A case for cannabidiol in Wolf–Hirschhorn syndrome seizure management

Complex, and sometimes intractable, seizures affect the quality of life and cognitive development of over 90% of individuals with Wolf–Hirschhorn syndrome (WHS). Fine resolution genotype–phenotype mapping of the WHS locus recently identified a candidate gene whose probable function has led to insights into a mechanism connecting WHS seizures with those of Dravet syndrome, a distinct condition caused by mutations in SCN1A and SCN1B. In addition to this possible molecular mechanistic connection, these disorders' seizures share a strikingly similar constellation of features, including clinical presentation, seizure types, early age of onset, EEG pattern, and responses to specific anti‐epileptic drugs. Based in part on these similarities, we suggest that a highly successful Phase III clinical trial of a formulation of cannabidiol for Dravet syndrome seizures may be directly translatable into possible benefits for WHS individuals with challenging seizure patterns. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

First known microdeletion within the Wolf‐Hirschhorn syndrome critical region refines genotype–phenotype correlation

Deletions within HSA band 4p16.3 cause Wolf‐Hirschhorn syndrome (WHS), which comprises mental retardation and developmental defects. A WHS critical region (WHSCR) of approximately 165 kb has been defined on the basis of 2 atypical interstitial deletions; however, genotype–phenotype correlation remains controversial, due to the large size of deletion usually involving several megabases. We report on the first known patient with a small de novo interstitial deletion restricted to the WHSCR who presented with a partial WHS phenotype consisting only of low body weight for height, speech delay, and minor facial anomalies; shortness of stature, microcephaly, seizures and mental retardation were absent. The deletion was initially demonstrated by FISH analysis, and breakpoints were narrowed with a “mini‐FISH” technique using 3–5 kb amplicons. A breakpoint‐spanning PCR assay defined the distal breakpoint as disrupting the WHSC1 gene within intron 5, exactly after an AluJb repeat. The proximal breakpoint was not found to be associated with a repeated sequence or a known gene. The deletion encompasses 191.5 kb and includes WHSC2, but not LETM1. Thus, manifestations attributable to this deletion are reduced weight for height, minor facial anomalies, ADHD and some learning and fine motor deficiencies, while seizures may be associated with deletions of LETM1. © 2001 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Genotype–phenotype correlations and clinical diagnostic criteria in Wolf‐Hirschhorn syndrome

We report on a clinical‐genetic study of 16 Wolf‐Hirschhorn syndrome (WHS) patients. Hemizygosity of 4p16.3 was detected by conventional prometaphase chromosome analysis (11 patients) or by molecular probes on apparently normal chromosomes (4 patients). One patient had normal chromosomes without a detectable molecular deletion within the WHS “critical region.” In each deleted patient, the deletion was demonstrated to be terminal by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). The proximal breakpoint of the rearrangement was established by prometaphase chromosome analysis in cases with a visible deletion. It was within the 4p16.1 band in six patients, apparently coincident with the distal half of this band in five patients. The extent of each of the four submicroscopic deletions was established by FISH analyses with a set of overlapping cosmid clones spanning the 4p16.3 region. We found ample variations in both the size of the deletions and the position of the respective breakpoints. The precise definition of the cytogenetic defect permitted an analysis of the genotype‐phenotype correlations in WHS, leading to the proposal of a set of minimal diagnostic criteria, which in turn may facilitate the selection of critical patients in the search for the gene(s) responsible for this disorder. We observed that genotype‐phenotype correlations in WHS mostly depend on the size of the deletion, a deletion of <3.5 Mb resulting in a mild phenotype, in which malformations are absent. The absence of a detectable molecular deletion is still consistent with a WHS diagnosis. Based on these observations a “minimal” WHS phenotype was inferred, the clinical manifestations of which are restricted to the typical facial appearance, mild mental and growth retardation, and congenital hypotonia. Am. J. Med. Genet. 94:254–261, 2000. © 2000 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Hip displacement in Wolf–Hirschhorn syndrome: Report on three cases and review of associated musculoskeletal pathologies

