ECFS standards of care on CFTR-related disorders: Updated diagnostic criteria

This paper is the first in a series providing updated guidance on the definition, evaluation and management of people with a Cystic Fibrosis Transmembrane conductance Regulator (CFTR)-Related Disorder (CFTR-RD). The need for this update relates to more precise characterisation of CFTR gene variants and improved assessment of CFTR protein dysfunction. The exercise is co-ordinated by the European CF Society Standards of Care Committee and Diagnostic Network Working Group and involves stakeholder engagement. This first paper was produced by a core group using an extensive literature review and papers graded for their quality. Subsequent wider stakeholder agreement was achieved.The definition of a CFTR-RD remains “a clinical condition with evidence of CFTR protein dysfunction that does not fulfil the diagnostic criteria for CF”. Clearer guidance on CFTR dysfunction and relevant CFTR variants will be provided. Thresholds for clinical presentations are presented and the paradigm that pathobiological processes may be evident in more than one organ is agreed. In this paper we reflect on the early patient journey, highlighting that CF specialists as well as other relevant specialists should be involved in the care of people with a CFTR-RD.     

Genetics of CFTR and male infertility

Cystic fibrosis (CF) is a rare autosomal-recessive disorder manifested as multisystem organ dysfunction. The cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) protein functions as an ion transporter on the epithelium of exocrine glands, regulating secretion viscosity. The CFTR gene, encoded on chromosome 7, is required for the production and trafficking of the intact and functional CFTR protein. Literally thousands of human CFTR allelic mutations have been identified, each with varying impact on protein quality and quantity. As a result, individuals harboring CFTR mutations present with a spectrum of symptoms ranging from CF to normal phenotypes. Those with loss of function but without full CF may present with CFTR-related disorders (CFTR-RDs) including male infertility, sinusitis, pancreatitis, atypical asthma and bronchitis. Studies have demonstrated associations between higher rates of CFTR mutations and oligospermia, epididymal obstruction, congenital bilateral absence of the vas deferens (CBAVD), and idiopathic ejaculatory duct obstruction (EDO). Genetic variants are detected in over three-quarters of men with CBAVD, the reproductive abnormality most classically associated with CFTR aberrations. Likewise, nearly all men with clinical CF will have CBAVD. Current guidelines from multiple groups recommend CFTR screening in all men with clinical CF or CBAVD though a consensus on the minimum number of variants for which to test is lacking. CFTR testing is not recommended as routine screening for men with other categories of infertility. While available CFTR panels include 30 to 96 of the most common variants, complete gene sequencing should be considered if there is a high index of suspicion in a high-risk couple (e.g., partner is CFTR mutation carrier). CF treatments to date have largely targeted end-organ complications. Novel CFTR-modulator treatments aim to directly target CFTR protein dysfunction, effectively circumventing downstream complications, and possibly preventing symptoms like vasal atresia at a young age. Future gene therapies may also hold promise in preventing or reversing genetic changes that lead to CF and CFTR-RD.     

Reclassifying inconclusive diagnosis after newborn screening for cystic fibrosis. Moving forward

BackgroundNewborn screening for Cystic Fibrosis (CF) is associated with situations where the diagnosis of CF or CFTR related disorders (CFTR-RD) cannot be clearly ruled out.Materials/patients and methodsWe report a case series of 23 children with unconclusive diagnosis after newborn screening for CF and a mean follow-up of 7.7 years (4–13). Comprehensive investigations including whole CFTR gene sequencing, in vivo intestinal current measurement (ICM), nasal potential difference (NPD), and in vitro functional studies of variants of unknown significance, helped to reclassify the patients.ResultsExtensive genetic testing identified, in trans with a CF causing mutation, variants with varying clinical consequences and 3 variants of unknown significance (VUS). Eighteen deep intronic variants were identified by deep resequencing of the whole CFTR gene in 13 patients and were finally considered as non-pathogenic. All patients had normal CFTR dependent chloride transport in ICM. NPD differentiated 3 different profiles: CF-like tracings qualifying the patients as CF, such as F508del/D1152H patients; normal responses, suggesting an extremely low likelihood of developing a CFTR-RD such as F508del/TG11T5 patients; partial CFTR dysfunction above 20% of the normal, highlighting a remaining risk of developing CFTR-RD such as F508del/F1052V patients. The 3 VUS were reclassified as variant with defective maturation (D537N), defective expression (T582I) or with no clinical consequence (M952T).ConclusionThis study demonstrates the usefulness of combining genetic and functional investigations to assess the possibility of evolving to CF or CFTR-RD in babies with inconclusive diagnosis at neonatal screening.     

