Therapeutic effect of carbon dioxide laser versus single application of trichloroacetic acid for koilocytic squamous papillae.

This paper reports the treatment results of 50 symptomatic females who had clinical features of squamous papillae and histologic evidence of koilocytosis. Either a carbon dioxide laser or a single application of trichloroacetic acid (TCA) was used to treat these patients. All of the patients were alternately and prospectively randomized into one of two groups. Twenty-three of the 25 women treated by laser and 10 of the 25 women treated by TCA had resolution of either the symptoms or the vulvar lesions in a follow-up period ranging from six to 22 months. Hence, we were able to control the symptoms and lesions in 92% of the women following initial laser treatment and 40% of the women following a single application of TCA. In addition, cosmetic results were satisfactory, and complications were minimal in the laser-treated group of patients. However, human papillomavirus DNA was still detected three to four weeks after treatment in 24% of the women treated by laser and 64% of the women treated by TCA. Whether they are at a higher risk of recurrence as compared to those without detectable viral DNA remains to be determined.