Muscle injury induced beneath and distal to a pneumatic tourniquet: a quantitative animal study of effects of tourniquet pressure and duration.

Previous recommendations regarding the "safe" period of tourniquet hemostasis were based largely on studies of ischemia distal to the tourniquet. This study quantitatively analyzed skeletal muscle injury induced beneath and distal to a pneumatic tourniquet applied to the hindlimbs of rabbits for 1, 2, or 4 hours with a cuff inflation pressure of 125, 200, or 350 mm Hg. Technetium Tc 99m pyrophosphate incorporation after systemic injection (Tc 99 uptake) and correlative histology were used to evaluate tissue damage 2 days after tourniquet application. Compared with the contralateral control limbs, compression and ischemia induced statistically significant increases in Tc 99 uptake in the thigh and leg regions of all groups. Pyrophosphate incorporation was significantly greater in the thigh region than in the leg region after 2 hours of compression in the 200 and 350 mm Hg pressure groups and following 4 hours of compression in all pressure groups. Focal and regional fiber necrosis and degeneration were observed in thigh muscles after 2 hours of tourniquet compression. Two hours of continuous tourniquet application at clinically relevant cuff inflation pressures induced significant skeletal muscle necrosis beneath the tourniquet. Use of the lowest possible inflation pressure for a limited duration should minimize the degree of tissue injury caused by tourniquet application.     

不同止血带时间止血带下及其以远肌损伤形态学观察

本文报告15只健康家犬的30条后腿,在气囊止血带40kPa压力下,扎止血带1、2、4小时,观察了缺血期、止血带后2小时、2天和6天止血带下及其以远不同部位肌肉组织学和超微结构变化,并对止血带时间、压力及损伤机理进行了讨论。结果表明止血带直接机械性压迫是肢体止血带损伤的主要原因。作者认为止血带压力40kPa、时间1小时较为安全,可使组织损伤减少到最低程度。     

Skeletal muscle injury induced by a pneumatic tourniquet: an enzyme- and immunohistochemical study in rabbits.

The pathophysiology of skeletal muscle injury induced by compression beneath pneumatic tourniquets is poorly understood. Tourniquet hemostasis was induced in rabbit hindlimbs for 2 hr with a cuff inflation pressure of either 125 mm Hg (n = 5) or 350 mm Hg (n = 5). Skeletal muscle biopsies, taken 2 days later from tissue beneath and distal to the tourniquet, were frozen and analyzed using enzyme- and immunohistochemical techniques. In the 350 mm Hg tourniquet group, four of 10 thigh muscle samples demonstrated significant regional necrosis (mean 37.3% of the total cross-sectional area). Regional necrosis was not observed in thigh muscles of the 125 mm Hg tourniquet group or in any of the ischemic leg muscles. A topographic pattern of necrosis consistent with the arterial distribution of skeletal muscle suggested pathogenic events during the reperfusion period, such as granulocyte-mediated superoxide radical formation. Extremely large and rounded fibers (histochemically identified as Type IIB fibers) were observed in compressed thigh muscles, indicating differential fiber sensitivity to tourniquet compression and ischemia. The present study demonstrated significant skeletal muscle necrosis after a 2 hr tourniquet applied at a clinically relevant cuff inflation pressure. Recent studies of systemic changes associated with limb "ischemia" should be reassessed in consideration of the confounding effects of tissue compression induced beneath pneumatic tourniquets.     

Nerve function and structure beneath and distal to a pneumatic tourniquet applied to rabbit hindlimbs.

