Percutaneous needle trephination for external CSF drainage: experience with 226 punctures

We report on our experience with 226 percutaneous needle trephinations in a total of 192 consecutive patients. Trephination was performed with a hand-driven drill. A special puncture needle was inserted into the anterior horn of the lateral ventricle. The main indication for this procedure was the treatment of occlusive hydrocephalus in an emergency. Duration of drainage ranged from 1 to 34 days and was 7 days on the average. We encountered 14 cases of infection (6.2%) and one case of symptomatic bleeding (0.4%). All these complications eventually resolved without permanent sequelae. In our opinion, ventricle puncture with this device is a simple and effective method and can especially be recommended for external CSF drainage in cases of emergency.     

Technical Note: External Cerebrospinal Fluid (CSF) Drainage by Percutaneous Needle Punction in Newborn Children

Summary  External drainage of CSF in children is indicated in acute hydrocephalus e.g. after intraventricular bleeding or infection. In these cases the drainage has to remain in place until physiological CSF circulation is restored or an internal shunt can be inserted. External drainage is mostly performed using a silicon catheter connected to a plastic bag. An external CSF drainage left for several days in situ bears an increasing risk of bacterial infection. In these cases a metal needle minimizes the risk of ventriculitis.  For prevention of accompanying infection we implanted a Cytocan^R port needle with a 20 G diameter in 7 infants. The needle is easily inserted with low risk of complications. By its plastic top angulated at 90° to the needle the system can be fixed to the skin very safely by suture or tape.  With this system neither an implantation related intracerebral haemorrhage nor an accompanying ventriculitis was encountered. In two cases a pre-existing ventriculitis was cured by this needle drainage and antibiotic treatment. In five cases an acute hydrocephalus after intraventricular haemorrhage was drained by the port needle system.     

Percutaneous needle trephination. Experience in 200 cases

Summary For many years percutaneous needle and classic burr-hole trephination with insertion of plastic catheters for external ventricular drainage are in use. The shortcomings of the conventional puncture needles were compensated for by the development of a modified instrument in recent years.In this prospective study we tried to define advantages and disadvantages of percutaneous ventriculostomy with this modified needle in a large number of patients. We treated and followed a total number of 200 patients with external ventricular drainage for various reasons (42% obstructive hydrocephalus, 27% haematocephalus, 11% malresorptive hydrocephalus, 11% elevated ICP and 9% infections). The ventriculostomy is performed — after percutaneous trepheication with a 1.5 mm drill and 1.2 mm needle under the local aesthesia as a bedside procedure. The modified blunt needle is provided with markings and a set screw which allows insertion to a prefixed depth and a sharp guide which is withdrawn after penetration of the dura. It is then bent rostrally and fixed by a plaster cast. The mean duration of drainage was 9 days (1–30 days). Mean operating time for the whole procedure including fixation and connection to the drainage system was 20 minutes. Overall complication rate was 13% (N=26). Two intracerebral haemorrhages (1%) occurred, of which one was caused by overdrainage. Five (3%) infections in primarily not infectious cases (N=182) were seen. Only one case of infection occurred without loosing of the needle on day 17. In 19 patients (10%) the needles had loosened. Fifteen times this complication was repaired in time and no infection occurred. The overall complication rate (13%) and the needle related risk of bleeding (0.5%) seem average. The true risk of infection with correct handling (0.5%) is very low despite the very long average duration of drainage. The main risk lies in the markedly high danger of loosening (10%), which entails a disproportionally high demand for nursing care. Nevertheless, we regard percutaneous needle trephination as the ventriculostomy method of choice because of its better practicability and low infection rate.     

Clinical value of percutaneous needle trephination (PNT)

Summary In 56 neurosurgical patients 70 percutaneous needle trephinations were performed. This method was mostly used in patients with acute increase of ICP due to occlusive hydrocephalus of various aetiologies. Thanks to the accuracy and exhaustiveness of CT information, and thanks to the simplicity and safety of percutaneous needle trephination, this latter could be more and more used in daily clinical practice as a diagnostic and therapeutic procedure, for example for the study of adult hydrocephalus, for provisional external ventricular drainage, for treatment of CSF infections, and for ventricular bleedings (also in newborns and premature infants). No serious complication was seen even after prolonged CSF drainage over a period of 41 days. The method of PNT, as described in detail, can be used under sterile conditions at the bedside, on the stretcher in the emergency room, or in the CT or X-ray laboratory. It fulfils the criteria for clinical acceptance: simplicity, low risk, reliability, exactness, and effectiveness.     

