Recovery and relapse in anorexia and bulimia nervosa: a 7.5-year follow-up study.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the course and outcome of anorexia nervosa (AN) and bulimia nervosa (BN) at a median of 90 months of follow-up in a large cohort of women with eating disorders. METHOD: A prospective, naturalistic, longitudinal design was used to map the course of AN and BN in 246 women. Follow-up data are presented in terms of full and partial recovery, predictors of time to recovery, and rates and predictors of relapse. RESULTS: The full recovery rate of women with BN was significantly higher than that of women with AN, with 74% of those with BN and 33% of those with AN achieving full recovery by a median of 90 months of follow-up. Intake diagnosis of AN was the strongest predictor of worse outcome. No predictors of recovery emerged among bulimic subjects. Eighty-three percent of women with AN and 99% of those with BN achieved partial recovery. Approximately one third of both women with AN and women with BN relapsed after full recovery. No predictors of relapse emerged. CONCLUSIONS: The findings suggest that the course of AN is characterized by high rates of partial recovery and low rates of full recovery, while the course of BN is characterized by higher rates of both partial and full recovery.     

Standard criteria for relapse are needed in obsessive-compulsive disorder

To assess how different criteria for relapse affect inferences about relapse in obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), a post hoc analysis of relapse was conducted using data from a multisite randomized controlled trial comparing clomipramine (CMI), exposure and ritual prevention (EX/RP), and its combination (EX/RP+CMI) in adults with OCD. Different relapse definitions were constructed based on criteria used in prior studies. For each definition, the number of relapsers was computed, and the proportion of relapsers and time to relapse were compared. When applied to this data set, relapse criteria used in prior OCD studies yielded different observed relapse rates (range: 27-63% for CMI; 0-50% for EX/RP; and 7-67% for EX/RP+CMI). Most criteria found that EX/RP responders (with or without CMI) had a significantly lower relapse rate and longer time to relapse after treatment discontinuation than did responders to CMI alone. However, some relapse criteria (e.g., those requiring minimal worsening) found no significant treatment differences in relapse rates or time to relapse, and some generated biases against one treatment or another. Most definitions concurred: in adults with primary OCD, EX/RP treatment (with or without CMI) can produce more durable short-term gains after treatment discontinuation than CMI alone. However, different relapse criteria can lead to very different observed relapse rates and even contradictory inferences about relapse. Standard criteria for relapse are needed in OCD to facilitate comparisons between studies (enabling better treatment guidelines) and to advance research on mechanisms of relapse and relapse prevention.     

Temporal patterns of recovery across eating disorder subtypes

OBJECTIVE: To compare patterns of recovery in individuals with index episodes of anorexia nervosa (AN) and bulimia nervosa (BN). METHOD: Using Kaplan-Meier methods and Cox proportional hazards models, comparisons were conducted that were conditional on duration of eating disorder from onset and included a conservative recovery criterion of 3 asymptomatic years. Data collection was retrospective and from two of the international Price Foundation genetic studies on 901 individuals with eating disorders. RESULTS: Using Kaplan-Meier methods, 11% of those with index AN and 10% of those with index BN met recovery criteria at 10 years. At 15 years, 16% of those with index AN and 25% of those with index BN met recovery criteria. In a Cox proportional hazards model the index BN group had three times the rate of recovery at 10-14 years (p=0.01) than the index AN group. CONCLUSIONS: Initially the probability of recovery was greater for those with index AN, but as the duration of the eating disorder lengthened those with BN had higher probabilities of recovery. Replication of these results with prospective data using similarly stringent recovery criteria and methods is required to confirm trends.     

