四个成串刺激和双短强直刺激用于评价神经肌肉传导阻滞的比较

采用单盲法对１０例患者比较目测或触感四个成串刺激（ＴＯＦ）和双短强直刺激（ＤＢＳ）肌收缩效应衰减，用于评价神经肌肉传导阻滞的相关性及可靠程度。结果发现，ＤＢＳ比值（ＤＢＳＲ）印ＴＯＦ比值（Ｔ４／Ｔ１）之间具有良好的相关性（ｒ＝０．９７，Ｐ＜０．００１）。在 Ｔ４／Ｔ１；低于 ０．７时、ＴＯＦ和ＤＢＳ的衰减检出率分别为 ３５％和 ６５％（Ｐ＜０．０１）；当 Ｔ４／Ｔ１为 ０． ４～０． ５时，ＴＯＦ和 ＤＢＳ的衰减检出率分别为 ３５／和８０％；当Ｔ４／Ｔ１为０．５～０．６时，ＴＯＦ的衰减检出率为７％，而ＤＢＳ的衰减检出率为６７％；当Ｔ４／Ｔ１为０．６～０．７时，ＴＯＦ已不能检测到衰减。但ＤＢＳ的衰减检出率仍有：３６％．但当Ｔ４／Ｔ１恢复到０．７以上时，ＤＢＳ的分辨率仅为２％．由此可见，如果仅凭目测或触感评价术后肌张力的恢复情况，则ＴＯＰ未检测到衰减并不能排除严重的肌张力恢复不全，而ＤＢＳ未检测到衰减时，肌张力已较好恢复。     

Comparison of double-burst and train-of-four stimulation to assess neuromuscular blockade in children

Double-burst stimulation (DBS), a new technique to evaluate neuromuscular function, consists of two 50-Hz trains of 60-ms duration and 750 ms apart. DBS was compared with train-of-four (TOF) stimulation in 21 children aged 3-10 yr, during halothane anesthesia. On one arm the ulnar nerve was stimulated supramaximally with TOF stimulation every 12 s and the force of the evoked contraction of the adductor pollicis measured with an FTO3 force transducer and recorded on paper. Atracurium (0.4-0.5 mg.kg-1) was administered. During recovery from neuromuscular blockade, TOF stimulation was interrupted periodically and DBS substituted. The same stimulation patterns were applied to the ulnar nerve of the other arm simultaneously, and the clinical anesthesiologist was asked to estimate the degree of fade with both. There was good correlation between the measured TOF ratio (ratio of fourth to first response) and DBS ratio (ratio of second to first response). The TOF and DBS ratios above which fade could no longer be appreciated manually were (mean +/- SEM) 0.44 +/- 0.03 and 0.67 +/- 0.04 (P = 0.0002). Corresponding ranges were 0.3-0.8 for TOF and 0.4-0.9 for DBS, but DBS fade was always apparent if TOF fade could be detected. Therefore, in children, DBS is more sensitive than is TOF stimulation for the clinical assessment of recovery from neuromuscular blockade.     

DOUBLE BURST STIMULATION (DBS): A NEW PATTERN OF NERVE STIMULATION TO IDENTIFY RESIDUAL NEUROMUSCULAR BLOCK

We present a new pattern of nerve stimulation—double burststimulation (DBS)—to detect residual neuromuscular blockmanually. The DBS consists of two short lasting, 50-Hz tetanicstimuli or bursts separated by a 750-ms interval. The responseto this pattern of stimulation is two single separated musclecontractions of which the second is less than the first duringnon-depolarizing neuromuscular blockade. The ability to identifyfade manually at different train-of-four (TOF) ratios was comparedin four DBS patterns in which different numbers of impulsesin the individual bursts were combined. The DBS with three impulsesin each burst (DBS_3,3) was considered to be the most sensitiveand the least painful and thus most suitable for clinical use.The degree of fade in TOF and DBS_3,3 was almost identical atany level of blockade (correlation coefficient 0.96), and themajor post-DBS_3,3 effect was a depression of the first twitchin TOF lasting less than 15 s. It is concluded that the DBSis more sensitive than the TOF in manual detection of residualblock.     

