A study of corneal thickness, shape and collagen organisation in keratoconus using videokeratography and X-ray scattering techniques

In keratoconus, the cornea becomes progressively ectactic resulting in severe visual impairment. Here, we use a combination of videokeratography and synchrotron X-ray diffraction to investigate the relationship between corneal shape and thickness, and the distribution and predominant orientation of stromal fibrillar collagen in five keratoconus corneas. In all but the least advanced case, the thinning and ectasia measured in vivo using corneal videokeratography was accompanied by corresponding changes in the relative distribution and orientation of stromal collagen in the excised corneal buttons. Although the most severe case of keratoconus possessed the most pronounced stromal collagen alterations, and only a minor disruption to stromal collagen arrangement was seen in the least advanced case, a variability in the extent of stromal collagen alteration was seen between these clinical extremes. The observed abnormalities in collagen distribution and orientation are consistent with a mechanism of keratoconus progression that involves inter-fibrillar or inter-lamellar slippage causing a redistribution of tissue within the cornea.     

The use of X-ray scattering techniques to quantify the orientation and distribution of collagen in the corneal stroma

The bulk of the corneal stroma is comprised of a layered network of fibrillar collagen. Determining the architecture of this unique structure may help us to better understand the cornea's biomechanical and optical function. The analysis of diffraction patterns obtained when X-rays are passed through the regularly arranged collagen molecules and fibrils of the stromal matrix yields quantitative data on fibrillar organisation, including the orientation and distribution of collagen lamellae within the corneal plane. In recent years, by exploiting the radiation from powerful synchrotron sources, techniques have been developed to enable the mapping of collagen fibril, and therefore lamellar, directions across whole corneas. This article aims to summarise the use of X-ray diffraction to map the orientation and distribution of collagen in the corneal stroma. The implications of the knowledge gained so far are discussed in relation to the optical and biomechanical properties of the cornea, and their alteration due to disease and surgical intervention.     

Second-harmonic imaging microscopy of normal human and keratoconus cornea

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the ability of second-harmonic imaging to identify differences in corneal stromal collagen organization between normal human and keratoconus corneas. METHODS: Six normal corneas from eye bank donors and 13 corneas of patients with keratoconus, obtained after penetrating keratoplasty were examined. A femtosecond titanium-sapphire laser with 800-nm output was used to generate second-harmonic signals collected at 400 nm from central and paracentral corneal tissue blocks. Three-dimensional (3-D) data sets were collected and reconstructed to evaluate the location and orientation of stromal collagen lamellae. RESULTS: Imaging of second-harmonic signals combined with 3-D reconstruction of the normal cornea identified a high degree of lamellar interweaving, particularly in the anterior cornea. Of note was the detection of lamellae that inserted into Bowman's layer and were oriented transverse to the corneal surface, penetrating posteriorly approximately 120 mum. In keratoconus corneas, imaging second-harmonic signals identified less lamellar interweaving and a marked reduction or loss of lamellae inserting into Bowman's layer in 12 of 13 cases, particularly in regions associated with cone development without breaks in Bowman's layer or scarring. CONCLUSIONS: Compared with normal adult corneas, marked abnormalities were detected in the organization of the anterior corneal collagen lamellae of keratoconus corneas by second harmonic imaging. These structural abnormalities are consistent with the known changes in collagen organization and biomechanical strength of keratoconus.     