A prospective study of bipolar disorder in children and adolescents from India

Bipolar disorder in adults is known to run an episodic course. However, little information exists on the long-term naturalistic course of bipolar disorder in juvenile populations. The present study was undertaken with the objectives of (i) documenting the rates of recovery and relapse, (ii) identifying the predictors of recovery and relapse and (iii) assessing the rates of comorbid conditions. A total of 30 subjects with onset of bipolar illness (according to DSM-III-R criteria) in childhood and adolescence were assessed systematically at baseline and 4 to 5 years later. All 30 subjects (100%) had recovered from their index episodes and none had exhibited chronicity. Twenty of the 30 subjects (67%) had relapsed, with most relapses occurring within 2 years of recovery from index episodes. No predictors of recovery and relapse could be identified. Conduct disorder was the only comorbid diagnosis in two subjects (7%). The main implication of our study, in view of the high rates of relapse in the crucial developmental phase of a young individual, is that long-term maintenance medication should be considered in juvenile bipolar patients, even if it is a first episode.     

One-year recovery and relapse rates of children with a prepubertal and early adolescent bipolar disorder phenotype

OBJECTIVE: The study examined 1-year recovery and relapse rates for mania in subjects who met criteria for a prepubertal and early adolescent bipolar disorder phenotype. METHOD: Outpatients identified by consecutive new-case ascertainment were assessed by means of separate child and parent interviews, consensus conferences, and blind best estimates. The definition of the prepubertal and early adolescent bipolar disorder phenotype was DSM-IV mania with elation and/or grandiosity as one criterion. RESULTS: Of 93 subjects seen at baseline, 89 were seen at 1 year (95.7% retention). The rate of recovery from mania was 37.1%, and the rate of relapse after recovery was 38.3%. No covariates were significantly associated with recovery or relapse. CONCLUSIONS: The low recovery and high relapse rates supported the study hypothesis of poor outcomes, which was made on the basis of similarity between the characteristics of the prepubertal and early adolescent bipolar disorder phenotype (long episode duration and high prevalence of mixed mania, psychosis, and rapid cycling) and those of severe bipolar disorder in adults.     

Criteria for recovery from eating disorders according to patients and therapists

No consensus exists on criteria for recovery from eating disorders. Different criteria are used in effect and outcome studies, suggesting different rates of recovery. The questions for research were: Which criteria for recovery are important to ex-patients and therapists, and which criteria for recovery are actually realized by ex-patients? A list of 52 possible criteria for recovery was compiled from the literature on eating disorders, representing the domains of eating behavior, body experience, physical and psychological well-being, and emotional and social functioning. Ex-patients (n = 41) and therapists (n = 57) were asked to select criteria from this list, that they viewed as important for recovery from eating disorders. Ex-patients were asked which criteria they had realized by the end of their most recent therapy or treatment and in the period thereafter. Ex-patients and therapists agreed on most of the criteria for recovery. At the end of their therapy, more than 50% of the ex-patients had realized 44 of the criteria for recovery but thereafter they improved on 38 criteria. To realize full recovery and to prevent relapse, it is important to consider not only eating behavior and weight, but also psychological, emotional, and social criteria.     

Treating adolescents with eating disorders in the family context. Empirical and theoretical considerations

The author described the Maudsley approach for family treatment of adolescent AN and the empirical evidence supporting its use in this population. This treatment focuses on the family as a resource for recovery and puts the patients in charge of re-feeding their affected child. Its success seems to depend on the successful motivation of parents to take on this task and see it through while simultaneously supporting the processes of adolescent development as they reemerge. Although this treatment is promising, substantial data to support its being the best approach for adolescents with AN are lacking. The author also described a theoretical model for involving parents in CBT for adolescents with BN. Although CBT is accepted as the most efficacious treatment for adults with BN, it has not been tested systematically in adolescents. At the same time, it is clear that the adult models of CBT for BN are unlikely to be successful without modifications that take into account the realities of adolescence. Although CBT as a model is likely to be acceptable to adolescents, parents are needed to promote motivation, provide a supportive milieu for behavioral change, and provide guidance and support in stressful periods that lead to relapse. It is important that CBT that is appropriately modified to include parents be tested for its efficacy in adolescents with BN. Preliminary, uncontrolled results are promising.     

