Analysis of referrals of mental health problems by general practitioners.

The majority of people in the community who have a psychiatric disorder will consult their general practitioner. Referrals from general practice to specialist services are, however, relatively rare. The filter between primary care and specialist care has been characterized by Goldberg and Huxley as the least permeable of the filters separating psychiatrists and other specialists from the populations they serve. These referrals form the subject of this study in the Netherlands. Using a large database of doctor-patient contacts, the proportion of mental health disorders resulting in a referral and the characteristics of the patient and general practitioner that are involved in such a referral have been determined. In addition, the type of mental health institution or specialist to which referrals were directed and the characteristics influencing this choice were examined. Only 6% of patients presenting with a psychiatric disorder during surgery hours were referred to specialist care. Younger patients, male patients and patients with severe diagnoses had a greater probability of being referred. The percentage of patients referred was higher in urban areas than in rural areas. Doctors with a limited task perception regarding mental treatment tended to refer more often. Although the diagnosis did have some relationship with the institutions to which patients were referred (psychotic conditions to psychiatric services and social/material problems to social workers), the most prevalent diagnoses (neurotic conditions and relationship problems) seemed to be more or less randomly distributed over the various possibilities. Preferences appeared to be related to the existence of regular meetings between general practitioners and specialists and a positive evaluation by general practitioners of the institution concerned.     

Reasons for requests for evaluation of competency in a municipal general hospital

During the period from July through September 1989, 380 referrals to a psychiatry consultation-liaison service were reviewed. Of these patients, 25% were referred for a determination of competency, despite the fact that they often showed no evidence of mental illness. Seventy-five percent of the patients were found to be competent. Fear of medical legal consequences, physician's anxiety, lack of understanding of the rights of patients to refuse treatment, and a misunderstanding of the physician's duty when presented with such refusal seem to be the reasons for the large number of referrals.     

Tardive dyskinesia and the primary psychiatric diagnosis

Over 300 patients were assessed for the presence of tardive dyskinesia in relation to the primary psychiatric diagnosis. Patients with organic mental syndrome or bipolar disorder showed a significantly (P < .01) higher prevalence of tardive dyskinesia (41% and 42%, respectively) than did those with schizophrenia (24.5%). This difference was not related to age or duration of neuroleptic treatment. Based on these findings, the physician should remain aware of the greater possibility of tardive dyskinesia in patients with organic mental syndrome or bipolar disorder and periodically review dosage and indications for neuroleptic treatment.     

CHARACTERISTICS OF CHILDREN

Children referred for neuropsychological evaluation to the NeurologyDepartment of the LSU School of Medicine are described. Almosthalf of all neuropsychology referrals were children. And ofthese children, almost half had school-related problems suchas learning disabilities, underachievement, or mental retardation.One third of the children referred had a primary diagnosis ofneurological diseases. Relatively few had a primary diagnosisof behavioral or emotional difficulty.     

Self-harm in postpartum depression and referrals to a perinatal mental health team: an audit study

There is a paucity of research on self-harm during pregnancy and the postpartum period despite suicide being a leading cause of death and high rates of mental disorder during this time. This audit describes a cohort of women referred to a new perinatal mental health team (PMHT) based in a large maternity hospital in the UK over a 12-month period. The audit was conducted in two stages. Stage one describes the clinical and socio-demographic characteristics of 225 pregnant women referred to the team after screening positive for a significant mental health history. Stage two determines the veracity of data on a subgroup of 73 pregnant women referred for previous postpartum depression (PPD), 58 % of whom disclosed an episode of self-harm with the ‘intent to kill themselves’ to the maternity staff when they first booked in for antenatal care. Previous PPD accounted for the largest majority of referrals (32 %) to the PMHT followed by depression (27 %) and self-harm (10 %). The majority of women (85 %) referred to the PMHT were engaged. Eight percent were so unwell at the point of referral they required an admission to the hospital. Attempted suicide in the subgroup of 73 women with previous PPD ranged from 24–49 %. The findings from this audit suggest that self-harm in PPD warrants further investigation.     

When do physicians request competency evaluations?

