Monte Carlo study on a flattening filter-free 18-MV photon beam of a medical linear accelerator

PURPOSE: Several studies on the dosimetric properties of unflattened photon beams have shown some advantages for radiotherapy. In this study, the effect of removing the flattening filter from an 18-MV photon beam was investigated using the Monte Carlo method. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The 18-MV photon beam of an Elekta SL25 linear accelerator was simulated using the MCNP4C Monte Carlo (MC) code. Beam dosimetric features, including central axis absorbed doses, beam profiles, and photon energy spectra, were calculated for flattened and unflattened 18-MV photon beams. RESULTS: A 4.24-fold increase in the dose rate was seen for the unflattened beam with a field size of 10 x 10 cm(2). A decrease in the out-of-field dose up to 30% was seen for the unflattened beam. For the unflattened beam, photon energy spectra were softer, and the mean energies of the spectra were higher for a smaller field size. CONCLUSION: Our study showed that the increase in dose rate and lower out-of-field dose can be possible advantages for an unflattened 18-MV beam.     

A Monte Carlo study on neutron and electron contamination of an unflattened 18-MV photon beam

Recent studies on flattening filter (FF) free beams have shown increased dose rate and less out-of-field dose for unflattened photon beams. On the other hand, changes in contamination electrons and neutron spectra produced through photon (E>10 MV) interactions with linac components have not been completely studied for FF free beams. The objective of this study was to investigate the effect of removing FF on contamination electron and neutron spectra for an 18-MV photon beam using Monte Carlo (MC) method. The 18-MV photon beam of Elekta SL-25 linac was simulated using MCNPX MC code. The photon, electron and neutron spectra at a distance of 100 cm from target and on the central axis of beam were scored for 10×10 and 30×30 cm² fields. Our results showed increase in contamination electron fluence (normalized to photon fluence) up to 1.6 times for FF free beam, which causes more skin dose for patients. Neuron fluence reduction of 54% was observed for unflattened beams. Our study confirmed the previous measurement results, which showed neutron dose reduction for unflattened beams. This feature can lead to less neutron dose for patients treated with unflattened high-energy photon beams.     

Dosimetric properties of a flattening filter-free 6-MV photon beam: a Monte Carlo study

Purpose The dosimetric features of an unflattened 6-MV photon beam of an Elekta SL-25 linac was calculated by the Monte Carlo (MC) method. Material and methods The head of the Elekta SL-25 linac was simulated using the MCNP4C MC code. The accuracy of the model was evaluated using measured dosimetric features, including depth dose values and dose profiles in a water phantom. The flattening filter was then removed, and beam dosimetric properties were calculated by the MC method and compared with those of the flattened photon beam. Results Our results showed a significant (twofold) increase in the dose rate for all field sizes. Also, the photon beam spectra for an unflattened beam were softer, which led to a steeper reduction in depth doses. The decrease in the out-of-field dose and increase in the contamination electrons and a buildup region dose were the other consequences of removing the flattening filter. Conclusion Our study revealed that, for recent radiotherapy techniques, the use of multileaf collimators for beam shaping removing the flattening filter could offer some advantages, including an increased dose rate and decreased out-of-field dose.     

Effect of wedge filter and field size on photoneutron dose equivalent for an 18 MV photon beam of a medical linear accelerator

Photoneutrons produced during radiation therapy with high energy photons is the main source of unwanted out-of-field received doses of patients. To analyze the neutron dose equivalent (NDE) for wedged beams and its variation with field size, Monte Carlo (MC) modeling of an 18 MV photon beam was performed using MCNPX MC code. The results revealed that the NDE is on average 6.5 times higher for wedged beams. For open beams, the NDE decreased with increasing field size especially for field sizes >20×20 cm². While, for wedged beams, the NDE increased with field size. It was suggested that the increase of NDE for wedged beams should be taken into account in radiation-induced secondary cancer risk estimations and radiation protection calculations.     

