Exaggerated startle reactions

The origin of the startle reflex lies in the caudal brainstem; it can be elicited by an unexpected stimulus resulting in a bilateral activation of many muscles. Two subsequent responses can be measured during EMG recordings; after the initial motor reflex, lasting until about 150 ms, a second response can occur. The second response contains more emotional and voluntary behavioral responses. Clinically, syndromes with hyperstartling as common feature can be divided into three groups: hyperekplexia, stimulus-induced disorders, and neuropsychiatric disorders. Classification of startle syndromes within these three groups remains challenging. Generalized stiffness at birth, excessive startling and temporary generalized stiffness after being startled point towards hyperekplexia. Stimulus-induced disorders are distinguished by careful clinical and neurophysiological evaluation, including video recordings. Neuropsychiatric disorders usually have additional behavioural and psychiatric symptoms. Polymyographic EMG startle recordings exhibit an exaggeration of the initial motor startle reflex in hyperekplexia, while neuropsychiatric startle syndromes demonstrate a variable response pattern and abnormal behavioural features. Neurophysiological investigation of the startle reflex can help to further delineate between the startle syndromes and unravel the aetiology of neuropsychiatric startle disorders.     

Major and minor form of hereditary hyperekplexia.

Hyperekplexia is a hereditary neurological disorder characterized by excessive startle responses. Within the disorder two clinical forms can be distinguished. The major form is characterized by continuous generalized stiffness in the first year of life and an exaggerated startle reflex, accompanied by temporary generalized stiffness and falls, whereas in the minor form only excessive startle and hypnic jerks have been described. Mutations in the gene encoding the alpha-1 subunit of the glycine receptor (GLRA1) are responsible for the major form of hyperekplexia but no mutation was detected in patients with the minor form in the large Dutch pedigree originally described by Suhren and colleagues. Here we describe the genetic analysis of the GLRA1 gene of two English families in which both forms of hyperekplexia were present. Mutation analysis revealed no genetic defect in the GLRA1 gene in patients carrying either the minor or major forms. This is further evidence that the minor form of hyperekplexia is seldom due to a genetic defect in the GLRA1 gene.     

Novel mutation of GLRA1 in Omani families with hyperekplexia and mild mental retardation

Hyperekplexia is characterized by neonatal hypertonia and exaggerated startle reflex in response to loud noise or tactile stimuli. Mutations in patients with hyperekplexia were evident in several genes encoding proteins involved in glycinergic neurotransmission, i.e., glycine receptor α and β subunits, collybistin, gephyrin, and glycine transporter 2. We clinically and genetically characterized two large, unrelated consanguineous families with hyperekplexia. Affected members of the two families manifested hyperekplexia with mild mental retardation. Patients exhibited a novel homozygote c.593G>C missense mutation in GLRA1, resulting in amino acid substitution p.W170S in the corresponding mature glycine receptor α1 subunit. This mutation was absent in 400 randomly selected chromosomes in the same population. In conclusion, a novel p.W170S mutation in the extracellular ligand binding domain of glycine receptor α1 subunit was detected in patients with hyperekplexia and mild mental retardation.     

Hyperekplexia phenotype due to compound heterozygosity for GLRA1 gene mutations.

Hyperekplexia (MIM 149400), or startle disease, is a neurological disorder characterized by generalized stiffness during the neonatal period, excessive startle reflexes, and generalized stiffness related to the startle response. Linkage analysis mapped a major gene for this disorder to chromosome 5q33-35. Subsequently, mutations in the GLRA1 gene, encoding the alpha1 subunit of the glycine receptor, were found in hyperekplexia families with an autosomal dominant or recessive inheritance pattern. In the present study, we describe the genetic analysis of the GLRA1 gene of a family consisting of 2 children with hyperekplexia, 2 nonaffected children, and their healthy nonconsanguineous parents. Although the pedigree suggested the presence of a recessive mutation, haplotype construction showed that the 2 affected children shared the same haplotype combination in which the maternal haplotype differed from the paternal haplotype, suggesting the presence of compound heterozygosity. Mutation analysis revealed different missense mutations on the two haplotypes, changing an arginine to a histidine at amino acid positions 252 and 392, respectively. It is interesting that the hyperekplexia phenotype was only seen in individuals compound heterozygous for the two mutations, whereas family members carrying either one of the two mutations had no clinical signs.     

