Perceptions and experiences of health care seeking and access to TB care--a qualitative study in rural Jiangsu Province, China

This study aims to obtain an in-depth understanding of factors that influence the health seeking behavior of TB patients, and access to tuberculosis (TB) care in counties with or without National TB Control Program (NTP) in rural China. Sixteen focus group discussions (FGDs) composed of TB patients and health care providers were held. Content analysis showed perceptions that financial difficulties influence health care-seeking behavior of TB patients in both program and non-program counties. Female and elderly patients were perceived to be more reluctant to seek health care and to seek care for cough from village health stations rather than general hospitals. Many TB patients said they could not afford the cost of TB care, even where services were subsidized. Fee-for-service incentives of health care providers and their ability to make a correct TB diagnosis were also perceived to influence patient access to TB care. Inappropriate treatment of cough patients was perceived to increase the risk of missing smear-positive diagnoses.     

Rural-Urban Differences in Stigma and the Use of Care for Depressive Disorders

Stigma may be a particularly important barrier to mental health care in rural communities where lack of anonymity increases the probability that someone who seeks care will be labeled "crazy." This study examined rural-urban differences in the stigma associated with depressive symptoms and the stigma associated with seeking treatment for depressive disorders. In addition, the study compared how the stigma associated with seeking treatment predicted use of care in rural and urban residents with a history of depressive symptoms. Two hundred subjects from metropolitan and adjacent non-metropolitan counties rated one of four randomly selected vignettes using 14-point semantic differential scales. The findings indicated that rural residents with a history of depressive symptoms labeled people who sought professional help for the disorder somewhat more negatively than their urban counterparts. Logistic models controlling for sociodemographic characteristics demonstrated that the more negative the labeling, the less likely depressed rural residents were to have sought professional help. Labeling was not associated with use of care among urban people with depressive symptoms. We concluded that prospective studies are warranted to inform the development of interventions to decrease the stigma associated with seeking treatment for depressive disorders in rural communities.     

Multiple perspectives on diagnosis delay for tuberculosis from key stakeholders in poor rural China: case study in four provinces

This study aims to understand the contextual barriers to accessing timely TB diagnosis after first seeking care, especially among the poor and vulnerable in rural China. Both quantitative and qualitative methods were used to elicit the experiences and perspectives of TB patients and suspected TB patients, community residents, health providers and policy makers in poor, rural areas of four provinces. Between 30 and 60% of patients across the four provinces experienced a delay in receiving a diagnosis after first seeking care. Most patients had to visit health facilities more than once before diagnosis, with 17-30% patients making more than 6 visits. These delays and multiple visits mainly occurred because of the limited capacity of health providers to recognize TB, and financial disincentives to refer patients to TB dispensaries, due to the pressures of the cost recovery system. Poverty and socio-economic disadvantage amongst patients also influenced their capability to seek further care to obtain a reliable diagnosis. Qualitative data showed that women and the elderly patients were likely to experience more 'system' delay, and these findings were to some extent supported by the survey. The study concludes that 'system' delay is a serious problem, which is influenced by the financing mechanisms for both TB control and general health services as well as poverty and disadvantage amongst patients. This requires a comprehensive strategy to shorten 'system' delay in order to enable successful DOTS expansion, including developing appropriate financing mechanisms to improve general provider capacity and encourage referral, as well as measures to improve financial and social access to services for potential TB patients.     

性别与社区潜在结核病患者就医行为的关系

目的探讨咳嗽满3周的潜在结核病患者就医行为和获得结核病诊疗服务可及性方面的性别差异。方法以结核病控制项目地区的湖北省当阳市为现场,通过随机整群抽样,对从18个村27458名14岁以上常住居民中识别的262例持续咳嗽或咳痰满3周的潜在结核病患者进行问卷调查和胸透及痰涂片检查,胸透异常者给予X线摄片检查。结果调查共发现262例(9.5‰)咳嗽满3周的潜在结核病患者,其中男性174例(12.5‰),女性88例(6.5‰)。虽然女性就诊率(59.1%)高于男性就诊率(37.9%)(P=0.001),但于男性相比女性更倾向于选择药房、村卫生室等质量较低的医疗机构。118例有就诊经历的患者中4例接受了痰涂片检查,均为男性。结论社区女性潜在结核病患者比男性更倾向寻求医疗服务,但医疗服务质量不如男性。男女患者获得结核病诊疗服务可及性均不高。     