Imaging of birefringent properties of keratoconus corneas by polarization-sensitive optical coherence tomography

PURPOSE: To investigate and map the polarizing properties of keratoconus corneas in vitro and to compare the results with those obtained in normal corneas. METHODS: Corneal buttons of five keratoconus corneas were investigated by polarization-sensitive optical coherence tomography (PS-OCT). The instrument measures backscattered intensity (conventional OCT), retardation, and (cumulative) slow axis distribution simultaneously. Three-dimensional (3-D) data sets of the polarizing parameters are recorded, and two-dimensional (2-D) cross-sectional images as well as en face images of the distribution of these parameters at the posterior corneal surface are derived. The results are compared to similar maps obtained from normal corneas. RESULTS: Compared with normal corneas, the retardation and slow axis orientation patterns are heavily distorted in keratoconus corneas. Larger areas of increased and decreased retardation can be found in keratoconus corneas, markedly increased retardation (up to >50 degrees ) can especially be found near the rim of corneal thinning. Contrary to normal corneas, regions where the slow axis markedly changes with depth (by up to 50 degrees -90 degrees ) are observed in keratoconus. CONCLUSIONS: The observed changes in the cornea's birefringence properties indicate a change in the arrangement of collagen fibrils in the corneal stroma associated with keratoconus. PS-OCT may be a useful tool for the study and diagnosis of corneal disease.     

Polarized light propagation in corneal lamellae

The propagation of polarized light through the cornea is affected by the orientations of the corneal lamellae and by the refractive imbalance between the collagen fibrils and the ground substance. Thus, well-designed measurements and analyses of polarized light propagation through the cornea can be used to obtain information regarding the cornea's lamellar and fibrillar structures. This paper shows that, for the rabbit, measured values of the optical parameters strongly suggest that the distribution of lamellae orientations is not random, but has one (or two) preferred orientation directions. Also, there is considerable evidence that collagen is intrinsically anisotropic. The Weiner formula gives the effective birefringence of an assembly of parallel isotropic fibrils and its generalization to the case of anisotropic fibrils is presented. Finally, calculations based on preferred orientation models having lamellae composed of anisotropic fibrils show that comparison with experimental values can yield structural information.     

Quantitative analysis of collagen fiber in keratoconus

In order to identify the direct pathogenic factors involved in the stromal thinning of keratoconus, quantitative analysis of keratocytes, collagen fibers and collagen lamellae in keratoconus cornea was performed histologically by light and electron microscopy. Both normal and keratoconus corneas showed a similar cell density of keratocytes in the central stroma, therefore the total number of keratocytes in keratoconus cornea might be smaller than that of controls, because of the thinning of stroma in the keratoconus. The collagen lamellae in keratoconus corneas showed a significant decrease in number compared with controls. There was a direct relationship between the stromal thickness and number of collagen lamellae. On the other hand, there was no statistical significance between normal and keratoconus corneas in terms of the thickness of collagen lamellae. These results suggest that the thinning of the cornea in keratoconus might occur as the result of a defect of some collagen lamellae due to a disorganization during the process of collagen lamellae formation.     

Noninvasive corneal stromal collagen imaging using two-photon-generated second-harmonic signals

PURPOSE: To investigate the feasibility of using femtosecond-pulse lasers to produce second-harmonic generated (SHG) signals to noninvasively assess corneal stromal collagen organization. SETTING: The Eye Institute, University of California, Irvine, California, USA. METHODS: Mouse, rabbit, and human corneas were examined by two-photon confocal microscopy using a variable-wavelength femtosecond lasers to produce SHG signals. Two types were detected: forward scattered and backward scattered. Wavelength dependence of the SHG signal was confirmed by spectral separation using the 510 Meta (Zeiss). To verify the spatial relation between SHG signals and corneal cells, staining of cytoskeletons and nuclei was performed. RESULTS: Second-harmonic-generated signal intensity was strongest with an excitation wavelength of 800 nm for all 3 species. Second-harmonic-generated forward signals showed a distinct fibrillar pattern organized into bands suggesting lamellae, while backscattered SHG signals appeared more diffuse and indistinct. Reconstruction of SHG signals showed two patterns of lamellar organization: highly interwoven in the anterior stroma and orthogonally arranged in the posterior stroma. Unique to the human cornea was the presence of transverse, sutural lamellae that inserted into Bowman's layer, suggesting an anchoring function. CONCLUSIONS: Using two-photon confocal microscopy to generate SHG signals from the corneal collagen provides a powerful new approach to noninvasively study corneal structure. Human corneas had a unique organizational pattern with sutural lamellae to provide important biomechanical support that was not present in mouse or rabbit corneas.     