Startle syndromes

Startle syndromes consist of three heterogeneous groups of disorders with abnormal responses to startling events. The first is hyperekplexia, which can be split up into the "major" or "minor" form. The major form of hyperekplexia is characterised by excessive startle reflexes, startle-induced falls, and continuous stiffness in the neonatal period. This form has a genetic basis: mutations in the alpha1 subunit of the glycine receptor gene, GLRA1, or related genes. The minor form, which is restricted to excessive startle reflexes with no stiffness, has no known genetic cause or underlying pathophysiological substrate. The second group of startle syndromes are neuropsychiatric, in which excessive startling and various additional behavioural features occur. The third group are disorders in which startling stimuli can induce responses other than startle reflexes, such as startle-induced epilepsy. Diagnosis of startle syndromes depends on clinical history, electromyographic studies, and genetic screening. Further study of these disorders may enable improved discrimination between the different groups.     

Physiological abnormalities in hereditary hyperekplexia.

Five patients from a kindred with hereditary hyperekplexia had physiological testing. The surface-recorded electromyographic pattern of audiogenic muscle jerks was identical to that of the normal acoustic startle reflex. Testing at graded stimulus intensities indicated an increase in the gain of the acoustic startle reflex. Nose-tap stimuli resulted in short-latency generalized electromyographic bursts that were similar to the R1 component of the blink reflex. Electrical stimulation of peripheral nerves elicited a pattern of generalized muscle jerks that was similar to that of the acoustic startle reflex. Somatosensory evoked potentials, brainstem auditory evoked potentials, and cortical auditory evoked potentials were normal. The primary physiological abnormality in hereditary hyperekplexia is widespread elevated gain of vestigial withdrawal reflexes in the brainstem and possibly the spinal cord, most likely resulting from increased excitability of reticular neurons.     

Neonatal Hyperekplexia: A Case Report

We report the case of a baby with transient generalized stiffness noticeable from the first days of life, hyperreflexia, massive jerks in response to sudden tactile and acoustic stimuli, and long-lasting myoclonic jerks closely resembling epileptic seizures. The father and paternal grandfather both had hyperekplexia. At age 3 years, the child had normal psychomotor development and persistent abnormal startle response to unexpected sounds or touch.     

Successful treatment of severe infantile hyperekplexia with low-dose clobazam

We report two cases of severe infantile hyperekplexia successfully treated with low-dose clobazam. The first case presented at 6 weeks of age with multiple episodes consisting of difficulty diapering because of stiffness and loud inspiratory noises followed by breath-holding in inspiration. She was diagnosed with hyperekplexia and started on clonazepam 0.05 mg daily. This was discontinued because of excessive sleepiness. The second case presented at 3 weeks of age with episodes of crying that would change in pitch and then abruptly stop, followed by leg and arm extension and stiffening. On occasion, there was cyanosis, and she received mouth-to-mouth resuscitation. She was diagnosed with hyperekplexia at 9 months of age. Both infants were treated with clobazam (0.25 and 0.3 mg/kg/day respectively), resulting in resolution of symptoms with no side effects. During treatment, both had minimal startle response to various stimuli and have now been successfully weaned from clobazam. Low-dose clobazam is effective in the treatment of hyperekplexia and is well tolerated in infants.     

Two Japanese families with hyperekplexia who have a Arg271Gln mutation in the glycine receptor alpha 1 subunit gene

We report two Japanese patients from two families with hyperekplexia who have a Arg271Gln mutation in the glycine receptor alpha 1 subunit gene. The clinical course of both patients was typical for hyperekplexia, characterized by neonatal hypertonia and exaggerated startle response, and which improved gradually with age. One was associated with umbilical hernia and hip dislocation, diagnosed at 11 months, while the other was diagnosed at 1 month. Both showed positive head retraction reflex. Four Japanese families have been reported as having hyperekplexia including our cases, of which three have shown the same missense Arg271Gln mutation, most frequently found in patients from Northern Europe and the United States.     