Tactile evaluation of fade of the train-of-four and double-burst stimulation using the anaesthetist's non-dominant hand

We have studied detection of fade in response to train-of-four (TOF), double-burst stimulation3,3 (DBS3,3) or DBS3,2, assessed tactilely by the anaesthetist using the index finger of the non-dominant hand and the thumb of the patient, compared with that assessed when the index finger of the dominant hand was used. The probability of detection of any fade in response to TOF or DBS3,3 using the non-dominant hand was significantly less than when the dominant hand was used (P < 0.05). The probability of identification of fade in response to DBS3,2 assessed using the non-dominant hand was comparable with that evaluated using the dominant hand when TOF ratios were 0-0.9, but when TOF ratios reached 0.91-1.00, detection using the non-dominant hand was significantly less common than with the dominant hand (12% vs 33%; P < 0.05). Using the non-dominant hand, the probability of detection of fade in response to ulnar nerve stimulation was less than that with the dominant hand and only the absence of DBS3,2 fade ensured sufficient recovery of neuromuscular block.      

Evaluation of residual neuromuscular blockade using modified double burst stimulation

Background: To assess the degree of residual neuromuscular blockade, double burst stimulation (DBS) is commonly applied in the clinical setting. However, fades in response to DBS_3,3 can rarely be identified manually when train-of-four (TOF) ratios are ≧0.70, and, in contrast, fades in response to DBS_3,2 are felt manually in an undesirably high proportion of cases, even at TOF ratios greater than 0.7. We investigated whether a new monitoring method, modified DBS, would be useful to determine an adequate degree of recovery from neuromuscular blockade. For modified DBS, two burst stimuli were applied at an interval of 750 ms. The first stimulation in the modified DBS consisted of two stimuli of 0.3 ms duration at 50 Hz and the second of two stimuli of 0.2 ms duration at 50 Hz. Methods: Forty-five adult patients undergoing elective nitrous oxide-oxygen-isoflurane anesthesia were randomly divided into one of three groups: DBS_3,3 group (n=15), DBS_3,2 group (n=15), or modified DBS group (n=15). During recovery from vecuroni-um-induced neuromuscular blockade, on both forearms, DBS_{3, 3}, DBS_{3, 2}, and modified DBS were delivered in the DBS_{3, 3} group, DBS_{3, 2} group, and modified DBS group, respectively. One hand and forearm (fixed arm) were immobilized to quantify the degree of neuromuscular blockade mechanically, and the contralateral arm (free arm) was unrestrained. An observer deter-mined tactilely on the free arm the presence or absence of fade in response to the three DBS patterns. Results: Probabilities of detection of fade in response to the DBS_{3, 3} were 67% (TOF ratio of 0.51–0.60), 40% (0.61–0.70), 19% (0.71–4).80), 5% (0.81–0.90), and 0% (0.91–1.00). Those to the DBS₃, ₂ were 95% (0.51–0.60), 93% (0.61–0.70), 83% (0.71–0.80), 65% (0.81–0.90), and 38% (0.91–1.00). Those to modified DBS were 90% (0.51–0.60), 86% (0.61–0.70), 65% (0.71–0.80), 25% (0.81–0.90), and 3% (0.91–1.00). The modified DBS was more sensitive in diagnosing residual neuromuscular blockade than DBS_{3, 3} at the TOF ratio of 0.51–0.90, but was less sensitive than DBS_{3, 2} at the TOF ratio of 0.81–1.00 (P < 0.05). Conclusion: Our results indicate that the modified DBS may be a useful stimulation pattern to diagnose the adequacy of recovery from neuromuscular blockade.     

Is the diagnosis of significant residual neuromuscular blockade improved by using double-burst nerve stimulation?

This study evaluated the use of double-burst stimulation (DBS) in the diagnosis of significant post-operative residual neuromuscular blockade. Ninety patients were allocated to three equal groups. In Group A the degree of residual neuromuscular blockade was assessed by clinical criteria (CC) only; in Group B by CC and manual evaluation of the response to train-of-four (TOF) nerve stimulation; and in Group C by CC, manual evaluation of the response to TOF, and DBS stimulation. Immediately after arrival in the recovery room mechanical twitch was recorded using TOF stimulation. The mean (+/- SD) TOF ratios were 0.53 +/- 0.19 in Group A, 0.67 +/- 0.11 in Group B and 0.81 +/- 0.08 in Group C. The incidence of a TOF ratio of less than 0.7 was 83.3% in Group A, 56.7% in Group B and 6.7% in Group C. It is concluded that the use of DBS enabled the anaesthetist to recognize significant residual block and thus reduced the incidence of post-operative residual neuromuscular blockade.     

