The role of developmental toxicity studies in acute exposure assessments: Analysis of single-day vs. multiple-day exposure regimens

In accordance with most toxicity guidelines, developmental studies typically utilize repeated exposures, usually throughout gestation or during organogenesis in particular. However, it is known that developmental toxicity may occur in response to single exposures, especially during specific windows of susceptibility. An overview of the available literature gave sufficient evidence that for many agents, the same endpoints observed in repeated dose, multiple-day studies were also observed in single-day exposures, thus indicating the relevance of developmental toxicity to health assessments of acute exposures. Further, results of benchmark dose modeling of developmental endpoints indicated that for embryo lethality, single-day exposures required a two- to fourfold higher dose than the multiple-day exposures to produce the same level of response. For fused sternebrae, exposures on specific days produced equivalent levels of response at doses that were more similar to those utilized in the repeated exposures. Appreciable differences in biological half-life (and corresponding dose metrics) as well as specific windows of susceptibility may partially explain the observed multiple- vs. single-day exposure dose–response relationships. Our results highlight the need of a more thorough evaluation of outcomes from repeated dose developmental toxicity studies in regards to their importance to chronic and acute risk assessments.     

Short exposure to glyphosate induces locomotor,craniofacial, and bone disorders in zebrafish (Danio rerio) embryos

Glyphosate [N-(phosphonomethyl)glycine] is the active ingredient in widely used broad-spectrum herbicides. Even though the toxicity mechanism of this herbicide in vertebrates is poorly understood, evidence suggests that glyphosate is an endocrine disruptor capable of producing morphological anomalies as well as cardiotoxic and neurotoxic effects. We used the zebrafish model to assess the effects of early life glyphosate exposure on the development of cartilage and bone tissues and organismal responses. We found functional alterations, including a reduction in the cardiac rate, significant changes in the spontaneous tail movement pattern, and defects in craniofacial development. These effects were concomitant with alterations in the level of the estrogen receptor alpha osteopontin and bone sialoprotein. We also found that embryos exposed to glyphosate presented spine deformities as adults. These developmental alterations are likely induced by changes in protein levels related to bone and cartilage formation.     

Induced toxicity in early-life stage zebrafish (Danio rerio) and its behavioral analysis after exposure to non-doped,nitrogen-doped and nitrogen,sulfur-co doped carbon quantum dots

In this study, the effects of doping of CQDs with alternative functional groups (dopants) were evaluated through embryonic development of zebrafish (Danio rerio). The CQDs were synthesized using simple and low-cost sources: Non-doped (citric acid was used as the carbon source), nitrogen-doped (N-doped) and nitrogen, sulfur-co-doped (N,S-doped). The CQDs induced significant toxicity to zebrafish (>150 μg/mL) and the toxic effects were dose-dependent. The N,S-doped CQDs were the most toxic (LD50 = 149.92 μg/mL), followed by the N-doped CQDs (LD50 = 399.95 μg/mL) while the non-doped CQDs were the least toxic (LD50 = 548.48 μg/mL) of the three. The growth rate (GR) was affected following the toxicity pattern (GR_NS-doped<GR_N-doped<GR_non-doped <GR_blanc), which, in turn, greatly depends on the type of dopant. Morphological malformations, such as pericardial edema, yolk sac edema, tail and spinal curvature were observed to zebrafish embryos as the toxicity, concentration and exposure time to the nanomaterial increased. Behavioral analysis showed that locomotor activity increases as the toxicity of the nanomaterial rises. The differences in toxicity, growth rate and malfunctions of CQDs were attributed to their doping with different heteroatoms. The N,S-doped CQDs, unequivocally, exhibited the most pronounced effects.     

Meta-analysis of toxicity and teratogenicity of 133 chemicals from zebrafish developmental toxicity studies

Zebrafish developmental toxicity testing is an emerging field, which faces considerable challenges regarding data meta-analysis and the establishment of standardized test protocols. Here, we present an initial correlation study on toxicity of 133 chemicals based on data in the literature to ascertain predictive developmental toxicity endpoints. We found that the physical properties of chemicals (BCF or log P) did not fully predict lethality or developmental outcomes. Instead, individual outcomes such as pericardial edema and yolk sac edema were more reliable indicators of developmental toxicity. In addition, we ranked the chemicals based on toxicity with the Toxicological Priority Index (ToxPi) program and via a teratogenic ratio, and found that perfluorooctane sulfonate (PFOS) had the highest ToxPi score, triphenyltin acetate had the highest average ToxPi score (corrected for missing data and having more than 4 outcomes), and N-methyl-dithiocarbamate had the highest teratogenic ratio.     