Distribution of specific collagen types and fibronectin in normal and keratoconus corneas

The distribution of five types of collagen and fibronectin in 6 normal and 9 keratoconus corneas was examined, using immunofluorescent staining and the enzyme-labeled antibody method. Types I, III and V collagens were detected in the corneal stroma. There was essentially no difference between normal and keratoconus corneas in their distribution. Type IV collagen and fibronectin were detected in the basement membrane of the normal corneal epithelium, while in the keratoconus corneas the disruption of the basement membrane as well as the excrescence of basement membrane materials was observed. The abnormal distribution of the type IV collagen and fibronectin was also observed in the anterior stromal area of keratoconus corneas.     

Expression of type XII collagen and hemidesmosome-associated proteins in keratoconus corneas

PURPOSE: Keratoconus is a disease characterized by thinning of the central and paracentral cornea and scarring in advanced cases. This study was performed to examine the expression of type XII collagen, proteins associated with hemidesmosomes, and beta1 integrin in keratoconus corneas. METHODS: Corneal buttons were collected from normal subjects and patients with keratoconus and other corneal diseases. Immunofluorescence staining was performed on frozen sections for type XII collagen, bullous pemphigoid antigen (BP180), and integrin subunits alpha6, beta4, and beta1. RESULTS: To varying degrees, all proteins examined were expressed in normal human corneas. The staining intensity of type XII collagen was diminished in keratoconus corneas in the epithelial basement membrane zone and the stromal matrix. No significant variation was found in either the staining patterns or intensities for BP180, or integrins alpha6, beta4, and beta1. CONCLUSIONS: The level of type XII collagen was reduced in the epithelial basement membrane zone and stromal matrices in keratoconus corneas. These alterations may affect critical interactions of the corneal epithelium with the under-lying basement membrane, and cell-matrix interactions and matrix organization in the stroma.     

Keratan sulfate glycosaminoglycan and the association with collagen fibrils in rudimentary lamellae in the developing avian cornea

PURPOSE: Keratan sulfate (KS), through its association with fibrillar collagen as KS-substituted proteoglycan (KS PG), is thought to be instrumental in the structural development of the corneal stroma. The authors used two different sulfate motif-specific antibodies to identify the sequence of appearance, and the association with collagen, of sulfated KS during avian corneal morphogenesis. METHODS: Corneas from chicken embryos throughout the developmental period, from day 8 through day 18 of incubation, were examined by immunofluorescence and immunoelectron microscopy using monoclonal antibodies 5D4 and 1B4, which react with high- and low-sulfated epitopes on KS, respectively. RESULTS: KS was identified as punctate labeling at incubation day 8, the earliest stage examined, suggesting a cell-associated distribution. By day 10, labeling was more homogeneous, indicating that KS sulfation motifs were present in the stromal extracellular matrix. At day 12 through day 14, immunopositive sites were concentrated primarily in the anterior stroma but became more uniform throughout the full stromal thickness by day 18. From day 10 on, electron microscopy revealed a high-sulfated KS epitope closely associated with bundles of regularly arranged collagen fibrils, initially near cell surfaces in rudimentary lamellae. Individual cells, associated with collagen bundles with different fibril orientations, imply the potential for simultaneous deposition of multiple lamellae. CONCLUSIONS: During chick corneal morphogenesis, significant matrix deposition of high-sulfated KS epitope occurs by day 10, with accumulation subsequently proceeding in an anterior-to-posterior manner. High-sulfated KS likely serves to help define the regular spatial organization of collagen fibrils in bundles newly extruded into the extracellular milieu.     