Visual evaluation of fade in response to facial nerve stimulation at the eyelid

STUDY OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study is to investigate the probability of visual detection of fade in response to train-of-four (TOF) stimulation, double-burst stimulation3,3 (DBS(3,3)), or DBS(3,2) at the eyelid in comparison to that at the thumb. DESIGN: This is a randomized single-blinded study. SETTING: The study took place at the University hospital. PATIENTS AND MEASUREMENTS: Sixty adult patients underwent general anesthesia. INTERVENTIONS AND MEASUREMENTS: Patients were randomly divided into either the eyelid group (n = 30) or the thumb group (n = 30). In the eyelid group, at the varying degrees of neuromuscular block caused by vecuronium, TOF, DBS(3,3), or DBS(3,2) were given at the temporal branch of the facial nerve, and the probability of visual detection of fade in response to TOF, DBS(3,3), or DBS(3,2) was determined at the eyelid. Similarly, in the thumb group, the probability of visual detection of fade in response to TOF, DBS(3,3), or DBS(3,2) was examined at the thumb. MAIN RESULTS: When the true TOF ratios were 0 to 0.60, the probability of detection of TOF fade in the eyelid group was significantly lower than in the thumb group (P < .05). At the true TOF ratios of 0.31 to 0.70, the probability of visual detection of DBS(3,3) fade in the eyelid group was significantly less than in the thumb group (P < .05). When the true TOF ratios were 0.81 to 1.00, the probability of detection of DBS(3,2) fade in the eyelid group was significantly higher than in the thumb group (P < .05). CONCLUSION: The probability of visual detection of fade in response to TOF or DBS(3,3) is lower at the eyelid than the thumb. In contrast, DBS(3,2) fade tends to be seen more frequently at the eyelid than at the thumb.     

Double burst stimulation for monitoring profound neuromuscular blockade: a comparison with posttetanic count and train of four.

Double burst stimulation (DBS) is a new nerve stimulation pattern introduced to facilitate tactile evaluation of recovery from neuromuscular blockade. DBS consists of two bursts of high frequency stimulations separated by a short time interval. The relationships between DBS, post-tetanic count (PTC) and train-of-four (TOF) on the evoked twitch response was investigated in 16 surgical patients and 7 intensive care patients given atracurium for muscle relaxation. A significant correlation between the twitch height of the first response to DBS and the number of post-tetanic responses was demonstrated when PTC was more than five (r = 0.47, p < 0.0003). When the first twitch of TOF was still not measurable, the first twitch of DBS ranged from 0 to 20% of the TOF-control twitch height. Furthermore the DBS ratio was significantly correlated to the TOF ratio (r = 0.92-0.96, p < 0.0002). It is concluded that DBS not only can be used for monitoring of recovery from neuromuscular blockade, but also for monitoring of intense degrees of neuromuscular blockade.     

Tactile fade detection with hand or wrist stimulation using train-of-four, double-burst stimulation, 50-hertz tetanus, 100-hertz tetanus, and acceleromyography

Residual neuromuscular blockade can be evaluated using acceleromyography, tactile assessment of train-of-four (TOF), double-burst stimulation (DBS), 50-Hz tetanus, or 100-Hz tetanus. Nerve stimulation can be at the hand or the wrist. We compared all these tests at both sites of stimulation. Rocuronium was given to 32 patients under sevoflurane anesthesia. The mechanomyographic adductor pollicis TOF ratio was measured at one extremity. In the other, stimulation was at the hand or the wrist, by random allocation, and the acceleromyographic TOF ratio was measured. During recovery, a blinded observer estimated tactile fade. The TOF fade became undetectable when mechanomyographic TOF ratio was (mean +/- sd) 0.31 +/- 0.15. For DBS, this threshold was 0.76 +/- 0.11. For 50-Hz tetanus, it was 0.31 +/- 0.15. For 100-Hz tetanus, it was 0.88 +/- 0.18, with a range of 0.14-1.00. These tactile responses were the same for hand and wrist stimulation. When acceleromyographic TOF ratio reached 1.0, the mechanomyographic TOF ratio was 0.89 +/- 0.06. With stimulation in the hand, acceleromyographic TOF ratio >1.0 was less frequent than at the wrist. To exclude residual paralysis, TOF, DBS, and 50-Hz tetanus are inadequate, 100-Hz tetanus is unreliable, and acceleromyography performs best.     