Relative sensitivity of developmental and immune parameters in juvenile versus adult male rats after exposure to di(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate

The developing immune system displays a relatively high sensitivity as compared to both general toxicity parameters and to the adult immune system. In this study we have performed such comparisons using di(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP) as a model compound. DEHP is the most abundant phthalate in the environment and perinatal exposure to DEHP has been shown to disrupt male sexual differentiation. In addition, phthalate exposure has been associated with immune dysfunction as evidenced by effects on the expression of allergy. Male wistar rats were dosed with corn oil or DEHP by gavage from postnatal day (PND) 10-50 or PND 50-90 at doses between 1 and 1000 mg/kg/day. Androgen-dependent organ weights showed effects at lower dose levels in juvenile versus adult animals. Immune parameters affected included TDAR parameters in both age groups, NK activity in juvenile animals and TNF-α production by adherent splenocytes in adult animals. Immune parameters were affected at lower dose levels compared to developmental parameters. Overall, more immune parameters were affected in juvenile animals compared to adult animals and effects were observed at lower dose levels.The results of this study show a relatively higher sensitivity of juvenile versus adult rats. Furthermore, they illustrate the relative sensitivity of the developing immune system in juvenile animals as compared to general toxicity and developmental parameters. This study therefore provides further argumentation for performing dedicated developmental immune toxicity testing as a default in regulatory toxicology.     

吡嗪酰胺对斑马鱼胚胎发育和氧化应激效应的影响

目的 本文研究吡嗪酰胺(PZA)对斑马鱼胚胎的发育毒性及其产生机制。方法 采用受精后4h的斑马鱼胚胎进行吡嗪酰胺不同浓度的暴露,分别于暴露后24、48、72和96h进行死亡率、孵化率的统计。给药96h后进行斑马鱼幼鱼形态评分、行为学分析、活性氧簇(ROS)和氧化应激指标检测。结果 表明吡嗪酰胺显著抑制斑马鱼胚胎孵化,导致斑马鱼幼鱼发育畸形(如卵黄囊吸收迟滞、鱼鳔缺失、心包水肿和体节模糊等),同时吡嗪酰胺的暴露造成斑马鱼幼鱼运动行为能力的降低。吡嗪酰胺的暴露能够引起斑马鱼体内ROS、总超氧化物歧化酶(T-SOD)、过氧化氢酶(CAT)、谷胱甘肽(GSH)和丙二醛(MDA)水平的变化。结论 吡嗪酰胺对斑马鱼胚胎有明显的发育毒性,并呈剂量和时间依赖性,氧化应激在吡嗪酰胺发育毒性中起着重要的作用。     

Sublethal exposure to propylparaben leads to lipid metabolism impairment in zebrafish early-life stages

Parabens are widely used in cosmetics, toiletries, food and pharmaceuticals. Toxicological effects of parabens on human lipid metabolism are not well established. The present study used the early-life stages of zebrafish (Danio rerio) to determine the toxicity of propylparaben (PP). The embryos were exposed for 96 hours postfertilization (hpf) at five different concentrations of PP, and lethal and sublethal alterations were recorded daily. The lethal concentration 50 (LC₅₀) value was 3.98 mg/L. The most common sublethal alterations recorded at 1 and 2 mg/L were an enlarged and misshaped yolk sac, hyperexcitability, and reduction in head size and swim bladder. At sublethal concentrations of 1 and 2 mg/L, we observed an altered lipid metabolism, in terms of decrease in neutral lipid mobilization from yolk and alteration of phospholipid metabolism, both in the body and in the yolk sac. These observations were combined with strong head cartilage defects, indicating a strong effect of PP on head development. This research demonstrates that PP interferes with lipid utilization in zebrafish during early-life stages that might be involved in neurological and skeletal abnormalities.     

Developmental immunotoxicity in male rats after juvenile exposure to di-n-octyltin dichloride (DOTC)

To determine relevant endpoints for evaluating developmental immunotoxicity due to juvenile exposure and optimal age of the animals at assessment, a wide range of immunological parameters were assessed in a juvenile toxicity study. Rats were exposed to di-n-octyltin dichloride (DOTC) by gavage from postnatal day (PND) 10 through PND 21 and via the diet after weaning using a benchmark dose (BMD) approach. Immune assessments were performed in male rats on PNDs 21, 42, and 70 and a subset of animals was used to evaluate the T-cell dependent antibody response (TDAR) to Keyhole limpet hemocyanin. Immune effects were more pronounced on PND 21 and 42 and observed at lower doses than developmental effects. The most sensitive immune parameters affected included TDAR parameters and thymocyte subpopulations with lower confidence limits of the benchmark doses (BMDLs) below the overall no-observed-adverse-effect-level (NOAEL) for DOTC reported so far in literature. These findings illustrate the relative sensitivity of the developing immune system for DOTC, the additional value of assessing functional immune parameters, and underscore the relevance of juvenile immunotoxicity testing in view of the risk assessment of chemicals.     