Benign intracranial hypertension and disorders of CSF absorption

Sixteen patients suffering from benign intracranial hypertension were studied by a continuous measurement of intraventricular pressure, a simultaneous recording of intraventricular and sagittal sinus pressures, and a measurement of the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) resistance to drainage. Isotope cisternography was performed and the patency of the dural sinuses verified by direct sinography or phlebography or both. The same procedure was used to study 6 other patients suffering from disorders leading to the same type of intracranial hypertension. In 16, our results confirm a defect in CSF absorption mechanisms linked to an abolition of the pressure gradient between CSF and sagittal sinus in 6 patients, as well as an important increase in CSF resistance to drainage in 10 others. Despite this defect, the CSF circulation was normal in most patients (10 of 12) as demonstrated by isotope cisternography.     

A simple technique to reduce the incidence of accidental dural puncture

We would like to respond to recent comments (Reynolds. Anaesthesia 2001: 56 : 1129) on our epidural technique. In our practice we apply loss of resistance to air technique, which helps identify a nick in the dura with a small leak of CSF. On many occasions, only a few drops of CSF and not a constant leak helped identify dural puncture, which could have been missed with the use of saline. Upon inserting the epidural needle, we remove the stylet when the needle is engaged in the interspinous ligament or the ligamentum flavum. Very often, it is difficult for our residents to advance the epidural needle with one hand and apply constant pressure on the plunger with the other hand. Excessive pressure with one hand, by a resident, had caused dural puncture when the needle was pushed in too far. By reinserting the stylet with each advancement of the needle, we remove tissues that may enter and occlude the epidural needle. It is quite possible that constant plunger pressure with saline may also avert this problem.     

Mounting device for external cerebrospinal fluid drainage: the Freiburg Stativ

Background  External drainage of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) is one of the most common neurosurgical procedures. It is important to maintain a stable drainage rate, but with the commonly available mountings for CSF drainage this can be difficult to achieve. The drainage rate is dependent on the height-difference between the CSF space and the drip chamber of the device. Most mountings for open CSF drainage cannot be satisfactorily fixed at the bed of the patient; especially if the head of the bed is moved, there is a risk of over- or underdrainage. Materials and methods  We have therefore constructed a mounting for open CSF drainage which allows appropriate adjustment of the rate of CSF outflow, even if the patient’s head part of the bed is moved. Findings  The device was easily mountable or exchangeable at any hospital bed and served equally well for ventricular or for lumbar drainage. Conclusion  We think that this device can help to reduce serious complication of over- or underdrainage in external CSF drainage.     

Tunneled lumbar drain. Technical note

The authors report a simple and rapid procedure for tunneling a lumbar drain subcutaneously to facilitate chronic cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) drainage. A standard lumbar puncture (LP) is performed with a large-bore Tuohy needle (14- to 16-gauge), the drainage catheter is advanced into the subarachnoid space, and the needle is removed. The free Tuohy needle is then passed from a lateral position and brought out through the initial LP site. The free catheter is fed through the needle, and the needle is removed. The drain is attached to an external drainage bag in the usual manner. The authors have found this method particularly useful in some skull base and spinal surgical applications in which longer term continuous CSF drainage is desired.     