Fifty consecutive requests for competency evaluations were reviewed retrospectively to determine the characteristics of the request. The data from this study suggest that requests for competency are seen within certain discrete, demographically varied categories; are often urgent; are usually not the result of a functional Axis I disorder; are more common for patients with previously diagnosed organic mental disorders; are often stimulated by patients who do not participate in diagnostic or treatment plans or by patients who threaten to leave against medical advice; are less frequently concerned with informed consent; and are more common in younger patients. Overall, patients are as likely to be judged competent as incompetent. Elements of the mental status examination that are crucial to the assessment of competency are delineated.     

Clinical genetics issues encountered by family physicians.

PURPOSE: To describe the genetics-related clinical issues encountered by family physicians, and the medical problems they referred to genetics consultants. METHODS: Questionnaires were mailed to a nationwide, random sample of 498 practicing family physicians, asking how many times in the past year they discussed genetic information about 19 familial or genetic conditions with patients and what proportion of the families with each genetic condition were referred for genetics consultation. Factor analysis was used to group the conditions. RESULTS: The response rate was 38% (n = 190). Respondents were similar to non-respondents except that more were women. Most family physicians reported discussing the genetics of common cancers, cardiovascular disease, and Alzheimer's disease with two or more patients in the past year. Thirteen percent had referred families for genetics assessment of breast-ovarian cancer but only two made genetics referrals for cardiovascular disease or dementia. 25% to 50% of family physicians had addressed genetic issues in at least one family with hemoglobinopathy, a blood clotting disorder, hemochromatosis, mental illness, vision loss or deafness, chromosome abnormality, infertility or pregnancy loss, congenital anomalies, mental retardation, and neurofibromatosis. Most cases were not referred to geneticists. Of respondents, 23% said that genetics consultation is very difficult to obtain or unavailable and 18% listed ethical and social dilemmas related to pursuing genetic diagnosis. CONCLUSION: Nationwide, family physicians address a variety of genetics issues with patients, most frequently consulting geneticists for perinatal conditions and familial cancers. Access to genetics consultation is more difficult in rural areas. These data may be used in organizing genetics services and in planning professional education programs for primary care clinicians.     

Patients with suspected myocardial infarction: effect of mode of referral on admission time to a coronary care unit.

The aim of this prospective study was to determine the delay between the onset of symptoms and arrival in the coronary care unit of patients with suspected acute myocardial infarction, and the relative contribution to the total delay of patient delay, method of referral (self referral or general practitioner referral) and delay in the hospital before reaching the coronary care unit. All patients admitted with chest pain to the coronary care unit at Dudley Road Hospital, Birmingham, over the six month period April-September 1989 were included in the study. Ninety five patients were referred by their general practitioner and 107 patients attended the accident and emergency department directly or arrived by ambulance without contacting their general practitioner. The proportion of self referred and general practitioner referred patients with acute myocardial infarction, angina and non-cardiac chest pain were not significantly different. The total delay was significantly longer for patients who had been referred by their general practitioner (median 5.3 hours) than for self referrals (3.2 hours, P less than 0.001), with a significantly higher proportion of self referrals arriving at the coronary care unit within six hours of the onset of symptoms (77% versus 54%, P less than 0.01). Among general practitioner referrals, initial patient delay accounted for a median of 2.5 hours and the general practitioner's response time for a median of 1.1 hours. The delay in hospital was similar for both groups of patients. In inner city areas, self referral may result in considerably less delay than general practitioner referral allowing a greater proportion of patients to receive effective thrombolytic therapy.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Prioritising referrals to a community mental health team.

BACKGROUND: Current national policies encourage prioritisation of people with severe mental illness (SMI) as well as the development of a primary care-led National Health Service. Where resources for mental health are limited, there is a potential conflict between the needs of people with SMI and the much more common depressive and anxiety disorders that form the bulk of the mental health workload in primary care. AIM: To describe the re-organisation of a community mental health team in order to prioritise people with SMI. METHOD: The number and type of referrals received in the 12 months before and after re-organisation were compared, and general practitioners' (GP) views on the changes sought. RESULTS: There was a significant reduction in GP referrals of patients with less severe disorders in the second year. In both years the proportion of patients with a possible psychotic diagnosis or risk of self-harm was much higher among referrals from within the psychiatry department (92% of referrals) than among GP referrals (20% of referrals). Using data from a postal survey, 46% of referring GPs reported a significant improvement in the service provided to patients with SMI, but 34% reported a deterioration in services for other patient groups. GPs were more likely to be satisfied with the service for people with SMI than with the service for other patient groups. CONCLUSIONS: Improvements in the service provided for those with SMI can be achieved, but this may be at the expense of services for other patient groups. Primary care groups will need to consider this potential conflict in setting priorities for mental health.     