Pilot study to develop a rapid assessment of tuberculosis care-seeking and adherence practices in rural Limpopo Province, South Africa

Studies of factors influencing tuberculosis (TB) care-seeking and treatment adherence in high TB/HIV co-burden African countries have typically surveyed urban patients' sociodemographic characteristics. To understand community perceptions and guide rapid assessment interviews, we interviewed key informants (nurses, tribal leaders, n = 9) and local researchers (n = 3) in poor, rural areas of South Africa. HIV-related stigma and misperceptions about TB causes and symptoms were cited as barriers. Key informants said older people preferred traditional healers; local researchers heard a preference for "western" care and suggested supporting clinic staff travel to remote villages with health education and diagnostic services. Key informants said not understanding the consequences of incomplete treatment and reluctance to relinquish disability grants decreased adherence. All reported that nonfamily DOTS supporters provided invaluable support. Rapid assessment should include drop-outs, re-treated, and co-infected patients and ask questions examining origins of misperceptions, stigma of testing, and pre-test messages to improve community perceptions about TB care-seeking and treatment adherence.     

Gender and community views of stigma and tuberculosis in rural Maharashtra, India

Stigma associated with tuberculosis (TB) is often regarded as a barrier to health seeking and a cause of social suffering. Stigma studies are typically patient-centred, and less is known about the views of communities where patients reside. This study examined community perceptions of TB-related stigma. A total of 160 respondents (80 men and 80 women) without TB in the general population of Western Maharashtra, India, were interviewed using Explanatory Model Interview Catalogue interviews with same-sex and cross-sex vignettes depicting a person with typical features of TB. The study clarified features of TB-related stigma. Concealment of disease was explained as fear of losing social status, marital problems and hurtful behaviour by the community. For the female vignette, heredity was perceived as a cause for stigmatising behaviour. Marital problems were anticipated more for the male vignette. Anticipation of spouse support, however, was more definite for men and conditional for women, indicating the vulnerability of women. Community views acknowledged that both men and women with TB share a psychological burden of unfulfilled social responsibilities. The distinction between public health risks of infection and unjustified social isolation (stigma) was ambiguous. Such a distinction is important for effective community-based interventions for early diagnosis of TB and successful treatment.     

Gender and community views of stigma and tuberculosis in rural Maharashtra,India

Abstract

Stigma associated with tuberculosis (TB) is often regarded as a barrier to health seeking and a cause of social suffering. Stigma studies are typically patient-centred, and less is known about the views of communities where patients reside. This study examined community perceptions of TB-related stigma. A total of 160 respondents (80 men and 80 women) without TB in the general population of Western Maharashtra, India, were interviewed using Explanatory Model Interview Catalogue interviews with same-sex and cross-sex vignettes depicting a person with typical features of TB. The study clarified features of TB-related stigma. Concealment of disease was explained as fear of losing social status, marital problems and hurtful behaviour by the community. For the female vignette, heredity was perceived as a cause for stigmatising behaviour. Marital problems were anticipated more for the male vignette. Anticipation of spouse support, however, was more definite for men and conditional for women, indicating the vulnerability of women. Community views acknowledged that both men and women with TB share a psychological burden of unfulfilled social responsibilities. The distinction between public health risks of infection and unjustified social isolation (stigma) was ambiguous. Such a distinction is important for effective community-based interventions for early diagnosis of TB and successful treatment.     

