervical spondylotic myelopathy has been treated by central corpectomy and strut grafting. This report focuses on 40 cases operated on between 1984 and 1987 and followed from 2 to 5 years. The perioperative complication rate was 47.5%, with a 7.5% incidence of persistent sequelae: severe C-5 radiculopathy in one patient, swallowing dysfunction in one, and hypoglossal nerve palsy in one. No single factor (age, duration of symptoms, or severity of myelopathy) was absolutely predictive of outcome; however, syndromes of short duration had the best likelihood of cure. Similar outcomes were associated, individually, with long duration of symptoms, age over 70 years, and severe myelopathy. After factoring a 5% regression of improvement, the long-term cure rate was 57.5% and the failure rate was 15%. Myelopathy worsening was not documented.