The referral problem in the field of alcohol abuse

This paper reports on referral sources and the disposition of 409 problem drinkers who were contacted over a two-year period for participation in a 17-week alcohol abuse treatment program. A longitudinal follow-up design was used with 103 persons to evaluate various learning-based techniques in moderating their drinking habits. Referrals were analyzed by source (75% were legal referrals), percentage completing the program (70%, 72%, and 69% for self, legal, and mental health referrals), and "success" at one year. Legal referrals reported a significantly smaller pretreatment alcohol intake than self and mental health referrals. However, the decrease in alcohol intake for legal and nonlegal referrals were almost identical. The stigma of alcoholism as a disease and the coercion associated with referral by legal agencies were considered to be factors in acceptance of treatment and in treatment outcome.     

Misdiagnosed delirium in patient referrals to a university-based hospital psychiatry department

The authors examined the factors associated with referral errors in which the presence of delirium was ostensibly not recognized by medical staff personnel. Medical records of 541 university-hospital patients consecutively referred for psychiatric consultation were scrutinized for extant delirium. The data indicated that a greater likelihood of a missed diagnosis was associated with younger age; referrals outside of family practice service; orientation as to person, place, and time; and a history of bipolar affective disorder or psychosis. The ramifications of failure to diagnose existing delirium include increased morbidity and mortality, longer length of hospital stay, and increased healthcare costs.     

Psychiatric referrals in two general hospitals

A prospective study was undertaken to compare the patterns of psychiatric referrals in two general hospitals in Bombay viz. the King Edward Memorial Hospital (64 cases) and the Jaslok Hospital and Research Centre (62 cases). It was observed that depressive symptoms were the most common presenting symptoms in these patients attending either of the hospitals. Similarly, the commonest diagnoses were depression and organic mental disorder. Attempted suicide with organophosphorous compounds was the commonest reason for hospitalization at K.E.M. Hospital (p less than 0.001). A significant number of these patients were females (p less than 0.05). The psychiatric referrals at Jaslok had been hospitalized mainly for suspected medical or neurological illness (p less than 0.001). These patients belonged to higher economic strata and hence had a better paying capacity compared to patients at KEM hospital, a significant number of whom were unemployed (p less than 0.001). The duration of pre-referred illness of patients and their stay at Jaslok hospital were longer as compared to those at KEM Hospital (p less than 0.01). The number of non-relevant special investigations carried out on patients in Jaslok was more (p less than 0.01). Further analysis of diagnoses revealed that a significant number of patients at KEM Hospital were admitted as primary psychiatric illness (p less than 0.05).     

The assessment of psychological symptoms of patients referred to community mental health teams: distress,chronicity and life interference

Mental health trusts are concerned to allocate scarce resources to those patients requiring secondary care services, rather than to those who can be managed in the community. It is important therefore to gain insight into the types of patient being referred into community mental health teams. This study was undertaken to explore this question. 421 patients completed the General Health Questionnaire and a newly devised symptom checklist, which allows assessment of distress/severity, chronicity and interference with life of individual symptoms. 81% of patients met criteria for caseness on the GHQ and those who did not still had a number of chronic symptoms. In regard to specific symptom profiles referred patients endorsed a wide variety of symptoms, related to anxiety, depression and impulse control. The most common anxiety symptom related to adjustment reactions and possibly post-traumatic stress. The most common mood symptom was mood instability, followed by fatigue and sleep problems. The majority of patients believed that they had had their symptoms and problems for longer than a year, indicating that many of the referrals to community teams are not short-term crises. Data suggests that the vast majority of referrals are appropriate but also point to a need for specific forms of intervention for the most common symptoms. Copyright © 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Low back pain and psychological factors. A social psychiatric study of the population of working age.

