In vitro analysis of transformation potential associated with retroviral vector insertions.

While replication-defective retroviral vectors provide excellent vehicles for the long-term expression of therapeutic genes, they also harbor the potential to induce undesired genetic changes by random insertions into the host genome. The rate of insertional mutagenesis for retroviral vectors has been determined in several different assay systems; however, the rate at which such events induce cellular transformation has not been directly determined. Such measurements are critical to determining the actual risk of carcinogenesis resulting from retroviral gene therapy. In this study, the ability of a replication-defective retroviral vector, GlnBgSvNa, to induce cellular transformation in the BALB/c-3T3 in vitro transformation assay was assessed. The transformation frequency observed in vector-transduced BALB/c-3T3 cells, which contained one to six copies of integrated provirus, was not significantly different from that of untreated control cells. The finding that GlnBgSvNa was nontransforming in this assay indicates that the rate of transformation induced by retroviral insertions is less than the spontaneous rate of cellular transformation by BALB/c-3T3 cells, or less than 1.1 x 10(-5). These results are the first to define an upper limit for the rate of transformation induced by retroviral vectors.     

Human gene targeting favors insertions over deletions

Gene targeting is a powerful technique for manipulating the human genome, but few studies have directly compared the targeting frequencies of various types of vector constructs. Here we show that similar targeting constructs are able to insert nucleotides at the homologous chromosomal target locus more efficiently than they can delete nucleotides, and combination insertion/deletion vectors appear to target at intermediate frequencies. This holds true for deletions ranging from 1 to 334 bp and insertions ranging from 1 to 1332 bp. In addition, vectors designed to inactivate the human hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase gene (HPRT) by deleting nucleotides often produced rearrangements at the target locus that in many cases were due to insertions of multimerized vector constructs, effectively converting a deletion vector into an insertion vector. These findings were obtained when adeno-associated virus vectors were used to efficiently deliver single-stranded DNA targeting constructs, but the same phenomenon was also observed when transfecting linearized double-stranded plasmids. Thus human cells distinguish between deletion and insertion vectors and process their recombination intermediates differently, presumably at the heteroduplex stage, with implications for the design of gene-targeting vectors and the evolution of human genomes.     

Development of herpesvirus-based episomally maintained gene delivery vectors

Successful gene therapy aims to deliver and express therapeutic genes to cure or slow the progression of disease. However, a major obstacle in the application of gene therapy has been the development of the vectors used to deliver heterologous DNA to the cell or tissue of choice. A number of viral- and non-viral-based vector systems have undergone clinical trials with varying success. However, at present, no vector system possesses the full complement of properties that are generally believed necessary in an ideal gene delivery system. Therefore, alongside attempts to improve current gene delivery vectors, the identification and evaluation of new viral vectors is crucial for the long-term success of gene therapy. Herpesviruses are large DNA viruses which possess a number of advantages as gene delivery vectors. These relate to an ability to package large DNA insertions and establish lifelong latent infections in which the genomic material exists as a stable episome. This review aims to highlight the potential of herpesvirus vectors, in particular an alternative vector system based on herpesvirus saimiri (HVS). HVS is capable of infecting a range of human cell lines with high efficiencies, and the viral genome persists as high copy number, circular, non-integrated episomes which segregate to progeny following cell division. This allows the virus-based vector to stably transduce a dividing cell population and provide sustained transgene expression for an extended period of time both in vitro and in vivo. Moreover, the insertion of a bacterial artificial chromosome cassette into the HVS genome simplifies the incorporation of large amounts of heterologous DNA for gene delivery. These properties offer characteristics similar to an artificial chromosome combined with an efficient delivery system and merit its continual development as a possible gene delivery vector for the future.     