Comparative studies of collagens in normal and keratoconus corneas

In this paper we present strong evidence that the aberrations in keratoconus corneas are not directly related to alterations in collagen composition and distribution. This conclusion is based on comparative studies of collagen types I, III, IV, V and the recently described collagen types VI and VII in keratoconus and normal corneas. The data are derived from biochemical analysis of collagen fractions sequentially extracted with pepsin and sodium-dodecylsulphate, from amino acid analysis of hydrolysates of entire corneal tissues as well as from immunoblotting of the extracted collagens with specific antibodies. These antibodies were also used to examine the distribution of the collagens in immunofluorescence experiments on corneal sections. The yields of the collagen extractions were demonstrated to be age dependent but were not altered in keratoconus samples. Apart from one case associated with osteogenesis imperfecta type I, comparative studies of keratoconus and normal corneas showed no differences in collagen composition of the extracts. This was confirmed by amino acid analysis of tissue-hydrolysates. The distributions of collagen types I, III, IV, V, VI and VII in corneal sections were in general unchanged in keratoconus corneas, the only differences being in scar tissues observed in the Bowman layer of some keratoconus samples.     

Unilateral congenital corneal keloid with anterior segment mesenchymal dysgenesis and subluxated lens: case report and review of literature

PURPOSE: To report the unusual association of unilateral congenital corneal keloid with anterior-segment mesenchymal dysgenesis and bilateral subluxated lens. METHODS: A 20-year old man presented with a mass lesion involving the left cornea. The corneal lesion had been present since birth. On biomicroscopic examination, a well-defined vascularized, grayish-white mass occupying the whole of the left cornea was seen. The right eye showed multiple peripheral corneal opacities with iridocorneal adhesions, a poorly defined supranasal limbus, and a subluxated lens. Excision biopsy of the mass was done for histopathologic examination. RESULTS: Histopathologic examination of the excised corneal mass showed features consistent with that of a corneal keloid: thickened keratinized epithelium, absent Bowman membrane layer, and fibrovascular hyperplasia composed of hyalinized collagen fibers with irregular orientation of the collagen lamellae. During penetrating keratoplasty of the left eye, an anomalous iris pattern with poorly defined angle and a supranasal subluxated lens was also observed. Extraction of the subluxated lens was also done. The graft failed subsequent to a nonhealing persistent epithelial defect. CONCLUSION: Our case report highlights the rare association of a unilateral congenital corneal keloid with anterior-segment mesenchymal dysgenesis and bilateral subluxated lens.     

Distribution of types I, II, III, IV and V collagen in normal and keratoconus corneas

By using type-specific antibodies to types I, II, III, IV and V collagens, distribution of distinct types of collagen in normal human cornea as well as keratoconus cornea were examined by indirect immunofluorescence microscopy. In normal human cornea, immunohistochemical evidence supported the previous biochemical finding that type I collagen was the major type of collagen in human corneal stroma. No reaction was observed to anti-type II collagen antibody in the whole cornea. Anti-type III collagen antibody reacted with the corneal stroma in a similar fashion as that of anti-type I collagen antibody. Type IV collagen was observed in the basement membrane of the corneal epithelium and in Descemet's membrane. Anti-type V collagen antibody also reacted with the corneal stroma diffusely. Bowman's membrane was strongly stained only with he anti-type V collagen antibody. For further details of the distribution of type I, type III and V collagens in human corneal stroma, immunoelectron microscopic study was undertaken. The positive reaction products of anti-type I and anti-type III collagen antibodies were located on the collagen fibrils, while that of anti-type V collagen antibody was either on or close to collagen fibrils. In keratoconus cornea, no difference was observed in terms of the distribution of type I, III and V collagens, while the disruptive and excrescent distribution of type IV collagen was noted in the basement membrane of the corneal epithelium.     