Penetrance is a critical parameter for assessing the disease liability of CFTR variants

BackgroundMajor issues of newborn screening (NBS) for CF are the assessment of disease liability of variants and of the penetrance of clinical CF, notably in inconclusive diagnosis. The penetrance of CF is defined as the risk of a particular genotype to lead to a CF phenotype.MethodsWe aimed to get insight into the penetrance of CF for fifteen CFTR variants: 5 frequent CF-causing and 10 classified as of varying clinical consequence (VCC) or associated with a CFTR-related disorder (CFTR-RD) in CFTR2 or CFTR-France databases. The penetrance was approached by: (1) comparison of variant allelic frequencies in CF patients (CFTR2) and in the general population; (2) estimation of the likelihood of a positive NBS test for the 14 compound heterozygous with F508del and the F508del homozygous genotypes, defined as the ratio of detected/expected number of neonates with a given genotype in the 2002–2017 period.ResultsA full penetrance was observed for severe CF-causing variants. Five variants were more frequently found in the general population than in CF patients: TG11T5, TG12T5, TG13T5, L997F and R117H;T7. The likelihood of a positive NBS test was 0.03% for TG11T5, 0.3% for TG12T5, 1.9% for TG13T5, 0.6% for L997F, 11.7% for D1152H, and 17.8% for R117H;T7. Penetrance varied greatly for variants with discrepant classification between CFTR2 and CFTR-France: 5.1% for R117C, 12.3% for T338I, 43.5% for D110H and 52.6% for L206W.ConclusionThese results illustrate the contribution of genetics population data to assess the disease liability of variants for diagnosis and genetic counselling purposes.     

Cardiovascular complications in cystic fibrosis: A review of the literature

Cystic fibrosis is a genetic disease caused by mutations in the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene, leading to dysfunction of the CFTR protein. CFTR dysfunction leads to disease in the respiratory and gastrointestinal systems. Disorders of the cardiovascular system in individuals with CF are usually attributed to secondary effects from progressive lung disease. However, CFTR has been localized to vascular endothelium and smooth muscle, suggesting that CFTR dysfunction may directly impact cardiovascular function. As treatments for CF improve and life-expectancy increases, the risk of vascular disease may increase in prevalence related to primary and secondary CFTR dysfunction, chronic systemic inflammation, nutritional health and hyperglycemia in individuals with CF related diabetes. Here we review the available literature on CF and the cardiovascular system, examining the secondary effects and evidence for direct CFTR dysfunction in the heart, aorta, pulmonary vessels, and vasculature, as well as future directions and treatment options.     

Severity of the S1251N allele in cystic fibrosis is affected by the presence of the F508C variant in cis

BackgroundIn cystic fibrosis (CF), genotype-phenotype correlation is complicated by the large number of CFTR variants, the influence of modifier genes, environmental effects, and the existence of complex alleles. We document the importance of complex alleles, in particular the F508C variant present in cis with the S1251N disease-causing variant, by detailed analysis of a patient with CF, with the [S1251N;F508]/G542X genotype and a very mild phenotype, contrasting it to that of four subjects with the [S1251N;F508C]/F508del genotype and classical CF presentation.MethodsGenetic differences were identified by Sanger sequencing and CFTR function was quantified using rectal organoids in rectal organoid morphology analysis (ROMA) and forskolin-induced swelling (FIS) assays. CFTR variants were further characterised in CF bronchial epithelial (CFBE) cell lines. The impact of involved amino acid changes in the CFTR 3D protein structure was evaluated.ResultsOrganoids of the patient [S1251N;F508] with mild CF phenotype confirmed the CF diagnosis but showed higher residual CFTR function compared to the four others [S1251N;F508C]. CFBE cell lines showed a decrease in [S1251N;F508C]-CFTR function but not in processing when compared to [S1251N;F508]-CFTR. Analysis of the 3D CFTR structure suggested an additive deleterious effect of the combined presence of S1251N and F508C with respect to NBD1-2 dimerisation.ConclusionsIn vitro and in silico data show that the presence of F508C in cis with S1251N decreases CFTR function without affecting processing. Complex CFTR alleles play a role in clinical phenotype and their identification is relevant in the context of personalised medicine for each patient with CF.     