Treatment planning and delivery of IMRT using 6 and 18 MV photon beams without flattening filter

In light of the increasing use of intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) in modern radiotherapy practice, the use of a flattening filter may no longer be necessary. Commissioning data have been measured for a Varian 23EX linear accelerator with 6 and 18 MV photon energies without a flattening filter. Measurements collected for the commissioning of the linac included percent depth dose curves and profiles for field sizes ranging from 2×2 to 40×40 cm² as defined by the jaws and multileaf collimator. Machine total scatter factors were measured and calculated. Measurements were used to model the unflattened beams with the Pinnacle³ treatment planning system. IMRT plans for prostate, lung, brain and head and neck cancer cases were generated using the flattening filter and flattening filter-free beams. From our results, no difference in the quality of the treatment plans between the flat and unflattened photon beams was noted. There was however a significant decrease in the number of monitor units required for unflattened beam treatment plans due to the increase in linac output—approximately two times and four times higher for the 6 and 18 MV, respectively.     

Thermoplastic wrapped lead sheet to reduce cardiac device cumulative dose

The objective of this project is to evaluate the percentage dose reduction in cardiac implantable electronic devices (CIEDs) using a thermoplastic wrapped lead sheet. The dose to CIED is evaluated in various situations with and without a lead shield. The efficiency of this type of shielding is supported by measurements made with a commercial plastic scintillation detector (PSD). Percentage depth dose (PDD) curve and lateral dose measurements (LDMs) were made with and without shielding for photon and electron beams. Photon LDMs were made at a depth of 0.5 cm. PSD measurements were compared with dose calculation from the treatment planning system (TPS). The benefit of shielding is greater at 23 MV than at 6 MV, with an average reduction of 71% and 59% of dose, respectively, for out-of-field distance range between 3 and 15 cm. Measurement of posterior beams shows there is no significant increase in skin dose due to backscatter from the lead sheet even when the field intercepts it. Large deviations between TPS calculation and measurements have been observed. The use of lead shielding with an anterior field is advised and provides an easy way to decrease the cumulative dose to CIEDs. Interception of shielding by an electron beam would increase significantly the cumulative dose to CIED for high energies or decrease the quality of the treatment. For a posterior out-of-field, shielding does not have a significant impact on CIED dose.     

Dosimetric considerations of water-based bolus for irradiation of extremities

The dosimetry of high-energy photon beams in the treatment of superficial lesions occurring in extremities was examined. Large parallel-opposed fields with different photon beam energies were used. The extremity was immersed in water contained in a commercially available plastic wastebasket. The water bolus serves to even out the surface irregularities of the extremities and to remove the skin sparing effect. A polystyrene block was placed at the floor of the wastebasket to ensure that the extremity was encompassed in the radiation fields. The photon beam energies considered were 4 MV, 6 MV, 10 MV, and 24 MV. The results show that the dose distributions are more homogeneous with higher photon beam energies. The isodose lines are more constricted at mid-plane for low energy photon beams. Higher energy photon beams, 10 MV and up would be preferable for the treatment of superficial lesions of the extremities immersed in water bolus contained in a typical wastebasket size.     

Dosimetric considerations of water-based bolus for irradiation of extremities

The dosimetry of high-energy photon beams in the treatment of superficial lesions occurring in extremities was examined. Large parallel-opposed fields with different photon beam energies were used. The extremity was immersed in water contained in a commercially available plastic wastebasket. The water bolus serves to even out the surface irregularities of the extremities and to remove the skin sparing effect. A polystyrene block was placed at the floor of the wastebasket to ensure that the extremity was encompassed in the radiation fields. The photon beam energies considered were 4 MV, 6 MV, 10 MV, and 24 MV. The results show that the dose distributions are more homogeneous with higher photon beam energies. The isodose lines are more constricted at mid-plane for low energy photon beams. Higher energy photon beams, 10 MV and up would be preferable for the treatment of superficial lesions of the extremities immersed in water bolus contained in a typical wastebasket size.     

Measurement of Backscattered Radiation from Secondary Collimator Jaws into the Beam Monitor Chamber from a Dual Energy Linear Accelerator