Neurophysiologic and neuropathologic changes were studied in rabbit hindlimbs after 2 hours of pneumatic tourniquet application with either 350 mmHg (n = 18) or 1,000 mmHg (n = 6) cuff inflation pressure. The toe spread reflex was decreased in 66% and absent in 33% of limbs 2 days after 350 mmHg compression, and was absent in all limbs after 1,000 mmHg compression. Compound motor action potential amplitudes (CMAPs), recorded from the abductor hallucis muscle, were significantly decreased with sciatic nerve stimulation 1 hour after 350 mmHg compression. CMAPs returned to baseline values one and two days later, however nerve conduction velocity (NCV) was still significantly decreased in the compressed sciatic nerves of these groups. In contrast, complete nerve conduction block, localized beneath the cuff's distal border, was observed two days after 1,000 mmHg compression, and NCV was still significantly decreased distal to the tourniquet zone. Using light and electron microscopy, scattered axonal degeneration, mild myelin damage, and normal nodes of Ranvier were observed two days after 350 mmHg tourniquet compression. Severe fiber damage and nodal obliteration were noted after 1,000 mmHg tourniquet compression. Although nodal invagination is probably not a significant pathogenic mechanism at clinically relevant tourniquet pressures and durations, functional abnormalities were induced by 2 hour, 350 mmHg tourniquet compression. Such changes probably correlate with clinical electromyographic abnormalities and delayed post-operative recovery following 'routine' extremity surgery using pneumatic tourniquets.     

The arterial tourniquet: pathophysiological consequences and anaesthetic implications

The arterial tourniquet is widely used in upper and lower extremity surgery and in intravenous regional anaesthesia. The local and systemic physiological effects and the anaesthetic implications are reviewed. Localised complications result from either tissue compression beneath the cuff or tissue ischaemia distal to the tourniquet. Systemic effects are related to the inflation or deflation of the tourniquet. Safe working guidelines for the application of an arterial tourniquet have not been clearly defined.     

Effects of reperfusion intervals on skeletal muscle injury beneath and distal to a pneumatic tourniquet.

To date there have been no experimental studies specifically directed at effects of reperfusion intervals on skeletal muscle injury beneath the tourniquet. 99mTechnetium pyrophosphate (Tc 99) incorporation and correlative histology were used to assess injury 2 days after tourniquet application in muscles beneath (thigh) and distal (leg) to the cuff. Tourniquets were applied to rabbit hindlimbs for a total of either 2 or 4 hours. In the 4-hour series, tourniquet compression (either 125 mm Hg or 350 mm Hg cuff inflation pressure) was either continuous or interrupted by 10-minute reperfusion intervals after 2 hours or after every hour of cuff inflation. In the 2-hour series, tourniquet compression (350 mm Hg) was either continuous or interrupted by 10-minute reperfusion intervals after 2 hours or after every hour of cuff inflation. In the 2-hour series, tourniquet compression (350 mm Hg) was either continuous or interrupted by a 10-minute reperfusion interval after 1 hour. Pyrophosphate incorporation (Tc 99 uptake) was significantly greater in the thigh region than in the leg region in all of the 4-hour tourniquet groups. Tc 99 uptake was significantly reduced by reperfusion after each hour of cuff inflation. With 350 mm Hg tourniquet pressure, a reperfusion interval after 2 hours of cuff inflation tended to exacerbate tourniquet compression injury. Reperfusion intervals did not significantly affect Tc 99 uptake in the leg region of these groups. With a 2-hour tourniquet time, Tc 99 uptake in the thigh was significantly decreased by reperfusion after 1 hour of cuff inflation. Previous clinical recommendations, based on serum creatine phosphokinase abnormalities after experimental tourniquet ischemia, probably reflected tourniquet compression injury. Hourly reperfusion limits skeletal muscle injury during extended periods of tourniquet use.     

Pneumatic tourniquets in extremity surgery

Pneumatic tourniquets maintain a relatively bloodless field during extremity surgery, minimize blood loss, aid identification of vital structures, and expedite the procedure. However, they may induce an ischemia-reperfusion injury with potentially harmful local and systemic consequences. Modern pneumatic tourniquets are designed with mechanisms to regulate and maintain pressure. Routine maintenance helps ensure that these systems are working properly. The complications of tourniquet use include postoperative swelling, delay of recovery of muscle power, compression neurapraxia, wound hematoma with the potential for infection, vascular injury, tissue necrosis, and compartment syndrome. Systemic complications can also occur. The incidence of complications can be minimized by use of wider tourniquets, careful preoperative patient evaluation, and adherence to accepted principles of tourniquet use.     