Hyperekplexia in a patient with a brainstem vascular anomaly

OBJECTIVES: To describe a patient with a clinical picture suggestive of idiopathic hyperekplexia (IH), who was later found to harbour a subtle brainstem vascular anomaly. PATIENT: A 35-year-old man, 4 years earlier, developed sudden jumping and falling in response to unexpected sensory stimuli. RESULTS: Neurological examination was normal. Electromyography showed an excessively large and non-habituating motor startle response. There were no mutations of the alpha1 subunit of the inhibitory glycine receptor which cause hereditary hyperekplexia. Although all these findings were consistent with a diagnosis of IH, a blink reflex study showed an enhanced recovery curve suggestive of a brainstem lesion. A detailed MRI study revealed a subtle vascular anomaly involving the lower brainstem. CONCLUSION: This is the first report of sporadic hyperekplexia related to a brainstem vascular anomaly. Subtle damage to the brainstem should always be excluded in patients with sporadic hyperekplexia, regardless of the coexistence of additional clear-cut neurological symptoms.     

Startle epilepsy complicating aspartylglucosaminuria

A 21-year-old right-handed man with definite diagnosis of aspartylglucosaminuria (AGU) presented with a 5-year history of progressive severe gait disturbance with frequent falls and generalized epileptic seizures triggered by unexpected stimuli. At one time, he was confined to a wheelchair because of the frequent falls. Electromyogram recording showed a large, excessive and not habituating motor startle response, with the classical and stereotyped order of muscle recruitment. During video-polygraphic recording, we recorded a reflex generalized tonic seizure triggered by a loud, unexpected acoustic stimulus. Brain magnetic resonance (MR) revealed no structural abnormality. A diagnosis of abnormal startle and startle epilepsy (SE) was made. The addition of clonazepam to valproate and phenobarbital led to a dramatic improvement in his abnormal startle and SE, and the patient was able to walk alone unaided. This report illustrates, for the first time, that abnormal startle and SE may occur in AGU and complicate its clinical picture. Recognition of this entity in AGU is important, as progressive gait disorder with frequent falls could be easily misinterpreted as an additional irreversible manifestation of the ongoing neurological deterioration characteristic of AGU.     

Essential startle disease may not be a uniform entity.

A 25-year-old man with essential startle disease has been reported. He had a history of sudden jerks and falls in response to unexpected stimuli. Abnormal falling developed when he learned to walk. No similar cases are known in his family. Physical examination revealed hyperreflexia. Pathologic startle reflex was elicited by light touching on the patient's nose, clapping or making other noises. EEG response to startle stimuli consisted of spikes recorded from both centroparietooccipital regions immediately preceding diffuse muscle and movement artifacts. The motor responses to auditory stimuli, which are startle reflex on the orbicularis oculi, sternocleidomastoid, biceps and quadriceps femoris muscles, habituated within 2-4 trials. Electrical stimulation of the median nerve at the wrist elicited a consistent C reflex (cortical long loop reflex) but not any giant cortical somatosensory evoked potentials. Our patient showed early disease onset and habituation of motor response, which are not seen in other essential hyperekplexia cases, and clinically differs from the patients with hereditary hyperekplexia in which neonatal rigidity, epilepsy, apneic attacks, low intelligence, congenital dislocated hips and inguinal hernia can be seen in differing frequency.     

Pontine hyperperfusion in sporadic hyperekplexia

Objective

To explore with neuroimaging techniques the anatomical and functional correlates of sporadic hyperekplexia.

Methods

Two elderly women with sporadic hyperekplexia underwent neurophysiological assessment, MRI of the brain and proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy (¹H‐MRS) of the brainstem and frontal lobes. Regional cerebral blood flow was investigated with single photon emission tomography (SPECT) during evoked startles and at rest.

Results

Both patients showed excessively large and non‐habituating startle responses. In both patients, MRI showed impingement of the brainstem by the vertebrobasilar artery, lack of frontal or brainstem abnormalities on ¹H‐MRS and hyperperfusion in the dorsal pons and cingulate cortex, and superior frontal gyrus at SPECT during evoked startles.

Conclusions

In our patients with hyperekplexia, the vertebrobasilar arteries were found to impinge on the brainstem. Neurophysiological findings and neurofunctional imaging of evoked startles indicated a pontine origin of the movement disorder modulated by activation in cortical, especially frontal, areas. The neurofunctional correlates of evoked startles in human sporadic hyperekplexia are similar to those observed for the startle circuit in animals.The startle reflex is a craniocaudal spreading wave of flexor movements along the neural axis that is elicited by an abruptly occurring sensory event. A pathological exaggeration of the normal startle reflex to unexpected stimuli, particularly sounds, is the hallmark of both hereditary and symptomatic hyperekplexia, whose clinical features arise from a functional disturbance of the brainstem startle relay.¹In animals, the neural circuit mediating the acoustic startle reflex involves three synapses located on the cochlear root, the nucleus reticularis pontis caudalis (PnC) and the spinal motor neurons.² Activation of an area in the medial pons corresponding to PnC has been reported during the startle reflex in normal humans by means of brain imaging studies.³We report neurophysiological and brain MRI evaluations with proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy (¹H‐MRS) and single photon emission tomography (SPECT) of two elderly women with sporadic hyperekplexia.     

