Acute injury of the ligaments of the knee: magnetic resonance evaluation

Eleven acutely injured knees and 13 normal knees were examined by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to assess the value of this modality in detecting acute ligamentous injury of the knee. The presence of torn ligaments in the injured knees was determined by arthroscopy and/or arthrotomy in ten cases and clinical follow-up in one case. The anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments (ACL and PCL) were demonstrated by sagittal spin echo (SE) images through the intercondylar notch (TE = 30 ms; TR = 2,000 ms). The tibial and fibular collateral ligaments (TCL and FCL) were evaluated on coronal SE images (TE = 30 ms, TR = 200 or 530 ms; TE = 120 ms, TR = 2,000 or 2,120 ms). The ACL and PCL were considered torn on MR if they appeared disrupted or were not seen in their normal anatomical positions. The collateral ligaments were considered torn if abnormal high-intensity signal was noted in adjacent soft tissues on TE = 120 ms images or if disruption of a ligament was apparent. Eleven of 15 torn ligaments and 80 of 81 normal ligaments were correctly identified by these criteria. It is concluded that MR imaging may be useful in detecting acute injury of ligaments of the knee.     

Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Cruciate Ligament Injuries of the Knee

The anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) are important stabilizers of the knee. These ligaments are commonly injured in sports and motor vehicle accidents. An accurate diagnosis of cruciate ligament injuries is vital in patient care. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) can diagnose cruciate ligament injuries with high accuracy. The imaging diagnosis should be based on primary signs, although the secondary signs are sometimes useful, particularly in chronic cases. The detection of associated injuries of other structures of the knee, including menisci, collateral ligaments, cartilage, and bone, are also important. Accurate interpretation of the MRI examination requires a meticulous MRI technique, knowledge of the imaging anatomy, and understanding of the lesion appearance. This pictorial essay reviews the MRI appearance of normal and injured cruciate ligaments. Mechanisms of injury, primary and secondary MRI signs, and associated abnormalities are discussed.     

Magnetic resonance imaging of the knee

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is an accepted non-invasive modality for evaluation of soft tissue pathology without exposure to ionizing radiation. Current applications demonstrate excellent visualization of the anatomy and pathology of various organs. Preliminary studies in the knee reveal fine resolution of anatomy and pathology involving the meniscus. The purpose of this study is to determine a prospective correlation between MRI scans and actual meniscal pathology as documented at the time of arthroscopy. MRI scans were obtained in 155 patients, on 156 knees (one patient with bilateral scans), with 86 patients (87 knees) eventually undergoing diagnostic and operative videoarthroscopy performed by the same surgeon (DWJ). All images were obtained on the same high-resolution 1.5 Tesla GE Signa Magnetic Resonance Scanner with the same radiologist performing all readings (PEB). The knees were studied in the coronal and sagittal plane using a spin echo sequence and 5 mm slice thicknesses. The menisci were described as having Grade 1, 2, or 3 changes, with Grade 3 reserved for complete tears. Using arthroscopy as the diagnostic standard, the accuracy of MRI in diagnosing medial and lateral meniscal tears was 93.1% and 96.6%, respectively with a Grade 3 MRI reading. For tears of the ACL, the accuracy was 96.6% as confirmed at arthroscopy. Five tears of the PCL were also documented by MRI and correlated with clinical evaluation. Other abnormalities seen were articular cartilage and osteochondral defects, bone tumors, tibial plateau fractures, Baker's cysts, and meniscal cysts. The MRI scan is a highly accurate, noninvasive modality for documentation of meniscal pathology as well as cruciate ligament tears in the knee.     