Bulimia nervosa with and without obsessive-compulsive syndromes

The present study was performed in a group of bulimic (BN) females (1) to assess prevalence rates of comorbid obsessive-compulsive phenomena; (2) to investigate whether BN patients display a characteristic cluster of obsessive-compulsive symptoms; and (3) to determine whether obsessive-compulsive symptoms influence the clinical picture of BN. Thirty-eight DSM-IV BN females were interviewed by means of the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-III-R (SCID) to assess the prevalence rate of obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD); the Yale-Brown Obsessive-Compulsive Symptom Scale (Y-BOCS) Symptom Check-List was also used to evaluate the presence of obsessive-compulsive symptoms. The phenomenology of BN females with obsessive-compulsive syndromes (OCS) as detected by the Y-BOCS was compared to that shown by a "control" group of nonbulimic OCD females. Finally, the eating-related psychopathology of BN women with and without OCS was compared. The current prevalence rates of OCD and of subthreshold obsessive-compulsive syndrome (sOCS) in our sample were 10.5% and 15.8%, respectively. Thus, a total of 26.3% of BN females had a current OCS that comprised both clinical disorders and subthreshold syndromes. No differences were detected between obsessive-compulsive symptoms of these females and those of the control group of nonbulimic OCD females. BN females with OCS had higher ratings on the Eating Disorder Inventory (EDI) total score and on the "drive for thinness" and the "bulimia" items of the scale, as compared to BN females without OCS. In conclusion, it appears that a considerable proportion of BN females display OCS, which sometimes are not severe enough to fulfill diagnostic criteria for OCD. Moreover, in these patients, obsessive-compulsive symptoms are undistinguishable from those of OCD females, and exert a negative influence on the clinical picture of the bulimic disorder.     

Expressed emotion and relapse in young schizophrenia outpatients.

High familial expressed emotion (EE) reliably predicts 9-month relapse rates in schizophrenia patients. Difficulties interpreting the EE-relapse finding arise, however, because EE is usually assessed during a hospital admission, yet relapse following discharge is predicted. Researchers in Scotland assessed EE in relatives while the patients were out of hospital; using conservative relapse criteria, they failed to find higher subsequent 6- and 12-month relapse rates among patients living in high-EE homes (McCreadie and Phillips 1988). Our goal was to determine the ability of EE to predict relapse in a sample of 69 schizophrenia outpatients using both conservative criteria (for 6-and 12-month rates) and standard relapse criteria (for 9- and 18-month rates). According to the conservative criteria, EE failed to predict 6- and 12-month relapse. According to the standard criteria, 9-month relapse rates were significantly greater among patients in high-EE households. In parental homes, relapse at both 9 months and 18 months was best predicted by fathers' critical comments and mothers' emotional overinvolvement. Relapse was not associated with medication compliance and the amount of contact with high-EE relatives.     

The Time is Ripe for a Consensus Definition of Clinical Recovery in First-episode Psychosis: Suggestions Based on a 10-Year Follow-up Study

ObjectivesA consensus definition of clinical recovery in first-episode psychosis (FEP) is required to improve knowledge about recovery rates in this population. To propose criteria for a future consensus definition, this study aims to investigate rates of clinical recovery when using a standard definition (full psychotic symptom remission and adequate functioning for minimum one year) across both affective and nonaffective FEP groups (bipolar spectrum and schizophrenia spectrum disorders). Second, we aim to explore changes in rates when altering the standard definition criteria. Third, to examine the extent to which healthy controls meet the functioning criteria.Study designIn total, 142 FEP participants and 117 healthy controls preselected with strict criteria, were re-assessed with structured clinical interviews at 10-year follow-up.Study resultsA total of 31.7% were in clinical recovery according to the standard definition, with significantly higher recovery rates in bipolar (50.0%) than in schizophrenia spectrum disorders (22.9%). Both groups’ recovery rates decreased equally when extending duration and adding affective symptom remission criteria and increased with looser functioning criteria. In healthy controls, 18.8% did not meet the standard criteria for adequate functioning, decreasing to 4.3% with looser criteria.ConclusionsFindings suggest that clinical recovery is common in FEP, although more in bipolar than in schizophrenia spectrum disorders, also when altering the recovery criteria. We call for a future consensus definition of clinical recovery for FEP, and suggest it should include affective symptom remission and more reasonable criteria for functioning that are more in line with the general population.     