Ultrastructural changes in rat peripheral nerve following pneumatic tourniquet compression

The sciatic nerves of 12 male rats were examined in the electron microscope 14 days after pneumatic tourniquet compression. Tourniquet pressure was maintained at 300 mmHg for varied lengths of time (30 minutes to 3 hours). Nerves compressed for 30 minutes showed very mild fissuring of the myelin without axonal degeneration. Examination of nerves compressed for 1 to 3 hours showed progressively more varied and extensive damage. Changes included splaying of myelin lamellae, axonal shrinkage with periaxonal edema. Schwann cell hypertrophy, and an increase in the number of microtubules and mitochondria per unit area. The myelin sheaths of some fibers, compressed for more than 2 hours, were completely ruptured. These changes resemble nerve lesions which could be induced by a variety of experimental procedures. Ultrastructural changes produced by tourniquet compression are apparently time-related and affect large-diameter nerves more profoundly than smaller-diameter nerves. The data reported provide an explanation for delayed muscle rehabilitation experienced by patients who have undergone extremity surgery with pneumatic tourniquet application. The evidence presented suggests that the incidence of tourniquet palsy may be far greater than previously recognized.     

Effect of different cuff widths on the motor nerve conduction of the median nerve: an experimental study

Background  

A bloodless operative field is considered mandatory for most surgical procedures on the upper and lower extremity. This is accomplished by using either an Esmarch bandage or a pneumatic tourniquet, but a number of complications are associated with both. Nerve palsy is one of the most frequently encountered complications of this procedure. Wider cuffs have been found to cause reduced risk of tourniquet induced injury to the underlying soft tissues than the narrower ones due to the fact that lower occlusion pressures are caused by the former. To address and investigate this question, conduction in the median nerve has been measured proximal to tourniquet as well as distal to the tourniquet. Parameters of nerve conduction measured are nerve conduction velocity, latency and amplitude.     

A large animal fatal extremity hemorrhage model and evaluation of a polymeric dressing (fatal extremity hemorrhage)

BACKGROUND: Extremity hemorrhage is a contributor to preventable battlefield mortality. The Army has liberalized tourniquet use guidelines in an attempt to prevent these deaths. To evaluate wound hemostatic agents that might allow for early tourniquet removal while maintaining hemorrhage control, a model of lethal extremity hemorrhage in the goat (Capra hircus) was developed and a polymeric dressing agent (BioFoam) tested. METHODS: After administration of a spinal block, animals were placed in lateral recumbancy with a head-up tilt of 6 degrees, 500 mL crystalloid was injected and 600 u/Kg of heparin was administered. After tourniquet application to the thigh, a soft tissue and vascular injury was created by transecting muscles and the femoral artery. The polymeric wound dressing was applied and the tourniquet was released. RESULTS: In testing, the primary endpoint was mortality within the first hour after tourniquet release. None of the control animals survived the full hour. Two out of five (40%) of the treated animals survived. With survivors' survival time calculated as 60 minutes, survival time was found not to differ between treated (34 +/- 19 minutes) and untreated (29 +/- 18 minutes) animals (p = 0.77). CONCLUSION: The physical characteristics of tissue injury, need for anticoagulation, and manipulation of blood pressure are vital factors contributing to the lethality of a large animal fatal extremity hemorrhage model. BioFoam was successful in preventing fatal arterial extremity hemorrhage after the release of an effective tourniquet in some cases. An agent that can reliably allow for safe tourniquet removal and restoration of collateral circulation is a potential solution to tourniquet-associated morbidity in traumatic extremity injury. The model developed will serve as a rigorous test for such agents.     

The pressure distribution under tourniquets

We measured the detailed pressure distribution under pneumatic tourniquets and Esmarch bandages in canine limbs. The results showed that pressure concentration can occur in the tissue under the tourniquet. The Esmarch-bandage tourniquet was shown to be capable of producing pressures in excess of 1000 millimeters of mercury immediately beneath the tourniquet. There is a wide variation between cuff pressure and the pressures in the underlying tissues.     