膝关节韧带损伤的MRI诊断

目的:探讨膝关节韧带损伤的MRI表现及诊断价值。方法:36例临床怀疑膝关节损伤的患者于关节镜及手术前行MRI检查,以关节镜结果作为金标准,前瞻性分析膝关节韧带损伤的MRI表现及诊断价值。结果:关节镜证实前交叉韧带损伤21例,其中完全撕裂15例,部分撕裂6例,后交叉韧带损伤12例,正常患者15例。MRI诊断前交叉韧带损伤的敏感度为95.2%,特异度为80%,准确度为88.9%;诊断后交叉韧带损伤的敏感度为100%,特异度为95.8%,准确度为97.2%。结论:MR1是诊断膝关节韧带损伤的理想检查方法,具有较高的临床应用价值。     

Diagnostic efficacy in knee MRI comparing conventional technique and multiplanar reconstruction with one-millimeter FSE PDW images

Background: Magnetic resonance (MR) imaging has proved to be an excellent tool in diagnosing injuries of the cruciate ligaments and menisci. However, multiple planes and sometimes optimal oblique or double-oblique scan planes are needed due to the variability in the positioning of important structures, which means there is a lower throughput and longer scanning time.

Purpose: To compare the performance of a 1-mm-thickness fast spin-echo (FSE) proton-density-weighted (PDW) MR imaging technique with multiplanar reconstruction (MPR) in diagnosing tears of the menisci and cruciate ligaments with that of conventional MR imaging.

Material and Methods: Twenty-five consecutive patients underwent preoperative conventional and 1-mm-thickness FSE PDW MR imaging with subsequent knee arthroscopic surgery. Two musculoskeletal radiologists evaluated the status of the cruciate ligaments and menisci using two sets of MR images (method A: conventional images including seven sequences, taking 26 min; method B: 1-mm-thickness FSE PDW images with MPR, taking 7 min 20 s). The diagnostic efficacies of both methods for tears of the cruciate ligament and menisci were calculated and compared.

Results: Arthroscopic surgery revealed 10 anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tears, one posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) tear, and 26 meniscal tears. The diagnostic values of both methods were 100% for a cruciate ligament tear. The diagnostic values (sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value) for meniscal tears were 90%, 100%, 96%, 100%, and 94% for method A, and 95%, 100%, 98%, 100%, and 97% for method B, respectively. There were no significant differences in the diagnostic values between methods A and B.

Conclusion: 1-mm-slice-thickness FSE PDW imaging with MPR showed comparable performance in diagnosing tears of the cruciate ligaments and menisci to conventional sequences but the scan time was much shorter. Therefore, this technique (method B) might improve the throughput of a 3T MR imaging system.     

Posterior horn lateral meniscal tears simulating meniscofemoral ligament attachment in the setting of ACL tear: MRI findings

PURPOSE: We have noted apparent far lateral meniscal attachment of the meniscofemoral ligament (MFL) with an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tear. This study evaluates MFL attachment and association with posterior horn lateral meniscus (PHLM) tear. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Nine months of knee arthroscopy reports were reviewed to classify the PHLM and ACL as torn or normal. After excluding those with prior knee surgery, MR images were reviewed by two radiologists to determine the number of images lateral to PCL, which showed the ligaments of Humphrey and Wrisberg visible as structures separate from the PHLM. Any patient with abnormal PHLM surface signal not continuous with the MFL was excluded. MRI findings were compared with arthroscopy using Student's t test and Fisher's exact test. RESULTS: Of the 54 participants, 5 had PHLM tears and 49 were normal. Twenty-one had ACL tears; all those with an PHLM tear had an ACL tear. The ligament of Humphrey inserted on average 0.9 consecutive images lateral to the PCL without an PHLM tear and 4.7 with an PHLM tear; the ligament of Wrisberg inserted on average 3.0 consecutive images without an PHLM tear and 4.5 with an PHLM tear (slice thickness/gap = 3 mm/0.5 mm). There was a significant association between PHLM tear and number of images (p = 0.0028), and between ACL tear and this type of PHLM tear (p = 0.0064). CONCLUSION: Apparent far lateral meniscal extension of a meniscofemoral ligament (greater than or equal to four images lateral to the PCL) should be considered as a possible PHLM tear, especially in the setting of an ACL tear.     

Multidetector computed tomography in acute knee injuries: assessment of cruciate ligaments with magnetic resonance imaging correlation

Purpose: To evaluate whether non-contrast multidetector computed tomography (MDCT) for suspected acute knee fractures can also be used to evaluate cruciate ligament pathology.