Long-term outcome of residential treatment for anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa

We analyzed results from surveys of respondents who had completed ≥ 30 days of treatment at Monte Nido Residential Treatment Program over a 10 year period. Participants with anorexia nervosa (AN; n = 66) and bulimia nervosa (BN; n = 52) completed the Eating Disorders Inventory-2 (EDI-2), the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI), and a structured eating disorder assessment at admission and follow-up. Mean duration between discharge and last follow-up was 4.6 years and 3.8 years for AN and BN respectively. For AN there were significant improvements in BMI, BDI, 10 of 11 EDI-2 subscales, and frequencies of bingeing and purging. For BN there were significant improvements in BDI, all EDI subscales, and frequencies of bingeing and purging. Eighty-nine percent of AN graduates and 75% of BN graduates had good or intermediate outcomes. Using linear regression, the best model contained the single variable, discharge BMI, which predicted 23% of the variance explaining full recovery from AN (p ≤ .02). For BN, the best model contained vomiting frequency and the bulimia subscale score of the EDI-2 at discharge, which accounted for 37% of the variance explaining full recovery from BN (p ≤ .02). The great majority of patients showed significant improvement at long-term follow-up after this program of residential treatment. In addition, these results underscore the importance of weight gain for AN patients and cessation of bulimic symptoms for BN patients when predicting long-term recovery.     

Dialectical behaviour therapy and an added cognitive behavioural treatment module for eating disorders in women with borderline personality disorder and anorexia nervosa or bulimia nervosa who failed to respond to previous treatments. An open trial with a 15-month follow-up

There is evidence from case studies suggesting that adapted dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) for borderline personality disorder (BPD) and eating disorders (ED) might improve disorder related complaints. Twenty-four women with BPD (9 with comorbid anorexia nervosa [AN] and 15 with bulimia nervosa [BN]), who already had failed to respond to previous eating-disorder related inpatient treatments were consecutively admitted to an adapted inpatient DBT program. Assessment points were at pre-treatment, post-treatment, and 15-month follow-up. At follow-up, the remission rate was 54% for BN, and 33% for AN. Yet 44% of women with AN crossed over to BN and one woman additionally met the criteria of AN. For women with AN, the mean weight was not significantly increased at post-treatment, but had improved at follow-up. For women with BN, the frequency of binge-eating episodes was reduced at post-treatment as well as at follow-up. Self-rated eating-related complaints and general psychopathology, as well as ratings on global psychosocial functioning, were significantly improved at post-treatment and at follow-up. Although these findings support the assumption that the adapted DBT inpatient program is a potentially efficacious treatment for those who failed to respond to previous eating-disorder related inpatient treatments, remission rates and maintained eating-related psychopathology also suggest that this treatment needs further improvement.     

Remission and recovery during the first outpatient year of the early course of schizophrenia

Background

Although in the early course of schizophrenia relapse prevention is of paramount importance, there is an increasing emphasis on establishing and maintaining sustained periods of symptom remission. Recovery in the early course of illness is also possible, although the rates of recovery are lower than for symptom remission. Symptom remission and recovery rates vary considerably across recent-onset schizophrenia studies because of a lack of consistency in treatment interventions and in applying operational outcome criteria.

Method

Patients who were within two years of their first psychotic episode (N = 77) that were treated with continuous antipsychotic medication in conjunction with psychosocial interventions (without targeted work rehabilitation) were assessed during the first outpatient year after hospital discharge. Published operational criteria were used to classify symptom remission and recovery.

Results

The rate of full symptom remission maintained for 6 months was 36%, while the rate of recovery for 6 months was 10%. When the same criteria were applied for a continuous period of one year, 22% of patients were found to achieve symptom remission but only 1% of patients met recovery criteria. Using multivariate prediction, the WAIS Comprehension score was a significant predictor of 6 months of good functional outcome.