Congenital Functional Scoliosis

Longitudinal and radial tissue-fluid pressure distributions were determined beneath and adjacent to wide (12 and 18 cm) pneumatic tourniquet cuffs placed on intact human cadaveric arms and legs, respectively. Tissue fluid pressures exhibited relatively broad maxima at midcuff, and in most cases showed no differences at the various depths studied. Limb circumference was not a determining factor in the transmission of pressure to deeper tissue. We also investigated the effect of four cuff sizes (4.5, 8, 12, and 18 cm) on eliminating/blood flow to the lower legs of normal subjects. The cuff pressure required to eliminate blood flow decreased as cuff width increased; thigh circumference was a determining factor in the pressure required to eliminate blood flow while using the smaller cuffs, but not while using the 18-cm cuff. Thus, wide cuffs transmit a greater percentage of the applied tourniquet pressure to deeper tissues than conventional cuffs; accordingly, lower cuff pressures are required, which may minimize soft-tissue damage during extremity surgery.     

Wide tourniquet cuffs more effective at lower inflation pressures

Longitudinal and radial tissue-fluid pressure distributions were determined beneath and adjacent to wide (12 and 18 cm) pneumatic tourniquet cuffs placed on intact human cadaveric arms and legs, respectively. Tissue fluid pressures exhibited relatively broad maxima at midcuff, and in most cases showed no differences at the various depths studied. Limb circumference was not a determining factor in the transmission of pressure to deeper tissue. We also investigated the effect of four cuff sizes (4.5, 8, 12, and 18 cm) on eliminating blood flow to the lower legs of normal subjects. The cuff pressure required to eliminate blood flow decreased as cuff width increased; thigh circumference was a determining factor in the pressure required to eliminate blood flow while using the smaller cuffs, but not while using the 18-cm cuff. Thus, wide cuffs transmit a greater percentage of the applied tourniquet pressure to deeper tissues than conventional cuffs; accordingly, lower cuff pressures are required, which may minimize soft-tissue damage during extremity surgery.     

An investigation of the neurophysiologic mechanisms of tourniquet-related pain: changes in spontaneous activity and receptive field size in spinal dorsal horn neurons

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Several theories have been proposed for the pain resulting from the nerve compression and ischemia associated with maintaining the inflation of a pneumatic tourniquet on an extremity. This investigation observes changes in the spontaneous activity and receptive field (RF) size of spinal dorsal horn neurons during tourniquet-related nerve compression and ischemia. METHODS: Forty-eight pentobarbital-anesthetized rats were prepared for single-unit spinal dorsal horn cell recording utilizing an in vivo extracellular technique. Cells were characterized as either low threshold mechanoreceptor (LTM) neurons, wide dynamic range (WDR) neurons, or high threshold nociresponsive (NR) neurons based on their response to light touch (brush), non-noxious pressure, or noxious pinch. Receptive fields were carefully mapped. A 1 x 9 cm pneumatic tourniquet (Hokanson, Inc., Seattle, WA) was then applied to the animals' hind limb thigh and inflated to 300 mm Hg for 60 minutes. Throughout the 60-minute tourniquet inflation period, spontaneous activity, cell firing rate response characteristics, and RF size were carefully monitored. RESULTS: Twenty-three cells in 20 animals were characterized and monitored: 8 LTM, 6 WDR, and 9 NR neurons. Receptive fields were distal to the tourniquet cuff for 16 cells and proximal for 7 cells. Low threshold mechanoreceptor neurons demonstrated little spontaneous activity prior to tourniquet inflation in the absence of RF stimulation. The RF size for all LTM neurons decreased or became silent during the tourniquet inflation period. The RF size increased in two of six WDR neurons with two cells demonstrating a progressive increase in intermittent spontaneous firing during the tourniquet inflation period. Receptive field size increased in five of five NR neurons with RF located proximal to the tourniquet cuff from 29 +/- 10 mm2 to 54 +/- 30 mm2 (RF area 1.9 +/- 0.7; t = 2.7, P = .03). All five of these NR neurons also demonstrated an increase in spontaneous activity at 37 +/- 14 minutes of tourniquet inflation which continued throughout the remainder of the tourniquet inflation period (P < .05). CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study indicate that nerve compression and ischemia results in block of input to LTM neurons having RFs distal to the tourniquet cuff and an increase in spontaneous activity and expansion of the RFs of NRs, especially those with RFs located proximal to the tourniquet. Increases in spontaneous firing activity and expansion of the RFs of nociresponsive dorsal horn neurons receiving input from primary afferent nociceptors proximal to the tourniquet may explain, in part, the neurophysiologic mechanism of tourniquet-related pain.     