Anterior stromal puncture for recurrent erosion: further experience and new instrumentation

Anterior stromal puncture has recently been proposed as a new treatment for recalcitrant cases of recurrent corneal erosion. Concerns about the risks of corneal perforation and scarring, as well as doubts regarding its efficacy have prevented many patients from benefiting from this procedure. We introduce a new, inexpensive, commercially available instrument designed to standardize this technique, minimize scarring, and prevent corneal perforation. In a clinical trial involving 25 consecutive patients with recurrent erosions resistant to vigorous conservative treatment, the first 11 patients underwent stromal puncture in which a straight tuberculin needle was used; the following 14 were treated with a newly designed prototype needle. All patients in this series remained free of erosions after completion of stromal puncture, except for one woman with marked diffuse anterior basement membrane dystrophy, who went on to develop spontaneous bilateral erosions. Follow-up ranged from 2 months to 30 months (mean, 13 months). There were no complications of stromal puncture, and subjective and objective evaluations revealed no significant postoperative glare. Microscopic analysis of eye bank eyes subjected to anterior stromal puncture procedures demonstrated that the new prototype needle provided shallower penetration and thus less likelihood of perforation or excessive scarring than the straight needle. Also, postoperative discomfort and scarring appeared to be significantly less in patients treated with the prototype needle.     

A flexible metal ventricular catheter for treatment of complicated and protracted infections of the cerebrospinal fluid spaces: Preliminary experiences

Summary In the management of shunt infection, the use of ventricular catheters made of silicone rubber for the temporary external drainage of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) is general practice. However, the eradication of the primary source of infection may be hindered by the affinity of bacteria to silicone-based material. Compared to silicone catheters, a metal drainage device for temporary ventriculostomy appears to offer more favourable conditions for successful eradication of the infection. Since metal needles cannot be implanted permanently and since their screw-type fixation precludes attachment to the skulls of infants or small children, we developed a flexible metal catheter. This catheter was used exclusively for the treatment of particularly serious or chronic infections of the CSF spaces. The catheter is made of implantation steel and consists of a corrugated tube that renders it flexible. Cerebrospinal fluid drains into a receptable bulb at the tip of the tube. Tubing of other materials may be connected to the end of the metal catheter for either external or internal drainage. It was implanted as a temporary and later permanent CSF drainage in 7 male patients aged from 4 to 60 years, who suffered from chronic, recurrent ventriculitis (n = 5) with an average of 7 previous surgical revisions, as well as from complex infections (n = 2; basal tuberculous meningitis, brain abscess). The infections were successfully eliminated in 6 patients. In the remaining patient, the metal catheter for external ventriculostomy had to be removed after 4 days due a leakage of CSF; it was replaced by a silicone catheter and later on by a needle drainage. Other complications, such as secondary infection or intracerebral haemorrhage, did not occur. The average duration of external CSF drainage via the flexible metal catheter was 27 days (range 4–50 days). In 4 patients, the CSF drainage was converted to a permanent ventriculoperitoneal shunt using a new flexible metal catheter. At the time of post-operative follow-up examination (average = 34 weeks), all shunts were functioning and there was no evidence of infection. In cases of especially complicated and protracted CSF infections, the flexible metal ventricular catheter is a promising device for treatment.     

Hollow mandrin facilitates external ventricular drainage placement

Summary Background. Placement of ventricular catheters is a routine procedure in neurosurgery. Ventricle puncture is done using a flexible ventricular catheter stabilised by a solid steel mandrin in order to improve stability during brain penetration. A correct catheter placement is confirmed after removing the solid steel mandrin by observation of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) flow out of the flexible catheter. Incorrect placement makes further punctures necessary. The newly developed device allows CSF flow observation during the puncture procedure and in addition precise intracranial pressure (ICP) measurement.Method. The developed mandrin is hollow with a blunt tip. On one side 4–5 small holes with a diameter of 0.8 mm are drilled corresponding exactly with the holes in the ventricular catheter, allowing CSF to pass into the hollow mandrin as soon as the ventricle is reached. By connecting a small translucent tube at the distal portion of the hollow mandrin ICP can be measured without loss of CSF. The system has been used in 15 patients with subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH) or intraventricular haemeorrhage (IVH) and subsequent hydrocephalus.Findings. The new system improved the external ventricular drainage implantation procedure. In all 15 patients catheter placement was correct. ICP measurement was easy to perform immediately at ventricle puncture. In 4 patients at puncture no spontaneous CSF flow was observed, therefore by connecting a syringe and gentle aspiration of CSF correct placement was confirmed in this unexpected low pressure hydrocephalus. Otherwise by using the conventional technique further punctures would have been necessary.Conclusions. Advantages of the new technique are less puncture procedures with a lower risk of damage to neural structures and reduced risk of intracranial haemorrhages. Implantation of the ventricular catheter to far into the brain can be monitored and this complication can be overcome. Using the connected pressure monitoring tube an exact measurement of the opening intracranial pressure can be obtained performed without losing CSF.     