The objective of the study was to find out how low back pain (LBP) and psychological factors are interrelated in the adult population. The study dealt with 220 individuals suffering from LBP and with a control group (n = 101). The method used was a psychiatric interview. Mental disorders were more prevalent in the LBP group than in the control group. A clinical disorder was diagnosed for 31% in the LBP group and they had many mild mental disturbances, too. The association between LBP and mental disorders was not as clear as found in previous studies with patient populations. The LBP group was divided according to the etiology of pain into functional and organic groups. No significant differences were found between the groups with regard to mental disturbance.     

Relationship style between GPs and community mental health teams affects referral rates.

BACKGROUND: Community mental health teams (CMHTs) are the established model for supporting patients with serious mental illness in the community. However, up to 25% of those with psychotic disorders are managed solely by primary care teams. Effective management depends upon locally negotiated referral and shared care arrangements between CMHTs and primary care. AIM: To examine whether the style of working relationship between general practices and CMHTs affects the numbers and types of referrals from general practices to CMHTs, taking into account population and practice factors and provision of other mental health services which may influence referral rates. DESIGN OF STUDY: Cross-sectional study. SETTING: All 161 general practices in East London and the City Health Authority. METHOD: Questionnaire survey to all general practices to identify style of relationship. Collection of routinely available referral data to all statutory mental health services over a two-year period. Main outcome measures were number and types of referrals from general practices to CMHTs. RESULTS: The average annual referral rate to the eleven CMHTs in east London is 10 per 1000 adult population annually. The teams show a sixfold variation in rates of referral from all sources. Where good working relationships (a consultation-liaison style) exist between CMHTs and general practice, there are greater numbers of referrals requiring both long and short-term work by CMHTs. Two-stage multivariate models explained 47% of the referral variation between practices. Where primary care-based psychologists work with practices there are greater numbers of CMHT referrals, but less use of psychiatric services. CONCLUSION: Shifting to a consultation-liaison relationship should increase rates of referral of patients with serious mental illness, including those who can most benefit from the skills of CMHTs. Increasing the provision of primary care-based psychology might improve practice use of mental health services, reducing avoidable outpatient psychiatric referrals.     

High rate of unrecognized bipolar mixed states among destitute Hispanic adolescents referred for "major depressive disorder"

OBJECTIVE: To ascertain the rate of bipolarity among adolescent Hispanic youths referred for the treatment of "major depressive disorder" (MDD) in a community mental health clinic (CMHC) in which the threshold for referral was moderate to severe impairment. METHODS: The patients were 49 consecutively presenting Hispanic adolescents (33 girls and 16 boys with a range of 12-17 years), many of whom had histories of unruly, hostile and/or assaultive behavior; indeed, 1 out of 3 had been referred to the CMHC from the "First-Time Offenders Program." Upon evaluation at the CMHC triage unit, all were diagnosed as MDD rendered by a licensed paramedical mental health professional managing this unit. They were subsequently evaluated by a psychiatrist using the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV. RESULTS: Seventeen (51.5%) of the girls and 10 (62.5%) of the boys met the DSM-IV criteria for bipolar disorder. Among the bipolars, 44.4% were bipolar II and 55.6% bipolar I; 74.1%% had mixed states and 40.7% were psychotic (not mutually exclusive categories). Euphoric mania was virtually absent in this population. LIMITATION: Data on social deviance was based on chart review. Nonetheless, given that a third had already entered the juvenile justice system upon referral validates the accuracy of characterizing this population as at least moderately impaired from the social deviance standpoint. CONCLUSIONS: Hispanic adolescents referred with a presumptive diagnosis of MDD must be carefully assessed for the presence of occult bipolarity using a structured interview. Concurrent aggressiveness and depression should tip mental health clinicians towards bipolarity--especially mixed states. Such activated-hostile depressive (and/or manic) mixed states may in part underlie the social deviance in these patients. Given that these destitute youth are often simultaneously encountered in the juvenile justice system, undetected bipolarity among Hispanic adolescents initially regarded to have MDD represents a matter of grave public health importance. Appropriate training for mental health staff to recognize bipolar spectrum disorders in CMHCs should be mandated.     