Toxicological assessment of combined lead and cadmium: Acute and sub-chronic toxicity study in rats

The exposure to chemical mixtures is a common and important determinant of toxicity and receives concern for their introduction by inhalation and ingestion. However, few in vivo mixture studies have been conducted to understand the health effects of chemical mixtures compared with single chemicals. In this study, the acute and 90 day sub-chronic toxicity tests of combined Pb and Cd were conducted. In the acute toxicity test, the LD₅₀ value of Pb(NO₃)₂ and CdCl₂ mixture by the oral route was 2696.54 mg/kg by Bliss method. The sub-chronic treatment revealed that the low-dose combination of Pb and Cd exposures can significantly change the physiological and biochemical parameters of the blood of Sprague–Dawley (SD) rats with dose–response relationship and causes microcytic hypochromic anemia and the damages of liver and kidney of the SD rats to various degrees. Histopathological exams showed that the target organs of Pb and Cd were testicle, liver, and kidneys. These observations suggest that Pb and Cd are practically additive-toxic for the SD rats in oral acute toxicity studies. The lowest observed adverse-effect level in rats may be lower than a dose of 29.96 mg/(kg bw day) when administered orally for 90 consecutive days.     

Oxidative stress‐mediated developmental toxicity induced by isoniazide in zebrafish embryos and larvae

Isoniazide (INH) is an important first‐line drug that is used to treat tuberculosis. However, the effect of INH on fetal growth has not yet been elucidated, and the mechanism of INH‐induced developmental toxicity is still unknown. In the present study, we employed zebrafish embryos and larvae to investigate the developmental toxicity of INH. The survival rates of the embryos and larvae as well as the hatching rates of embryos were significantly reduced. Morphological abnormalities, including spinal curvature, yolk retention, swimming bladder absence, tail bending and shorter body lengths were induced by INH. Histopathological analysis showed loose cell‐to‐cell contacts and large vacuoles in the larval hepatocytes. Thin intestinal walls, frayed gut villi and widespread cell lysis were observed in the intestines of the larvae in the higher concentration (8, 16 mm ) exposure groups. In addition, exposure to high doses (≥ 6 mm ) of INH significantly reduced the locomotor capacity of the zebrafish larvae. INH significantly increased the levels of reactive oxygen species and malondialdehyde and decreased the superoxide dismutase activity in zebrafish larvae, which suggested that oxidative stress was induced and that the antioxidant capacity was inhibited. Superoxide dismutase 1 and liver fatty acid‐binding protein mRNA levels were significantly downregulated, while the GSTP2 and cytochrome P450 3A mRNA levels were significantly upregulated in the INH‐exposed zebrafish larvae. The overall results indicated that INH caused a dose‐ and time‐dependent increase in developmental toxicity and that oxidative stress played an important role in the developmental toxicity induced by INH in zebrafish larvae. Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Ethanol- and acetaldehyde-mediated developmental toxicity in zebrafish

Ethanol is a well-established developmental toxicant; however, the mechanism(s) of this toxicity remains unclear. Zebrafish are becoming an important model system for the evaluation of chemical and drug toxicity. In this study, zebrafish embryos were utilized to compare the developmental toxicity resulting from either ethanol or acetaldehyde exposure. Embryos were exposed to waterborne ethanol concentrations for various lengths of time but encompassed the earliest stages of embryogenesis. The waterborne ethanol concentration that causes 50% mortality (LC₅₀) following a 45-h ethanol exposure was approximately 340 mM (1.98% v/v). A number of reproducible endpoints resulted from ethanol exposure and included pericardial edema, yolk sac edema, axial malformations, otolith defects, delayed development, and axial blistering. When the exposure period was reduced, similar signs of toxicity were produced at nearly identical ethanol concentrations. To estimate the embryonic dose following a given waterborne ethanol concentration, a kinetic alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) assay was adapted. The average embryonic ethanol dose was calculated to be a fraction of the waterborne concentration. Embryos exposed to waterborne acetaldehyde resulted in similar, but not identical, endpoints as those induced by ethanol. Embryos were however, almost three orders of magnitude more sensitive to acetaldehyde than to ethanol. Ethanol and acetaldehyde both negatively impact embryonic development; however, ethanol is more teratogenic based on teratogenic indices (TIs). These results demonstrate that the zebrafish model will provide an opportunity to further evaluate the mechanism of action of ethanol on vertebrate development.     