Mutagenesis and oncogenesis by chromosomal insertion of gene transfer vectors

Increasing evidence reveals that random insertion of gene transfer vectors into the genome of repopulating hematopoietic cells may alter their fate in vivo. Although most insertional mutations are expected to have few if any consequences for cellular survival, clonal dominance caused by retroviral vector insertions in (or in the vicinity of) proto-oncogenes or other signaling genes has been described for both normal and malignant hematopoiesis. Important insights into these side effects were initially obtained in murine models. Results from ongoing clinical studies have revealed that similar adverse events may also occur in human gene therapy. However, it remains unknown to what extent the outcome of insertional mutagenesis induced by gene vectors is related to (1) the architecture and type of vector used, (2) intrinsic properties of the target cell, and (3) extrinsic and potentially disease-specific factors influencing clonal competition in vivo. This review discusses reports addressing these questions, underlining the need for models that demonstrate and quantify the functional consequences of insertional mutagenesis. Improving vector design appears to be the most straightforward approach to increase safety, provided all relevant cofactors are considered.     

Analysis of gamma-globin expression cassettes in retrovirus vectors

With the goal of optimizing retrovirus vectors for human gamma-globin, we studied the effect of several globin gene expression elements on vector titer, stability, and expression. We found that all combinations tested were genetically stable, but that vectors with therapeutic titers (0.5 to 2 x 10(6) colony-forming units/ml) could be achieved only by either partially or fully deleting the second intron of the Agamma-globin gene. Efficient transfer and high-level expression was achieved only when an optimized beta-globin promoter was linked to an Agamma-globin cassette containing an intact intron 1 and a 714-bp internal deletion of intron 2. When flanked by two copies of the HS-40 enhancer core from the alpha-globin locus, this cassette expressed gamma-globin mRNA at 46 +/- 19% per copy of mouse alpha-globin in the murine erythroleukemia cell line MEL585. Complete deletion of the first or second intron diminished expression to < or = 2.0%, and deletion of the HS-40 enhancer diminished expression to 7 +/- 8%. High-level, uniform expression of gamma-globin protein was confirmed in MEL585 clones (n = 12) transduced with the optimized vector. Efficient but variable expression of the optimized vector was also observed in erythroid progenitor colonies (n = 6) grown from transduced mouse bone marrow. Taken together, these studies demonstrate the role of intronic, promoter, and enhancer sequences on retrovirus vectors for human gamma-globin, and the development of an optimized vector capable of efficient expression in a murine erythroid cell line and primary cultures.     

Evidence for nonspecific adsorption of targeted retrovirus vector particles to cells

The ability to specifically target a cell-type is important for the development of vectors for in vivo gene therapy. In order to produce retrovirus vectors targeting ovarian cancer cells, which specifically overexpress alpha folate receptor (alphaFR), a single chain antibody was fused as an N-terminal extension of the ecotropic and amphotropic murine leukemia virus (MLV) envelope glycoproteins. Vector particles bearing the modified glycoproteins were produced and analysed. Although conventional FACS studies indicated that viral particles bearing the modified Env could bind to ovarian cancer cells, targeted infection was not achieved. The initial step of virus-cell interaction was further studied using an immunofluorescence technique, which allows visualisation of single retrovirus particles. Vectors bearing chimeric or wild-type glycoproteins bound equally well to cells with or without the targeted receptor, although soluble chimeric glycoproteins bound specifically to FBP. Our results indicate that the incorporation of specific ligands to the virus envelope does not necessarily result in significant enhancement of vector particle binding. A similar interaction was also observed using Env-defective virus particles, suggesting that cellular factors incorporated into the lipid envelope play a dominant role in promoting initial adsorption of virus particles to cells. Significant implications arise from these observations on the interpretation of previous reports on 'targeted' vectors, and for the development of vectors for in vivo gene therapy protocols.     

Development of a suspension packaging cell line for production of high titre, serum-resistant murine leukemia virus vectors.

