Detection of simulated pulmonary nodules by single-exposure dual-energy computed radiography of the chest: effect of a computer-aided diagnosis system (Part 2)

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the performance of the computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) scheme on the detection of pulmonary nodules (PNs) in single-exposure dual-energy subtraction computed radiography (CR) images of the chest, and to evaluate the effect of this CAD scheme on radiologists' detectibilaties. METHODS AND MATERIAL: We compared the detectability by the CAD scheme with the detectability by 12 observers by using conventional CR (C-CR) and bone-subtracted CR (BS-CR) images of 25 chest phantoms with a low-contrast nylon nodule. RESULTS: Both in the CAD scheme and for the observers, the detectability of BS-CR images was superior to that of C-CR images (P<0.005). The detection performance of the CAD scheme was equal to that of the observers. The nodules detected by the CAD did not necessarily coincide with those by the observers. Thus, if observers can use the results of the CAD system as a 'second opinion', their detectabilities increase. CONCLUSION: The CAD system for detection of PNs in the single-exposure dual-energy subtraction method is promising for improving radiologists' detectabilities of PNs.     

Detection of lung cancer using single-exposure dual-energy subtraction chest radiography

PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to evaluate the detectability of lung cancer by chest radiography with a single-exposure dual-energy subtraction (ES) method. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Five radiologists read two sets of chest radiographs from 77 patients (66.5 +/- 9.6 years old) with histologically proven lung cancer measuring or=50 but <100%; (3) solid: TDR was <50%. RESULTS: Overall, detectability with the ES method was significantly better than that without ES (mean Az value increased from 0.7673 to 0.8265, P < 0.05). In the subgroup analysis of the nonsolid group and the solid group detectability did not change using the ES method, whereas in the partly solid group detectability with the ES method was significantly better than that without ES (mean Az value increased from 0.7162 to 0.8209, P < 0.005). CONCLUSION: The ES method improves the detectability of lung cancer by chest radiography, especially of the partly solid group.     

Clinical evaluation of pulmonary nodules with dual-exposure dual-energy subtraction chest radiography

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to assess the effect of dual-exposure dual-energy (DE) subtraction chest radiography with flat-panel detector. MATERIALS AND METHODS: One hundred patients underwent dual-exposure DE subtraction chest radiography and chest CT for evaluation of pulmonary nodules. Fifty-two patients with pulmonary nodules and 48 patients with normal lungs were selected for receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis. Ten radiologists who were unaware of the CT results evaluated chest radiography alone and chest radiography with DE subtraction images in the detection of pulmonary nodules. For each radiologist, we calculated the areas under the ROC curve (Az) for chest radiography alone and chest radiography with DE subtraction images. RESULTS: The average detectability of dual-exposure DE subtraction chest radiography was statistically significantly higher than that of chest radiography without subtraction images (mean Az value increased from 0.784 to 0.815, p<0.001). CONCLUSION: Dual-exposure DE subtraction chest radiography improves diagnostic accuracy of pulmonary nodules.     

Calcification in pulmonary nodules: detection with dual-energy digital radiography

The authors undertook a clinical study to determine the accuracy of dual-energy digital radiography in revealing nodule calcification because calcification in a pulmonary nodule almost excludes the possibility of malignancy. Over a 6-month period, 61 patients with pulmonary nodules (less than or equal to 3 cm) or masses (greater than 3 cm) were examined on a prototype scanned projection unit using a dual-energy detector. In 49 of 61 patients, nodules were noncalcified, and in 12, they were calcified. In 57 patients, the benignancy or malignancy of nodules was established beyond reasonable doubt by pathologic confirmation in 38 and by strong inference in 19 (four patients with noncalcified solitary pulmonary nodules either refused further investigation or surgery or their follow-up was too short to permit exclusion of malignancy). Dual-energy radiography was found to be highly accurate in assessing the presence or absence of calcification in pulmonary nodules and thus in determining their benignancy or possible malignancy.     

Usefulness of temporal subtraction images of chest computed radiography for detection of metastatic pulmonary nodules

Temporal subtraction is a technique by which a previous chest radiograph is subtracted from a current radiograph in order to enhance interval changes. Our purpose in this study was to evaluate the usefulness of temporal subtraction for the detection of metastatic pulmonary nodules. We examined 19 cases of metastatic nodules less than 15 mm in diameter (8.4 mm on average). Temporal subtraction images were created based on the matching of local lung areas in pairs of chest radiographs. By using the subtraction images, the detectability of nodules was clearly improved in 5 cases and moderately improved in 8 cases; there was no improvement in 6 cases. The subtraction images were especially useful for nodules superimposed over normal structures, such as rib, mediastinum, and diaphragm, as well as for small nodules. In 6 of the 19 cases, the nodules had been missed clinically; however, the temporal subtraction images clearly demonstrated half of missed small nodules. Temporal subtraction made it possible to enhance subtle interval changes and helped in detecting small pulmonary metastases. This technique seems promising for augmenting the capabilities of computed radiography of the chest.     