The predictive value of external continuous lumbar drainage,with cerebrospinal fluid outflow controlled by medium pressure valve,in normal pressure hydrocephalus

Summary Background. Although sporadic studies have described temporary external cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) lumbar drainage as a highly accurate test for predicting the outcome after ventricular shunting in normal pressure hydrocephalus (NPH) patients, a more recent study reports that the positive predictive value of external lumbar drainage (ELD) is high but the negative predictive value is deceptively low. Therefore, we conducted a prospective study in order to evaluate the predictive value of a continuous ELD, with CSF outflow controlled by medium pressure valve, in NPH patients.Method. Twenty-seven patients with presumed NPH were admitted to our department and CSF drainage was carried out by a temporary (ELD) with CSF outflow controlled by a medium pressure valve for five days. All patients received a ventriculoperitoneal shunt using a medium pressure valve based upon preoperative clinical and radiographic criteria of NPH, regardless of ELD outcome. Clinical evaluation of gait disturbances, urinary incontinence and mental status, and radiological evaluation with brain CT was performed prior to and after ELD test, as well as three months after shunting.Findings. Twenty-two patients were finally shunted and included in this study. In a three-month follow-up, using a previously validated score system, overall improvement after permanent shunting correlated well to improvement after ELD test (Spearman’s rho = 0.462, p = 0.03). When considering any degree of improvement as a positive response, ELD test yielded high positive predictive values for all individual parameters (gait disturbances 94%, 95% CI 71%–100%, urinary incontinence 100%, 95% CI 66%–100%, and mental status 100%, 95% CI 66%–100%) but negative predictive values were low (< 50%) except for cognitive impairment (85%, 95% CI 55%–98%).Conclusion. This study suggests that a positive ELD-valve system test should be considered a reliable criterion for preoperative selection of shunt-responsive NPH patients. In case of a negative ELD-valve system test, further investigation of the presumed NPH patients with additional tests should be performed.     

经皮穿刺肝脓肿引流术的临床应用

目的探讨经皮穿刺肝脓肿引流术的临床应用。方法对13例肝脓肿行经皮穿刺引流术,13例均放置引流管持续引流。结果13例手术均获得成功,成功率100%(13/13)。随访15~45天,症状明显好转,病灶缩小或消失。无一例发生并发症。结论经皮穿刺肝脓肿引流术,可缩短病程,手术成功率高,并发症少,值得推广应用。     

Cerebrospinal fluid shunting: anesthetic particularities

The symptomatic treatment of hydrocephalus remains cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) drainage to an external reservoir (external CSF drainage) or to an internal cavity mainly the peritoneum or the right atrium via a unidirectional valve (internal CSF drainage) and finally by endoscopic ventriculocisternostomy. Local anaesthesia is adequate for external CSF drainage in adults and children above 10 years while general anaesthesia is required in all other cases. The main problems encountered in these patients are difficult intubation and full stomach associated with increased intracranial pressure. The anaesthetic approach should favour homeostasis. With the exception of ketamine and enflurane, the majority of anaesthetic drugs can be used. Anti-epileptic drug are mandatory. Antibioprophylaxis mainly against staphylococcus is systematic in internal CSF drainage. Rapid emergence from anaesthesia and extubation should be encouraged. Complications (infectious, mechanical and bleeding kinds) are frequent and are often the cause of reinterventions or revisions of the device, exposing the patients to iterative anaesthesia. Furthermore, patients with shunts are at risk of malfunction of the device when exposed to situations like pregnancy, magnetic resonance imaging, or laparoscopy. Under these circumstances, it is recommended to associate the neurosurgical team in the management of these patients and to verify that the shunt is working well before and after the procedure or event.     