Conclusions

Although some schizophrenia patients can achieve both symptom remission and recovery in the early course of illness, the overall rate of symptom remission during the first post-hospitalization year is much higher than the rate of recovery. This suggests that interventions targeting work and social functioning are likely necessary to raise the chances of recovery. Cognitive factors can be predictive of good functional outcome even in the early course of schizophrenia.     

Recovery and relapse from major depressive disorder in the elderly.

OBJECTIVE: Results from the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) Collaborative Study of the Psychobiology of Depression raised serious concerns about the longer-term prognosis for major depressive disorder in younger persons. However, little research has examined the prognosis for major depressive disorder in the elderly despite suggestions that they have poorer clinical outcomes than younger adults. The objective of this study was to 1) document rates of recovery and relapse from major depressive disorder in a large group of inpatient elderly and 2) compare recovery and relapse rates from major depressive disorder in the elderly with those in a mixed-age patient group from the NIMH collaborative study. METHOD: The psychiatric status of 127 elderly inpatients diagnosed with major depressive disorder by Research Diagnostic Criteria was evaluated for 1 year. The same diagnostic and follow-up method to assess psychiatric symptoms employed in the NIMH study were used. RESULTS: One year after study admission, 72% of elderly patients had recovered. Nineteen percent of recovered patients, however, had a subsequent episode of major depressive disorder. Recovery and relapse rates in the elderly did not significantly differ from those reported for the mixed-age group in the NIMH study. CONCLUSIONS: It is erroneous to single out the elderly as being more likely to have poorer longitudinal treatment outcomes than others. Study findings indicate the need for continued refinement of somatic and nonsomatic treatments for the elderly to improve rates of sustained recovery from depression.     

An interoceptive model of bulimia nervosa: A neurobiological systematic review

The objective of our study was to examine the neurobiological support for an interoceptive sensory processing model of bulimia nervosa (BN). To do so, we conducted a systematic review of interoceptive sensory processing in BN, using the PRISMA guidelines. We searched PsychInfo, Pubmed, and Web of Knowledge databases to identify biological and behavioral studies that examine interoceptive detection in BN. After screening 390 articles for inclusion and conducting a quality assessment of articles that met inclusion criteria, we reviewed 41 articles. We found that global interoceptive sensory processing deficits may be present in BN. Specifically there is evidence of abnormal brain function, structure and connectivity in the interoceptive neural network, in addition to gastric and pain processing disturbances. These results suggest that there may be a neurobiological basis for global interoceptive sensory processing deficits in BN that remain after recovery. Data from taste and heart beat detection studies were inconclusive; some studies suggest interoceptive disturbances in these sensory domains. Discrepancies in findings appear to be due to methodological differences. In conclusion, interoceptive sensory processing deficits may directly contribute to and explain a variety of symptoms present in those with BN. Further examination of interoceptive sensory processing deficits could inform the development of treatments for those with BN.     

Pathological gambling and comorbid substance use

OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to determine the rates of substance use problems in a sample of diagnosed pathological gamblers seeking treatment in a university teaching hospital cognitive behavioural outpatient clinic. METHODS: A semistructured interview schedule and the composite international diagnostic interview (CIDI-auto) were administered to assess substance dependence in a sample of 75 poker-machine gamblers meeting DSM-IV and South Oaks gambling screen (SOGS) criteria for pathological gambling. Both the self-reported rates and the proportion meeting criteria for a psychiatric disorder were determined. RESULTS: The rates for substance use disorder within a sample of treatment-seeking pathological gamblers is higher as compared to general population figures. Gender differences were found with more current alcohol-abuse problems reported among male than female participants. Non-alcohol-related substance abuse was relatively lower than rates reported by other studies in the literature. CONCLUSIONS: Substance abuse is a common comorbid condition of pathological gambling and therefore should be screened for in routine clinical assessments. Failure to identify and treat comorbid substance-use disorders in gamblers may lead to higher relapse rates.     