Molybdenum cofactor deficiency presenting as neonatal hyperekplexia: a clinical, biochemical and genetic study

We report a newborn with exaggerated startle reactions and stiffness of neonatal onset, the prototypical signs of hyperekplexia. Startle and flexor spasms, leading to apnoea, did not respond to treatment with clonazepam but did partially to sodium valproate. Molecular analysis of GLRA1 revealed no mutations. The incidental finding of hypouricemia led to a work-up for molybdenum cofactor (MoCo) deficiency; the diagnosis was confirmed by the altered urine chemistries, including elevated urine S-sulphocysteine. Despite persistence of the spasms, clinical or electrographic seizures were never detected before the infant died at age 1 month. In this patient, the concurrence of hyperekplexia and MoCo deficiency was suggestive of impaired gephyrin function. GPH mutational analysis, however, showed no abnormalities. The patient was eventually found to harbour a novel c.1064T > C mutation in exon 8 of the MOCS1 gene. Despite extensive sequence analysis of the gene, the second causative mutation of this recessive trait still awaits identification. MoCo deficiency should be considered in the differential diagnosis of neonatal hyperekplexia, particularly in the instances of refractoriness to clonazepam, an early demise in infancy or the evidence of no mutations in the GLRA1 gene.     

The impact of human hyperekplexia mutations on glycine receptor structure and function

Hyperekplexia is a rare neurological disorder characterized by neonatal hypertonia, exaggerated startle responses to unexpected stimuli and a variable incidence of apnoea, intellectual disability and delays in speech acquisition. The majority of motor defects are successfully treated by clonazepam. Hyperekplexia is caused by hereditary mutations that disrupt the functioning of inhibitory glycinergic synapses in neuromotor pathways of the spinal cord and brainstem. The human glycine receptor α1 and β subunits, which predominate at these synapses, are the major targets of mutations. International genetic screening programs, that together have analysed several hundred probands, have recently generated a clear picture of genotype-phenotype correlations and the prevalence of different categories of hyperekplexia mutations. Focusing largely on this new information, this review seeks to summarise the effects of mutations on glycine receptor structure and function and how these functional alterations lead to hyperekplexia.     

Mutational analysis of familial and sporadic hyperekplexia

Hyperekplexia is a rare, autosomal dominant neurological disorder characterized by hypertonia, especially in infancy, and by an exaggerated startle response. This disorder is caused by mutations in the ?1 subunit of the inhibitory glycine receptor (GLRA1). We previously reported two GLRA1 point mutations detected in 4 unrelated hyperekplexia families; both mutations were at nucleotide 1192 and resulted in the replacement of Arg²⁷¹ by a glutamine (R271Q) in one case and a leucine (R271L) in the other. Here, 5 additional hyperekplexia families are shown to have the most common G-to-A transition mutation at nucleotide 1192. Haplotype analysis using polymorphisms within and close to the GLRA1 locus suggests that this mutation has arisen at least twice (and possibly four times). In 2 additional families, a third mutation is also presented that changes a tyrosine at amino acid 279 to a cysteine (Y279C). Five patients with atypical clinical features and equivocal or absent family history of hyperekplexia and 1 patient with a classical presentation but no family history are presented in whom a mutation in the GLRA1 gene was not detected. Thus, only clinically typical hyperekplexia appears to be consistently associated with GLRA1 mutations, and these affect a specific extracellular domain of the protein.     

The effect of posture on the normal and pathological auditory startle reflex.