Treatment of failed Adult Chiari Malformation decompression with CSF drainage: observations in six patients

OBJECTIVE: We report the use of CSF drainage for the management of failed Adult Chiari Malformation (ACM) decompression. METHODS: All patients with more than one year follow-up after treatment of their failed ACM were included in this study. They underwent initial decompression between September 1998 and April 2000. Clinical and radiological data were collected initially and at recurrence. Lumbar punctures (LP) were done at recurrence for diagnostic and therapeutic purposes. Opening pressures and symptomatic relief were recorded. Therapeutic options included intermittent LP and ventriculo-peritoneal shunting (VPS). RESULTS: There were 6 patients (5 females and one male). Their age ranged from 19 to 43 years. Tonsillar descent ranged from 5 to 21 mm. The symptoms recurred 1.5 to 9 months postoperatively (average 5.6 months). Postoperative imaging revealed the presence of CSF flow behind the tonsils and the formation of a retrotonsillar neocistern in all patients. On LP, the opening pressure ranged from 17 to 31 cm of water (average 23 cm). All patients improved after CSF drainage, and four patients underwent VPS. The other patients were treated with repeat LP+/-Acetazolamide. There was significant improvement in all patients, with 18 months follow-up after CSF drainage (range 16-21 months). CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest a role for CSF drainage in the treatment of some patients with failed ACM surgery. Possible explanations for the failure of ACM surgery in this subgroup include: surgical complications leading to neural hydrodynamic alteration, inadequate initial surgery, and coexistence with another pathology, possibly a mild form of intracranial hypertension. More prospective and hydrodynamic studies are needed to further clarify these issues.     

A comparison of the 24-gauge Sprotte and Gertie Marx spinal needles for combined spinal-epidural analgesia during labor

BACKGROUND: Prior experience with the combined spinal-epidural technique (CSE) for labor analgesia demonstrated a high (up to 14%) failure rate because of failure to obtain cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) or lack of response to appropriate doses of intrathecal sufentanil. The current study was designed to test whether a longer needle with a shorter side port (Gertie Marx needle; 127 mm long) would eliminate failures to obtain CSF compared with the needle we had used previously (Sprotte needle; 120 mm long). METHODS: Seventy-three parturients were randomly assigned to have a CSE performed with one of these two needles. After identifying the epidural space with an 18-gauge Touhy needle at the L2-L3 or L3-L4 interspace, the spinal needle was introduced through the Touhy needle until penetration of the dura was felt or until the needle was maximally inserted. If no CSF was obtained, the alternate needle was tried. After obtaining CSF, 10 microg sufentanil diluted in 1.8 ml saline was injected. Verbal pain scores (0-10) were obtained every 5 min for 30 min. RESULTS: Failure to obtain CSF occurred six times in the Sprotte group compared with none in the Gertie Marx group (P < 0.05). In all six failures in the Sprotte group, the Gertie Marx needle subsequently proved successful in obtaining CSF. There were no differences in pain scores between the groups. CONCLUSIONS: The extra length of the 127-mm Gertie Marx needle resulted in a higher success rate for obtaining CSF when used in the CSE technique. Side port design was not a factor influencing success in this clinical setting.     

The risk of rebleeding after external lumbar drainage in patients with untreated ruptured cerebral aneurysms

Summary Background. Does continuous external lumbar CSF drainage before aneurysm repair in patients with aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage increase the risk of rebleeding? Method. The study population, consisting of 18 patients treated by External Lumbar Drainage (ELD) after SAH before aneurysm repair, was compared with an independent control group of 324 SAH patients treated in another clinic. Control patients were selected for not being treated for the ruptured aneurysm yet and not having undergone any form of CSF drainage during the exposure time in the case patients. We calculated hazard ratios with the Cox regression model, adjusted for age and clinical condition on admission and hydrocephalus. Findings. The cox regression analysis shows a non-adjusted hazard ratio of 2.1 (95% CI 0.8 to 5.3) in the model with 5 rebleedings in 18 patients. Adjustment for age, clinical condition on admission and hydrocephalus did not alter the hazard ratio estimate importantly in either analyses. Conclusions. An increased risk of rebleeding by external lumbar drainage in the acute phase after aneurysmal SAH could not be confirmed, but the data are too imprecise to rule out an increased risk. The potential benefits of early drainage should be weighed against the risks if the aneurysm is not occluded before or early after the start of drainage.     

