Characterizing the Dynamics of Postural Sway in Humans Using Smoothness and Regularity Measures

We investigate human postural sway velocity time series by computing two dynamical statistics quantifying the smoothness (the central tendency measure or CTM) and the regularity (the sample entropy or SampEn) of their underlying dynamics. The purpose of the study is to investigate the effect of aging and vision on the selected measures and to explore the nature of postural dynamics by performing surrogate data tests. A group of 14 young subjects was compared to a group of 11 older healthy subjects in two visual conditions: with eyes open (EO) and with eyes closed (EC). The results suggest that vision and age do not influence the two statistics of the velocity data in the same way. More specifically, the smoothness statistic is able to detect the aging effect. The regularity measure is sensitive to the visual feedback removal. In contrast with some findings in the literature, the results of the surrogate data tests indicate that the center of pressure velocity dynamics are stochastic and are not produced by a purely determinisitic behavior. Finally, we discuss some potential implications of our results in terms of postural control mechanisms.     

视觉因素对前交叉韧带重建患者足底压力中心的影响

目的 分析患者前交叉韧带重建(anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, ACLR)术后早期与术后 1 年在视觉因素影响下足底压力中心面积(center of pressure area, COPA)和压力中心速度(center of pressure speed, COPS)等参数的变化。 方法 纳入 ACLR 患者 17 例,于术后早期和术后 1 年测试足底 COPA 和 COPS 等数据;匹配 17 例健康受试者作为对照组。 进行睁、闭眼不同视觉状态站立平衡测试,对各测量状态进行相关性分析。 结果 双足站立测试时,短期组 COPA 和 COPS 在睁眼和闭眼对比均有统计学差异(P<0. 05);长期组 COPS 睁眼和闭眼对比有统计学差异(P<0. 001)。 健侧站立时,各组间差异具有统计学意义(P<0. 05),伤侧站立时各组间差异无统计学意义(P>0. 05)。 健侧站立睁眼条件下,长期组 COPA 高于短期组和对照组,对照组 COPS 低于短期组和长期组(P<0. 01)。 健侧站立闭眼条件下,对照组 COPA 低于短期组和长期组,对照组 COPS 低于长期组(P<0. 01)。 双足睁眼与双足闭眼之间、双足睁眼与伤侧睁眼之间、健侧睁眼和伤侧睁眼之间、健侧闭眼和伤侧闭眼之间在 COPA 和COPS 上均呈正相关。 结论 通过对 ACLR 患者站立位压力中心相关数据的分析,发现视觉对姿势稳定控制有重要影响。 术后 1 年患者双足和单足站立时对比正常人稳定性波动较大,提示在临床上要加强术后长期训练以巩固康复效果,并对开展长期评估和制定精准训练计划具有一定的指导作用,以防止术后长时间功能退化和降低再次损伤的风险。     

Nonlinear analysis of orthostatic posture in patients with vertigo or balance disorders

The stabilometry signals involve irregular and unpredictable components. In order to identify the hidden dynamics that underlie the multi-link networks consisted of the multiple sensory systems, motor components and central integration, we applied a nonlinear analysis to these signals. We evaluated the postural control differences between eyes open and closed by means of the dynamical closeness between two states, known as similarity index, for the patients with vestibular disorders. We were able to demonstrate that some patients (eight of 21) showed a difference between the conventional and nonlinear measures. Especially, the similarity index tended to reflect the clinical course of the vestibular compensation and the findings in the patients with benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (BPPV) demonstrated that its vestibular function may include various pathologies besides canalithiasis. These results suggest that nonlinear analysis can elucidate the complex postural control networks and this procedure may also be able to provide the new findings of the stabilometry examinations.     

Dental occlusion and postural control in adults

We studied the influence of a dental occlusion perturbation on postural control. The tests were performed in three dental occlusion conditions: (Rest Position: no dental contact, Maximal Intercuspal Occlusion: maximal dental contact, and Thwarted Laterality Occlusion: simulation of a dental malocclusion) and four postural conditions: static (stable platform) and dynamic (unstable platform), with eyes open and eyes closed. A decay of postural control was noted between the Rest Position and Thwarted Laterality Occlusion conditions with regard to average speed and power indexes in dynamic conditions and with eyes closed. However, the head position and stabilization were not different from those in the other experimental conditions, which means that the same functional goal was reached with an increase in the total energetic cost. This work shows that dental occlusion differently affects postural control, depending on the static or dynamic conditions. Indeed, dental occlusion impaired postural control only in dynamic postural conditions and in absence of visual cues. The sensory information linked to the dental occlusion comes into effect only during difficult postural tasks and its importance grows as the other sensory cues become scarce.     