It's enough to make you sick: the impact of racism on the health of Aboriginal Australians

BACKGROUND: Experience of interpersonal racism has been neglected as a mechanism by which inequalities between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal people are created and maintained. METHODS: Cross-sectional survey of randomly selected residents of a rural Australian town (n=639). Interpersonal racism was measured by two questions on experiences in the past four weeks of negative racially based treatment that evoked an emotional or physical response. Health was measured with the mental and physical health component scores of the Short-Form 12 and self-reported fair or poor general health. Linear and logistic regressions modelled the effects of interpersonal racism on health, controlling for age, sex, socio-economic status and Aboriginality. FINDINGS: The 183 Aboriginal respondents had lower health component scores, were more than twice as likely to report fair-to-poor general health (34% compared with 17%, p<0.001), and 2.6 to 5.0 times more likely to report negative racially based treatment. Demographic and socio-economic characteristics were not associated with reporting negative racially based treatment. After controlling for other variables, Aboriginal respondents who reported negative treatment were more likely to have poor health on all three measures. Non-Aboriginal respondents who reported experiencing negative treatment had lower mental health component scores. IMPLICATIONS: Experiencing racist treatment should be recognised as a social determinant of health. Improved health care and other initiatives may not eliminate health inequalities in the absence of fundamental changes in how non-Aboriginal people behave towards Aboriginal people.     

江苏省扬中市社区慢性咳嗽患者结核病医疗服务可及性及其影响因素研究

目的探讨慢性咳嗽满3周的潜在结核病患者结核病医疗服务可及性及其社会经济和人口学影响因素。方法以非直接督导下的短程治疗策略(Directly observed treatment short-course,DOTS)结核病控制项目地区的江苏省扬中市为现场,通过随机整群抽样,对从20个村33549名14岁以上常住居民中识别的171例持续咳嗽和/或咳痰满3周的潜在结核病患者进行问卷调查和胸透及痰涂片检查。结果33%的对象从未就诊,其估计的就诊延误中位数为67(51~93)天,远大于已就诊者的首诊延误10(4~31)天和正式就诊延误中位数15(5~31)天(P=0·000)。无医疗保险者就诊及正式就诊的可能性仅为有医疗保险者的42·2%,且发生就诊延误和正式就诊延误的可能性较高;男性就诊的可能性比女性小;农民及距离医疗机构较远者就诊延误的可能性大。结论非结核病控制项目地区慢性咳嗽患者结核病医疗可及性较弱,有可能影响结核病的人群发现率,不健全的医疗保险制度是其重要的制约因素。     

TB Perspectives among a Sample of Mexicans in the United States: Results from an Ethnographic Study

OBJECTIVE: A study was conducted to describe the sociocultural aspects of tuberculosis (TB) among Mexicans in the U.S. and to provide TB programs with practical recommendations for serving this population. METHODS: In-depth, structured, open-ended interviews were conducted with 50 persons from Mexico living in the U.S. Local bilingual, bicultural researchers conducted the interviews with respondents recruited from TB clinics and surrounding communities. Both qualitative and quantitative strategies were used to analyze the data. RESULTS: We found diverse TB perceptions and attitudes, but few were associated with specific participant characteristics. We detected widespread misperceptions about TB transmission and low perceptions of risk. Anticipated TB stigma among those with no history of disease was qualitatively greater than reported stigma among those who had TB disease. We also detected missed opportunities for TB education. Reported barriers to care included lack of transportation, limited clinic hours, cost of services, inconvenient clinic location, and communication problems with staff. CONCLUSIONS: To address the diverse needs of Mexican-born clients, we recommend that TB programs provide culturally-appropriate, patient-centered care. We suggest several strategies aimed at raising risk awareness and reducing stigma. Finally, we encourage programs to facilitate access by providing language-appropriate services, extending clinic hours, and facilitating transportation.     

Healthcare Seeking Behavior for Back and Joint Pain in Rural Gadchiroli,India: A Population-Based Cross-Sectional Study

Background:

Musculoskeletal back and joint pain is common in rural agrarian communities in India.

Objectives:

To understand the healthcare seeking behavior for back and joint pain among adults in rural Gadchiroli, India.

Materials and Methods:

A cross-sectional survey of 315 randomly selected respondents from 84 villages between 30 and 60 years of age was conducted by community health workers (CHWs) between October 2010 and January 2011.