Clinical outcomes of a large cohort of individuals with the F508del/5T;TG12 CFTR genotype

BackgroundIn recent years, patients with cystic fibrosis (CF) conductance regulator (CFTR) variant poly(T) sequences have been increasingly reported with a wide spectrum of clinical severity. We describe the long-term clinical outcomes and progression to a CF diagnosis over time in a large Italian cohort of patients carrying the CFTR F508del/5T;TG12 genotype.MethodsA retrospective analysis of subjects from 10 CF centres in Italy with the F508del/5T;TG12 genotype was performed. Demographic, clinical, microbiological, and biochemical data, as well as information about the follow-ups and complications of the enroled patients, were collected.ResultsA total of 129 subjects (54 females; median age: 15.0 years, range: 0–58 years; 59 older than 18 years) were included. In terms of initial diagnoses, 30 were CF (23.3%), 41 were CFTR-related disorder (CFTR-RD) (31.7%), and 58 were CF transmembrane conductance regulator-related metabolic syndrome/cystic fibrosis screen positive, inconclusive diagnosis (CRMS/CFSPID) (45.0%). After a median follow-up of 6.7 years (range 0.2–25 years), 15 patients progressed to CF, bringing the total number of CF diagnoses to 45/129 (34.9%). Most of these patients had mild lung diseases with pancreatic sufficiency and a low prevalence of CF-related complications.ConclusionsAt the end of the study, 34.9% of subjects with the CFTR F508del/5T;TG12 genotype were diagnosed with CF. We suggest including patients with the F508del/5T;TG12 genotype in long-term follow-ups.     

SLC26A9 SNP rs7512462 is not associated with lung disease severity or lung function response to ivacaftor in cystic fibrosis patients with G551D-CFTR

BackgroundThe CFTR modulator ivacaftor has been variably effective in treating individuals with cystic fibrosis (CF) who harbor CFTR gating variants such as G551D, as well as other classes of CFTR variants when used with other modulators. Because CFTR genotype does not fully explain this variability, defining genetic modifiers of response to modulator therapy is of particular interest to the field of individualized CF drug therapy. Previous studies have proposed that a variant in SLC26A9 (rs7512462) is associated with lung disease severity and with response to treatment with ivacaftor in individuals with CF who carry G551D or gating variants.MethodsGiven the implications for CF treatment, we re-examined the reported associations in three cohorts; patients enrolled in the Twin and Siblings study at Johns Hopkins University, the CF modifier study at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, and the prospective G551D Observational (GOAL) study. The GOAL study was specifically designed to measure lung function response to ivacaftor.ResultsWe find no association between SLC26A9 (rs7512462) genotype and lung disease severity (n = 272) or change in lung function at one-, three-, and six-month intervals following ivacaftor treatment(n = 141) in individuals with CF who carry at least one G551D variant.ConclusionsOur inability to replicate this association indicates that rs7512462 genotype should not be used in treatment decisions.     

Cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene mutations in pancreatitis

BackgroundThe pancreas is one of the primary organs affected by dysfunction of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) protein. While exocrine pancreatic insufficiency is a well-recognized complication of cystic fibrosis (CF), symptomatic pancreatitis is often under-recognized.ResultsThe aim of this review is to provide a general overview of CFTR mutation-associated pancreatitis, which affects patients with pancreatic sufficient CF, CFTR-related pancreatitis, and idiopathic pancreatitis. The current hypothesis regarding the role of CFTR dysfunction in the pathogenesis of pancreatitis, and concepts on genotype–phenotype correlations between CFTR and symptomatic pancreatitis will be reviewed.Symptomatic pancreatitis occurs in 20% of pancreatic sufficient CF patients. In order to evaluate genotype–phenotype correlations, the Pancreatic Insufficiency Prevalence (PIP) score was developed and validated to determine severity in a large number of CFTR mutations. Specific CFTR genotypes are significantly associated with pancreatitis. Patients who carry genotypes with mild phenotypic effects have a greater risk of developing pancreatitis than patients carrying genotypes with moderate–severe phenotypic consequences at any given time.ConclusionsThe genotype–phenotype correlation in pancreatitis is unique compared to other organ manifestations but still consistent with the complex monogenic nature of CF. Paradoxically, genotypes associated with otherwise mild phenotypic effects have a greater risk for causing pancreatitis; compared with genotypes associated with moderate to severe disease phenotypes. Greater understanding into the underlying mechanisms of disease is much needed. The emergence of CFTR-assist therapies may potentially play a future role in the treatment of CFTR-mutation associated pancreatitis.     