The effect of a first-generation H1-antihistamine on postural control: a preliminary study in healthy volunteers

First-generation H₁-antihistamines are known to cause fatigue and drowsiness, due to their poor receptor selectivity and their high penetration rate of the blood–brain barrier. However, little is known about the effects of first-generation H₁-antihistamines on postural stability. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of d-chlorpheniramine on postural stability using posturography with and without foam rubber. A double-blind study with three parallel groups was conducted. Twenty-seven healthy young volunteers (mean age 21.9 years) were recruited and orally administered d-chlorpheniramine, 2 or 4 mg, or placebo. Postural sway was measured every hour up to 8 h after administration. Two-legged stance tasks were performed by each subject in four conditions: eyes open or eyes closed and with or without foam rubber. Inter-group comparisons showed that the group receiving 4-mg d-chlorpheniramine showed significantly larger sway in the eyes open with foam rubber condition (visual and vestibular information available, somatosensory information reduced). Inter-subject analysis in the 4-mg d-chlorpheniramine group showed that the effect of d-chlorpheniramine on postural control was variable. Our results suggest that among the three main sensory systems responsible for postural control (visual, vestibular, and somatosensory), d-chlorpheniramine may have a larger effect on the visual and/or vestibular systems in susceptible individuals.     

Effects of immersion in virtual reality on postural control

In the present study, we examined the effects of the time lag between visual scene and the head movement in the virtual reality (VR) world on motion sickness and postural control in healthy volunteers. After immersion in VR with additional time lags (from 0 to 0.8 s) to the inherent delay (about 250 ms), the visual-vestibular conflict induced a slight motion sickness in experimental subjects, but no change was noticed in the body sway path with eyes open and closed. However, Romberg ratio of body sway path with eyes closed divided by that with eyes open after immersion in VR was significantly decreased in comparison with that before immersion in VR. Since Romberg ratio is an index of visual dependency on postural control, this finding indicates that the immersion in VR decreases the visual dependency on postural control. It is suggested that adaptation to visual-vestibular conflict in VR immersion increases the contribution of vestibular and somatosensory inputs to postural control by ignoring the conflicting delayed visual input in the VR world. VR may be a promising treatment for visual vertigo in vestibular patients with unsuccessful compensation by its ability to induce vestibular and somatosensory reweighing for postural control.     

Recurrence analysis of human postural sway during the sensory organization test

The present study examined how the availability of and alterations in sensory information during the sensory organization test (SOT) influenced the amount, variability, and temporal structure of spontaneous postural sway in young, healthy adults. Findings indicated that postural sway tended to increase in amount and variability as the SOT condition became increasingly difficult (i.e. as the SOT condition moved from eyes open to eyes closed, to sway-referenced visual surround or support surface, and to sway-reference surface and visual surround). In addition, recurrence quantification analysis revealed that the temporal structure of postural sway tended to become increasingly regular as the SOT condition increased in difficulty. The functional utility of the observed changes in the temporal structure of postural sway across sensory conditions was discussed.     

Postural control in women with breast hypertrophy

OBJECTIVES:

The consequences of breast hypertrophy have been described based on the alteration of body mass distribution, leading to an impact on psychological and physical aspects. The principles of motor control suggest that breast hypertrophy can lead to sensorimotor alterations and the impairment of body balance due to postural misalignment. The aim of this study is to evaluate the postural control of women with breast hypertrophy under different sensory information conditions.