Simulated pulmonary nodules: detection with dual-energy digital versus conventional radiography

Performance of a prototype dual-energy digital chest radiography unit in detecting calcified and noncalcified simulated pulmonary nodules was compared with that of a highly optimized, conventional system. Nodules ranging in size (0.5, 1.0, and 1.6 cm), in number (five to 11), and in calcium content (0-25 mg) were superimposed over the lungs of a frozen, unembalmed, human chest phantom. For each technique, six observers examined 50 posteroanterior projections with different randomized nodule locations. Detection consisted of locating and assigning a level of confidence to each perceived nodular opacity. The resulting plots of the true-positive fraction versus the mean number of false-positive calls per projection indicate that for both calcified and noncalcified nodules, the digital unit performed significantly better (P less than .01).     

Single-exposure dual-energy subtraction chest radiography: Detection of pulmonary nodules and masses in clinical practice

The purpose of this retrospective study was to evaluate the impact of energy subtraction (ES) chest radiography on the detection of pulmonary nodules and masses in daily routine. Seventy-seven patients and 25 healthy subjects were examined with a single exposure digital radiography system. Five blinded readers evaluated first the non-subtracted PA and lateral chest radiographs alone and then together with the subtracted PA soft tissue images. The size, location and number of lung nodules or masses were registered with the confidence level. CT was used as standard of reference. For the 200 total lesions, a sensitivity of 33.5–52.5% was found at non-subtracted and a sensitivity of 43.5–58.5% at energy-subtracted radiography, corresponding to a significant improvement in four of five readers (p < 0.05). However, in three of five readers the rate of false positives was higher with ES. With ES, sensitivity, but not the area under the alternative free-response receiver operating characteristics (AFROC) curve, showed a good correlation with reader experience (R = 0.90, p = 0.026). In four of five readers, the diagnostic confidence improved with ES (p = 0.0036). We conclude that single-exposure digital ES chest radiography improves detection of most pulmonary nodules and masses, but identification of nodules <1 cm and false-positive findings remain a problem.     

应用计算机辅助检测系统对观察者在数字化胸片肺结节检测中的训练

摘要目的评估短期反馈能否帮助观察者提高在数字化胸片中运用计算机辅助系统(CAD)检测肺结节的能力。方法140例胸部平片(56例CT证实存在孤立性肺结节,84例为阴性对照)分为4组,每组各35例;每组均有6名观察者按不同顺序阅片。在有和没有CAD(IQQA-Chest,EDDA Technology)辅助情况下分别对病变的存在、部位、诊断的可靠性进行计分。观察者在每组阅片后获得独立的反馈。     

Single-exposure dual-energy computed radiography: improved detection and processing

Recent reports have emphasized the potential for dual-energy computed radiographic applications. An improved method for single-exposure material-selective imaging with a photostimulable phosphor computed radiography system was investigated. The essential elements of the technique are (a) prefiltration with gadolinium, which divides the incident broad-beam x-ray spectrum into low-energy and high-energy peaks; (b) a cassette consisting of four photostimulable phosphor plates that record images of increasing mean energies, with a computed energy separation of 23 keV from the front to the rear plate; (c) spatially dependent scatter and beam-hardening corrections; and (d) a noise-reduction algorithm based on noise correlations between bone-selective and soft-tissue-selective dual-energy images. These elements result in improved material cancellation and signal-to-noise ratio throughout the image.     

Comparison of dual-energy and conventional chest radiography for nodule detection

This paper presents the results of a nodule detection study, using a Humanoid chest phantom, which was designed to evaluate the performance of two types of dual-energy and conventional (single-energy) chest radiography. The film-screen apparatis were used as image detectors for all imaging modalities. The area under the ROC curve and the cumulative true-positive fraction both were used as performance indexes in the evaluation. Because of the small number of false-positive responses in the observer studies, the cumulative true-positive fraction was eventually regarded as a more conclusive index of accuracy than the area under the ROC curve to make a reasonable conclusion. Both dual-energy techniques, dual- and single-exposure, were found to be superior to conventional chest radiography, P less than 0.0005 and P less than 0.006 for dual- and single-exposure techniques, respectively. The difference between the two dual-energy techniques was statistically insignificant, P less than 0.47. We concluded that the dual-energy, single-exposure technique is worthy of further clinical study based on these encouraging results and because of the ease with which the technique can be implemented.     