To date, only adherent cell lines have been used for the generation of packaging cells for the production of type C retrovirus vectors. The large-scale production of high titre retrovirus vectors could benefit from the development of packaging cells growing in suspension. Here, we describe the ability of two different lymphoid cell lines, one B- and one T-lymphoblastoid cell line (Namalwa and CEM, respectively), to produce MLV-based vectors. Upon transfection with a third generation packaging construct, the virus particle production by Namalwa cells was characterised by low RT-activity, and by CEM cells as high RT activity as previously established adherent packaging cells. An amphotropic packaging cell line (CEMFLYA) was therefore established from CEM cells. Upon introduction of a lacZ vector genome, the novel packaging cell line produced vector particles routinely in the region of 10(7) infectious units/ml. The vectors were helper-free and highly stable in fresh human serum. The potential for scaled up vector production was demonstrated by continuous culture of the new packaging cells for 14 days in a 250 ml spinner flask. These suspension packaging cells should be applicable to large bioreactor systems to bulk produce high titre, complement-resistant retrovirus vectors for gene therapy.     

Production of minigene-containing retroviral vectors using an alphavirus/retrovirus hybrid vector system.

In an attempt to increase the synthesis of human clotting factors VIII and IX in transduced cells, optimized expression cassettes containing genomic genelike elements (minigenes) were assembled. Plasmid DNA containing factor VIII or factor IX minigenes and driven by three human cellular promoters (albumin, factor IX, PGK) or the strong viral promoter RSV-LTR were electroporated into TE671 and HepG2 cell lines, and clotting factor levels were determined by ELISA. In comparison with a parallel transfection of MLV-LTR-promoted retroviral vector plasmid DNAs, the PGK- and RSV-LTR-promoted minigene constructs produced equal or greater amounts of clotting factor proteins. A factor IX minigene cassette was cloned into the retrovirus-based gene transfer vector LN (in both forward and reverse orientations) and the minigene vector was introduced into the Phoenix retroviral packaging cell line. Analysis of neo(r) cells demonstrated that insertion of a factor IX minigene into the retroviral vector LN resulted in rearrangement of the factor IX sequence and loss of factor IX expression in the Phoenix packaging cell line. The same factor IX minigene was then inserted into an alphavirus/retrovirus hybrid vector that facilitates the synthesis of retroviral vector RNA in the cytoplasm of cells. Alphavirus/retrovirus virions were produced and used to transduce the Phoenix retroviral vector packaging cell line. The cytoplasmically produced factor IX minigene-containing retroviral vectors were collected and used to transduce TE671 cells. Analysis of transduced cells demonstrated stable transfer of the minigene and expression of factor IX.     

Single-shot, multicycle suicide gene therapy by replication-competent retrovirus vectors achieves long-term survival benefit in experimental glioma.

Achieving therapeutically efficacious levels of gene transfer in tumors has been a major obstacle for cancer gene therapy using replication-defective virus vectors. Recently, replicating viruses have emerged as attractive tools for cancer therapy, but generally achieve only transitory tumor regression. In contrast to other replicating virus systems, transduction by replication-competent retrovirus (RCR) vectors is efficient, tumor-selective, and persistent. Correlating with its efficient replicative spread, RCR vector expressing the yeast cytosine deaminase suicide gene exhibited remarkably enhanced cytotoxicity in vitro after administration of the prodrug 5-fluorocytosine. In vivo, RCR vectors replicated throughout preestablished primary gliomas without spread to adjacent normal brain, resulting in profound tumor inhibition after a single injection of virus and single cycle of prodrug administration. Furthermore, stable integration of the replicating vector resulted in persistent infection that achieved complete transduction of ectopic glioma foci that had migrated away from the primary tumor site. Thus, efficient and stable integration of suicide genes represents a unique property of the RCR vector that achieved multiple cycles of synchronous cell killing upon repeated prodrug administration, resulting in chronic suppression of tumor growth and prolonged survival.     

A uniquely stable replication-competent retrovirus vector achieves efficient gene delivery in vitro and in solid tumors