A new method for estimating arterial occlusion pressure in optimizing pneumatic tourniquet inflation pressure

To reduce pressure-related injuries resulting from pneumatic tourniquet use, the lowest possible inflation pressure is recommended. Arterial occlusion pressure (AOP) is a measure of the cuff pressure required to maintain a bloodless surgical field. However, its determination method is time consuming, requires operator skill, and is therefore seldom used in current practice. An AOP estimation can be made by knowing the pressure transmitted to the underlying soft tissues. We measured upper and lower extremity tissue pressures under the tourniquet cuff at 100, 200, and 300 mm Hg of tourniquet inflation pressures in 30 anesthetized living adult patients. All patients received general anesthesia with neuromuscular relaxation. A Stryker intra-compartmental pressure monitor was used to measure tissue pressures under the tourniquet cuff. In all patients, the soft tissue pressures were consistently lower than the applied tourniquet inflation pressures. Our results revealed tissue padding coefficients for extremities 20 to 75 cm in circumferences. An estimation method of AOP was developed [AOP = (systolic blood pressure + 10)/Tissue padding coefficient]. The new AOP estimation method may be a simple, rapid, and clinically practical alternative to the AOP determination method.     

Local compression patterns beneath pneumatic tourniquets applied to arms and thighs of human cadavera

Distributions of tissue fluid pressure were examined beneath a standard pneumatic tourniquet in six upper extremities and six lower extremities of fresh human cadavera, disarticulated at the shoulder and hip, respectively. A standard 8-cm-wide tourniquet cuff was applied at mid-humerus or mid-femur position. Tissue fluid pressures were measured by 100-cm-long slit catheters inserted parallel to the bone at four tissue depths: subcutaneous, subfascial, mid-muscle, and adjacent to bone. All arms and thighs were studied at the following cuff pressures: 100, 150, 200, 250, 300, 400, and 500 mm Hg. Tissue fluid pressure was always maximal in subcutaneous tissue at mid-cuff. Transmission of cuff pressures to deeper tissues was significantly less (p less than 0.01) in the thighs with a girth of 40-52 cm than in the arms with a girth of 22-33 cm. At the four tissue depths studied, tissue fluid pressures fell steeply in a longitudinal direction near the cuff edge to levels near zero at points 1-2 cm outside each cuff edge. Our results suggest that wider cuffs are required on thighs than on arms to provide a bloodless field during limb surgery and to minimize underlying tissue injury associated with high cuff pressures. Our recommendation for wider tourniquet cuffs than those presently used during orthopaedic surgery is contrary to recent prevailing knowledge.     

Effects of tourniquet compression on neuromuscular function

Neuromuscular function in New Zealand White rabbits was evaluated after thigh tourniquet compression in the directly compressed quadriceps muscles and the distal tibialis anterior by measuring isometric contractile function after supramaximal stimulation of the motor nerve. Tourniquet compression resulted in markedly decreased force production beneath and distal to the tourniquet. Two days after compression, maximal quadriceps force production was decreased to 46% of control values with 125 mm Hg compression and 21% of control values after 350 mm Hg compression. Maximum tibialis anterior force production declined to 70% of control values after 125 mm Hg thigh compression and 24% of control values after 350 mm Hg thigh compression. Functional deficits were greater in the directly compressed quadriceps muscles, but the quadriceps and tibialis anterior had significantly increased impairment when the tourniquet inflation pressure was increased from 125 mm Hg to 350 mm Hg. Three weeks after compression, quadriceps function had returned to 94% of control value after 125 mm Hg compression and 83% after 350 mm Hg. Tibialis anterior function returned to 88% of control values after 125 mm Hg thigh compression and 83% after 350 mm Hg. Clinically, the use of lower inflation pressures may minimize the complications of tourniquet use and enhance postoperative recovery.     