Results:

Among 280 respondents on whom good quality data were available, 215 (76.8%) respondents had back and/or joint pain in 6 months preceding the survey. A majority of the respondents with pain had sought care (170; 79.1%), mainly from private practitioners (116; 68.2%). Severe pain and inability to work were the reasons to seek care. Complete pain relief was considered the major indicator of an effective treatment. Injectable medications (127; 59.1%) and intravenous fluids (92; 42.8%) were considered highly effective; while about 50% were unaware of the role of physiotherapy and surgery for this problem. When asked about the preferred provider who should provide village level treatment of this problem, more than half (135; 62.8%) of the respondents chose a trained village health worker.

Conclusions:

A majority of the individuals with back and/or joint pain in rural Gadchiroli seek care, mainly from private practitioners. However, for the village-level treatment of this problem, respondents preferred a trained village level worker. High expectation of complete pain relief, preference for injectable medications, and low awareness about nonpharmacological modalities will be the major challenges while providing community level care for this problem.     

Low-income rural women and depression: factors associated with self-reporting

OBJECTIVE: To examine factors associated with self-reporting depression for low-income rural women experiencing depressive symptoms. METHODS: Data were from 219 Rural Families Speak participants with CES-D scores >15. Chi-square and multiple logistic regression were utilized. RESULTS: Just over one half (52.5%) of respondents who were experiencing depressive symptoms self-reported depression, whereas 47.5% of respondents self-reported no depression. Women reporting depression were significantly likelier to report physical health problems, injury/illness, and more frequent physician visits. Women reporting no depression were significantly likelier to have been pregnant in the previous 3 years. CONCLUSIONS: Women reporting depression had more health care system exposure and perhaps depressive symptomotology knowledge. Public health campaigns should educate about depressive symptoms, including postpartum depression, to reduce stigma and increase treatment-seeking.     

Factors affecting delays in tuberculosis diagnosis in rural China: a case study in four counties in Shandong Province

Improving case detection is an urgent and serious challenge for tuberculosis (TB) control in China. We investigated the extent to which TB patients delayed seeking TB care and health services delayed reaching a diagnosis, and socio-economic factors associated with the delays. Standard questionnaires were administered to 190 new smear-positive TB patients who had completed treatment at TB dispensaries in four counties of Shandong Province in 2001. Multivariate analysis using Cox Regression showed that old age, lack of education and distance from home to a township health centre were significantly associated with delay in seeking care from service providers. In examining the delay between first contact with a service provider and diagnosis, we found that women experienced longer delays than men, and that the higher the level of facility patients first visited, the less time was needed to achieve a diagnosis. These two factors were statistically significant in multivariate Cox Regression analysis. We concluded that the elderly, the less educated, women, and those living far from health facilities face the longest delays in reaching TB services and achieving diagnosis.     

Turning liabilities into resources: informal village doctors and tuberculosis control in Bangladesh

In 1998, the Damien Foundation Bangladesh invited semi-qualified, private "gram dakter" (Bangla for "village doctors") to participate in tuberculosis (TB) programmes in a population of 26 million people in rural Bangladesh. The organization trained 12 525 village doctors to not only refer suspected TB cases for free diagnosis but also to provide directly observed treatment (DOT) free of charge. Source of referral and place of DOT was recorded as part of the standardized TB recording and reporting system, which enabled us to quantify the contribution of village doctors to case detection rates and also allowed disaggregated cohort analysis of treatment outcome. During 2002 and 2003, 11% of all TB cases with positive sputum smears in the study area had been referred by village doctors; the rate of positive tests in patients referred by village doctors was 14.4%. 18 792 patients received DOT from village doctors, accounting for between 20% and 45% of patients on treatment during the 1998-2003 period. The treatment success rate was about 90% throughout the period. Urine samples taken during random checks of treatment compliance were positive for isoniazid in 98% of patients treated by village doctors. Within the framework of Public-Private Mix DOTS, services provided by semi-qualified private health care providers are a feasible and effective way to improve access to affordable high quality TB treatment in poor rural populations. The large informal health workforce that exists in resource poor countries can be used to achieve public health goals. Involvement of village doctors in TB control has now become national policy in Bangladesh.     