METHOD:

This cross-sectional study included 14 women with breast hypertrophy and 14 without breast hypertrophy, and the mean ages of the groups were 39±15 years and 39±16 years, respectively. A force platform was used to assess the sensory systems that contribute to postural control: somatosensory, visual and vestibular. Four postural conditions were sequentially tested: eyes open and fixed platform, eyes closed and fixed platform, eyes open and mobile platform, and eyes closed and mobile platform. The data were processed, and variables related to the center of pressure were analyzed for each condition. The Kruskal-Wallis test was used to compare the conditions between the groups for the area of center of pressure displacement and the velocity of center of pressure displacement in the anterior-posterior and medial-lateral directions. The alpha level error was set at 0.05.

RESULTS:

Women with breast hypertrophy presented an area that was significantly higher for three out of four conditions and a higher velocity of center of pressure displacement in the anterior-posterior direction under two conditions: eyes open and mobile platform and eyes closed and mobile platform.

CONCLUSIONS:

Women with breast hypertrophy have altered postural control, which was demonstrated by the higher area and velocity of center of pressure displacement.     

Influence of pathologic and simulated visual dysfunctions on the postural system

Visual control has an influence on postural stability. Whilst vestibular, somatosensoric and cerebellar changes have already been frequency analytically parameterised with posturography, sufficient data regarding the visual system are still missing. The aim of this study was to evaluate the influence of pathologic and simulated visual dysfunctions on the postural system by calculating the frequency analytic representation of the visual system throughout the frequency range F1 (0.03–0.1 Hz) of Fourier analysis. The study was divided into two parts. In the first part, visually handicapped subjects and subjects with normal vision were investigated with posturography regarding postural stability (stability effect, Fourier spectrum of postural sway, etc.) with open and closed eyes. The visually impaired and the normal group differed significantly in the frequency range F1 (p = 0.002). Significant differences of the postural stability between both groups were found only in the test position with open eyes (NO). The healthy group showed a significant loss of stability, whereas the impaired group showed an increased stability due to sufficient somatosensoric processes. Visually handicapped persons can compensate the visual information deficit through improved peripheral–vestibular and somatosensoric perception and cerebellar processing. In the second part, subjects with normal vision were examined under simulated visual conditions, e.g., hyperopia (3.0 D), reduced visual acuity (VA = 20/200), yoke prisms (4 cm/m) and pursuits (pendulum). Changes in postural parameters due to simulations have been compared to a standard situation (open eyes [NO], fixation distance 3 m). Visual simulations showed influence on frequency range F1. Compared to the standard situation, significant differences have been found in reduced visual acuity, pursuits and yoke prisms. A loss of stability was measured for simulated hyperopia, pendulum and yoke prisms base down. Stability regulation can be understood as a multi-sensoric process by the visual, vestibular, somatosensoric and cerebellar system. Reduced influence of a single subsystem is compensated by the other subsystems. Obviously the main part of reduced visual input is compensated by the vestibular system. Moreover, the body sway, represented by the stability indicator, increased in this situation.     

Postural control in athletes participating in an ironman triathlon

We studied the degree of dependence on vision of static postural control among ten male adult ironmen and ten healthy subjects (firemen, control group) who took part in regular physical activity, and the perturbations of equilibrium after prolonged exercise in ironmen. Static postural stability was measured during standing on a single-force platform alternating between eyes open and eyes closed. First, body sway was analysed on a force plate in both groups, and the athletes then took part in an ironman triathlon. The measurement was repeated after the race. The sway in both directions was subjected to spectral analysis. The frequency spectrum of the platform oscillations was calculated by fast Fourier transformation in the intervals 0–0.3, 0.3–1 and 1–3 Hz. The sway path in both directions and the total path were significantly lower in the ironmen than in the control group without vision, and the absence of visual control caused a significant increase in sway in both directions in the control group, but not in the ironmen. The frequency analysis revealed a higher level of stability in the medio–lateral direction with closed eyes. The endurance race caused increases in both the total sway path only with closed eyes, and these changes were significant at higher frequency bands. These results indicate that ironmen are more stable and less dependent on vision for postural control than the control subjects, and the prolonged stimulation of the proprioceptive, vestibular and visual inputs in the endurance race causes a significant disturbance in postural control.     