Residual paralysis in the PACU after a single intubating dose of nondepolarizing muscle relaxant with an intermediate duration of action

BACKGROUND: Residual neuromuscular blockade remains a problem even after short surgical procedures. The train-of-four (TOF) ratio at the adductor pollicis required to avoid residual paralysis is now considered to be at least 0.9. The incidence of residual paralysis using this new threshold is not known, especially after a single intubating dose of intermediate-duration nondepolarizing relaxant. Therefore, the aim of the study was to determine the incidence of residual paralysis in the postanesthesia care unit after a single intubating dose of twice the ED(95) of a nondepolarizing muscle relaxant with an intermediate duration of action. METHODS: Five hundred twenty-six patients were enrolled. They received a single dose of vecuronium, rocuronium, or atracurium to facilitate tracheal intubation and received no more relaxant thereafter. Neuromuscular blockade was not reversed at the end of the procedure. On arrival in the postanesthesia care unit, the TOF ratio was measured at the adductor pollicis, using acceleromyography. Head lift, tongue depressor test, and manual assessment of TOF and DBS fade were also performed. The time delay between the injection of muscle relaxant and quantitative measurement of neuromuscular blockade was calculated from computerized anesthetic records. RESULTS: The TOF ratios less than 0.7 and 0.9 were observed in 16% and 45% of the patients, respectively. Two hundred thirty-nine patients were tested 2 h or more after the administration of the muscle relaxant. Ten percent of these patients had a TOF ratio less than 0.7, and 37% had a TOF ratio less than 0.9. Clinical tests (head lift and tongue depressor) and manual assessment of fade showed a poor sensitivity (11-14%) to detect residual blockade (TOF < 0.9). CONCLUSION: After a single dose of intermediate-duration muscle relaxant and no reversal, residual paralysis is common, even more than 2 h after the administration of muscle relaxant. Quantitative measurement of neuromuscular transmission is the only recommended method to diagnose residual block.     

Response to double-burst appears before response to train-of-four stimulation during recovery from non-depolarizing neuromuscular blockade

Background: Double-burst stimulation (DBS) it a relatively new nerve stimulation mode introduced for improved manual detection of residual neuromuscular blockade. Previous studies have shown that DBS_{3,3 50/50} (3 stimuli at 50 Hz followed 0.75 seconds later by 3 stimuli at 50 Hz) can detect deeper degrees of neuromuscular blockade than train-of-four (TOF) stimulation.
Aim: The aim of the present study was to examine if DBS_{3,3 80/40} (3 stimuli at 80 Hz followed 0.750 s later by 3 stimuli at 40 Hz) can detect even deeper degrees of neuromuscular blockade than DBS_{3,3 50/50} and to determine the time lapse from reappearance of response to each of the two DBS modes until reappearance of response to the TOF mode of nerve stimulation.
Methods: The study comprised 20 women undergoing gynaecological surgery and anaesthetised with fentanyl, thiopentone, halothane, and nitrous oxide. Neuromuscular transmission was monitored by using mechanomyography and stimulation of the ulnar nerve. Atracurium was used for neuromuscular blockade.
Results: Elapsed time from reappearance of response to DBS_{3,3 80/40} and DBS_{3,3 50/50} to reappearance of response to TOF stimulation was 459±196 (mean±SD) and 360±150 seconds, respectively, ( P <0.05).
Conclusions: DBS_{3,3 80/40} is capable of detecting deeper degrees of blockade than DBS_{3,3 50/50} which again is capable of detecting deeper degrees of blockade than TOF.     

Residual Paralysis in the PACU after a Single Intubating Dose of Nondepolarizing Muscle Relaxant with an Intermediate Duration of Action

Background: Residual neuromuscular blockade remains a problem even after short surgical procedures. The train-of-four (TOF) ratio at the adductor pollicis required to avoid residual paralysis is now considered to be at least 0.9. The incidence of residual paralysis using this new threshold is not known, especially after a single intubating dose of intermediate-duration nondepolarizing relaxant. Therefore, the aim of the study was to determine the incidence of residual paralysis in the postanesthesia care unit after a single intubating dose of twice the ED95 of a nondepolarizing muscle relaxant with an intermediate duration of action.