Advances in Adolescent Substance Abuse Treatment

Alcohol and other drug use among adolescents has been a public health problem for decades. Although some substance use may be developmentally routine, a concerning number of adolescents meet criteria for a substance use disorder and could greatly benefit from a quality treatment experience. However, parents and health care providers want evidence of the efficacy of adolescent-specific treatment programs. This review summarizes four factors surrounding the efficacy of current adolescent treatment programs: 1) adolescent-specific treatment services; 2) the variety of therapeutic modalities; 3) relapse and recovery rates; and 4) the need for evidence-based, quality assessments and research. Current adolescent treatment efforts are summarized, and the recent literature regarding the efficacy of adolescent treatment and recovery rates is discussed.     

Relapse in recurrent unipolar depression

Treatment of the acute phase of recurrent depression has become both routine and successful in the last decade, but the rates of relapse and recurrence remain a problem. In this study a combined psychopharmacologic/psychotherapeutic approach to the acute and continuation treatment of unipolar depressed patients was used. For 59 patients who completed the continuation phase of treatment, the relapse rate after 8 weeks of recovery was 8.5%. Since other recent studies of recurrent depression have reported relapse rates of 15%-22%, these results suggest that there are advantages in combined treatment.     

Two-year prospective follow-up of children with a prepubertal and early adolescent bipolar disorder phenotype

OBJECTIVE: Longitudinal outcomes of bipolar disorder with onset in the late teenage years or in adulthood have been reported, but little is known about the natural history of childhood-onset mania. This study sought to provide rates and predictors of recovery and relapse in children with a prepubertal and early adolescent bipolar disorder phenotype. METHOD: Eighty-nine consecutively ascertained outpatient subjects (mean age=10.9 years [SD=2.7]) received comprehensive research assessments, including separate interviews of mothers about their children and of children about themselves, at baseline and at 6, 12, 18, and 24 months after baseline. The study phenotype required DSM-IV mania with elation and/or grandiosity as one criterion to distinguish the study phenotype from a diagnosis of mania based on criteria overlapping with those for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and to ensure that subjects had at least one of the two cardinal features of mania (i.e., elation and/or grandiosity). Subjects were treated by their own community practitioners. RESULTS: The proportions of subjects who recovered from mania and who relapsed after recovery were 65.2% and 55.2%, respectively. The mean time to recovery was 36.0 weeks (SD=25.0). Relapse occurred after a mean of 28.6 weeks (SD=13.2). Living with an intact biological family significantly predicted rate of recovery, and a low level of maternal warmth significantly predicted rate of relapse. CONCLUSIONS: The relatively poor outcomes of these subjects may be related to their phenotypic resemblance to severely ill adults with bipolar disorder who have mixed mania, continuous rapid cycling, psychosis, and treatment-resistant psychopathology. A lower level of effectiveness of mood stabilizers in children cannot be ruled out. Although the significance of maternal warmth as a predictor is consistent with reports in adult mania, the significance of intact family as a predictor may be unique to childhood mania.     

A meta-analysis of relapse rates in cognitive-behavioral therapy for anxiety disorders

Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) is a first-line treatment for anxiety and related disorders, with large pre- to post-treatment effect sizes. Rates of relapse, or the likelihood that a state of remission will be maintained once treatment is withdrawn, have been relatively neglected in CBT outcome studies. The present meta-analysis aimed to determine the overall rate of relapse in CBT for anxiety and related disorders. A secondary aim was to assess whether demographic, clinical, and methodological factors were associated with rates of relapse in CBT. Articles were identified from prior CBT meta-analyses and review papers and from literature searches using the PsycINFO and Medline electronic databases, with 17 full-length articles retained for meta-analysis (total N = 337 patients). Results showed an overall relapse rate of 14 %, which did not significantly differ between diagnoses. The way in which relapse was defined was significantly associated with relapse rates; when relapse was defined as meeting diagnostic criteria, estimates were lower than when alternative definitions were used. The findings indicate that relapse following symptom remission occurs in a minority of patients, suggesting that future treatment development and refinement efforts should focus on improving relapse prevention skills and interventions to minimize risk of relapse.