The Threshold of Toxicological Concern for prenatal developmental toxicity in rats and rabbits

The Threshold Toxicological Concern (TTC) is based on the concept that in absence of experimental data reasonable assurance of safety can be given if exposure is sufficiently low.Using the REACH database the low 5th percentile of the NO(A)EL distribution, for prenatal developmental toxicity (OECD guideline 414) was determined. For rats, (434 NO(A)ELs values) for maternal toxicity, this value was 10 mg/kg-bw/day. For developmental toxicity (469 NO(A)ELs): 13 mg/kg-bw/day. For rabbits, (100 NO(A)ELs), the value for maternal toxicity was 4 mg/kg-bw/day, for developmental toxicity, (112 NO(A)EL values): 10 mg/kg-bw/day. The maternal organism may thus be slightly more sensitive than the fetus. Combining REACH- (industrial chemicals) and published BASF-data (mostly agrochemicals), 537 unique compounds with NO(A)EL values for developmental toxicity in rats and 150 in rabbits were evaluated. The low 5th percentile NO(A)EL for developmental toxicity in rats was 10 mg/kg-bw/day and 9.5 mg/kg-bw/day for rabbits. Using an assessment factor of 100, a TTC value for developmental toxicity of 100 μg/kg-bw/day for rats and 95 μg/kg-bw/day for rabbits is calculated. These values could serve as guidance whether or not to perform an animal experiment, if exposure is sufficiently low. In emergency situations this value may be useful for a first tier risk assessment.     

Developmental toxicity and alteration of gene expression in zebrafish embryos exposed to PFOS

Perfluorooctanesulfonate (PFOS) is a persistent organic pollutant, the potential toxicity of which is causing great concern. In the present study, we employed zebrafish embryos to investigate the developmental toxicity of this compound. Four-hour post-fertilization (hpf) zebrafish embryos were exposed to 0.1, 0.5, 1, 3 and 5 mg/L PFOS. Hatching was delayed and hatching rates as well as larval survivorship were significantly reduced after the embryos were exposed to 1, 3 and 5 mg/L PFOS until 132 hpf. The fry displayed gross developmental malformations, including epiboly deformities, hypopigmentation, yolk sac edema, tail and heart malformations and spinal curvature upon exposure to PFOS concentrations of 1 mg/L or greater. Growth (body length) was significantly reduced in the 3 and 5 mg/L PFOS-treated groups. To test whether developmental malformation was mediated via apoptosis, flow cytometry analysis of DNA content, acridine orange staining and TUNEL assay was used. These techniques indicated that more apoptotic cells were present in the PFOS-treated embryos than in the control embryos. Certain genes related to cell apoptosis, p53 and Bax, were both significantly up-regulated upon exposure to all the concentrations tested. In addition, we investigated the effects of PFOS on marker genes related to early thyroid development (hhex and pax8) and genes regulating the balance of androgens and estrogens (cyp19a and cyp19b). For thyroid development, the expression of hhex was significantly up-regulated at all concentrations tested, whereas pax8 expression was significantly up-regulated only upon exposure to lower concentrations of PFOS (0.1, 0.5, 1 mg/L). The expression of cyp19a and of cyp19b was significantly down-regulated at all exposure concentrations. The overall results indicated that zebrafish embryos constitute a reliable model for testing the developmental toxicity of PFOS, and the gene expression patterns in the embryos were able to reveal some potential mechanisms of developmental toxicity.     

Toxicological evaluation of peroxy sulfonated oleic acid (PSOA) in subacute and developmental toxicity studies

Peroxy sulfonated oleic acid (PSOA) is a new coupler used in sanitizing solutions primarily for the food and beverage industry. The toxicity of PSOA was evaluated in a 28-day repeat dose study according to OECD 407 guidelines with a 14-day recovery period and a developmental toxicity study according to OECD 414 guidelines. In both studies, PSOA was administered once daily via gavage at 0, 5, 15 and 50 mg/kg/day to Sprague–Dawley rats. Due to its corrosive properties, the highest test concentration was restricted to 0.5%. No findings related to PSOA administration were observed for the 28-day repeat-dose study and the NOEL is 50 mg/kg/day. Additionally, no impairment of the mucous membranes of the gastrointestinal tract was observed up to 0.5%, which is considered the NOEC in terms of local toxicity. For the developmental study, an embryo-fetal NOEL of 50 mg/kg/day was identified and the maternal NOEL is considered to be 15 mg/kg/day, based on slight reductions in maternal body weight and food consumption, as well as a modest increase in the incidence of clinical observations at the high dose. These findings demonstrate that PSOA appears to have minimal potential to induce toxicity associated with repeat-dose or developmental exposures.     