AIM: The photons and electrons backscattered from the upper and lower secondary collimator jaws give rise to a significant increase in the ion charge measured by the monitor chamber, and this increase varies between different accelerators. We have studied the effect of backscatter into the monitor chamber at 6 MV and 18 MV photon energies for the linear accelerator Clinac-1800. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The variation of the output factor was first studied for variable asymmetric fields of fixed field size defined by variable right upper collimator jaw together with a variable Cerrobend block low melting point alloy, with constant lower jaw position. Output measurements were carried out at Dmax in a polystyrene phantom at the geometric center of the asymmetric field. The backscatter radiation effect was also analyzed applying a pair of 20 x 20 x 7.5 cm Cerrobend alloy blocks with 6.0 mm diameter pin-holes in the center aligned telescopically with the field defining light beam. The ion chamber with build-up cap was placed at 25 cm behind the second pin-hole. The in air measurements were made varying upper and lower collimators individually and together. For comparison, a similar study was conducted in a Theratron-780C cobalt-60 beam. RESULTS: In the asymmetric field experiment it was noticed that till the collimator jaw crosses the midline, the output factor is almost constant for 6 and 18 MV photon beams. For extreme field asymmetry, the decreases in output factor were 3.2% and 4.3% for 6 and 18 MV, respectively. The telescopic experiment demonstrated 4.0% and 3.9% reduction in output factor for 6 and 18 MV beams when only the upper jaws were varied. Field definition by the lower jaws only reduced the output factor by 3.3% and 3% for 6 and 18 MV photon beams. For square fields achieved by both the jaws, the output factor variation was similar to that achieved with the upper collimator for both energies. Cobalt-60 measurements with the telescopic arrangement did not show significant dependency of output with field variation, provided that the field-dependent scatter from source capsule and collimator jaws is excluded. CONCLUSION: From this study a maximum reduction of 4% and 4.3% in dose delivery was observed for 6 MV and 18 MV photon beams due to backscattered radiation originating mainly from upper collimator reaching the beam monitor chamber. For asymmetric fields it is felt that direct output measurement is more reliable in order to avoid errors in output factor due to radiation backscattered from the collimator jaws into beam monitor chamber.     

Forward Scatter Dose Effect at Metallic Interfaces Irradiated by X and Gamma Ray Therapy Beams

AIM: In this study forward scattering effects near different metallic interfaces are measured for Co-60 gamma and 6 and 18 MV photon beams. The studied effects are the transport of secondary electrons across the metallic interface and the scattering of photons by the metallic inhomogeneity. MATERIALS AND METHODS: All measurements were carried out with a PTW thin-window, parallel plate ionisation chamber (B 23344-036) and an RDM-1F electrometer with digital readout. Thin sheets of aluminium, mild steel, copper, cadmium and lead were used as inhomogeneities. The inhomogeneities were placed between the polystyrene phantom and the front window of the chamber which was maintained at 100 cm SSD. RESULTS: It was noticed that for a high energy photon beam (18 MV) the forward scatter dose factor (FSDF) increases rapidly as the thickness of the metallic inhomogeneity increases. For low energy photons, there is a sharp initial decrease of the FSDF until a minimum value is reached followed by a slow increase with increasing thickness of the inhomogeneity. It was also noted that the FSDF variation at off-axis distances has slightly more slope compared with the ionization ratio (IR) curves for both 6 MV and 18 MV photons. However, the variation in slope is prominent for 18 MV compared with 6 MV photon beam. CONCLUSION: The sharp dose decrease observed downstream of a metallic inhomogeneity at relatively low photon energies (Co-60, 6 MV) is attributed to the internal scattering of secondary electrons within the metal. The dose enhancement observed for high energy photon beams is attributed to the domination of the pair production process, increasing with atomic number. Since FSDF is dependent on the photon beam spectra, it can be used as a measure of beam quality across the beam.     

Dependences of mucosal dose on photon beams in head-and-neck intensity-modulated radiation therapy: a Monte Carlo study

Dependences of mucosal dose in the oral or nasal cavity on the beam energy, beam angle, multibeam configuration, and mucosal thickness were studied for small photon fields using Monte Carlo simulations (EGSnrc-based code), which were validated by measurements. Cylindrical mucosa phantoms (mucosal thickness = 1, 2, and 3 mm) with and without the bone and air inhomogeneities were irradiated by the 6- and 18-MV photon beams (field size = 1 × 1 cm²) with gantry angles equal to 0°, 90°, and 180°, and multibeam configurations using 2, 4, and 8 photon beams in different orientations around the phantom. Doses along the central beam axis in the mucosal tissue were calculated. The mucosal surface doses were found to decrease slightly (1% for the 6-MV photon beam and 3% for the 18-MV beam) with an increase of mucosal thickness from 1–3 mm, when the beam angle is 0°. The variation of mucosal surface dose with its thickness became insignificant when the beam angle was changed to 180°, but the dose at the bone-mucosa interface was found to increase (28% for the 6-MV photon beam and 20% for the 18-MV beam) with the mucosal thickness. For different multibeam configurations, the dependence of mucosal dose on its thickness became insignificant when the number of photon beams around the mucosal tissue was increased. The mucosal dose with bone was varied with the beam energy, beam angle, multibeam configuration and mucosal thickness for a small segmental photon field. These dosimetric variations are important to consider improving the treatment strategy, so the mucosal complications in head-and-neck intensity-modulated radiation therapy can be minimized.     