Wide tourniquets eliminate blood flow at low inflation pressures

Previous recommendations for use of pneumatic tourniquets in extremity surgery suggest parameters for maximum pressure and time limits without regard for optimum cuff width. Wide cuffs produce lower readings of blood pressure relative to narrow cuffs, presumably because the wide cuffs arrest flow at lower inflation pressure. We investigated three tourniquet sizes and the inflation pressure required to eliminate flow to the upper extremity using an ultrasonic Doppler device to monitor blood flow in the radial artery of ten normal subjects (arm circumference 24.5 to 37 cm). Arterial flow was always eliminated at the lowest pressure using the widest tourniquet cuff. Significantly lower inflation pressures will eliminate blood flow if wider tourniquet cuffs are used; therefore, use of a wider tourniquet cuff may result in a reduced incidence of tourniquet complications.     

Clinical experiences with a new tourniquet device

Cessation of blood flow to the extremity improves the comfort of the surgeon. So pneumatic tourniquets are commonly used to obtain a bloodless field during upper- and lower-extremity surgery despite the several problems that tourniquet pressure may lead to. In this paper, we present our clinical experiences with a new tourniquet device called S-MART (OHK Medical Devices, Haifa, Israel) and compared the device with the traditional pneumatic tourniquet in terms of efficacy and complications. A total of 30 patients were included in the study. Preoperative systolic blood pressure measurements were obtained, and patients with a systolic blood pressure >190 mm Hg were excluded. S-MART was used in stead of pneumatic tourniquet in half of the patients in group 1. Pneumatic tourniquet was applied to the patients in group 2. The patient groups were compared. No major complications were observed in either group. But it was observed that S-MART was unsuccessful to maintain a bloodless field during the whole operative procedure in some of the cases. In conclusion, application of S-MART is practical, provides bloodless field for a certain time, and does not increase the complication rate related with the pressure applied to underlying tissues, but it is not a suitable tourniquet device for long surgical procedures.     

Influence of systemic hypotension on skeletal muscle ischemia-reperfusion injury after 4-hour tourniquet application

OBJECTIVE: Tourniquet use for extremity hemorrhage control is common in military trauma. Tourniquet use may be accompanied by systemic hypotension, but this phenomenon has not been studied. We aimed to define the muscle effects of the combined insult of tourniquet-induced skeletal muscle ischemia-reperfusion injury (I-R) and hemorrhagic hypotension. DESIGN: After a 33% carotid arterial hemorrhage, Sprague-Dawley rats underwent 240-min hindlimb ischemia induced by pneumatic tourniquet. Control animals were not hemorrhaged. No resuscitation was given. After tourniquet release, muscles were reperfused for 120 min and then dissected. Weights and mitochondrial viability assays (nitroblue tetrazolium method) were performed on the plantaris (PL), and soleus (SO). Histologic analysis was performed on the PL and SO. Muscle edema is expressed as the ratio of tourniquet limb to contralateral limb muscle weight. SETTING: Animal laboratories of the United States Army Institute of Surgical Research. STUDY ANIMALS: Twelve Sprague-Dawley rats. RESULTS: The mean arterial pressure of hemorrhaged animals was 38 +/- 3 mm Hg before tourniquet placement and 86 +/- 4 mm Hg before release, both significantly (p < 0.05) lower than controls at the same time points. Pre- tourniquet mortality was 38% with hemorrhage and 0% without. All muscles experienced edema, with weight ratios greater than 1. The PL experienced significantly (p < 0.05) less edema with hemorrhage. Viability was unaffected by hemorrhage in all muscles, as was tissue inflammation. No differences in inflammation were observed with hemorrhage. CONCLUSIONS: Systemic hypotension modulates the impact of 4 hours of tourniquet ischemia by decreasing muscle edema but minimally altering measures of muscle viability. Compartment anatomy and muscle fiber type both influence muscle response to the combined insult of hypotension and I-R. In this model, hypotension did not worsen the skeletal muscle I-R observed after the use of a tourniquet for 4 hours.