CFTR modulator theratyping: Current status,gaps and future directions

Background

New drugs that improve the function of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) protein with discreet disease-causing variants have been successfully developed for cystic fibrosis (CF) patients. Preclinical model systems have played a critical role in this process, and have the potential to inform researchers and CF healthcare providers regarding the nature of defects in rare CFTR variants, and to potentially support use of modulator therapies in new populations.

Complete CFTR gene sequencing in 5,058 individuals with cystic fibrosis informs variant-specific treatment

BackgroundCystic fibrosis (CF) is a recessive condition caused by variants in each CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) allele. Clinically affected individuals without two identified causal variants typically have no further interrogation of CFTR beyond examination of coding regions, but the development of variant-specific CFTR-targeted treatments necessitates complete understanding of CFTR genotype.MethodsWhole genome sequences were analyzed on 5,058 individuals with CF. We focused on the full CFTR gene sequence and identified disease-causing variants in three phases: screening for known and structural variants; discovery of novel loss-of-function variants; and investigation of remaining variants.ResultsAll variants identified in the first two phases and coding region variants found in the third phase were interpreted according to CFTR2 or ACMG criteria (n = 371; 16 [4.3%] previously unreported). Full gene sequencing enabled delineation of 18 structural variants (large insertions or deletions), of which two were novel. Additional CFTR variants of uncertain effect were found in 76 F508del homozygotes and in 21 individuals with other combinations of CF-causing variants. Both causative variants were identified in 98.1% (n = 4,960) of subjects, an increase of 2.3 percentage points from the 95.8% (n = 4,847) who had a registry- or chart-reported disease-causing CFTR genotype. Of the remaining 98 individuals, 78 carried one variant that has been associated with CF (CF-causing [n = 70] or resulting in varying clinical consequences n = 8]).ConclusionsComplete CFTR gene sequencing in 5,058 individuals with CF identified at least one DNA variant in 99.6% of the cohort that is targetable by current molecular or emerging gene-based therapeutic technologies.     

Macrophages from gut-corrected CF mice express human CFTR and lack a pro-inflammatory phenotype

Macrophages represent prominent immune orchestrators of cystic fibrosis (CF) inflammation and, as such, are an ever-increasing focus of CF research with several reports of intrinsic immune dysfunction related to loss of CFTR activity in macrophages themselves. Animal models of CF have contributed, in no small part, to a deepening of our understanding of the pathophysiology of the disease and towards therapeutic development. A commonly-used animal model in CF research is the Cftr^tm1Unc Tg(FABP-hCFTR) mouse, which displays gut-specific expression of a human CFTR transgene in order to rescue the high rate of early mortality in Cftr-null mice associated with severe intestinal obstruction. We find significant variation in the response to inflammatory challenge of patient macrophages and cells derived from the Cftr^tm1Unc Tg(FABP-hCFTR) mouse and show that macrophages derived from this mouse exhibit aberrant expression of human CFTR. This may contribute to the absence of inflammatory changes in this model.     

Ivacaftor in cystic fibrosis with residual function: Lung function results from an N-of-1 study

BackgroundIvacaftor shows benefit in patients with cystic fibrosis (CF) and CFTR mutations associated with residual CF transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) function. Here we further assess the effect of ivacaftor in such patients using an N-of-1 study design.MethodsPatients aged ≥12 years with CF with clinical or molecular evidence of residual CFTR function were randomized to 1 of 4 treatment sequences for two 4-week, double-blind crossover cycles (each divided into 2 weeks of ivacaftor treatment and placebo) followed by 8 weeks of open-label ivacaftor treatment. The primary endpoint was absolute change from cycle baseline of percent predicted forced expiratory volume in 1 s (ppFEV₁) after 2 weeks of treatment with ivacaftor relative to placebo.ResultsAbsolute change (SD) from study baseline in ppFEV₁ favored ivacaftor by 2.3 (1.0) percentage points (95% credible interval, 0.4–4.1) after 2 weeks of treatment. Absolute mean change (SD) from open-label baseline (defined as day 1 of the open-label ivacaftor treatment period) in ppFEV₁ after 8 weeks of treatment was 4.7 (4.2) percentage points (P<.0001). Safety of ivacaftor was consistent with that observed in prior studies.ConclusionsIvacaftor improved lung function during the double-blind and open-label treatment periods in patients with CF and CFTR mutations associated with residual CFTR function (ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT01685801).     