Wolf–Hirschhorn syndrome is a rare genetic disease caused by a chromosomal deletion of the distal short arm of Chromosome 4. It is associated with multisystem abnormalities, including delayed growth, characteristic facial features, epilepsy, and skeletal abnormalities. We report three patients who developed hip displacement, and describe the occurrence of delayed and nonunion in patients who underwent corrective proximal femoral osteotomy for hip displacement. We also performed a literature review identifying common musculoskeletal presentations associated with the condition. Patients with Wolf–Hirschhorn Syndrome are at risk of hip displacement (subluxation), and we would advocate annual hip surveillance in this patient group.     

A novel 4p16.3 microduplication distal to WHSC1 and WHSC2 characterized by oligonucleotide array with new phenotypic features

Larger imbalances on chromosome 4p in the form of deletions associated with Wolf-Hirschhorn syndrome (WHS) and duplications of chromosome 4p have a defined clinical phenotype. The critical region for both these clinical disorders has been narrowed based on the genotype-phenotype correlations. However, cryptic rearrangements in this region have been reported infrequently. We report on a male patient with a microduplication of chromosome 4p, who presents with findings of macrocephaly, irregular iris pigmentation-heterochromia, and preserved linear growth in addition to overlapping features of trisomy 4p such as seizures, delayed psychomotor development, and dysmorphic features including prominent glabella, low-set ears, and short neck. Using a high-density oligonucleotide microarray, we have identified a novel submicroscopic duplication involving dosage sensitive genes TACC3, FGFR3, and LETM1. The microduplication did not involve WHSC1 and WHSC2 which are considered in the critical region for WHS and trisomy 4p. This patient's presentation and genomic findings help further delineate clinical significance of re-arrangements in the 4p16 region without the involvement of WHS critical region.     

Wolf-Hirschhorn syndrome facial dysmorphic features in a patient with a terminal 4p16.3 deletion telomeric to the WHSCR and WHSCR 2 regions

We report on a patient with developmental delay and several facial characteristics reminiscent of Wolf-Hirschhorn syndrome, who carries a terminal 4p16.3 deletion of minimally 1.691 Mb and maximally 1.698 Mb. This deletion contains the FGFRL1 gene, but does not include the WHSC1 gene. Given its expression pattern and its involvement in bone and cartilage formation during embryonic development, the FGFRL1 gene represents a plausible candidate gene for part of the facial characteristics of Wolf-Hirshhorn syndrome in 4p16.3 deletion patients.     

Microduplication of 4p16.3 due to an unbalanced translocation resulting in a mild phenotype

With the widespread clinical use of comparative genomic hybridization chromosomal microarray technology, several previously unidentified clinically significant submicroscopic chromosome abnormalities have been discovered. Specifically, there have been reports of clinically significant microduplications found in regions of known microdeletion syndromes. In general, these microduplications have distinct features from those described in the corresponding microdeletion syndromes. We present a 5½‐year‐old patient with normal growth, borderline normal IQ, borderline hypertelorism, and speech and language delay who was found to have a submicroscopic 2.3 Mb terminal duplication involving the two proposed Wolf–Hirschhorn syndrome (WHS) critical regions at chromosome 4p16.3. This duplication was the result of a maternally inherited reciprocal translocation involving the breakpoints 4p16.3 and 17q25.3. Our patient's features are distinct from those described in WHS and are not as severe as those described in partial trisomy 4p. There are two other patients in the medical literature with 4p16.3 microduplications of similar size also involving the WHS critical regions. Our patient shows clinical overlap with these two patients, although overall her features are milder than what has been previously described. Our patient's features expand the knowledge of the clinical phenotype of a 4p16.3 microduplication and highlight the need for further information about it. © 2011 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