A lost cause? Extending verbal autopsy to investigate biomedical and socio-cultural causes of maternal death in Burkina Faso and Indonesia

Maternal mortality in developing countries is characterised by disadvantage and exclusion. Women who die whilst pregnant are typically poor and live in low-income and rural settings where access to quality care is constrained and where deaths, within and outside hospitals, often go unrecorded and unexamined. Verbal autopsy (VA) is an established method of determining cause(s) of death for people who die outside health facilities or without proper registration. This study extended VA to investigate socio-cultural factors relevant to outcomes. Interviews were conducted with relatives of 104 women who died during pregnancy, childbirth or postpartum in two rural districts in Indonesia and for 70 women in a rural district in Burkina Faso. Information was collected on medical signs and symptoms of the women prior to death and an extended section collected accounts of care pathways and opinions on preventability and cause of death. Illustrative quantitative and qualitative analyses were performed and the implications for health surveillance and planning were considered. The cause of death profiles were similar in both settings with infectious diseases, haemorrhage and malaria accounting for half the deaths. In both settings, delays in seeking, reaching and receiving care were reported by more than two-thirds of respondents. Relatives also provided information on their experiences of the emergencies revealing culturally-derived systems of explanation, causation and behaviour. Comparison of the qualitative and quantitative results suggested that the quantified delays may have been underestimated. The analysis suggests that broader empirical frameworks can inform more complete health planning by situating medical conditions within the socio-economic and cultural landscapes in which healthcare is situated and sought. Utilising local knowledge, extended VA has potential to inform the relative prioritisation of interventions that improve technical aspects of life-saving services with those that address the conditions that underlie health, for those whom services typically fail to reach.     

Health service providers' perceptions of barriers to tuberculosis care in Russia

The Russian Federation has witnessed a marked rise in rates of tuberculosis (TB) over the past decade. Public health TB control institutions remain broadly modelled along pre-1990 lines despite substantial programmes of investment and advocacy in implementing the World Health Organization's 'Directly Observed Treatment--short course' (DOTS) strategy. In 2002, we undertook a qualitative study to explore health care providers' perceptions of existing barriers to access to TB services in Samara Oblast in Russia. Six focus group discussions were conducted with physicians and nurses from facilities in urban and rural areas. Data were analyzed using a framework approach for applied policy research. Barriers to access to care were identified in interconnected areas: barriers associated with the health care system, care process barriers, barriers related to wider contextual issues, and barriers associated with patients' personal characteristics and behaviour. In the health care system, insufficient funding was identified as an underlying problem resulting in a decrease in screening coverage, low salaries, staff shortages, irregularities in drug supplies and outdated infrastructure. Suboptimal collaboration with general health services and social services limits opportunities for care and social support to patients. Worsening socioeconomic conditions were seen both as a cause of TB and a major obstacle to access to care. Behavioural characteristics were identified as an important barrier to effective care and treatment, and health staff favoured compulsory treatment for 'noncompliant' patients and involvement of the police in defaulter tracing. TB was profoundly associated with stigma and this resulted in delays in accessing care and barriers to ensuring treatment success.     

Social franchising of TB care through private GPs in Myanmar: an assessment of treatment results, access, equity and financial protection

This article assesses whether social franchising of tuberculosis (TB) services in Myanmar has succeeded in providing quality treatment while ensuring equity in access and financial protection for poor patients. Newly diagnosed TB patients receiving treatment from private general practitioners (GPs) belonging to the franchise were identified. They were interviewed about social conditions, health seeking and health care costs at the time of starting treatment and again after 6 months follow-up. Routine data were used to ascertain clinical outcomes as well as to monitor trends in case notification. The franchisees contributed 2097 (21%) of the total 9951 total new sputum smear-positive pulmonary cases notified to the national TB programme in the study townships. The treatment success rate for new smear-positive cases was 84%, close to the World Health Organization target of 85% and similar to the treatment success of 81% in the national TB programme in Myanmar. People from the lower socio-economic groups represented 68% of the TB patients who access care in the franchise. Financial burden related to direct and indirect health care costs for tuberculosis was high, especially among the poor. Patients belonging to lower socio-economic groups incurred on average costs equivalent to 68% of annual per capita household income, with a median of 28%. However, 83% of all costs were incurred before starting treatment in the franchise, while 'shopping' for care. During treatment in the franchise, the cost of care was relatively low, corresponding to a median proportion of annual per capita income of 3% for people from lower socio-economic groups. This study shows that highly subsidized TB care delivered through a social franchise scheme in the private sector in Myanmar helped reach the poor with quality services, while partly protecting them from high health care expenditure. Extended outreach to others parts of the private sector may reduce diagnostic delay and patient costs further.     