Multiphoton fluorescence and second harmonic generation imaging of the structural alterations in keratoconus ex vivo

PURPOSE: To demonstrate the application of multiphoton fluorescence (MF) and second harmonic generation (SHG) microscopy for ex vivo characterization of the structural alterations of human corneas due to keratoconus. METHODS: Buttons of keratoconic corneas derived from penetrating keratoplasty were sent for structural analysis with a custom-built multiphoton microscope. Fluorescence detected within the cytoplasm and the SHG signal obtained from collagen were used to demonstrate the morphologic changes in the corneal specimens. RESULTS: The fluorescent epithelial cells around the apical area were elongated and were aligned parallel to the adjacent collagen fibers. Parallel and centripetal distribution patterns of stromal collagen bundles were demonstrated at different depths within the keratoconic corneas. CONCLUSIONS: MF and SHG microscopy provides three-dimensional structural analysis of keratoconus ex vivo. It may provide important morphologic information for the investigation of the pathogenesis of keratoconus and may have potential in a clinical setting as an in vivo diagnostic and monitoring system for advancing keratoconus.     

Effects of riboflavin/UVA corneal cross‐linking on keratocytes and collagen fibres in human cornea

Purpose: To evaluate the effects of corneal cross‐linking on keratocytes and collagen fibres in human corneas. Methods: Fifteen corneal buttons were examined. Ten were from patients with keratoconus submitted to penetrating keratoplasty and five of them were treated with cross‐linking 6 months before penetrating keratoplasty. Five normal corneal buttons from healthy donors were used as controls. All samples were prepared for TUNEL assay and Western blot analysis for the detection of keratocyte apoptosis and immunohistochemical analysis for the morphological evaluation of keratocytes and collagen fibre diameter. Results: Normal corneas exhibited no TUNEL‐positive keratocytes and keratoconic and cross‐linked corneas showed moderate apoptotic cells mainly in the anterior part of the stroma. This apoptotic trend was confirmed by the cleavage of poly (ADP‐ribose) polymerase assessed using Western blot. The Ki‐67 staining showed a significant increase in the keratocyte proliferation in cross‐linked corneas compared with normal and keratoconus. In cross‐linked corneas CD34‐positive keratocytes were regularly distributed throughout the whole corneal stroma as in the control, and keratoconus was associated with patchy loss of immunoreactivity. The immunohistochemical analysis of collagen type I showed a significant increase in fibre diameter of cross‐linked corneas compared with control and keratoconus. Conclusion: Corneal cross‐linking leads to keratocyte damage; after 6 months a repopulation by proliferating cells, a distribution of CD34‐positive keratocytes as in control and an increase in collagen fibre diameter were observed. These modifications are the morphological correlate of the process leading to an increase in biomechanical stability.     

Bilateral congenital corneal keloids and anterior segment mesenchymal dysgenesis in a case of Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome.

PURPOSE: To report the unusual association of bilateral corneal keloids and anterior segment mesenchymal dysgenesis in a child with Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome. METHODS: Case report of a 2-year-old boy. RESULTS: Excision of the epicorneal mass in the right eye was followed by recurrence of the lesion. Multiple penetrating keratoplasties were unsuccessful in reconstructing the anterior segment because of recurrent corneal epithelial breakdown, suggesting limbal stem cell insufficiency. Histopathology and electron microscopy of the excised mass lesion showed features typical of a corneal keloid: thickened keratinized epithelium, absent Bowman's layer, and fibrovascular hyperplasia, with haphazard orientation of the collagen lamellae. Ultrasound biomicroscopy and intraoperative findings suggested a diagnosis of Peter anomaly, but genetic analysis did not show a PAX6 mutation. CONCLUSION: The findings in our patient add to the spectrum of ocular changes described in Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome and confirm earlier reports of poor ocular prognosis in corneal keloids and Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome.     