A 137‐kb deletion within the Potocki–Shaffer syndrome interval on chromosome 11p11.2 associated with developmental delay and hypotonia

Potocki–Shaffer syndrome (PSS) is a rare disorder caused by haploinsufficiency of genes located on the proximal short arm of chromosome 11 (11p11.2p12). Classic features include biparietal foramina, multiple exostoses, profound hypotonia, dysmorphic features, and developmental delay/intellectual disability. Fewer than 40 individuals with PSS have been reported, with variable clinical presentations due in part to disparity in deletion sizes. We report on a boy who presented for initial evaluation at age 13 months because of a history of developmental delay, hypotonia, subtle dysmorphic features, and neurobehavioral abnormalities. SNP microarray analysis identified a 137 kb deletion at 11p11.2, which maps within the classically defined PSS interval. This deletion results in haploinsufficiency for all or portions of six OMIM genes: SLC35C1, CRY2, MAPK8IP1, PEX16, GYLTL1B, and PHF21A. Recently, translocations interrupting PHF21A have been associated with intellectual disability and craniofacial anomalies similar to those seen in PSS. The identification of this small deletion in a child with developmental delay and hypotonia provides further evidence for the genetic basis of developmental disability and identifies a critical region sufficient to cause hypotonia in this syndrome. Additionally, this case illustrates the utility of high resolution genomic approaches in correlating clinical phenotypes with specific genes in contiguous gene deletion syndromes. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Deletions involving genes WHSC1 and LETM1 may be necessary,but are not sufficient to cause Wolf–Hirschhorn Syndrome

Wolf–Hirschhorn syndrome (WHS) is a complex genetic disorder caused by the loss of genomic material from the short arm of chromosome 4. Genotype–phenotype correlation studies indicated that the loss of genes within 4p16.3 is necessary for expression of the core features of the phenotype. Within this region, haploinsufficiency of the genes WHSC1 and LETM1 is thought to be a major contributor to the pathogenesis of WHS. We present clinical findings for three patients with relatively small (<400 kb) de novo interstitial deletions that overlap WHSC1 and LETM1. 3D facial analysis was performed for two of these patients. Based on our findings, we propose that hemizygosity of WHSC1 and LETM1 is associated with a clinical phenotype characterized by growth deficiency, feeding difficulties, and motor and speech delays. The deletion of additional genes nearby WHSC1 and LETM1 does not result in a marked increase in the severity of clinical features, arguing against their haploinsufficiency. The absence of seizures and typical WHS craniofacial findings in our cohort suggest that deletion of distinct or additional 4p16.3 genes is necessary for expression of these features. Altogether, these results show that although loss-of-function for WHSC1 and/or LETM1 contributes to some of the features of WHS, deletion of additional genes is required for the full expression of the phenotype, providing further support that WHS is a contiguous gene deletion disorder.     

Unusual chromosomal mosaicism in Wolf‐Hirschhorn syndrome: del(4)(p16)/der(4)(qter‐q31.3::pter‐qter)

We report on the unusual cytogenetic findings in a girl with moderate mental retardation and a mosaic karyotype 46,XX,del(4)(p16)/46,XX,der(4)(qter‐q31.3::pter‐qter). The facial features observed in the child initially did not suggest the diagnosis of Wolf‐Hirschhorn syndrome (WHS), but the distinct facial gestalt became obvious at prepubertal age. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis with different probes that map to 4p and 4q helped to clarify the karyotype. We discuss the mechanism of appearance of this unusual type of mosaicism, which has not been reported before. © 2001 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

"Tandem" duplication of 4p16.1p16.3 chromosome region associated with 4p16.3pter molecular deletion resulting in Wolf-Hirschhorn syndrome phenotype