Study on surface dose generated in prostate intensity-modulated radiation therapy treatment

The surface doses of 6- and 15-MV prostate intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) irradiations were measured and compared to those from a 15-MV prostate 4-beam box (FBB). IMRT plans (step-and-shoot technique) using 5, 7, and 9 beams with 6- and 15-MV photon beams were generated from a Pinnacle treatment planning system (version 6) using computed tomography (CT) scans from a Rando Phantom (ICRU Report 48). Metal oxide semiconductor field effect transistor detectors were used and placed on a transverse contour line along the Phantom surface at the central beam axis in the measurement. Our objectives were to investigate: (1) the contribution of the dynamic multileaf collimator (MLC) to the surface dose during the IMRT irradiation; (2) the effects of photon beam energy and number of beams used in the IMRT plan on the surface dose. The results showed that with the same number of beams used in the IMRT plan, the 6-MV irradiation gave more surface dose than that of 15 MV to the phantom. However, when the number of beams in the plan was increased, the surface dose difference between the above 2 photon energies became less. The average surface dose of the 15-MV IMRT irradiation increased with the number of beams in the plan, from 0.86% to 1.19%. Conversely, for 6 MV, the surface dose decreased from 1.33% to 1.24% as the beam number increased from 7 to 9. Comparing the 15-MV FBB and 6-MV IMRT plans with 2 Gy/fraction, the IMRT irradiations gave generally more surface dose, from 15% to 30%, depending on the number of beams in the plan. It was found that the increase in surface dose for the IMRT technique compared to the FBB plan was predominantly due to the number of beams and the calculated monitor units required to deliver the same dose at the isocenter in the plans. The head variation due to the dynamic MLC movement changing the surface dose distribution on the patient was reflected by the IMRT dose-intensity map. Although prostate IMRT in this study had an average higher surface dose than that of FBB, the more even distribution of relatively lower surface dose in IMRT field could avoid the big dose peaks at the surface positions directly under the FBB fields. Such an even and low surface dose distribution surrounding the patient in IMRT is believed to give less skin complication than that of FBB with the same prescribed dose.     

The Effect of a Carbon-Fiber Couch on the Depth-Dose Curves and Transmission Properties for Megavoltage Photon Beams

PURPOSE: To investigate the attenuation of a carbon-fiber tabletop and a combiboard, alongside with the depth-dose profile in a solid-water phantom. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Depth-dose measurements were performed with a Roos chamber for 6- and 10-MV beams for a typical field size (15 cm x 15 cm, SSD [source-surface distance] 100 cm). A rigid-stem ionization chamber was used to measure transmission factors. RESULTS: Transmission factors varied between 93.6% and 97.3% for the 6-MV beam, and 95.1% and 97.7% for the 10-MV photon beam. The lowest transmission factors were observed for the oblique gantry angle of 150 degrees with the table-combiboard combination. The surface dose normalized to a depth of 5 cm increased from 59.4% (without table, 0 degrees gantry), to 108.6% (tabletop present, 180 degrees gantry), and further to 120% (table-combiboard combination) for 6-MV photon beam. For 10 MV, the increase was from 39.6% (without table), to 88.9% (with table), and to 105.6% (table-combiboard combination). For the 150 degrees angle (tablecombiboard combination), the dose increased from 59.4% to 120% (6 MV) and from 39% to 108.1% (10 MV). CONCLUSION: Transmission factors for tabletops and accessories directly interfering with the treatment beam should be measured and implemented into the treatment-planning process. The increased surface dose to the skin should be considered.     