Methods: Five hundred twenty-six patients were enrolled. They received a single dose of vecuronium, rocuronium, or atracurium to facilitate tracheal intubation and received no more relaxant thereafter. Neuromuscular blockade was not reversed at the end of the procedure. On arrival in the postanesthesia care unit, the TOF ratio was measured at the adductor pollicis, using acceleromyography. Head lift, tongue depressor test, and manual assessment of TOF and DBS fade were also performed. The time delay between the injection of muscle relaxant and quantitative measurement of neuromuscular blockade was calculated from computerized anesthetic records.

Results: The TOF ratios less than 0.7 and 0.9 were observed in 16% and 45% of the patients, respectively. Two hundred thirty-nine patients were tested 2 h or more after the administration of the muscle relaxant. Ten percent of these patients had a TOF ratio less than 0.7, and 37% had a TOF ratio less than 0.9. Clinical tests (head lift and tongue depressor) and manual assessment of fade showed a poor sensitivity (11-14%) to detect residual blockade (TOF < 0.9).     

Tactile evaluation of the response to double burst stimulation decreases, but does not eliminate, the problem of postoperative residual paralysis

Background: Routine perioperative monitoring with accelero-myography might prevent residual block, whereas routine tactile evaluation of the response to train-of-four (TOF) nerve stimulation does not. The purpose of this prospective, randomised and blinded study was to evaluate the effect of manual evaluation of the response to double burst stimulation (DBS_3.3) upon the incidence of residual block. Methods: Sixty adult patients scheduled for elective abdominal surgery were included in the study. Pancuronium 0.08 to 0.1 mg kg^?1 was given for relaxation and tracheal intubation. For maintenance of neuromuscular block, pancuronium 1–2 mg was administered. The patients were randomly allocated into two groups. In group DBS (double burst stimulation) the degree of block during anaesthesia was assessed by manual evaluation of the response to TOF nerve stimulation. During reversal, when no fade was detectable in the TOF response, the stimulation pattern was changed to DBS_3.3. The trachea was extubated when the anaesthetist judged the neuromuscular function to have recovered adequately and no fade in the DBS_3.3 response could be felt. In group CC (clinical criteria) patients were managed without the use of a nerve stimulator, and the level of neuromuscular block and reversal were evaluated solely on the basis of clinical criteria. In both groups, the TOF ratio was measured by mechanomyography immediately after tracheal extubation. Also, the ability to sustain head lift for 5 s, to protrude the tongue, to open the eyes, and to lift one arm to the opposite shoulder were tested. Results: The TOF ratio, as measured immediately after tracheal extubation, was significantly lower in group CC than in group DBS (means: 0.68 and 0.78, respectively), and the incidence of residual neuromuscular block defined as a TOF ratio <0.7 was significantly higher in group CC than in group DBS (57 and 24%, respectively). The time from the first TOF measurement until the TOF ratio reached 0.8 was significantly longer in group CC than in group DBS (means: 11.5 and 6.2 min, respectively). No significant differences between the two groups of patients were found in duration of anaesthesia, in times from end of surgery to injection of neostigmine, tracheal extubation or TOF ratio 0.8, in dose of pancuronium, or in any other postoperative variable. Conclusion: Routine perioperative manual evaluation of the responses to TOF and DBS_3.3 decreased the incidence and the degree of residual block following the use of pancuronium. It did not, however, exclude clinically significant residual paralysis, nor did it influence the amount of pancuronium used during the operation, the duration of anaesthesia or the time from end of surgery to tracheal extubation or to sufficient recovery of neuromuscular function (TOF=0.8).     

Utility of double burst stimulation in the detection of residual neuromuscular blockade

OBJECTIVE: To assess the usefulness of double burst stimulation (DBS) for detecting neuromuscular blockade caused by atracurium and vecuronium. PATIENTS AND METHODS: One hundred nineteen adult patients were randomly assigned to receive atracurium (n = 62) or vecuronium (n = 57), with electromyographic monitoring of the number of responses to train of four (TOF) stimuli, TOF-ratio (TR) and the amplitude of the first TOF response (T1) in the pollicis adductor and the response to neurostimulator DBS in the contralateral forearm. During recovery from neuromuscular blockade an independent anesthesiologist manually assessed two responses to DBS every minute as being clearly differentiated, doubtful or undifferentiated. The results were later compared to T1 and TR. RESULTS: Significant differences (p < 0.05) between groups were observed for TR in doubtful (0.27 +/- 0.18 and 0.34 +/- 0.17 for atracurium and vecuronium, respectively) and undifferentiated (0.34 +/- 0.22 and 0.43 +/- 0.18, respectively) responses to DBS, and for T1 with three TOF responses (26.0 +/- 13.6 and 33.1 +/- 14.2, respectively) or four responses (30.9 +/- 14.1 and 38.7 +/- 18.4, respectively). T1 values when TR was 0.75 (extubation criterion) were 68.1 +/- 23.8% and 60.5 +/- 17.4% for the atracurium and vecuronium groups, respectively (NS). CONCLUSIONS: Assuming that DBS reduces the risk of residual curarization and that a TOF-ratio greater than 0.75 indicates adequate recovery from neuromuscular blockade, manual assessment of DBS response as obtained in this study indicates curarization and equal responses do not guarantee its absence. The most reliable index of recovery from neuromuscular blockade is the TR obtained by electromyographic monitoring.     