Frequency of the hyperactive W493R ENaC variant in carriers of a CFTR mutation

BackgroundThe basic defect of the autosomal recessive disorder cystic fibrosis (CF) manifests in chloride hyposecretion and sodium hyperabsorption. CF-like disease has been reported in a heterozygous carrier of F508del CFTR and the hyperactive variant p.W493R-SCNN1A of the epithelial sodium channel (ENaC).MethodsThe hypothesis that heterozygosity for p.W493R-SCNN1A and one loss-of-function CFTR mutation causes or predisposes to CF or CF-like disease was tested in 441 parents of a child with CF.Resultsp.W493R-SCNN1A was detected in three female carriers of F508del CFTR who did not show any symptoms of respiratory or intestinal disease that could be interpreted as the manifestation of CF or CFTR-related disorder. Frequency of p.W493R was lower in CF parents than in Caucasian control subjects.ConclusionsA hyperactive ENaC does not necessarily cause CF-like disease in a CF gene carrier, but its low frequency in CF parents suggests that it is a risk factor.     

Comparison of Cas9 and Cas12a CRISPR editing methods to correct the W1282X-CFTR mutation

BackgroundW1282X-CFTR variant (c.3846G>A) is the second most common nonsense cystic fibrosis (CF)-causing mutation in the Cystic Fibrosis Transmembrane Conductance Regulator (CFTR) gene. Even though remarkable breakthroughs have been done towards CF treatment with the approval of four CFTR protein modulators, none of these are approved for patients with nonsense mutations. CRISPR gene editing tools can be of great value to permanently correct the genetic defects caused by these mutations.MethodsWe compared the capacity of homology-directed repair (HDR) mediated by Cas9 or Cas12a to correct W1282X CFTR mutation in the CFF-16HBEge W1282X CFTR cell line (obtained from CFF), using Cas9/gRNA and Cas12a/gRNA ribonucleoproteins (RNPs) and single strand DNA (ssODN) oligonucleotide donors.ResultsCas9 shows higher levels of correction than Cas12a as, by electroporating cells with Cas9 RNPs and ssODN donor, nearly 18% of precise editing was achieved compared to just 8% for Cas12a. Such levels of correction increase the abundance of CFTR mRNA and protein, and partially restore CFTR function in the pool of edited cells to 18% of WT CFTR function. Moreover, homozygous corrected clones produced levels of mRNA, protein, and function comparable to those of cells expressing WT CFTR.ConclusionAltogether, this work demonstrates the potential of gene editing as a therapeutic strategy for CF directly correcting the root cause of the disease.     

Laboratory reporting on the clinical spectrum of CFTR p.Arg117His: Still room for improvement

BackgroundThe clinical spectrum associated with cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) variant p.Arg117His is highly variable, ranging from full-blown cystic fibrosis (CF) in a small number of cases to CFTR-related disorders (CFTR-RDs) or no symptoms at all. Therefore, taking into account phenotype variability is essential for interpretation. External quality assessment (EQA) schemes can help laboratories to objectively assess the quality of genotyping and reporting by the laboratory.MethodsWe performed a retrospective longitudinal data analysis on laboratory performance regarding the interpretation of p.Arg117His during CF EQA scheme participation. Completeness and accuracy of reporting on two mock clinical cases were each compared over time (case 1: 2005, 2007 and 2012; case 2: 2015 and 2018). These cases concerned subjects compound heterozygous for p.Phe508del and p.Arg117His in cis with 7T, but with different clinical backgrounds (family planning (case 1) versus diagnostic testing for a child (case 2)). Furthermore, we analyzed the influence of previous participations, annual test volume, accreditation status and laboratory setting on overall performance.ResultsOverall performance improved over time, except during the 2007 CF EQA scheme. In addition, previous participations had a beneficial effect on laboratory performance. Accreditation status, annual test volume and laboratory setting did not significantly influence total interpretation scores.ConclusionsIn general, laboratories performed well on both cases, although reporting on the variable clinical spectrum of p.Arg117His in cis with 7T and on the disease liability of individual CFTR variants can still improve. Moreover, this study underlined the educational role of CF EQA schemes.