Evaluation of dose delivery based on a comparison of dosimetry calculations using open beam and wedged beam depth dose data

The purpose of this study is to evaluate the magnitude of the error in dose delivery caused by the use of open beam depth dose data in dosimetry calculations for wedged photon beams. Isodose pians were calculated for treatments given in a 3-field isocentric prostate or rectal setup using an open AP beam with two lateral wedged beams. The dose distributions were first calculated using open beam depth dose data for all three fields. Next, the open beam data was used only for the AP field and true wedged beam depth dose data was substituted for the two lateral wedged fields. The magnitude of the depth dose variations for wedged vs open beams depends on the nominal beam energy, the wedge angle, and the depth of measurement. Consequently, isodose distributions calculated for wedged fields were found to be different when true wedged beam depth dose data was used instead of open beam data as is commonly done. Monitor unit calculations using a field size specific wedge factor show that dose delivery errors up to 4% can result from the use of open beam depth dose data in wedged beam dose distribution calculations for a 6-MV photon beam. Accurate treatment planning for wedged fields requires the use of wedged beam depth dose data specific to each wedge. Simply using open beam depth dose data in dose calculations for wedged beams will result in dose delivery errors, the magnitude of which depends on the combination of wedge angle, field size, and nominal beam energy.     

Study on surface dose generated in prostate intensity-modulated radiation therapy treatment

The surface doses of 6- and 15-MV prostate intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) irradiations were measured and compared to those from a 15-MV prostate 4-beam box (FBB). IMRT plans (step-and-shoot technique) using 5, 7, and 9 beams with 6- and 15-MV photon beams were generated from a Pinnacle treatment planning system (version 6) using computed tomography (CT) scans from a Rando Phantom (ICRU Report 48). Metal oxide semiconductor field effect transistor detectors were used and placed on a transverse contour line along the Phantom surface at the central beam axis in the measurement. Our objectives were to investigate: (1) the contribution of the dynamic multileaf collimator (MLC) to the surface dose during the IMRT irradiation; (2) the effects of photon beam energy and number of beams used in the IMRT plan on the surface dose. The results showed that with the same number of beams used in the IMRT plan, the 6-MV irradiation gave more surface dose than that of 15 MV to the phantom. However, when the number of beams in the plan was increased, the surface dose difference between the above 2 photon energies became less. The average surface dose of the 15-MV IMRT irradiation increased with the number of beams in the plan, from 0.86% to 1.19%. Conversely, for 6 MV, the surface dose decreased from 1.33% to 1.24% as the beam number increased from 7 to 9. Comparing the 15-MV FBB and 6-MV IMRT plans with 2 Gy/fraction, the IMRT irradiations gave generally more surface dose, from 15% to 30%, depending on the number of beams in the plan. It was found that the increase in surface dose for the IMRT technique compared to the FBB plan was predominantly due to the number of beams and the calculated monitor units required to deliver the same dose at the isocenter in the plans. The head variation due to the dynamic MLC movement changing the surface dose distribution on the patient was reflected by the IMRT dose-intensity map. Although prostate IMRT in this study had an average higher surface dose than that of FBB, the more even distribution of relatively lower surface dose in IMRT field could avoid the big dose peaks at the surface positions directly under the FBB fields. Such an even and low surface dose distribution surrounding the patient in IMRT is believed to give less skin complication than that of FBB with the same prescribed dose.     

辽宁省核查放射治疗参考与非参考条件下剂量学参数方法验证

目的 研究用热释光剂量计（TLD）方法核查放射治疗参考条件和非参考条件下剂量学参数的可靠性验证。方法 在参考条件和非参考条件下,用建立的TLD方法,核查5家医院10条6 MV光子线束剂量随深度、源皮距、照射野大小和45°楔形板等变化,5条9 MeV电子线束轴向最大剂量点处等剂量学参数,TLD测量结果与剂量仪测量结果进行对比。结果 6 MV 光子线束TLD测量结果与指形电离室测量结果的平均相对偏差为4.45%,低于IAEA要求的≤±7%;9 MeV电子线束TLD测量结果与平行板电离室测量结果平均相对偏差为2.45%,低于IAEA要求的≤±5%。结论 用TLD核查参考条件和非参考条件下放射治疗剂量学参数方法可靠,简单易行。     

Choice of beam energy and dosimetric implications for radiation treatment in a subpopulation of women with large breasts in the United States and Japan.