Train–of–four fade during onset of neuromuscular block with nondepolarising neuromuscular blocking agents

Fade in the train-of-four (TOF) responses during onset of neuromuscular block was studied following administration of atracurium (225 or 450 micrograms/kg), vecuronium (40 or 80 micrograms/kg), pancuronium (60 or 120 micrograms/kg) and tubocurarine (450 micrograms/kg). TOF ratios were measured at approximate heights of T1 (first response in the TOF) of 75, 50 and 25%. Fade in TOF increased as the height of T1 decreased, with maximum fade being observed at T1 of 25%. The greatest difference between relaxants was observed at T1 of 25%, vecuronium showing the least fade and pancuronium, atracurium and tubocurarine showing increasing fade, in that order. The difference between atracurium and tubocurarine or between vecuronium and pancuronium was not significant, but the degree of TOF fade was significantly greater with atracurium and tubocurarine in comparison to vecuronium or pancuronium.     

Visual assessment of train-of-four and double burst-induced fade at submaximal stimulating currents

The influence of current intensity on visual assessment of fade in response to train-of-four (TOF) and two modes of double-burst stimulation (DBS) was determined to assess the utility of low-current neurostimulation. Each of 150 sets of assessments (in 51 patients) included a mechanographic TOF at 60 mA followed by visual assessments of TOF, DBS3,3 (two minitetanic bursts of three stimuli each), and DBS3,2 (a burst of three followed by a burst of two impulses) at 20, 30, 50, and 60 mA in random order. For the range of mechanographic TOF ratios between 0.41 and 0.70, visual assessment of TOF fade failed to identify fade in 33%, 36%, 44%, and 58% of cases at 20, 30, 50, and 60 mA, respectively. Corresponding false-negative rates for DBS3,3 were 11%, 17%, 36%, and 33%, and for DBS3,2 they were 6%, 6%, 17%, and 28%. Within each method, P less than 0.05 (by Mantel-Haenszel analysis) for a linear trend of increasing accuracy as current decreased. For the range between 0.41 and 0.70, quantitative assessment overestimated the actual ratio at all currents for TOF, at 30, 50, and 60 mA for DBS3,3, and at 50 and 60 mA for DBS3,2 (P less than 0.05 by Wilcoxon signed rank test). At each current tested, DBS was more sensitive in detecting fade visually than TOF. The accuracy of visual fade detection was not influenced significantly by level of observer training. In conclusion, visual assessment of fade by novice and expert observers is improved by testing at low currents.     

Intraoperative Acceleromyographic Monitoring Reduces the Risk of Residual Neuromuscular Blockade and Adverse Respiratory Events in the Postanesthesia Care Unit

Background: Incomplete recovery from neuromuscular blockade in the postanesthesia care unit (PACU) may contribute to adverse postoperative respiratory events. This study determined the incidence and degree of residual neuromuscular blockade in patients randomized to conventional qualitative train-of-four (TOF) monitoring or quantitative acceleromyographic monitoring. The incidence of adverse respiratory events in the PACU was also evaluated.

Methods: One hundred eighty-five patients were randomized to intraoperative acceleromyographic monitoring (acceleromyography group) or qualitative TOF monitoring (TOF group). Anesthetic management was standardized. TOF patients were extubated when standard criteria were met and no fade was observed during TOF stimulation. Acceleromyography patients had a TOF ratio of greater than 0.80 as an additional extubation criterion. Upon arrival in the PACU, TOF ratios of both groups were measured with acceleromyography. Adverse respiratory events during transport to the PACU and during the first 30 min of PACU admission were also recorded.