Material and Methods: A total of 42 patients (17-65 years) underwent four-section MDCT. The images were independently evaluated at clinical workstations by four radiologists. They assessed the integrity (normal or torn) and the best slice direction (axial, sagittal, or coronal) for visualization of the cruciate ligaments. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), performed within 4 weeks (mean 6 days) in relation to MDCT, was considered the gold standard.

Results: Ligament integrity at MDCT: the mean interobserver proportion of agreement for a normal anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) was 0.73, for a torn ACL 0.41, for a normal posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) 0.96, and for a torn PCL 0.54. Interobserver variation for ACL was significant (P = 0.0136-0.0260), but insignificant for PCL (P = 0.3389-0.7212). Intra-observer variation was insignificant. Visualization was best in the axial and sagittal direction for ACL and PCL, respectively. At MRI, 29 normal, one partially, and 12 completely torn ACLs, and 37 normal, four partially and one completely torn PCL were found.

Conclusion: MDCT can detect an intact ACL and PCL with good specificity, accuracy, and negative predictive value. The assessment of torn ligaments is unreliable.     

Surgical treatment of acl-pcl-medial side-lateral-side injuries of the knee

The multiple-ligament-injured knee is a complex problem in orthopaedic surgery. Most dislocated knees involve tears of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL), posterior cruciate ligament (PCL), and at least one collateral ligament complex. Careful assessment of the extremity vascular status is essential because of the possibility of arterial and/or venous compromise. These complex injuries require a systematic approach to evaluation and treatment. Physical examination and imaging studies enable the surgeon to make a correct diagnosis and to formulate a treatment plan. Arthroscopically assisted combined ACL/PCL reconstruction is a reproducible procedure. Knee stability is improved postoperatively when evaluated by using knee-ligament rating scales, arthrometer testing, and stress radiographic analysis. Acute medial collateral ligament tears when combined with ACL/PCL tears may, in certain cases, be treated with bracing. Posterolateral corner injuries combined with ACL/PCL tears are best treated with primary repair, as indicated, combined with reconstruction by using a post of strong autograft (split biceps tendon, biceps tendon, semitendinosus) or allograft (Achilles tendon, bone—patellar tendon—bone) tissue. Surgical timing depends on the ligaments injured, the vascular status of the extremity, reduction stability, and the overall health of the patient. We prefer the use of allograft tissue for reconstruction in these cases because of the strength of these large grafts and the absence of donor-site morbidity.     

膝关节弯曲位3T 磁共振成像的临床分析

目的：探讨3 TMR膝关节弯曲位成像的优越性。方法58例临床怀疑膝关节损伤的患者行3 TMRI检查,58例患者同时行常规成像和弯曲位成像。采用双盲法对2种方法得出的常规图像和弯曲位图像按照韧带显示程度和对病变的显示能力进行评价。结果58例膝关节常规成像中,前后交叉韧带同时完整显示19例,显示韧带损伤25例（前交叉韧带损伤9例,后交叉韧带损伤16例）。58例膝关节弯曲位成像中,前后交叉韧带同时完整显示45例,Wrisberg韧带完整显示7例,显示韧带损伤28例（前交叉韧带损伤11例,后交叉韧带损伤16例,Wrisberg 韧带损伤1例）。结论膝关节弯曲位成像的交叉韧带、Wrisberg韧带和病变显示程度明显优于常规方法。     

Comparing in vivo kinematics of anterior cruciate-retaining and posterior cruciate-retaining total knee arthroplasty

The purpose of this study was to compare knee kinematics in patients with bi-cruciate preserving total knee arthroplasty and posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) preserving total knee arthroplasty. Five knees received PCL-retaining arthroplasty and nine knees received both cruciate-retaining arthroplasty (ACL/PCL knees). We studied treadmill gait, stair stepping, and maximum flexion activities using lateral fluoroscopy and shape matching. For maximum flexion, the ACL/PCL knees showed 6 mm more posterior translation of the lateral condyle (p < 0.05). For the stair activity, posterior translations of the lateral condyle were significantly greater in the ACL/PCL knees from 30° to 70° flexion (p < 0.05). Both condyles in the ACL/PCL knees showed greater posterior translation in the stance and swing phases of gait than in the PCL knees (p < 0.05). Preserving both cruciate ligaments in total knee arthroplasty appears to maintain some basic features of normal knee kinematics in these activities.     