Postural control in response to an external perturbation: effect of altered proprioceptive information

The purpose of the study was to investigate the role of altered proprioception on anticipatory (APAs) and compensatory (CPAs) postural adjustments and their interaction. Nine healthy adults were exposed to external perturbations induced at the shoulder level while standing with intact or altered proprioception induced by bilateral Achilles tendon vibration. Visual information was altered (eyes open or closed) in both the conditions. Electrical activity of eight trunk and leg muscles and center of pressure (COP) displacements were recorded and quantified within the time intervals typical for APAs and CPAs. The results showed that when proprioceptive information was altered in eyes-open conditions, anticipatory muscle activity was delayed. Moreover, altered proprioceptive information resulted in smaller magnitudes of compensatory muscle activity as well as smaller COP displacements after the perturbation in both eyes-open and eyes-closed conditions. The outcome of the study provides information on the interaction between APAs and CPAs in the presence of altered proprioception.     

Regularity of center-of-pressure trajectories depends on the amount of attention invested in postural control

The influence of attention on the dynamical structure of postural sway was examined in 30 healthy young adults by manipulating the focus of attention. In line with the proposed direct relation between the amount of attention invested in postural control and regularity of center-of-pressure (COP) time series, we hypothesized that: (1) increasing cognitive involvement in postural control (i.e., creating an internal focus by increasing task difficulty through visual deprivation) increases COP regularity, and (2) withdrawing attention from postural control (i.e., creating an external focus by performing a cognitive dual task) decreases COP regularity. We quantified COP dynamics in terms of sample entropy (regularity), standard deviation (variability), sway-path length of the normalized posturogram (curviness), largest Lyapunov exponent (local stability), correlation dimension (dimensionality) and scaling exponent (scaling behavior). Consistent with hypothesis 1, standing with eyes closed significantly increased COP regularity. Furthermore, variability increased and local stability decreased, implying ineffective postural control. Conversely, and in line with hypothesis 2, performing a cognitive dual task while standing with eyes closed led to greater irregularity and smaller variability, suggesting an increase in the "efficiency, or "automaticity" of postural control". In conclusion, these findings not only indicate that regularity of COP trajectories is positively related to the amount of attention invested in postural control, but also substantiate that in certain situations an increased internal focus may in fact be detrimental to postural control.     

Dynamical structure of center-of-pressure trajectories in patients recovering from stroke

In a recent study, De Haart et al. (Arch Phys Med Rehabil 85:886-895, 2004) investigated the recovery of balance in stroke patients using traditional analyses of center-of-pressure (COP) trajectories to assess the effects of health status, rehabilitation, and task conditions like standing with eyes open or closed and standing while performing a cognitive dual task. To unravel the underlying control processes, we reanalyzed these data in terms of stochastic dynamics using more advanced analyses. Dimensionality, local stability, regularity, and scaling behavior of COP trajectories were determined and compared with shuffled and phase-randomized surrogate data. The presence of long-range correlations discarded the possibility that the COP trajectories were purely random. Compared to the healthy controls, the COP trajectories of the stroke patients were characterized by increased dimensionality and instability, but greater regularity in the frontal plane. These findings were taken to imply that the stroke patients actively (i.e., cognitively) coped with the stroke-induced impairment of posture, as reflected in the increased regularity and decreased local stability, by recruiting additional control processes (i.e., more degrees of freedom) and/or by tightening the present control structure while releasing non-essential degrees of freedom from postural control. In the course of rehabilitation, dimensionality stayed fairly constant, whereas local stability increased and regularity decreased. The progressively less regular COP trajectories were interpreted to indicate a reduction of cognitive involvement in postural control as recovery from stroke progressed. Consistent with this interpretation, the dual task condition resulted in less regular COP trajectories of greater dimensionality, reflecting a task-related decrease of active, cognitive contributions to postural control. In comparison with conventional posturography, our results show a clear surplus value of dynamical measures in studying postural control.     