Results: A lower frequency of residual neuromuscular blockade in the PACU (TOF ratio <= 0.9) was observed in the acceleromyography group (4.5%) compared with the conventional TOF group (30.0%; P < 0.0001). During transport to the PACU, fewer acceleromyography patients developed arterial oxygen saturation values, measured by pulse oximetry, of less than 90% (0%) or airway obstruction (0%) compared with TOF patients (21.1% and 11.1%, respectively; P < 0.002). The incidence, severity, and duration of hypoxemic events during the first 30 min of PACU admission were less in the acceleromyography group (all P < 0.0001).     

Residual paralysis at the time of tracheal extubation

Respiratory and pharyngeal muscle function are impaired during minimal neuromuscular blockade. Tracheal extubation in the presence of residual paresis may contribute to adverse respiratory events. In this investigation, we assessed the incidence and severity of residual neuromuscular block at the time of tracheal extubation. One-hundred-twenty patients presenting for gynecologic or general surgical procedures were enrolled. Neuromuscular blockade was maintained with rocuronium (visual train-of-four [TOF] count of 2) and all subjects were reversed with neostigmine at a TOF count of 2-4. TOF ratios were quantified using acceleromyography immediately before tracheal extubation, after clinicians had determined that complete neuromuscular recovery had occurred using standard clinical criteria (5-s head lift or hand grip, eye opening on command, acceptable negative inspiratory force or vital capacity breath values) and peripheral nerve stimulation (no evidence of fade with TOF or tetanic stimulation). TOF ratios were measured again on arrival to the postanesthesia care unit. Immediately before tracheal extubation, the mean TOF ratio was 0.67 +/- 0.2; among the 120 patients, 70 (58%) had a TOF ratio <0.7 and 105 (88%) had a TOF ratio <0.9. Significantly fewer patients had TOF ratios <0.7 (9 subjects, 8%) and <0.9 (38 subjects, 32%) in the postanesthesia care unit compared with the operating room (P < 0.001). Our results suggest that complete recovery from neuromuscular blockade is rarely present at the time of tracheal extubation.     

FADE PROFILES DURING SPONTANEOUS OFFSET OF NEUROMUSCULAR BLOCKADE: VECURONIUM AND GALLAMINE COMPARED

The characteristics of the train-of-four (TOF) response havebeen studied electromyographically during the onset and thespontaneous offset of neuromuscular blockade indued with vecuroniumor gallamine. During the onset of blockade, at 75% depressionof initial twitch height, gallamine was associated with significantlymore TOF fade than vecuronium. Both agents were associated withsignificantly less fade during onset than during spontaneousoffset. When the two neuromuscular blocking drugs were comparedduring spontaneous offset they showed a similar degree of fadeduring early offset (up to 50% recovery of initial twitch height).However, during late spontaneous offset, when the initial twitchheight had recovered to 75% of control values, vecuronium wasassociated with more fade than gallamine.     

Comparison of tactile and mechanomyo-graphical assessment of response to double burst and train-of-four stimulation during moderate and profound neuromuscular blockade

It is common clinical practice to estimate the degree of neuromuscular blockade by tactile evaluation of twitch responses. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the use of tactile responses of adductor pollicis to double-burst stimulation (DBS) and train-of-four (TOF) peripheral nerve stimulation for monitoring moderate and profound levels of neuromuscular blockade. The study comprised 44 women scheduled for gynaecological laparotomy and anaesthetised with midazolam, fentanyl, thiopentone, halothane, nitrous oxide and atracurium. The tactile responses of the adductor pollicis were compared with mechanomyographical measurements in the contra lateral arm during recovery from neuromuscular blockade. The observers (anaesthetic nurses) of the tactile responses were blinded with regard to the stimulation pattern and the mechanomyo-graphical measurements. The time from injection of the initial dose of atracurium until tactile reappearance of the first twitch in DBS (D₁), was 24.6 (0–39.8) min, median (range). This was more rapid than the time until tactile reappearance of the first twitch in TOF (T₁) 32.8 (18.–243.4) min (P< 0.05). The median time from tactile reappearance of D₁ until T₁ recovered to 15% of the control twitch height was longer than the median time from tactile reappearance of T₁ (14.6 versus 10.5 min) (P < 0.05). One or two responses to DBS or TOF were often felt before any responses had been detected mechanomyographically in the contralateral arm. When three or four responses to TOF were felt, responses were always detected mechanomyographically. It is concluded that tactile evaluation of responses to DBS stimulation can estimate deeper levels of blockade than tactile evaluation of responses to TOF.