Accuracy of MRI patterns in evaluating anterior cruciate ligament tears

 The purpose of this study was to determine the different patterns of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tears on MRI and the prevalence and accuracy of these patterns. Images were obtained on high-tesla and low-tesla units and the results compared to determine whether field strength affects the interpretation using the grading system. In 172 patients who underwent knee MRI (109 knees with high-tesla units and 63 knees with low-tesla units) and arthroscopy, there was a total of 91 arthroscopically proven ACL tears. Five patterns of ACL tears were observed and designated as type 1 (diffuse increase in signal on T2-weighted images and enlargement of the ligament, 48%); type 2 (horizontally oriented ACL, 21%); type 3 (nonvisualization of the ACL, 18%); type 4 (discontinuity of the ACL, 11%); and type 5 (vertically oriented ACL, 2%). The positive predictive value (PPV) for type 2, 4, and 5 patterns was 100% for both field strengths; for type 3 PPV was just above 80% for both field strengths. The PPV value for type 1 was 90% for the high-tesla unit and 79% for the low-tesla, unit, which was not statistically significant. Combining the results of both field strengths, the overall sensitivity and specificity were 93% and 89%, respectively. Arthroscopic results were also used to determine the association between meniscal and ACL tears. Only 13% of ACL tears were isolated, the rest being associated with meniscal tears. Forty-five percent of medial meniscal and 50% of lateral meniscal tears were associated with an ACL tear, and 94% of ACLs were torn when both menisci were torn.     

Ex-vivo MR imaging of the cruciate ligaments

Eight pairs of cruciate ligaments were obtained at autopsy for ex-vivo MR imaging. Image analysis demonstrated no differences in intrinsic signal characteristics between the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and posterior cruciate ligament (PCL). Histologic examination showed no differences in ligament organization. These findings support the hypothesis that the normal signal intensity difference between the ACL and PCL noted on clinical images is due to a volume-averaging artifact.     

膝关节前十字韧带撕裂的MRI诊断价值

目的：评价MRI诊断前十字韧带撕裂的价值。方法：对临床拟诊为膝关节前十字韧带撕裂的12例患者，对照分析其MRI资料及手术结果。结果：MRI矢状面9例，冠状面7例显示前十字韧带撕裂。12例中8例前十字韧带内有不规则高信号，4例前十字韧带前缘呈不规则波浪状，1例前十字韧带不连续。12例中6例伴后外侧胜分平台分析。MRI确诊11例。结论：MRI诊断前十字韧带撕裂是有价值的，膝关节后外侧胜管平台分析高度提示急性前十字韧带撕裂。     

前交叉韧带断裂的MRI征象研究

目的 研究前交叉韧带(ACL)断裂的MRI表现,探讨其直接征象和间接征象的产生机制及诊断价值.方法 本组男37例,女3例;年龄16～49岁,平均33岁.急性期断裂28例,慢性期断裂12例,均经关节镜检查和手术证实.采用1.5 T西门子MRI扫描仪,SE或TSE序列T1、12、质子压脂、medic和横断位、矢状位、冠状位多方位成像.组织3名高年资医师进行回顾分析,对ACL断裂的MRI直接征象和间接征象进行统计分析.结果 ACL断裂4|D例中完全性断裂35例,部分断裂5例.急性期断裂的28例直接征象分别为信号中断或不连续24例(86%),信号不均匀18例(64%),韧带肿胀增厚10例(36%);而慢性期断裂的12例分别韧带增厚11例(92%),信号中断或不连续9例(75%),信号不均匀7例(58%),其中韧带增厚征象主要见于慢性期的ACL断裂(P＜0.01).完全性断裂的35例中,28例(80%)发生在中段,上端、下端发生率低;5例部分断裂均发生在前内侧束.ACL断裂的间接征象中,后交叉韧带(PCL)"7"字变形34例(85%);半月板外露26例,其中外侧半月板外露16例(62%);骨损伤15例,其中胫骨撕裂骨折8例(53%);关节间隙增宽9例,其中78%属于慢性断裂;胫骨前移23例(57%).本组40例中,术前正确诊断37例,正确率为92%;3例部分断裂术前未能诊断,漏诊率为8%.结论 根据ACL断裂的直接征象和间接征象,结合外伤史,术前诊断比较容易.     