The effect of posture on the EMG pattern of the normal auditory startle reflex was investigated. The startle response to an unexpected auditory tone was studied in eleven normal subjects when standing, and in six normal subjects when sitting relaxed or tonically plantar flexing both feet. Reflex EMG activity was recorded in the tibialis anterior and soleus about twice as frequently when standing, than when sitting relaxed. In addition, the median latencies to onset of reflex EMG activity in the tibialis anterior and soleus were about 40 and 60 ms shorter during standing, than when sitting relaxed. No short latency EMG activity was recorded in the calf muscles during tonic plantar flexion of the feet, while sitting. The effect of posture on the EMG pattern of the pathological auditory startle reflex was studied in five patients with hyperekplexia. In three patients the latency to onset of reflex EMG activity in the tibialis anterior was shorter when standing, than when sitting relaxed. The EMG pattern of the reflex response to sound was studied in detail in two of these patients and consisted of up to three successive components. The expression of each EMG component depended on the postural set of the limbs. In particular, a distinct short latency component was found in posturally important muscles following auditory stimulation. This short latency component was not recorded when sitting relaxed. It is concluded that the EMG pattern of the physiological and pathological auditory startle response is not fixed, but may change with the postural stance of the body. This finding supports the theory that the normal startle reflex and the abnormal startle reflex in hyperekplexia have a common brainstem origin.     

Identification of a de novo Lys304Gln mutation in the glycine receptor α‐1 subunit gene in a Korean infant with hyperekplexia

Startle disease or hyperekplexia (STHE; MIM 149400) is a rare disorder that is characterized by marked muscular hypertonia in infancy and an exaggerated startle response to unexpected acoustic or tactile stimuli. Mutations in the gene encoding the α‐1 subunit of the inhibitory glycine receptor (GLRA1) were reported as causes of STHE. Recently, we encountered a Korean male infant with generalized stiffness that was observed from the first 3 days of life. The abnormal startle response was evident from the fourth week of life, and he showed marked improvement in the startle response and muscle hypertonia after being administered phenobarbital and clonazepam. Direct sequencing analysis of the infant and his parents revealed a de novo variation (c.910A>C) in the GLRA1 gene, resulting in a novel Lys304Gln missense mutation. © 2007 Movement Disorder Society     

Functional characterization of compound heterozygosity for GlyRalpha1 mutations in the startle disease hyperekplexia

The human disease hyperekplexia is characterized by excessive startle reactions to auditory and cutaneous stimuli. In its familial form, hyperekplexia has been associated with both dominant and recessive mutations of the GLRA1 gene encoding the glycine receptor alpha1 subunit (GlyRalpha1), which mediates inhibitory transmission in the spinal cord and brainstem. Here we have examined the functional consequences of two amino acid substitutions found in a compound heterozygous family, R252H and R392H, to investigate the mechanisms determining this inheritance pattern. When expressed in Xenopus laevis oocytes, both mutations were non-functional. Neither mutant affected the electrophysiological properties of wild type GlyRalpha1 when co-expressed. We introduced a green fluorescent protein tag to mutant subunits and found that both mutant proteins were detectable. Evidence that subcellular localization differed from wild type was significant for one of the mutants. Thus, an effective loss of functional GlyRalpha1-mediated current underlies hyperekplexia in this family, whereas a partial loss is asymptomatic.     

Hyperekplexia and sudden neonatal death.

Fifteen patients with hyperekplexia were identified in 3 families; diagnostic clinical characteristics were defined which allowed for early recognition and treatment. During the first 24 hours of life, spontaneous apnea and sluggish feeding effort were observed. After the first 24 hours, surviving infants exhibited the hyperekplexic startle response to nose tapping. This startle response is characterized by sudden muscular rigidity, feeding-induced oropharyngeal incoordination, and poor air exchange often with apnea, persisting with repetitive nose tapping. Untreated infants experienced recurring apnea until 1 year of age. Three of 15 patients died unexpectedly during the neonatal period. Patients treated with clonazepam (0.1-0.2 mg/kg/day) had no serious apneic episodes and startle reflexes were diminished. The pathophysiologic mechanism for hyperekplexia remains obscure. Electroencephalographic studies were consistently normal. The response to and tolerance of benzodiazepines are striking in newborns and infants and suggest an aberrant central nervous system reflex as the etiology; therefore, hyperekplexia should be considered in the evaluation of neonates and infants with apnea, aspiration pneumonia, episodic muscular rigidity, hyperexcitability, and near-miss sudden infant death syndrome. The need for immediate monitoring of at-risk infants, observation for signs of hyperekplexia, and initiation of clonazepam in these patients are emphasized. Hyperekplexic startle response to nose tapping should be included in the routine examination of all newborns.