Current possibilities in the treatment of infected pancreatic necrosis

This is a retrospective study about 80 patients treated for infected necrosis of the pancreas between 1998-2003. Operation was performed in 74 patients, diagnosis was achieved by CT or U.S. guided drainage in 12 patients. In further 6 patients drainage and antibiotic therapy provided cure. In patients who were drained pre-operatively (n=12) the first surgical intervention was performed on average on the 30.2 days after admission, while in the group of patients without drainage surgery became necessary after 15.6 days. The difference is statistically significant (p = 0.001). Our data proved that in certain cases percutaneous drainage can delay surgical intervention. Our results also prove that percutaneous drainage itself can lead to complete cure. In our own practice this stands for about 20% of our patients. In 3 patients we proved that if the patients general condition is stable infected necrosis detected by fine needle aspiration can be successfully treated by antibiotic therapy, without surgical or further radiological intervention.     

Port-site closure: a new problem, an old device.

OBJECTIVE: Trocar-site incisional hernias and their complications are reported in 1% to 6% of patients. Such hernias are attributed to the difficulty of applying standard suturing techniques to wound closure. We report our experience with a simple device, the Deschamps ligature needle. METHODS: The Deschamps needle has a handle and a tip (sharp or blunt), with an opening to pass suture. The blunt tip is very effective for closing trocar sites. Disposable needles are obviously sharp, but can bend on the needle holder and break in a deep small incision. The Deschamps needle is a rigid, noncutting instrument that can be forced through fascia and peritoneum (around the surgeon's fingertip) avoiding loss of pneumoperitoneum. A full-thickness closure is accomplished. We perform closure under direct vision through the scope. Tactile sense is provided by the surgeon's finger. The last trocar site is closed in the same manner without the scope. RESULTS: We have used the Deschamps needle since 1992 in all (1400) laparoscopic procedures. We close 10-mm and 5-mm trocar sites and have not observed wound dehiscence or hernias at these sites. CONCLUSION: The Deschamps needle is effective in preventing incisional hernias and wound dehiscence. It is cost-effective. Disposable, single-use devices vary in price from $30 to $75 each. The Deschamps needle is sold in Italy at approximately $35 each. Considering that it may have been in the trays of most operating rooms for years (as in our case), and the number of procedures performed, we conclude that the real cost of this instrument is almost negligible.     

Prophylactic percutaneous sealing of lumbar postdural puncture hole with fibrin glue to prevent cerebrospinal fluid leakage in swine

We explored the effect of fibrin glue injection at the site of dural puncture on cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leakage in a swine model. Pigs were subjected to a lumbar dural CSF puncture in the sitting position with a 17-gauge Tuohy needle. Fibrin glue 1.4 mL was injected through the same needle into the epidural space. Evans blue dye was infused through the cisterna magna 15 min later, and the appearance of dyed CSF through the skin puncture and along the needle trajectory to the dura was inspected and categorized. In seven of eight animals, the CSF leak was sealed with fibrin glue. Control animals were injected with 1.4 mL saline. A sham operation group of animals underwent cisternal dye infusion without a lumbar puncture. CSF pressure at the cisterna magna was recorded throughout the procedure. No significant differences in the leakage indicators were found between the fibrin glue-injected and sham-operated group, whereas both groups showed significant differences with respect to the control group. The fibrin glue seal was effective against CSF pressures of 24.5 [17-31] cm H(2)O. We conclude that percutaneously injected fibrin glue is effective in stopping CSF leaks after dural puncture in this animal model. IMPLICATIONS: In this swine study, we repaired a cerebrospinal fluid leak after a dural puncture by percutaneously injecting tissue adhesive. The technique of percutaneous injection of fibrin glue seems promising for the prophylaxis of headache associated with cerebrospinal fluid leakage, and may be an alternative to an epidural blood patch.