A category approach to predicting the developmental (neuro) toxicity of organotin compounds: The value of the zebrafish (Danio rerio) embryotoxicity test (ZET)

Zebrafish embryos were exposed to different organotin compounds during very early development (<100 h post fertilization). Morphology, histopathology and swimming activity (in a motor activity test) were the endpoints analyzed. DBTC was, by far, the most embryotoxic compound at all time points and endpoints studied. In fact, we observed a clear concordance between the effects observed in our zebrafish embryo model, and those observed with these compounds in full rodent in vivo studies. All organotin compounds classified as developmental (neuro) toxicants in vivo, were correctly classified in the present assay. Together, our results support the ZET model as a valuable tool for providing biological verification for a grouping and a read-across approach to developmental (neuro) toxicity.     

Quantitative GFP fluorescence as an indicator of arsenite developmental toxicity in mosaic heat shock protein 70 transgenic zebrafish

In transgenic zebrafish (Danio rerio), green fluorescent protein (GFP) is a promising marker for environmental pollutants. In using GFP, one of the obstacles which we faced was how to compare toxicity among different toxicants or among a specific toxicant in different model species with the intensity of GFP expression. Using a fluorescence detection method, we first validated our method for estimating the amount of GFP fluorescence present in transgenic fish, which we used as an indicator of developmental toxicity caused by the well-known toxicant, arsenite. To this end, we developed mosaic transgenic zebrafish with the human heat shock response element (HSE) fused to the enhanced GFP (EGFP) reporter gene to indicate exposure to arsenite. We confirmed that EGFP expression sites correlate with gross morphological disruption caused by arsenite exposure. Arsenite (300.0 microM) caused stronger EGFP fluorescence intensity and quantity than 50.0 microM and 10.0 microM arsenite in our transgenic zebrafish. Furthermore, arsenite-induced apoptosis was demonstrated by TUNEL assay. Apoptosis was inhibited by the antioxidant, N-acetyl-cystein (NAC) in this transgenic zebrafish. The distribution of TUNEL-positive cells in embryonic tissues was correlated with the sites of arsenite toxicity and EGFP expression. The EGFP values quantified using the standard curve equation from the known GFP quantity were consistent with the arsenite-induced EGFP expression pattern and arsenite concentration, indicating that this technique can be a reliable and applicable measurement. In conclusion, we propose that fluorescence-based EGFP quantification in transgenic fish containing the hsp70 promoter-EGFP reporter-gene construct is a useful indicator of development toxicity caused by arsenite.     

Brief embryonic cadmium exposure induces a stress response and cell death in the developing olfactory system followed by long-term olfactory deficits in juvenile zebrafish

The toxic effects of cadmium and other metals have been well established. A primary target of these metals is known to be the olfactory system, and fish exposed to a number of different waterborne metals display deficiencies in olfaction. Importantly, exposure over embryonic/larval development periods can cause deficits in chemosensory function in juvenile fish, but the specific cell types affected are unknown. We have previously characterized a transgenic zebrafish strain expressing the green fluorescent protein (eGFP) gene linked to the hsp70 gene promoter, and shown it to be a useful tool for examining cell-specific toxicity in living embryos and larvae. Here we show that the hsp70/eGFP transgene is strongly and specifically upregulated within the olfactory sensory neurons (OSNs) of transgenic zebrafish larvae following a brief 3-h exposure to water-borne cadmium. This molecular response was closely correlated to an endpoint for tissue damage within the olfactory placode, namely cell death. Furthermore, cadmium-induced olfactory cytotoxicity in zebrafish larvae gives rise to more permanent effects. Juvenile zebrafish briefly exposed to cadmium during early larval development display deficits in olfactory-dependent predator avoidance behaviors 4-6 weeks after a return to clean water. Lateral line neuromasts of exposed zebrafish larvae also activate both the endogenous hsp70 gene and the hsp70/eGFP transgene. The data reveal that even a very brief exposure period that gives rise to cell death within the developing olfactory placode results in long-term deficits in olfaction, and that hsp70/eGFP may serve as an effective indicator of sublethal cadmium exposure in sensory cells.