Effects of dual-energy subtraction chest radiography on detection of small pulmonary nodules with varying attenuation: receiver operating characteristic analysis using a phantom study

Purpose  

The aim of this study was to investigate the detectability of simulated pulmonary nodules with different X-ray attenuation by flat-panel detector (FPD) chest radiography using a dual-exposure dual-energy subtraction (DES) technique.     

HASTE MRI versus chest radiography in the detection of pulmonary nodules: comparison with MDCT.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of our study was to compare the diagnostic accuracy of an ultrafast ECG-triggered black blood-prepared HASTE sequence with chest radiography for the detection of pulmonary nodules. SUBJECTS AND METHODS. Sixty-four patients with various primary malignancies who had undergone radiography and MDCT of the chest also underwent ECG-triggered black blood-prepared HASTE MRI of the lung. MR images and radiographs were interpreted separately. The number, location, and size of detected lesions were recorded, and each hemithorax was classified as affected or not affected on the basis of a grade reflecting the conspicuity of nodular involvement. Sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values for the detection of pulmonary nodules with diameters of 5 mm or larger were determined, using MDCT findings as the standard of reference. Lesions with diameters smaller than 5 mm were not evaluated. Additional lesion-by-lesion comparisons between MDCT and MRI findings were performed. RESULTS: MDCT confirmed pulmonary lesions in 32 patients, whereas HASTE MRI revealed lesions in 30 patients and chest radiography, in 19 patients. MDCT revealed 226 nodules in 32 patients, whereas MRI HASTE revealed 227 lesions in 30 patients. Conspicuity scale-based sensitivity and specificity for chest radiography were 55.8% and 92.4%, respectively, whereas HASTE MRI had a sensitivity of 93.0% and a specificity of 96.2%. Positive and negative predictive values for chest radiography were 80% and 79.3%, respectively, and for HASTE MRI, 93.0% and 96.2%, respectively. The sensitivity of HASTE MRI increased with lesion size, ranging from 94.9% for nodules between 5 and 10 mm in diameter to 100% for lesions exceeding 3 cm in diameter. CONCLUSION: ECG-triggered black blood-prepared HASTE MRI is reliable for detecting pulmonary nodules exceeding 5 mm and has proven significantly more accurate than conventional chest radiography. The technique appears useful as an adjunct to MRI of the heart, great vessels, or chest, potentially increasing the diagnostic yield of MRI examinations.     

DDR双能量减影软组织像降低胸片对肺小结节的误诊

肺是全身各部位恶性肿瘤最常见的转移器官,文献统计约有20%～54%的恶性肿瘤转移到肺部。随着技术发展及临床资料的积累,我们发现目前普通胸片检查对小结节经常会发生误诊,导致不必要的继续检查、费用的浪费和患者的心理负担。双能量减影（dual energy substraction,DE）通     

Bone images from dual-energy subtraction chest radiography in the detection of rib fractures

Objective

To assess the sensitivity and image quality of chest radiography (CXR) with or without dual-energy subtracted (ES) bone images in the detection of rib fractures.

Materials and methods

In this retrospective study, 39 patients with 204 rib fractures and 24 subjects with no fractures were examined with a single exposure dual-energy subtraction digital radiography system. Three blinded readers first evaluated the non-subtracted posteroanterior and lateral chest radiographs alone, and 3 months later they evaluated the non-subtracted images together with the subtracted posteroanterior bone images. The locations of rib fractures were registered with confidence levels on a 3-grade scale. Image quality was rated on a 5-point scale. Marks by readers were compared with fracture localizations in CT as a standard of reference.

Results

The sensivity for fracture detection using both methods was very similar (34.3% with standard CXR and 33.5% with ES-CXR, p = 0.92). At the patient level, both sensitivity (71.8%) and specificity (92.9%) with or without ES were identical. Diagnostic confidence was not significantly different (2.61 with CXR and 2.75 with ES-CXR, p = 0.063). Image quality with ES was rated higher than that on standard CXR (4.08 vs. 3.74, p < 0.001).

Conclusions

Despite a better image quality, adding ES bone images to standard radiographs of the chest does not provide better sensitivity or improved diagnostic confidence in the detection of rib fractures.