The relationship between postural stability and virtual environment adaptation

Currently little is known about how adaptive responses to virtual environments are different between individuals who experience sickness related symptoms and those who do not. It is believed that sensory interactions between visually perceived self-motion and static inertial cues from vestibular and/or proprioceptive sensory systems contribute to the development of adaptation symptoms. The aim of this study was to evaluate the relationship between adaptation symptoms and postural stability in a virtual environment (VE) driving simulator. In addition, the role of sensory interaction was assessed using direct electrical stimulation techniques of the vestibular and cutaneous sensory systems. Posture performance was measured using centre of pressure measures of single leg stance tests during eyes open and eyes closed conditions. Correlation analysis of postural measures and symptom scores were conducted, as well as analysis of variance of posture performance between SICK and WELL individuals. Results indicate that posture stability is negatively correlated to symptom reporting. WELL individuals displayed the greatest decrease in postural stability during eyes open single leg stance following VE simulation. Application of a secondary sensory stimulation (vestibular or cutaneous) resulted in increased visual dependency for postural control following simulation. Combined, these results suggest that sensory interactions drive postural changes that are observed following VE simulation and are related to how visual information is used to control posture.     

Balance control and adaptation during vibratory perturbations in middle-aged and elderly humans

The objective was to investigate if healthy elderly people respond and adapt differently to postural disturbances compared to middle-aged people. Thirty middle-aged (mean age 37.8 years, range 24–56 years) and forty healthy elderly subjects (mean age 74.6 years, range 66–88 years) were tested with posturography. Body sway was evoked by applying pseudorandom vibratory stimulation to the belly of the gastrocnemius muscles of both legs simultaneously. The tests were performed both with eyes open and eyes closed. The anteroposterior body sway was measured with a force platform and analyzed with a method that considers the adaptive changes of posture and stimulation responses. The results showed that middle-aged people generally used a different postural control strategy as compared to the elderly. The elderly responded more rapidly to vibratory perturbation, used more high-frequency (>0.1 Hz) motions and the motion dynamics had a higher degree of complexity. Moreover, the elderly had diminished ability to use visual information to improve balance control. Altogether, despite having an effective postural control adaptation similar to that of middle-aged people, the elderly had more difficultly in withstanding balance perturbations. These findings suggest that the balance control deterioration associated with aging cannot be fully compensated for by postural control adaptation.     

Degradation of postural control system as a consequence of Parkinson's disease and ageing

In this study we have shown how Parkinson's disease and ageing affect the postural control system. Our investigation of that system has involved analysis of quiet-standing center of pressure (COP) trajectories. Using the method derived from Langevin equation, we have found disease-specific and age-specific changes in the dynamics of the COP. These findings were obtained from a comparison of the diffusion matrix, the friction coefficient and the matrix of the fluctuation strength for healthy young, healthy elderly and parkinsonian (elderly) subjects under eyes-open and eyes-closed conditions. Especially the analysis of the friction coefficient and the matrix of the fluctuation strength have allowed the more detailed study of the postural control system of the parkinsonian and elderly subjects. We have found that the healthy elderly as well as parkinsonian subjects exhibit larger level of the muscular stochastic activity, compared to the young subjects. Furthermore, closure their eyes causes further increment of that activity. We have also shown that for the healthy elderly subjects a compensating mechanism, which can be described by the friction coefficient, acts under eyes-closed conditions, whereas for parkinsonian subjects this mechanism was not observed. Thus, the increase of the muscular activity is an age-specific indicator, whereas the absence of the compensation of that increase is a disease-specific indicator.     

Postural control in children with strabismus: Effect of eye surgery

The purpose of this study was to examine the postural control in children with strabismus before and after eye surgery. Control of posture is a complex multi-sensorial process relying on visual, vestibular and proprioceptive systems. Reduced influence of one of such systems leads to postural adaptation due to a compensation of one of the other systems [3]. Nine children with strabismus (4-8 years old) participated in the study. Ophthalmologic, orthoptic, vestibular and postural tests were done before and twice (2 and 8 weeks) after eye surgery. Postural stability was measured by a platform (TechnoConcept): two components of the optic flux were used for stimulation (contraction and expansion) and two conditions were tested eyes open and eyes closed. The surface area of the center of pressure (CoP), the variance of speed of the CoP and the frequency spectrum of the platform oscillations by fast Fourier transformation were analysed. Before surgery, similar to typically developing children, postural stability was better in the eyes open condition. The frequency analysis revealed that for the low frequency band more energy was spent in the antero-posterior direction compared to the medio-lateral one while the opposite occurred for the middle and the high frequency bands. After surgery, the eye deviation was reduced in all children and their postural stability also improved. However, the energy of the high frequency band in the medio-lateral direction increased significantly. These findings suggest that eye surgery influences somatosensory properties of extra-ocular muscles leading to improvement of postural control and that binocular visual perception could influence the whole body.     