A major obstacle in cancer gene therapy is the limited efficiency of in vivo gene transfer by replication-defective retrovirus vectors in current use. One strategy for circumventing this difficulty would be to use vectors capable of replication within tumor tissues. We have developed a replication-competent retrovirus (RCR) vector derived from murine leukemia virus (MuLV). This vector utilizes a unique design strategy in which an internal ribosome entry site-transgene cassette is positioned between the env gene and the 3' long terminal repeat (LTR). The ability of this vector to replicate and transmit a transgene was examined in culture and in a solid tumor model in vivo. The RCR vector exhibited replication kinetics similar to those of wildtype MuLV and mediated efficient delivery of the transgene throughout an entire population of cells in culture after an initial inoculation with 1 plaque-forming unit (PFU) of vector per 2000 cells. After injection of 6 x 10(3) PFU of vector into established subcutaneous tumors, highly efficient spread of the transgene was observed over a period of 7 weeks, in some cases resulting in spread of the transgene throughout the entire tumor. MuLV-based RCR vectors show significant advantages over standard replication-defective vectors in efficiency of gene delivery both in culture and in vivo. This represents the first example of the use of an RCR vector in an adult mammalian host, and their first application to transduction of solid tumors.     

Transduction of human embryonic stem cells by foamy virus vectors.

Human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) are important tools for the study of stem cell biology and may ultimately be used in cellular therapies and regenerative medicine. For hESCs to achieve their potential, stable genetic modification of the hESC genome will be required. Here we have studied the transduction of hESCs by vectors based on foamy virus (FV), an integrating retrovirus with no known pathogenicity. We find that hESCs and also ESCs derived from rhesus monkeys can be efficiently transduced by FV vectors at frequencies of 14-48%. Integration of FV vector DNA was demonstrated by Southern blot analysis, and stable expression was observed from a single integrated provirus in several clones. Transduced hESCs expressed markers characteristic of undifferentiated cells, differentiated and expressed markers from all three germ layers after serum exposure, and formed teratomas with persistent transgene expression in differentiated cells. Thus, FV vectors are promising tools for the genetic modification of hESCs.     

Complement and anti-alpha-galactosyl natural antibody-mediated inactivation of murine retrovirus occurs in adult serum but not in umbilical cord serum.

Many retroviral vectors for hematopoietic cell and other clinical gene therapy are derived from murine packaging cell lines. The exposure of these retroviruses and packaging cell lines to adult human serum (AS) inactivates them by complement and anti-alpha-galactosyl natural antibody-mediated mechanisms. We show that virus stability and infection efficiency of CRIP/BAG, a murine packaging cell line derived amphotropic retrovirus vector is reduced > 95% following a 30-min incubation in AS. This inactivation is prevented by replacing AS with umbilical cord serum (CS), wherein full retroviral transduction efficiency is maintained after 30 min of incubation. The loss of retrovirus transduction efficiency in AS was smaller upon blockage of anti-alpha-galactosyl antibodies with galactose alpha 1-3-galactose. Serum levels of CH 100, as well as C1q complement which inactivates retroviruses by an antibody-independent mechanism were similar in AS and CS. The high stability of CRIP/BAG retrovirus vector in CS is likely due to its lower levels of maternally derived anti-alpha-galactosyl antibodies. These results have implications for in vivo gene transfer in adults and also in newborns since neonates do not produce natural antibodies during the initial months of life.     

Insertion Sites in Engrafted Cells Cluster Within a Limited Repertoire of Genomic Areas After Gammaretroviral Vector Gene Therapy

Vector-associated side effects in clinical gene therapy have provided insights into the molecular mechanisms of hematopoietic regulation in vivo. Surprisingly, many retrovirus insertion sites (RIS) present in engrafted cells have been found to cluster nonrandomly in close association with specific genes. Our data demonstrate that these genes directly influence the in vivo fate of hematopoietic cell clones. Analysis of insertions thus far has been limited to individual clinical studies. Here, we studied >7,000 insertions retrieved from various studies. More than 40% of all insertions found in engrafted gene-modified cells were clustered in the same genomic areas covering only 0.36% of the genome. Gene classification analyses displayed significant overrepresentation of genes associated with hematopoietic functions and relevance for cell growth and survival in vivo. The similarity of insertion distributions indicates that vector insertions in repopulating cells cluster in predictable patterns. Thus, insertion analyses of preclinical in vitro and murine in vivo studies as well as vector insertion repertoires in clinical trials yielded concerted results and mark a small number of interesting genomic loci and genes that warrants further investigation of the biological consequences of vector insertions.