Urgent GP referrals for suspected lung, colorectal, prostate and ovarian cancer

BACKGROUND: The UK urgent cancer referral guidance was introduced between 1999-2000. There is a dearth of literature relating to the effectiveness in detecting cancer of urgent suspected cancer referrals and general practitioners' compliance with the guidance. AIMS: This paper aims to determine the diagnostic yield from urgent referrals for suspected colorectal, lung, ovarian and prostate cancer, and the proportion of patients with cancer who were urgently referred. Secondary aims are to determine the association of these findings with age, ethnicity, sex and marital status, and to determine the proportions of patients who fulfilled the urgent referral criteria. DESIGN: Detailed notes analysis of all urgent referrals and all cancer diagnoses. SETTING: One hospital trust in England. METHOD: Data regarding all urgent referrals and all cancer diagnoses were obtained from one hospital trust over a 2-year period. Data analysis was undertaken to determine, diagnostic yields and their association with sociodemographic factors, trends over time and fulfilment of the guidance. RESULTS: The percentages of urgent referrals diagnosed with cancer were colorectal 11%, lung 42%, ovarian 20%, and prostate 50%. The percentages of patients with cancer referred urgently were colorectal 21%, lung 23%, ovarian 24%, and prostate 32%. Patients who were urgently referred without cancer were younger than those with cancer for all but prostate. There were no significant differences by sex, marital status or ethnicity. For patients with cancer there were no differences for any sociodemographic factors in whether or not they were referred urgently. CONCLUSIONS: The predictive power of the referral guidance as a marker for cancer is low, resulting in significant numbers of patients being urgently referred without cancer. A large majority of patients not diagnosed with cancer through the urgent referral route did fulfil the criteria for urgent referral, suggesting that with more widespread use of the guidance the diagnostic yields will be higher. This has implications for patients, on hospital diagnostic systems, and for patients presenting through other pathways.     

Characteristics of 80 adolescents referred for secure inpatient care

Despite the recognition of the need for secure adolescent mental health provision, the extent and precise nature of the services required in the United Kingdom remains unquantified. The present study describes some of the key characteristics of 80 young people referred from around the United Kingdom for medium secure health care. The pattern of referrals indicates a substantial need for secure health care in the 14‐ to 18‐year‐old age range. Young people requiring such care present most commonly with psychotic, personality or post traumatic stress disorder. Nearly half of the young people (45%) were requiring constant observation. Over 90% of those assessed presented a risk of aggression and over 60% presented a suicide risk. Over half (53%) had been charged with one or more offence and 29% had at least one conviction. The need for the further development of an adolescent forensic specialism is supported by these data. Copyright © 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Social workers and their clients: a comparison between primary health care and local authority settings

A social work attachment scheme to several general practitioners was established. Data from the first 300 referrals to the scheme were compared with data from a previous study of referrals to the `intake' teams of the social services department of the same London borough. In addition, data about the activities of the social workers in the `attachment' were collected, and the work was found to be predominantly short-term.

The populations referred to social workers in both settings were found to be similar in age and sex. Although general practitioners in the area referred only a few clients to social services departments, the clients in both groups were generally in poor health.

The psychiatric morbidity of those referred to the attached social workers was significantly higher, however, than those referred to the intake team (p < 0·01), and their problems were also more likely to need psychological help rather than practical measures. These differences were considered to be due mostly to the different types of referral agencies operating in the two settings and to their perceptions of the social worker's role.

The findings support the argument for closer liaison between medical and social services in the community: the attachment of social workers to general practices proved to be particularly valuable in the management and treatment of patients with emotional and mental illness.

     

Failure of the Hs-Pt index to distinguish organic from functional patients

Investigated the effectiveness of the MMPI HS-PT index to separate patients with a brain disorder from those with functional disturbance. A sample of 303 male patients who were referred for neuropsychological evaluation because of known or suspected brain damage was used in the study. Of these, 187 were diagnosed as organic and 116 as functional. The HS-PT index failed to separate these groups beyond a chance level. Hit rates were 52.4% for the organic patients and 36.2% for the functional patients using the cut-off established in previous research. No discriminations were possible at any of the HS-PT ranges. Failure of the HS-PT index to hold up in this sample of patients is probably due to some very different patient characteristics from those prevalent in earlier research.