青海省农牧区乡村卫生服务一体化管理的实践研究

随着社会经济发展和医药卫生改革的逐步深化,人民群众的医疗卫生需求得到了进一步释放,面向基层的卫生资源下沉和医疗保健关口前移,使原有的乡村卫生管理体制机制已远远不能满足日益增长的基层卫生服务的要求。为应对挑战,研究者通过构建符合当地社会经济发展水平和卫生服务现状的乡村卫生服务一体化适宜模式,以破解困扰青海省基层卫生发展的难题,提高青海省农牧区乡、村两级医疗卫生机构的服务能力,促进农牧民对基层卫生服务的利用,从而提高农牧民健康水平。     

The Role of Stigma in Access to Health Care for the Poor

Context

The Affordable Care Act provides new Medicaid coverage to an estimated 12 million low-income adults. Barriers to access or quality could hamper the program''s success. One of these barriers might be the stigma associated with Medicaid or poverty.

Methods

Our mixed-methods study involved 574 low-income adults and included data from an in-person survey and follow-up interviews. Our analysis of the interviews showed that many participants who were on Medicaid or uninsured described a perception or fear of being treated poorly in the health care setting. We defined this experience as stigma and merged our qualitative interviews coded for stigma with our quantitative survey data to see whether stigma was related to other sociodemographic characteristics. We also examined whether stigma was associated with access to care, quality of care, and self-reported health.

Findings

We were unable to identify other sociodemographic characteristics associated with stigma in this low-income sample. The qualitative interviews suggested that stigma was most often the result of a provider-patient interaction that felt demeaning, rather than an internalized sense of shame related to receiving public insurance or charity care. An experience of stigma was associated with unmet health needs, poorer perceptions of quality of care, and worse health across several self-reported measures.

Conclusions

Because a stigmatizing experience in the health system might interfere with the delivery of high-quality care to new Medicaid enrollees, further research and policy interventions that target stigma are warranted.     

“Their place is beyond the town's border”: A qualitative exploration of stigma associated with tuberculosis in rural and urban areas of Lagos,Nigeria

Tuberculosis (TB) remains a major public health challenge in Nigeria with a minimum yield of various TB control efforts due to sociocultural determinants of health including TB-associated stigma. Therefore, to achieve the Sustainable Development Goal targets for TB control, an understanding and reduction in TB-associated stigma is necessary. The study aims to explore the perspective of community members and investigate the possible ways of mitigating TB-associated stigma in rural and urban areas in Lagos State, Nigeria. Eight focus group discussions (FGD) were conducted among eight homogenous groups of participants living in the community in rural and urban areas of Lagos state who were stratified by gender, between July and November 2017. Analysis of data was done using the modified grounded theory. A total of 86 participants took part in the FGDs. There were various stigmatising behaviours towards people infected with TB in rural and urban communities studied. This includes: Not willing to eat with people suffering from TB, withdrawal from TB patients in social gatherings, verbal abuse of TB patients and refusing to visit their houses because of their illness. There were also misconceptions about the cause of TB in our study which includes spiritual attack, ingestion of cat hair and inhalation of dust. However, participants in the study believed that mitigating the effect of TB-associated stigma will require adequate community education on TB, provision of financial and emotional support to the patients, as well as the involvement of community leaders in TB control activities and stigma reduction interventions. TB-associated stigma exists in rural and urban communities, with a lack of appropriate knowledge of TB and fear of infection as a major determinant in rural and urban areas respectively. Health education and sensitisation about TB, with community leaders as champions could help to mitigate the effect of TB-associated stigma.