Diagnosis of cruciate ligament injury using single contrast arthrography

To evaluate the accuracy of arthrography for assessing the status of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL), 212 arthrograms from 212 knees in 205 consecutive patients undergoing single contrast arthrography and subsequent arthroscopy or arthrotomy were reviewed. Criteria for evaluation of the ACL included the clarity of its radiographic appearance as well as the anterior laxity of the knee as seen on manual stress views. Of the 111 knees having intact ACLs at surgery, 98 (88%) were evaluated correctly by arthrography. Of the 101 knees having a damaged ACL, 85 were read as torn or attenuated on the arthrogram. When the torn and attenuated ligaments were considered separately, accuracy was decreased. Of the 87 ligaments actually torn, 68 (78%) were read as torn and 9 (10%) as attenuated. Of the 14 actually attenuated, 5 (36%) were read as attenuated and 3 (21%) as torn. Of 114 arthrograms read as intact, 98 (86%) were correct. Of 77 arthrograms read as torn, 68 (88%), were correct. Of 21 arthrograms read as attenuated, 5 (24%) were correct. Of 114 torn medial menisci, 112 (98%) were correctly diagnosed, as were 38 (69%) of 55 torn lateral menisci. Sixteen of the 17 missed lateral meniscus tears were in knees with torn medial menisci. Single contrast arthrography is, therefore, highly accurate in distinguishing intact from damaged ACLs. The distinction between torn and attenuated ligaments, however, is not valuable.     

O'Donoghue's triad: magnetic resonance imaging evidence

Objective The objective was to search for magnetic resonance imaging evidence of medial collateral ligament (MCL) injury in knees with proven tears of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and medial meniscus; the three abnormalities that make up O'Donoghue's triad. Although the MCL injury can be unapparent clinically, knee joint stability may be compromised. Design The superficial portion of the MCL was evaluated on 19 MR studies of 16 knees with arthroscopically proven ACL and medial meniscal tears. MCL thicknesses were compared to those on MR images of 19 normal knees. Patients The injured knees were of 13 men and 3 women, ranging in age from 19 to 56 years; the normal knees were of 10 men and 9 women, ranging in age from 19 to 55 years. Results and conclusions The medial collateral ligaments of all injured knees were abnormal, and, as a group, they had greater thicknesses and more intraligamentous thickness variability than normal knees. The MR appearance of both ACL and medial meniscal tears served as indirect evidence of MCL injury, with irregular MCL thickening indicative of prior injury.     

Magnetic resonance imaging of anterior cruciate ligament tears: evaluation of standard orthogonal and tailored paracoronal images

PURPOSE: To evaluate the three standard orthogonal imaging planes and a paracoronal imaging plane for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tears. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Ninety patients (91 knees; 29 F and 61 M) aged between 15 and 84 years (mean 36.9 +/- 16.4 years) underwent magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the knee prior to arthroscopy. At surgery, 32 knees had an intact ACL, 4 a partial tear, and 55 a complete ACL tear. In all patients, axial, sagittal, coronal, and paracoronal T2-weighted turbo-SE images were acquired. The ACL was classified as intact, partially, or completely torn. Partial and complete tears were combined for statistical evaluation. RESULTS: Partial ACL tears (four cases) were not correctly diagnosed at MRI except in one knee by one observer on coronal images. Sensitivity in detecting ACL tears was 95%/63% (reader1/reader2) in the axial, 93%/95% in the sagittal, 93%/86% in the coronal, and 100%/93% in the paracoronal plane. Specificity was 75%/81% in the axial, 72%/81% in the sagittal, 78%/94% in the coronal, and 78%/88% in the paracoronal plane. CONCLUSION: ACL tears can be diagnosed accurately with each of the standard orthogonal planes. Based on reader confidence and interobserver agreement paracoronal images may be useful in equivocal cases.     