Radiation complications are often related to the dose inhomogeneity (hot spot) in breast tissue treated with conservative therapy, especially for large patients. The effect of photon energy on radiation dose distribution is analyzed to provide guidelines for the selection of beam energy when tangential fields and limited slices are used to treat women with large breasts. Forty-eight patients with chest wall separation > 22 cm were selected for dosimetric analysis. We compared the maximum dose in the central axis (CAX) plane (2D) using 6-, 10-, and 18-MV photon beams in all patients and 3D data set for 16 patients. Correlation between hot spot dose (HSD), separation, breast cup size, breast volume, and body weight was derived with beam energy. Among the 48 patients in this study, HSD > 10% in the CAX plane was noted in 98%, 46%, and 4% of the population when 2D dosimetry was performed; however, with 3D study, it was in 50%, 19%, and 6% of the patients with 6-MV, 10-MV and 18-MV beams, respectively. The chest wall separation, body weight, and breast volume were correlated with the HSD in both the 2D and 3D plans. Patient's bra size was not correlated with the hot spot. The chest wall separation was found to be the most important parameter to correlate with hot spot in tangential breast treatment. Simple guidelines are provided for dose uniformity in breast with respect to chest wall separation, body weight, bra size, and breast volume with tangential field irradiations.     

Effect of a carbon fiber tabletop on the surface dose and attenuation for high-energy photon beams

Purpose  The dose changes in the buildup region and beam attenuation by a carbon fiber tabletop were investigated for 6-and 18-MV photon beams. Materials and methods  Measurements were performed for 2 × 2 cm to 40 × 40 cm field sizes. The surface dose and percentage depth doses (PDD) were measured by a Markus parallel plate chamber. Attenuation measurements were made at the cylindrical phantom for 180° rotation of the beam. Results  A carbon fiber tabletop increases the surface dose from 7.5% to 63.0% and from 4% to 43% for small fields at 6 and 18 MV, respectively. The increase was nearly fivefold for the 10 × 10 cm field and nearly twofold for the 40 × 40 cm field. Beam attenuation of the tabletop varies from 3.0% to 5.6% for 180° and 120° gantry angles for 6 MV. Conclusion  The carbon fiber tabletop significantly decreases the skin-sparing effect. The dosimetric effect of the tabletop may be higher, especially for the intensity-modulated radiation therapy depending on the beam orientation. Attenuation should be considered and corrected such as any material under the patient at the treatment planning stage.     

Verification of a simple point dose calculation method for a dual energy linear accelerator with asymmetric jaws

Certain fundamental dosimetrical parameters involving the applications of asymmetric jaws were investigated. The nominal accelerating potentials (NAPs) were found to decrease from 5.1 to 4.2 and from 18.0 to 13.4 for the 6 and 18 MV beams, respectively, as the off-axis distance (OAD) increases from 0.0 to 15.0 cm. The relative beam intensity increases from 1.00 to 1.07 at OAD of 15.0 cm for the 6 MV beam, and to 1.02 at OAD of 7.0 cm for the 18 MV beam. The percentage depth doses (PDDs) for half-blocked fields of 4 × 4 cm, 10 × 10 cm and 20 × 20 cm were found to deviate from those of corresponding symmetric fields by less than 2% down to the depth of 35.0 cm. The field size factor (FSF) for the asymmetric field from 4 × 4 cm to 20 × 20 cm deviates less than 1.0% from those of the corresponding symmetric fields. The equivalent square concept was found to be applicable to asymmetric fields within 1% error if the jaw exchange effect is taken into consideration. The measured point doses for half-blocked fields of 4 × 4 cm, 10 × 10 cm and 20 × 20 cm for both 6 and 18 MV were within 3% of the calculated dose based on a published dose calculation method which employs symmetric field beam parameters, such as field size factor (FSF), percentage depth dose (PDD), and off-axis correction factors (OAFs). The efficacy of this point dose calculation method is discussed.     

Dosimetric considerations in the choice of photon energy for external beam radiation therapy: clinical examples.

Laughlin, Mohan, and Kutcher have evaluated photon beams for Co-60 through 24 MV for eight clinical disease sites plus pediatrics and concluded that two energy ranges are required for the best patient care: a 4 to 6 MV beam and a 10 to 18 MV beam. The present study investigates the question which two energies in a dual energy machine are optimum for the average patient mix. The method used is to calculate two dimensional sample cases including breast, head and neck, and pelvic tumors on the same treatment planning system using machine data including Co-60, 4 MV, 6 MV, 10 MV, and 18 MV x-ray beams. The resulting plans were evaluated considering tumor doses, spinal cord doses, doses to subcutaneous tissues and doses to other radiosensitive structures. The conclusion is that the optimum two beams are 6 and 10 MV.