Mapping collagen organization in the human cornea: left and right eyes are structurally distinct

PURPOSE: Aspects of the biomechanics and surface topography of fellow human corneas are known to exhibit midline symmetry, but the structural basis of these observations is poorly understood. The mechanical performance of the cornea is strongly influenced by the organization of stromal collagen fibrils. The present study was designed to examine and compare the organization of collagen fibrils in the corneal stroma of left and right eyes. METHODS: Wide-angle x-ray scattering was used to map in detail the orientation and distribution of fibrillar collagen across the cornea, limbus, and adjacent sclera of three normal human eyes, including a fellow pair, and the central 9-mm corneal region of a further four eyes. RESULTS: Fibrillar collagen in the human cornea and limbus is arranged anisotropically, and in a highly specific manner. Left and right corneas are structurally distinct. In general, the mass distribution of preferentially aligned fibrils in the cornea appears to exhibit a degree of midline symmetry between left and right eyes. CONCLUSIONS: Structural information, such as that presented herein, will enable a better understanding of corneal biomechanics and shape. Midline symmetry in the distribution of aligned, mechanically reinforcing collagen fibrils between left and right eyes may relate to the biomechanical and topographical enantiomorphism reported in the literature.     

An x-ray diffraction study of corneal structure in mimecan-deficient mice

PURPOSE: Keratan sulfate proteoglycans (KSPGs) in the corneal stroma are believed to influence collagen fibrillar arrangement. This study was performed to investigate the fibrillar architecture of the corneal stroma in mice homozygous for a null mutation in the corneal KSPG, mimecan. METHODS: Wild-type (n = 9) and mimecan-deficient (n = 10) mouse corneas were investigated by low-angle synchrotron x-ray diffraction to establish the average collagen fibrillar spacing, average collagen fibril diameter, and level of fibrillar organization in the stromal array. RESULTS: The mean collagen fibril diameter in the corneas of mimecan-null mice, as an average throughout the whole thickness of the tissue, was not appreciably different from normal (35.6 +/- 1.1 nm vs. 35.9 +/- 1.0 nm). Average center-to-center collagen fibrillar spacing in the mutant corneas measured 52.6 +/- 2.6 nm, similar to the 53.3 +/- 4.0 nm found in wild-type mice. The degree of local order in the collagen fibrillar array, as indicated by the height-width (H:W) ratio of the background-subtracted interfibrillar x-ray reflection, was also not significantly changed in mimecan-null corneas (23.4 +/- 5.6), when compared with the corneas of wild-types (28.2 +/- 4.8). CONCLUSIONS: On average, throughout the whole depth of the corneal stroma, collagen fibrils in mimecan-null mice, unlike collagen fibrils in lumican-null mice and keratocan-null mice, are of a normal diameter and are normally spaced and arranged. This indicates that, compared with lumican and keratocan, mimecan has a lesser role in the control of stromal architecture in mouse cornea.     

Ultrastructural analysis of collagen fibrils and proteoglycans in keratoconus

Purpose: To investigate ultrastructural alterations in the distribution of collagen fibrils (CFs) and proteoglycans (PGs) in the keratoconus cornea. Methods: Four normal corneas (donor age 24–75 years) and four severe and one mild keratoconus corneas (donor age 24–47 years) were fixed in 2.5% glutaraldehyde containing 0.05% cuprolinic blue dye for electron microscopy. Analyses were carried out on approximately 39 000 CF and 66 000 PG filaments in the anterior, middle and posterior stroma, using analySIS^® soft imaging software. Results: In severe keratoconus, stromal lamellae were seen to undulate in most regions, whereas in mild keratoconus only the middle and posterior lamellae were affected. In keratoconus corneas the mean diameter and interfibrillar spacing of CFs was reduced in all zones (p < 0.0001) and the CF and PG number density and area fractions were significantly increased (p < 0.0001) compared with in normal corneas and were higher (p < 0.0001) in the corneas with severe keratoconus than in that with mild keratoconus. The lamellae contained microfibrils (8–9 nm wide) and, in addition, PGs embedded within CFs. Degenerate keratocytes containing PGs were found in all keratoconus corneas. Conclusions: These studies suggest that as keratoconus progresses, the PG content of the stroma increases, whereas fibril diameter is reduced. The altered stromal content of PGs may influence CF diameters and their organization in keratoconus, weakening lateral cohesion and resulting in significant disorder of CF packing.