Computed arthrotomographic evaluation of chronic lesions of the cruciate ligaments

The high incidence of cruciate ligament injuries as a result of acute knee trauma with hemarthrosis and abuse of diagnostic arthroscopies call for a suitable radiological imaging of the central pivot. Computed Arthrotomography (CAT) was used to examine the knee joint in 20 cases of clinically suspected chronic cruciate ligament injury. The images were correlated with arthroscopic and/or arthrotomic findings. Thirteen lesions of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) (65%) were found, plus 1 lesion of the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) (5%), 2 associated lesions of ACL + PCL (10%), and 4 normal cases. Confirmation of pathology was available in all cases but one by arthroscopy and/or surgery. The central pivot diseases were classified as follows: absence, detachment, partial or complete tear. CAT findings of cruciate ligament injuries are emphasized and the role of the technique as compared to arthroscopy is discussed. CAT is useful in 3-D evaluation of central pivot and detection of different cruciate ligament injuries, with high sensitivity-specificity for ACL and high specificity-moderate sensitivity for PCL. In the evaluation of the chronic unstable knee, CAT is highly accurate and gives the surgeon useful information towards the planning of therapeutic procedures. CAT is almost non-invasive, well tolerated and easy to perform in out-patients, which make it a first-choice procedure in the screening of chronic ligament injuries.     

MR imaging of posterior cruciate ligament injuries

Posterior cruciate ligament(PCL) injuries are less frequent than anterior cruciate ligament(ACL) injuries, but are presumably more common than once thought. Thirty-nine patients with PCL injuries identified on MR images were studied. The criteria for PCL injury were complete tear, partial tear, and avulsion fracture. The approximate site of a partial tear was categorized as proximal, midsubstance, distal, or combination. Fourteen patients(35.9%) had complete tears of the PCL, 21 patients(53.8%) had partial tears, and four patients(10.3%) had avulsion fractures. A total of 12 patients (30.7%) had isolated PCL injuries, while the remaining 27 patients demonstrated evidence of other coexistent knee injuries, such as meniscal tears and ligamentous injuries. Of coexistent knee injuries, meniscal tears(18 patients, 46.2%) were most often seen.     

Value of fat-suppressed PD-weighted TSE-sequences for detection of anterior and posterior cruciate ligament lesions--comparison to arthroscopy

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate fat-suppressed (FS) proton-density-weighted (PDw) turbo spin-echo (TSE) magnetic resonance imaging for the detection of anterior and posterior cruciate ligament lesions in comparison to arthroscopy. MATERIALS AND METHODS: In a prospective study 31 knee joints were imaged on a 1.5T MR scanner (Vision, Siemens, Erlangen) prior to arthroscopy using following sequences: (a) sagittal FS-PDw/T2w TSE (TR/TE: 4009/15/105 ms); (b) sagittal PDw/T2w TSE (TR/TE:3800/15/105 ms). Further imaging parameters: slice thickness 3mm, FOV 160 mm, matrix 256 x 256. A total of 62 anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments (ACL/PCL) were evaluated, standard of reference was arthroscopy. Sensitivity, specificity, positive (ppv) and negative predictive value (npv) and accuracy were calculated. RESULTS: Twenty-one cruciate ligament ruptures were detected in arthroscopy, 19 ACL- and 2 PCL-ruptures (on MRI 34/124, 25/62 ACL, 9/62 PCL lesions). For all four sequences in the 31 patients with arthroscopic correlation sensitivity, specificity, ppv, npv and accuracy were 86%, 98%, 95%, 93% and 94% for detection of tears, and 84%, 100%, 100%, 80% and 90% for ACL-ruptures respectively. The two PCL-ruptures were true positive in all sequences, one intact PCL was diagnosed as torn (false positive). CONCLUSIONS: Fat-suppressed PDw/T2w TSE-MR sequences are comparable to PDw TSE sequences for the detection of ACL/PCL-lesions.