‘One mission accomplished,more important ones remain’: commentary on Every‐Palmer,S., Howick,J. (2014) How evidence‐based medicine is failing due to biased trials and selective publication. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 20 (6), 908–914

Every‐Palmer and Howick suggest that evidence‐based medicine (EBM) is failing in its mission because of contamination of research by manufacturer and researcher‐motivated bias and self‐interest. They fail to define that mission and to distinguish between the EBM movement and the research enterprise it was developed to critique. An educational movement, EBM accomplished its mission to simplify and package clinical epidemiological concepts in a form accessible to clinical learners. Its wide adoption within educational circles fostered critical literacy among several generations of practitioners. Illumination of bias, subterfuge and incomplete reporting of research has been a strength of EBM. Increased uptake and use of clinical research within the health care system properly defines the failing mission that eludes Every‐Palmer and Howick. Responsibility for failure to make progress towards its achievement is shared by virtually all relevant streams within the system, including policy, clinical guideline development, educational movements and the development of approaches to evidence synthesis. Discordance between the epistemological premises pervading today's research and health care community and the complex social processes that ultimately determine research use constitutes an important factor that must be addressed as part of a remedy. Enhanced emphasis on and demonstration of alternative approaches to research such as realism and realist synthesis and the momentum towards development of a learning health care system hold promise as guideposts for the rapidly evolving health care environment.     

‘Why nurses are leaving the profession … lack of support from managers’: What nurses from an e‐cohort study said

The shortage of nurses is known. We explored nurses' reasons for leaving the profession based on responses from an e‐newsletter of the Nurses and Midwives e‐cohort Study. Qualitative content analysis of data from email responses (n = 66) showed ‘Lack of support’ as a social work value describing their manager's lack of support, unsupportive relationships within their work group, and a health‐care system putting business principles before care resulting in job dissatisfaction and nurse turnover. These findings are examples of a ‘complex'/‘wicked’ problem and as such will resist simple solutions to the presenting issues. The dialogic process such as Open Space Technology and Talking Circles should be considered as potentially suitable to the needs of nurses.     

Health,utilisation of health services, ‘core’ information,and reasons for non‐participation: a triangulation study amongst non‐respondents

Aim. To explore health, use of health services, ‘core’ information and reasons for non‐participation amongst males. Background. Gender may provide an explanation for non‐participation in the healthcare system. A growing body of research suggests that males are less likely than females to seek help from health professionals for their problems. The current research had its beginnings with the low response rate in a prior voluntary survey and health examination for Finnish males born in 1961. Design. Data triangulation among 28 non‐respondent middle‐aged males in Helsinki was used. Methods. The methods involved structured and in‐depth interviews and health measurements to explore the views of these males concerning their health‐related behaviours and use of health services. Results. Non‐respondent males seldom used healthcare services. Despite clinical risk factors (e.g. obesity and blood pressure) and various symptoms, males perceived their health status as good. Work was widely experienced as excessively demanding, causing insomnia and other stress symptoms. Males expressed sensitive messages when a session was ending and when the participant was close to the door and leaving the room. This ‘core’ information included major causes of concern, anxiety, fears and loneliness. Conclusions. This triangulation study showed that by using an in‐depth interview as one research strategy, more sensitive ‘feminist’ expressions in health and ill‐health were got by men. The results emphasise a male’s self‐perception of his masculinity that may have relevance to the health experience of the male population. Relevance to clinical practice. Nurses and physicians need to pay special attention to the requirements of gender‐specific healthcare to be most effective in the delivery of healthcare to males.     

‘Outside the Original Remit’: Co‐production in UK mental health research,lessons from the field

The aim of this discursive paper was to explore the development of co‐production and service user involvement in UK university‐based mental health research and to offer practical recommendations for practitioners co‐producing research with service users and survivors, informed by an overview of the key literature on co‐production in mental health and from a critical reflection on applied research through the medium of a case study. The paper is co‐written by a mental health nurse academic and a service user/survivor researcher academic. The authors argue that the implications of co‐production for mental health research remain underexplored, but that both the practitioner and service user/survivor researcher experience and perspective of co‐production in research can provide practical reflections to inform developing research practice. The theories and values of emancipatory research can provide a framework from which both practitioners and service users can work together on a research project, in a way that requires reflection on process and power dynamics. The authors conclude that whilst co‐produced investigations can offer unique opportunities for advancing emancipatory and applied research in mental health, practitioner researchers need to be more radical in their consideration of power in the research process.