Chromosome imbalance affecting the short arm of chromosome 4 results in a variety of distinct clinical conditions. Most of them share a number of manifestations, such as mental retardation, microcephaly, pre- and post-natal growth retardation, anteverted and low-set ears, that can be considered as nonspecific signs, generally attributable to gene dosage impairment. On the other hand, more distinctive phenotypic traits correlate with the segmental aneuploidy. Duplications of the distal half of 4p give rise to the partial trisomy 4 syndrome, characterized by a "boxer" nose configuration and deep-set eyes. These signs are usually observed even in cases of small terminal duplications. Haploinsufficiency of 4p16.3 results in the so-called Wolf-Hirschhorn (WH) syndrome, a contiguous gene syndrome characterized by maxillary hypoplasia, large and protruding eyes, high nasal bridge, skeletal abnormalities, and midline defects. The smallest overlapping deletion described so far as a cause of this condition is only 165 kb long, suggesting that one or a few genes in this region act as "master" regulators of different developmental pathways. A "tandem" duplication of 4p16.1p16.3 was detected in association with a subtle deletion of 4p16.3pter on the same chromosome in a patient with the WH phenotype. The 3.2 Mb deletion, spanning the genomic region from the vicinity of D4S43 to the telomere, encompasses the recently delimited "WHS critical region" [Wright et al., 1997: Hum. Mol. Genet. 6:317-324]. This unusual chromosome rearrangement resulted in WH phenotype, clinical manifestations of partial 4p trisomy being mild or absent. This observation led us to speculate that the regulatory gene/genes in the critical WH region affect the expression of other genes in a dose-dependent manner. Haploinsufficiency of this region could be more deleterious than various partial trisomies.     

Cardio–facio–cutaneous syndrome phenotype in an individual with an interstitial deletion of 12q: Identification of a candidate region for CFC syndrome

We report on a 19‐month‐old girl who presented with the phenotype of cardio–facio–cutaneous (CFC) syndrome including characteristic minor facial anomalies, cardiac defect, ectodermal anomalies, and developmental delay. Cytogenetic analysis showed the presence of an interstitial deletion of one chromosome 12, del(12)(q21.2q22), confirmed by fluorescence in situ hybridization with chromosome band specific probes. Controversy exists as to whether CFC and Noonan syndrome (NS) are distinct disorders, a contiguous gene syndrome, or allelic variants. The identification of the del(12) in this patient, in a region distinct from the putative NS locus, supports the view that CFC is a genetically distinct condition from NS. In addition, this implicates the region 12q21.2→q22 as a candidate region for the gene(s) causing CFC syndrome. Am. J. Med. Genet. 93:219–222, 2000. © 2000 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Detection and delineation of an unusual 17p11.2 deletion by array-CGH and refinement of the Smith–Magenis syndrome minimum deletion to 650 kb

Smith–Magenis syndrome (SMS) is a multiple congenital anomaly/mental retardation syndrome and it is characterized by an interstitial deletion of chromosome 17p11.2. SMS patients have a distinct phenotype which is believed to be caused by haploinsufficiency of one or more genes in the associated deleted region. Five non-deletion patients with classical phenotypic features of SMS have been reported with mutations in the retinoic acid induced 1 (RAI1) gene, located within the SMS critical interval. Happloinsufficiency of the RAI1 gene is likely to be the responsible gene for the majority of the SMS features, but other deleted genes in the SMS region may modify the overall phenotype in the patients with 17p11.2 deletions. SMS is usually diagnosed in the clinical genetic setting by FISH analysis using commercially available probes. We detected a submicroscopic deletion in 17p11.2 using array-CGH with a resolution of approximately 1 Mb in a patient with the SMS phenotype, who was not deleted for the commercially available SMS microdeletion FISH probe. Delineation of the deletion was performed using a 32K tiling BAC-array, containing 32,500 BAC clones. The deletion in this patient was size mapped to 2.7 Mb and covered the RAI1 gene. This case enabled the refinement of the SMS minimum deletion to 650 kb containing eight putative genes and one predicted gene. In addition, it demonstrates the importance to investigate deletion of RAI1 in SMS patients.