The effects of spaceflight on open-loop and closed-loop postural control mechanisms: human neurovestibular studies on SLS-2

Stabilogram-diffusion analysis was used to examine how prolonged periods in microgravity affect the open-loop and closed-loop postural control mechanisms. It was hypothesized that following spaceflight: (1) the effective stochastic activity of the open-loop postural control schemes in astronauts is increased; (2) the effective stochastic activity and uncorrelated behavior, respectively, of the closed-loop postural control mechanisms in astronauts are increased; and (3) astronauts utilize open-loop postural control schemes for shorter time intervals and smaller displacements. Four crew members and two alternates from the 14-day Spacelab Life Sciences 2 Mission were included in the study. Each subject was tested under eyes-open, quiet-standing conditions on multiple preflight and postflight days. The subjects' center-of-pressure trajectories were measured with a force platform and analyzed according to stabilogram-diffusion analysis. It was found that the effective stochastic activity of the open-loop postural control schemes in three of the four crew members was increased following space-flight. This result is interpreted as an indication that there may be in-flight adaptations to higher-level descending postural control pathways, e.g., a postflight increase in the tonic activation of postural muscles. This change may also be the consequence of a compensatory (e.g., stiffening) postural control strategy that is adopted by astronauts to account for general feelings of post-flight unsteadiness. The crew members, as a group, did not exhibit any consistent preflight/postflight differences in the steady-state behavior of their closed-loop postural control mechanisms or in the functional interaction of their open-loop and closed-loop postural control mechanisms. These results are interpreted as indications that although there may be in-flight adaptations to the vestibular system and/or proprioceptive system, input from the visual system can compensate for such changes during undisturbed stance.     

脑卒中患者姿势控制的感觉系统特征

目的 研究脑卒中患者姿势控制的感觉系统特征,分析各感受器对脑卒中患者姿势控制能力的贡献率和利用率。 方法 老年脑卒中患者 30 例(患者组)和健康老年人 30 例(对照组)采用计算机动态姿势描记系统进行感觉统合测试(sensory organization test,SOT),记录 6 种条件下的平衡得分、平衡综合分,计算分析视觉、本体感觉、前庭觉在不同站立条件下的贡献率与整体利用率。 结果 患者组在闭眼/ 支撑面稳定(Z = -3. 248,P = 0. 001)、视觉干扰/ 支撑面稳定 ( Z = - 2. 829, P = 0. 005)、 闭眼/ 支撑面不稳 ( Z = - 4. 283, P = 0)、 视觉干扰/ 支撑面不稳(Z= -4. 074,P= 0)条件下的平衡分显著低于对照组,平衡综合分显著低于对照组(Z = -4. 133,P = 0)。 睁眼/ 支撑面稳定和闭眼/ 支撑面稳定测试中,患者组本体感觉占比分别为 16. 351% 、34. 942% ,对照组本体感觉占比分别为14. 307% 、18. 390% ,患者组本体感觉占比始终大于对照组,说明本体感觉对患者组作用大于对照组。 同理,视觉对患者组作用大于对照组。 不同站立条件下前庭觉的贡献率最低为 64. 648% ,说明维持人体平衡主要因素是前庭觉。 患者组本体感觉、视觉、前庭觉的利用率分别为 95. 092% 、72. 382% 、32. 879% ,其中本体感觉(Z = - 1. 984,P= 0. 047)、前庭觉(Z= -4. 283,P= 0)利用率显著低于对照组。 结论 脑卒中患者感觉系统的贡献率与利用率下降是脑卒中患者姿势控制障碍的重要因素之一,其中姿势控制贡献率前庭觉最大,其次为本体感觉、视觉。 而其姿势控制利用率最大的为本体感觉,其次为视觉、前庭觉。 影响脑卒中患者姿势控制能力下降的原因之一为脑卒中患者本体感觉、视觉的感觉信息输入效率下降,以及其本体感觉、前庭觉参与运动输出的部分降低。 建议脑卒中患者注重本体感觉、前庭觉的训练以提高其姿势控制能力。